Jeremey's been doing this a long time, and there are many, many awesome vids. One of my favorites is Cloud Atlas. It also has my single favorite sin starting at about the 16:50 mark of that video. Made me laugh so hard I almost died. Def check out the Everything Everywhere All At Once sins vid. Another great one. Cheers.
"The two seasons I've spent here have given me happiness" She says, in the tone someone trying to say something nice about the lentil casserole she barely managed to choke down. With every previous shot of her looking like it's about to show the suicide prevention hotline's number at the bottom of the screen. And this is the emotional center of the movie, her love for this village and desire to preserve this "happiness." God, what a mess.
“They have to go to a vast planet they’ve never been to to meet this samurai warrior chick.” “A whole planet to find one person? That’s gonna be pretty difficult and time consuming…” “Actually, it’s gonna be super easy, barely an inconvenience!”
This movie seems to be a whole fever dream of movies mottled together and has no idea what it wants to be. We have: Star Wars, Dune, Riddick, Prometheus, Star Trek, John Carter, Jupiter Ascending, Iron Sky...
What was infuriating, was the fact that home-girl sets out to find this great Titus guy…then finds all these other people on the way, who each get a scene to show how awesome they are…then she finally gets to Titus…who is freakin Djimon Honshu, and his character turns out to be a washed up drunkard covered in mud, who gets nothing to show what makes him special, despite being the whole reason for her initial quest….ARGH!
That would be because it's one story across three movies that is in parts. Titus plays a significantly larger role in the second film and you get more of his backstory, this movie was about assembling the team
This was originally written as a treatment for a possible Star Wars movie. When it was rejected he slapped a skin on it and wrote the script without really removing any of the Star Wars-iness.
I thought that this WAS a star wars movie? I'm not much of a fan so I am curious as to why it isn't? :) thanks. Edit: in the way that 'Solo' is a star wars movie?
@@notkimpine I'm trying to understand here: is the fact that the female lead is not just a damsel in distress that makes it "woke"? Or is it that there's more than one ethnicity represented? I'm truly curious and eager to learn.
The movie should have focused on the robot. Looks like his story was much more interesting than the generic checklist we got. "Ok, we got the Native who's has a connection with animals, now we need an Asian person who uses swords..."
The robot is literally just a mechanicus from warhammer 40K. There are plenty of books and other media that explore those in depth. Literally every single element of this movie was plagiarized from other science fiction stories.
@@Diree i wouldnt know, i have never consumed any 40K content, but even so i know that robot was ripped off from 40K just through general cultural osmosis
Contrarians and nostalgia. Some people saw 300 when they were in middle school and thought it was the best movie ever made. When their peers became older and started seeing the gaping faults in every Zach Snyder movie they refused to accept the criticism and dug their heels in deeper and consider every Snyder movie ever a masterpiece because they think it's rebellious and that other people just can't see Snyder's greatness.
@@christianhartman1298 My take was that he got a following during the 00's with movies like 300 and Watchmen, his other movies were hit or miss like Sucker Punch or Immortals. He got the cult status when Justice League was taken over by Joss and it ended up being awful, and Synder got to play up the idea that he was reigned in and the studio interfered with "his vison," basically he got the hindsight bias. I don't think his fans think his recent movies are good, so much that he basically propped himself up as the only director to not get interfered with by studios, and if you don't support him then you somehow get a shittier industry. He totally knows this btw, he recent interviews are him giving this ultimatum to his critics.
An incoherent script, poor casting, poor acting, poor sets, unrealistic aliens, poorly paced and boring but apart from that Rebel Moon Part One was terrible.
If you went to ChatGPT and told it to take Star Wars, Dune, and Seven Samurai and put all those together for a script to a Zack Snyder film, I'd be willing to bet that what you'd end up with would be like 80-90% identical to this film.
I can't imagine why the empire will land to kill the good guys instead of nuking from orbit. Sure as heck not going to watch part 2 to see what cockamamie reason the director will cook up.
Missed one huge glaring flaw, nemesis says not to celebrate hamada's death, as it could easily be any one of them lying dead in the name of revenge. Six minutes later, SIX, Kora recruits the general by saying if not for honor, do it for revenge and THAT'S what gets through to him, and nemesis says nothing
@@garylua5877 "did a Chuck Norris" that is now part of my permanent speech. Ya I just watched it today. It was pretty much the only good part of the show.
Once again it's astounding how many people have missed the entire point being that the first film is part 1 of a three-part story, James (the bot) gets to do what you described at the end of the second part
ok so I love all the nicknames you have for the robot. Also, I'm fist pumping the sins for all the times Cora could've easily been killed if someone just took a shot.
That bit when Cyborg runs up that scaffolding literally SCREAMS: “Hey, this thing isn’t very long so don’t run that fast, but swing your arms and high step like a fool as though you’re running really fast and we’ll slow it down in post. No one will be able to tell.”
By my rough calculations, 2,000 bushels of wheat can provide sufficient caloric intake (at the recommended levels for the average person today) for 230 people for one year. But there are three huge caveats which will bring that amount way down: A portion of the crop must be kept as seed for the next year, so not all is available to be eaten. That was always a classic question in times of foor shortages, how to balance feeding people now with having enough seed to grow food next year. This is likely a society very dependent on manual labour and will thereby require a greater caloric intake than your average westerner today. Look up the meals that farmers used to eat, they are absurd today. They likely have to trade a portion of their crops for other needed goods they dont product in sufficient amounts.
Some points: you forgot about rats, and grainstore fires. Also, speculation. Most famines in medieval times, which appears to be the tech level these people operate at, werent caused by failed crops directly. A small reduction in crop yields would result in merchants buying up the grain and storing it speculating on further price increases. Then, either the rats would eat the stored grain, it would mold, or angry mobs would start a fire resulting in famine. Also, you cant survive just on grain. Potatoes, yes. Grain, no. My estimate is that regardless of the outcome of the war all those people will be dead in less than a year.
@@TheSuperappelflap Yeah, spoilage is a thing but that is getting deeper than I wanted to go and going to be highly dependent on storage technology which I can't even speculate. As to needing other foods for nutrients, sure, but that would some combination of things they produce in small amounts for consumption or things obtained by trading their excess crops.
(After watching Rebel Moon) Luke Skywalker: I'm getting pretty tired of people ripping off my story. I think I'll read something to relax. (reads Eragon) Damn it! Maybe I'll play a video game instead. (plays Final Fantasy XII) DAMN IT!!
Eragon was written by a teenager intending to create a generic hero's journey story. You have to know the rules first in order to break them effectively
Also, watching RM:Part2, when you do your CinemaSins for that movie, in the Post Sentence phase, please have Okoye from Avengers Infinity War say the "Why was she up there all this time?!" when James does his ATAT-wannabe bomb drop, eject, super-hero landing in slo-mo, destruction. Thanks.
No sin for the fact that, of all the places they stopped and found a person to fight with them, the person they find in Gladiator arena was Djimon Hounsou ?!
"i'm sorry but I forgot who this is" totally relate, cause they brought her in during the damn final battle. No one gets developed in anyway to make us give a damn
Someone once told me that Snyder movies have "Divorced dad trying to get in the pants of his daughter's best friend" vibes, and I hated his movies ever since.
I don't know the veracity of this, but I did hear it was a movie that Snyder pitched to Disney to take place in the Star Wars universe, but Disney turned him down. If that's true, all the Star Wars elements would be easily explainable.
However, I can't help but notice there wasn't a sin for "a farm boy from the outer region of the sector goes on an epic quest to take down the tyrannical rulers of the galaxy".
