Haredi: The Ultra orthodox society in Israel 5/5

Подписаться 35 тыс.

Просмотров 148 тыс.

50% 1

This is a documentary that follows a variety of people in the Ultra orthodox community in Israel, and tells different stories. First of is the Israeli election, in a feud between the sides in the community whether they should vote or not vote, second issue is the issue regarding education and poverty, where two women try to change the enviroment regarding haredi education and family planning, and the third part is about the controversy surrounding the internet in the Haredi world. Should internet be allowed or not?

Опубликовано:

1 июн 2012

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 287

@FPLNameless Год назад

The last part was one of the ABSOLUTELY BEST mic drops regarding politics and the corrupt nature of those who sit there. Just a shell, a golden shell, with rotten insides.

@MikeyPikeyPix 11 лет назад

Let me get this straight. A couple gets married. The man devotes himself to studying the torah all his life. The couple has fifteen kids. Everyone else is expected to provide food for the family. The family recieves welfare for the family. People go to the U.S and other countries to raise money to give to these dead beats There's something wrong here. This is sick. I'm glad I saw this documentary. I would never give money to people like this.

@SnyderBearFarm 4 года назад

Considering we still learn lessons everyday from Torah scholars from millennia ago means it may be pretty important.

@Shalomalechm Год назад

I hope you don't need their help one day, if you do don't forget to apologize from all the shi. you wrote and said about them.

@volapuk49 10 лет назад

I just finished watching this documentary. Really good presentation.

@dinomite161 11 лет назад

That woman, Adena, should have been allowed to study. She was obviously brighter than most and should have done more than just learn to sew. Shame on her parents for holding her back.

@Nyarlathoteplol 7 лет назад

Communities of closedminded, isolated religious scholar-ascetics have existed throughout history, and even flourished for long periods. The difference? They called themselves monasteries, and existed out in the countryside where they could support themselves through subsistence farming without needing much interaction with outsiders (besides trading their agricultural surplus for whatever necessities they couldn't make themselves). No idea why these guys are living in the middle of an urban society that they hate and can't support themselves in. Put the Haredim out in the middle of nowhere and hand them pitchforks, and I think both they and everyone else will be much happier. Hell, even the idyllic, romanticized eastern European shtetls that they themselves pine for were pretty much that.

@deniseg-hill1730 7 лет назад

Tuvia Dulin yes absolutely

@bjahava 5 лет назад

It's pretty obvious why. In the city its closer to the welfare office. Out in the country side they wouldn't be able to read the Torah all day so how could they farm for themselves/

@Nyarlathoteplol 4 года назад

@Samuel Levy No. A small population of indigenous orthodox Jews have been there longer. The majority came in the late nineteenth through mid twentieth centuries, just like the more secular Jews. The people causing the problems are, for the most part, *not* from that small first group. Also, this isn't only an issue in Jerusalem, though it's more serious there.

@Shalomalechm Год назад

I hope you don't need their help one day

@janebibby5933 5 лет назад

Respect for Bambi , she’s a strong woman , who I suspect doesn’t really agree with men who choose to study and not work to support their families. She’s seeing the consequences of poverty everyday , love to know what she really thinks. She’s really trying to make a difference

@DellaStreet123 4 года назад

She seems to be a truly nice person. I bet she was shamed by other Haredis for being barren, even though it could have been her husband who was sterile. Not to mention that it doesn't matter, she found beautiful words to explain why she does not need pity.

@jonathanmccormack3607 10 лет назад

I can't believe how much irrational hostility is directed to these Orthodox who simply don't want the distractions, pornography, trivialities, and other cultural pollution to effect their kids. Millions of new age hipsters have gotten rid of TV and internet. Everyone is committing the exact same intolerance they aim at the Orthodox by lambasting them for not living the modern "right" way ! "Either live like us or you are intolerant and wrong !"

@janesmith2770 9 лет назад

The only real objection is if they cannot be self sufficient and if it's hard for those who grow up in them to leave. Apart from those issues I have no problems with them at all. We have them in London and other parts of the UK and they have always been good neighbours.

@akindelebankole8080 9 лет назад

jonathan mcCormack Clearly, you can be more balanced in your assessment than that.

@annagitana1 8 лет назад

+jonathan mcCormack Uh, it's not irrational to be skeptical and critical of a community that, due to its insularity, lack of education, strict segregation of the sexes and intense rules about "morality", is comprised of a majority living in abject poverty, affords zero choice to its children about whether to be a member of the society at large and become educated or not, (unlike the Amish, by the way, who have rumspringa) has rampant child abuse, both sexual and physical and subjugates its women in an incredibly cruel manner.

@jonathanmccormack3607 8 лет назад

The Hassid’s are eminently educated, they study and recite Torah constantly. But you probably mean the type of education thats the “right kind,” makes money, upholds the ideology that values freedom and liberty, and not the “wrong” values of tradition and communal living. I wonder, what choice were you given? Which different communities were you brought to and given a choice to live in? Of course, I wouldn’t want to be irrational and question the value of individual choice, clearly your “morality” is the correct one. Liberty and free choice are “good” and tradition “bad.” Of course separating the sexes and other “wrong morals” have kept the Jewish people alive for 3,000 yrs, but that’s nothing compared to the experience of a brief few decades of life, obviously a person should think for themselves and not rely on centuries of proven wisdom. The child abuse - does it rival the sexual abuse found on American college campuses? One and four college women are sexually assaulted but what what would you have them do ? Live in (gasp) poverty! Raising families?! Devoting themselves to God and honoring their ancestors ?! No, clearly you know what life is really about, what the right values are, and shame on them for disagreeing !

@nosimilar 7 лет назад

I am a muslim and i agree with your point. I don't understand why the secular community -Im secular my self- keeps pushing communities that don't want to live up to their standards to become more like them. How is that part of tolerance the secular community claims to be part of? yes of we can speak against things wrong in some communities like the treatment of women, and we need to stop spreading false stereotypes on them too. They are not ignorant, stop calling them that, they are just different.

@barbarastepien-foad4519 7 лет назад

I have watched the other sections of this documentary and found this concluding one very moving indeed, also sad, it is these people's determination that keeps them segregated, it is a Jewish way. I can understand their feelings however i cannot condone the aggression that some are stirring up. The world is not us and them, God would not agree to violence or hatred, neither would God want misery or inequality. There are many things that are wrong in the world , a great many but what is needed is a way forward to combat that, not a degeneration into hatred and alienation....we need to try to understand one another more...Amen.

@YTfancol 4 года назад

Very interesting but where are parts 3 and 4 of the documentary ?

@ezniyazov7970 4 года назад

For some reason its blocked from watching in US

@marcovitolimburgo8510 3 года назад

Wisdom Understanding Knowledge even in Europe. I tried in Italy, Austria, Polonia and France

@Boaty5 9 лет назад

"Understand that these people know the ways of the Lord, and decided to rebel against Him" GEVALD!!!

@Chloe-eu1op 6 лет назад

hahhahah

@elizabethburke5322 7 лет назад

Committed Christians would consider smoking to be sin but these people appear to be ok with it.

@eauvive3101 5 лет назад

Sin means transgression of the Torah. Drinking alcoholic beverages isn't prohibited, as well as smoking. In fact, the Torah condemns the abuse of something, as for instance being drunk or addict, because it makes you loose your self control and thus makes it easy for you to sin (ex : lusting after someone, being violent, insulting people etc).

@eauvive3101 5 лет назад

@Guns N' Moses I think you haven't understand my comment at all. Apologies for my language, if it wasn't clear enough. First of all I was reacting to the fact that many Christians consider drinking as sinful. I never said that the Torah prohibits the drinking of alcoholic beverages! On the contrary, if you read, my point is that because sin = transgression of Torah, as alcohol isn't prohibited, then it cannot be considered sin, no pb with that. I think it is stupid to call sin things that are not, while on the other hand certain prescriptions are ignored. Drinking is encouraged (I disagree when you say "commanded" the term is not appropriate) on some occasions as kiddush, havdalah, feasts, marriages, for rejoicing. Or for people who need their hearts to be warmed up, as the sick, those in pain, those who are mourning. You quote passages which talks about wine consumption for people who need comfort, this is quite different as being drunk at a party. Drinking is a pleasure just as eating good food. However to reach the state of drunkeness and loose all self control is not "commanded" because it can easily lead to sin. Excesses can happen, but should we let our péchés mignons dictate us ? Should we excessively eat (kosher) fast food because the Torah doesn't prohibit such type of food? It is best to avoid any sort of excess, be it food, wine, cigars... Both for the health and spiritual consequences that might come out of it. This is why there are rabbinical prescriptions about which amount of alcohol it is best to not exceed. From all the bad exemples of excessive drinking I quote the episode of Noah making a fool of himself in Genesis 9:20-21. The exemple of Lot who got drunk and committed incest (Genesis 19:21). Adonai also commanded that certain men be consecrated to Him and never consume alcohol as Samson (Judges 7:13) for a reason obviously. The Natzirim vow (Numbers 6) of abstaining from any fruit of the vine and sort of alcohol in order to avoid any possible defilement of the being is also a good exemple. And we also have our own exemples that may be even more insightful on the matter... Everything that is permitted isn't profitable. I would not recommend you to get drunk. Feeling tipsy is kinda okay and normal when drinking a few glasses and I believe it is the rejoicing of the heart you talk of. Beyond that, imo loosing one's mind shouldn't be assimilitated to joy as it is definitely not. Joy isn't blabbering, laughing stupidly, or letting one's thoughts go wild. It's up to you to seek God's counsel on that matter concerning His will for you. We're all different in our experiences, physical abilities and limits. Adonai bless you and keep you, Adonai forgive you, and renew you. Shalom

@scottskaggs6765 5 лет назад

Guns N' Moses ....the Orthodox also "misreads and misquotes Torah"....often and blatantly

@MrBrightlight66 8 лет назад

Very good documentary. It is really an eye opener. It is just a question of time before technology and new ideas permeate. It has happened and is still happenning in every society. I wish the Haredi of good will the vey best.

@JamoStar21 9 лет назад

So I watched all of the parts of this documentary. At the end of it all, it just goes to show that their world is crumbling down before their very eyes, and if they don't admit to their faults, they will not exist. The fact that they have to make countless offspring just to stay relevant shows that. They live in poverty when they don't have to. The men don't work. Women make babies. They live off of charity. The planet's resources are going scarce. They aren't doing much to provide for it. When shit gets real, charities will dwindle. And the last group of people to be fed and aided for survivial will be them because they don't provide anything even for themselves. Why help people that don't help themselves? Not to mention the hatred that they hold. Time to let go. If other oppressed people (especially your own people, the ones you look down on, the seculars) can let go, so can you. I love how they look down on everyone else, but are the lowest to begin with. How can you look down on something that isn't beneath you? Some twisted logic right there. They will slowly die off if they don't change. Education is key. What Bambi and that lady's school are doing is the best thing for these people. Only thing I would say is stop giving to them because we are give them more than they are producing. There should be an equal exchange, and none exists here. Teach them that there are ways to preserve your old ways without living in poverty or shamelessness. THe fact that they don't even speak to or awknowledge anyone outside of their communities means that they don't exist on the outside. Therefore, they should be self-sustaining themselves, but they aren't. Well, we shall see what the future holds for them.

@SomeOne-jq9gd 9 лет назад

+Princess Amira's Mind Puppet a poor blend of ignorant words...

@JamoStar21 9 лет назад

+SomeOne How are my words ignorant? If you can't disprove it or come up with a counter point, you have the ignorant words. it also shows how uneducated you are.

@richardlitwin4046 8 лет назад

+SomeOne she is opening her mind to us and how dare you call her poor and ignorant, is that not lashon hara, you are bad mouthing someone you do not even know, everyone has their story, everyone has their opinion and each has great value because we are made in the image and likeness of Almighty God.

@joelkestenbaum6465 Год назад

@@richardlitwin4046 Chofetz Chaim Ch. 8 Halacha 5 states that: An "apikorus" (heretic) is one who denies the laws and prophecies of Israel, whether the Written Law or Oral Law. Even if he says, "All the Torah is true with the exception of one Scriptural verse, kal v'chomer, g'zeira shava, or one grammatical detail," he is included in this category. ["Kal v'chomer" and "g'zeira shava" are Talmudic terms for two of the logical principles from which we understand many laws.] The apikorsus does not have a connection to AM YISRAEL he does not have Olam Haba. Learn Halacha. Learn Hilchot LaShon HaRa from the Holy Chofetz Chaim before you say anymore kefira using his Holy Sefer levatala like that.

@HelenRainier 8 лет назад

This is a very harsh, patriarchal, and suppressive life -- it reminds me of the Fundamentalist Latter Day Saints.

@MsStormcrow 8 лет назад

Any form of fundamentalism really, be it Jewish, Christian, Muslim or other are all oppressive. Especially to women.

@HelenRainier 8 лет назад

Lori Burnip Very true, Lori. Fundamentalism of any kind is oppressive.

@didihern 2 года назад

@@MsStormcrow At least in the Christian and Muslim groups the men work to support the families!

@Lhwbakao 7 лет назад

Interesting documentary! Those two woman were both well so well spoken for. Thanks or uploading this.

@richardlitwin4046 8 лет назад

Now let there be a seker for the men, too, to sort out which of them has a real talent for Torah and which are just wasting everybody's time. Sure not every man is an illui just as not every man is a Rebbe in the diaspora.

@flute4hire 11 лет назад

its correct that haradi have many living in poverty, i deliver toys to haradi familys. i wish one day i could become as devoted as these haradi.

@marksimons8861 8 лет назад

Seems to me you can't keep a good woman down, with or without an education!

@Phoenixspacecraft 11 лет назад

Those who don't work for 10, 20 years due to yeshiva studies, here goes a good thing: most renowned rabbis in Jewish history worked hard to maintain family...

@Gentilejedi 8 лет назад

The man is worried about the internet (boys looking at porn and other misc things). The two women have a better priority educating these people in the long term to be productive. in the previous video it shows some of them on the internet looking at women in bathing suits and what appeared to be adult videos. They can get access to internet however they won't always have access to academics in their own community.

@ebaltrace 7 лет назад

Very interesting view. When a man studies Torah what does he produce for the rest of the world? Does he write something down on paper that will enlighten others? Enrich others? Lighten the burden of others? Is there any value for society for his study?

@landwarrior348 10 лет назад

Internet? What is it?

@cruzcastroE 8 лет назад

I appreciate being able to see this. I took this constant struggle as a good thing because some are really seeking and desire to please God. The courtroom scene was poignant to me because of the sadness that Jewish people would like to achieve justice apart from Hashem and it seems the secular Jews do not wish to acknowledge they are Jews because God chose them to be His people.

@peternorton7665 8 лет назад

Very interesting

@Celestiaetterra 9 лет назад

Praise YHWH for His faithfulness. May His people be blessed.

@NuisanceMan 10 лет назад

I could never live like these people, but I think they are beautiful.

@hinanochick 10 лет назад

Beautiful??? why dont you join them and do not use the internet!!

@NuisanceMan 10 лет назад

hinanochick I just said I could never live like them, dumbshit.

@hinanochick 10 лет назад

Now it comes out......the vulgarity! Why cant you just write and say something you do not agree without being vulgar? Besides my comment was not directed to you.

@l_pin5930 10 лет назад

hinanochick It's another way of living. But as you see, the men don't work nor support their family. They are a burden. They could work AND study.

@janesmith2770 9 лет назад

Luca Pinsuti Yes, that's the objection and the difficulties for women who want to be educated. The sexism of course and unfairness on women as ever and so common this planet.

@velvetindigonight 2 года назад

I found it very interesting listening to the section in school where the young women were studying sociol work. It appears the issues have evolved post Holocaust when so many spiritual leaders died. The idea that those who study and refine themselves lift the world is a noble one and there have been others such as the Cathars/Perfecti in Southern France.......... I noticed though that this appears bad for the young women who are left with all the children and this affects the mental health of some. Poor parenting has a huge effect and perhaps some husbands do need to have paid work instead of spiritual work to help support their wives and families. The Elders need to sit down and discuss these very divisive and unfair issues and find a way through for their well being of present and future generations.

@randytucker1965 9 лет назад

Ancient custom in a modern world = cost

@tamarabaye 10 лет назад

I am haredi and you can see the shades and variations within our world- but this is nothing new-- they say 2 jews, 3 opinions- the thing that unites us all is the utmost importance of torah study and following the commandments- even in Talmudic times there were conflicting opinions on all issues, but with the times, there forms a slow concensus and mainstream approach-- the hot issues today are computers/smartphones, army, etc-- in short, everyone chooses their community and specific rabbi for spiritual guidance- psychologically, it makes you feel a part of something, -- a feeling that you're going somewhere and accomplishing something in this world for yourself and for your people

@micselaneouswickedwitch3526 7 лет назад

Tamar Abaye If you agree haredi why are you on the internet ? Some pretty offensive language here which makes me sick.

@utkarshg.bharti9714 6 лет назад

Surprising you are on the internet. Watching this documentary as a non-Abrahamic, I feel that you Ultras are actually quite similar to the welfare-seeking radical islamists in France, Sweden and Germany.

@eugeniageorgescu2614 5 лет назад

Get work and feed your families ! Accomplish at least that !

@Shalomalechm Год назад

Shalom is part 3&4 available? Torah is life! If we read in this week's parashat, who is calling Israel lazy and that they have to work more? Pharaoh! The world wants us to assimilate to its jobs and schedules, violate Shabbas. No thanks, our god told us to work 6 days, it doesn't say in what or how much, this can mean study. Rest and keep Shabbas holy and he provides for us, he gives us our parnasá. HalleluYah, good Shabbas!

@nielsqbc4 12 лет назад

I think it is good that they created a save internet. Internet is needed, so it cannot be ignored. Secondly it is good that bad things are blocked, because the soul is weak.But our soul cannot get rid of the sins by ourselves working for it. David asks God in psalm 51 to wash his sins from him and to give a new spirit and joy. It states that God has no joy in workings of humans, but in a broken mind, verse 19: a broken heart God will not reject. you can change your life but not your soul.

@jagoaranda6481 6 лет назад

Bambi is a true hero

@doginthecity9635 6 лет назад

A great inside to The Ultra Orthodox Community.....Thank you.......

@dc2277 8 месяцев назад

This is a really great documentary. Is there a way to see parts 3 and 4? Thanks for sharing

@d7787 7 лет назад

I'M WITH BAMBI !!!

@FPLNameless Год назад

On the channel; 2 episodes are missing, is there a way to get them, does anyone know please?

@janesmith9024 4 года назад

This is a very good programme. We have ultra orthodox people in the UK too. Whilst I respect their right to practise their religion the position of women is wicked and if there is a God she will be crying at the mess men have made of it. Given equal rights and fairness to women and girls.

@boliussa 12 лет назад

many times, the men study all day, and the women work

@coffeebreakist 10 лет назад

What is Internet? That would be evil. I have never used that even once!

@EvenbenYosefbenAvraham 10 лет назад

everyone should have the right to choose the life they wish, within reason. If that lifestyle infringes on fundamental human rights, it should be discarded.

@missplasticpony 9 лет назад

Wow this is just criminal how they try to keep the youth from intellectually advancing! Give them a Internet-free Computer with no chance of watching movies and a SECURITY COMPANY á la NSA on the orthodox level watching over who does what on those computers. While denying any possible education or yearning for higher knowledge by restricting the Internet, I think they're should be consequenses in the form of jail sentences for these fanatics!

@BobJones-jp8wk 6 лет назад

Ms Plastic: Movies do not equal intellectually advancing or education. Indoctrination into a life style is all movies do, unless someone vets the movies. Seems your'e indoctrinated and want others to follow your plastic ways.

@robdawg417 11 лет назад

Brate moj, svaka ti cast, situacija u staroj Jugi je pogurala nekoliko nas koji tako misle da dogju u Erec Israel.

@elleilafares4035 7 лет назад

So i see all these ladies wearing scarfs and defending their way of life, isnt that what muslim women do? Yet they get attacked and labelled as all sorts of names

@MineMeMineMeMineMe 7 лет назад

welcome to the double standard world of western media and ruthless illiterate people and societies.

@thepenguinwarriors4167 7 лет назад

Elleila Fares Because muslims outnumbers ultra orthodox by a factor larger than 1000 to 1.

@secretdaisy6484 3 года назад

Missed segments 3 & 4.

@maryvampiregirl666 Год назад

*what happened to parts 3 and 4?*

@karolinapakostova4264 4 года назад

I ve got part 3 and 4 blocked, can i watch it somewhere else? Thx

@sounsure9108 4 года назад

Karolina Pakostova me to

@emadtaha4463 3 года назад

Go inside the channel and search for it and you will find them both. I had the same prob.

@user-ih9it5bu4i Месяц назад

Do you know wher i can find the movie ''the Rabbi's daughter and the midwife '' there are parts that are not shown here

@BornInTzyon 12 лет назад

8:50 I don't understand the logic of this hareidi *unless* he doesn't actually believe what he is saying. If he doesn't believe that Jews should have a homeland until Mashiyach, yet doesn't consider non observant Jews to even be Jewish at all, then what is he protesting for? He doesn't believe they're Jews,according to his own standards, so it's no different than before, thus rendering the opposition of it entirely irrelevant...unless he doesn't actually believe what he is saying.

@EvenbenYosefbenAvraham 10 лет назад

the Hasidic make me depressed

@Nihiliste- 10 лет назад

Hasidic > all. The real ruler of the world bruh

@EvenbenYosefbenAvraham 10 лет назад

Xecutionner2K What bull shit! I think your user name is apt BRUUUUUUUUUHHHHH! stop talking about thing's you don't know about! Who told you this? Leave Jewish problems to Jews to sort out! Stop interfering in things you have no idea about!

@tracyscanlon4587 11 лет назад

Eeing a gentile,i find this extremely hard to comprehend,but i will the same way i have come to know GOD i really want to strive to understand his people and know what they went through

@hfd268 7 лет назад

Anything taken to the extreme is always bad

@ellahope6494 9 лет назад

If men want to study Torah all day, don't marry and have 15 children. Family God began in Gen. it is the foundation of society. Man is to work scripture says. He can study or read a few hours evenings weekends.. His God and family should be first all day Torah don't Marry just as a Catholic priest doesn't to give all his time to Church and people.

@dogtraininginthedark 8 лет назад

I think your comment you're somewhat ignorant. I have a family, children and I had a wife but she was killed, and I work and study Torah. If you work if you want to study, you make time. I listen to tapes when I am working, or read in the evenings during my spare time, when my chronic pain keeps me up at night I study. My day is full, I make time anyway. It's important to me, because it's the way I should live my life, however, it is not all there is. We were put on this earth to learn and to do. We were not put on this earth to sit and learn all day long, which one could say is kind of lazy. There's a point where you become saturated with the material.

@neongirluk 6 лет назад

Exactly if you can afford to do both then do both. If not do not have that many children. Also do not make the state pay for you to sit at home and study Torah. Just like you do not want to pay for men to sit at home reading the Qu'ran. Though oddly enough most fundamental Muslim men actually work. Now we need to help liberate the women.

@richardlitwin4046 8 лет назад

In the Bible Israel said, We will hear and WE WILL DO. These frumme Torah scholars, they only read and hear, they do not DO. But the Torah is there to be DONE, not just learnt. And you don't need to learn until 40 to DO Torah. You need to learn till 40 to read the Zohar, but not to DO Torah in the world. Jews are called to be a light to the gentiles but how can the Gentiles see this light if it is locked away in a room studying?

@BobJones-jp8wk 6 лет назад

Do you know the light of the world, he is Jewish, he is alive, he lives at the right hand of God. The Jew rejected the light and live under a basket as the light said they would. It is sad, and I thank God for blocking their sight for a time so we could be brought in, we are Israel.

@RallyRossi 12 лет назад

That happens when you over do it. Over doing anything, even if it's good for you is bad. Even water in large enough quantities can kill you. You just gotta learn how to handle it.

@jeffglanstein4489 7 лет назад

From a Torah perspective this entire documentary is seen differently. I looked up Matan B'seser Bambi; 1667 54th St., Brooklyn, NY 11204. They will get a check from me for sure. With the focus of a Torah Microscope we can ascertain what are positive and negative qualities. If we gave only into our raw emotions we would miss the most important facets of living and growing in Yiddishkeit.

@janesmith2770 9 лет назад

It is very good thank you. I remember my mother (Catholic) despairing of the story of Martha and Mary in the Bible - all right for all those men worshipping Jesus and Mary not lifting a finger whilst poor Martha had to get on with the chores. Man may not live by bread alone but he and his wife still need to provide the bread - not by donations from others. By all means live a simple religious life with few possessions (eg Gloriavale Christians in NZ) but support yourself in doing so.

@DellaStreet123 4 года назад

That story can be upsetting. However, I find it interesting that Martha is a saint in the Catholic Church, while Mary, the one who "chose the better" is not in the calendar.

@flute4hire 11 лет назад

if your not religious why do you need a jewish state?

@saeed-vc9mt 4 года назад

yes Zionists are absolute hypocrites

@DellaStreet123 4 года назад

My impression ist that these people claim the physical land, but want it only for people like themselves. The state of Israel recognizes secular and non-orthodox Jews and has a set of laws that is different from the Torah -- that's why the Haredim reject it. But they still believe they are entitled to the soil.

@eeinay2010 11 лет назад

Thanks for sharing!!

@timdetmers3240 5 лет назад

My problem with the Haredim is that they want to tell everyone how to live. I believe they have the right to live the way they want to but they do NOT have the right to tell the rest of us how to live. This is where I push back against them. One thing that really bothers me about their beliefs is that they blame non-haredi Jews for causing the holocaust. They believe that Jews who are not haredi actually caused the holocaust. This is. hateful and disgusting point of view in my opinion. I have no sympathy for this point of view. I do not hate the Haredim, but I do hate some of their beliefs, such as the aforementioned. Still, I judge each individual on their merits, not based on their group identity.

@MosheBorisoff 8 лет назад

Very well done

@MineMeMineMeMineMe 7 лет назад

I do respect people religious practices and customs! the shameful thing in their story of victimization is that they became savages while victimizing people who have given them escape from their genocide, now they are occupying their land illegally, killing people ruthlessly, bulldozing people homes arrogantly and taking their shelter away inhumanely. So, just because you became victim of holocaust, doesn't give you a right to go and cause genocide and holocaust to any body else in the world especially those people who ended up providing you shelter. Shameless morons! The disgraceful thing was studying Torah all day and having dozens of Kids while dependent on charities to feed them? where is the human dignity and man's self respect of taking care of his family? what kind of God would tell you not to have your priorities set straight and not to have balance between worshiping and practically providing for the family without been dependent on charities?

@zenoagha1274 5 лет назад

I hear u.

@josephinemullar7857 5 лет назад

As far as I understand it is the Ultra Orthodox Jews who don't agree with Zionism and conscription of their youth into the military. As far as all men learning Torah 24/7 that was not a command at least not in my bible. Moses instructed by the command of G_D in Exodus 20:8 "Remember the sabbath day to hold it sacred, you are to render service and you must do all your work in six days But the seventh day is a sabbath to YHWH your Elohim. It is not my place to decide what other people should do but I feel it would be good if the men of the Orthodox Religion could work some pasture grounds and have their own produce and the women could have the means to make their own and families clothing within a secluded community lifestyle. I think they would feel a sense of accomplishment if they could do that. Even if they could work 5 days a week studying on the sabbath and one other day plus they have evenings after the little ones are in bed. It seems to me these Jews want to live the life of the Nazirite who did dedicate their lives to their Elohim as Levite priests did for a period of time. However it is very difficult for a community to have lots of children without the means to provide for them. I don't want to make any decisions for a persons way of life as long as they don't harm other people then I will not make any decision for them by objection. These Orthodox Jews appear to have a desire to be holy in the presence of YHWH. Although you might say they harm their own families. Their own families generally appear to uphold the decisions of their parents way of life up until now when the world is stepping up the One World Government agenda which means depopulation of most of the world's inhabitants which Orthodox Jews in this video appear to be against..

@cinnaminson0667 10 лет назад

it is probably a good thing that some people live this way. they are the same as the amish, for example. some people just want to live the religious life. good for them. i would have no desire to live this way myself but i am not against it.

@justcallmeassinine 9 лет назад

Please don't compare the Orthodox Jews with the Amish. When a nutjob murdered Amish schoolgirls in Pennsylvania,the Amish leaders immediate went to the killer's parents and forgave them,and offered their consolation and support. The Amish really do believe in "turning the other cheek".

@janesmith2770 9 лет назад

yumi mango The Hassidim would be similar. The difference here might be the hassidic jews may rely on state support and the Amish don't.

@justcallmeassinine 9 лет назад

Jane Smith I do hope you are right.My guess is that some portion of Hassidim would behave like that. Israeli police cracked a conspiracy by young Hassids to blow up a Muslim elementary school not so many years ago. Then you have the Kahane - like groups of today.But I think this is a small minority and rare. Also you are correct,USA Hassids do not hide the fact that many men just fill their days with Torah study and rely on state support for their large families.Between the two,the Amish seem more upstanding and responsible.The Amish also appear much more low-key and relaxed in both their demeanor and talk. Just my opinion.

@KP-vg3zn 6 лет назад

The Amish might separate themselves but they actually work & make a contribution. You would never see Amish people hate the way these people do.

@Eman1900O 5 лет назад

Don’t you dare compare these lazy animals to the hard working Amish

@ankemarais2534 9 лет назад

Yeshua in the Brit HaGadasha is a Jew. He came to bring us back to the Torah. When Yeshua (Jesus) walked the earth there was no New Testament. Every single book in the New Testament refers us back to the Tanak. The land of Yisra'el is not to be devided or sold. It is the dowry of the bride. It is YHVH"s Land. We have to keep Torah to stay in the land and because we love YHVH. Yisra'el and Yehudah got dispersed because they did not keep Torah. I am a South African woman and I keep Torah and have the ya'ad (Witness) that Yeshua is HaMassiach and He will return to Zion. Amein,Amein

@rehannaseem4103 11 лет назад

a) God Almighty speaks to Moses in Book of Deuteronomy chapter 18 verse 18: "I will raise them up a Prophet from among their brethren, like unto thee, and will put my words in his mouth; and he shall speak unto them all that I shall command him."

@theaccidentalhousewife 7 лет назад

Maybe I'm not totally "with it" ... but where TF are you getting a tv for $13k?

@ginarios9442 6 лет назад

Excellent documentary. Tudah Rbah. HaMSHYHh SHUB HR M GDD (hill from GDD), SHGH YSHRAL, L MUGhDY. (The Messiah will return at HR M GDD, to save YSHRAL, at the appointed time.)

@richardlitwin4046 8 лет назад

Anyway the Torah is a law about how to live in the world, and you won't understand the Torah until you have fully understood the world, and seen and known what really goes on in it. Exile was God's idea and he equipped the Jews to live in exile, indeed all the time in the Bible they were being exiled, so it is today that Israel is still in exile, so no wonder they can't get on in Israel. the frum communities in the diaspora, there is a logic there, that makes them real in their hasidut in the world. but put hasidut in the context of medinat yisrael and there is trouble, because the whole of hasidut is about protest and separation, but how can you separate from the holy land and the holy people? That is separating from the separate, and it doesn't work.

@redduckinpond 12 лет назад

They work in Israel, too... but they do it under the table because otherwise they will be forced into the army. They are mortally afraid of mixing in with secular society and the army does not provide enough haredi-safe opportunities.

@csilla924 8 лет назад

I only have questions. What if a woman doesn't want to have children? What if a woman or a man would like to study? What if someone is ill, but modern technology could save their lives? What if I only want to have 2 children? For me as a woman, who speaks three languages and has 2 degrees, really hard to understand, what it means, that aather and husband don't allow to study? Not to mention, if God forbid someone is gay or lesbian in that community? I can accept religions. But I can't understand why do you need to live a life like in the stoneage?

@boliussa 12 лет назад

They also don't fight in the army if studying all day. And most people even in that community, don't have the capacity to really study all day, so they waste much of the day. There should only be a few elite that are allowed to do it, and the rest not. Also they have so many children,and so it's a ridiculous burden on the woman and means they all live very poor.If you actually watch the video, you see some religious women themselves want change.Even Rabbi Ovadia Yosef's religious daughter.

@boliussa 12 лет назад

the woman at 6:06 passionately argues one side, then the other. "are you saying the husband is wrong to study torah?" vs "the woman dropping down dead". The solution to her would have to be a compromise.. so the husband doesn't study so much that the woman drops dead.

@danieleduchene-alessandrin6959 4 года назад

I have to slow down the video so i have time to read the subtitles.

@RallyRossi 12 лет назад

That's bullshit. I speak English thanks to the computer, i have learned to play the guitar thanks to the computer, i have increased my knowledge tenfold thanks to the computer. Maybe porn is bad, but teens need to see it so they will know how to handle it, much like sex education. It is addictive like food and tea are. If you think you are addicted find other things to do and go out with friends. If anything, it enhanced my childhood rather than destroying it.

@zadokbabu 5 лет назад

Praise the '''LORD''' Salute to all who made this possible. There is only one thing left to pray... '''YEHOVAH''' please send thy son '''JESUS CHRIST''' soon.. Shalom

@nkwari 11 лет назад

The seem to be similar to the Fundamentalist LDS, have a lot of kids and limited money.

@boliussa 12 лет назад

Also there are other theories, for Ashkenazi IQ, like maybe being restricted to finance meant the smarter Jews got married and had more children Or the marrying off of daughters of business men to rabbinical scholars Also, many find the Talmud not very impressive. Another answer, is maybe back then, Torah study made literate. In those days most gentiles couldn't read. But nowadays with academia, the mind can operate at a high level outside of Torah, and accomplish great and greater things.

@MrOnionterror 10 лет назад

So a man can sit and read fairy stories all day while the woman pops out a baby every year and still somehow supports the family? It's very discouraging to see the female students defending it.

@paticakoos1 8 лет назад

Joseph was a carpenter and supported his family so why won't you?

@adamwets 8 лет назад

+paticakoos1 I totally agree. I was thinking 'Isn't the Torah full of examples of men providing for their families and prospering.' Why are they studying the Torah and not living by it.

@adolfomatus6318 11 лет назад

Behold the nail, Behold the hand..

@westwindzigns2727 8 лет назад

The girl who is speaking at 8:08, there is wisdom in her words. I don't know much about the nation of Israel much less of Haredi but it seems that they are not the same as the Zionists. I am glad to hear that the Ultra Orthodox Society in Israel seems to care for the Torah. I can see that one of the ideas to have men study the Torah is so that they search for the Most High God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. I see these videos and it is unavoidable to feel sadness due to the poverty that these people are going to and the little children specially. It is a joy to my heart to know that at least this society still cares and repenting from their doings and looking to come to terms with God. The following I embrace as truth: there is no better enterprise for men than to honor the Lord God almighty all the days of of his life with all his mind with all his heart. But also taking care of the family wife and children and parents is a way to honor God. the weight of the law is too heavy bear; this is for all men Jewish or gentile. Also remember that by the law nobody can have peace nor true life. But God so loved us that he send his only begotten Son Jesus Christ/Yeshua Hamashiach so that whoever beliefs in him will not perish but have everlasting life. From the bottom of my heart I pray that the only one God, the God of Abraham and Isaac and Israel may forgive our transgressions open yourt eyes and help you see that the only way to Him is thorugh His Son Jesus Christ. For He is a good God and he is forever merciful so Thanks be to Him for the sacrifice of his only begotten Son because if it wasn't because of him I would have never come to learn of the God of truth and love a faithful loving God. Praises be to Him forever and ever. Amen. So people Open your heart to Him, it is just Him you are missing. With much love

@Smil7001 11 лет назад

Theres a million Arabs in Israel today with citizenship. If all of them were forced out then where did this people come from?

@boliussa 12 лет назад

I think the protest was not to vote wasn't it? Maybe to stop people in his charedi community from doing something unjewish like voting. Some vote to get more money for their yeshivas, even though they don't accept the govt system, so voting may not mean accepting the system, but they still oppose voting. It doesn't mean those in their community that vote become not jewish . And if it does mean that ot him, then he doesn't want that to happen.

@Levied12 5 лет назад

If a man shall not work, then he shall not eat. Ever learning, but never coming to a knowledge of the truth.... How sad...

@YouTubeHandleYes 11 лет назад

Street warrior - I agree that having the Torah for modern Israel isn't appropriate; however, it's more practical that Muslim religious law (are you familiar with it?).

@danieldetweiler1259 8 лет назад

Funny that a guy with the last name of Rothschild could be so anti Internet....

@crimeandpunishment1130 6 лет назад

Yes I was surprised by his surname as well. To think he seems to live in the poverty.

@ijunkie 7 лет назад

@12:20 what a chilul hashem

@AEN08 11 лет назад

So in that case you should know better that there were far less jews in Palestine that is so Call Israel (from 1948) you should know too how many Arabs were there before Israel was formed, all of them were forced out. To fill in jews from Poland and other part of Europe

@voraciousreader3341 3 года назад

People believe what they want to believe, and people take to themselves-or try-the exact amount of power or control they feel they need to be safe. And there are men who need so much control for themselves to feel OK, without caring that other people have rights, and that the men’s rights are not one jot more important to anyone else’s. But power hungry men, control hungry men, will go to great lengths to take power from other people....these Haredim call the police Nazis, but this is simply a projection of their own insensate need for control. They have become what they’re most afraid of.

@user-xj8de4pd3j 10 лет назад

well directed

@363Magi 11 лет назад

Take what ever reaction or insult you want. I have no hate for you and I mainly wrote that for others whom stand on the fence not those with closed hearts and minds.

@marcschneider4432 7 лет назад

23:43 No, dude, you had it right the first time. That's pure, ignorant hate you're feeling, not "alienation". No takebacks.

@vomiecuz3722 10 лет назад

Love is best always , believe don't believe , learn to get a long on planet earth excepting diversity! None of us picked our parents our countries and yet we'd die for both over someone we don't even know or who is different then we are. I can use ugly words and be mean too if I choose too! Love conquers all in my opinion pass it on if u choose! Hate gets too much attention look at hate as the bully down the block you wouldn't even speak too, this way it is diluted don't give it undeserving power. Love is always best serve that and serve God.

@janesmith2770 9 лет назад

And one problem with these groups with 12 children each family (and many religions groups including Christians and Muslims have similar large families if they are fundamentalists) is you end up with 50% of the population under 25. The problem with that is hot headed people lacking wisdom are often that age so it gets harder for the wise elders to control the young.

@carolcheny 11 лет назад

Fear and religion minus brains is the worst combination.

@thehighlander_91 2 года назад

❤️👍🏻

@sounsure9108 4 года назад

It to bad 2 out of 5 parts are blocked

@technology3628 8 лет назад

I do not hate the Jews, I love them. The One whom I follow instructed me to pray for them and the peace of Jerusalem. This is the truth revealed thousand of years ago: The Mosaic Law was given specifically to the nation of Israel (Exodus 19; Leviticus 26:46; Romans 9:4). It was made up of three parts: the Ten Commandments, the ordinances, and the worship system, which included the priesthood, the tabernacle, the offerings, and the festivals (Exodus 20-40; Leviticus 1-7; 23). The purpose of the Mosaic Law was to accomplish the following: (1) Reveal the holy character of the eternal God to the nation of Israel (Leviticus 19:2; 20:7-8). (2) Set apart the nation of Israel as distinct from all the other nations (Exodus 19:5). (3) Reveal the sinfulness of man (cf. Galatians 3:19). Although the Law was good and holy (Romans 7:12), it did not provide salvation for the nation of Israel. “No one will be declared righteous in God's sight by the works of the law; rather, through the law we become conscious of our sin” (Romans 3:20; cf. Acts 13:38-39). (4) Provide forgiveness through the sacrifice/offerings (Leviticus 1-7) for the people who had faith in the Lord in the nation of Israel. (5) Provide a way of worship for the community of faith through the yearly feasts (Leviticus 23). (6) Provide God’s direction for the physical and spiritual health of the nation (Exodus 21-23; Deuteronomy 6:4-19; Psalm 119:97-104). (7) Cause people, after Christ came, to see that they couldn’t keep the Law but needed to accept Christ as personal Savior, for He had fulfilled the Law in His life and paid the penalty for our breaking it in His death, burial, and bodily resurrection (Galatians 3:24; Romans 10:4). The believer in Christ has the very righteousness of the Law fulfilled in him as he obeys the Holy Spirit who lives within him (Romans 8:4). The purpose of the Mosaic Law raises these questions: “Are you trusting in yourself to keep all the Ten Commandments all the time (which you can’t do)?” OR “Have you made the choice to accept Jesus as your Savior, realizing that He has fulfilled all the commandments all the time for you, even paying your penalty for breaking them?” The choice is yours.

@boliussa 12 лет назад

I don't see what you mean at all. When you say education, you seem to mean Jewish education. You talk of Jewish contribution to the world, but when people refer to that, what they usually mean are people like the 30% of nobel prize winners that are of Jewish background. Perhaps you think that's caused by their Torah study. I find it hard to see what you mean.

@boliussa 12 лет назад

Funny how the Haredi salesman technicial here says The Internet is blocked completely without exception, but you have Email. At 3:43, I didn't know Bambi was a mythological jerusalem midwife!

@davidacpyehuda 6 лет назад

No one who has NOT learned Torah the orthodox way should comment negatively on this series. It is important to remember that not too long ago there is NO SUCH THING as reform, conservative, modern, reconstructionist or any of those invented denominations. Orthodox or Haredi is the ONLY true form of Judaism.

@beahilu1 8 лет назад

The bases ,the pilar of Moses, TORA/ TABOT which is called in Ethiopia is ´´FASTING`` with out fasting one cant call himself the worsheper of TORA/TABOT and the follwers of MOSSES who is called in Ethiopia MUSE, MUSE himself fasted many monthes at DEBERE THSION mountain.´´ FASTING IS THE KEY TO HEAVEN´´ ´´ LET THE TRUTH, THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH ALAWAYS PREVAIL.

@beahilu1 8 лет назад

***** you dont know the truth, even you dont know who reslly are in truth, find your SOUL if you have one, other wise forget about it, you need a SOUL to understand and know the truth, and FASTING, LET THE TRUTH, THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH ALAWAYS PREVAIL.