How are Humans Chosen in PMD? 

The concept of a human turning into a Pokémon is surprisingly not utilized as much as I’d hope it would be. Sure, turning into a cute Starter Pokémon is cool and all, but Imagine having a game with the Pokémon equivalent of Ben 10’s Omnitrix.

"So if you ever find yourself transfered to the world of pokemon" Me: Well come on now dont get my hopes up ;-;

Honestly, Explorers Of Sky is my favorite game of all time since I got it as my first game ever. I've played through the whole game one time, and it was totally worth playing through again. I am currently playing as a Shinx with a Riolu as my partner. Despite being female, IRL, I wanted to play as a Shinx because I thought it would be fun. And oh boy, has it been fun. I still have my original copy from when I was a kid, which is the copy I am playing right now. The Shinx and Riolu combo has been really nice to play with. I can't wait until I reach the end of the game to go through Destiny Tower. Anyway, my experience with these games has always been awesome. I love these games and will continue to play them.

Someone I think would be a really good PMD plot would be...well...spoilers for Scarlet and Violet: the character has...odd memories. What they recall are human memories, but they seem to be observing them rather than experiencing them directly. There's a very important person they're with, and though they're with that person (and exclusively that person for some reason...), their memories also seem to be filtered through them. As such, everything seems *new* to them, every experience like something they're unfamiliar with. ...the AI it's the AI they got turned into a Pokemon and can go on adventures of their own now I just really want them to be happy and I feel like that would be a really good storyline for them.

Really hope that, if there's a new Mystery Dungeon game in the future, they'll do more with the idea of multiple humans being brought into the Pokémon world. Sounds pretty interesting.

A PMD theory? Let's gooooooo Btw, I love GtI's take on this; you are not "the chosen one", but you still end up being the last one standing. It is obvious that if it weren't for the paradise gang you would've ended like the other humans. That makes the bond with the other characters even stronger. Also if this 13:18 is true, you can actually explain why GtI didn't include the personality test: the council / voice of life didn't even have time to interview you lol

I really hope the next game explains the human world more and lets the protsgonist travel back and forth, rather than remaining a pokemin forever. Explorers REALLY confused me about where humans were located.

Its stuff like that makes me wish people would pull from the 3ds games a bit more over tunnel visioning explorors, perhaps pulling from rescue team now and again. Sure, Explorors might have the deeper and more tastefully written story, But i genuinely had zero clue that the otherwise fannon concept of, "humans get brought here kinda a lot", was not only a plot point, but that they literally murderd people in gates. Like, actually WTF?

This is such a cool theory! I agree with the idea that the personality quiz may also double as an interview to make sure the human is ready or has the right potential, although you can’t actually fail it. This also furthers as a possible explanation for why gates didn’t have a quiz, as they were rapidly selecting humans until one succeeded. They were running out of time. I also had a theory that before the hero from red/blue rescue loses their memories there was even more quizzes or tests, and the one that we see is just the end one to determine which Pokemon they become. But that’s just really my headcanon for it! :D

This is the first video I see from you, and OMG your avatar is so adorable! Very pretty design!

The explorer series explains the reason why you became a pokemon, is because the time tunnel was damaged as you were stepping through it. In other words, the something went wrong and your existence within the timeline was rewritten to be a pokemon instead of a human.

The question i'd like answered is if the spirits those humans that were defeated by muna's gang are going back to their respective bodies or if they're like actually dead, like you die in the pokemon world you die in the human world. bit of a morbid question but I can see how intense it would make the moment tho

Also remember that in gates to infinity you didn't get a quiz to determine your pokemon, you just picked from a selection of 5, which could also show just how urgent that situation was. As for explorers, maybe you got chosen by celebi to help grovyle stop dialga from going insane, and you got connected to the voice of life after the time rift split up. And for super mystery dungeon it could be the same thing with mew, or maybe the voice of life figured that a human would be more suited for fighting against dark matter, and you only become a pokemon because your identity needed to be hidden so the pokemon possessed by dark matter couldn't find you

Honestly, never been a big mystery dungeon fan. The gameplay never clicked. However, the concept has always been so intriguing, and I hope they go more in depth whenever there’s a new game. Glad to see some of my questions answered and all. Great video as usual! Keep up the great work.

I love Pokémon mystery dungeon, even though I never played the game I like it a lot

Regarding Time/Dark/Sky, personally, I just assumed that the Human was sent into the Dark Future to aid Grovyle for one reason or another, my headcanon being they were an expert trainer/strategist and would've been able to aid Grovyle/Celebi on a tactics level (after all, it was your idea to gather the time gears in the past to stop the future, that is before you get amnesia). Thus, they didn't need to be a Pokemon because they were mostly planning battles, their role assigned to them was not meant for participating in battles. After all, when Darkrai was struck down by Palkia in a similar manner to us/the protag was at the end of Sky, they didn't turn into another Pokemon (in fact, they can be encountered post-game as an amnesiac who doesn't remember the player, and can even be recruited, so the only commonality is amnesia from such an attack.) The only reason I see for the human being turned into a Pokemon by this attack is likely divine intervention by Arceus, who knew you could still be of use and simply made you a temporary body, one that would be more... inconspicuous in a world inhabited by Pokemon (after all, the only pokemon left in the future were Dusknoir, Grovyle, Celebi, Dialga, and a bunch of feral Pokemon. So they didnt need to exactly hide their humanity, whereas a human would stick out like a sore thumb in Treasure Town and be quickly found by Dusknoir). Speaking of Arceus, I am 100% convinced he/it is the one to send the protag to the Dark Future and assigned them their role. As for *why* Arceus did this? No idea, but again, my headcanon was that the protag's personality, before and after amnesia, would have a personality/aura that was similar enough to Grovyle's to where the two would become close allies and friends. After all, you need to trust each other to work together. So, to summarize: The Dark Sky Human (just a name I give them because it sounds cool) was an unknown human from an unknown world who's personality, aura, and intelligence were suitable for the mission Arceus had. As for why Arceus doesn't just intervene himself...idk... point being, they were a human in the future and were only turned into a Pokemon after essentially being killed and given a second chance by Arceus. As for why they stay a Pokemon, and aren't sent back to their human world, well, they're a living paradox. Their human body, what little of it would've remained after being attacked, was erased from time. This likely affected their human past as well. Its my headcanon that if Arceus sent them back to their human world, it would be a world where they were never born (because again, wiped from existence/time). So, to avoid that awkward moment, revived them in a world where they had friends and were regarded as a hero, instead of sending them back to a world where their own parents wouldn't recognize them.. tl;dr God liked you, the player, enough and thought you'd get along with Grovyle. They saw you get killed/seriously wounded by Darkrai and decided it was better for you to finish your job as a Pokemon, where you can actually defend yourself. They spare you from time erasure, but you have no world to go back to, so you crash at your friends house in the mean time.

For a one-off anime special, Team Go-Getters Out of the Gate did some pretty masterful foreshadowing. When Team Go-Getters help Team Meanies with their Oran Berry and Gengar wants to know why, former-human Squirtle tells him that they’re brothers, that they’re both Pokémon. How crazy is it that the protagonist ex-human says this to the ex-human of prophecy?

I always found the lore of Mystery Dungeon to be utterly fascinating and sadly never explored. I already typed a long ass comment, so instead, I'll just make a bulletpoint of the stuff I find the most fascinating: - Where did the humans go? They existed in the world at some point, judging by all the dilapidated structures, most notably in Red/DX - What is the Council & The Agents of Spirit? - Just what was the event that caused the birth of The Bittercold? - Just how many humans have been in the world of Pokemon, how many have failed? - Why are humans so OP when placed into the body of a Pokemon? They can resist the Bittercold, resist Dark Matter, and can go from the strength of a Caterpie to the strength of LEGENDARIES, within like, a week, a month tops? Red/Blue defeats the continent forming Groudon and is able to fight Rayquaza to a standstill. Sky can fight the embodiment of TIME to a standstill. - Why do the partners get so much stronger when in the presence of a human? Besides Super, the partner is an ordinary Pokemon. - How are humans chosen (like this video asks) - What happened to the humans that failed in Gates? Are they dead for good? When TVoL started yoinking humans, did they all come from the same world, or even timeline? What about their worlds, would they still have families to go back to? - If The Council does exist, why doesnt it get involved in future entires? Why did they let TVoL start grabbing humans who werent up to the task? Perhaps they were disbanded by this point, or Red is the last in the series chronologically? - Are all the humans children, or are they turned into young pokemon? In Super, they seem to be treated like a child out-right, but in Red, Sky and Gates, they're given the responsibility of their own home, or even a town. And in the case of Sky, they work for an actual guild, the closest thing to a company in that world. So either kids are given more responsibility, or only Super is canonically a child. Etc etc. I could go on forever, I wish we got expanded content regarding this stuff, but then I guess it would rob the Mystery from the Mystery Dungeon?

Idk why I'm subscribed to this channel but I'm gonna binge watch some of your videos now! How are you so underrated??

If you could pick any village or area in the Mystery Dungeon series to live or be summoned to, what would it be?

Thank you for covering the Voice of Life! Hydreigon is a character I muse a great deal about so I wanted to share one of my own observations. In the post game when he is explaining how to help the Hero return to the Pokemon World, there's a piece of dialogue from Hydreigon that goes like this: "I communicated with the Voices of Life from various lands. I gathered a great deal of information." in a similar line of thought to your pointing out that Gardevoir uses the word 'we' when discussing who chose that human, I think this is worth studying... This could imply that Hydreigon has to relegate his physical form to be concentrated in a single area... thus at that moment his inherent information only comes locally-- this could explain why the greater world of Gates wasn't mentioned during the threat of the Bittercold-- because Hydreigon can only obtain certain info close by (like that of the routes of dungeons to return to paradise) when in his physical form. It could maybe explain how he so quickly tracked down Emolga, Dunsparce, Virizion, Espeon, and Umbreon after being shattered by Kyurem... or, much more interestingly, it could imply the existence of MULTIPLE voices of life relegated to specific areas whilst one region's vocal collection is in its physical form, so there could even be multiple beings like Hydreigon with the same goals and ideas in mind running around I would easily say he just gathered info from Pokemon across the land, but the term was capitalized in game, so... I figured it would be neat to drop here! I loved the video!!

Personally I’d like to see a game where the human became a Pokemon due to a dusknoirs involvement Like the signal it got told it that your soul needs to go somewhere other than where it usually goes

Here's the sad thing, the last Pokemon Mystery Dungeon game released was back in 2014/2015 and hasn't had another Pokemon Mystery Dungeon video game release since (except the remake of Pokemon Red and Blue but that's more of a remake, not a NEW installment in the franchise)...Either way, I do hope they bring it back at some point, whether on the NIntendo Switch or Nintendo's new console and such.

I haven't played Rescue Team in forever, I completely forgot about Gardevoir being the one who brought you here. Haven't played GTI either, so that was new. I find it interesting that Legendary Pokémon don't step in to at least bring Humans in. Maybe most aren't capable of it, but we know Dialga probably is. After all, he undid you being erased in the ending of EoS. I always considered it a reactionary thing from the world itself, or even a byproduct of disasters, but the idea that there's an entire COUNCIL is very interesting. I'll have to keep that in mind, it'd be very interesting in a PMD&D Campaign. Awesome video!

pleasantly surprised by the quality of the video! So cute

Okay SPOILERS FOR ALL 4 GAMES HERE: The only games where I would say the player was a “chosen one” would be rescue team and GTI. Gardevoir and Hydreigon seem to kind of fill a similar role being a spiritual guide to the player and they seem to imply that the player was chosen in some way by them and others as they both use “we” observed you and chose you in those conversations. It’s been awhile since I’ve replayed the games but I feel like I remember both of them saying the player also consented to it. If not then I know for sure that the Super protagonist did. Again further proves my case that the Explorers protagonist definitely had it the worst since they came from a dystopian future, did not consent, and then literally got erased from existence. The GTI protagonist definitely had a loving family that missed them and while I’m inconclusive on RT, I can say that it definitely seems like the both got to choose to come back and that there is some dimension travel from the human as the Pokémon mention humans being “fairy tales”. Whereas in EOS and Super, the human player worked with Pokémon at some point. This might just be me filling in blanks but the protagonists of both Explorers and Super were not really chosen because they already had prior involvement to the story (the explorers player having been working with Grovyle to save the future and the super player having already fought dark matter with the partner in the past). A bit of a side tangent, Grovyle mentions some sort of council which seems to mean that there were other Pokémon and possibly humans in the bad future coming to an agreement that it needed to be prevented. Interesting that nobody ever talks about that. I am so tempted to make a comic for EOS that adds onto the story by elaborating on lore like that.

Going on an adventure in mystery dungeon may not be as fun as it sounds. Based on what games I've played in the series, they seem to have a slightly darker and more mature theme to them. The villains don't challenge you with the intent of making you faint, or winning some prize money. They're trying to straight up kill you, as they seek to bring about the apocalypse.

Wake up, everyone! It's Nekolacey NTuesday! ...Yeah, that alliteration does not work. Explorers is funny, somehow there's just a human in the future even though there's no other human anywhere else in the game. Very interesting, though I haven't played PMD1 or Gates, so I have nothing to add.

Man why should I do my math homework due next period rn this is more important

13:28 so its completedly random to become a pokemon, good to know

I expect this info to be sufficient to finally go into the pokemon world. And yes I WILL judge you AND your channel on that alone.

awesome video!! :)

I love your avatar so much!!! Also I really hope we get more mystery dungeons… they were the best Pokémon games ngl. And what if they made it a group of humans that turned into Pokémon. And they all lost their memory! I think that would be fun, but maybe easy since you start off with a group instead of 2 pokemon on your team

A mystery& question that I still have about this franchise is: where did the human from Explorer’s future come from? What I mean is, in all other MD games except the originals, humans are either extinct in this world or even a myth. So how was a human not brought from our realm already living there? Where did he come from?

The RT protagonist was given the choice. He wanted to be tested if hes really the one.

Let's suppose that that this theory is true, what happens if the main villain of a pmd game is the one to bring you to the pokemon world?

thats right, wii.....

Cool video there😎👍

Must. Resist. Fanfiction impulses.

Here me out: Multiplayer