No video :(

Formula 1 Stewarding Is BROKEN | The Fernando Alonso Podium Saga

Подписаться 33 тыс.

Просмотров 4,1 тыс.

50% 1

Fernando Alonso and Aston Martin have once again proven to be a force to be reckoned with in F1 2023. The Spaniard secured a second podium finish at the Saudi Arabian Grand Prix having driven flawlessly throughout. However, the race didn't come without controversy, as he was initially demoted from P3 due to not serving his 5 second time penalty correctly. This decision was then overturned after Aston Martin's appeal. However, it begs the question, should we trust F1 stewards anymore?
Let me know your thoughts in the comment section below.
Please like, share and subscribe to the channel if you are new, to get my latest videos in the future
Formula 1 Channel: / @formula1
Music provided by the talented LCS beats: / lcsprod
Copyright Disclaimer: Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. There are certain scenes from the Formula 1 calendar where race footage is used. All those rights are property of FOM. Other photos and news elements are used solely for the purpose of assisting the original content illuminate a more in depth story.
#f1 #astonmartin #alonso #formula1 #formulaone #saudiarabia #saudiarabiagp

Опубликовано:

6 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 45

@Well_be_right_back Год назад

I think the FIA have been in utter disarray ever since Charlie Whiting unfortunately passed away. He was actually a competent race director who didn’t make decisions to favour one driver or team like a certain somebody. I can bet that if he was still race director, controversies such as Abu Dhabi 2021, what happen yesterday with penalties would not be happening. It’s great to see someone making a high quality video on a topic that is rarely talked about

@BMPHF1 Год назад

Thanks Sangeth. Charlie was a brilliant race director who often got too much stick than he deserved. He was as close to impartial as possible and actually used common sense when judging most incidents.

@42mag Год назад

I understand both sides of the safety car issue. Was it needed? No. However, for whatever reason they were unsure of where the car was so they immediately brought out the safety car. In the recent past there has been a lot of criticism with how they have delayed a safety car, and for good reason. Better to have it and not need it, then need it and not have it. Jetta is a track with not a lot of run off or safe places to park a car off the track. If Stroll had to stop the car right away it could have been in a very dangerous spot.

@BMPHF1 Год назад

True. I guess it’s better to be safe rather than sorry. In hindsight, maybe they thought also that it wasn’t necessary

@42mag Год назад

@@BMPHF1 Yeah, but even ignoring the safety car issue, it's still another clown show weekend for the FIA.

@troltroltrolman Год назад

Bmph the best f1 RU-vidr around

@BMPHF1 Год назад

🤝

@uzaironf1704 Год назад

Honestly, I can't be bothered to watch F1 anymore, and the FIA is a big reason for that. I'll just keep up to date on Twitter until something interesting happens.

@BMPHF1 Год назад

I understand where you’re coming from man. Things are different than they used to be

@sanjayoak4416 Год назад

It means all teams must have an independent department to handle these kind of situations where huge points can be gained (regained) or lost. Good work Aston Martin.

@BMPHF1 Год назад

Very good point. Especially for teams lower down the grid. Every point counts.

@sanjayoak4416 Год назад

I would like to add to this- why the concerned race stewards should not be penalised for such irresponsible decisions. We all know that each point is worth thousands of dollars. This penalty recovered should go to the concerned team as it unnecessarily has to dig deep into proving this otherwise, or else lose points/money.

@graemewestbrook8826 Год назад

Merc moaning to the fia toto can't stand that a customer team is better with the same engine

@marcusstrymon693 Год назад

I know a funny story: Member, when stewards did not overturn decisions in Abu Dhabi? Man that was epic and so fair.

@BMPHF1 Год назад

🎯

@fortijr Год назад

Savage!

@marcusstrymon693 Год назад

@@fortijr I am waiting for team verstappen to enter the chat lol

@carlob517 Год назад

Another occasion was when Hamilton wasn't penalised until AFTER a GP was over & Podium celebrations done, the FIA had plenty of time to enforce a penalty during the race on him this resulted in Carlos Sainz missing out on his 1st podium , Q. How the he'll do they correct this? Sainz will never feature in any photos or videos whatsoever great job FIA 👏 , have to agree since Whiting isn't stewarding any more the FIA have done a very mediocre job NO consistency at all NONE!, Liberty should be giving the FIA a stern warning that it Must do better as it affects income and support in F1 Or there should be consequences

@BMPHF1 Год назад

Yeah the Brazil incident in 2019, Lewis should’ve been penalised there and then. It was clear-cut. Sainz deserved to be up there with Verstappen and Gasly that day. Remember the clash between the FIA and F1 recently? Involving Mohammed Ben Sulayem. The FIA needs some serious work in order to come anywhere close to being considered competent

@Banyo__ Год назад

I can't really pick a side with this one. On one end, the drivers/teams are always barking about the sport needing to be policed more because drivers are getting away with things, and it seems they have taken that complaint on board...four tenths of a second...I'd say they are watching, but then there is of course consistency. This wasn't a last lap thing. This was a "this happened 30 minutes ago" thing and there is nothing worse than stripping a driver of a trophy, after the fact when this could have been settled mid race as it should have been. Problem with blame it on the FIA culture is...okay, we can all do that until we're red in the face, but what have you got to replace them? Who is going to do it better to the satisfaction of all teams/drivers? What entity is that much greater than what the FIA can provide? So far, no one has thrown their hat in the ring or been accepted as any type of real replacement. There were threats of mutiny years ago and nothing came of it. All we can really do is say, do better and they will hopefully try, but we know next race, or the one after that, there will be some incident that has never happened before that will cause a cluster F, that we will once again be having this conversation about.

@BMPHF1 Год назад

I understand the sentiment that for those instances that haven’t been seen there being margin for error and a certain level of forgiveness. But on the other hand, it’s important to call out the shortcomings of the governing body for the same reason you mentioned - there’s nobody else who is capable of stepping in and replacing them. If they are all the sport has, then I think it’s very valid to be critical of such incidents. Of course, doing so in a sensible manner.

@gizmo-8762 Год назад

What can I say!!! Thanks for this fact base perspective!!!

@BMPHF1 Год назад

😊

@isakibrahim8316 Год назад

This year gonna be so dead but welcome back to the best f1 RU-vidr

@BMPHF1 Год назад

Thank you Isak 😊

@fortijr Год назад

Great content!

@BMPHF1 Год назад

Thank you 😊

@garythefishable Год назад

I'm starting to think the FIA uses them manatees from South Park to dish out penalties.

@BMPHF1 Год назад

💀😂

@fortijr Год назад

LMAO

@imibuks-replit Год назад

Maybe even ChatGPT could do better

@fortijr Год назад

@@imibuks-replit Brilliant!!

@ryanjonathanmartin3933 Год назад

The penalty was fair, I think. But the fact that they took so long to make a decision is embarrassing. Not the first time they've done something like this. Also I notice that these dumb decisions tend to happen at Jeddah specifically, and yeah some have pointed out that the track layout may have something to do with it. I actually think the FIA's sporting regs are generally well-written. It's the way they enforce it that is below par.

@imibuks-replit Год назад

Yes that is hte problem!

@BMPHF1 Год назад

This 🎯

@marco_1909 Год назад

The fia policies jewelry and underwears more than on track action. Twitter experts could do much better than the clown show the fia is.

@Bahamuttiamat Год назад

Inconsistency in f1? Tell me more. Prior to the last 3 posting you were far and away more consistent than the FIA will ever hope to be. Speaking on Lewis's Russia 2020 practice starts infringements, did you know charles leclerc did the exact same thing in spa earlier in the year? But Lewis is erm... different. And deserves.... different treatment. *removes tinfoil hat* Cheers buddy, keep it coming.

@imibuks-replit Год назад

"everyone is special" ~ That one mom

@BMPHF1 Год назад

Lmao. Yeah at least my 3 month upload schedule had some pattern 😂. And yeah the penalties for the Russia 2020 practice starts were just a joke. As you say, Leclerc in Spa got let off for doing the same.

@ak7-constantine213 Год назад

There is NO audio ! I tried on 3 devices 😠

@inigogonzalez8277 Год назад

Bring back Michael Masi

@paulsmith8750 Год назад

F1 stewarding is a joke. Decisions dont seem to have any objectivity. They seem to be driven less by racing and more by the narrative and viewership. This is sad as it negates F1 as a fair and unbiased sport. The stewards are headed towards losing all form of credibility and becoming a meme.