Graham Hancock vs Flint Dibble: All DeDunking Responses

Подписаться 43 тыс.

Просмотров 8 тыс.

50% 1

A compilation of my 5 videos covering the debate.
Debate:
• Joe Rogan Experience #...
Patreon:
/ dedunking
Ko-Fi:
ko-fi.com/dedu...
Instagram:
/ dedunking
Twitter:
/ dedunkingpast
Discord:
/ discord
Scientific Papers:
www.pnas.org/d...
academic.oup.c...
genome.cshlp.o...
www.sciencedir...
link.springer....
academic.oup.c...
www.eurekalert...
www.nature.com...
www.tandfonlin...
www.sciencedir...
agupubs.online...
www.dri.edu/as...
www.nature.com...
icecores.org/a...
www.dri.edu/as...
icecores.org/a...
nsidc.org/data...
www.science.or...
edu.rsc.org/fe....
An exploration of the boat form and the element of water through craft based sculptural works
www.nationalge...
www.heritageda...
www.nationalge...
novoscriptoriu...
www.academia.e...
www.nbcnews.co...
www.dailymail....
www.apollo-mag...
www.nbcnews.co...
www.livescienc...
www.annualrevi...
www.researchga...
cp.copernicus....
www.sciencedir...
onlinelibrary....
ncseagrant.ncs...
www.science.or...
www.jstor.org/... - skeptic af
www.archaeolog...
www.jstor.org/...
www.bradshawfo...
hakaimagazine....
heatherpringle...
significance-of-the-bluefish-caves-in-beringian-prehistory
www.researchga...
Photographic-montage-showing-the-Bluefish-Caves-mammoth-bone-core-upper-left-and-the_fig3_251906253
www.cbc.ca/new...
www.journals.u...
www.sapiens.or...
link.springer....
www.structural....
• Randall Carlson & Grah...
home.dartmouth...
faculty-direct...
graham-hancock-joe-rogan-archaeology
www.thoughtco....
documents.saa....

Опубликовано:

30 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 194

@carijay 3 месяца назад

My impression of Dibble is that he got frustrated with the lack of attention he was getting, so he decided to go full drama on something he assumed was an easy target. He thought Rogan was his ticket to fame and used his name as click-bate , announcing his victory after his horrible diatribe. He didn't win anyone over,. Hancock is more like a philosopher than a scientist. Rogan serves as a host. The only one fighting is Dibble, and he would rather rant than get out in the field and get dirty.

@abelbabel8484 3 месяца назад

100% this is about the academy fighting off independent competition

@SassyTheSasquatch96 4 месяца назад

Cant wait for all the comments that will no doubt try to misrepresent you or simply not listen to what you had to say because tiktok video says Dedunking man bad.

@matthewsmolinsky5605 4 месяца назад

What TikTok video?!

@musically-assureddestructi8843 4 месяца назад

Electrician man bad

@xenosophont 4 месяца назад

After the JRE debate, there have been lots of videos from the system-sanctioned science-priesthood attacking Hancock & alt-theories etc. with the usual stale talking points and the Dibble-drivel and these vids are promoted like crazy with the YT algo (obv. an artificial boost). After this series, you could pick some of the prominent ones among those vids and pick them apart.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Thanks I may just do that!

@DrMattColborn 4 месяца назад

As usual, no matter who we think ‘won’ the debate, everyone stands to learn a lot of new things from this video! Very interesting and nuanced!

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Thanks!

@bschmidt1 4 месяца назад

I love the way you laid out the rice feralization topic, pointing out the pros/cons of both sides. This really gets at the issue I had with Dibble - the outright confidence in something nobody could possibly know, shutting down any attempt to research it. It's as if Dibble doesn't feel anyone other than him and his team are qualified to speak about a subject and he often speaks way beyond what he could know, and with a scary confidence.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Thanks, yeah Flint was debating and took that position over scientific impartiality. Sadly he seems to do this anytime he speaks on this topic.

@DickiesDisintegratingWan-dt3ek 3 месяца назад

Old Hancock certainly isn't qualified to speak about anything to do with archaeology. He is a peddler of unoriginal, third rate pseudoscience and a drug addict, nothing more.

@axax7668 4 месяца назад

Dribble reminds me of the Muppet show Swedish chef waving his hands and talking gibberish!😂

@bschmidt1 4 месяца назад

"My dad told me!!"

@axax7668 4 месяца назад

@@bschmidt1 Are you the Swedish chef's son?

@brianmincher716 3 месяца назад

His tiny, tiny hands.

@josh.8104 4 месяца назад

If you're looking for something as a believer, everything you find will be evidence, even if it isn't. If you're looking for something as a skeptic, you'll never find any evidence at all, even if there is.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

No I won't! Or yes I will! Whatever you're saying, I oppose it because...

@WillyOrca 4 месяца назад

It was awesome seeing my DeDunking/last supper fan art being used for the transitions! 😅 it makes me feel like I contributed lol

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

It's epic art! Thanks!

@andymccracken4046 4 месяца назад

This worked really well as a longer video, I enjoyed watching it again, and I am impressed by how much research you must do to find all these papers and video clips.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Wow, thank you! I try, but I am glad it shows :)

@phoboskittym8500 3 месяца назад

Re: Clovis first is held on to because of the implications of colonization are far more profound if people were in the Americas 50,000 years ago, it also shows how underserved indigenous traditions are.

@brianmincher716 3 месяца назад

Why doesn’t Flint wear clothes that fit?

@NONANTI 3 месяца назад

It was his dad's suit.

@benjaminnewton8018 Месяц назад

That's a tough size to find

@Dillonmac96 Месяц назад

His dad’s clothes?! No way… dude is so fried he misses his dad so much that he wants to die knowing that everything his dad said was right and not disproven

@johncage3969 3 месяца назад

41:45 Mate, do it! Make as many videos as you want! This is such great content.

@RM-yf2lu 4 месяца назад

The assumption that seed shattering is the benchmark for domestication and it was a linar progression that only happened once is the most simplistic, academic friendly concept that an undergrad can be thankful for😂

@AIenSmithee 4 месяца назад

My issue is that this is a lot of work to just hold up the idea that we can’t 100% rule out lost civilization. That shouldn’t be where we start. Why put in all this effort before there is a good reason to believe in lost civilization

@RM-yf2lu 4 месяца назад

@@AIenSmithee so should we just sweep the technological anomalies that don't fit into the mainstream version of history under the carpet?

@AIenSmithee 4 месяца назад

@@RM-yf2lu don’t be so dramatic. The simple fact is that there is no evidence of any lost advanced tech. What tech anomalies are you talking about?

@RM-yf2lu 4 месяца назад

@@AIenSmithee barabar caves, the denisovan jade bracelet, antikythera mechanism, among many others...

@AIenSmithee 4 месяца назад

@@RM-yf2lu Baribar caves: There is no technological anomaly about polished walls. You can literally see an unfished one at the Lomas Rishi cave. Althoughthe workers were very skilled, we know how they are made. polishing stone is something we have known about since antiquity. Denisovan Jade Bracelet: its amazing but hardly a technological anomaly. Its just earlier then we would expect to see such work. Antykythera mechanism: by this stage it seems to me you don't google much and just on the "Top 10 mysteries scientists don't want you to know about" videos. Once again, impressive but not an anomaly. I don't think you want to know the truth you just want to be impressed by mysteries. I never trust someone who wants spends more time trying to tell people what we don't know than trying to find out what we can know.

@weatherstation71 4 месяца назад

Hi, Flint!

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

lol

@sonny-rush1388 4 месяца назад

Dan if you feel up to it can you do a deep dive into the barabar caves in India? Bam investigations put there documentary on RU-vid 4 weeks ago and as far as I can tell the barabar caves are the best evidence for a advanced civilization with technology comparable to our own. Wish I could support you more but it's a struggle to pay bills right now. Lol

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

One of these days I'll look into them, thanks. No worries, I understand tight finances. Thanks!

@sonny-rush1388 4 месяца назад

@DeDunking thank you

@themushmonk 4 месяца назад

You're the man! Teach me your ways!

@CharlesNotXavier 4 месяца назад

What a fun one and a half hour. While you're preparing to take a rest, I'm finishing my lunch 😂. Looking forward for your Baalbek video. Be careful with the Roman teritory, lol. Thanks, Dan.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Thanks, it was fun for sure tonight! Have a good day Charles

@v8interceptor134 4 месяца назад

Can’t speak to plants but as a farmer whose wife breeds dogs and cats I can tell you that the domestic traits humans select animals for disappear very quickly when the control stops , we get accidents in the breeding process and I can say that without doubt 2 generations of no controlled breeding will leave a product barely resembling the start points but what is more interesting is that it is far far more difficult to get back where you started than lose it

@v8interceptor134 4 месяца назад

@@Joe-sg9ll it happens so fast , particularly with dogs , In a couple of years you can have something that bears no resemblance to what you started with and a huge task to get it back , having not bred plants I can’t really speak but I suspect it’s much the same , three years and you will have something looking absolutely nothing like what you started with

@patrickday4206 14 дней назад

Pigs in Texas are a prime example one generation they go from hairless domesticated pige to a strong powerful hairy boar 🐗

@Othis-Morf Месяц назад

The all time number of shipwrecks is totally irrelevant as 99,99 percent of the wrecks are from more modern times. How big was the world population 10000 years ago? How many ships were there? Most probably boats were built out of wood so do wrecks from that time and beyond even exist anymore? Only cold water with low oxygen levels is suited for preserving wood for longer periods. How many ancient peoples sailed in the Arctic and Antarctic waters and how many archeological surveys have been done in those waters? Not to mention sea floor changes occurring since the last ice age.

@DROP_BEARZ 2 месяца назад

Love your channel i almost let the mental garbage take over the first time i ever saw your channel, watched no more than a minute or two and began to assume your position and integrity. Rookie mistake. Im stoked to be a subscriber and regular viewer and i should be old enough to know better 😂

@hbhighlander 2 месяца назад

You hit the nail on the head early, I like your page because you are fair and not towing a specific rhetoric.

@fmills1583 4 месяца назад

Next: Flint Dibble vs Dick Trickle.

@Unkdunk 4 месяца назад

Cheers dan

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

cheers!

@SI-up7zi 3 месяца назад

I both love and I hate, that I like all these players so much! Thanks to you, dedunked❤

@SI-up7zi 3 месяца назад

Binging!! You give me a great, great sense of security Dedunked.

@vbarranch4424 3 месяца назад

Jimmy C sent me here! 😊

@DeDunking 3 месяца назад

Jimmeneny Crewcut?

@vbarranch4424 3 месяца назад

@@DeDunking Core Seti

@EnoShadow-Walker 4 месяца назад

12k year old graffiti in a Crete cave. Has a ship with a sail

@DrSpoculus 4 месяца назад

They can't test the graffiti. It's not organic material. It's painted on something very old.

@johnferry7778 4 месяца назад

@@DrSpoculusWhat is it painted on?

@EnoShadow-Walker 4 месяца назад

@Joe-sg9ll didn't see that video will try to find it. Thanks

@EnoShadow-Walker 4 месяца назад

@@Joe-sg9ll they age it by extinct deer in the art

@EnoShadow-Walker 4 месяца назад

@Joe-sg9ll that's the cave. Good timing

@lostadamsgold Месяц назад

Dribble Dibble. Archaeology is NOT science, BTW. Until time machines are invented. It is excruciatingly-derived story telling.

@muddywitch9016 24 дня назад

Dibble’s point about the domestication of grains is completely beside the point when Hancock has never made the claim that domesticated crops were brought TO areas like Globekli Tepe directly AFTER the last ice age. He claims that the technology TO domesticate crops was brought, not the domesticated crops themselves.

@triax7218 Месяц назад

The way that flint worded and presented the feralisation and domestication of plants it very heavily insinuated it was a collectively agreed upon fact across science. The fact that it seems he didnt bother to inquire with even just 1 scientist from a overlapping field, is the exact opposit of proper scientifically sound researching. I dare go as far as calling it borderline disgraceful.

@mersmithy1269 3 месяца назад

Too old and wise for 'Flint Lockwood'. But as a kid, living in the late 70's early 80's, i loved 'Top Cat' and Officer Dibble. Hope this helps.👍

@larafamily3675 4 месяца назад

@lloyddale3818 2 месяца назад

A cheap and shoddy opinion, I am sure but, I feel sorry for the rabbits that died, and their fur went into Flint Dibble's felt hat so that he could feel good channelling Indiana Jones to show his professionalism as an archaeologist.

@satanshantverkare 2 месяца назад

Thenkyou for not participateing in the ändless sea of ridicule and mockery. instead focusing on what is important here.

@ericmaumaryjr8344 4 месяца назад

Swing both ways, eh?...

@bajavolvo 2 месяца назад

I think Atlantis is a neat subject. I like connecting mythology to reality. Am I one of the baddies? ☠️

@surfdocer103 Месяц назад

I just can’t listen to anybody named Flint dribble especially when they dress like that.

@Brent-l5e 2 месяца назад

I do not like the 2 min ads with weird monster sounds and guns firing…I’m trying to sleep to this man’s soothing voice 😶

@Al-AI 4 месяца назад

I'd sub to an audio only podcast

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Thanks!

@alexanderm8880 3 месяца назад

The only thing Flint got out of the debate was for his last name to become synonymous with disingenuous establishment stooges.

@demonsluger 3 месяца назад

yes and no i think dillehey was soft with his words and didnt wanna trample anyone on the toes but still wanted his point to come across he feels very reserved and humble in the video

@henrikschultze1668 4 месяца назад

thank's for this video and sorry for the late answering.

@henrikschultze1668 4 месяца назад

ps - i still love your backgrounds !!!

@bigrollinghome2091 4 месяца назад

was a really fun night watching this!

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

I had fun too, thanks for joining the chat!

@opgg1 4 месяца назад

I'm glad I found your channel. I dont believe in lost advanced ancient civilization but sympathise with the idea.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Welcome aboard, thank you :)

@stephenkemp3372 Месяц назад

Archeology is gatekeeping

@Arto300-yn5fv 4 месяца назад

Man, can you edit ALL of your channel videos in a one super long one!? That's a cool idea. One long podcast.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

10 hours of Nyan Dan...

@TangieTown81 Месяц назад

It isn't- co en sci dent It's- co in seh dent

@benmaxwell3808 3 месяца назад

Hogs will go feral in a single generation.

@phoboskittym8500 3 месяца назад

Re: Ice core samples to detect metallurgy, during the ice age the civilization Hancock is trying to prove existed was in the equatorial regions of the world, with no Ice sheets forming even in the high mountain regions i would presume, so looking for such a thing in ice core samples might not be practical. lots of space metal around 13,000 bce though.

@enness9175 3 месяца назад

I have just become a subscriber of this channel. Great summary of salient points. I only watched 30 min of the debate and gave up in front of the way F Dibble was twisting the arguments of G Hancock to fit his narrative.

@BS89. 4 месяца назад

Terrence Howard de-dunking👍🏽💪🏽 -🤩

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

It's being requested a ton, gotta finish Baalbek for sure first...

@GAB-vq7re 3 месяца назад

My mans has a copy of left 4 dead behind. You are clearly a man of culture sir 👌

@DeDunking 3 месяца назад

It's still sealed, I had a few copies I got cheap back in the day and kept one new. Like one of them 'grade my stuff' nerds. "Grabbin pills"

@fmills1583 4 месяца назад

Ever what to Debunk Terrance Howard? Plenty of material there.

@bschmidt1 4 месяца назад

But Terrence Howard is correct

@fmills1583 4 месяца назад

@@bschmidt1 Cool story bro.

@bschmidt1 4 месяца назад

@@fmills1583 It was a cool story, that's why it's already one of the most popular JREs so quickly with many likes

@fmills1583 4 месяца назад

@@bschmidt1 Validation from complete strangers is your goal? Congratulations for being the champion of this unique category you dominate.

@Murray_69 4 месяца назад

Bint Dribble

@matthewsmolinsky5605 4 месяца назад

Atlantis is dead, and Flint Dibble killed it!

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

Derp

@matthewsmolinsky5605 4 месяца назад

@@DeDunking I know, it never existed outside of myth and literature, but still ;)

@timmysvensson4902 4 месяца назад

@@matthewsmolinsky5605dont forget they also lost the war against ancient Athens according to Plato. So much for high tech civilisation loosing a war against Athens thousands of years ago.. Cherry picking grifters, why are Atlantis fans always cherry picking from Plato and history as a whole?

@patrickday4206 14 дней назад

Dribble Dribble Dribble

@RudyRifle 3 месяца назад

Lol I love how graham even if he stretches this term “fingerprint evidence”, never mentions his own wife when facing white supremacy comments. Graham is taking the word of the people he spoke to, which why he referenced his passport a few times. But you bringing up flints own university bad press on dealing with native bones, is the chefs kiss on his own ridiculous narrative lol

@channelwhoa66 2 месяца назад

Stop acting like there’s is ANY evidence suggesting Atlantis, exists just because Hancock Meant” in the ocean! Just stop!

@DeDunking 2 месяца назад

You feeling ok?

@channelwhoa66 2 месяца назад

@@DeDunking well, I’m feeling like your being quite a bit sneaky! Would you say you’ve seen any evidence that points to an Atlantis type of civilization having ever existed?

@Jacob-uw4tk 4 месяца назад

You should consider sky diving without a parachute

@cheeseonatwig 3 месяца назад

What an odd thing to say

@beasthazard 3 месяца назад

How old are you? This is such an immature thing to type on the internet

@patrickday4206 14 дней назад

I would flag your response but youtube will remove it and it's good for people see

@donoi2k22 3 месяца назад

I'm sorry but who are you? Are you archeologist? What's your credentials?

@AustinKoleCarlisle 3 месяца назад

the truth isn't limited to credentials.

@donoi2k22 3 месяца назад

@@AustinKoleCarlisle yeah but it doesn't help to not have one.

@donoi2k22 3 месяца назад

@@AustinKoleCarlisle how am i supposed to know you're speaking truth

@AustinKoleCarlisle 3 месяца назад

@@donoi2k22 people with credentials have more to lose and are less likely to go against the grain

@jr1648 2 месяца назад

@@donoi2k22How do you know someone with credentials is speaking the truth. They could just as likely be a bad faith actor as someone who is uncredentialed.

@AIenSmithee 4 месяца назад

You responded to a comment I made on Twitter a while ago. I was talking about how disappointing it was to me that you had become buddies with Jimmy Corsetti. After watching this I feel I can explain myself a bit better. I was so dismayed that you are friendly with Corsetti because you are way better than that grifter. I have a lot of problems with this vid but I think that you are one of the most honest alternative history guys out there. I can’t say the same about Jimmy in fact, he is disgusting. I could never se you trying to insinuate that Flint’s cancer battle was fake to avoid a debate. That is the fucking lowest thing I’ve seen in this archeology space. All I hope is that you avoid the lure of guys you have looked up to and books you’ve read and stay honest. Like I said, I have a lot of disagreements with this vid but I can’t say you’re in the same box as the rest of grift RU-vid.

@yawnskidsberry3209 4 месяца назад

Insisting that people that may disagree with each other can’t be friendly is so immature and really is what the problem in our country is today. And I’m obviously not just talking about ancient history. Grow up!

@WillyOrca 4 месяца назад

How old are you? Why are you trying to police people's associations? He can talk to whoever he wants lol. He's more than capable of being friendly to people he disagrees with, and more than comfortable disagreeing with someone he's friendly with. Unless he's compromising his integrity to maintain these relationships (he's not) his associations are his business.

@DeDunking 4 месяца назад

This is not the way I try to handle things. Jimmy and I have disagreements, but we also get along too. Same with Milo, same with Graham, same with so many other creators it's absurd. I pressed Jim on the cancer thing months ago, never seen anything like that from him since. Can't say the same for the majority archaeologists I tried to quit doing the same thing by conflating Hancock's work with racism... I'm not here to judge people who are willing to change their behavior. Keep in mind, I am the first 'commentary' channel in this community, everyone has been in their partisan bubbles for a long time here. So bad behavior, on both sides, ran amok for years, cause no one said anything. Sounds a bit arrogant of me, but the signs are there. Jimmy's a good dude, and he seems happy to move past vitriol.

@AIenSmithee 4 месяца назад

@@yawnskidsberry3209 he insinuated Flint was faking his cancer….he’s an asshole. That’s not a disagreement. By the way, you disagree with me and you called me immature and told me to grow up. Seems you don’t practice what you preach.

@AIenSmithee 4 месяца назад

@@WillyOrca police? You think I gave that power. You’re right he can be friends with guys that make fun of peoples cancer if he wants. Speaking of integrity I wouldn’t associate with something like that.

@e7ebr0w 4 месяца назад

I finally tried watching this debate and it just pissed me off every time Graham pulled an immature move and wouldn't let Dibble speak

@matthewsmolinsky5605 4 месяца назад

He obviously wasn’t prepared for that debate with Dibble

@e7ebr0w 4 месяца назад

@@matthewsmolinsky5605 true. I just can't stand when someone asks a question with no simple answer, and then attacks the person for not giving a quick easy answer. At no point was Dibble not answering the questions Hancock put forward, but it wasn't the answer Hancock wanted