I guessed 1 at the beginning because I thought she was the scottish one and the scottish sounded the most white. I've never heard a black scottish person but she sounded exactly like a white scottish person. By the time I realized that I had mixed them up 1 still looked more convincing especially after the dancing. 2 was trying too hard to look awkward and off beat when 1 looked hella natural. Especially with the white twerk.