Song: New York State of Mind Originally by: Billy Joel (Made famous by Barbra Streisand) Sung by: Melissa Benoist (Marley Rose) & Lea Michele (Rachel Berry) Episode: 4x01 "The New Rachel"
Gosh I love Melissa Benoist's voice!! Both are great singers but I find Melissa's to be rich and full, something I prefer over Rachel's raspy and intense voice.
Melissa is such a wasted character. They should include her more. Rachel was always important to the club and Marley was just there. Her voice was so misused. Terrible season 4-6.
I know people gonna hate for this, but I don't like Rachel's voice, it just hits this nerve in my brain and annoys me so much, marley on the other hand has a calm soothing voice while Rachel's is raspy and annoying