I remember that back in the day Central Park developers proposed a plan for a skybridge connecting Taman Anggrek and Central Park for easy access, but they refused. Rumor says that Taman Anggrek is currently in the negotiation of reviving the plan, lmao
I can already guess that MKG is gonna be one of the top malls just because it's absolutely huge and has an LRT station right outside of it although I didn't think it'll be #1.
That is maybe because the visitors of MKG actually buy something. My boss has an pharma chainstore and his best selling store is always MKG. And the gap is a lot from store no 2.
ini juga banyak dari kota satelit. Jakarta di Shindo itu JABODETABEK jadi sampe Tangerang, Bogor, Depok, Bekasi juga Jakarta soalnya satu area metropolitan.
Izin ralat sedikit, "AEON" mall pelafalannya "Ion Mall": Aeon mall berasal dari Jepang. Dan di Jepang sendiri, nama Aeon diucapkan イオン。 Berarti cara baca yang benar adalah ion mall. Keep up with the vid, cant wait for another bus line/train line review!
Thank you for the tier. Some malls are missed like Malls in Bekasi/Cibubur (Grand Galaxy Park, Bluplaza, BTC Mall, Green Walk Mall, Metropolitan Mall Cibubur), Malls around Jl. Rasuna Said (Mall Setiabudi, Epiwalk, Plaza Festival). But I think you didn't visit it yet or not enough into the criteria.
Very thoughtful and thorough researched video! I knew SMKG is the God Tier of mall in Greater Jakarta.. I spend whole my childhood there.. Heck, Summarecon is the OG mall developers.. I love all their malls, especially SMS (PS. Wear your best walking shoe if you get there) Also, both SMKG and SMB are the go to malls if my family get bored at home.. Lippo Mall Puri and BXC is my next on checklist..
halo shindo new subs here, kalo boleh request bikin video basic guide soal public transport di Jakarta, yang bener-bener basic, ibarat orang gapernah naik transportasi umum sama sekali, mungkin bisa bakalan banyak ngebantu orang yang gapernah naik transportasi umum (myself), anyway keep up the good work and also thankuu for the video 👍
What an amazing video! I myself have been living in Jakarta for more than 20 years but I don't recognise most of the mall that you mentioned here. Anyway, I'm really curious about this for sometime and I would love to see you making a video about companies that run these malls in greater Jakarta.
Thank you! Though I think that is beyond the scope of this channel since thats more into business. What I can and plan on doing is rate the suburbs that these companies have built.
surprised the puri duo actually broke top 10, as someone who used to live nearby they are nice but never quite matched the uniqueness of the rest of the top tiers. The puri indah mall expansion plan does look interesting and if done right can definitely boost it up a bit. Lippo mall puri however I think suffers from sloppy construction, with noticeably uneven ceilings and absolutely dire parking lots with pillars right in the middle of the path of cars. The outdoor area of lippo is also quite underdeveloped, and they really should've connected the mall to living world with a bridge / tunnel, especially considering that building used to be the marketing gallery for the lippo mall complex. Will definitely have to revisit MKG though, didn't know that it looks that good now!
I normally use Public Transport when going to Jakarta, but yeah I heard bad things about LMPs parking. So much so my parents suggested that we Drive to Puri Indah, then walk to LMP. MKG is really crowded now, like Kokas/PIM level crowded due to La Piazza and GAFOY.
personally, i'd rank trans studio mall cibubur lower for the fact that the roller coaster reverberate throughout the mall especially on the top floor. if you 're sensitive enough you can feel the vibrations when you're in the cinema but personally, i cant feel it. also the public transport to AEON sentul city is kinda ass irl but i think the fact that the road leading to the mall gets heavily congested during peak hours and not a lot of other road you can take (especially if you're going to jakarta). also iirc, you can take angkot from pondok cina to margocity mall, but not sure tho, havent been there in a while. thanks for compiling all this, you're a mad man i havent even been to half the malls mentioned o7
Pacific Place and Supermall Karawaci is nostalgic place for me as I was visiting Kidzania and trying the rollercoaster in Supermall Karawaci. I also remember that the area near Supermall Karawaci are used to be a racing arena that are now turned into road (also the racing paddock are now used as college building IIRC). Great that you also mention Bintaro Exchange. I used to go there frequently few years ago and I haven't visit the new tunnel from Jurangmangu station. Back then people need to cross the highway via the "tunnel" which is a passage way under the highway bridge. Also, some additional note that Supermall Karawaci are also gonna be served by MRT East-West line though it's not gonna near as the first phase of the route are on the inside of Jakarta only. Anyway, that was a great video! Well done!
i thought this video idea was too much of a hassle, but when you made a video ranking this much malls i think this one would be possible maybe a ranking of most of the notable the commuter line stations? based on stuff like the stores in it, how its designed, and maybe the connectivity with other forms of publlic transport (in this specific scenario stations like cawang will get a lot of points)
6:35 A random dude from Pamulang, South Tangerang here. Just want to inform you, that before 2012, theres also a now-abandoned mall(or plaza) a bit south from Tangcity named Serpong Plaza. Its famous becauze its connection with Robert Tantular's money laundering aka Bank Century scandal.
I really wish that they build some sort of underground connection between GI, PI, and Bundaran HI Station. Transport here is nice but not when it's raining. Same thing also goes when moving from GI to PI as when it rains, there no way crossing the road in the open Btw i'm Manadonese and I am curious as to why does Manadonese who come to Jakarta would almost certainly go to Central Park, and then take a picture at the outdoor section with the 2 towers in the background and then upload it to instagram, kinda like a "I've been to Jakarta" thing for Manadonese but don't know the reason why
Daftar mal di kota Jakarta(.List of malls in the city of Jakarta.) 🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️ Jakarta Barat(West Jakarta) 1.Central Park Jakarta 2.Ciplaz Cengkareng 3.CityWalk Gajah Mada 4.Green Sedayu Mall 5.HubLife Taman Anggrek 6.Lindeteves Trade Centre Glodok 7.Lippo Mall Puri 8.Mal Ciputra Jakarta 9.Mal Puri Indah 10.Mal Taman Anggrek 11.Mal Taman Palem 12.Neo Soho Podomoro City 13.Plaza Slipi Jaya 14.Seasons City 15.Srengseng Junction 16.Mal Matahari Daan Mogot 17.Mal Taman Palem 🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️ Jakarta Pusat (Central Jakarta) 18.CityWalk Sudirman 19.FX Sudirman 20.Gajah Mada Plaza 21Grand Indonesia Shopping Town 22.Green Pramuka Square 23.ITC Cempaka Mas 24.ITC Roxy Mas 25.Mangga Dua Mall 26.Plaza Atrium 27.Plaza Indonesia 28.Plaza Senayan 29.Ratu Plaza 30.Sarinah 31.Senayan City 32.Senayan Park 33.Thamrin City 34.Lippo Mall East Side 35.Menara Jakarta Shopping Centre 36.Agora Thamrin 🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️ Jakarta Selatan(South Jakarta) 37. ÆON Mall Tanjung Barat 38. Astha District 8 39.Blok M Plaza 40.Blok M Square 41.Cilandak Town Square 42.Epiwalk 43. Gandaria City 44.Grand ITC Permata Hijau 45.ITC Cipulir 46.ITC Fatmawati 47.Kalibata City Square 48.Kota Kasablanka 49.Kuningan City 50.Lippo Mall Kemang 51.Lotte Shopping Avenue 52.Mall Ambasador 53.One Belpark Mall 54.Pacific Place 55.Pasaraya Grande 56.Pejaten Village 57.Plaza Festival 58.Plaza Kalibata 59.Plaza Semanggi 60.Poins Square 61.Pondok Indah Mall 62.Setiabudi One 🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️ Jakarta Timur(East Jakarta) 63.ÆON Mall Jakarta Garden City 64.Arion Mall 66.Buaran Plaza 67.Cibubur Junction 68.Ciplaz Klender 69.Cityplaza Jatinegara 70.Grand Cakung 71.Lippo Plaza Kramat Jati 72.Mall@Bassura 73.Mall Cipinang Indah 74.Mall Graha Cijantung 75.Pondok Kelapa Town Square 76.Pusat Grosir Cililitan 77.Tamini Square 🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️🗂️ Jakarta Utara(North Jakarta) 78.Ancol Beach City 79.Baywalk Mall 80.Bella Terra Lifestyle Center 81.Emporium Pluit 82.ITC Mangga Dua 83.Mall Artha Gading 84.Mal Kelapa Gading 85.Mall Of Indonesia 86.Mangga Dua Square 87.Metro Sunter Plaza 88.Pasar Pagi Mangga Dua 91.PIK Avenue 92.Pluit Junction 93.Pluit Village 94.Sunter Mall Silakan yang mau menambahkan. juga ada daftar untuk seluruh Jabodetabek.🙏🙏 Please feel free to add. There is also a list for all of Jabodetabek.🙏🙏. We need part 3
Thanks for the list of your revommendation. Well, for me i think Grand Indonesia is still the best mall for me for 3 reasons: very large indoor space, very close to BRT and MRT station, and even better, probably the closest mall to visit from PIK Golf Island (had to use 1A, took me just 1.5 hours) MKG is nice but took me as bad as 4 to 5 hours. 30 mins to 1 hour extra because of Manggarai LRT line construction causing the road to LRT from the train station to reduced to just 1 lane. So while i love this mall and i visit it quite often, not as often as GI due to that reason (imagine from 10 AM from PIK to MKG, you arrives at 3PM only to be there for 2 hours then go back to PIK at 10PM). Cant wait for the Manggarai LRT line to finish, it will definitely cut the travel time significantly XP Central Park is also great but due to Penjaringan BRT station is only goes to PIK, we have to drop off from the bus at Aston Pluit, then wall about 1km to Penjaringan BRT station then finally get into always overcrowded bendy bus to CP. While yes its short time, the walking distance is quite hellish on that one especially if its raining (yep, i got wet twice already because of this, that by the third time i ended up going to GI instead)
@@shindoride ye, i think i can use that too since both are stopped at Balai Kota and the Pulomas LRT Completely forgor about both of those two since both are always overcrowded for some reasons…
@@Keikoatr72 GI and PI is not comfortable for pedestrians tho, they need to direct access to MRT stations and prioritize pedestrians over cars in their lobby
@@DevaraGian1998 i didnt have issue with that when entering GI because im using their side door (there is a door for pedestrian when you walk to the mall, its only connected to Floor 2 and 3A. No need to walk to their overcrowded lobby there) As of crossing the 6 lane road,the red light for the pedestrian is pretty long but bearable considering the notorious traffic jam in Bundaran HI area
Honestly the graphics is an improvement over the first one as it's less Google Map like, but i think you need to show the mall's looks especially the exterior a bit more since sometimes. I don't know what mall you're talking about and exterior always makes the first impression
Huh...so if you considered the connected malls seperate.. there are only 74 malls...NGL...that is much less than I thought...for comparison, the Greater KL area had 178(!!)....
Technically there's more due to many "malls" are smaller older shop buildings style for example ITC Roxy or Mangga Dua Square. Shindo only used the ones that are Proper Malls.
Ah...ok (and I also see from the comments from the other video that he miss 1 proper one at Tangerang)... but still, considering the population of Jabodetabek(35 million vs Klang Valley 9 million)...I was expecting at least 120 proper ones....and 5 S tier mall Let's hope this tier list would go viral enough that there would be a news story on this by a prominent business radio station...(like the Klang Valley tier list)
I love how cynical this series sounds but at the same time is hitting the right amount of things the local government (AND some of the malls mentioned) needs to work on. Yes, most Jabodetabek residents (when it comes to visiting a mall) do visit using cars or motorcycles, hence most of the mall's infrastructures are catering towards bigger parking spaces instead of providing good connection to nearby stops or terminus. Note to Plaza Indonesia, it is a farce because the management isn't keen to directly connect it to the adjacent BRT and MRT stations, just like Blok M Plaza and Revo Mall have done. I can understand their point to "cater" more to "high class clients using cars with chauffeur" rather than commoner using public transportations, but the potential is there and they just wasted it. Also it is brutal that sometimes, most malls forces pedestrians (or visitors walking to the mall) to take longer route just to get inside and they are treated harsher than those coming with cars. But again, maybe (just maybe) they want to tighten the security (due to history of bombings in Jakarta in the last two decades or so) by having multiple security checkpoints (such as in Grand Indonesia) for those coming by foot. Overall, really great series!
Thank you! Personally I don't think the multiple security checkpoints actually make the pedestrian experience worse. What really matters is how wide the sidewalks are and how frequently pedestrians confict with cars on the way in/out of the mall. GI and PI I think have pretty good pedestrian access compared to say Kokas or Emporium Pluit despite those only having one layer of security.
@@shindoride I agree. Although I always have a soft spot for Kokas, mainly because I grew up and used to go around Kuningan area during my highschool years. Kokas' walkway does feel like a "walk of shame" because of how confusing and long it is to go from exiting TJ or Angkot to go inside. Top man for ranking MKG as no. 1!
People these days prefer buy food than buy others so mall that have a lot of food usually more crowded. Aeon use this approach and Aeon often give chairs so people can relax. Old mall have lack of chairs to sit.
Central Park has it, Neo Soho has it too, along with SMKG and MAG. Emporium Pluit Mall has one but you need to know where to turn to get there. Same with Ciputra Mall Jakarta. Ask security guards! I like riding my motorcycle to the malls too.
Out of all 3 malls being Plaza Senayan, Senayan City, and Pacific Place. I Think Plaza Senayan has the most affordable tenants since they're the only one with a food court. After that would be Senayan City since they have that bottom floor that has the lagoon thats filled with cafes and restaurants. Idk much about Pacific place though
Fakta bahwa jakarta adalah kota dengan jumlah mall terbayak di dunia . dan kepadatan pertokoan m² / km² terbesar di dunia. Entah sebuah fakta yang harus dibanggakan atau tidak aku tidak tau
@@shindoride Hmm mnarik. Klo Personal review AC dingin sih, tpi klo kebersihan…ya bs ditingkatkan lah. Mmg jatuhny ke Trading center sih jd ba dibilang rada butut.
We have different criteria I guess, but anything C+ and up is good since Im particularly strict in this video, otherwise all the malls are gonna flood A and B tier.
compare to GI PI is pretty much tier 2 of GI in terms of everything and the fact PI is full of high brand makes me poor people doesnt want to there lol (GI i can tolerate it somehow)
@@shindoride well because most people will go to GI that's why less people and less toilet waiting AC is same as GI way too cold for me probably because i wore short pants when going there lol
Also wondering about FX, but if I have to say myself, good public transport link (MRT, Transjakarta), but it's just small + mostly empty on the top floors (IMO not really worth it unless if you're wota and there's a JKT48 event there)
C+ to B- range for sure. A lot of empty stores bring it down but it manages to shoehorn a lot of essential stores like supermarket, cafes, clothing stores (modest), fitness centre, cinema, university and JKT48 theatre in a rather small building.
@@shindoride Mungkin Seasons City juga bakal masuk C+ atau malah B-, bisa ke sana pakai terminal 9, B01, 7R, 9F M9, M25, M41, JB03, M43 sama Transjabodetabek Grogol-Ciawi.
![Greater Jakarta Malls Tier List [70 Malls][Part 2] + My top 10 favorite malls!](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
