"Have You Got it Yet?" Film Trailer discussion, Peeling Syd Barrett Episode 43

Подписаться 371

Просмотров 9 тыс.

50% 1

A discussion of 2 trailers of the film "Have you Got it Yet?"; the film intro by Roddy Bogawa and a podcast interview with Mr. Bogawa. I give conclusions and thoughts, and end with a modified trailer with a song i think suits the life of Syd Barrett most closely.
Videos used or referenced:
Trailer one (Pink Floyd):
• Have You Got It Yet? T...
Trailer two (Abramorama):
• Have You Got It Yet? T...
Roddy film intro (Syd Barrett Official):
• Roddy Bogawa introduci...
Roddy podcast interview (Deepest Dream)
• 'Have You Got It Yet? ...
My own library:
Peeling Syd Barrett Introduction:
• Peeling Syd Barrett - ...
Peeling Syd Episode 4 - Boy and Lion
• Peeling Syd Barrett - ...
Peeling Syd - Effervescing Elephant
• Peeling Syd Barrett - ...
Peeling Syd - Apples and Oranges
• Peeling Syd Barrett - ...
Peeling Syd - Baby Lemonade
• Peeling Syd Barrett - ...
Did Syd Barrett - Dark Side of the Moon
• Did Syd Barrett - Dark...
Did Syd Barrett - The Wall?
• Did Syd Barrett - The ...
Did Syd Barrett - The Beatles?
• Did Syd Barrett & Pink...
Did Syd Barrett - More?
• Did Syd Barrett - More...
Did Syd Barrett - Have Synethesia?
• Did Syd Barrett....Hav...
Books you may enjoy:
"Grapefruit" - Yoko Ono
"The Subterreneans" - Jack Kerouac
"Psychedelic Renegades" (Photos of Syd Barrett) - Mick Rock
"Barrett" - Beecher and Shutes
"A Very Irregular Head" - Rob Chapman
"Dark Globe" - Julian Palacios
And Now; You've Got It.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

25 июл 2023

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 78

@valpreston1393 11 месяцев назад

Amazing, more Syd vids please! We need you

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

Thanks Val; glad you liked it. I admit, it was a fun one to make. Since there were movie trailers and podcasts i had more ease with copyrights. other things legally are more difficult to use.

@trudyhughes40 11 месяцев назад

Love your educational, yet conversational presentation. It's like I'm sitting in an auditorium, listening to a respected professor! Really hope the movie doesn't disappoint!

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

ty trudy. we'll see. already got a neg feedback on the movie by one fan so i'm a little worried.

@cosmicretrouniverse 9 месяцев назад

I'm lucky to live near Cambridge (England) where all this started, people should understand he never wanted fame or glory just a young guy in a 1960's world where he just loved painting, this extraordinary guy and events turned into something he never quite understood, or wanted, He made "The Pink Floyd" legend

@vincentvanbarrett7138 9 месяцев назад

it's obvious to me that he loved the area, his friends, his family, and his blonde. :)

@stoner4378 10 месяцев назад

you deserve so much more credit !! amazing series

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

thanks stoner, it was a lot of work and i hope it was enjoyable to some folks. and i hope telling a story about syd that's more fair to him is rewarding to his family and his fans.

@stoner4378 10 месяцев назад

@@vincentvanbarrett7138 oh you can really tell that you care about his art and his work more than most 100% by the unique facts you present. Most documentaries on syd just do the basic storys on him walking in on wish you were here and the few times he froze up on stage but i can tell you really went the extra mile so to you sir i say bravo and thank you 🙌💯

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

thks stoner; i made the series for people like you.@@stoner4378

@jackries6575 6 месяцев назад

Never mentioned Robyn Hitchcock as musicians strongly influenced by Syd.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 6 месяцев назад

thx jack. he should def be included.

@rockern78 10 месяцев назад

I recently saw this film in the US. It's well worth seeing for any Barrett fan. A few things I liked were that many more Barrett contemporaries are interviewed including people like playwright Tom Stoppard. So, they did cast a much wider net than the previous documentary. They also used actors to portray Barrett at various life stages which I thought was thought provoking. One aspect I was disappointed in is that once again this film adheres to the theory that Barrett took too much LSD and damaged his brain. I believe this is not only inaccurate, not based on any scientific evidence, but also feels like victim blaming. Short shrift is given to the idea of a mental health disorder that went untreated. Not a very balanced view,, but overall I enjoyed it. Looking forward to your observations.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

rockern; i suspect i'll feel the same way you do since you seem to have many of the concerns i did and do. I agree....i think Syd likely had a personality disorder (i hate the word disorder) for that. But his sister has stated he was on the spectrum. So that should clue people in a little bit at least.

@absurdyellowdog9700 10 месяцев назад

I thought it was balanced. I didn't take away that from the film.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

still haven't seee it yet; not showing anywhere near me >< but thank you for the thots yellowdog and i hope you are right and it's fair and balanced.@@absurdyellowdog9700

@waynesilverman3048 6 месяцев назад

The guy who did podcast interview with syds sister said it will eventually go on blueray DVD ,I had The chance to go to a one night screening near my next city not that far but I had work very early next day and couldn't arrange properly

@robertdefex3439 10 месяцев назад

Like a Capricorn musician who first favorite band was nirvana and then I discovered Syd. Syd was a living human common sense tells u what it was as like being Syd .a creative force that wouldn't t put up with bullshit. and one hip tripping young artist who is no older than your granpa

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

hi robert; i think you're likely right that Syd wouldn't tolerate BS. He had a documented short temper at times...in my opinion...he was quiet and people would push him and he'd snap. That seems to be the dynamic. It's interesting you mention Nirvana. Cobain was quite similar. Cobain is one of the reasons i'm happy for Syd. He chose a path that let him live a full life. I suspect he wouldn't have made it if he stayed with the group. I think the stress and people in that orbit would have used him up and discarded him. Cobain also was aware of that...and was also an artist of sorts. his lyric "...she eyes me like a pisces when i am weak" speaks volumes.

@robertdefex3439 10 месяцев назад

@@vincentvanbarrett7138as a guitarist Eddie Van Halen is also a visionary and a Tru rebel renegotiated his contract as soon as the 2 album so it would be fair and and within 4 yrs built his own studio and told warner bros to ef them selves

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

hahaha, great story. i love when musicians and artists finally have enough power to go their own way.@@robertdefex3439

@Raggaennight 9 месяцев назад

This is for me the saddest story of music...we had the chance to know Hendrix, Jim Morrison, John Lennon, etc...we never had the chance to know Sid Barrett...and yet he left us so much

@vincentvanbarrett7138 9 месяцев назад

i felt that way too raggae; til i realized he didn't want to be known. he just wanted to make things and share them from a distance. some people show their love in that way; it's a beautiful thing, IMO - to say - they want to share lovely and valuable things, and you can live your life; and they will live theirs. the passing moment is valuable and bittersweet in a way but we honestly don't have much time on this earth, and even less with people that we don't have daily contact with.

@cynthiasmith5011 6 месяцев назад

Syd is a huge cult figure and he worked for only a short period of time. Maybe he knew that because of his looks and charisma he would be an icon like Jim Morrison or Elvis Presley. He knew that he wasn't able to withstand that kind of life. He walked away on his own terms and lived the way he wanted to.

@jaybee7890 8 месяцев назад

I find it a strange obsession but I suppose we all have hobbies.

@waynesilverman3048 6 месяцев назад

That photo that's one of your favourite I got the impression the photographer gets the name of the band wrong with syd not amused with the guy but rest are ,don't forget bowie met syd twice and both didnt go well ( another joke n.o. when he heard laughing gnome )he said ,at last someone who has made a video who likes syd like me ,as for syds penetrating look accordingly to his old collage teacher she said he studied u when he looked at u eager to find the real you .

@vincentvanbarrett7138 6 месяцев назад

ty for the info wayne. which teacher was it that made the note on syd, if you recall? (or what class taught?)

@nickgodalin6487 10 месяцев назад

Are there any recordings (legit or bootleg) of concerts with both Gilmour and Barrett?

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

hi nick; i can't think of any. the closest we'll get may be syd's solo stuff that gilmour helped out with; both albums. tho again, hard to know exactly what gilmour may have personally added. there may be some shows they played together when gilmour first joined floyd; but only one would be singing and i'm not sure they could play guitar together; gilmours guitar style is very different to syd's.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

awesome thanks von!@@vonclohk507

@donleblanc2669 11 месяцев назад

The " Quote " you mentioned near the beginning is from Peter Jenner .

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

thanks Don! kinda surprising. Mr. Jenner had some run ins with Syd. I always kinda felt he didn't get him but maybe he did after all.

@sheranni 11 месяцев назад

😊😊😊😊❤❤❤

@dangerfellini 10 месяцев назад

I saw the movie but forgot the reference to the name FRED. Do you remember what the story was about that ?

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

Syd liked to make nicknames. I think Fred may have been his nickname for David Gilmour or perhaps Beck. As Syd was vastly influenced by DIRECT INSTANCES of literature...he appears to have been giving nicknames the same way Kipling does in "Wee Willie Winkie". He makes other references tho obscure to Kipling as well, like the use of the Tyger as a symbol for death and destruction and terror.

@tool_fighter 10 месяцев назад

Dave.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

Fairly certain yes; and FRED sounds similar to Dave (backwards). And i'm pretty sure Syd could think things thru backwards when he wanted to.@@tool_fighter

@paulmessis1094 11 месяцев назад

You need to read the book Crazy Diamond, thats the ultimate Syd Book, kind of gives more depth to post 1972 Syd.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

Thanks for book suggestion Paul. I'll take a look.

@stephenstone8480 11 месяцев назад

Crazy Diamond is just full of inaccuracies and poorly researched. The book to read is "A Very Irregular Head" by Rob Chapman.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

@@stephenstone8480 thx stephen; that's one of my core books. good book too, easy read.

@madcapglass1454 10 месяцев назад

How is "Lost In the Woods"? If anyone has read it.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

@@madcapglass1454 hi madcap; i haven't read it...sorry can't give an honest opinion. I will say palacios wrote dark globe and that is very detailed. I suspect that's how he always is. Based on dark globe; he discusses as much measurable as he can but also allows for spiritual / non-measurable considerations which i do like. i suspect he does the same in that book. there are aspects of syd that are not measurable, IMO.

@CheestosParade 4 месяца назад

Where and when is this movie coming out? Is there any new footage? Live performances? Audio? Otherwise die hard syd fans maybe be just tired of the same old thoughts and questions surrounding him

@vincentvanbarrett7138 4 месяца назад

hi cheestos. the film has run its course and i believe in a few months will be available on dvd....including more excluded footage which is kind of standard now. perhaps it's better to wait for that anyway if you are a diehard fan. who will release it, unsure. there is a confirmation of release, but no release date set yet. hopefully not too much longer.

@music_fanatic1111 9 месяцев назад

Hope the movie comes online

@vincentvanbarrett7138 9 месяцев назад

we haven't had any showings out here. i think it was a fairly limited release....which is disappointing. but the other two Pink Floyd films (more and obscured by clouds) were also somewhat limited. only the Wall really went pop i guess.

@smaug1234 11 месяцев назад

The goal of any artist is supposed to be creation of original or unique material and Syd brought that in spades. Definitely a different animal, while the other Pop groups are writing songs about love and other normal things, this guy is writing about stealing woman's underwear from close lines. My guess is the official story is more then likely close to the truth. I think he probably pushed things too far and either had second thoughts about the pop lifestyle, or was incapable of that lifestyle (either way the exit happens). I doubt he actually contributed any material outside of the things he is credited as providing. His shadow is all over the "biggest" era for the Floyd however.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

thx for the comment smaug. love your last sentence.

@scottmooneyham5521 11 месяцев назад

Too much hippie-dippy/conspiracy stuff here. Syd was their meal ticket. Until his break in late July 67, Roger Waters and Nick Mason were perfectly fine riding his creativity to fame and fortune. Even then, they hoped he might get into back together until the US tour. Syd, whether through his drug use or pre-existing mental conditions or a combination, he became mentally ill, period. And, as Joe Boyd said, HE WROTE POP SONGS, along with the other stuff. EMI wanted another Beatles. They were perfectly willing to give him/them the rein to do Interstellar Overdrive. He perfectly understood in May ‘67, that to do that, he needed to and enjoyed writing See Emily Play. What is Gigilo Aunt but a pop song? Of course people had their biases about the tragedy that ultimately occurred. That is the one thing this commentary gets right.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

thanks for the comments scott. pro and con. it's good to have a convo. i think the romantic interest(s?) of syd also were pulling at him. same as they did with peter gabriel later

@scottmooneyham5521 11 месяцев назад

⁠@@vincentvanbarrett7138 I have never studied much on the life of Peter Gabriel, except that if I had had a chance to date Roseanna Arquette, I certainly would have done so, even if my friends would think I was a nut. I might even proclaim that I could turn water into wine pulling that off. To the point, though, I just think there is far too much of a tendency among some to dismiss the tragedy of Syd’s life, to paint him as someone who rationally turned his back on stardom to lead a simple, happy life, and/or think of him as the victim of evil conspirators lurking here or there. In the process, they often want to paint a brilliant artist himself, RW, as evil, simply because of his drive and ego. Those things simply are not true, even if hindsight shows that Syd might have been saved if things had been done differently. I would encourage anyone to read David Gale’s superbly-written obit in the Guardian to get a true picture of all of this from a friend who was not subject to some of the same biases as others around Barrett.

@KF-my8zz 4 месяца назад

I believe Iggy passed away from what I found online.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 4 месяца назад

Sad to hear; tho that would explain some. There's some history between syd and iggy; or there was anyway. Very specific history and Mr. Gilmour knows some of it since he has a story about listening to an album with Syd when Iggy came by. It would be nice to know everything he has to say about that day/night...tho i doubt he'll say anything. I believe the album was....get this...."More".

@pjamdragon1 2 месяца назад

Duggie Fields and Mike Leonard also RIP

@sfender2182 10 месяцев назад

@VncentVanBarrett Do you agree with my analysis that Syd Barrett had schizophrenia. I’ve heard it brought up a few times and my own brother has this disease. Because of what I’ve experienced with my brother; that guides my opinion on this. I don’t think this was ever officially ever acknowledged by anyone, not even his sister. I totally agree with your statement that we need religion in today’s world more than ever. Myself I’m Catholic. I love Syd’s 3 solo albums and his Floyd material; what a genius he was!! God bless Syd and all of Pink Floyd. Can’t wait to see the new Have you got it yet?

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

hi sfender, thanks for the comment and question. to answer your question on schizophrenia; i'll only say that it's possible. I don't think it's knowable. Only he and maybe his sister would really know. Syd could be extremely private and compartmentalized. HIs sister has said on record that she believes he was 'selfish' and 'on the spectrum'. Just my opinion but those two qualities can EASILY be seen from the outside as schizophrenia. We haven't observed him; we aren't psychologists; we simply can't know. I do think MANY people have schizophrenic traits. Many people do. The question is how strong are those traits and are they consistent? etc. One of the questions i have is ... what did she mean by selfish? From context i think she meant 'private'. selfish meaning 'not sharing'. And a private person does not share their thoughts or feelings or worries, hopes, aspirations, creations, etc. I think that's what she meant. Hope this helps.

@cynthiamarston2208 10 месяцев назад

Selfish could mean self absorbed in UK point of view? Not the typical hoarding their things and not sharing

@cynthiamarston2208 10 месяцев назад

Bowie said he felt free to wear makeup due to Syd. They all get influenced by each other. An atypical schizophrenic. Some strange acid like what Peter Green and his roadie took and got altered further mentally. Some psychic stuff was nurtured by lsd. Thats a common happening. I love most everything about the Syd year of out front and center. You know he had diabetes right? He needed hospital and had some issues with speed the doctors wanted him to stop. He had anger issues. He could be quite rude at times. Overall a kind of undesirable personality compared to the charismatic boy he used to be. Its a shame. He made a lot of contribution in that year.

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

Very much agree. Keeping to himself and hiding things from people. when someone is as creative as syd i suspect people were always asking him what he was doing and he'd say nothing....which can seem selfish. or perhaps; not being willing to go along with others when you know the way you want to live your life and walk your own path. @@cynthiamarston2208

@vincentvanbarrett7138 10 месяцев назад

thanks much for the comments ms. cynthia. i did know about the diabetes; and the anger issues. i'm not sure about the anger issues completely. i think perhaps he was disappointed by people changing things he was trying to do. if he was on the spectrum as his sister said...well, things not going to plan or behaving properly can be very aggravating to people like that. perhaps that was a contributor. and one of the most chaotic things a person will ever interact with is....other human beings :)@@cynthiamarston2208

@JohnFiocchi 7 месяцев назад

Syd Barrett was not particularly fond of the music business. He didnt like doing the BBC and why do you think that is? Because its garbage. Because its a redundancy. Because it has little to do with having real talent or being creative. Instead the music business deals with dress code and image. Forcing musicians to be anything other than themselves. Being impatient and not allowing music to inspire the musician and instead demanding that the musicians force the music and then it becomes contrived. Oh yeah...I practice 10 hours a day so I can become a person ...a musician who wants to make up shit. And force music to be something that it isnt..

@vincentvanbarrett7138 7 месяцев назад

agreed john

@MrBenmanning 11 месяцев назад

Hated the movie. Wrote a review on my blog. Like your review not a crit of you I just HATE the movie

@vincentvanbarrett7138 11 месяцев назад

ah man, that's disappointing to hear. I'm a little worried it will be clean and lack depth on certain topics. I'll try and check out your blog. feel free to link.

@tool_fighter 10 месяцев назад

Link to your blog ?

@MrBenmanning 10 месяцев назад

It won't let me paste my blog if you search Ben Manning author on Google you will see my Barrett article

@234cheech 8 месяцев назад

when this fuckin oot

@vincentvanbarrett7138 8 месяцев назад

it was limited cheech. i think i'll have to see it on video. it wasn't avail in my area. not enough interest in syd and PF in general pop anymore i think.