Тёмный

How Denmark Destroyed Greenland: Brief History of Denmark's Colonialism in Greenland 

Fredda
Подписаться 86 тыс.
Просмотров 103 тыс.
50% 1

Denmark has an often neglected and quite dark history of colonialism. A history which hangs as a shadow over many communities in the world, sometimes even as living memory.
Denmark has committed many atrocities towards the people of Greenland, this is a brief history of some of them. Even so, this video only scratches the surface of the many indignities suffered by the Greenlandic people at the hands of Danish colonial policy.
This video deals with distressing topics, the link below provides hotlines for many countries should you be in need:
www.findahelpline.com
- Bibliography:
M. Birkhold, “A Brief History of the Indignities Heaped Upon Greenland”, NY Times, 22. Aug. 2019.
N. Busch, “No End in Sight: The Continuing Menace of Nuclear Proliferation”, (2004)
S. Christensen, “There Was No Bomb.” DIIS. (2019)
Danish PM’s Office, “Historisk Udredning om de 22 Grønlandske Børn, Der Blev Sendt til Danmark i 1951” 15. Nov. 2020.
T. Folger, “Why Did Greenland’s Vikings Vanish?” Smithsonianmag.com, March, 2017
D. Goldschmidt, “Grønlændernes Selvstendiggørelse. Grøndlandsk Autonomi eller Dansk Herredømme” (1991)
J. Helliwell, et. al., “World Happiness Report 2013”, World Happiness Report, (2013)
R. Hersher, “The Arctic Suicides: It’s Not The Dark That Kills You”, NPR (2016)
T. John, “How a failed social experiment in Denmark separated Inuit children from their families.” CNN, 14. Jan. 2022.
H. Kristensen, “Secrecy on a Sliding Scale: U.S. Nuclear Weapons Deployments and Danish Non-Nuclear Policy.” Nautilus Institute, 20. Oct. 1999.
P. Langgaard, "Modernization and Traditional Interpersonal Relations in a Small Greenlandic Community: A Case Study From Southern Greenland.” in Arctic Anthropology Vol. 23, Nos. 1 & 2. (1986)
H. Laursen, “Kvinner fra Grønland saksøker den danske staten”, NRK, 3. Oct. 2023
M. Leone, J. Knauf, “Historical Archeologies of Capitalism” (2015)
Macrotrends “Denmark Suicide Rate 2000-2023”, (2023), macrotrends.net
M. Naum, Et. Al. “Scandinavian Colonialism and the Rise of Modernity” (2013)
I. Seidler, et. al. “Time trends and geographical patterns in suicide among Greenland inuit”, (2023), BMC Psychiatry 23, Article Number 187
Statistics Greenland, “Deaths”, (2021), stat.gl
A. Sørensen, “Denmark-Greenland in the Twentieth Century” (2007)
A. Sørensen, “Grøndlands Historie” Darnmarkshistorien.dk, 25. May, 2020.
- Music:
Nuuk Drum Dancers
Artwork used for the thumbnail by Tyler Jacobson:
www.tylerjacob...
#history #greenland #denmark
----------------------------------------------------------
Second Channel ► / @fredda-gaming
Twitter ► / punishedfredda
Patreon ► / fredda
Twitch ► / fredda_
Community Discord ► / discord
----------------------------------------------------------

Опубликовано:

 

20 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1 тыс.   
@tora9915
@tora9915 10 месяцев назад
RU-vid glitch is telling me this has 2.7 million likes before the premiere. The global proletarian masses rally around their historian 🫡🫡🫡
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
Not a glitch that's real
@tora9915
@tora9915 10 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYTOf course chairman Fredda, as always your words bring truth to this clouded matter 🫡🫡🫡
@Carlo_von_Habsburg
@Carlo_von_Habsburg 10 месяцев назад
🫡🫡🫡
@SumeriyaYaxlaka
@SumeriyaYaxlaka 3 месяца назад
🫡🫡🫡
@BLANK-kq8wv
@BLANK-kq8wv 10 месяцев назад
this is serious I WON'T be gooning for this
@uisce_
@uisce_ 10 месяцев назад
The comment from the future wth
@BLANK-kq8wv
@BLANK-kq8wv 10 месяцев назад
@@uisce_ i'm gooning now
@Stoneworks
@Stoneworks 10 месяцев назад
You can tell this channel has a good community from this one
@uisce_
@uisce_ 10 месяцев назад
@@BLANK-kq8wv hhhhooooooooooollyyyyyyyyy
@pivomanslovensko
@pivomanslovensko 10 месяцев назад
​@@StoneworksYour videos are wicked ❤
@hochimeme4432
@hochimeme4432 10 месяцев назад
As an Australian, it’s scary how familiar this all sounds to how we treated and continue to treat our indigenous population.
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
Last time I checked the danes didn't have to make government-funded ads to prevent the inuits from sleeping on the road.
@nicholasmwangangi6257
@nicholasmwangangi6257 10 месяцев назад
@@bosertheropode5443 The aboriginals dind ask to be colonised, genocided and have their land stolen from them
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
@@nicholasmwangangi6257 Their land wasn't stolen, it was conquered. Since they were still stuck in the paleolithic period when the british landed there a couple centuries I'd say they got it relatively easy. Not saying that the australians are blameless, but Australia was built and turned into a country by europeans, not at all by aborigines.
@boopy3919
@boopy3919 10 месяцев назад
​@@bosertheropode5443this is such a backwards way of thinking -- why is it that you draw a difference between Inuits & Aboriginal peoples? Both groups went through horrific colonisation and forced loss of culture.
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
@@boopy3919 And for both groups, especially the aborigines, their colonization was and is a net positive for them in the end. Do you have any idea how rampant infanticide and cannibalism was in pre colonial Australia?
@I_am_somebody_1234
@I_am_somebody_1234 10 месяцев назад
its sad to know just how easily a colonial power can dismantle an entire society, and therefore how widespread this problem is. This is the tragedy of the New World, the erradication of the cultures of native societies and their forced assimilation. Greenland is a great example of a wider problem, which streches from the Inuit communities of Canada and Greenland all the way to the Mapuches down in Chile and everywhere in between...
@ishredder4006
@ishredder4006 10 месяцев назад
to Africa as well as Asia, it's very sad.
@S3lkie-Gutz
@S3lkie-Gutz 10 месяцев назад
This video reminds me of the s*icide epidemic on Canadian indigenous reservations it was awful, this is how deep the extent of the damage is caused by colonialism. We're still struggling to get our politicians to take responsibility and take decolonial action and a lot of white non-indigenous Canadians deny it ever happened either openly or insidiously behind closed doors. inuqutivut sungagijauvut suraksimallutiglu, mamisalaaqtuksauvugut :(
@mysampson284
@mysampson284 10 месяцев назад
​@21stcentury-schizoid-dude you can apologize all you want, but they will still hate you for being White.
@bestuan
@bestuan 10 месяцев назад
israel
@ishredder4006
@ishredder4006 10 месяцев назад
@@bestuan isntrael
@EyeoftheU
@EyeoftheU 10 месяцев назад
My grandmother was a Greenlander (she grew up in a small coal mining town that no longer exists today), and very proud of it. She was an educated teacher, and so was her Danish husband, my grandfather. My grandmother was educated in Denmark, but her and my grandfather lived, worked their profession, and raised their family in Greenland for some years. Problem was, as my grandmother was a native Greenlander, she received a notably lower salary than my grandfather, even though their job was by all means the same. This eventually prompted them to move to Denmark, were they would receive the same pay. (I wouldn't be surprised if their move was motivated by other factors too, but that was the one reason I was given.) My grandmother would never talk all that much about it herself, but from the few bits she told me and from the more comprehensive picture I got from talking with my relatives, I get the impression that this experience of being discriminated against in her own country was something that fundamentally bothered for all of her life.
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes 10 месяцев назад
"At this time Greenland was inhabited by the Dorset and Thule people". Kind of conflates the two. When Erik the Red arrived in Greenland the Thule culture would have been developing around Northern Alaska, arriving into Greenland by ~the 1200s. You do show a diagram that explains this, but it doesn't match the narration really because "at this time" would have to mean during the entire history of the settlement and not when settlers initially arrived as your phrasing suggests. Not that big of a deal since they aren't the focus I guess, but I do remember hearing that the time of arrival of the Thule people may have marked a change in viking interaction in the settlements. I also just find the pre-columbian history of cultures in the arctic circle really fascinating so.
@someguy7723
@someguy7723 10 месяцев назад
The thule people are invaders and genocided the first people of Greenland. The came arond 1300, and is NOT native
@isar1612
@isar1612 10 месяцев назад
Just wanted to clarify a few things. The Thule people were not present in southern Greenland when the Norse arrived there, it was empty land. the Saqqaq people had gone extinct in southern Greenland in 800BC and the Thule people migrated over from Nunavut in Canada and down from northern Greenland around 300 years after the Norse had been settled in southern Greenland. The expedition from Iceland to Greenland was likely not mercantile in nature or intent, rather Erik the Red being exiled. It's historical negationism to assert that the Norse had landed on Inuit inhabited land and disrupted their settlement, as they landed on empty land that Thule Inuit migrated to 300 years later that Norse were living on. Not to mention the Thule people wiped out the Dorset people living in northern Greenland when they migrated over in the 12th century, before hitting southern Greenland and the Norse settlements around the 15th century. The Dorset were not present in southern Greenland ever. This is all historically and archeologically verifiable and I implore you to research the things I've mentioned.
@raultoichoa1574
@raultoichoa1574 10 месяцев назад
Or you could just give us your sources, considering you've already done the research and it would make it 100x easier for interested people to verify your claims.
@isar1612
@isar1612 10 месяцев назад
​@@raultoichoa1574 No problem! Here you go. The first people arrived in Greenland from the Canadian island of Ellesmere, around 2500 to 2000 BCE, from where they colonized north Greenland as the Independence I culture and south Greenland as the Saqqaq culture. The Early Dorset replaced these early Greenlanders around 700 BCE, and themselves lived on the island until c. 1 CE. These people were unrelated to the Inuit. Save for a Late Dorset recolonisation of northeast Greenland c. 700 CE, the island was then uninhabited until the Norse arrived in the 980s. Between 1000 and 1400, the Thule, ancestors of the Inuit, replaced the Dorset in Arctic Canada, and then moved into central and southern Greenland from the north around 1300. The Norse disappeared from southern Greenland in the 15th century, and although Scandinavians revisited the island in the 16th and 17th centuries, they did not resettle until 1721. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3116382/ www.researchgate.net/publication/254939336_The_Prehistory_of_Inuit_in_Northeast_Greenland www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/cambridge-history-of-the-polar-regions/norse-settlement-of-greenland/374AA6805C6C4580A7E019224E354F25#
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
"The expedition from Iceland to Greenland was likely not mercantile in nature or intent, rather Erik the Red being exiled." This is an absurd thing to say, Erik the Red didn't arrive and then all migration to Greenland stopped hence. If you believe all Norse settlement on Greenland was motivated by Erik the Red's banishment, then please take that up with the archeologists I cited. I never claimed either the Thule or Dorset were present in southern Greenland the moment Norse first landed in Greenland, what are you talking about. I claimed both were present on Greenland when the Norse arrived. The source I cited said the Thule people were present in Greenland when the Norse arrived, the Norse did not just arrive once and then no Norse ever arrived hence, that's not how any of this works.
@isar1612
@isar1612 10 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYT There was absolutely a mercantile aspect later on and there was mobility across the north sea including to Greenland that is absolutely true, but the INITIAL intent was due to exile. "I never claimed either the Thule or Dorset were present in southern Greenland the moment Norse first landed in Greenland, what are you talking about. I claimed both were present on Greenland when the Norse arrived." The Thule culture was not present in Greenland at the time the Norse landed and only the far northwest corner of Greenland was inhabited by the Dorset people, who would later be displaced by the Thule culture, the ancestors of the modern Inuit. The Dorset never moved south to get anywhere even remotely close to the Norse settlements, and it wasn't until 300 years later that the Thule culture would come in contact to the Norse, whose settlements they would run into while coming down from the north. The Thule people were actually not at all related to the Dorset peoples, using ancient DNA samples "It was found that the Thule people probably descended from the Birnirk culture of Siberia, and that they were genetically very different from the indigenous Dorset people of northern Canada and Greenland, whom they culturally and genetically completely replaced around 1300 AD." Greenland has a complex and multi-faceted history of human settlement and these groups cannot be lumped together. It's much more clear cut later when the Danes arrive, but early Greenlandic history is more complex.
@themeerkat5157
@themeerkat5157 9 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYT ratio
@atypicalprogrammer5777
@atypicalprogrammer5777 10 месяцев назад
As a child in Denmark, my grandfather read a comedic children's story, about a Danish missionary in Greenland to me and my siblings -- I think it was called "vejledning i sælfangst" (how to catch a seal) or something like that. I thought it was really fun back then, but now, I realise how deeply racist it was, portraying the Inuits as childish or stupid. One story was about how all the villagers tried to sell the main character sleigh-dogs so that he could hunt seals, and when he explained he did not intend to hunt seals they said he needed to do that, to feed his sleigh-dogs. Another story involved the local priest turning up drunk to a sermon. To be fair, it was a comedy, and some of the jokes were made at the main character's expense, so maybe I am reading too much into it, but it was clearly playing into the stereotypes of the time.
@FischerNilsA
@FischerNilsA 10 месяцев назад
Even rather recent childrens books still carry that colonial paternalist view. Michael Ende - whom I thoroughly adore - and who was a really progressive liberal thinker in most things, was not above using "childlike native" or "noble savages" tropes in his works. Or Lindgreen - also a deeply emacipatory author of high standing - making the father of Pippi Langstump a white sailor who got to be "king of a negro island tribe". Those authors where formed by their time, and racism is even today usually not recognize by those who espouse it.
@thgeremilrivera-thorsen9556
@thgeremilrivera-thorsen9556 10 месяцев назад
It was written by the later actor Flemming Jensen about his own experiences as a school teacher in Greenland. It's been a long time since I read it and I wasn't very good at spotting colonial mindsets back then, but the way I perceived it, he was poking way more fun at the Danish visitor clumsily trying to adjust to Greenland culture, than the culture itself. But maybe a re-read may change my mind about that...
@OscarOSullivan
@OscarOSullivan 10 месяцев назад
John Fowles had many years of unpublished diaries when they were published it turned out he was writing disparaging remarks about his publisher and other writers like Edna O’ Brien
@jahinsadman1505
@jahinsadman1505 10 месяцев назад
negerboller
@masterofthesun138
@masterofthesun138 10 месяцев назад
that seal hunting, sled dog thing is actually pretty funny
@thepeasantsofdithmarschen3507
@thepeasantsofdithmarschen3507 10 месяцев назад
After watching Knowing Better’s videos on the oppression of American Indians I’ve been thinking about how a lot of these problems explained exist and still are perpetuated to this day for so many native cultures. The worst of it to me is how they’re always looked at with pity for their current situation as if not much can be done, rather than with support. Ya know, that is if they get noticed at all. Its good to see videos like this giving light to the issues for those in their own bubble
@FischerNilsA
@FischerNilsA 10 месяцев назад
What is weird to me is how that the examples of those colonial opressions that have since largely been ceased - like the clearing of the scottish highlands - are now considered barbaric practices of long.dead time. While those still going strong or at least reverbating in living memory - canadian and australian boarding school systems, US reservation legislation, han chinese supression of conquered minorities like the uygurs or tibetan peoples - are still at least downplayed or outright justified with the same arguments colonialists have always used. Current conflicts _(cough, middle east, cough)_ can also be viewed under that perspective.
@wile123456
@wile123456 10 месяцев назад
Greenland future is hopeful because they have a chance at full independence, and their land wasn't really comepltly stolen, there wasn't mass migration to the place by Danes, and many Danish families there start to see themselves more as greenlandic than Danish. They just drafted an idea for a constitution recently, completely in their native language, where they had to invent a lot of new vocabulary for all the legal phrases that were usually done in Danish. It's slso very modern and progressive, having gay rights and more in it, unlike Denmark where human rights are attached later and not properly enshrined
@ColoringAHouse
@ColoringAHouse 10 месяцев назад
​@@wile123456is "independence" all you guys think about nowadays?
@makslargu5799
@makslargu5799 10 месяцев назад
@@wile123456​land can be stolen without mass migration, there wasn’t mass migration to most European colonies in Africa either, and many aftikaaners also saw themselves as more southafrican than Dutch - it sadly doesn’t mean the impacts of colonialism were less. I’m sure most Dutch people would not want to move to a rural island where the cost of living is so expensive - just like most Americans wouldn’t choose to move to Alaska, it doesn’t mean the Dutch/ Americans don’t benefit from the huge amount of wealth generated from those lands or the exploitation of the indigenous peoples. Independence hardly seems like restitution when Greenland has been contaminated with plutonium particulates.
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
​@@wile123456Mass migration you say, interesting, wonder where that happens rn
@DefinitelyACircle
@DefinitelyACircle 10 месяцев назад
As a greenlandic person I would just like to say Its all in the past I'm not starving, I'm not sick, and I dont give a single shit aslong as I'm not apart of murica!
@DefinitelyACircle
@DefinitelyACircle 10 месяцев назад
Ngl having medical bills in greenland would probably double the suicides.
@BONKSHLOB
@BONKSHLOB 9 месяцев назад
​@@DefinitelyACirclelol😄
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 9 месяцев назад
😃😃😃
@GuyShōtō
@GuyShōtō 9 месяцев назад
@@DefinitelyACircle American states can establish their own state-owned healthcare, example Medi-Cal. Most Americans when polled don't opt for a Federal system due to the high taxes required to fund it. Also a large percentage of Americans are insured via the businesses they work for.
@DefinitelyACircle
@DefinitelyACircle 9 месяцев назад
@@GuyShōtō I would rather kms than be in america
@i____amakiwi
@i____amakiwi 10 месяцев назад
The recent IUD case is tragic and I hope that Greenland can recover from its dire state. Amazing video!
@wile123456
@wile123456 10 месяцев назад
Sad thing it isn't recent. It was public knowledge and openly discussed in parlament. The only recent thing is the media in Denmark shining a light on it.
@i____amakiwi
@i____amakiwi 10 месяцев назад
@wile123456 I meant 'recent' in terms of the investigation but yes, it absolutely is sad that these women have been forced into silence for so long
@tesso.6193
@tesso.6193 10 месяцев назад
You know, if true it could be be considered an act of genocide. Taking measures to restrict births within a group is an act of genocide.
@SergioGomez-eg7wr
@SergioGomez-eg7wr 10 месяцев назад
Most of the indigenous people that puritans shared land with were largely sedentary farmers, relying most heavily on agricultural production of maize and squash occurring in small villages. just like Europeans 😇 they may have moved seasonally, but generally on the eastern seaboard we see a higher degree of sedentary living styles. They maybe would be best described as “semi sedentary” and tbh if I could do that, moving north and south with the seasons, I definitely would 😭
@SergioGomez-eg7wr
@SergioGomez-eg7wr 10 месяцев назад
And interestingly enough! When the going got tough, further south for the colony of Roanoke, the European settlers did join a semi nomadic group :$
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
Yeah I think the professor's characterization of the colonization of the Americas was a little off, but he was just trying to make a point in a live interview I think.
@SergioGomez-eg7wr
@SergioGomez-eg7wr 10 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYT yes for sure! Sorry I just wanted to add that, didn’t mean to be pedantic :) Beautiful video I loved it ! Thank you for sharing
@LOL-zu1zr
@LOL-zu1zr 9 месяцев назад
But but moving around means you are barbaric😢
@shzarmai
@shzarmai 5 месяцев назад
​@@FreddaYT yeah; this reminds of Anti-Roma discrimination, Swedification and Norwegianization of the Sami en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegianization_of_the_S%C3%A1mi
@carnivalgames1
@carnivalgames1 10 месяцев назад
I wanna start out by saying that I generally enjoy your videos, and that includes this one. It is very well presented and thoroughly researched, and for the most part it seems balanced and nuanced despite talking about a very politicized subject. I really liked for instance that you included the IUD/spiral case despite it still being an ongoing investigation! It really is atrocious that something like that could happen in the 1960's! I'm personally very interested in finding out what the investigation is leading to, and at what political level it was decided. It is so scary that people only 60 years ago could in anyway find that a reasonable solution! Even today you still hear some politician talk about "whether Greenland is mature enough" for this and that. But since your channel is also so much about debunking pseudo-research and biases I fell like I need to add some comments on some missing pieces thatI think constitute a selection bias: I know you've titled the video "How Denmark Destroyed Greenland: a brief history of Denmark's Colonialism in Greenland" but I think it is a little lacking that the video doesn't cover anything about the steps in forming the modern greenlandic state. Like the creation of the 2 landsraad in 1908 and how Greenland officially changed from being a colony to a county in 1953, as well as the home-rule act of 1979. I feel like decolonization is a big part of the history of colonialization. You manage to tell a full story about Greenland, without mentioning any Inuit by name or talking about Greenlandic achievements or having any Greenlandic sources or accounts, so I think you should be aware of how euro-centric your sources are. I can't help but feel that you in this well-researched highlighting of Danish colonialism have been too set on fulfilling the narrative in the title ("How Denmark Destroyed Greenland") and have failed to assess Norway's involvement (which is your native country I'm guessing?). Perhaps because it makes the overarching narrative clearer when there is no change of colonizer state? or perhaps because it plays into a greater narrative in Norway about Denmark being dominant and abusive in the union of the two kingdoms. Either way I seem to notice a quite severe selection bias. This bias is the most apparent in section 2. "Denmark Returns". Denmark most certainly had not been in Greenland before, so it doesn't make sense to say that they returned in 1721. Hans Egede was a Norwegian priest and he decided to explore Greenland to find and convert the Norse settlers, which the Norwegian had claimed as subjects back in the 13th century. In other words: the Norwegians returned. So "the Danish crown considered Greenland to be one of it's dependencies" is simply wrong when the context is 1721. Greenland was a Norwegian crown dependency until 1814, and you also didn't mention, that Hans Egedes company was called the Bergen Greenland Company in the beginning before it got replaced by the general trade company. Mentioning that Norway invaded and occupied a large portion of Eastern Greenland in 1931-1933 as Erik the Red's Land because they thought they still had an inherent claim would also have been an interesting addition, showing just how little value was given to the Greenlandic people at the time in Norway and how foreign the thought of Greenlandic self-determination was in the 1930's. The UN however, dismissed the Norwegian claims as you probably know, based on statements from the two Greenlandic Landsraad (the predecessors of the modern greenlandic parliament). This is a turning point for Greenlandic self-determination, since it to my knowledge is the first time Greenland's own inhabitants voices were counted as influential in a major decision. Sidenote: The closing of villages that you by extension are referring to as "Danish colonialism" has also happened during and with approval of home-ruling Greenland. It is furthermore still a very active topic in Greenland sermitsiaq.ag/node/224741 among politicians.
@idonnow2
@idonnow2 10 месяцев назад
Wow thank you very much for this much needed context. I have been interested in the history of colonialism in Greenland for a while, i did find it odd that there was no mention of the movement for Greenlandic self determination which has quite a long history by now, but i actually had no clue about the involvement of Norway.
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
I literally did mention it.
@andreasnicolaisen1618
@andreasnicolaisen1618 10 месяцев назад
Great comment, had many of the same thoughts. A lot of missing information regarding the topic, and a general bias towards telling how Denmark singlehandedly destroyed Greenland
@lucyandecember2843
@lucyandecember2843 10 месяцев назад
o.o
@_greenrunner_
@_greenrunner_ 10 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYTmention what exactly? you have to be clear cause you missed a lot of detail for clicks
@AnkfordPlays
@AnkfordPlays 10 месяцев назад
17:00 this is interesting because my best friend was bullied precisely because he only spoke Danish well despite having a Greenlandic father. His situation was pretty much reversed
@spookysenpai7642
@spookysenpai7642 10 месяцев назад
What are your thoughts on the Sami people considering that they were/are victims of discrimination in Northern Europe as the Inuits are?
@nathangillingham5734
@nathangillingham5734 10 месяцев назад
cultural genocide bad
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
I'm Sámi by descent, though my part of the country saw pretty aggressive Norwegianization and so any sort of Sámi culture was pretty much wiped out in my family generations ago. The results of the injustices on the Greenlandic Inuit in the present are far worse than those presently visited upon the Sámi, but the Sámi are still continually oppressed and their interests made secondary to those of Scandinavian states. Both peoples have been subject to Scandinavian colonialism, and both are victims of ethnic cleansing campaigns.
@nathangillingham5734
@nathangillingham5734 10 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYT I feel the same can be said for all Inuit. Canadian Inuit experience similar challenges with high suicide rates, food shortages, loss of culture/lifestyle, intergenerational trauma, etc.
@Chewy_GarageBandDad
@Chewy_GarageBandDad 10 месяцев назад
@@nathangillingham5734It is the same in the US. Our governments suffer no "inconveniences" such as truth.
@Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation
@Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation 10 месяцев назад
* looks around innocently in Swedish *
@CHagnM
@CHagnM 10 месяцев назад
As a dane living in Greenland (in the "worst" part of the country), I'm very excited for this episode. Either it go "Danes bad, indepenence go braaa" or it is, as i hope, a varied take on a complex subject. But knowing your work, it's gonna be great.
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
The Danish state definitely is the villain of this story, but it's not a simple as saying independence now. Denmark made Greenland a colonial subject with all that entails, and part of that is making Greenland entirely dependent on Denmark. While Greenlandic independence is something that should be pursued, Denmark has a serious responsibility to facilitate that on Greenlandic terms, not on Danish terms.
@olo4704
@olo4704 10 месяцев назад
But like we are bad in the situation, and have done and keep doing horrendous stuff while dehumanizing them. The ways and reasons for our actions might be complex, but we did it to further our economic and geopolitical standing in the world, not for the good of anyone in Greenland.
@CHagnM
@CHagnM 10 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYT Was sure the Danish state, would be the villain, in a video called "How Denmark Destroyed Greenland" :) - and I'm looking forward to watch the video, as I said, your work is great, and I'm sure you did you research. But alot of the moden problems here in Greenland are hard to find out about, f.ex the internal racisme between East og West. The central govenment in Nuuk don't even acknowledge the language here on the eastcoast they call it "A dialekt" and the kids in out schools are not yet allowed (by the govenment in Nuuk) to use it in and offecial setting (Schools, books, meetings ect) - Here in the east, many people hate the people on the wastcoast more then Denmark, because Denmark was never "a problem" here, like the central govenment in Nuuk has been. And I love this place an it's people, all I want is what's best for Greenland, and it's not for me to decide, what the "best" is. Qujanar for the response, means the world.
@CHagnM
@CHagnM 10 месяцев назад
@@olo4704 But that's the thing, saying "to further our economic and geopolitical standing" is making a complex thing way to simple - a lot of good was done by Denmark, to help, it almost always went wrong, but you can't say, nothing good was done, for the good of the people. Otherwise, this would be a very different place to live (Plumming, housing, schools, food, hospitals ect.) The stat did some horrendous stuff yes, very true, but not only horrendous stuff. An a lot of danes (not the stat) are trying to do good here. But I do agree, the Danish state done fucked up waaaay to frequent, an still do, no excuses.
@villesohlberg4973
@villesohlberg4973 10 месяцев назад
@@CHagnM Danes are still bad tho. Sincerely a Swede.
@jacquesoff2726
@jacquesoff2726 9 месяцев назад
are you planning on making a video about the treatment of sámi in scandinavia and finland? like denmark's colonialism, i feel like that it is a topic not often talked about. thank you for making this video by the way.
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 9 месяцев назад
Some day yes
@jacquesoff2726
@jacquesoff2726 9 месяцев назад
@@FreddaYT glad to hear
@morriskaller3549
@morriskaller3549 6 месяцев назад
​@@FreddaYT Great idea
@redacted9280
@redacted9280 10 месяцев назад
Its really disgusting how many of these issues regarding arctic communities are often chalked up to being a result of the "cold isolated and miserable environment where it is dark for half the year", despite people living in said environment for thousands of years perfectly fine. These issues are a result of colonialism in recent centuries. Its also annoying how people will often say that danes are actually more indigenous to greenland than the inuit because they were technically in the region before the inuit despite the fact that the norse greenlanders weren't even danish and left the region likely before the inuit arrived.
@MrTheWaterbear
@MrTheWaterbear 10 месяцев назад
Did they though? Have you not read a single story of Inuit folklore and mythology? That’s some of the darkest shit you will ever read, terrifying and dark stories. Not that alcohol and alienation helped, that’s true.
@mysampson284
@mysampson284 10 месяцев назад
It's not the white man's fault
@christophermurphree2315
@christophermurphree2315 10 месяцев назад
In Greenland there is good reason to believe that both play a factor. Suicidality can be determened from three main factors. Alchoholism, Distance from equator, and access to lethal weaponry. Greenland is already one of the most prone contries, but that dosen't mean that any one of these reasons should be ignored. Colonialism has been traced to causing alcoholism in a vast amount of cultures, and Greenland is no exception. Lastly colonialism would still be bad even if it had no consequence on sucidality, so i see no harm in examining the multiplitous causes of the subject.
@ffff7164
@ffff7164 10 месяцев назад
If you move to the middle of the sahara desert and dies of thirst, whose fault its it?
@alexanderl.6207
@alexanderl.6207 10 месяцев назад
@@mysampson284no its the danes fault
@WretchedRedoran
@WretchedRedoran 10 месяцев назад
I think it is important to note that during the initial period of Norse settlement in Greenland, there weren't yet any proto-Inuit in the regions the Norse settled, and the Dorset were quite a distance from the places of Norse settlement in Greenland.
@seantolson6223
@seantolson6223 10 месяцев назад
It’s also wrong to consider the modern Inuit as being the same as the Dorset people whom the Norse traded with. There is almost no relation between the Dorset and the Proto-Inuit, and the former were probably either wiped out by the latter or died en masse during the little ice age.
@SophiaAstatine
@SophiaAstatine 10 месяцев назад
I'm not sure how much it matters for today.
@WretchedRedoran
@WretchedRedoran 10 месяцев назад
@@SophiaAstatine You're right, that's actually the point, the Norse settling of Greenland doesn't actually matter very much to the situation in Greenland today, however I felt the video implied otherwise.
@SophiaAstatine
@SophiaAstatine 10 месяцев назад
@@WretchedRedoran The more important point should be to make things better if anything and for Denmark to treat the people of Greenland like equals rather than dependents. Especially if it in turn can help remedy the divisions that exist within Greenland itself.
@WretchedRedoran
@WretchedRedoran 10 месяцев назад
@@SophiaAstatine The video already addresses that, and I don't mean to take away from that point either. I just mean to provide a clearer picture on the topic the video starts on.
@skipperbent6654
@skipperbent6654 9 месяцев назад
Im from Greenland and this video is cherry picking which parts of the truth of portrays, and in at least one case it is factually wrong. The Norse arrived on uninhabited lands to the South. The Inuit arrived there from the North centuries later. The video criticises how Denmark shut down villages and moved people to cities for economic reasons. But it does not try to understand or explain how difficult it is to provide education, health care, postal service, psychologists etc. to small villages spread out over thousands of miles of arctic conditions with no infrastructure. The video constantly shows Denmark as doing misdeeds for economic exploitation, but Greenland is a money drain for Denmark. Half of Greenlands GDP comes from Danish substitutes payed for by Danish taxpayers. Denmark is not innocent, and some actions in the past where racist, misguided or simply foolish. But try to compare Greenlands colonial history with virtually any other colonial history, and I think it is fair to say that we were the lucky ones. We need to take our lives into our own hands instead of playing victims and blaming Denmark for everything.
@24jh42
@24jh42 10 месяцев назад
In Denmark the suicide rate was 2-3 times higher in the 1970's, and by 1980 increased to 4-5 times what it is today. Some initiatives caused that rate to plummet. Took more than a generation, but it is duable. So there is nitpicking in the data shown. The economy of the Danish colony of Greenland was a blatant failaure. Apart from the few years where cities in europe burned blubber (fat from seals or whales) as a light source at night, the Greenlandic colony consistently cost the Danish state money. Sending Greenlanders to Denmark for education is viewed with modern eyes a despicable thing to do, but it still happens today because the population of Greenland is tiny. It can not justify having universities or teaching facilities locally. So if greenlanders does not go to Denmark for learning for free, Greenland would need to pay some other nation for this education. Which required them to learn an additional language besides Greenlandic and Danish.
@banditten78
@banditten78 9 месяцев назад
I guess you haven’t heard about the home rule, Greenland can take over several areas to control themselves, so start with going through the list of areas that is controlled by Inatsisartut at the moment and which they can just take but doesn’t want too www.retsinformation.dk/eli/retsinfo/2023/9001 www.retsinformation.dk/eli/lta/2009/473 The list of areas already being govern in Greenland www.stm.dk/media/12119/gr-oversigt-over-sagsomraader.pdf Furthermore Greenland can tomorrow take a vote on leaving the Kingdom of Denmark - chapter 8 par. 21 www.retsinformation.dk/eli/lta/2009/473
@theculturedjinni
@theculturedjinni 10 месяцев назад
I will look forward to this. It is also fun that I can actually read the sources you are using.
@andreasnicolaisen1618
@andreasnicolaisen1618 10 месяцев назад
Many of the arguments are tilted in a biased fashion. The danes didn’t bring alcohol to Greenland to make them addicted and thereby getting cheap labour. The danes actually heavily regulated alcohol all the way until 1954, with the harshness decreasing the years before. Further, the danish government payed danes in Greenland more than the greenlanders because labours with certain skills were needed, and these weren’t readily available in Greenland. So to incentivise danish craftmen to move from Denmark to Greenland, they were payed handsomely. Even more than danes in Denmark. So it wasn’t because of racism, it was just a good old supply and demand problem. Im not trying to argue that he is lying throughout the entire video, but I am encouraging you to not just flat out believe everything he is saying whitout doing some research of your own. A norwegian being mad about Greenland not being theirs can’t be trusted ;) (joke)
@domerame5913
@domerame5913 10 месяцев назад
it's a tankie community trying to fud social democracy it seems. youtube algorithm doing what it does best
@theonlydkdreng
@theonlydkdreng 10 месяцев назад
The problem of lacked of skilled/specialised labour continues to this day. I know a legal practioneer ("jurist" in danish) who went to greenland for some time, because the conditions were relatively handsome, for the first job after completing law school. They ended up not staying for more than some years, because an opportunity to work in something they wanted to specialize in, presented itself in Denmark. Likewise with the lack of doctors and other health professionals.
@banditten78
@banditten78 9 месяцев назад
@@theonlydkdreng and sad enough this like school and social system is under Greenlandic sovereignty, they have taken those areas home - home rule
@andreasmagnussengriis6539
@andreasmagnussengriis6539 4 месяца назад
A few things too add: 1. I love the video, but the forceful closure of Greenlandic cities and removal of their homes is a series of major tragic events too. 2. The fatherless law, that made it so Danish men who got Greenlandic women pregnant was “not their father” and “owed them nothing.” Is also a tragic part of the tale. 3. A contributing factor to the suicide rate is also Denmark forced the Greenlanders to no longer be migratory but stationary. With areas that do not get sunlight for months doing the winter, this is of course not healthy. Men, women, and children today live most of their lives in areas that do not see the sun, where normally they would have migrated South. A few corrections: 1. The Thule people had not settled there yet when the Northmen arrived, only the Dorset. The Thule people did not reach Greenland before the 1200-1300 hundreds, and vocal tales in Greenland and Nunavut tells the story of the Thule people driving out the Dorset who had lived in Greenland from 700 bc. There are no physical or written records of these actions, only the oral tales from local Inuit. 2. “The Norse came for a specific purpose; they came looking for resources to export.” As far as we know, they came to avoid being under the Scandinavian Kings, and to avoid paying tax. Also to stay alive, as Eric himself had been exiled from Iceland. While resource and export certainly were a part of the motivation, “Only for the resources” Is not historical. 3. It is still unclear whether the IUD campaign was due to fear of a population increase. Time will hopefully tell.
@Sorenzo
@Sorenzo 10 месяцев назад
As a Dane who has known and admired some of my Greenlandic fellow citizens, I do feel awful about the social engineering of colonial times. I get the impression that we don't have any policies towards that goal in the modern day, but we are aware that Greenlanders have a lot of challenges that aren't easy to meet. Quite a lot of resources are spent on the welfare of Greenlanders, but it's not exactly easy to attract doctors or psychologists to live on a glacier, and the moment anyone suggests we just pay them more, you'll have some petty-minded folks asking why "some people" should get more funding than others. I also do know that there are racist attitudes in some quarters - I don't know if this is a general anti-"immigrant" racism or specific to Greenlanders, but I honestly get the sense that most Danes respect Greenlanders and think their traditions should be preserved. But, you know... Racists are gonna racist.
@thedanishsocialmonarchist7286
@thedanishsocialmonarchist7286 10 месяцев назад
I also support giving more money to Greenland and its people i found Them cool but i must also admit i have another reason pride and the fear Of lossing the last lands thats not our cores Denmark as lost land after land and war after war We only have Greenland and the faroe islands left If giveing Them more money to improve there Living standards and keep Them happy in our kingdom i say do it
@thedanishsocialmonarchist7286
@thedanishsocialmonarchist7286 10 месяцев назад
@@YehWNoU so We shuold just let Greenland go free and stop giving Them money
@kakyoin9688
@kakyoin9688 10 месяцев назад
@@YehWNoUit literally will? Your gonna lose the last bit of empire if you don’t change
@hedgehog3180
@hedgehog3180 10 месяцев назад
There absolutely is specific racism aimed at Greenlanders but it isn't as prevalent anymore as it was just 10-20 years ago, a lot of this is due to the BLM movement which ended up leading mostly to a focus on Greenland in Denmark. However on the other hand I remember when I was a child seeing DR children's television making explicitly racist jokes about Greenlanders so that also shows just how recently things were still pretty bad.
@Gnomgnash
@Gnomgnash 10 месяцев назад
Yeah, as a Dane I also think should be helping Greenland more. But right now it just seems pretty hard as Greenland wants to rule themselves and Denmark doesn't want to help to the point that they could selfsustain and leave the kingdom. Greenlanders in poles have admitted that the majority would leave Denmark if it didn't mean quality of life would faulter, and in that sense I kind of get why the state and a lot of danes don't want to invest more, why put money into a place that will just leave? In that sense, it's kind of hard to get any political incentive to help Greenland out.
@Milk-jy1kn
@Milk-jy1kn 10 месяцев назад
Such a beautiful video Fredda. Thank you for this. As a Puerto Rican it sounds almost the same as our experience with American colonization; word for word, the rapid urbanization, the forcible adoption of another language, the eradication of local traditions, the forced sterilization of women, ubiquitous substance abuse, etc. How touching and sad at the same time the empathy and understanding that colonized peoples have for each other.
@AL-lh2ht
@AL-lh2ht 10 месяцев назад
Oh was Puerto Rico has it so bad that they are literally the richest per capita Latin America region on the planet.
@Milk-jy1kn
@Milk-jy1kn 10 месяцев назад
@@AL-lh2ht you googled that one pretty quick didnt you? I bet you didnt even know shit about puerto rico before you read my comment. Dont speak on shit you dont know anything about.
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
​@@Milk-jy1knIt's telling how you didn't say he is wrong.
@Milk-jy1kn
@Milk-jy1kn 10 месяцев назад
@@bosertheropode5443 he is wrong, the numbers on those graphs are a gross misrepresentation of the precarity people live through.
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
@@Milk-jy1kn Compared to proper US states they are quite poor of course, but for carribean standards it really isn't bad.
@gameking50P
@gameking50P 8 месяцев назад
It's crazy how different countries implemented similar methods of colonialism all over the world which leads to similar results for indigenous people all over the world
@ludi0us
@ludi0us 10 месяцев назад
i remember watching a documentary in danish on greenlanders struggle with school and one of the interviewees literally killed themselves between the first and second interview, it was heartbreaking
@PenguinEconomics-st2ws
@PenguinEconomics-st2ws 10 месяцев назад
This is important history that is often ignored in order to lionise the exploits of western nations. I'm English and I can confirm the horrible crimes of the British Empire were never brought up outside of a module on slavery. Thank you for making this video. I really hope one day the Greenlandic people will be allowed to self-determine. Same for the indingenous people of the Americas and Hawaii.
@PlatinumAltaria
@PlatinumAltaria 10 месяцев назад
We learn more about ancient Egypt than colonial Nigeria, and that is not ok.
@AL-lh2ht
@AL-lh2ht 10 месяцев назад
Greenland voted to stay. Greenlands have the right to leave pretty much at any time and have extreme autonomy.
@PlatinumAltaria
@PlatinumAltaria 10 месяцев назад
@@AL-lh2ht They literally voted against staying.
@jerrystusrapworkshop5483
@jerrystusrapworkshop5483 10 месяцев назад
​@@AL-lh2htI highly doubt the people of Greenland would vote yes to stay in conditions so bad they would rather commit suicide
@mysampson284
@mysampson284 10 месяцев назад
@@PlatinumAltaria that seems pretty ok to me. I don't want to learn about a contienent that hates me and my race.
@wile123456
@wile123456 10 месяцев назад
22:26 correction, this is not "allegedly" we know it for a fact. The government and politicians spoke OPENLY about these concerns in the parliament in the 60's and 70's. It was no secret, it was not taboo, it was plain politics.
@maus439
@maus439 10 месяцев назад
I like your videos. You should keep making them imo
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
Thank you so much, I will
@Gropylol
@Gropylol 10 месяцев назад
As a dane, we ofc reflect badly on this period of time, but it is was mild compared to other colonial powers.
@EyeoftheU
@EyeoftheU 10 месяцев назад
I sidste ende er det lidt som at bede om en præmie for at være den "mindst værste koloniherre".
@TheAlkochef
@TheAlkochef 4 месяца назад
@@EyeoftheU hørt. det kan ikke forsvares. ikke at forglemme vest indien
@Taurmin
@Taurmin 9 месяцев назад
You start off by saying that the Dorset culture were the ancestors of modern Inuits, and then almost immediately contradict yourself by saying that no link has ever been found between the two cultures...
@yaaaboi1456
@yaaaboi1456 10 месяцев назад
æ hadde virkelig likkt en liggnende video om fornorskningsprosesen. keep up the great work
@IshayuG
@IshayuG Месяц назад
I know 5 people from Greenland, and the impression I got from all of them is not that we're oppressing them, but rather that they think Greenland is dreary and without much opportunity. That's not the fault of the Danes. There simply aren't enough people there to build a university and things like that. I am always told that the weather is depressing, very few live there, and the jobs aren't that great. This is not surprising at all and is a result of the land itself, not Danes. Discrimination does happen though, but they all say it wasn't that bad.
@nattygsbord
@nattygsbord Месяц назад
Greenland is a place with large amounts of natural resources. And countries with much economic muscles could help to extract those resources and bring that place out of poverty. But Denmark has not got the economic resources to do that. It should then just step aside to help Greenland, but little Denmark rather cling ons to whatever little global influence it could get, like deciding over the resource extraction in the artic, deciding over trade routes for ships there, and deciding over military matters, and offering USA the ability to fly over Greenland to drop atomic bombs over russia in exchange for giving favors to Denmark in return. Denmark has never been a succesful colonial power. Iceland was driven into poverty by Denmark. The rule over Norway was mixed with Danish plundering of the country with Danish help to Norway to expand its mining industry. So Norwegian nationalists complaints about Danish rule are exaggerated, but some of them holds a little merit. It was however much more succesful to create colonies and to keep them than Sweden, but that was perhaps more a blessing than a curse that Sweden never really got involved into the slave trade and the historical guilt that comes with that. And nor are there any shameful histories of colonial opression either. Denmark did wisely sell off its colonies in the Baltics during the middle ages, and later on they sold its colony in India to Britain after it became impossible to do much with it. And the colony in the west Indies was an unnusual economic success story compared to all failed Swedish colonies. However its profitability fell when new ways of producing sugar was invented, and there no longer was any need for that island. And then it was sold off to USA. And Denmarks colony in west africa never really found any profitable crop it could produce after slavery became forbidden, so Denmark got rid of it later on. In the end did the main flaw of the Danish empire never got solved in its thousand year history. The empire sucked at assimilating its territories. There really was no glue keeping all its areas togheter. It was an old useless feudal state like the Austro-Hungrian empire in that regard. All its many territories had nothing in common with each other not the same language, not the same laws, not the same economic model, not the same culture, not the same anything except religion. It lost its Baltic provinces when the empire became over-stretched. And the area was not enough assimilated to wanna belong to Denmark anyways. It also lost control over England and France. It lost Sweden when it left the Kalmar union - which I think was almost inevitable to happen given that Danish control over Sweden was never strong. It later on also lost Norway in the 1800's. And despite all silly Putin style claims by Danish nationalists that all Norwegians are Danes with an odd dialect, just like all Ukrainians are really russians - Do I on the contrary think that Norway always was its own country. It was only tied to Denmark through a tradition of royal marriage, where the Danish King traditionally also would inherit the throne of Norway. Its remarkable that this union managed to hold for as long as it did. Denmark also had a problem with keeping Schleswig and Holstein. Danish nationalists followed their burning passion in their hearts instead of using their brains and realizing the hopeless situation of fighting Germany and provocing it into war with unreasonable demands. Denmark tried to make people into Danes by force in Germany, Iceland and Greenland... but it didn't work out. And the weak royal power, in Denmark was a big road bloc that prevented the Danish state from ever becoming strong and centralized to be able to solve problems when nobles opposed every such iniative. However not all blame could be put on them. I think it noticable how extremely little interest Danish Kings took in all the provinces he owned. For 1000 years did not a single Danish King for example set his foot on Iceland, which I think is extremly nonchalant and even arrogant towards the Icelandic subjects of the empire. This island was poor, sparesely populated and distant, however it provided Denmark with hunting falcons that Danish Kings could use as diplomatic gifts to mighty world leaders, and Iceland produced much sulphur for gunpowder for the Danish military. I think one can compare this all to Swedish Kings who regulary visited even the poorest and unpopulated regions of Sweden, like Finland that only had 20% as many people as Sweden back in the 1500s. Travelling by boat was much easier than travelling on land back in those days, so Finland was very distant from Stockholm. But Gustavus Adolphus would spend much time listening to common Finnish people and their complaints on corrupt and power abusing local rulers and punish them and replace them. For that reason is Gustavus one very loved Swedish King in Finland. In the end did Denmark also lose control over Iceland and Greenland. And those areas was really never Danish to begin with either. They were founded by Norwegian vikings, had norwegian culture, and remained part of Norway until the union between Denmark and Norway ended, and Denmark took those islands after the divorce. My words on Denmark has been harsh in this long speech. But in the end did little Denmark achieve an impressive empire, especially during the viking age. Had Denmark had not suffered from the shaky political crisis and murders during the 1300s and 1400s do I think that the country could have taken another path and became centralized, and the Kings would hold much power and not the nobles. And provinces could have become assimilated and Danish. And Denmark would then likely have succesfully have conquered Sweden, Finland, northern Germany and the Baltics and colonialized the world. However its flawed construct made it almost certain that the empire would get eaten up by Sweden and other powers in the future.
@DanieleCapellini
@DanieleCapellini 10 месяцев назад
are you Kurdish
@charolastrasoy
@charolastrasoy 10 месяцев назад
Fredda never replied..
@cordedwaif
@cordedwaif 10 месяцев назад
Exactly what a kurd would do…
@soni3608
@soni3608 10 месяцев назад
Fredda has become a proud citizen of Rojava
@elmo8524
@elmo8524 10 месяцев назад
Fredda will never beat the Kurdish allegations
@spaghettiisyummy.3623
@spaghettiisyummy.3623 10 месяцев назад
Free Kurdistan?
@samsu1437
@samsu1437 Месяц назад
Unsure on if you will see this comment but I appreciate videos like this, highlighting the clear colonialism and oppression that many groups have faced and by countries that so many seek to glorify in some regard I'd love for there to be a possible video on the Sapmi people in this same vein as I'd love to get some more knowledge on the struggles that many do face and bringing awareness to this struggle Another video idea I'd love if you ever considered would be on the English treatment of the Celtic peoples in Scotland and Wales, I cannot say that it comes close to the levels of deprevaty that the Danish government had put upon the Greenlanders as this video demonstrated but I think it could serve a purpose of highlighting this sort of treatment and colonial tendencies within our own backyard, that's only a suggestion and I could probably understand you not doing that form of video as you seem to specialise in Scandinavian and Norse writings but do hope at least for something on the Sapmi people since they've suffered quite poorly considering they're between 4 differing nations Amazing video though, I love watching content from you and especially videos like this that highlight the lesser known issues that even persist today, hope to see even more videos in this style even though quite upsetting, always good to spread the word
@taiwanisacountry
@taiwanisacountry 4 месяца назад
Hello I am Danish, I am a sinologist, with minor in Greenland and arctic studies for my bachelor and for masters I wrote about suicide. What we have done to Greenland is absolutely horrific, it is inexcusable and it was absolutely terirbly. The way Greenland is run today is also shitty. Now about the rate of suicide in Greenland. There are many factors at play, multiple of my teachers were Greenland experts who speaks and teach kalaallisut.(Greenlandic) They all had different takes on the situation on the question of "why". If we use my theory that I presented in my thesis, then in shrot term "lost the capacity to aspire" in short. And then we need to discuess the ability to do it. What do you need to do to end yourself? This is why America in general got a higher rate than in other developed countries because they have access to firearms. Anybody who have been on Greenland are familiar with how easy it is to end yourself. Go outside in the winter. That is actually a real altruistic way of ending yourself if you are "a burden" on your community, within inuit cultures in Canada, and formerly on Greenland. Anyway it is a complicated topic and I know that a majority of people in Greenland are in favour of the Danish rule over Greenland, for now until they are able to trust themselves.
@TheQeltar
@TheQeltar Месяц назад
"@taiwanisacountry" lmao
@christophermurphree2315
@christophermurphree2315 10 месяцев назад
The three most apparent causes for suicide are access to lethal weapons, distance from the equator, and alcoholism. I one can often draw a direct parallel between alcoholism and transnational colonialism, with a few notable exceptions. But I don’t think that one should underestimate the natural conditions as well. Days without sun or without “night” can really mess up one’s quality of life. Another statistic worth noting is that Greenland has a spike in suicidality between the ages of 15-24, with rates decreasing after that unlike everywhere else in the world. Indicating something unique about Greenland.
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 10 месяцев назад
Yes unique or, maybe the Greenlanders are "just" part of a colonial power who quite often cleanse out their own...(every time the state is broke) and, have become quite "smart" using new methods" every time...😰 I wonder if Denmark is using MK-Ultra in Greenland every time as we now see done (committed) within Denmark!?!? I don't know but, I do know they've clearly "educated" the Danish "suicide"-method within the EU during the past 20 years...😱 I have shadowed "teacher" - Danish Mr. Vedsted-Hansen and his 2 colleagues on their way around Europe, teaching the Danish method!! From the very same Vedsted-Hansen family who was part of the horrible subjects who started the Holocaust 😰😰😰
@eVill420
@eVill420 9 месяцев назад
I'm finnish and the days without night are the absolute best
@d.g4466
@d.g4466 4 месяца назад
As a Canadian I feel this very similar to our history with the First Nations and Inuit people.
@theoheinrich529
@theoheinrich529 10 месяцев назад
live freddacel reaction to the effects of colonialism:
@bruhroof
@bruhroof 10 месяцев назад
You have sources included in time with what you talk about! My respect!
@kimdani1795
@kimdani1795 9 месяцев назад
i wonder if you also think like suicide it is Denmarks fault Greenland also have 10 x cases with paedophaeli towrds children??
@Robert-xx8jx
@Robert-xx8jx Месяц назад
Is that true?
@nightingaleblades5493
@nightingaleblades5493 10 месяцев назад
I really appreciate the discussion of material extraction’s role in Greenland and it’s people’s exploitation, and with projections of rare earth mining projects becoming prevalent in the next few decades the pattern looks to be continuing.
@AL-lh2ht
@AL-lh2ht 10 месяцев назад
You mean Greenlanders wanting to profit it for themselves. You…do know they voted to stay themselves right? And that they could leave pretty much any time.
@MrTheWaterbear
@MrTheWaterbear 10 месяцев назад
Just a hit of awareness: Greenland has full autonomy over its mining and fishing industries, apart from having to pay Danish taxes and follow EU legislation on those industries. Their privatization of their fishing industry created a massive monopoly in which 3 Greenlandic families own all industry and pay pathetically poor wages compared to other Nordic countries. Turns out an Inuit can be just as much of a capitalist bastard as a European. This would only get worse if they separated from Denmark, which is why that idea always gets rejected by Greenlanders every time they consider voting on it. I suppose their alternative is being stuck with America or Russia as partners, which would be an utter disaster for the country.
@joaquinvideo2959
@joaquinvideo2959 10 месяцев назад
​@@MrTheWaterbearIs this autonomous Greenland being led by the Inuit tho?
@MrPhilipleif
@MrPhilipleif 10 месяцев назад
​@@joaquinvideo2959 It's ruled by a Greenlandic parliament, that to my knowledge isn't directly influenced by the Danish one, and is of course only voted in by citizens of Greenland
@joaquinvideo2959
@joaquinvideo2959 10 месяцев назад
@@MrPhilipleifYes, but that Greenlandic parliament could be ruled by the colonizers who live in greenland
@robertortiz-wilson1588
@robertortiz-wilson1588 8 месяцев назад
Explain how the they caused illiteracy when they weren't literate to begin with.
@martinkrog5943
@martinkrog5943 6 дней назад
Thanks for the vid : ) Skål
@rachelhyatt5766
@rachelhyatt5766 10 месяцев назад
It’s terrible what colonialism caused in Greenland 😢
@AmongUs-sy5ct
@AmongUs-sy5ct 10 месяцев назад
I mean your saying colonialism is bad because you are letting emotion get to you but consider all the innovations colonialism bring. I mean yeah some people died but we all die
@AL-lh2ht
@AL-lh2ht 10 месяцев назад
Greenlanders have it pretty good. Massive welfare state, half the economy is free money from Denmark. Extreme well educatedz
@badabing3391
@badabing3391 10 месяцев назад
@@AL-lh2ht if that mattered greenland wouldnt have such a high suicide rate.
@bosertheropode5443
@bosertheropode5443 10 месяцев назад
​@@badabing3391A lot of it has to do with the lack of Sunlight during the winter months.
@memesarekeem
@memesarekeem 10 месяцев назад
@@AmongUs-sy5ct Innovation which was not requested nor asked for; you speak from a Eurocentric "saviour" point of view. The Inuit had their own traditions, culture, and societies, all of which were self-sustaining up until the arrival of the Danish, where now almost all of these have been eradicated and what remains is unhappy. The Inuit are unable to enjoy the same luxury from innovation as the Danish, for the Danish frequently kept them FROM benefitting from it. Even in the modern era, the Danish shut down villages and force them to assimilate with larger cities. Innovation can only be called as such when it helps.
@stephenkramer7157
@stephenkramer7157 4 месяца назад
1:22 I believe the dominant view is that the Dorset People were unrelated to the modern Inuits, who replaced the Dorsets as they migrated into and across the American arctic from Siberia from about 2000-1000 BCE. Moreover, Dorset and early Inuit colonization of Greenland was limited to the north of the island--the Norse Grœnlanders were the first human inhabitants of the SOUTHERN Greenland until they themselves were replaced by the Inuit.
@AlbanianDogma
@AlbanianDogma 10 месяцев назад
Thank you for your excellent content as usual. This video was particularly relevant for me as I recently attended a conference from a Greenlandic scholar relating her biological work to the issues of Greenlandic indigenousness in the context of being a colony of Denmark. Her talk focused on Greenlandic diet, and how historically and contemporary Danish government and university officials have been implicitly shunning traditional Greenlandic forms of food acquisition and preparation. Sorry for the long comment, thank you again for your content :)
@JPMartinson
@JPMartinson 10 месяцев назад
Qujanaq suliannut (Thank you for your work)!
@williammacdonald9905
@williammacdonald9905 8 месяцев назад
The only reason we have a modern industrialized world is because of Europe. Your thinking that this is a "problem" is objectively false. Greenland does not attribute its issues to colonialism that ended in 2009, that is ridiculous. "Peter Bjerregaard from Denmark’s National Institute of Public Health has noted that while Greenland’s suicide problem began in 1970, almost all the deaths involved people born after 1950-the same year that Greenland began its transformation from remote colony to welfare state, as the Danes resettled residents to give them modern services and tuberculosis inoculations. Hicks, the Canadian researcher, said the correlation is present in other Inuit societies as well. “It happened first in Alaska, then Greenland, and finally in Canada’s Eastern Arctic,” he told me. “It’s not the people who were coerced into the communities as adults who began to exhibit elevated rates of suicidal behavior-it was their children, the first generation to grow up in the towns.” It was a lack of assimilation that was the issue. You directly blaming this on Danes and their exportation of modern society is quite ridiculous.
@chrisgaming9567
@chrisgaming9567 6 месяцев назад
I stopped taking this comment seriously at the "colonialism ended in 2009" part
@Natsymir
@Natsymir 9 месяцев назад
I don't think its entirely fair to say that the Greenlandic Norse where there only for resource extraction - their colonies lasted for more than 300 years, with the vast majority of them never ever travelling back to Europe. They were born and died on Greenland. Put that in some perspective: 300 years, thats far, far, far longer than most modern American families have been in the US. To people born in the Norse settlements of Greenland in the 14th century, it must have felt like they'd been there forever, like it was their home. Long lines of their ancestors would have been born on that soil, and never had a sense that they had taken it from someone else - back when they arrived, there - was - no one else. The Thule people mostly lived to the far north. Until the Inuits came from the west centuries later, interactions might have been very limited. It's true indeed that they unwillingness to fully adapt might have played a part in their societies ultimate fall, but there is also evidence that they did -some- adapting - for example an increased relience on maritime food sources. What I'm saying is that the Greenlandic Norse is a famous case of a society that failed, described brilliantly in Jared Diamond's book "Collapse" among others. Why they failed is still an open question, but it does them a disservice to imply that they were only greedy colonists. Greenland did become their home, and they endured for an exceptionally long time.
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 9 месяцев назад
Take it up with the experts I sourced, also I do not put much stock in Jared Diamond's theses
@mooreanonumbers
@mooreanonumbers 10 месяцев назад
13:55 Worth noting the Thule air base was built after the forced displacement of 130 people, around 0.5% of Greenland's population at the time
@BSideWasTaken
@BSideWasTaken 10 месяцев назад
The take away I choose to have from this video is that because of people like Atsa Schmidt and Anda Poulsen, humanity is generally good and worth saving.
@thisrandomdude2880
@thisrandomdude2880 10 месяцев назад
I was making lunch while listening to this video. I happened to finish plating at the very end. When you thanked us for watching, and only the singing of the drum dance remained in the background, I started uncontrollably sobbing. Thank you for making this video. I often try to tough it out, for if I were to cry for all oppressed and marginalised peoples of this earth, I would never stop. Nevertheless, shedding a few tears for them from time to time helps me from feeling alienated from my own humanity.
@bomba1905
@bomba1905 10 месяцев назад
Bu- but muh wholesome Nordic welfare state 😢
@A-A_P
@A-A_P 5 месяцев назад
As far as I know, it was (even up to) more like eugenics, systemic racism and unequality decades past it being a fad in e.g. Germany (the treatment of Samis in Scandinavia comes to mind)
@berjoxhn5142
@berjoxhn5142 4 месяца назад
@@A-A_P that's false, the Nordic countries never really championed behind the Germans Nordic superiority thing
@avinashreji60
@avinashreji60 3 месяца назад
@@berjoxhn5142Sweden created the State Institute for Racial Biology
@Friend2Trolls
@Friend2Trolls 10 месяцев назад
Looking at the channel, it's interesting to see how this was a gaming channel for a majority of its existence, but in the past year, it's all been about history. Not saying this is a bad change. Just looking at view counts, I can see why the pivot was made. But I am curious if he'll return to gaming content, or if he'll keep up the history?
@upnorth1511
@upnorth1511 10 месяцев назад
Greetings from Greenland. Great content.
@EvilTwin8888
@EvilTwin8888 9 месяцев назад
I really dislike the narrativization of this video. Calling the viking settlements norse colonization is just wrong by any normal definition as no people where colonized and as far as we know the vikings came to settle and survive rather than exploit and profit. Living conditions in both Iceland and Greenland are difficult so them moving after discovering South Greenland in summer makes total sense. Saying that the motives of the settlements where mercantile is not wrong in the sense that it was for ressources, but the video seem to imply some sort of malicious markeddriven logic at play rather than a simple calculation of a better life given the ressources. Why put the history of vikings in greenland in this politized light? It is just setup for the actual colonization anyway. I am less familiar with the facts of the actual colonization, but I am aware that it was bad. but I have hard time trusting the presentation of the rest of the video given the early narrativization.
@thepakistanipotato
@thepakistanipotato 9 месяцев назад
did you watch the rest of the video?
@EvilTwin8888
@EvilTwin8888 9 месяцев назад
@@thepakistanipotato Yes, and I dont trust it.
@MohammedAli-hl4mr
@MohammedAli-hl4mr 7 месяцев назад
​@@EvilTwin8888colonisation isn't the same as conquest. So your lack of trust in this video comes from ignorance
@EvilTwin8888
@EvilTwin8888 7 месяцев назад
​@@MohammedAli-hl4mr Colonization: is the action or process of settling among and establishing control over the indigenous people of an area. This is the modern laymans understanding and it implies much. The video needs to explain if it uses the word in a different way.
@MohammedAli-hl4mr
@MohammedAli-hl4mr 7 месяцев назад
@@EvilTwin8888 words like colony, colonization and colonialism mean many different things, there is settler colonialism, building a colony, and conquest of a people for the purpose of keeping them as a captive market to use in a mercantilist economy. the confusion you had was because you apparently couldn't figure out that settling in a region is colonization and that for something to count as colonization there doesn't need to be anyone conquered and subjugated. you thus inferred some nefarious intent in the video through ignorance which you excuse by saying "modern layman's understanding" which it just isn't, you just don't understand much about the subject and invent conspiracy to fill in the gaps and explain away your lack of knowledge on this particular subject without having to acknowledge that the majority of people in this comment section didn't have the same difficulty in understanding something which was pretty clear.
@LetsGoGetThem
@LetsGoGetThem 9 месяцев назад
Excellent, you hinted at this in the past with denouncing the treatment of Samis in Norway in your Whatifalthist video, would love to see a video like this against your own country's treatment of Samis. I know that internationally that is even less known than the Danish crimes against the Greenlanders.
@hedgehog3180
@hedgehog3180 10 месяцев назад
This is a pretty good but definitely brief history of Greenland, the relationship between Denmark and Greenland is quite a bit more complex and there's also a lot of ongoing issues. There's a DR series about Greenland which despite being made by DR which has to avoid being perceived as partisan does do a pretty good job like for example highlighting the fact that in 1957 Denmark essentially lied to the Greenlandic government and said Greenland could either become part of Denmark or independent even though there was a third option of becoming independent with compensation.
@Oldass_Deadass_dumbass_channel
@Oldass_Deadass_dumbass_channel 10 месяцев назад
This is serious, I WILL be gooning for this
@Arms.Enthusiast
@Arms.Enthusiast 9 месяцев назад
The concentration of people from the villages into the urban municipalities reminds me of the closing of outport communities in Newfoundland in the mid to late 19th century, the latter also lead to a lot of negative outcomes for individuals.
@byronritchie5449
@byronritchie5449 10 месяцев назад
What the Danish government did to the Greenlandic kids unfortunately reminds me of what my own nation of Australia has done to aboriginal kids
@hedgehog3180
@hedgehog3180 10 месяцев назад
People in Denmark recognize the similarity too so it goes both ways, I know a few Australians online and it's something that comes up rather often.
@byronritchie5449
@byronritchie5449 10 месяцев назад
Yeah I can imagine both nations did fucked up things @@hedgehog3180
@Megabean
@Megabean 4 месяца назад
I'm a Canadian Matis individual, this all sounds too familiar for me. Its sad how European colonialism mirrors itself in so many regions around the world
@AlxzAlec
@AlxzAlec 10 месяцев назад
"Greenland is under the Kingdom of Denmark and have a high suicide rate, therefore the fault of these suicide rates are Denmark's" Do you know that it's not uncommon for cold nations like these to have loads of sad people?
@Th69571
@Th69571 Месяц назад
This guy has always had an anti-european bias. If he can find anything bad he will try to attribute it to europeans.
@TheSwedishHistorian
@TheSwedishHistorian 9 месяцев назад
fisheries is the reason why greenland left the european union in 1985, following a referendum in 1982 with 53% voting for withdrawal after a dispute over fishing rights.
@kommentator9272
@kommentator9272 10 месяцев назад
Very interesting video about a topic I never knew I'd be interested in. I saw Greenlands high suicide rate in some map visualizing it and as the general trend is that countries further north tend to have higher suicide rates and never gave it a second thought
@spoxx1802
@spoxx1802 10 месяцев назад
Amazingly presented and researched video. This should be the gold standard for RU-vid history
@crkcrk702
@crkcrk702 10 месяцев назад
Today it's better to be danish for Greenland though
@EyeoftheU
@EyeoftheU 10 месяцев назад
Well yeah, but still. It's kind of like wanting a price for being the least worst.
@crkcrk702
@crkcrk702 10 месяцев назад
@@EyeoftheU im not danish
@ProjectRedfoot
@ProjectRedfoot 9 месяцев назад
This was great. Thanks
@shzarmai
@shzarmai 5 месяцев назад
This all reminds me of the Norwegianization, Anti-Roma discrimination in Europe and Swedification of the Sami in Scandinavia - en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegianization_of_the_S%C3%A1mi
@goksir5845
@goksir5845 10 месяцев назад
Veldig spent, har alltid hatt lyst til å lære mer kritikk om moderne skandinavisk kolonialisme. Fett å se det dekket av en god kanal. Er litt for zoomer for å nå en omfattende forståelse selv.
@lazykabang3198
@lazykabang3198 10 месяцев назад
Det er uheldigvis ikke så mange utlendinger som vet at Skandinavia en gang har urbefolkninger
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 10 месяцев назад
Denmark was the very first country in planet Earth, to start human slavery and, Denmark never stopped but, are still trafficking and exploring in the utmost extreme...😰😰😰
@BryceV817
@BryceV817 10 месяцев назад
​@Jetmab04 denmark was the first country to ban the slave trade in 1792. African and Middle East nations still practice slavery today.
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 10 месяцев назад
@@BryceV817 According to our written History, you are correct....however, when/if you start digging, you'll find very different knowledge... My diggings started many years ago, when I by chance, participated in a History lesson on a different continent...fascinating and afterward I started trawling archives, checking up on the information I found...did it again in a new place and so on... My "thing" has always been to question what I hear ..called critical thinking 😊..absolutely worth the effort..especially when you start finding information which clearly were meant to be hidden (below the carpets) or just, "something we don't talk about,". These things in History, are often worth persuing - not because we want to hurt anyone but, simply to find facts - often hidden in plain sight.. Have you ever visited the Virgin islands??
@banditten78
@banditten78 9 месяцев назад
@@Jetmab04ancient Egypt and pyramids is earlier, and the pyramids where not build with paid labor 😂
@TomiAdewoleAdetom
@TomiAdewoleAdetom 4 месяца назад
Micah 2:2 “And they covet fields, and take them by violence; and houses, and take them away: so they oppress a man and his house, even a man and his heritage.”
@lucvader_1
@lucvader_1 10 месяцев назад
I like that you made this, such an underappreciated part of the world.
@petej4752
@petej4752 9 месяцев назад
OK. I can see the problem. They had to learn Danish. Thats meen. BUT. If they wanted to educate hemself higher than pre-school they had to go to Denmark. So how far do you think you could get with the Greenlandic in Denmark? And remember. Schools are free in Denmark. Even the University. If you know Danish at that time or English now. Read up on history.
@cxtashes
@cxtashes 5 месяцев назад
one time i brought up the native peoples of Greenland at my (Norwegian) grandparents' house and multiple people insisted no one lived there becore the scandinavians
@dragon723.
@dragon723. 9 месяцев назад
Wrong the dorset people were not in the parts of Greenland the vikings colonized, their range was not that far into southern Greenland and the vikings never spread that far north. Their ranges did not overlap. The Thule people who conquered the Dorset people spread that far, but only around the 15th century, centuries after the Norse arrived. They may have had some conflicts, but its more likely cooling weather drove the norse to abandon Greenland. Edit: Though the rest of the video does paint a fairly accurate image of danish colonialism in Greenland. I will challenge the idea that alcoholism is not in itself a massive, massive issue in Greenland. It is. It also forgets to mention the fact that the greenlandic population is tiny, as well as the struggles that has brought them on their path to independence from Denmark.
@DozerfleetProd
@DozerfleetProd Месяц назад
In videos I've seen, if any Greenlanders actually feel this way, I sure don't see them put it on display. Most of them are like: "Yeah, that happened in history. It's terrible. But those guys are all dead now. We have real problems with the real world today. What are we doing to work together to pave the future, rather than be bitter about the past?"
@danishkriger4017
@danishkriger4017 10 месяцев назад
Hmmm I would mean that the story of the relation between Denmark and Greenland is a lot more complex than this, I would say rather biased, video would imply. I am Danish, and therefor I am well aware that the opinons I will express can be considered biased or a bit grim. The statement "How Denmark Destroyed Greenland" ignores the obvious fact that greenland as a country is a danish construction. Before the norwegian priest, Hans Egede, arrived to greenland, there were no nation or civilised people. The name greenland, their cities, there written language is a danish-norwegian construction. I find it problematic that you, a norwegian person, is so loud in the critic of danish rule of greenland, but you must understand that norway also has a invested history in the good bad and ugly treatment of the inuits. Before our ancestores arrived the inuits lived a brutal life, some say it was better for them back then. That discussion is complicated, because the danish influence, that lead to the formation of the greenlandic state, has also given both great oppertunities to the natives in Greenland and great oppertunities for the inuits outside of greenland. Democracy, litteracy, health care, education and a stable life is the consequence of danish rule. I completely understand the dark history betweens us, but to say we destroyed Greenland is an extreme interpretation.
@randomhumanofearth7267
@randomhumanofearth7267 8 месяцев назад
Native Greenlandic music showed at the end is beautiful I don’t understand how colonial Danes didn’t find this nice
@unilajamuha91
@unilajamuha91 10 месяцев назад
The Norwegian urge to dunk on Denmark
@bigjamie9000
@bigjamie9000 9 месяцев назад
This is a great video all together, but there are a good few parts where you’re really reaching to make the story of greenland about markets and class struggle where such was hardly present.
@jacobparry177
@jacobparry177 10 месяцев назад
I know the situations weren't exactly the same, but as a Welsh speaker, I can't help but notice the parallels between how Welsh and Greenlandic were and are still viewed. An "educational" report on schools in Wales during the 19thC, nicknamed, 'Brad y llyfrau gleision', treachery of the blue books, (led by a Welshman living in England) stated: The Welsh language is a vast drawback to Wales and a manifold barrier to the moral progress and commercial prosperity of the people. And it shamed people into forgoing their native language (despite the fact that we know full well that bilingualism/multilingualism has literally no negatives, as we see with people who learn Latin, Ancient Greek and modern languages). Dwi'n gobeithio bydd iaith y kalaallit yn barhau a'u diwylliant yn ffynnu.
@banditten78
@banditten78 9 месяцев назад
Since 1979 Greenland has controlled its own school laws, you forget Greenland has 3 distinct languages, West (majority decided this is the official), East and Thule, as Greenland controls the school laws and decided that west is official school books is made in this language, so East and Thule speaking is left as a minority. I can’t comment on the Welsh, but before Greenland chose to take home school laws, there weren’t that big of issue with language, but in 79 the decided to exclude east and Thule, at the same time the quality of Danish learning plummeted, higher learning is limited on Greenland so you would go to FREE universities in Denmark, but with limited proficiency in Danish and English it is hard. But the issue is self created
@videovoer8130
@videovoer8130 10 месяцев назад
I shared your video, and someone was saying you were just capitalizing on Greenland's colonization which pissed me off tbh
@cjhunt9532
@cjhunt9532 10 месяцев назад
Such, such a good video. As an American (well, sort of an Irish Brit, but living in America), I think the vast majority of people outside the sphere of Danish-language politics think Greenland is just another "Scandy" place, and don't understand the pain and hardship of its people at all.
@kimdani1795
@kimdani1795 9 месяцев назад
as a dane i think greenland would be worse if. USA were in charge of Greenland
@Jonslau
@Jonslau 9 месяцев назад
Quick thing from a Dane. We did make Nuclear Bombs Illegal in Denmark (Mainland), The Faroe Islands and Greenland.
@1GentleGiant1
@1GentleGiant1 10 месяцев назад
I find it unsettling that a lot of these conditions remind me of puerto rico and the results of how we were treated by colonizers for generations. Wonderfully produced video, straight to the point, you tell the story of many colonized people through the story of the greenlanders, a story which must be heard more.
@Milk-jy1kn
@Milk-jy1kn 10 месяцев назад
I WAS JUST THINKING THE SAME THING. As colonized peoples, we tend to think our experience is uniquely abhorrent, little did we know they all used the same fucking textbook.
@AL-lh2ht
@AL-lh2ht 10 месяцев назад
Puerto Rico is the richest per capita Latin American region in the world.
@1GentleGiant1
@1GentleGiant1 10 месяцев назад
​@@AL-lh2ht yet we are still extremely poor and see none of the profit that American and other foreign companies reap. We went without a power grid for over half a year at some points due to colonial admin incompetency. Please dont base your presumptions off pure numbers. It makes you seem ignorant.
@bummerdrummer1649
@bummerdrummer1649 10 месяцев назад
@@1GentleGiant1if PR was independent it would just be like Cuba, or mexico, or any of the other dumps in Latin America. Maybe if your people can’t build a proper society, given rain or snow, island or landlocked, its time to stop blaming every1 else.
@marcino457
@marcino457 10 месяцев назад
@@bummerdrummer1649Cuba is literally exporting doctors to other countries. It enjoys longer life expectancy than the Inbred States of Obesity, lower inequality and higher government satisfaction even despite the constant embargo.
@oversizedspeedbump9375
@oversizedspeedbump9375 5 месяцев назад
started watching this video feeling reassured that the US didn't do something heinous, not sure what i expected.
@TheBlaiit
@TheBlaiit 10 месяцев назад
Half Greenlandic, half Dane here. Haven’t watched the video yet, but I love that there’s attention to the subject :)
@waddupdawgness
@waddupdawgness 9 месяцев назад
The problem with starting at the norse colonization is that you're starting after the first colonization of Greenland by the Thule people. The Dorset are the only indigenous Greenlandic people, and they were gone before the Norse ever arrived. So the only thing that has been colonized is a colonizing people who in all likelihood led to the extinction of the actual indigineous people.
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 9 месяцев назад
This is a story about Denmark so I focused on the norse, which was their rationale for saying it was still Danish despite not having been there for centuries. By this sort of logic, nobody is indigenous to anywhere. The Dorset didn't spawn out of the ground in Greenland.
@waddupdawgness
@waddupdawgness 9 месяцев назад
That's right but this isn't a case like the USA or Africa where certain peoples had been for thousands of years before colonizers arrived. Greenland was colonized by the Norse only around 2 centuries after it was colonized by the Thule. I don't think there's any argument to be made they can call themselves any more indigenous than the Norse who came right on their heels.@@FreddaYT
@MrTheWaterbear
@MrTheWaterbear 10 месяцев назад
I strongly respect and praise the Danish agreement with Greenland, enshrined in their constitution, that they can separate completely from Denmark with a simple majority vote of Greenlanders. The difficulty of being a small country far away from everything is, that any alternative partner to Denmark will be MUCH worse for the Greenlandic people :(
@nikolamilicevic1040
@nikolamilicevic1040 10 месяцев назад
they can join China instead.Become naval base etc...
@MrTheWaterbear
@MrTheWaterbear 10 месяцев назад
@@nikolamilicevic1040 Yeah, that would be the worst possible outcome. China is NOT a kind ally. In fact, they’re never an ally. They’re a stakeholder. Without being under the current EU and North Atlantic regulations they have to follow under Denmark, China would put them in a squeeze and make sure they’d pump out all their natural resources. And then there’s the existing US base… somehow don’t think they’d ever let China become a factor. But not in any way that would benefit Greenlanders, particularly.
@nikolamilicevic1040
@nikolamilicevic1040 10 месяцев назад
@@MrTheWaterbear China is NOT a kind ally ?who tells you that?Western merdia. China would put them in a squeeze and make sure they’d pump out all their natural resources. like cina woudl have other reasons to be there or that is that desperate fro greenland resources. And then there’s the existing US base… it can be removed.Niger ousted french troops even under coup gfovberment usa woudl have even lss possiblities to make case about greenaldn goverment,... But not in any way that would benefit Greenlanders, particularly. All under china are profiteering.
@marcino457
@marcino457 10 месяцев назад
China is not an ally? But Western colonial powers are? The ones who committed so may atrocities against the native peoples as well as the settlers? Westoids are truly beyond redemption
@Gump1405
@Gump1405 10 месяцев назад
​@@MrTheWaterbearChina has never really participated in the form of colonial exploitation that you describe here. No the worst thing that could happen if Greenland gained independence would be the USA coming in. They already expressed that they want Greenland more than once in the past.
@deadlyduck11
@deadlyduck11 10 месяцев назад
This was a very good video with a lot of interssting information. Thank you for your work in making this information accesible in this way!
@sylviamontaez3889
@sylviamontaez3889 10 месяцев назад
Regarding the iud scandal: there's also evidence it was continued during the 90s-2010s, after greenland gained control of its healthcare system in 1992
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 10 месяцев назад
You mean "health-care" in marks I assume 😰 Exactly the same "programs" as Denmark have "teached" to other European countries during the past 20 + years 😰
@hedgehog3180
@hedgehog3180 10 месяцев назад
@@Jetmab04 What do you have against the Danish healthcare system?
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 10 месяцев назад
@@hedgehog3180 I'm sure it's a good system - when and if the people behind it, decide to treat people in a professional way...we've unfortunately seen everything but professionalism from Denmark for many years and, I don't like to experience that. I simply don't respect or accept Eugenics which sadly seen to be, exactly what - especially the Danish public system now (again) practice and, to see this in the place in which I was born, doesn't just hurt me...makes me condemn the people involved 😪
@Jetmab04
@Jetmab04 10 месяцев назад
And a little sad PS...And, just for your information: The MK-Ultra* now tortured into people by the state of DK (and her Religions) as well as the 100% false medical journals made about, - especially us Danes who no longer live in the place, as well as the raped of innocent people .....these things among other completely horrific "methods" sadly tells us here, the very, very sad condition our old country is in. Like, when people from other continents ask - quote:" Denmark...that's where they crush their own in vaste insenerstors, right?" End quote. Knowing, that this is just one torture method in Denmark by now, tell me more about the condition of both your medical, legal and government "system".. And, the child-sex-trafficking...whst kind of a medical/legal/government system commit such pure evil!?!?!?.....Certainly not a place to ever come to again. That's for sure..I thankfully have my own medical record (the original) for all my life but, not the point here....😰😰😰 * When CIA introduced MK-Ultra the population of the world condemned it....I am 100% sure the population of the world, haven't changed our minds about such evil..where does all this hate come from Danes in Denmark???
@domerame5913
@domerame5913 10 месяцев назад
@@Jetmab04 you are crazy lmao stop reading conspiracy theories
@sisuka6505
@sisuka6505 10 месяцев назад
Really glad to see this kind of well-researched video an this topic.
@erikthomsen4768
@erikthomsen4768 10 месяцев назад
To conflate two different Greenlandic peoples is problematic. Same goes for mixing up Danes and Norwegians. The Dorset Culture encountered the Norwegian Culture and their cousins; the Inuit Culture encountered the Danish Culture only 300 years ago. The cultural focus lacks an appropriate definition of what might be considered a native lifestyle. In this case hunter-gatherers who lived as tribal nomards in a deeply unforgiving land that has wiped out the Greenlandic population six times before the Inuits arrived. The economic focus implies that the state of Denmark made a profit. This couldn't be further from the truth. But I wouldn't mind that if you had just included the decolonial history where Greenland was transformed from a colony to an equal province of the State of Denmark with communal governance and representation in the parlament. This changes the context of Kangeq which nows resembles the cases in Denmark where towns were moved for practical reasons such as making way for highways. It is a disagreeable law, mayhaps. But no less legal. Today Greenland is country without famine, tribal conflict or the more sexist aspects of Greenlandic Culture that even the conservatives don't want back. They have accomplishments such as a carbon foodprint (%) lower than most other countries and an educated youth. I know these things contradict the narrative you're trying to built. It can be confusing. Complicated. But I frankly don't care.
@FreddaYT
@FreddaYT 10 месяцев назад
Good thing I never conflated different Greenlandic peoples and always referred to them as "The Greenlandic peoples" "Greenlanders" or "Greenlandic Inuit" (plural) "The Dorset Culture encountered the Norwegian Culture and their cousins; the Inuit Culture encountered the Danish Culture only 300 years ago." This makes absolutely no sense. The Norse settlers were Icelandic for the most part, not Norwegian. Anything approximating a modern Norwegian or Danish culture did not exist at this time. "The Danish culture" was Danish-Norwegian as I established, and viewed its colonization of Greenland as a recolonization, a reclaiming of what the crown had viewed as a dependency, I was quoting word for word from the source. "The economic focus implies that the state of Denmark made a profit. This couldn't be further from the truth." Please educate yourself somewhat on colonialism and the way resource and profit extraction functions independently of anachronistic GDP per capita statistics and public expenditure statistics. There is no contradiction between the Danish state operating on a loss in Greenland using very specific definitions and statistics, and Denmark extracting profit out of Greenland.
@jonasringtved2454
@jonasringtved2454 10 месяцев назад
Thank you for making this video! There is not enough info about this tragic history. It is still felt everywhere in Denmark especially in the for of jokes about alcohol abuse. I feel truly ashamed and for a lot of danish history, but most of all that it is'nt acknowledged more. Nå ja for ikke at tale om den danske kolonisering af Norge, nogen ville mene vi holdt fast for længe, undskyld.
@KonenIRL
@KonenIRL 10 месяцев назад
Yup another fredda classic
@AbdulHannanAbdulMatheen
@AbdulHannanAbdulMatheen 8 месяцев назад
👏🙂 Great video
@PoppyHapalopus
@PoppyHapalopus 9 месяцев назад
Great video. The Danish schools taught us very little about our colonial history.
@joshualamberth8966
@joshualamberth8966 9 месяцев назад
i was personally only taught "oh we brought civilization while trying to preserve their culture!!" and that was it absolutely no nuance and only the occasional "well some danes were kind of mean but most were neat!" they really do attempt to hide how much denmark profited of off greenland
@icu6661
@icu6661 9 месяцев назад
Simply not true.. I have learned a lot about dk history good and bad parts of it when i went to school in dk
@PoppyHapalopus
@PoppyHapalopus 9 месяцев назад
@@icu6661Guess you went to a better school than I did!
Далее
Greenland - The Nation Explained
54:06
Просмотров 325 тыс.
Eco-hero strikes again! ♻️ DIY king 💪🏻
00:48
How to split your drink
00:45
Просмотров 815 тыс.
People Cling To Trees As Typhoon Slams Into Shanghai
00:34
Work.
33:16
Просмотров 953 тыс.
How Greenlanders Survive Brutal Winters
35:11
Просмотров 3,2 млн
The Faroes Under The Danish Crown
11:19
Просмотров 74 тыс.
Hegel: A Complete Guide to History
2:04:06
Просмотров 833 тыс.
The Right-Wing War on Education
56:20
Просмотров 653 тыс.