Everything Wrong With The Lion King (2019) In The Circle Of Minutes 

YES TRUE

Yeah, he just looks like if a depressed and sad dog and a crazy lion had a baby

Have you seen a lion with menacing eyes. It's supposed to be like a real life lion.

Sometimes I couldn’t tell if Simba was sad. Sure I heard the I’m sorry dad crying voice but the lion look like he was saying it with a straight face. Hard to show emotion on cgi animals.

He IS sad

I nearly spit out my food when I realized

*Uncles be like that sometimes*

Funniest one too

I yelled and almost choked while driving!! 🤣🤣😭

Uncles and their little secrets!

My exact question

To obvious

Elected News This channel doesn’t do good / actually sins anymore. Watch Birdmen EWW Cinema Sins.

@@AstroStrongBox well thats the thing, they never did 😂

The only movie they did actual sins for was Dragonball Evolution

Battle Burrito Lol. 😁

Well, it was Jeremy Irons, and that man's charisma can shine through even when he's just an animated character

Yep

They changed it because the old one apparently was too "queer coded"

They ruined his song ;/

ikr

1,000 sins.

I’ll take it I’m glad the next generation had more representation and next up black little mermaid lol

@@frozenlizard3370 I give it 1,000,000 sins 😒

“This movie exists” *Adds 1000 sins, and the video ends*

Right

They didn't ask him to return because they wanted all the lions to be voiced by black people. I guess.

Cintrón Productions lmao

As if it would even manage to make this garbage fire movie better. But still a fair sin.

@@cintronproductions9430 I don't get as to why they thought that would work. The original was an animated movie involving talking animals in Africa where no humans appear at all and the actors gave vocal performances for their characters, not acting on a set like you would in live action. The original cast had a mix of white and black actors and nobody made a big deal about actors like Moria Kelly, Matthew Broderick, and James Earl Jones playing lions that live in the same environment. The directors picked those actors because they thought that they were the right choice for the characters they wanted them to be portrayed. They were voice acting, so race didn't matter in that case, so why did they do this attempt here? It failed because everyone felt miscast.

Yep, so true

Yeah so true

How is that "cliché"?

@@cameussmith It's a reference to the "cliché" running gag on CinemaSins

*Ding*

ok...wdym?

Which, in Swahili, either means "Want" or "Garbage." Damn, their parents were horrible

well, giving yourself a nickname is horrible and i would avoid that nickname at all time if i know someone who did that

I thought Mufasa nicknamed him Scar after Taka got the scar.

@@b3rz3rk3r9 And Mufasa means King. They were like: pff I don't care about the eldest one, this other one shall be king

@Lệ Hoa Trương Oh I thought he wasn't sorry then

Me too. Waste of time.

Yup

You didn't miss much

Same here. Disney is going to the well one to many times.

It isn't good

i knew this but now that i think ab it, mufasas a dickhead and so were his parents

I didn't know his name was Taka, but the rest was super obvious. I don't know why Jeremy even asked the question

His parents set him up for failure naming him "Trash".

Maybe Mufasa was actually being NICE when he called him Scar? After all, wouldn't you prefer your brother to be named after a scar rather than garbage?

@Dixie Cronin I mean, Taka also means “To want,” as in like, ambition or something.

What's after Bugs life and Nemo live remakes I wonder.. Cars???

@@robertagu5533 Dont send us down that path.

_Cars_ lmao. THAT would be freaky. Although if they remade it with real cars and just had their characters transmitted to human drivers, I feel like that could actually be cool

I can see it now "cars" is gonna be the new disney transformer movie

The future is now old man

New Lion King: ok boomer

Old Lion King: whatever Youngin

@@TimdeKousemaeker Certain restrictions apply. Blackout periods and availability subject to change. For full details contact lunarleisureliving.com.

I was so looking forward to that part but was dissapointed when he finds his staff in the middle of the final battle.

In the original that lines delivery was triumphant yet dripping with malice. They really butchered it.

But Jeremy Irons was too white to be in the remake

exactly! I thought I was the only one who was really disappointed with this. it changed from _"Long, live, the _*_king..."_* and Scar throwing his brother off the mountainside, to "Long, live, THE KING!" and Scar..... slapping Mufasa away from him?

He seems to scream it in this one, in the original he whispers

@@roydm143 yep, but that doesn’t mean the original “long live the king” wasn’t twice as sinister and bone-chilling (simply put it, better voice acting)

Lol. 😂

I think they were trying too hard to make it feel more "extreme" this time around lmao

I much preferred the original where Scar stabs his claws into Mufasa, the soft whisper into Mufasas ear “...long live the king...” as he looks his writhing brother and throws him off the ledge

I personally think that the new version also doesn’t really fit his character. Tho OG establishes that Mufasa got the brawns while Scar got the brains, which is why Scar comes up with the plan with the Wildebeests to trample him to death. If he tried to fight Mufasa, he’d get his ass beat hard. That’s carried even more so when his claws stuck in Mufasa’s on the cliff. He’s proud of himself. His plan worked. And he’s gonna let Mufasa know as he slowly says, “Long.. live.. the King.” His brother looks at him, with horror in his eyes as he realizes what he’s about to do as Scar lets him fall to his death. In the new version, Scar just bitch slaps him off the cliff AND his delivery is so fast we don’t see Mufasa’s reaction as he falls to death(which is ultimately fine since none of the characters have any sort of facial expressions at all). One issue, aside from many, I have with these Disney remakes is that they make such tiny and small changes to certain scenes that you think wouldn’t be noticeable, but ultimately make those scenes not hit nearly as hard as they should. They lack the nuance that made the originals classics.

yes its super unsatisfying

I like this remake, a lot more then most. but I will admit the other scar was better

To be fair, the original _everything_ was better

I liked this version cause it was so different, it felt more like a war chant than a song, but yeah I agree the original, of course, is definitely way better.

Agreed. Jeremy Irons and Jim Cummings were ICONIC in that performance (Jim finished the second half, Jeremy's voice gave out).

Ashlyn Lockard YES! OMG. MYFABOURITE SONG FROM THISMOVIEANDTHEY FRICKING CUT IT!

Natalie Chua Not Disney’s fault. They weren’t going to have the song in the movie at all but people just had to bitch and moan about it which gave us the short version.

...true

Good point

Scar wanted Sarabi in this version for two reasons: one, it was more realistic regarding lion pride dynamics and two, it gave mufasa and scar more of a backstory.

Sierra Faith ..I’m pretty sure it’s because he’s gotten old, but I’m not sure. I’m not James Earl Jones.

Sierra Faith You have a point.

I mean, the Star Wars franchise dragged him back briefly, and he sounded tired there too

Dixie Cronin But he actually tried in what they brought him back for. Rebels was my favorite show as a kid, and I remember how awesome that voice was compared to Matt Sloan’s in the LEGO parodies. I also saw Rogue One in theaters, and he was absolutely incredible. What he was brought back was something he wanted to try, and he didn’t want to try in this movie.

You have a point, but I would credit that to his age. He was already old in the original.

Couldn't agree more, one of my favorite sins but one I haven't heard outside of this video and one of his originals years ago. Could be used so much more often on atrocities like The Last Airbender or Justice League

this movie is one huge bag of nope. and really this live movie was probably a test to see if people would like it and make another one.

Total waste of 💰

Olle Selin to us, yes, to Disney, no

Every thing is wrong about the movie if u play orginal side by side with this one they would not sync up at all that's why isaid he'll nocwyen isaw trailer just all wrong and something no one asked for along with the other shitty remakes

Sweet home Alabama.

Jeremy Irons offered to do Scar again.

My uncle’s wasn’t little

@@jacobhales4557 lmfao 😂 holy shit I hope your ok

Either "Sweet home Alabama" or if they are from my country the "Sweet home Santiago Del Estero"

dID yoU kNoW taka also means hawk in japanese? 😄

@@mahuarangorath2423 CoOl

Yeah Taka means garbage in Swahili, which makes the nickname both worse and better I guess

@@mahuarangorath2423 OMG THATS SO COOL OMG I AM TOTALLY NOT SARCASTIC OMG THAT IS SO COOL

Well, I thought scar was a stupid name...

@@sierrafaith403 I hope that's what he did

Sierra Faith I hope he did that. James Earl Jones is too good for this abomination. Let him retire in peace.

He was in his 80s, would you want to sit in a recording booth for hours on end at 80 years old?

​@@sierrafaith403 Not defending anything but as someone whose grandfather is 88 years old. People that old can't do much and considering how much it sounds like poor old Earl was struggling through his lines, I don't doubt he was any different.

James Earl Jones is old as hell. Even in rogue one his VA was diminished.

Good thing that they didn’t add that delete scene: Scar goes wild (if you know what I mean 😏😢)

@@yoshi_chuck05 I think I remember a cut scene from the cartoon Lion King where Scar was overly flirty with Simba's mother, to no success. As if implying he tried hard to solve that.

@@JayHog1992 Nope, that was Nala, not Sarabi

@@Aimi_Kaneko Ah. That's just creepier then.

There isn’t enough sins for that shit show

The Independent And the worst in the remake, along with ‘Can You Feel the Love Tonight?’.

The Independent yup, the best

@@patrickgracias5782 And Scar survived the fall from the Pride Rock, because he had the High Ground, right?

The biggest let down of this film, that was one of my fav songs from the origanol

I lost it hearing that xD

First time I actually laugh out loud with a sins video, that line was gold.

atJesper I’d like the comment but it’s 420 likes

I had to pause the video and just laugh for a solid minute. That shit was so dark and so out of nowhere for only being one word.

Thats the reason the LGBT complained back in the 90s. They felt Jeremy Irons portrayal was too British gay and swishy. There were a lot of negative coded play on words screaming that Scar was a negative gay stereotype. So when the direct to video sequel came out they gave Scar a wife and daughter. And Irons was not asked back for the remake.

I agree

Thank you. I also hate how it was cut in half and they didn’t do the full song

Thank you for somebody noticing pluses entire movie is terrible except 1 only one scene actually no I take that back now

Totally agree

Totally agree

Huhu i see what ya did there

@2023 Brayden Langford how about you do what you suggested, you rude pos?

Ahhh ab old meme

You deserve 20 sins just for making that joke

@@ArtisticallySpoken gladly

My jaw dropped when he said that

bro i was in shock...😱

Did Liverpool say some mean things to them beforehand, I wonder?

When did he say it

Chiedozie Agwu 17:32

Daniel Palmer DADDY HAS THE HIGH GROUND

*YOU WERE THE CHOSEN JUAN!!!*

it's simply "Don't try it." also one doesn't have to do with the other. Lion King is falling. Star Wars is jumping. I'll never understand how such random comments get votes.

Josh McIver because it’s about the high ground and you both movies don’t have to be related to make memes out of them

That is boss level lazy

The legend is 88 years old! He's allowed to be tired after such a distinguished and lengthy career.

@@KareemHarper true, though the fact he has to compete with his own younger performance makes it too obvious and further shows Disney was only thinking "if we get the original voice of Mufasa, no one will complain. Who cares if he sounds too old now. No one will notice". Yeah, Disney. We noticed. Ya wanna know how? WE HAVE THE ORIGINAL MOVIE!

That was one thing I noticed immediately. James just sounded so bored, he barely emoted and literally sounded like he was just flatly reading the lines out. They all did... Pumbaa and Timon's actors were the only ones that actually attempted to interject any personality into the characters they were playing.

@@KareemHarper Umm, no. Christopher Plummer is 89 years old and is still acting his butt off in movies like All the Money in the World and most recently, Knives Out, so age should not excuse acting ability.

@@Lauren_210 this was also james last role he retired after this flim

Scar was the favorite. Totally, for sure. 🤣

Why does everyone keep saying this? Taka was from a non canon book. We still don’t know how scar got his name.

You don’t have that power sir

Get a room.

*D I N G*

Yep. Hated it.

Chos3n Entertainment it was horrible they just killed the whole song

Be prepared was always my favourite Villain song, and I like this version. Sure it's different but I don't think it's as bad as I see some people say it is. But then it's all about taste. Some will like it, some won't ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

It deserved all the sins in the world

No no no no no. It wasn't even a song. It was chanting. It doesnt count

and if you see the behind the scenes--at least what i have glimpsed--that seems to be pretty close to how they actually did it, too...

maybe they should have had blake and gwen play simba and nala

And last I checked, almost all of them did.

and they all have

I'm sure one has to be good... if not to you, then to someone else. I enjoyed this remake.

@@RosheenQuynh Jungle Book is one that was okay. The only one so far. Mulan seems to adapt the original chinese source material instead of the animation one. So there is hope that it might be good.

@@KhanMann66 Yeah, the Jungle Book one is the only good they did in recent memory. Others are passably at best but totally unnecessary.

When this came out, I watched sooooo many videos just ripping this movie apart and quite a few of them at the very least mentioned if not full on discuss how emotions on a cgi lion worked way better on Aslan than in this movie

Well yes, but Mufasa's appearance in the scene where Jeremy makes that comment looks almost exactly like a scene from the 2005 Lion/Witch/Wardrobe movie.

Well in that particular scene it did look like aslan bruh

The fact that the chronicles of Narnia movies message to get more expression out of the animals than in this movie, is just hilarious to me.

It’s not that he looked more realistic, it’s that Aslan could emote better than the animals in this movie because the creators of narnia weren’t so obsessed with realism. The animals in this remake look realistic yet emotionally stunted.

Extremely disappointed

Yeah, I was. cuz it's like the best song in the movie, and it's done so badly in the remake!

Blame the people that complained when they found out that it wasn't going to be in the movie at all.

You are correct

Disney actually said it wasn't gonna be put in, but ig it was even though it was so flat and uninspiring.

True, the rest of us are still trying to forget that it even exists!😅😉

I think You have Alzheimer.

Just Some Guy without a Mustache I feel you. I saw this movie (against my will) and forgot about it

@@rodrigosilv30 or just a lack of interest for yet another Disney remake

You're lucky. I wish I could forget this movie exists

I don’t know how they missed that sin! It was so obvious right on screen when the song occurred!

"can you feel the love this afternoon?" Doesn't ring to well! Even Elton John hated this movie !

OH GOD *EUGH* I FEEL LIKE I'M ABOUT TO- *PUKES*

Please don't give them ideas

*Finding Nemo Disney on Ice*

Okay, but that's actually hilarious to imagine bc how terrible it sounds (so long as it never actually happens).

It's a Pixar movie, Pixar would never dare to make a live action adaptation of their movies, it's pointless and many of their movies don't really work in live action especially Finding Nemo, Toy Story and Ratatouille, imagine those movies in live action

That’s basically every live action remake in a nutshell. The cartoony styles of the originals have lots of charm and energy and when they are remade to live action, it just becomes dull and soulless, with probably The Lion King remake being the best/worst example (but I wouldn’t be surprised if that honor/dishonor could belong to The Little Mermaid remake that comes out soon)

How about Mulan, will you forgive them for that and Hong Kong?

Creterampage Studios same. I could’ve cried. That was the ONLY song I was prepared to sing.

@@RecoveringChristian he is not even talking about that

Imagine what they'd do to Zira's lullaby God it would be awful

I cringed on how Scar said "Long Live the King" in this film

same, been laughing for forever

Leonard part 6? Oh sorry, we don't talk about that

Can someone explain?

I am a pig!

The world exploded

Wasn't the Amazon rainforest "actually" on fire when this video came out?

@DutchViking 6949 Shut up

indeed

next stop: Hell part 2, 2021

That is what happens when all your actors in the original completely 100% nail their parts. Then some company, lets say for example Disney, is all like "Lets do it all again, just umm somehow better than the people who did it perfect before you. Your motivation is umm something about the best whatever movie because we probably wont try to remake in again in the future and tell those actors the same thing we are telling you.... Umm make us money, er I mean try....to .... do..... better...... than.... the....original.....perfection?"

Dan Christmas let’s hope that never happens. It’s possible because they did it to The Lion King.

Dan Christmas a little extreme but I’m in! I would’ve just put a severed horse head in their bed.

I prefer the animated version I grew up with not this.

@Dan Christmas yup

m jefferson and all the voices sound the same, emotionless and mono toned lol.

Exists*

CinemaSins: Dumbo 2019 - This movie exist CinemaSins: Dog pussy and the Trump 2019 - Sigh CinemaSins: Mulan 2019 - ??? (Honestly I have no idea how that remake will do when it comes out)

Dumbo 2019 = cinemasins didn't said this movie exist .

This shitty profile picture also exists ding

he's old and even he hated it.

Gee he's 90.

But granted, he IS in his 80s, so I'd cut him a LITTLE slack, but i get what you mean. He sounds like he REALLY doesn't want to be there.

He’s probably the only one with an excuse. He’s in his 80’s, he can’t perform as good as he used to. The others have no real excuse.

Even when he asks Scar to help him up the cliff it just sounds like he's asking for help to bring groceries in.

@@aliciacleeland2257 Yeah and he didn't even say "brother", he just sounded like he was saying "Hey Scar, help me move this sofa". 🤣

Same thing when he voices Vader in Rogue One. He's old and tired. Should have casted someone that could imitate for Vader, and just do a complete recast in this. Also, Beyoncé ruined every song. She sang them like it was an audition for American Idol, completely messing up the harmony. They are songs - not a demo reel to show off your vocal range.

I bet its because people throw around Copyright Claims non stop nowadays.

Pumbaa singing the hula song was missing, I was gutted

Tracy Johnson I forget about that and me to!

@@SupportMensMentalHealth I think you mean Timon. Pumbaa was who he was singing about lol

@@MurderOfSuburbia Ehh, he did add those upbeat "yup yup yup"s to the sing lol

Indeed

Aslan means lion in turkish

@@batukurtluoglu845 💀

I mean lions can only look so different

@Juan Cortez Muro This isn't Instagram, fuck off with that self-promotion.

Teskii 94 WELL THAT WAS EASY

Nice

yeah, i dont get how they managed that when so many documentaries add a narrative and emotion over real animals actions.

What pisses me off the most about this remake is the fact they didn't darken Scar's mane. Like, that's an actual thing in lion's. Some lion's have dark fur and almost black manes. They could've kept it, but nope! They made him some ashy little weirdo with an anatomically incorrect face.

Is "CGI lions doing it" a - the name of an unsuccessful hipster ska band from California. b - deleted scenes from Lucy. c - Detroit american football fans' only solace since Matthew Stafford was drafted. d - what my college girlfriend was focused on while trying to fake orgasms.

@@luckyspurs how could they do it? No balls, no lion snusnu

@@luckyspurs The third always has to be a spicy Albanian cola drink

Lion porn

KatArt Corner same, I absolutely love the original and to see it like this really hurts.

Even the Jungle Book animals look more realistic.

I think it's not just realism as a factor. Other Disney movies that have gone for realistic animals still stylised them, giving the characters a range of expressions that are absent in the Lion King remake.

The idea of photorealistic animals would have been better if they used it in an original story

Mhm. You are correct.

'Tis a shame how giant corporations tend to stray from their founders' mission statements after the founders pass. Look at Walmart, for example.

So basically Bob Iger deliberately disobeyed Walt’s legacy.

Large Format Master Yup.

Large Format Master Walt wasn’t a greedy man. He just wanted to show the world his talents.

@@francoisburnette901 And his ambitions. The studio was just the money machine to fuel said ambitions.

How did a corporate giant like Disney miss that?

The Ashman r u trying to be funny because I’m so sick of seeing this overused copied comment it’s not funny at all

@@ElizabethGlasby at least it's funnier than YOUR comment. Or mine. But whatever

LILYAN MEYERS Thanks

SonicBoom AXA Thanks

Robyn Howells I bust out laughing 😭

Same, maybe if aslan was in this movie it'd be better

God if only the animation was that good

Robyn Howells That was my first thought when I saw that seem too!

They never do what he says he wiil take them off for because Hollywood, especially Disney, doesn't have the balls or creativity needed to get him to remove all the sins. Something unexpected, unpredictable, and genuinely/horrifically funny.

Never

Wait for next April Fool's Day.

Man if Simba started Humping nala at that exact moment, I think we'd all like this movie suddenly

Well the slogan of this channel is “no movie is without sin” so I don’t think they’d ever remove all the sins. Would be neat to see though

no

💀

I don’t even think you watched the video before posting this

I didn't say the comment was about the video

You’ve already made the same comment in the previous videos, be creative next time dude.

LARSON FREDERICK - well Nala was a female and male lions are supposed to protect the female ones, not lead them to danger (there’s been cases where female lions end up attacking the leading Male lion in refute to its unfair treatment)

I think it's like, you did your stupid bullshit that I told you not to do, and you dragged someone else into your stupid bullshit that I told you not to do.

LARSON FREDERICK you can practically hear James Earl Jones in the recording booth questioning why the hell he has to say these lines again when he got it right the first time around. He has little to NO emotion in that scene compared to the original

Which doesn't make sense in the first place... real lion prides have one dominant male who produced ALL THE OFFSPRING. Nala would be his daughter... When a new male takes over the pride by defeating the old male, he kills the old male's cubs and bangs the lionesses to make his own. The lionesses don't refuse him. It's fucked up, but nature is fucked up.

@@nahor88 I don't think lions really cares about incest 😂

Jeremy Irons is not black. They wanted black/africans/african-american actors voicing all the lions this time around.

@@tayl2991 and it ruined the movie by doing so

Taylor Lange And this is how casting based on race is shit comparing to casting based on merit and skills...

로라 [Laura] I think it was creative to have the remake done with minorities. It’s about time white people didn’t get all the best stuff. Look at the Aladdin remake. Hardly any white people in it, and Mena Massoud is so cute and Naomi Scott is so beautiful

@@tayl2991 The race of a character should not be changed in remakes just to appeal to minorities. If you want to give minorities more recognition create characters based off their race. I am sure a lot of people would have been pissed to see a white Aladdin or a pink Genie!

Nope

@@Marvelfanatic3658 what's wrong?

FACTS I SAY!!! FACTS GAWD DAMMIT!!!

And they will thank you for showing them one of those, and hate you for showing them the other two.

Yeah and Snow White is from 1937... She didn't need a fricking remake to keep her alive

People forget there's no real benevolent reason for these remakes, they literally exist either to renew some trademarks or just make big money at the box office. Which all the Renaissance remakes did.

amen to that!

Glover, Ejiofor, and Jones sounded that way too.

i feel like they could have animated the faces more.

How disappointing...

well, yeah, that's literally how voice acting works.

@@nuberiffic umm. No. Lol. I should have said it felt emotionless and drab.

I think he needs therapy. We all do.

Please someone remove your like so we can stay at 420 please

The Human Garage Disposal YOU THINK YOU’RE BETTER THAN ME?!

@@handsomest1 Yes.

The Human Garage Disposal BIG MAN ON CAMPUS OH FUCKING LOOK AT YOU WHAT A FUCKING JOKE

he’s better than everyone in the movie

He completely made me see Scar differently after that. Lmfao

Just like my uncle :(

I WAS ABOUT TO COMMENT THIS

and he got the scar from a cobra, shown in The Lion Guard

Cool!

No, it means "I am Lion. Son of King." (Yes, that means a lion named King and a lion named Mirage had a cub and decided to name it "Lion".) (Extra fun fact while I'm here: Scar's real name, Taka, translates as "dirt" or "garbage".)

@@jerryorg1 technically, Taka means 'Want' (the verb). Waste or garbage is 'Takataka'.

I hated the "Be Prepared" remake. That was the closest I ever came to making an IED and causally dropping it in one of the bushes near the Disney headquarters.

Yo I hated that.

It's a lot more obvious when you smack him as opposed to whispering and then letting go. Even if Zazu or Simba did see the animated version, Scar could at least try to spin it as him being unable to hold on. Here he has NO alibi in the event of someone seeing this happen.

@@crocuslament9680 I liked the animated one better cause as scar whispers in his ear you can see the fear & betrayal in mufasa's eyes and feel the pain when scar releases his paws. This one it's like well I didn't know what to do so I'll just slap you off the cliff.

@@aliciacleeland2257 The slap was so out of place that I couldn't help but chuckle. The reaction was more "what a dick" then "you monster."