History of the Talmud 

As a Jew I'm shaking my head ! Do you know why we had prophets !? Were send by God to tell the rabbis to quit the occult making their own rules and regulations corrupting God's law however they persecuted and killed the prophets continuing with their abomination kept till today . This is the history of Talmud ! The end !

Murder is extremely illegal.

Doctrine of the "Synagogue of Satan". They have "added" and "taken" away from Yehovah Elohim (HaShem's) WORD. Follow the Tanakh. Talmud written by those exiled to Babylon, who refused to return with Ezra and Nehemiah. They assimilated with the Babylonians and adopted many of their "pagan practices". One only has to read of what was happening in the Temple, those found worshipping pagan Gods. As Yehovah has said. "The Israelites (including Judah), have continually rebelled against Yehovah Elohim". Hence the "destruction" of the Temples, and being exiled into the foreign nations.

Thanks! You filled in a lot of gaps for me but left a lot of interesting byways that I still want to explore. Especially useful was tying it to my own sketch of world history.

There were no jews in the beginning. What does he mean when he says from the beginning of history.

we follow the Shulchan aruch in practice as Orthodox Jews. Talmud a collection of arguments and discussions from the Mishna. Shalom

He keeps saying “Christian” but I’m almost sure he means the Romans, where Catholicism came from as an attempt to marry Messianic Judaism and Roman paganism. (because Jesus was an Israelite so he would have practice Judaism true to the Torah (not the talmud) because he “didn’t come to abolish it” but to establish it in its truth. And all those who followed him were then Jews believing he was the Messiah ergo Messianic Jews. ) the last super was actually Passover (Pesach) dinner. A Jewish holiday, the painting is wrong by the way because there would have been no fluffy bread on that table but Matzah. Then again the painting was painted by Romans. So *Christ was crucified during Passover not easter* (the pagan holiday giving homage to the fertility goddess ishtar) So Messianic Judaism + Roman Paganism = Catholicism (this marrying of the two is evident with the modern holidays that are celebrated as “Christian” (I.e easter, lent, christmas 😬 *sorry* ) but have nothing to do with Christ. Many of the holidays are around the same time (ex: easter and Pesach. Hanukkah and christmas) so it allowed for Pagans of the time to do their thing, and Messianic Jews and regular Jews of the time to do their thing because it was law that everyone had to be Catholic. The Roman persecution of “Christians” in history is better described as the Roman persecution of Messianic Jews. Then waaaayyyy later came Christianity (Catholicism rebellious child. It doesn’t like its parents, but it sure still looks like them) when people in England started getting fed up with the strict religious laws of England (*it does well to note that Catholics at some point tried to ban christmas due to its origin and the shear craziness of the holiday but obviously it didn’t work out too well*) Those people then left England in search of a “new world” where they could practice religious freedom = Christianity is established with the formation of the Protestant Church. The religion of Christianity is only about 400 or so years old. _-Happy birthday D.O.S btw! -_ With all that in mind, As well as the information based on the video. I’m gathering that the talmud is Jewish law written with the influence of Eastern Babylonians and Western Roman Catholics (*cough* Pagans) 😬🙃

YHWH is shaking his head. "I gave you the law, and this is what I get??"

Many people think a Rabbi is a teacher, that is true to a point, a better definition would be "Judge", on Jewish matters, A Beit Din is where 3 of them come together to make rulings, It could be anything from Marriage issues to the last step in conversion to Judaism, to civil matters. A Rabbi might look in the Talmud to see what another past rabbi said, and the commentaries surrounding that decision by other Rabbies, I'm no Talmud scholar, but that is my understanding.

As an aside about something said in the video, prayer was never forbidden in public schools. The old joke goes, if you think that there is no prayer in public schools just listen the high school students during finals week.

One of the best introductions of the Talmud.

Thank you, Becky. I'm very grateful to Dr. Neiman for his engaging and illuminating lecture, and to you for your observation. I'm certainly going to listen to more of the Neiman online talks. It just seems odd to suggest that Jews, whose religion was officially recognized by Rome as legal in 200 AD, would be at a legal disadvantage to mostly lower-class Christians, whose own legal status was minimal to non-existent, and numbers of whom were being fed to lions in that era. But, I can't claim to be an authority on that particular historical period. There may be more to this question. All the very best.

Yet, prophet moses just went by what God instructed him and God never mentioned him anything about the tulmud. never told him things like that just meditate on what I just said

I'm puzzled that Dr. Neiman suggests that in 200AD in the Roman Empire, Christians already dominated Roman law courts, to the detriment of Jews there. That's 125 years before Christianity was even legal in the Empire, and in fact Christians then were often persecuted severely. Does this make sense? There's something I'm missing.

It is legal opinion.

You know how much mohels get paid. No much just minimum wage. But the are allowed to keep the tips😂

The Mishnah is the oral Law or what Jesus called the tradition of the elders making the law of God of non effect. See how I can say God.

Shalom, Great Lecture, Toda Raba.

He's saying that the law of Yahweh was of no effect by itself so they created the talmud to interpret the Torah. The law says u must not add nor take away from Yahwehs word or your name will be taken out of the lambs book of life.

Fantastic. Thanks for posting.

Why do you allow so any obnoxious advertisements to disrupt this lecture.

The Talmud provides proof that Jesus was the Messiah. Jesus condemned the corruption of the Jewish religious elite, the Talmud ratifies the level of corruption and decadence of some of these individuals. It is obvious who is righteous between the New Testament that teaches love and forgiveness and the Talmut that justifies hatred, violence and some other atrocious allowances, along with endless unnecessary and irrelevant rules.

Only one thing I would like to bring to light. Dr. Neiman doesn't speak at all about the role of s'micha in this teaching which I believe deserves to be discussed considering that the function of Talmudic law is inextricably dependent upon the continuation of the Sanhedrin which has not been active since the late 4th century C.E. without this legitimate judicial body, no new laws can be determined as part of the corpus of case law according to the Torah.

Thank you Rabbi for these online talks. I live in an area where there is not manyJews so i rely on youtube for spiritual education and a lot of things jewish.

Why is Neimans tube bombarded by Christian ads? Interruptions are annoying enough but this is more than just a little inconsiderate .

If one would believe that each person houses the 'spirit' of God... each would then be a 'temple'. Imagine the level of respect that would be required of someone and required simply by looking upon a crowd of people - each of them... a 'temple'.

Did Rabbinical Judaism follow G-d's Torah or was Hashem aware of this new Oral Law (Talmud) long before men made of dust decided to take his power away from Hashem? Thus said the LORD, Israel’s Holy One and Maker: Will you question Me on the destiny of My children, Will you instruct Me about the work of My hands [Isaiah 45:11]

No love in the talmud.

He knoweth our frame...that we are human.

Thank you for this informative video. So, we Jews who believe in Yeshua of Nazareth, we also believe in keeping Torah, but the difference is that you and I interpret the meaning of the Laws differently. For instance, the law to refrain from doing any work on shabbat. We believe that it means actual labor, one's employment, yardwork, house keeping, cooking, or anything physically strenuous. We also believe we should refrain from entertainment on Shabbat, such as sports, hobbies, etc and of course no buying or selling. You, however, define work in a much more extreme sense, as meaning one cannot even carry something on shabbat, or use electricity, drive a car, etc. I think you view work more in terms of creating something, while we view work more in terms of producing something. For example, you would say, do not create a fire, but we would say, do not build a fire. We do not cast away all of Talmud, but only what seems to go beyond what we believe God actually intended, causing unnecessary burdens upon us.

22 minutes, the idea of not cooking meat in milk, I think according to the Kabbalah, is milk is natural nurturing food for life of a calf, to use with death is contrary as I understand it!

Does the jews of the nazi era fit the Deuteronomy 28 criteria yes or no?

What does the TALMUD says about Jesus and his mother?

he should used the correct term in 5:14 which is the Land of Israel not the fictitious term "palestine" which is, besides being fictitious, is misleading.

To all the uninformed U can buy translated Talmud in English Read it and tell me where is all this hate is written that u talk of

Chicken ala King... that law is NOT about cooking meat and milk together - it is about the 'teaching' being TOO HARSH. The 'teaching is the milk' and the 'teaching' shouldn't destroy what it is that is being 'taught'. This was the point of the teachings of Jesus the Christ - a 'man' who was wrongfully 'executed' because of His insights into the intention of the law of God. Which is to give us a 'hope and a future' - not to give us rights to destroy each other for our mistakes, as this is then one claiming God's rights to 'judge' and thus is robbing God of His right to provide the 'milk'.

What a gem this is. Thank you

Seriously...I believe I may help create a shortcut that would end much of the confusion and caos that has steered this world since the sanhedrin gave up the son of God as a sacrificial victim...as Pontius Pilate washed his hands.... admitting this huge error would be a great path to forgiveness and redemption... cheers from Mexico

stop w the ''suffering''....jews love it,

a sect of Jews CAN NOT account for all of us,as any culture, race,gender,etc. SHALOM~J.Shapiro

Too much to bear on one person.

Many useful summary observations here, but a bet too telescoped. eg the idea that Jewish-Christianity died out circa 70 CE is hundreds of years off. Such Christians upset both religions for a long time.

I think of Christianity as a Jewish Religion. My father had all his sons circumcised. Even though he was a Roman Catholic. He had to call in a Rabbi, not an easy thing in Newfoundland in 1960's.

As a Jew I am in a way conflicted about the validity of Mishnah and Gemara. It is true they were the creations of Galut and saved the Jews from disappearance over almost two millennia. But are they really a part of Torah, what the rabbis call the “Oral Torah”? Well, I doubt.

the Word (legal) goes against Gods Law .

The Pharisees that killed Jesus left, wrote the Babylonian Talmud, then went to Europe, converted the Kharzarians and that is when the trouble started.

The Talmudic contains the main holy books of the new Jewish or Judaic religion which was started after the Resurrection of Christ, the Christian Church being the continuation and fulfillment of the religion of the Old Covenant. The Old Covenant or Old Testament was superseded by the New Covenant, the New Testament. Due to this and the fact that the second Temple was destroyed and all Jewish priesthood geneologies we're destroyed. Since Jew Temple sacrifice was forever made impossible the Pharisees, the rabbis, had to start a new religion, currently called Jews, with the Babylonian and Palestinian Talmud being it's main holy book even more important to them than the Torah and the rest of the Old Testament. Ergo, It is important to remember that the current day Jewish religion was started after the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. It is younger than Christianity and is not the religion of the Old Testament.

Does God approve of the Talmud? Why? Please explain. If God doesn’t approve then what purpose does it serve?

Lots of arguing on this comment thread while im just wondering why Palestine is still Israeli occupied? Its weird how Palestine shrinks just a little each year, (insert sarcasm here) im sure they don't mind giving away their land with absolutely no reciprocation!

Always a decent perspective, but Dr Neiman may be ascribing too much influence to Christians in the Emperor's second century CE court. Trajan and Hadrian are far away from Constantine in the fourth century. Bar Kochba, and the memory of Titus CE 70, were reason enough to forbid the Temple's reconstruction. A Church subject to 200 more years of Roman persecution did not turn the emperors of this era against the Jews.

Lots of confusion

The Old Testament Babylonian Talmud has some pretty dark origin. Is that why it was destroyed it?

Aramaic was not the languag spoken in the entire middle east it was part of other mesopotamia spike their own khaldian language south Arabia their own even in levant they spoke multi languist

Mysterious God is everywhere - it is illogical to say God would tell people to face kaba to be in touch with Her / Him. One can pray to Bhagavan, God, Allah, Jehovah in a church or a synagogue or a mosque or in the cafe when sipping coffee or anywhere else in the world and God will listen for She / He is merciful, Caring and kind. The Kingdom of Heaven we talk about is the Country on Earth in which all people can live in harmony and ancient religions do not come into this as ancient books are outdated for our modern times. The ancient books were written for times past and not for our times of today with mixed cultures. The Kingdom of Heaven is likely to be the UK for here no religion is given prominence but its citizens are. Believing a Kingdom of Heaven exists somewhere else is a misconception which does not undersatnd the Harmony of Nations. Mohammed was a social reformer and an intelligent person. He by himself with his cabinet were quite capable of drafting the text of the Quran. He used the ideas coming from the Sumeria to Greeks to Buddha to Moses and Jesus. This is very common in human societies even at the times of the learned Greeks and Romans who lived many years before Mohammed. In like manner there is evidence to show that Jesus borrowed his ideas from Buddha on peace and tolerance. And there is evidence based on his upbringing as a prince in Egypt that Moses with his cabinet was more than capable of writing the Torah by himself. Buddha who wrote sensible laws as good as the laws in the Torah, Bible and the Quran never said god gave him the message - reflections on life did. In the modern world we need to modernise all ancient texts including the three stated above. Sunyat Iqbal, UK

there was no england in the time of first century enough with imaginary history

yes governing evil principles

there is only ONE LAW-TORAH for all nations

Talk about historic revisionism! LOL!

Loyola, huh...

What happened with Galut uprising? Liar

Mathew 24:2 “And Jesus said unto them, See ye not all these things? verily I say unto you, There shall not be left here one stone upon another, that shall not be thrown down.”

what do these Revelation 2.9 and 3.9 ''jews'' of Khazar and Ashkenazi origins say the name of YHWH is,.?

A man should always incite the good impulse in ones soul to fight against the evil impulse. Talmud. Judaism is interesting. I could deny christ for the torah and talmud.

Finally a video that's informing and educating and not that usual racist, antisemitic crap people have filled the internet with (unfortunately). My congratulations. A minor correction, though, should be made to the description: It's a 7.5 million words long legal code with a great deal of biblical commentary.

HOW CAN THE TALMUD OVER RIDE THE TORAH THE LAW OF GOD! ITS SIMPLE AS WRITTEN. THE TORAH HAS BEEN OVER THROWN FOR THE VIEW POINT OF MEN. TRADITIONS OF MEN :PHARISEES AND SADDUCEES

A question to the uploader - why do you think the Jews were so vehement and malicious in their propaganda against the Assyrians and Babylonians? Archaeology has uncovered a wondrous region with beautiful Pagan cultures, deeply spiritual, complex and truly innovative in their understanding of the relationship between men and their environment. Very progressive minds with a high emphasis on science and strengthening the bond between Mesopotamian and Levant tribes. The Jews wrote something completely different in the Torah, excessively slanderous and seemingly all untrue. Can you please explain why there exists such a massive gulf between the Jewish narrative and the archaeological narrative? Because it seems most stories are corroborated by multiple non-Jewish sources in the region at any given time, but the Jewish narrative seems extremely bigoted, violent, and slanderous.

The Dr speaks in favour of his own religion.. That is natural, but truth is one. Yes , oldest form of Abrahamic religion is Israel which is Nick name of Jacob.We love Abraham and Jacob.Their religion was ok.But brother Ísraeli religion of today is not of type of Jacob. Jesus has said it is of Devil. Religion of Tora and religion of Talmud completely different. Earlier Israelis were chosen,but not today s Jews. Jews now don't like Joseph, Ezra, Zaccaria,so God is no longer with Jews except a few. , Talmud can not be your guide.Please follow Tora. Please don't say middle east people are A Amlakites. Amlakites were idol worshippers whom Jehova Hashem did not like. M E people now believer in one formless God like Jews. ME people support more laws of Tora than Jews who are mostly atheist secular homosexual gay. Is it the religion of Abraham, Issac and Jacob? Hashem no longer with you Solution all 3 Abrahamic religions should live peacefully,otherwise prophecy of Jesus will be fulfilled.Moses, Jesus and Muhammed SM all are connected with Hashem whatever one calls Him He is only ONE.

I love 402 comment, he's right on the money

Based on all the adds this is an authentic Jewish video.

109 and counting

Top ten horror hotel in the idiot area .

Finally a normal, relistic, historic documentary/semi-tutorial on the talmud. Thank you.

Bamboozle. Truth sandwiched between fiction. "What is truth"?

9:20 messianic b.s what christian Jews !? there was no christianty back then at that time 70 ad ! fake history

🔴🔴🔴 The Talmud also says many evil things even lies about Yeshua The Moshiach/Christos and slanderous and false accusations against His mother

hominids....

Pre nup for Marraige? It's always about money isn't it?

Jesus is God the only son of the living God .🙏🇺🇸

בורא זהו כוח השפעה ואהבה ולא דמות חומרית, הוא צריך לשרות בינינו. זה נקרא שחרור (מהאגו), יציאת מצרים. כוח החיבור פועל מעל לכל הגבולות. אנחנו נרגיש את העולם שקוף, כאחד שלם, כל אחד ירגיש מחובר עם כולם ובתוכנו - הבורא!

nothing fails like prayer

Very lucid video. As a Catholic, it baffles me how the Jewish people have managed to forge on with their beliefs despite the perennial mistreatment they've endured...unless you consider the strength of their faith!