Тёмный

Harry Potter Theory: Snape Killed Hedwig?! 

SuperCarlinBrothers
Подписаться 2,2 млн
Просмотров 806 тыс.
50% 1

Visit lovebookonline.com/scb to receive a special 20% discount!
Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss Harry's pet owl Hedwig and discuss the theory that Snape killed Hedwig!
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

26 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,8 тыс.   
@SuperCarlinBrothers
@SuperCarlinBrothers 4 года назад
What do you think... WAS IT SNAPE!?
@abrahamo2895
@abrahamo2895 4 года назад
Yes
@westontheexistent7154
@westontheexistent7154 4 года назад
Yes
@chonkyc4t
@chonkyc4t 4 года назад
It was... FRANKLIN!!!!
@KllDLn
@KllDLn 4 года назад
Yes I love your channel and it would mean the world to me if you liked my comment Thank you SCB
@benTi900
@benTi900 4 года назад
No. J.k did. Wait?!
@franknad7140
@franknad7140 4 года назад
J.K.R. : Hedwig’s death marks the end of Harry’s innocence. Harry: Casts expelliarmus to the freaking Dark Lord.
@ishitaasen3733
@ishitaasen3733 4 года назад
😂😂😂😂 Harry : I'm gonna use that disarming charm that all second years can on Voldemort. DEAL WITH IT !
@GoldenMushroom64
@GoldenMushroom64 4 года назад
It’s an effective disarming spell that could literally render even the Dark Lord almost defenceless if it actually landed so I’d say it’s a valid tactic.
@douchebaggenie2964
@douchebaggenie2964 4 года назад
@@GoldenMushroom64 So they could arrest him? 😂
@wulfpup350
@wulfpup350 4 года назад
Good beats evil.
@Scandal262
@Scandal262 4 года назад
A loss of innocence doesn't necessarily mean a loss of...not being a murderer(???)
@mothwizard3095
@mothwizard3095 4 года назад
Love how this just turns into an “everything wrong with Hedwig” video for a few minutes.
@goldenhd9656
@goldenhd9656 4 года назад
Tbh he doesnt really give proof that snape actually killer hedwig
@randallflagg3700
@randallflagg3700 4 года назад
@@goldenhd9656 - Indeed, the sinning of Hedwig was, IMHO, more interesting that the theory itself, that could have been explained in one sentence: Snape killed it because it could be a clue to where Harry is. (even if every one of the Harrys had a copy of Edwige in a cage, so...) I'm not sure what to think about it, Avada Kedavra sounds a bit overkill for a small animal like that. But why not?
@chezwizard
@chezwizard 4 года назад
@ULGROTHA That would work.......if it wasn't Hagrid that gave him the owl. Can we reasonably assume he wouldn't know the difference? The better solution would be "Hedwig is a failed animagus."
@LokiLoverForever99
@LokiLoverForever99 4 года назад
Hedwig was his first present that he was able to remember getting.
@DustyStarrs
@DustyStarrs 4 года назад
cinemasins would be proud
@Mayonnaise_man35
@Mayonnaise_man35 3 года назад
Imagine Sirius gets a letter from the ministry just saying ‘ladies and gentlemen, we got him’ and then he gets bombarded by spells
@Chunkalunka68
@Chunkalunka68 Год назад
Hahaha why doesnt this have any comments
@molbotuk6557
@molbotuk6557 4 года назад
*“She was a SAINT J a SAINT”* Truer words have never been spoken Rest in peace Hedwig
@Jpcn111
@Jpcn111 3 года назад
F
@stevencarenduff2623
@stevencarenduff2623 3 года назад
I think it’s jay
@smiledbanjo4171
@smiledbanjo4171 2 года назад
Actually in pieces, the side car (where Hedwig’s dead body was in) fell very far and probably shattered Hedwig’s body into several pieces. :)
@Thesis_Rose
@Thesis_Rose Год назад
@@stevencarenduff2623 nope, he has stated before he is called J but his actual name is Jonathan
@rps524
@rps524 Год назад
He’s Ben.
@edfarquharson4143
@edfarquharson4143 4 года назад
Another fact: The owl that played Hedwig was actually male. Female snowy owls have many more black spots.
@miroden4387
@miroden4387 4 года назад
FACTS WITH @Ed Farquharson :D (i think i knew that i don't remember)
@vadifadoms
@vadifadoms 4 года назад
"Hedwig is transgender" J.K Rowling probably
@nkirukaj2384
@nkirukaj2384 4 года назад
Vadi Fadoms no, she wouldn’t say that. She doesn’t think those are real 🧐😒
@thathsaraamarasinghe6774
@thathsaraamarasinghe6774 3 года назад
I thought she was like... CGI-ed or something cuz how could you train ANY animal like that...????
@moviehermit5631
@moviehermit5631 3 года назад
There was also multiple owls used to portray Hedwig
@unoriginal1562
@unoriginal1562 4 года назад
“Certainly my favorite bird!” Poor Bob the Phoenix...
@Arctic226
@Arctic226 4 года назад
Unoriginal 156 he prefers Mr Bob
@unoriginal1562
@unoriginal1562 4 года назад
Lapis shoot, sorry Mr. Bob
@amelieschneider9251
@amelieschneider9251 4 года назад
Don’t forget Mr Little Bob!
@user-ss2pj1rh7q
@user-ss2pj1rh7q 4 года назад
Poor Mr. Bob, no one ever gets his name right...
@randomstuff1387
@randomstuff1387 4 года назад
Umm... it’s Mr.Bob
@gavinmarquardt1744
@gavinmarquardt1744 4 года назад
“Because his parents are dead” had me dying
@drawkilldragon
@drawkilldragon 4 года назад
Like his parents? :D
@ninahu4415
@ninahu4415 4 года назад
Drawkill Dragon Dude too soon!
@alyssaschnitzius4592
@alyssaschnitzius4592 4 года назад
At least he has his parents! .... his parents are DEAD
@joshuadesautels
@joshuadesautels 4 года назад
"At least they still have their parents...Their parents are dead."
@tiffany-up2ii
@tiffany-up2ii 3 года назад
@@drawkilldragon I was gonna say that
@missstaceyshep
@missstaceyshep 4 года назад
“Once dressed, the fake Harry’s took rucksacks and owl cages, each containing a stuffed snowy owl, from the second sack”
@alfredocruz123426
@alfredocruz123426 4 года назад
Stacey Shepherd the comment I had been looking for 🤦🏽‍♂️
@theundertakerrisen
@theundertakerrisen 4 года назад
If we are talking about the books. I think that (If it WAS snape), then he saw hedwig moving and making noises and realized "Shes gonna give him away!" Because i think even flying you would eventually notice that owls not moving. Then see the one that is, and "THAT'S HIM!" So snape killed her, still in the cage, so she could look like a stuffed fake like the rest and not give him away.
@hazbinedits_1186
@hazbinedits_1186 4 года назад
If you notice no other owl was flying And moving
@theundertakerrisen
@theundertakerrisen 4 года назад
@@hazbinedits_1186 that was movie. Books she was still in cage
@rubyrangitsch5248
@rubyrangitsch5248 4 года назад
At Just A Swell Guy, that's what I thought too.
@ashleymarie2749
@ashleymarie2749 4 года назад
Ben: “Seems to me they’re attending a school called Non Magical Warts. Ew” Me: as opposed to Magical Warts
@jacquelynchin5513
@jacquelynchin5513 4 года назад
Ashley Marie smh they should’ve gone to pigfarts
@maddiemauch8265
@maddiemauch8265 4 года назад
🤣🤣🤣
@carlosvaldez4356
@carlosvaldez4356 4 года назад
@@jacquelynchin5513 Pigfarts? Do you mean non-magical farts?
@carlairving
@carlairving 4 года назад
@@jacquelynchin5513 PigFarts PigFarts here I come! PigFarts PigFarts Yum Yum Yum!
@RobertKaucher
@RobertKaucher 4 года назад
Still a better school than Venerealwarts
@dxnzonyt
@dxnzonyt 4 года назад
No, Hedwig was not his first present. Remember Sirius, his present when Harry was 1?
@ScarletShade13
@ScarletShade13 4 года назад
But the first one he remembers
@olivia-wm1ph
@olivia-wm1ph 4 года назад
The Dursley’s had also given Harry a coat hanger and a pair of socks for a birthday present. These may not seem like“good” presents but they are presents
@sunilpermaul7876
@sunilpermaul7876 4 года назад
@@ScarletShade13 You don't have to remember a gift for it to still be a gift lol I would say his first gift upon entering/re-entering the magical world.
@SultanFilm
@SultanFilm 4 года назад
The first genuine gift given to him after at least 9 to 10 years of abuse and neglect makes Hedwig the first present of worth to him
@micropie1544
@micropie1544 4 года назад
@@SultanFilm no that would be the cake given by hagrid on his birthday to be his first gift then
@joshuadesautels
@joshuadesautels 4 года назад
"Sorry I'm late. The owl that delivered my release papers got all lost and confused. Some ruddy bird called Errol."
@MetaFanWing
@MetaFanWing 3 года назад
Maybe Errol’s just old. He does act “senile”.
@Commonwealth_Of_Pennsylvania
@Commonwealth_Of_Pennsylvania 4 года назад
Ben: *Talks about hedwig Mr. Bob: Mr. Bob is not amused
@laurenotts3747
@laurenotts3747 4 года назад
I really like the movie's interpretation: that Hedwig died trying to protect Harry.
@chendror872
@chendror872 4 года назад
Same
@Doctor_Straing_Strange
@Doctor_Straing_Strange 4 года назад
Same
@TheRibottoStudios
@TheRibottoStudios 4 года назад
it makes it hurt worse but i do really like that.
@minervasalazar3515
@minervasalazar3515 4 года назад
Same
@SilviaNight99
@SilviaNight99 4 года назад
I honestly don't even remember how she died in the books....it's been a while. *TIME TO RE-READ THE BOOKS*
@donrob7779
@donrob7779 4 года назад
She could screech, she seemed to live longer, it’s almost as if she’s an owl in a magical world that was bred by magical people with the abilities to merge different traits
@sawdustfart9249
@sawdustfart9249 4 года назад
I know. So hard to believe.
@stonerbland7621
@stonerbland7621 4 года назад
The movie's owl was male
@fauxhuman0
@fauxhuman0 4 года назад
@@stonerbland7621 Fun fact: The owl was supposed to be a girl. So we say she's a girl.
@stonerbland7621
@stonerbland7621 4 года назад
@@fauxhuman0 you don't say? I'm talking about the actor. Sure, he played the role of a female...
@ovni2295
@ovni2295 3 года назад
Or an entirely different species of owl separate from the Muggle Snowy Owl?
@leoyori9829
@leoyori9829 4 года назад
I love how J just pops up with facts, and bothers Ben, it’s such a sibling thing to do
@sanjoykumardas4018
@sanjoykumardas4018 Год назад
It's really funny.
@insertclevernamehere1186
@insertclevernamehere1186 4 года назад
Ben: (Says anything about snowy owls) J: "Well, actually..." Ben: *"My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined."* (Also, couldn't he have just, I don't know, stunned Hedwig? Paralyzed? Shrunk?)
@haroldinho9930
@haroldinho9930 4 года назад
She would of died from fall damage
@insertclevernamehere1186
@insertclevernamehere1186 4 года назад
@@haroldinho9930 Not if he caught her.
@celestialdetective
@celestialdetective 4 года назад
@@haroldinho9930 she was in a cage in the books
@lev7509
@lev7509 4 года назад
@@haroldinho9930 NoT If hE ShRuNk hEr!1!1
@severedpighead4141
@severedpighead4141 4 года назад
I remembered that Dumbledore is dead by this time, so he’d use the information to help the order if he could and overall defeat Voldemort
@alfiej.armstrong4450
@alfiej.armstrong4450 4 года назад
*Snape kills Dumbles* Me: Meh *Snape kills Hedwig* Me: *_P E A C E W A S N E V E R A N O P T I O N_*
@Shadowy_Cupcake
@Shadowy_Cupcake 4 года назад
Dumbles..? You married to Dumbledore or smth mate?
@insertclevernamehere1186
@insertclevernamehere1186 4 года назад
Well, to be fair, Dumbledore was asking for it...
@DrMonir-hd3ez
@DrMonir-hd3ez 4 года назад
actually Snape kills Albus Percival Wulfic Brian Dumbeldore ME:it was planned but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO snape kills hedwig me:At that point he was preparing to do a hate crime
@deejah4529
@deejah4529 4 года назад
@@insertclevernamehere1186 aNd i oOp
@lourdes5110
@lourdes5110 4 года назад
DUMBLES HAHA
@georgehowatt4492
@georgehowatt4492 4 года назад
One burning question that I am dying to see a good theory for is: What is the deal with Aberforth's fixation with goats?
@9nikolai
@9nikolai 4 года назад
Same as Harry's fixation with girls.
@timmyt-roll9415
@timmyt-roll9415 4 года назад
@ULGROTHA Not directly, but it's been mentioned once or twice. Yeah, he had some...adventures...with his goats.
@carlosvaldez4356
@carlosvaldez4356 4 года назад
I mean, to be fair we just know he did "something" with some goats that reeeeeally freaked people out.
@radgamerrach
@radgamerrach 4 года назад
Maybe he liked goats because goats have bezoar (stone-like mass taken from the stomach of a goat) and bezoar are a great poison antidote. Or maybe he just liked goats 🤔
@sunilpermaul7876
@sunilpermaul7876 4 года назад
It's been stated that Aberforth's favourite story was "Grumble the Grubby Goat".
@zenix9313
@zenix9313 4 года назад
2:50 Are we just going to forget the toy broom Sirius gets him.
@brelonwy
@brelonwy 4 года назад
In the book, all of the fake Potters had toy snowy owls placed into a fake cage to help throw off the Death Eaters
@amandahather
@amandahather 4 года назад
To be fair, the ministry isn’t all that good at thinking.
@annabethchase3943
@annabethchase3943 4 года назад
Amanda Hather exactly
@smellybuttbread
@smellybuttbread 4 года назад
*Hermione has joined the chat*
@kamishy_Art
@kamishy_Art 4 года назад
"let's believe that the death eaters had been under the imperius curse without using a potion for them to say the true sure what a good idea"
@luigiteam2584
@luigiteam2584 4 года назад
It makes me sad how Hedwig's Death just happened so fast. :(
@abbyjaramillo1369
@abbyjaramillo1369 4 года назад
At least she didn't suffer😭😭
@PetitPoneyDuVercors26
@PetitPoneyDuVercors26 4 года назад
My dog was poisoned when I was a young teen...hedwig's death was very realistic to me in fact...injust, sudden
@sunilpermaul7876
@sunilpermaul7876 4 года назад
I really enjoyed it like that. It's the same with the Battle of Hogwarts. The point is it's all happening so fast you don't have time to process or do anything. It's showing the urgency and pain of war.
@georgiarodriguez2516
@georgiarodriguez2516 4 года назад
It makes perfect sense in that scene. One: Harry loses he’s innocents. And two: Severus needed to protect Harry by killing the one thing that could be a dead giveaway (no pun intended)
@melissaknive3494
@melissaknive3494 4 года назад
Too soon ;)
@briarose1234
@briarose1234 2 года назад
Could he not have just stunned her though
@balbert24
@balbert24 Год назад
And that's the giveaway that tips the death eater off as to which Potter is the real Harry for Voldemort to attack which to me feels like a real missed opportunity to let it be the Expeliarmius spell
@insertgoodnamehere2247
@insertgoodnamehere2247 Год назад
​@The Gaming Club she would've just just fell to her death (yes I'm replying to something commented 1 year ago)
@i.r.3016
@i.r.3016 4 года назад
You: Hedwig is certainly my favourite bird! Fawkes: D:
@44BlueFoxes
@44BlueFoxes 4 года назад
"That joke will never get old." "LiKe HeDwIg?"
@Doctor_Straing_Strange
@Doctor_Straing_Strange 4 года назад
Too soon
@leilyniap6522
@leilyniap6522 4 года назад
Shame.
@sentinellj
@sentinellj 4 года назад
"Dude too soon!"
@SilviaNight99
@SilviaNight99 4 года назад
😢
@jayspamsa1197
@jayspamsa1197 4 года назад
too soon
@trashpandame4236
@trashpandame4236 4 года назад
"Why do they even bother addressing the letter so specifically?!" The only answer I can come up with is because Minerva McGonagall is the queen of passive-aggressiveness and is not above exploiting her station as 'letter writer' for Hogwarts to maintain this. Also it would freak out Vernon Dursley. Win-win.
@maximilianosalvador9559
@maximilianosalvador9559 4 года назад
New headcanon
@PhilBagels
@PhilBagels 4 года назад
I speculate that it depends on the person and the relationship to the owl. Sirius has actually met Hedwig, so Hedwig can find him. The owls sent from Hogwarts to Harry have never met Harry before.
@anvime739
@anvime739 4 года назад
@@PhilBagels I tought the same
@annakilifa331
@annakilifa331 4 года назад
@@PhilBagels but Harry didn't only send Hedwig to Sirius. In the books Sirius tells him at sime point to not send Hedwig because she attracts too much attention. Harry then sends postal owls to Sirius. Have the postal owls also all met him before?
@leonorewinterer8644
@leonorewinterer8644 4 года назад
@@annakilifa331 If I remember correctly, when Harry was sending school owls to Sirius, he already knew exactly where Sirius was hiding. So he could just could have told the owl where to go (probably wouldn't have written it on the letter so but seriously, do we believe that owls can actually read?)
@ladonnabeard34
@ladonnabeard34 4 года назад
Snape also had to be seen participating in the battle. A well aimed spell taking out an owl but looking like it was meant for Harry would help Snape appear to be on Voldemort's side. 2 birds 1 stone (protecting Harry from being recognized and looking like he was fighting. )
@Lexithepoptart
@Lexithepoptart 4 года назад
Snap-Pats Insta-Tronuses I’m dying
@suhakhan8601
@suhakhan8601 4 года назад
Title: Snape killed Hedwig?! Actual Video: Why Hedwig doesnt make sense Great video btw, laughed A LOT!!!
@jasminvalerie
@jasminvalerie 4 года назад
This video was both super sad and super funny. *(Back turned) "they're dead.....". *J popping up everywhere had me in tears. *And that letter from Voldemort, comedy gold 🤣🙌🏼😭
@Rujewitblood
@Rujewitblood 4 года назад
I feel like anytime something happens for plot reasons its either 'Dumbledore planned it' or 'Snape'
@molbotuk6557
@molbotuk6557 4 года назад
“Did no-one *Siriusly* not think to send a letter to *Sirius* with an owl and then follow the owl”
@jessicaschleicher89
@jessicaschleicher89 2 года назад
Why did the ministry not
@dancasey7
@dancasey7 4 года назад
Ben: Harry’s first birthday present Hagrid: my cake Aunt Marge: my doggy biscuits...
@sentinellj
@sentinellj 4 года назад
Sirius: my toy broom
@wyattmyers4900
@wyattmyers4900 4 года назад
Exactly U are truly a Harry Potter fan but don't forget when Harry was 1 toy broomstick
@michelemullican6627
@michelemullican6627 4 года назад
Uncle Vernon: my smelly socks...
@dancasey7
@dancasey7 4 года назад
OverHaul yep, but I saw someone elses comment saying that so
@miscvideos9903
@miscvideos9903 4 года назад
Lily: life.
@jmc8262
@jmc8262 4 года назад
I cried when she died in the book and the movie
@EtzEchad
@EtzEchad 4 года назад
It was awfully quick. She could've suffered more IMO.
@MrGabeanator
@MrGabeanator 4 года назад
oh man
@sunilpermaul7876
@sunilpermaul7876 4 года назад
@@tessb.lichtman4547 Poor He'd Wing...taken far too soon
@MrGabeanator
@MrGabeanator 4 года назад
Sunil Permaul yep
@melimontenegro6298
@melimontenegro6298 4 года назад
I just cried again when they showed the scene
@beanstatic
@beanstatic 4 года назад
The theory about Snape killing Hedwig starts at 9:10
@beanstatic
@beanstatic 4 года назад
Ahlbaas Woolfrik Bryainn Purcievaal Bumblebee Alright, well SOME of us don’t want to wait for all that to finish.
@avaaaa0
@avaaaa0 3 года назад
@@beanstatic agreed, not all of us want to sit through nearly 10 minutes of an ‘intro’.
@cathiaaskew1106
@cathiaaskew1106 4 года назад
Theory: it was Bob who killed Hedwig because Bob wanted to be the only important bird.
@Kimmy0721
@Kimmy0721 3 года назад
Who's Bob?
@Kimmy0721
@Kimmy0721 3 года назад
@Neil Mehta I thought that was Fawkes
@Kimmy0721
@Kimmy0721 3 года назад
@Neil Mehta since when?
@Kimmy0721
@Kimmy0721 3 года назад
@Neil Mehta *dramatic gasp* SOMEONE ON THE INTERNET DOESN'T KNOW SOMETHING? SHAME!
@sanjoykumardas4018
@sanjoykumardas4018 Год назад
And... he failed.
@zfrank4095
@zfrank4095 4 года назад
why do seven Harry's when you could just disguise Harry as some other character that wasn't there at all? logic, people.
@carliewiseman5446
@carliewiseman5446 4 года назад
Because why would a bunch of wizards be at Harry's home of 17 years when Harry wasn't there? Logic.
@carliewiseman5446
@carliewiseman5446 4 года назад
@wolfgirl 56 Ok, that makes more sense. I was thinking along the lines of if there was nobody that looked like Harry, then being at his house didn't work. Lol
@fidelianerina
@fidelianerina 4 года назад
Someone could have aparated with Harry to another location then disguise him
@gamesmastertobi29
@gamesmastertobi29 4 года назад
Actually 7 Harry’s was actually pretty smart. What I don’t get is why they didn’t do that then disguise Harry as someone else and he and another Order member take the Knight bus.
@AbdullahKhan-el6xw
@AbdullahKhan-el6xw 4 года назад
@@gamesmastertobi29 your plan makes sense except that the knight bus would probably be controlled by voldemort or not running.
@Beeba10
@Beeba10 4 года назад
Didn't the other "Potters" have stuffed snowy owls in cages, though? Or am I remembering that wrong? Edit: I was right - Chapter 4, The Seven Potters: "Once dressed, the fake Harrys took rucksacks and owl cages, each containing a stuffed snowy owl, from the second sack." However, just before Hedwig is killed, her cage slips from between Harry's legs; Harry quickly catches it, yelling "No - HEDWIG!" as he does so. This yell, implying that he cares about the bird in the cage (i.e. it's a real bird, not stuffed like the others), is what gave him away to - according to this theory - Snape.
@sophiet2164
@sophiet2164 4 года назад
Yes they did But hedwig was the only one that moved so he must have noticed that
@amanekabbaj
@amanekabbaj 4 года назад
Sophie T only hearing Harry was possible it’s dark and chaotic I doubt the death eaters would have seen anything
@fantabulousunicorns3946
@fantabulousunicorns3946 4 года назад
Amane Kabbaj yeah but at least one would’ve been focused on the real Harry to see him freak out over Hedwig But yeah, idk, I’ll just agree to whatever’s explained the best lol (this video - exhibit a)
@tigerprincess816
@tigerprincess816 4 года назад
Nice catch
@quantumgirl3047
@quantumgirl3047 4 года назад
Exactly! They were all in cages too. Mad-eye was very smart; he never would’ve made the mistake of sending off only the real Harry with a rare snowy owl.
@chaoticproductions3922
@chaoticproductions3922 4 года назад
Me reading the book: NOOOOOO HEADWIGS DEAD!!! My mom: who heard me: Honey you gotta big storm coming
@caffeinejournalist
@caffeinejournalist 4 года назад
I’ve been busy with school/work and haven’t seen your videos far a hot minute THE NEW INTRO IS SO SICK!!!
@completelyuselesstrivia5319
@completelyuselesstrivia5319 4 года назад
Ben: Snowy owls don't eat bacon Snowy owls are mute Snowy owls have a large wingspan Snowy owls aren't native to Britain Me: What is Hedwig is a magic owl?
@cass01993
@cass01993 4 года назад
I always just assumed she was.
@ashleeknowlton5805
@ashleeknowlton5805 4 года назад
😂
@PhilBagels
@PhilBagels 4 года назад
Wizards can travel to other countries if they want and bring back owls for sale in Britain. Just like muggles can bring animals from anywhere they want for display in zoos. So - 1. Not native to Britain - not a problem. Snowy owls don't eat bacon IN THE WILD. But if you have one in captivity, and you offer it bacon, I'll bet you cash that the owl will eat it! So - 2. Don't eat bacon - not a problem. Large wingspan. So what? Does it say in the books anywhere what her wingspan was? So mute. Well... magic?
@xMRxZEROx
@xMRxZEROx 4 года назад
@@PhilBagels Thank you! I was going to say. All these things could be explained. 🤣
@cpink102292
@cpink102292 4 года назад
In the wild snowy owls are mostly mute, expect during mating season, defending territory, and when attacking other small animals. So they can make noise, and they actually have a lot of noises that they can make. I always assumed that Hedwig making a lot of noise was do to the fact that she was domesticated and probably born into captivity. Lots of animals make more sound in captivity then in the wild. Take, for example, a feral cat v. a house cat. Feral cats are mostly silent, only making sounds during mating time and for territorial reasons, where as house cats have sounds for all ranges of emotions and times of day. As for eating bacon, I just chalk that up to bad ownership more then anything. I mean dogs don't eat mashed potatoes or ice cream in the wild, but there are dog owners who feed their dogs those foods.
@nourwalaamaher
@nourwalaamaher 4 года назад
A Question I need answered because its driving me insane, if they were going to a triwizard tournament how would Hogwarts arrive at other schools.
@arandomuser9459
@arandomuser9459 4 года назад
Nour Walaa Maher I really want to know that to. Ever since they bought it up in a video I’ve wanted the answer.
@shanapare8772
@shanapare8772 4 года назад
Magical train??😅 no seriously I have no idea but would love to know
@armadillolover99
@armadillolover99 4 года назад
I'd think the Hogwarts Express. They own the train, so they might as well use it.
@armadillolover99
@armadillolover99 4 года назад
I know it'd be difficult because they have to travel across the sea to get to either Beauxbatons or Durmstrang, but they're wizards, they could figure out a way to get the train there.
@ElentariRose
@ElentariRose 4 года назад
@@armadillolover99 not really, because there's already a train connection between the UK and the European mainland (France in this case), via a tunnel under the sea. The Hogwarts Express could use that tunnel as well. It's probably not a good idea to use a steam train in a long tunnel, but it's possible.
@Tcaine1111
@Tcaine1111 4 года назад
What shouldve happened: just as the killing curse was going to hit hedwig, a confused Errol who has no idea where he is flies in front of it
@ashl2115
@ashl2115 2 года назад
I can totally see Snape as doing something to protect Harry but also being pleased that it would cause Harry pain.
@sanjoykumardas4018
@sanjoykumardas4018 Год назад
I know, that's why I hate Snape.
@bob837
@bob837 4 года назад
the ministry of magic: sends letter to sirus black the letter: gotcha
@deepinthought2329
@deepinthought2329 4 года назад
I'd commented about that very question before. I can't think of any reason for it not to work.
@elizabethgrosvenor153
@elizabethgrosvenor153 4 года назад
Make it a howler
@Calvinosaur
@Calvinosaur 4 года назад
I've always wondered why no one ever sent letter bombs by owl post. We know from what happened to Hermione in Goblet of Fire that you can mail malicious stuff that way.
@Acerthorn
@Acerthorn 4 года назад
"Hagrid gives Harry an owl because he's ri-" **SIRENS & TRUMPHETS** "-ch"
@lev7509
@lev7509 4 года назад
Those are called airhorns. MLG airhorns.
@sukhbirsingh8053
@sukhbirsingh8053 3 года назад
I can actually imagine Snape thinking... This dumb idiot couldn't conceal Hedwig? He'd be instantly recognised! And Dumbledore thinks he'd succeed against the dark lord!
@Ninjinhah
@Ninjinhah 4 года назад
This was one of the funniest videos you guys did! Loved the surprise appearances lol
@gnikawpleasant9013
@gnikawpleasant9013 4 года назад
I need a while to prepare for this video. I’m still not over this particular death.
@deepinthought2329
@deepinthought2329 4 года назад
Opposed to all the human deaths.
@glamyumable
@glamyumable 4 года назад
If this theory is true, Hedwig’s death is even sadder.
@joshual4513
@joshual4513 3 года назад
​@Your boy geno 2000, Snape was definitely not a good person, but in the end he did die loyal to Dumbledore and did all of this in order to protect Harry.
@groot8950
@groot8950 3 года назад
It's a rubbish fan theory. If you've read the books, you'll know that Snape was fighting somewhere else. He did the Sectumsempra Curse on George.
@jamy306
@jamy306 3 года назад
@@groot8950 bruh he explained how that would have happened smh although I can remember what point hedwig did die in the book(cannon) so I’m not sure
@jessiehogue.
@jessiehogue. 3 года назад
@@groot8950 Accidentally* did the Sectumsempra curse on George, while aiming for one of the Death Eaters attacking him.
@Lexithepoptart
@Lexithepoptart 4 года назад
Actually, Hewig wasn’t Harry’s first birthday present. He got a toy broomstick from Sirius for his first birthday (and probably other presents) and the Dursleys DID give him presents, just horrible ones.
@Brucedash
@Brucedash 3 года назад
I just realised that if Voldemort was in danger no polyjuice potion could help him. He has no hair.
@Cafin8ed
@Cafin8ed 4 года назад
“That joke will never be old” My thoughts exactly
@endersdragon34
@endersdragon34 4 года назад
Neither will Hedwig
@Cafin8ed
@Cafin8ed 4 года назад
Bryan G Back to back jokes got me wheezing
@ulazlo
@ulazlo 4 года назад
The his parents are dead joke got me out of left field
@westube3493
@westube3493 4 года назад
6:53 strange, that's my nick name for the Dursleys
@hollyhartwick3832
@hollyhartwick3832 4 года назад
Hedwig was not Harry’s first ever birthday gift. On his first birthday he got a miniature broomstick.
@DarkSkies_1992
@DarkSkies_1992 4 года назад
Actually his first present was a birthday cake from hagrid and then Hedwig then the cloak then the broom.
@hollyhartwick3832
@hollyhartwick3832 4 года назад
Rose Miller - I think you’re confused. I meant when he was a baby. For his first birthday, Harry received a miniature broomstick. Harry read a letter from his mother that he found in Grimauld Place thanking Sirius for the gift.
@DarkSkies_1992
@DarkSkies_1992 4 года назад
@@hollyhartwick3832 I'm sorry about that I was referring to the movies, not both movies and books. I am really sorry for this miss understanding. it's time for me to go open the books back up and reread them.
@hollyhartwick3832
@hollyhartwick3832 4 года назад
Rose Miller - No worries. I knew straight off where the confusion came from. He got a broom twice as a gift while at school and that reference in the letter is obscure enough to easily forget. That’s actually why I commented on it in the first place. The same oversight was made in the video. BTW, how ironic Harry got a broom from Sirius twice. First the miniature, then the Firebolt.
@Logan_Gibson
@Logan_Gibson 4 года назад
It could also be Snape protecting himself from Voldemort finding out that he's a traitor. It would like kinda suspicious if he didn't try to attack anyone.
@ethansmith4503
@ethansmith4503 4 года назад
George's ear: Am I a joke to you?
@rozu7772
@rozu7772 4 года назад
@@ethansmith4503 That was an accident, but at least it worked.
@victoriabryer4710
@victoriabryer4710 4 года назад
"I'm Reading deathly Hallows" "Snape kills Hedwig" "No, it's not true, it's not possible". "Watch SCB, you know it to be true."
@calebwhittington1960
@calebwhittington1960 4 года назад
ur way behind on the HP universe... just wait until the lore consumes you after finishing the 7th 😂
@armadillolover99
@armadillolover99 4 года назад
@@calebwhittington1960 So...much...lore
@armadillolover99
@armadillolover99 4 года назад
Also you can skip Cursed Child, that thing is as much of a fanfic as it gets
@calebwhittington1960
@calebwhittington1960 4 года назад
ArmadilloLover99 i spent legit weeks reading lore, watching videos, it was all i dod for a while. Almost failed a couple finals because of it
@armadillolover99
@armadillolover99 4 года назад
@@calebwhittington1960 I thankfully didn't have to go through that process because I finished the series back in 2010 when I was still in 5th grade so I was able to consume all the post-series lore as it came out. But considering how often I had to check Pottermore to keep up with everything, I can imagine how hard that was to catch up on.
@noorykorky5056
@noorykorky5056 3 года назад
4:28 I LOVE Ben's face here!
@ChirgottCreativeArts
@ChirgottCreativeArts 4 года назад
thank you guys for always making me laugh :) I really needed this today.
@tinas_hotdog_sophie
@tinas_hotdog_sophie 4 года назад
How is "Just like Hedwig" too soon but "coz his parents are dead" is not??? 😂 😂 😂
@ki-adi-mundi635
@ki-adi-mundi635 4 года назад
His parents were dead for 15 years.
@jackclark1994
@jackclark1994 4 года назад
No emotional attachment to them.
@mjslack3073
@mjslack3073 4 года назад
I love when they just popping up in each other videos like that
@DLPMouse8
@DLPMouse8 3 года назад
The picture of Hedwig in the thumbnail 😆👀 Love your videos!!!
@bredalynch9358
@bredalynch9358 4 года назад
5:22 that will never get old😂
@maddtaggz
@maddtaggz 4 года назад
Last time I was this early...I thought the Carlin brothers were one person.
@BlitzerXYZ
@BlitzerXYZ 4 года назад
Glad I wasn't the only one who thought that at first. I was always confused at the intro
@Mary_Studios
@Mary_Studios 4 года назад
Same!
@aislingffyona
@aislingffyona 4 года назад
Omg yes!!!
@gavink.9539
@gavink.9539 4 года назад
I genuinely thought that J was the only one and that Ben was his deceased brother and that he made the videos for him. That’s why he always ended it with “I’ll see you in another life brother.”
@Giveuponyourdreamsanddie2
@Giveuponyourdreamsanddie2 4 года назад
same here
@NonApplicable_YtSucks
@NonApplicable_YtSucks 2 года назад
0:08 I think this might be my favorite gag I’ve seen from your vids
@withintheshyness
@withintheshyness 4 года назад
How Jay always have those snowy owl facts that disrupts Ben 🤣
@wcmdtl
@wcmdtl 4 года назад
I love that they start the actual theory with only two minutes left.
@isabellehanson8269
@isabellehanson8269 4 года назад
I already know I’m gonna be convinced this is true at the end of the video
@permeus2nd
@permeus2nd 4 года назад
10:04 im willing to bet your going to say snape did it to SAVE harry as lets face it been the only one with Harrys owl is kind of a massive sign saying this is the real one.
@ls199418
@ls199418 2 года назад
you are amazing guys!!! i love your videos😍😍
@valentinarunko67
@valentinarunko67 4 года назад
I laughed for a minute straight at the "non-magical warts" 🤣🤣🤣
@monstercrisis9312
@monstercrisis9312 4 года назад
Since when does J know so much about snowy owls😜
@leightwinter7885
@leightwinter7885 4 года назад
Ok this is by far my favourite SCB video to date
@Vikt0rian
@Vikt0rian 3 года назад
This is one of the first sensible theories out there that I have seen. Good job.
@jessrose4301
@jessrose4301 4 года назад
I've thought this theory for so long I honestly forgot it wasn't canon.
@monroerobbins7551
@monroerobbins7551 4 года назад
Maybe Hedwig was half snowy owl, half something else, hence why she could hoot and chirp. She was only half mute.
@althealligator1467
@althealligator1467 4 года назад
Or, you know, MAGIC
@thebigenderqueen1586
@thebigenderqueen1586 4 года назад
rip hedwig we miss you 😢
@elinamansbridge9945
@elinamansbridge9945 4 года назад
Hedwigs and dobbbies death was the saddest moment in the entire Serie. 😭😢🥺
@doomforzombies
@doomforzombies 4 года назад
I just need to point out that the other had stuffed Hedwigs in cages as well
@lauramayparkes6852
@lauramayparkes6852 4 года назад
Knew I remembered that! Glad it wasnt just me!
@NeoEvincar
@NeoEvincar 4 года назад
In the books. In the movie they didn't, and since Snape cursed off George's ear, we already know he wasn't around Hedwig when she died in the book, so I think this is a movie only theory.
@doomforzombies
@doomforzombies 4 года назад
NeoEvincar when did we find out Snape cursed off George’s ear
@rockyfellaq
@rockyfellaq 4 года назад
@@doomforzombies the chapter when Harry gets Snape's memories, it tells us that Snape was aiming for a death eater that was going to curse Lupin/George but hit George in the ear.
@rosyellis14
@rosyellis14 4 года назад
yeah but it isnt like the real Hedwig was sitting there super still when they were flying crazy. also Harry had to catch Hedwigs cage so she definitely would have reacted to that
@ryanhiccups
@ryanhiccups 4 года назад
I thought it said “HEDWIG KILLED SNAPE?!” 🤣 love ya guys❤️🤣
@MannyBoy96
@MannyBoy96 4 года назад
AU where everythign is the same except Hedwig kills Snape. Thanks, I love it.
@althealligator1467
@althealligator1467 4 года назад
@@MannyBoy96 At first, I thought you were saying "Astronomical Unit where Hedwig killed Snape" lol
@user-pk8bb6lf9b
@user-pk8bb6lf9b 4 года назад
Wouldve have been just as accurate as the real title
@viktordominguez
@viktordominguez 2 года назад
I love the interruptions of J in Ben's videos XD
@youtubelife921
@youtubelife921 4 года назад
This would be a good theory apart from this one line ‘Once dressed, the fake Harrys took rucksacks and owl cages, each containing a stuffed snowy owl’ It makes perfect sense for the film though
@taviacharles3364
@taviacharles3364 4 года назад
Unpopular opinion: The saddest deaths were Hedwig and Dobby
@FreedomAnderson
@FreedomAnderson 4 года назад
That's not an unpopular opinion, just fact.
@OctavKitty
@OctavKitty 4 года назад
It IS an unpopular opinion... You have Snape (he he), Sirius, Fred... Hedwig, you have like 10 seconds of "No, no!". Dobby's death was tragic though. But not the only one.
@taviacharles3364
@taviacharles3364 4 года назад
OctavKitty ok I’ll admit Sirius and Fred were really sad but I never liked snape so his death wasn’t really sad to me
@leymons1236
@leymons1236 4 года назад
Its not! They are! (Plus fred)
@IAtodd
@IAtodd 4 года назад
Saddest deaths were Lupin and Tonks. They could finally be together, they had a son, it's all ready for their happy ending... but then they did and their son is an orphan.
@danielsolomon3794
@danielsolomon3794 4 года назад
You: Owl's don't eat bacon Me: But they still deliver your letters
@422katieleigh
@422katieleigh 4 года назад
This is one of the all time great vids.
@gabiyoung610
@gabiyoung610 3 года назад
This is now my favorite SCB video
@peterhosea369
@peterhosea369 4 года назад
i thought they gave each fake harry a stuffed "hedwig" in a cage
@SeaKnight_Rory
@SeaKnight_Rory 4 года назад
They did page 49 it doesn't break the theory though as the real Hedwig could move (before she died!!)
@mink2316
@mink2316 4 года назад
The wise words of Queenie... “ don’t you mean hogwash?” Everyone knows illvermory is only the greatest magical school. Thanks for the video boys. Another good one and love the banter between the both of you. Keep it up!
@brelonwy
@brelonwy 4 года назад
I liked your little Frozen 2 reference at 5:22
@rebekahaltizer9887
@rebekahaltizer9887 4 года назад
Great video as always, where did that sweater come from? I love it! It’s got a nice Modern Hoth vibe. (Ice planet, not Goth typo.)
@carlairving
@carlairving 4 года назад
6:48 Can't believe you missed this amazing opportunity to refer to PigFarts
@angeladavidson2350
@angeladavidson2350 4 года назад
J's interruptions were golden 😂😂😂
@mena94x3
@mena94x3 3 года назад
5:23 . . . 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I don’t think I’ve ever laughed that hard or that loud during one of your videos. I woke up my husband who is downstairs and my son who is down the hall, all while trying to quiet myself. Edit: 4:47 . . . Close second.
@akhilanair4472
@akhilanair4472 2 года назад
It wasn't Snape chasing Harry, but other Death Eaters. Snape was following George and Remus he was following them for quite some time because his Sectumsempra curse was aimed at the Death Eater, but he missed and got George instead - this is what caused George to lose an ear. everybody was missing their curses direction as the brooms were very fast.
@chibiluciano7603
@chibiluciano7603 4 года назад
Ben:”I think I know specifically Who killed her, today we discuss” Me who has already read the title: “Omg I wonder who it is😱”
@ruckas3435
@ruckas3435 4 года назад
Chibi Luciano facts
@meg1955
@meg1955 4 года назад
It makes sense. Snape was living in a total dilemma as a double agent.
@Shfurjsgdufngwkfktnjegwjwbrhuw
@Shfurjsgdufngwkfktnjegwjwbrhuw 4 года назад
That’s sad but a sound argument. It would be weird with them on the run carrying hedwig around
@interestedobserver1853
@interestedobserver1853 3 года назад
What I find hard to understand is why (in the film), when Hedwig is murdered all Harry does is say, "no, no." But, when Dobby dies Harry is inconsolable, for about the length of time it takes to bury him. I just didn't understand that.
Далее
Игровой Комп с Авито за 4500р
01:00
Задержали в аэропорту
00:56
Просмотров 73 тыс.
The 5 Most Powerful AURORS in Harry Potter (RANKED)
12:59
The TRUTH About Polyjuice Potion | Harry Potter Theory
16:22
J vs Ben: HARDEST Lord Voldemort Quiz EVER
29:16
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Harry Potter Theory: Filch Is Actually A Poltergeist?!
12:17
Aberforth's Goats EXPLAINED [Harry Potter Theory]
14:22