This programme never had much to recommend it, but now it just isn't worth watching. The entire panel are condescending, out of touch and boring to listen to. I wouldn't be surprised if the viewing figures for this programme plummet and it closes down.
@@neillester6457 Knowing the "law" doesnt make a person intelligent in the face of not understanding the principle, and laws function in society. On the contrary, it makes her stupid. She is just one of hundreds or even thousands of establishment figures. A bit like the senate of romes time, or the aristocracy of the middle ages, they to will have their day.
Jo Cox very impressive Lady she actually helped the refugees and the poor, It was an awfull loss of a genuinely good MP, for current Labour politicians to use her name to score political points is a digrase
@Old Skool Bodybuilding Routines .. the point is he was in charge when the referendum went on . He and every leader campaigned on in or out end of story . Then every mp promised to carry out the will of the people.. problem is none of these people ever thought leave would win .. be very careful what you wish for there could come a time when you vote for something and they just dismiss your vote also . Democracy in this country is dead if Brexit is overturned there will be no going back . This country will see riots and violence like never before. It wont be you or me on front line it will be police doctors hospitals
@Old Skool Bodybuilding Routines You honestly think that uk membership of the EU has been a problem in our politics for ONLY the last 3 years? You honestly think leavers came from nowhere? This issues has been brewing under the surface since god old John Major signed the Maastricht treaty, which he didn't ask the people about btw, despite saying we'd have a say, then Tony Blair and Gordon Brown did the same thing with Lisbon AKA the EU constitution. Brexit isn't going to go away, brexit has been simmering away under the surface for the past 4 decades. Do your political homework.
When I first arrived here no one told me I had to have a tv licence. I invited the inspectors in to see my rented tv not knowing who they were or what they wanted. When the court fined me, I vowed never to have a tv licence ever again in my lifetime. Amen.
All Remain has ever had was facts, evidence, reason, maturity, wisdom and intelligence. All Leave had was Dom Cumm and fake news and lies and they won the con trick that Cambridge Analytica provided. Roll on Nazi ideology !
rufanuf1 hi, rufanuf. Populism itself is generally used as a tool by some politicians to turn the public against the ‘elite’. They use emotive rhetoric to stir up fear and anger against their opponents that is often misplaced. The irony is, populist politicians are often highly elite themselves. (Donald Trump, Bojo etc) Those who employ populist tactics tend to deflect the word and seldom identify as populists. It is seen as a disingenuous tactic because rather than using popular opinion to win votes, it attempts to implant opinions in the minds of its target audience. In this instance using charged words like “surrender” “betrayal” to create a feeling that we are somehow at war to scare people in to accepting their arguments. That’s an objective assessment of populism. My own personal belief is that it’s best to stick to more reasoned debate because emotion, anger, resentment can lead to poor political choices and division in society. All the best
@@CalumRhysJones So is not patronising someone and being civilised rather than being passive aggressive. So tell me what is the context that was acceptable to you in him being called a Nazi?
Hawkeye 1000 he was not called a nazi by any mp in the house of commons, therefore his response to another mp in the house of commons in relation to the murder of another mp is disgusting.
Couldn't agree more. They put themselves out as public servicemen like police, the army ect, and they do nothing to protect them. Then they get called a few names and they don't like it. Do what the public want, which is your job, and it wouldn't happen.
Gina Miller is shocked by the rhetoric in Commons the first day back. Really, Gina? Maybe if people like Gina just accepted the 2016 Referendum, the debate would be less incendiary.
The 23 June 2016 direct democracy not parliamentary democracy referendum was a mockery of democracy. "Advisory only" was written into it but the government simply ignored that. The restricted, gerrymandered, disenfranchized so-called referendum was and still is a mockery of democracy. The nation decided to Leave. Really, did they? All 11.4 million of the nation. Where is your arithmatic grades There are 70 million not 11.4. 60 million people want to remain in the family of Europe. The referendum should have been done properly instead of a piece of shit that the entire world laughs about but has moved on because Little England is a tiny irrelevant nation committing suicide and self harm. Good luck with that.
@@Alto53 Yeah, based on legal precedents not historical facts which haven't ever been ruled on. You are simply wrong legally speaking. However, the hypocrisy of Major is palpable and should be called out.
Gina Miller has been proved over and over and over to be right and a champion of democracy and the sovereignty of parliament. In any case, British system is dead and lost because of the folly and utter stupidity of Brexit. You can't fix stupid!
@@mozartsbumbumsrus7750 Good morning! I've just seen your comment. Can I say firstly that I am so sorry to see how badly you seem to have been affected psychologically by the subject of Brexit. Democracy is respecting the wishes of the winning side - in this particular case the 17.4 million people who voted to leave the EU. And, really is resorting to calling 17. 4 million people who voted to leave 'stupid' necessary? These people were/ are not 'stupid' they knew exactly what they were voting for. If you recall, and I am in no doubt that you do, politicians of all hues promised to respect the outcome of the referendum no matter what the result and not to throw all kinds of obstacles in the way of delivering that result. Anyway, that aside, many people who read your comment here will probably be very concerned about your well-being from a human perspective. You may be suffering from anxiety issues and possibly suffer from insomnia? Most people would probably advise you to get yourself off to your GP in the first instance - or, if you can afford it go private and perhaps Gina Miller and her associates could pay for private treatment for you if you can't or can't get a GP? - who will be able to offer you counselling or a suitable medication. If you still find that you may be unable to sleep until the medication that you are offered takes effect you can always go back onto websites to view comments others have made about Gina Miller and respond to those to pass the time - that should keep you occupied for some considerable time. Best wishes. Well done the Welsh blokes!
I would hardly call it tackling. It was a bunch of south welsh men trying to argue something they clearly didn't understand. it's akin to watching chimpanzees interact with a mirror someone placed into their enclosure.
You're right, Boris Johnson has clearly demonstrated that anyone born outside the UK should not be allowed within a mile of parliament. In fact they should not even be allowed in this country; what experience or insight could they possibly have that could benefit anywhere other than where they were born? Baffling.
brumsgrub you’re, it’s a contraction of the second person pronoun “you” and the verb to be form “are”. “Your”, however, is the second person possessive pronoun.
Reckless talked some sense but notice how quickly he jumped to defend the profits of "big pharma" against the proposal that the NHS produces generic medicine; it just looked like more vested interest. He didn't seem to understand that generic medicine: is less costly than brand named drugs; they are produced after the original patent has run out and they have the same active ingredients (just ask at your chemist/ drug store for the generic version of a branded pain -killer it always costs less). He's now on to his third political party so I'm beginning to wonder if it's the political parties (and it may well be) or him where the problem lies. Any talk of medicine shortages if/when the UK leaves the EU seems to ignore that the UK is a major exporter of medicine. What price common sense? I think Reckless (and a few in the house of Lords) work for big pharma; big business should not be sponsoring politics as that is corruption.
And when another MP gets killed? Don't apologise then? Keep going? No. These people desperately need to grow up and stop using such inflammatory language.
alan christopher - I’m with you on this. Having seen the Richard Hall video there are some amazing anomalies. I certainly believe it occurred to initially increase the vote for the Remain cause and now (and almost certainly in the future) it’s used to vilify the leave vote. Despicable imho.
Jo Cox's name needs to be brought up to stop politicians using language such as traitor, surrender act etc. Politicians like this language to fuel the divisions in the population for their political gain. They don't give a f* about "Brexit". All they care is power, even if that rips the country and population apart!
Gina Miller is the only person using brain to evaluate and act accordingly. You tell me what the plan is after the UK leaves the EU. Will you quit your job just because there are other options out there?? Will you??
Wasnt the "will of the people" to take back control? Well here it is. British MPs blocking economic suicide. British courts not allowing the PM to break the law. You wanted British law, here it is. Enjoy 👍 Oh no wait... you want YOUR opinion enforced by tyranny. What a patriot you are 😂😂😂
parliament - democratically elected by the people - was shut down and silenced. she campaigned to ensure it was re-opened again, so that the electorate's representatives could continue to debate. How is that contra democracy?
@Caerau Park I won't be clicking on that link. I have never lost my backbone. I was referring to critical thinking and having a brain in all this. You should look for yours. And when you do, send me this link again if what you believe in materialises.
Courts never "rule a country" - they simply _ENFORCE_ the law. And if a certain Bojo PM skirts the law then he's bound to be told off by the courts in a forceful manner.
Insults the working class, she's trying to save you? Bo Jo comes from Eton for gods sake how far from the working class is that, he's a millionaire? In 2020 the EU will be changing the tax rules forcing millionaires and billionaires to show all their tax records, why do you think the Tories are wanting us to leave the EU? Most of you couldn't be bothered with the EU before 2015. When you come out of the EU who do you think will suffer, not the rich Tories, that's for certain! The UK will become a tax haven, hedge funds will be making millions from the profits of betting on Brexit and once again the working class and the poor will suffer! Don't believe what I say? Just look it up it's all on the web, it's all there!
Democracy in the UK has no codified constitution. Only the rule of law protects whatever little democracy this ancient monarchy has. Gina Miller is one of the only democrats around willing to fight for democracy and the rule of law!
I think the show should be restarted with a new cast (especially new producers) and name and always have an equal amount of right and left wing panalists, which it should do anyway. i still think the show has an audience and shouldnt be completly stopped
@@robflood8003 it's a joke they won't dare come to one of the leave voting towns outside of London.... they're terrified of giving leave voters a voice.
@@libertasdemocratiam887 I totally agree, the majority of East anglians voted leave yet the show last week (l think) was from Norwich which was remain!
Time to suspend the BBC's broadcasting licence until all the Common Purpose graduates have been sacked. Then reduce the licence fee to £10 annually. One TV station, one radio station.
It's a shock to realise that isn't it, see the MSM don't want you to know that they know that you know that the brexit party aren't actually full of bs and lies as the MSM likes to claim. Watch 'em in the EU parliament tearing the commission an co a new backside via words.
laura nixon she is a disgrace along with major one law for him and nothing for the bits all fees remain year do not mind war Tony Blair enjoyed the war nothing but a big laugh to him both him and his wife Sherry Blair she’s a disgrace also giving that traitor woman thinking she should be paid legal aid for what she did the whole lot stinks stinks stinks. As well as buying all council houses up and buying them for them selves to rent out talk about grade it’s also just on they’ll get it sorted we went out never changed our mind in three years we are not likely to do so now all we want is what we voted for. Boris as got the balls to tell people the truth if Boris a long with mogg Nigel Farage or speaking the truth speaking to people that matter and they all matter very much to us please get on with it we do not want more we want peace for God sake get on with it..
You live in cloud coo-coo land fantasy of delusion and denial of the facts and truth. The Brexit Party is just a pack of lies and liars who are just old fashioned Nazi ideologues. Good luck with that.
because Jo Cox's assassination shows us that death threats are no always empty and sometimes people actually follow through. we would be wise to not ignore that
@@mick9708 Wrong - it was brought up be her "friend" on the opposition benches - to which the PM responded. Did you actually bother watching anything before commenting or do you prefer to parrot what other morons are telling you?
Now we know Brexit was all about lies. These folks speaking in favour of the move look incredibly stupid now. We're so much poorer financially it's a disaster.
To me it's all obvious. They concocted this plan prior to re-entering parliament. The media were in on this plan and editing their programme in order to broadcast a total pack of lies. Its more propaganda. BS.
If Gina Miller has been looking at parliament for many years, how come she never stuck her nose in the same way when John Major Prorogued parliament...
Once again Fiona Bruce kept interrupting James Cleverley but let that Millar women keep rambling on uninterrupted,it's the same every week interrupting the brexiteers and leaving the remainders alone
Brexit will kill the midlands and the people get what they deserve and the people deserve what they get. Roll on Brexit and the devil take the hindmost. You will learn the lesson the hard way!
@@pardeepsingh6138 Time will tell. I use the Baloney Detection Kit. What do you use besides BS without facts or evidence. Good luck with that. The UK is dying and Brexit kills it. It's not rocket science but then the Brittunculi were never up to much. Gone. Bye bye and enjoy the ride to the bottom with the other bottom feeders.
"Nationalism causes war" - Francois Mitterrand in 1997 and every one in the world in 1945 . Every reason for voting Leave was Nationalism. Brexit is pure Nationalism. Brexit causes war. Wait for it and your wish shall be granted Mr. Miller.
Oh this is gonna be good I’m 30 seconds in and making this comment upfront 😂🔥 Edit; first three god damn questions - were from plant hardline remainers
I agree. I am from Australia.British political comedy like bbc qt has been top of my weekly watch list for the last 3 years, so much better than our q@a on the abc on Monday nights. How do these people keep a straight face when they must have great difficulty to lie straight in bed.
@Pink Alien I can't get over Remainers talking about democracy whilst overturning the democratic vote, its like something out of a pantomime. The media have shown just how weak people are, free thinking individuals are not only under attack from the powers that be but also the uneducated are now campaigning for mass surveillance, Digital DNA, Socialism, Higher Tax's because of the climate and over turning democratic votes. Well done and hats off to the elite, master manipulators.
@@sterlingforever4913 "overturning democratic vote" - well, when a leave option was on the ballot paper in the Commons in January and March 2019, Rees-Mogg and all his pals of the ERG voted against it. SO they frustrated Brexit and the will of the people, right?
the audience is always 50/50. True the panel is always badly chosen. I have tried for four years now asking why professor A. C. Grayling has never been invited on. The reason? : SILENCE. They never reply. The English Conspiracy of Silence remains class system solid.
@@NPC-st7zv That's exactly right. Wales voted to leave. Since then Wales has changed its mind and now it wants to stay and remain in the family of Europe.
@@mozartsbumbumsrus7750 since When? did you do a poll around Caerdydd? You need to get out of Cardiff and up into the valleys. None of the VC I have met voted remain and none of them have changed their mind.
@@mick9708 if you listen and step out of the box you'll hear the difference. Words have meaning and depends how you look at it power. Just because someone is Hurt emotionally by words does not negate that They then win the debate by default of saying, surrender is wrong. Churchill said it best We shall never surrender
@@celticRicky honestly the inane ramblings of a mad man, wow. So if he had said something racist or homophobic he shouldn't apologise either? What you are saying makes no sense whatsoever and I'm not surprised you support someone like bojo who basically just says shit that sounds good and has no substance whatsoever
@@mick9708 you're programmed pretty well Mick. I don't agree with the homosexual lifestyle, does that make me a homophobic? No, I believe in male and female. Together they blend exactly how its supposed to be. Like gin and tonic. You my friend just want to listen to one side, and use words like Inane Rambling Mad Racist Homophobic No sense (which means I can't understand someone with a different way of understanding to me) It sounds wonderful to me, makes great sense because listening to the other side isn't as strong. Its weak and its losing the war on logic. That my friend is the freedoms worth dying for The freedom to understand words, to use vocabulary that is to be tested with truth and not have our freedoms destroyed by modern Day Gestapo that wants to burn our digital books of consciousness so that They can be authors of confusion. Sorry Mick, you won't win the war with your language because its easily destroyed. It's each of our own responsibility to encourage one another to push on to improve and we will never do that with thinking the above list.
@@brianbell3836 And Johnson was the one who lied to us. Nigel farage told the country what it is, but nobody wants to listen. He told us all about the imergration situation, and how we could of stopped it in its tracks. But nobody wants to listen, so we are now paying the price, because we have idiots running everything.
I must stop watching this terrible program, it just angers me so much, Fiona Bruce is a disgrace and a champion of the Brexit Bashing Corporation Bias. She constantly talks over guests or cuts them off from making valid points the Beeb does not want broadcast, and once again the imbalance of the Panel is shameful, that's the last time i swear|
Does anyone remember that time when Gina Miller took the government to Court after they signed the mastricht and Lisbon treaties? Or the time they signed the UN global compact on migration?
Fiona Bruce is not for this programme especially if anybody challenges the Tories she wants to change the subject bring back David the show was much more exciting
AND NOW THE GINA MILLER SHOW....Someone ask her HOW she can get court cases in a few days (because she is a REMAINER) YET LEAVERS BRINGING A CASE HAVE TO WAIT MONTHS THEN THEY ARE DISSMISSED AS HAVING NO MERIT ie ROBIN TILBROOK CASE, HE HAS THE FACTS THAT WE LEGALLY LEFT THE EU ON THE 29th MARCH .....IT;s PURE REMAINER BIAS FROM MPs AND JUDGES
Actually: while Gina Miller got the verdict she wanted the supreme court of the UK rejected her argument as an attempt to bring the law into matters of high politics; they accepted the Scottish government argument that debate was being stifled and Scotland voting remain may have decided the issue. However, at the moment there seems to be some dispute over who is in charge: The Queen; Westminster (parliament); the law or the people ... in Scotland it's the people. I've lost all trust in the current Westminster parliament, but it's pretty rich for the Tory to start trying to caution others about: being divisive; inconveniencing workers and while I don't understand the English education system, with tuition fees it's already looking like another debt mountain that can't be paid. Ten years of Tory austerity hasn't worked; the class war has (but only for the rich) and listening to the other Tory -> UKIP -> Brexit chap arguing against the NHS inconveniencing multinational "big pharma" by producing it's own generic medicine shows me where he gets his money and incidentally generic medicine: is out of patent; means you don't have to pay for the brand and so is a fraction of the price. The Welsh chap asking for another referendum on the same question is worse than nonsense: from then on every referendum will be contested; if the first isn't honoured why would the second or third be and (to the woman in the audience) if you aren't above voting age you just have to wait until you are; nobody has perfect knowledge of the future of the UK people vote for their reasons and usually they are on matters affecting them and referendums are used when there is no compromise. I believe it's easy enough for the UK to leave the EU (just stop paying membership and the EU will tell the UK when); I believe if you ask the UK voters a question that is the will of the people and any delay is an insult; this concept of parliamentary democracy where 650 people go their own way I don't believe in. Parliament has many roles, but telling us what to think is not one of them; what the voters require are facts and then they can decide based on them. I can't see the future, but I wonder if that many MPs do as many are making themselves unelectable and it has to be said that there is much more to the UK than two political parties which I think they may find out (neither wants a general election, by the way). I want to know who our elected representatives think they represent? (because it doesn't look like the voter, on whom they depend).
The Tory MP here is being disingenuous. The reason we don’t have Brexit is because the Tory MPs in the ERG refused to vote for Brexit when Theresa May put leaving to the House to vote for. If the Tory party and their DUP allies had voted for it, we would have left the EU by now. Labour is not the reason why we have not left yet.
Kris - Teresa May's 'deal' was BRINO (Brexit In Name Only). The Irish 'backstop' tied the UK to the whims of the EU for as long as they wanted without any hope of breaking free without their say so. Only a militarily defeated country could or should accept those terms. By the way had a few of your Labour MP's voted for it it would have passed so ironically they have done us a favour and with any luck we might get a proper Brexit as the 17.4m people voted for
Barney Rubble the referendum question was to leave the EU or remain. There was no mention on the ballot paper about the terms of leaving. If we left the EU, that would have been the leave vote being honoured Just because you don’t like the reality of what Brexit looks like doesn’t mean Britain leaving the EU isn’t Brexit A lot of people had enough common sense before the vote to know any deal Britain made with the EU about leaving would involve shitty terms and conditions and Britain having less control and less say. That’s why only thick people voted for it That’s what you voted for.
@@krisinsaigon that definitely would have been BRINO which is why it was voted down. Boris is trying to get a good deal in the interests of all the people of the UK not just the leave voters. It is hard to argue that the Benn Act is anything other than a Surrender Act as espoused by Boris and the remainers amongst us are biting off their noses to spite their face as it is in everyones interest to get a fair deal including that of the EU. At least you and I are having an exchange or debate without resorting to name-calling as is usually the case when someone is on the losing side of the argument. Regards
@Eye Ball well idk about that. But given that all you have to do is call up to be part of the audience suggests audience members reflects QT fans who are predominantly remainers
congratulations from Germany - I watch your discussions about brexit - it is very entertaining - don't stop please otherwise I have to pay for netflix !
Why can't this awful lot let us leave. Look. We ain't stupid. We know no deal will have some temporary shortages of food (while they get the customs properly running) and maybe a few car companies bugger off, but in the long-run the UK will be greater. For too long we have relied on foreign firms and labour to produce stuff. We need to get rid of that, start buying british and making british. None of us holiday in the UK anymore, about time we stopped holidaying in the EU, lining others pockets. If we have to close our borders down completely (like in WWII) we will. We can and will make a success of it. People have got too soft, nowadays.
Yes Gina we are a representative democracy but I can’t remember you being elected to speak for the public 🤷🏻♀️ you represent investment bankers and the elite who can afford to bring expensive court cases. They’re your backers not the wider public.
Mark Reckless is an incredible man. Would love to see him with the top job in Wales. So glad he is in charge of Brexit Wales! Gina Miller is disgusting.
Yes, and soon we'll have blood tests to verify Britishness and build special "reeducation centers" for non-Brits... I hope my sarcasm isn't too subtle for you.
Millions of pounds spent on that court case. And when they got back into Parliament they did not even talk about brexit only hurt feelings what a waste of money.
We need a new speaker. Unfortunately the MPS who connect the name of a murdered MP with Brexiteers is the lowest of lowest. Let her family grieve and could those who are against democracy stop.
It’s fantastic that we hear the Brexit legalities explained by Gina Miller the problem here is she never completed her education in legal studies, she actually never completed this set of studies. Hypocrisy at its finest.
Fiona Bruce is a dreadfully biased presenter. She passes over comments from the audience that are 'pro-leave' and punts questions to Gina Miller to reinforce the message the BBC clearly sides with.
There is a major difference between incitement and Free Speech. Politicians are expected to act in a certain way but need to be free to speak their minds as they see fit.
That first day back in parliament: what happened was, the remainers came back expecting the government to be sheepish. Then came Geoffrey Cox, and they did not like it.
