I got the fortunate opportunity to meet Jeff Daniels, playing Joshua Chamberlain in this scene. I told him how much I enjoyed seeing “Gettysburg” as well as “Gods and Generals” and he replied “Thank you very much. Those were the good ones.”
This film does show the absolute tragedy of sending good men off to be slaughtered by bad generals. And other good men being sent into the meat grinder in defense of a treasonous and morally bankrupt cause. Lessons we still need to learn.
The three characters I really "fell for" in Gettysburg were Longstreet, Buford and Chamberlain. But it was Chamberlain who won my heart with that outstanding bayonet charge on Little Round Top.
This movie was definitely flawed in ways that Gettysburg was not. But at the same time it’s still very underappreciated. It’s a lot better than people give it credit for.