Тёмный

How fast is Earth traveling through space? That depends. | Michelle Thaller | Big Think 

Big Think
Подписаться 7 млн
Просмотров 237 тыс.
50% 1

How fast is Earth traveling through space? That depends.
New videos DAILY: bigth.ink
Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: bigth.ink/Edge
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How fast are you, planet Earth, our solar system, and the galaxy moving right now? There's no one answer to that question because we're going in several directions and multiple speeds all at the same time. How is that possible?
Within the Milky Way galaxy, our solar system is orbiting around a massive black hole at the center of the galaxy at half a million miles an hour. Separately, the Milky Way galaxy is in the Virgo Supercluster, which is falling into the Great Attractor, a huge group of galaxies called the Laniakea Supercluster, at one and a half million miles an hour.
And all of that is superimposed on top of the natural expansion of the universe, which isn't really a speed, but is happening at 75 kilometers per second per megaparsec.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MICHELLE THALLER
Dr. Michelle Thaller is an astronomer who studies binary stars and the life cycles of stars. She is Assistant Director of Science Communication at NASA. She went to college at Harvard University, completed a post-doctoral research fellowship at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech) in Pasadena, Calif. then started working for the Jet Propulsion Laboratory's (JPL) Spitzer Space Telescope. After a hugely successful mission, she moved on to NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC), in the Washington D.C. area. In her off-hours often puts on about 30lbs of Elizabethan garb and performs intricate Renaissance dances. For more information, visit
NASA.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TRANSCRIPT:
MICHELLE THALLER: Eugene, you've asked one of my favorite questions and a surprisingly deep one. The essence of it is: How fast are we really moving? We are a solar system; we are planets going around the Sun. But the Sun has its own motion around the galaxy, the Milky Way. And there are larger motions still because the Milky Way galaxy is also moving through space. So I'm going to try to break this down because there are a number of different ways to think about motion because when you get to these scales, one of the most important questions you have to ask is: Motion compared to what? And I'll explain that as I go along.
So one of the most easy to understand motions, but a kind of mind-blowing one is that the Sun is orbiting around the center of the Milky Way galaxy. Now, the Milky Way galaxy is a huge collection of about half a trillion stars, and it's about 100,000 light years across end-to-end. Now, we actually orbit around the center of the galaxy -- the center of the galaxy is about 30,000 light years away from us -- and we orbit around about once every 230 million years. OK, that sounds like a long time. So 230 million years to make one orbit around the galaxy. So how fast are we going? It turns out that the Sun, and us with it, it's going at about 560,000 miles an hour. That's over half a million miles an hour just around the center of our galaxy. So right now, you are moving at over half a million miles an hour around the center of the galaxy. And if you want to think about it in kind of a dramatic way, the center of the galaxy has a massive black hole at the middle, and it's about 4 million times the mass of the Sun. So right now, you are orbiting a massive black hole at half a million miles an hour. That's kind of fun.
But there are larger velocities as well. And here's where things start to get a little bit complicated because the universe is expanding. And what that really means is that space itself is expanding. It's not really correct to say the galaxies are flying through the universe with the expansion of the universe. That's actually not how it works at all. The galaxies in that sense are standing still, but the space in between them is getting bigger. It's a very strange thing to think about, but the expansion of the universe is not galaxies moving through empty space. And one of the reasons that this is important is because the farther away you look into space, the more expanding space you look through. And it's not that galaxies very far away are actually moving through space very, very fast, but they appear that way to us. There's something called the Hubble Constant, and what that means is how fast the universe is expanding for every amount of space that you look through. The Hubble constant right now is about 75 kilometers per second per megaparsec, and a megaparsec is about 3 million light years. So that means that every 3 million light years you go out, things are receding from yo...
For the full transcript, check out bigthink.com/v...

Опубликовано:

 

29 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,1 тыс.   
@bigthink
@bigthink 4 года назад
Want to get Smarter, Faster? Subscribe for DAILY videos: bigth.ink/GetSmarter
@duchi882
@duchi882 5 лет назад
*Police Officer:* Do you know how fast you were going? *Me:* Relative to what sir? *Police Officer:* Relative to this ticket I am holding
@squu9800
@squu9800 5 лет назад
Lol
@a.yashwanth
@a.yashwanth 5 лет назад
😂
@rustyshackleford2841
@rustyshackleford2841 5 лет назад
Me: Well the ticket is moving along with me through space at the speed of..... - gets taser to the face.
@christian669
@christian669 5 лет назад
Elegant joke 👌
@aqimjulayhi8798
@aqimjulayhi8798 5 лет назад
*Me* : But from my reference point, you are the one violating the speed limit. *Police officer* : Hands above your head, sir
@blahblah-js5ux
@blahblah-js5ux 5 лет назад
Wow, this lady explained it so well. I love the passion with which she does it.
@brightdaysarehere3094
@brightdaysarehere3094 5 лет назад
blah blah umm..passion does not mean truth..just because she is passionate does not mean she is right..if you knew anything about astronomy and astrophysics you would know that every single thing she said was a theory..she literally just mashed up 14 different 'theories' without one iota of proof and you believe her
@juanfrarubiolo1482
@juanfrarubiolo1482 5 лет назад
@@brightdaysarehere3094 you must feel so smart dont u
@bxzidffbxzidff
@bxzidffbxzidff 5 лет назад
@@panaccoman And after reading your comment I feel smarter, funny isn't it?
@jopmens6960
@jopmens6960 5 лет назад
How fast is she moving?
@craigcorson3036
@craigcorson3036 5 лет назад
@@brightdaysarehere3094 And if YOU knew ANYTHING about science, you'd know that "theory" is NOT the same as "hypothesis", or "guess". Please stop displaying your stupidity in public.
@joedasilva134
@joedasilva134 5 лет назад
Absolutely amazing ! Thanks for the awesome video
@christopherbettridge
@christopherbettridge 2 года назад
Perfect - that galaxies themselves are not actually moving away from each other, rather, they are standing still but the space IN BETWEEN THEM is moving them within itself the space in between them is getting bigger ❤️
@sawdat9376
@sawdat9376 5 лет назад
Hi Michelle, thank you for taking the time to explain the amazing things in our universe =) If I could ask a question it would be: Why can’t math quantify the density of a black hole?
@alphagt62
@alphagt62 2 года назад
I wasn’t aware that it couldn’t? I’d say, is the lack of information. We know black holes exist, but we have never observed one close enough to get the data needed to calculate such a thing, the simple assumptions we make gives us infinity, but in reality nothing is truly infinite, we just don’t have enough info to know exactly.
@youngandrew66
@youngandrew66 2 года назад
Everything is moving so quickly, yet stand in your backyard and look at the calm stillness of space. As the good lady says - 'speed relative to what?' great video.
@brunocosta8974
@brunocosta8974 5 лет назад
Thanks, Michelle. I've recently stumbled upon your videos and now I'm a big fan. As a physics enthusiast, I really appreciate these videos! :)
@IBoyan
@IBoyan 5 лет назад
I want to go back to school again and have her as a teacher!
@locodupre
@locodupre 5 лет назад
I really like these videos, but I can't understand why use the imperial system without any kind of mention as to what does that mean in the metric system.
@MikeKayK
@MikeKayK 5 лет назад
Google.
@davidmahon5269
@davidmahon5269 5 лет назад
Does 804672 km/h really make that much more sense to you? At these scales, you can just let your mind wrap around "Big Number" and not worry about the details.
@Patalenski
@Patalenski 5 лет назад
David Mahon, The metric system is *the norm* !
@gg5115
@gg5115 5 лет назад
@@Patalenski It ain't the norm here in the US, and while I'm paying her salary, I expect her to talk to me in American. Over here, everybody knows exactly what a half million miles an hour means, we use the term daily, but a half million kilometers per hour could be the speed of a snail or the starship Enterprise, who knows.
@edwardslusarski3139
@edwardslusarski3139 2 года назад
I thought Michaelson and Morley cleared this up back in 1897 right here in my Hometown of Cleveland Ohio at the Case School of Applied Sciences. Cleveland is best Known as the birthplace of rock and roll.. Few people realize that it is also, in a very real sense, the birthplace of Einstein's theory of relativity.
@IRex-wm9pd
@IRex-wm9pd 5 лет назад
Everything I know about how fast we are going I learned from Eric Idle. Sing with me! Just remember that youre standing on a planet thats evolving and revolving at 900 miles an hour. Its orbiting at 19 miles a second, so it's reckoned, the sun that is the source of all our power. Now the sun and you and me, and all the stars that we can see are moving at a million miles a day, in an outer spiral arm at 40 thousand miles an hour of the galaxy we call the Milky Way.
@juanramirez6251
@juanramirez6251 5 лет назад
Thank you Michelle for correcting me. In another dialogue I had concerning time travel, I mistakenly mentioned that our solar system was traveling around our galaxy at 55,000 mph and that the universe was expanding at what seemed was near the speed of light. Wow! It’s a half million millions an hour. That’s not counting the space widening galaxies apart and gravity pulling Andromeda and our Milky Way together. Anyway, I stated that if someone were to travel back in time, they would be lost in space because there were no reference points they could use to distinguish where the dinosaur filled earth was 65 million ago. We don’t know where the earth was in the universe 65 million years ago. It’s one thing to travel back in time, however if we could, we would also have to travel to where the earth was in the universe 65 million years ago. I don’t think we have those mathematical skills yet to determine that trajectory, that type of space craft to travel those distances to get to the dinosaur earth, let alone time travel. Could I be wrong?
@koala323ro
@koala323ro 2 года назад
Time travel feels imposibile, only a human made concept…too many paradoxes to break…
@almonjoinye
@almonjoinye 4 года назад
Micheller Thaller is so inspiring !!!
@kreaturen
@kreaturen 5 лет назад
I wonder, hypothetically of course... Would we be able to detect absolute zero motion by measuring its effect on the speed of time, relative to Earth time? I mean, since time progresses slower on board a really fast space ship, could we attempt to build a space craft whose only purpose was to do the complete opposite, decelerate down to a point where it truly stood completely still in relation to everything, using its effect on time as our reference guide?
@jacksavage197
@jacksavage197 5 лет назад
How can this wonderful woman make things so understandable for us without degrees. Thank you.
@AlexTube2006
@AlexTube2006 4 года назад
Thanks! Clear and fascinating
@seanwatts8342
@seanwatts8342 5 лет назад
No matter how many Neil deGrassholes tell you, *NOBODY can ever prove any truly inertial reference frame.*
@nebtheweb8885
@nebtheweb8885 5 лет назад
Lol, Really? 1960. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-bJMYoj4hHqU.html
@seanwatts8342
@seanwatts8342 5 лет назад
@Owen Marble If you're responding to me, the answer is 'No.' I'm an engineer. If you do not know what the term 'Inertial reference frame' means, you're behind on your reading.
@seanwatts8342
@seanwatts8342 5 лет назад
@@nebtheweb8885 This video demonstrates exactly what "Nobody can ever prove any truly inertial reference frame" means.
@richardsilva-spokane3436
@richardsilva-spokane3436 5 лет назад
Michelle, I am a science fiction fan and have always felt that any time-travel subject needed to always include a means of navigation and prediction of the position of a spacial destination point and the return to the original departure point. Wouldn't THAT throw a wrench into design of such a machine? Think of the complex calculations!!!
@photondance
@photondance 5 лет назад
In a practical sense, my body is barely moving at all, but my mind is racing faster than light. Thank you for that, Michelle.
@sosalish441
@sosalish441 5 лет назад
What effect does this movement have on time dilation? Does it change depending on whether our orbit around the sun is moving with or against the rotation of the galaxy? Is this something we can even detect? What would the effect be, if any, on our standard time be if we were able to come to a complete stop in space? Is there a universal standard time at this dead stop if we were to calculate out the effects of gravity?
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
Time dilation is another RELATIVE quantity. If you aren't comparing it to something else, you can't tell it is there.
@soumenb22
@soumenb22 5 лет назад
She explains so well. I wish she would have been my mentor
@HollywoodF1
@HollywoodF1 5 лет назад
Michelle, if I could add up how much time I've spent listening to you over the years, I'd probably qualify for another degree. You are so engaging and knowledgeable, and I can't thank you enough for what you contribute to your field.
@247tubefan
@247tubefan 5 лет назад
So basically we are going at Ludicrous Speed. Like in the movie Spaceballs.
@bullbythehorns808
@bullbythehorns808 5 лет назад
Didn't even cover how fast we are going around our sun or how which part of our orbit around sun or our Galaxy then changes our net velocity relative to andromeda or better yet the origin point of the big bang.
@mavortius8388
@mavortius8388 5 лет назад
There is no single origin point to the big bang. That's a misconception of what the expansion is. The universe did not necessarily explode out from a particular place. I believe there's actually another Big Think video on this. Search for Big Bang Big Think and you may find it.
@brightdaysarehere3094
@brightdaysarehere3094 5 лет назад
Moscovium because they are all unprovable theories...
@dannydewario1550
@dannydewario1550 5 лет назад
@@brightdaysarehere3094 They are all "unprovable" theories? That sounds like an "unprovable" theory to me.
@moonbeamskies3346
@moonbeamskies3346 5 лет назад
@@brightdaysarehere3094 A lot of people don't want to face the fact that scientists are clueless about the universe. We've only been around a few thousand years. We can see some things and we've been to the moon. And that is all we'll ever know about space. Everything she said in this video is an unproven theory because WE DON'T KNOW JACK SQUAT.
@Alcohen2006
@Alcohen2006 5 лет назад
She's describing what's implied by observations. It's internally consistent, and it hasn't been DISproven. So it's the best we have, and if you have a reason to want to see it discarded, that's YOUR job at this point. We're all waiting to hear your evidence. Note: Maybe Michelle's descriptions blew your mind, but that's not evidence.
@420snoogins
@420snoogins 5 лет назад
There are some people with the gift, MT has it, grabs your attention and stuffs knowledge between your ears!
@JE-ee7cd
@JE-ee7cd 5 лет назад
👍For the nice, pretty and smart lady. 😁
@allertonoff4
@allertonoff4 5 лет назад
yeah .. wasn't she cool ! :]
@ronleak7209
@ronleak7209 2 года назад
She never named a final answer. I just want to know how fast we are moving relative to , when the science and the future astronomical instrumentation get so advanced,that we discover in deep space a hand lighting a fuse
@drackxman
@drackxman 3 года назад
This makes me wonder why I still see the same star shapes in the sky as I did over 50 years ago. Like say Orion's Belt or the Big and Little Dipper. One other thing. Is the North Star still believable / trustable if the Earth is travelling through space ?
@acerovalderas
@acerovalderas 5 лет назад
Excellent explanation, clear and sharp.
@courtlaw1
@courtlaw1 3 года назад
I like to think of our galaxy as the Alpha Quadrant.
@mikemeiners105
@mikemeiners105 5 лет назад
Nice job. I have a question. Space is expanding, am I? As the universe grows bigger do it's component parts grow also? or just the space between them?
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
Just the space between them. Gravity and other forces keep you the same size.
@BhagyaYogShala
@BhagyaYogShala 5 лет назад
This lady makes my major life problems look like crap. Astronomy is a religion with facts that brings you at peace, yet gets you curious, happy n mellow together with huge humbleness.
@travisfrost5175
@travisfrost5175 2 года назад
And yet my hair still looks good. Fantastically taught.
@MAFiA303
@MAFiA303 5 лет назад
why don't you use kilometers instead of miles?
@dannygjk
@dannygjk 5 лет назад
A lot of scientists on RU-vid use miles because so many viewers are Americans and if you use metric in a video many Americans will stop watching.
@benlloyddavis
@benlloyddavis 5 лет назад
Your just wrinkled my brain...and I love it!
@IamGhede
@IamGhede 5 лет назад
Are there stars or galaxies, that we observed previously, that moved past our observable universe already?
@Patalenski
@Patalenski 5 лет назад
There's a border beyond which we cannot observe further because the light from that region of the Universe will *never* reach us (if it continues to expand). This is the reason we build bigger and bigger optical telescopes - to see further into that region, which presents the Universe in its "infant years".
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
@@Patalenski If the light will NEVER reach us, bigger telescopes aren't going to help. Bigger telescopes are for looking at the things that AREN'T receding faster than the speed of light.
@ricklayeux5688
@ricklayeux5688 2 года назад
Wow, I feel like I'm barely moving.
@busterhikney6936
@busterhikney6936 2 года назад
Hi Michelle, Continue your thoughts about the realities of our flat earth. -Buster
@guilhermebacchin5261
@guilhermebacchin5261 2 года назад
So, the universe has a center! And we know where it is, our galaxy is being attracted to this center of the universe! When a lot of galaxies hit each other in the center another Big Bang I’ll happen and then everything starts again, future life on universe will call this God!
@ANDROLOMA
@ANDROLOMA 2 года назад
Future life "on universe" will think up a better, less contentious name.
@Dabigez829
@Dabigez829 5 лет назад
First star to the left, and onward to tomorrow. See you soon.
@dannygjk
@dannygjk 5 лет назад
Come on man give credit where credit is due. :)
@rudy6222
@rudy6222 5 лет назад
I love this lady. She is so smart
@thedude6405
@thedude6405 2 года назад
I wish my mother was as wise as this lady, talks about real knowledge instead of secondhand politics.
@piglex1
@piglex1 5 лет назад
Relative to what and does it matter?
@akinishi1985
@akinishi1985 5 лет назад
She's my fav! :) A fan from Japan!
@Andy-df5fj
@Andy-df5fj 5 лет назад
We are still experiencing the big bang.
@DaddyDaughterMovieNight
@DaddyDaughterMovieNight 5 лет назад
Love your videos. It sounds like, from certain vantage points, we might appear to violate the cosmic "speed limit"? How is this appearance reconciled with what we know about the speed of light? Maybe you explain it elsewhere...I'm working my way through your videos!
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
Nothing can travel THROUGH SPACE faster than the speed of light. Having the Universe expand the space between two objects, doesn't count as moving through space.
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
@Harold Potsdamer If the Universe is infinite, how could you possibly know that it is or isn't expanding? Infinity * 2 = Infinity. That of course leaves aside the question of how you could possibly know that it is infinite.
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
@Harold Potsdamer 1) The universe isn't expanding INTO anything. Think of it as new space being created everywhere all the time. 2) Not necessarily. But even if it had a center, that doesn't mean it would be within our OBSERVABLE universe. And no, having a center does NOT imply that new space has to be coming from the center. See 1). 3) Either way, infinite or not, central or not, all evidence appears to say that everything (we can see) used to be closer together, and that the rate at which things are getting farther apart is increasing. The Universe could be infinite, and the energy and matter could STILL have started small and be getting bigger. Or the Universe could have started small along with the energy and matter. I can't think of any experiment which would differentiate those two. p.s. You can't prove anything based on the definition of a word.
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
@Harold Potsdamer You know this how? Because you are agreeing with astrophysicists on some points and disagreeing with them on others.
@polite_as_fuck
@polite_as_fuck 5 лет назад
The universe has expanded since I started writing this sentence. The same goes for this sentence as well. Aaaaaaaaand this one, too.
@RPKGameVids
@RPKGameVids 5 лет назад
And now the replies are expanding.
@kurtklimbs
@kurtklimbs 5 лет назад
Does any of this motion affect the way we experience time?
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
Yes. Relative to others NOT moving with us.
@jonmars9559
@jonmars9559 5 лет назад
Michelle, I love how clearly you speak and are able to make potentially complex topics comprehensible.
@t_mokgohloa
@t_mokgohloa 4 года назад
Thats so true
@jameskellenberger8740
@jameskellenberger8740 4 года назад
She’s good
@MetalRam
@MetalRam 2 года назад
intelligence is hot
@georgemoore7186
@georgemoore7186 2 года назад
Well if you're so smart, how fast ARE we moving??? She talked a lot and in the end didn't really answer the question, did she? if she doesn't really know, how did you understand what she said, when what she really said, when you break it down....was, I don't know how fast we are moving? all I could comprehend was that is was incomprehensible! Just kidding, it is way over my head but she is very entertaining and has a way of enticing you into wanting to know more
@davidsaldivar7434
@davidsaldivar7434 2 года назад
@@MetalRam calm down perv.
@vitorsatan8542
@vitorsatan8542 5 лет назад
This woman is amazing...she glows love and wonder about the cosmos...I can relate. love you MT
@Remnantsf
@Remnantsf 5 лет назад
Me to
@michaelblacktree
@michaelblacktree 5 лет назад
Michelle is the only reason I'm still subscribed to this channel.
@corniel657
@corniel657 5 лет назад
@@cliffordernest7825 no u
@MrGuitarman8000
@MrGuitarman8000 4 года назад
She glows with cosmic hairspray
@V4NI5H3D
@V4NI5H3D 3 года назад
She works for nasa and lies
@desertpair2
@desertpair2 5 лет назад
OMG . . . this presentation is SO good, I tried to subscribe just now . . . even though I've already subscribed. Michelle Thaller, you are truly a prize! Thanks for these videos. I understand about 90 percent of the concepts you explain . . . and sometimes, as with all astrophysics, I'm just left scratching my head.
@Graphite974
@Graphite974 5 лет назад
I agree. She’s a brilliant speaker. I could listen to her for hours!
@iu2
@iu2 5 лет назад
What I don't understand is how space can be expanding. Space is nothing, so how can nothing do anything?
@joeyfeliciano9199
@joeyfeliciano9199 5 лет назад
@@iu2 Haha nail it!
@desertpair2
@desertpair2 5 лет назад
@@iu2 Yeah, well THAT was the 10 percent I didn't understand. LOL. Thanks for replying!
@neilsiebenthal9254
@neilsiebenthal9254 2 года назад
@@iu2 where has any scientist said space is nothing? I'll help ya out, they havent and don't say that.
@engrtun
@engrtun 5 лет назад
One day we might discover that “The Great Attractor” is moving toward something also. It’s mind boggling.
@x3ICEx
@x3ICEx 5 лет назад
Already discovered; Shapley Supercluster Now I wonder where that /ultracluster/ is moving. (Laniakea + Shapley + the other superclusters.)
@WillMauer
@WillMauer 5 лет назад
It should be a crime to use imperial units on science videos.
@mattfalls2328
@mattfalls2328 5 лет назад
It should be a crime to use them at all, they make no sense!! 😂 I love my USA but guys seriously we need to switch lol
@ffggddss
@ffggddss 5 лет назад
They're "English" units; not "Imperial." Some of the latter differ from their counterparts in the former. Fred
@billneo
@billneo 5 лет назад
I think giving both is a good idea. I'm one who grew up w mph not to mention still driving my car in those units. I don't easily relate to kph so giving both provides a chance that i might learn the equivalencies. (I know multiplying by .6 [.6214...] gets me there too but how many of the 4k viewers are going bother to do the math?) Do you want to educate people or you want to them to feel left out? But actually the distances and speeds she's talking about here are not easily relatable no matter which units one is used to.
@ffggddss
@ffggddss 5 лет назад
@@billneo A useful rule of thumb for km-mi conversions is 5:8; that is, 5 mi ≈ 8 km. The exact conversion factor (1.609344) is remarkably close to the Golden Ratio, so any two consecutive Fibonacci numbers make a good approximation. Fred
@billgiles3261
@billgiles3261 4 года назад
ffggddss They are British measurements and the American system is based on that.
@Bevo_Baker
@Bevo_Baker 5 лет назад
I love listening to someone who's truly passionate in their field of expertise
@platypusmaximus9278
@platypusmaximus9278 5 лет назад
About tree fitty.
@OzFPVflyer
@OzFPVflyer 2 года назад
lol
@peppereater3028
@peppereater3028 5 лет назад
Anytime I'm feeling smart I watch a video of hers and it brings me back to earth. (Round earth) 🌎
@davidp.7620
@davidp.7620 5 лет назад
Her knowledge was heard of in all four corners of the Earth
@cyclemadness
@cyclemadness 5 лет назад
Round can still be flat.
@peppereater3028
@peppereater3028 5 лет назад
@@cyclemadness Thank you captain obvious. 🙄
@beastman.330
@beastman.330 4 года назад
Come on WHO are you kidding everyone know it's flat as a pan cake .
@peppereater3028
@peppereater3028 2 года назад
@@jefffrazier2465 I agree, that was a dumb and rude comment. Probably just having a bad day. Thank you for bringing it to my attention and please have a nice day. I apologise Kevin.
@diorynovis
@diorynovis 5 лет назад
Speed = relative to your relatives heading towards you
@nuranichandra2177
@nuranichandra2177 2 года назад
I have been watching MT for over 15 years and she always amazes me with her authoritative monologues packed with information. The sparkle in her eyes and the bubbly tone in her vocals indicate her passion for space and astronomy. Please post more such videos that would benefit the mankind .
@almightytreegod
@almightytreegod 5 лет назад
Nah, I still think we’re going about 60.
@jacqueeelle6287
@jacqueeelle6287 5 лет назад
Hall of Canons 42 😊
@Alcohen2006
@Alcohen2006 5 лет назад
And relative to that car that just whizzed past you, I'd agree with you. But you can only speak for yourself.
@0topon
@0topon 5 лет назад
Please use the metric system more often
@Eliaspraciano
@Eliaspraciano 5 лет назад
Agreed! (y)
@MikeKayK
@MikeKayK 5 лет назад
@@Eliaspraciano She and most of the viewers are in the USA. We don't ask your astrophysicists to use the Imperial System ;)
@Eliaspraciano
@Eliaspraciano 5 лет назад
@@MikeKayK it's not forbidden to ask anyone to use whatever system you feel is the right one. And I wasn't talking to you. 👍☕
@PGraveDigger1
@PGraveDigger1 5 лет назад
@@MikeKayK Science uses the metric system, she is a scientist explaining science, she should use the metric system, just like any other American scientist does in their job/research.
@MikeKayK
@MikeKayK 5 лет назад
@Harold Potsdamer What do you mean when you say she has no clue what she is saying? Of course she does. And as for the units...it's called knowing your audience. She's a lot smarter than you with that respect. She's an educator who's goal is to get fresh young minds interested in science/astronomy. The units are not important and she is wisely using units that most of the viewers of this video will understand. This isn't an astronomy lecture at a university. You knock her but it is you who doesn't understand the reason for these videos.
@ffggddss
@ffggddss 5 лет назад
I like how you explained that the expansion of space isn't galaxies "moving" away from one another, but the space between them expanding. I'm gonna use that. We all should. You also touched somewhat on the critically important point that asking what speed/velocity something is going, is a meaningless question without at least an _implied_ reference frame. Fred
@larryslemp9698
@larryslemp9698 2 года назад
Yes sir!! Exactly the same thing that..... made me think in a way that I had not before!!
@Alan_Page
@Alan_Page 2 года назад
Like a blueberry muffin or a piece of raisin bread expanding and the galaxies and galaxy clusters are the blueberries or raisins.
@alphagt62
@alphagt62 2 года назад
Depending on perspective! From the point of view of some distant galaxy, we are moving faster than light! But from the point of view of my house, I’m not moving at all. I’ve always thought this would be the biggest problem with building a time machine, if we went back in time, but remained in the same place, we’d find ourselves floating out in space somewhere! It would be nearly impossible to predict where we were one year ago, even one second ago.
@ffggddss
@ffggddss 2 года назад
@@alphagt62 Yes! Even in non-relativistic terms, any "time machine" would really be a "spacetime machine." It would have to take account of place & time, in some reference frame. Where you wind up, would depend on that choice of frame of reference. Fred
@michaelblacktree
@michaelblacktree 5 лет назад
Cue up the flat Earthers saying "But I can't feel the speed, so it's not true!" 🙄
@karaa7595
@karaa7595 5 лет назад
m.blacktree and you're going by the word of people who've never seen ANY of this happening. They are going off of mathematical equations written by people they've never met, clearly not understanding that mathematical equations CAN be manipulated to support an outcome a "scientist" wants to be "fact". Science today is mythological at best.
@nemanjabasaric4042
@nemanjabasaric4042 5 лет назад
@Fireball XL5 Damn,she might need some cold water for that burn. Maybe she could melt some of that ice wall on the edge of our flat earth
@michaelblacktree
@michaelblacktree 5 лет назад
@@karaa7595 - Thank you for helping to fill out the tail end of the bell curve. It's a dirty job, but someone's gotta do it. 👍
@polite_as_fuck
@polite_as_fuck 5 лет назад
Kara A - _”[Y]ou’re going by the word of people who’ve never seen ANY of this happening. They are going off of mathematical equations written by people they’ve never met...”_ As opposed to what, exactly? The supernatural claims of sorcery and creationism found in the Bible? I’m going to go out on a limb and assume that you haven’t met the illiterate Iron Age sheep herder who is [traditionally] credited with writing the Book of Genesis, so how can you possibly deride anyone else for putting their trust in scientific theories? After all, scientific theories are falsifiable - by their very definition - so what’s stopping you from falsifying them?
@agingchill9012
@agingchill9012 5 лет назад
@@karaa7595 ~ Oversimplifying to make a point, think about this: if the earth were exactly 24,000 miles around at the equator and though you stood still, it took exactly 24 hours to rotate completely around, sun straight up to sun straight up, then covering 24,000 miles in 24 hours equals a rotational speed of 1,000 mph. The equator is closer to 25,000 miles around so, you actually travel faster than 1,000 mph at the equator. Internet search how that's determined or ask a teacher or pilots and astronauts. Now, think about the earth being an average 93 million miles from the sun. C=2πr means the earth travels over half a billion miles circling the sun in a year equating to more than 1.5 million miles per day or nearly 67,000 mph. Cosmic speeds really add up. Like Michelle said... Fun!
@Gorrebell
@Gorrebell 5 лет назад
Relative to the surface of the Earth, 0 MPH
@shannonchuprevich3021
@shannonchuprevich3021 5 лет назад
Adds up to a lot of torque.
@Gulgathydra
@Gulgathydra 5 лет назад
Thanks, I'll use this argument the next time I get a "failure to stop" ticket.
@craigcorson3036
@craigcorson3036 5 лет назад
Yeah, let us know how THAT plays out. I mean, once they let you out of the pokey.
@norbertocalderon2364
@norbertocalderon2364 5 лет назад
Mmm you didn't answer the question how fast is the earth traveling or what is the speed of the planet around the sun
@GoldSrc_
@GoldSrc_ 5 лет назад
Amazing, get ready for the globe deniers though, I can almost smell their lack of brain coming towards this video.
@DanielDogeanu
@DanielDogeanu 5 лет назад
You forgot to account for the Earth's speed around the Sun and the Earth's speed around itself.
@jamescollier3
@jamescollier3 2 года назад
only 67 kmph, and once every 24 h, so, the 1/2 million mph is Much faster
@bobyoung241
@bobyoung241 5 лет назад
The Milky way, our Galaxy. If the only man made object is just leaving our solar system, witch is in the Galaxy. how can we have pictures of the Galaxy? If we just got out of bed , how can we have a picture of the house.
@g6ter1
@g6ter1 5 лет назад
@bob 2 things: 1. As our solar system is orbiting around the milky way galaxy closer to its outskirts, we can look in towards the center from earth and get visual representations that way (ie - looking at the milky way from places like Yosemite). 2. Any images that show the "milky Way" in its entirety complete with spiraling arms are really images of similar spiral type milky way-like galaxies, Andromeda would be one for example.
@mr.d3916
@mr.d3916 5 лет назад
So all these galixies will collide in the great attractor?
@jamescollier3
@jamescollier3 2 года назад
the mostly miss. all almost all empty space
@joestallings6993
@joestallings6993 5 лет назад
This channel needs a "love" button so I can click that.
@ominous-omnipresent-they
@ominous-omnipresent-they 5 лет назад
*Conversion to kilometers for my fellow humans not in the USA:* Sun orbiting around Milky Way - 901,233 km/h The speed at which Andromeda is moving towards the Milky Way - 482,803 km/h Our movement towards the Great Attractor (Laniakea Supercluster) - 2414016km/h
@dbuezas
@dbuezas 5 лет назад
You and Pinker speak very similarly! (And equally fascinatingly)
@realityrealized8370
@realityrealized8370 5 лет назад
5:21 Gravity isn't a force so how can gravity be pulling Andromeda and us together faster than this expansion and the gravity from the "great attractor" is still pulling everything to it?
@nebtheweb8885
@nebtheweb8885 5 лет назад
Gravity isn't a force? According to whom?
@realityrealized8370
@realityrealized8370 5 лет назад
@@nebtheweb8885 Every single physicist who has any clue about anything ever? In order for a force to be real it needs to exist in all reference frames which gravity does not so they pretend it's real because it helps describe something that is real but they don't know what it is. That's not even debatable.
@ominous-omnipresent-they
@ominous-omnipresent-they 5 лет назад
@@realityrealized8370 Gravity is real, but gravity is not simply a force between masses. Gravity is instead an effect of space and time.
@realityrealized8370
@realityrealized8370 5 лет назад
@@ominous-omnipresent-they Right... So then you should have no problem answering my question how is gravity supposedly effecting different areas of space time in different directions at once? How do you calculate it? Can it be demonstrated in any real way?
@ominous-omnipresent-they
@ominous-omnipresent-they 5 лет назад
@@realityrealized8370 First off, gravity isn't isn't responsible for the expansion of the universe; dark energy is an unknown force which effects cannot currently be measured due to it's non-interaction with light. We can only assume an entirely new and unseen force which can be seen functioning much different than gravity. Currently, gravity's strong interaction between the Milky Way and Andromeda is greater than the mysterious forces of dark energy. As far as your question about different areas of spacetime, I may not understand what you're truly trying to ask. Satellites in space have onboard clocks which must be adjusted due to the lower effects of gravity acting on them. The time, relative to our position on Earth, moves slightly faster than on Earth. Just mere microseconds a day, but enough to observed. Engineers account for this by programming the clocks to move slightly slower than our ground-based clocks. Can I demonstrate gravity? As in recreate it in a lab? Well, no. The only way we know to recreate gravity is use mass. There's no lab big enough that would allow controlled manipulation of matter on such a grand scale. We don't understand everything about gravity, we're only able to see its obvious effects.
@Author-Chad_Kunego
@Author-Chad_Kunego 5 лет назад
The biggest question I always had about this is, the faster you move, the more time dilates, so since we're moving really fast, how much is time getting dilated for us? In other words, the old, "If a set of twins is separated, one travels to one light year away in 5 years, relative to the twin doing the travel, then comes back, to that twin, they've only gotten ten years older, yet the twin that stayed on Earth is something like eighty years old." If we've only been "traveling" for a couple thousand years, could alien races have already progressed through millions of years of time because they're moving at a significantly slower rate of velocity, thereby being long dead to our frame of reference? I know that's probably badly worded, but hopefully I got the main idea of my question across
@joeyfeliciano9199
@joeyfeliciano9199 5 лет назад
BIGBANG is really a fairytale for grownups! I like how she tell a story of another collection of galaxies to collide with each other, andromeda is the leader, great!😅
@donaldbrown4711
@donaldbrown4711 2 года назад
How fast is the earth spinning around the sun? 18.5 miles per second = 66,600 miles per hour.
@mlfilion
@mlfilion 2 года назад
The great attractor is at the bottom of the universe with a super giant massive black hole pulling everything down. We're in a spiral vortex headed down the drain at a million miles an hour
@jerrywang696
@jerrywang696 5 лет назад
Forget WWJD. HWME (How Would Michelle Explain (it)) is how I'm living my life from now on.
@GajanaNigade
@GajanaNigade 5 лет назад
That's actually not a bad idea.
@drew-shourd
@drew-shourd 4 года назад
....I would really like to comment on this video, but currently I am picking up the pieces of my brain.....
@MichaelWheatland
@MichaelWheatland 5 лет назад
Fantastic video but please stop mixing SI and imperial units. Stick with SI so it's easier to understand.
@FrankDijkstra
@FrankDijkstra 5 лет назад
She forgot to mention the rotation of the earth, which is around a thousand miles per hour. And the rotation of the earth around the sun, which is 67000 miles per hour.
@firstdog4
@firstdog4 5 лет назад
When studying for my pilots license the training material states 'for our purposes we will assume the earth is flat and stationary'. What's up with that?
@PGraveDigger1
@PGraveDigger1 5 лет назад
It means that that assumption is useful for the context in which it is made. That doesn't mean that the assumption is true, or that it has any use outside of that context.
@ruthfannin9990
@ruthfannin9990 5 лет назад
B. Glynn They do that to make the math easier. It works because the curvature of the Earth is very gradual with respect to the slow motion of civilian aircraft. But if you were flying a military aircraft such as an F-22 Raptor at the top speed of about 1500 miles per hour and you didn't include the curvature of the Earth you'd end up in the wrong place.
@jimmynobody8344
@jimmynobody8344 5 лет назад
That same material says they would also assume the aircraft was rigid and had a constant mass. Obviously for the purposes of that exercise the earths curvature, the planes moving parts, and using fuel did not need to be taken into account. It seems odd that that was confusing to you.
@michaelanderson4849
@michaelanderson4849 5 лет назад
Context, context, context.
@hellifiknow1315
@hellifiknow1315 4 года назад
I've seen documents on trajectories of airplanes done by the airforce for the army and it says same thing. "...assuming and flat non rotating earth." my son, in the army, found it interesting and sent me a copy.
@x3ICEx
@x3ICEx 5 лет назад
Breakdown, SI units: You (frame of reference) are standing still. (sitting, probably) 0 km/h - The Earth under you is dragging you along with it; spinning / rotating around its own axis. 1600 km/h @ equator - Planet Earth is also orbiting the Sun. 107,000 km/h - The Sun is orbiting the center of our galaxy; the Milky Way. 828,000 km/h - The Milky Way is hurtling towards Andromeda at 402,000 km/h - But the Milky Way is also falling towards a so called "great attractor"; the center of the Laniakea Supercluster. 2,160,000 km/h - The Great Attractor is moving towards the Shapley Supercluster. (Not covered in this video.) - And space is expanding everywhere. Technically "faster than the speed of light" if measured over long enough distances. - But the local space, say between two of your fingers is expanding at such a negligible speed that it's safe to round down to 0. - These above speeds all add together, or subtract, or cancel each other out, or somewhere in between, combine ratio depending on direction (3D vector math) - Maximum speed: lightspeed 1,080,000,000 km/h is technically our "speed" as measured from the opposite end of the galaxy.
@x3ICEx
@x3ICEx 5 лет назад
Breakdown, SI units: You (frame of reference) are standing still. (sitting, probably) 0 km/h The Earth under you is dragging you along with it; spinning / rotating around its own axis. 1600 km/h @ equator Planet Earth is also orbiting the Sun. 107,000 km/h The Sun is orbiting the center of our galaxy; the Milky Way. 828,000 km/h The Milky Way is hurtling towards Andromeda at 402,000 km/h But the Milky Way is also falling towards a so called "great attractor"; the center of the Laniakea Supercluster. 2,160,000 km/h The Great Attractor is moving towards the Shapley Supercluster. (Not covered in this video.) And space is expanding everywhere. Technically "faster than the speed of light" if measured over long enough distances. But the local space, say between two of your fingers is expanding at such a negligible speed that it's safe to round down to 0. These above speeds all add together, or subtract, or cancel each other out, or somewhere in between, combine ratio depending on direction (3D vector math) Maximum speed: lightspeed 1,080,000,000 km/h is technically our "speed" as measured from the opposite end of the galaxy.
@gmailaaaa
@gmailaaaa 5 лет назад
Fail to understand your obsession with miles. Use METERS.
@Mikey-ym6ok
@Mikey-ym6ok 5 лет назад
Harold Potsdamer ignorance is not being able to do simple math to convert. We have our own system. Deal with it. You don’t see the u.s complain about the roads in the u.k. Or they’re obsolete government. If you can’t convert then i feel sorry for you
@Mikey-ym6ok
@Mikey-ym6ok 5 лет назад
Harold Potsdamer again. I feel sorry for you. If you don’t want to convert that’s your problem. Don’t message me back. I don’t like wasting my valuable time arguing with a lazy troglodyte.
@Mikey-ym6ok
@Mikey-ym6ok 5 лет назад
Harold Potsdamer cry me a river. Build a bridge and get over it. The fact is you will have to convert cause we aren’t changing. Okay I say it again. Stop replying to me. I don’t like to argue with idiots.
@HugoHugunin
@HugoHugunin 5 лет назад
With the speeds involved, would there be any time distortion based upon relativistic motion? If there was, how could we ever truly know what time it was, currently...here on Earth?
@Patalenski
@Patalenski 5 лет назад
The Time always "ticks" the same for you, no matter what speed you have! :-p Different galaxies have slightly different time speed than ours but than, they are millions of light years away from us! :-)
@superdave54811
@superdave54811 5 лет назад
I have an issue with the idea of space between all galaxies expanding. That seems to clearly not be the case as we see galaxies colliding moving towards each other, clumping and creating virtual strings and walls of galaxies all together. Something about Dark Energy and Dark Matter is not making sense. I keep hearing scientists refer to them both but with no physical proof. I want the JWST to launch and begin its work as a telescope. I belive it may debunk some of these overused theories: The Big Bang, Expansion, Dark Matter, Dark Energy. I think that there are more elegant answers to explain the universe beyond the necessity for those theories.They seep to perceive the speeds of the universe based upon redshift. However, space is not empty. It is full of gravity, gases, dust and many things that affect light by bending spacetime and bending light or simply light moving through fields of matter. The more that light has to move by and through the more it is shifted towards the red spectrum. This can be seen locally with our Sun.
@Mikey-ym6ok
@Mikey-ym6ok 5 лет назад
Lana were still in the orbit of the sun. If not we’d be flung out or towards the sun
@frederickjk3
@frederickjk3 5 лет назад
Interesting
@Burt_Cokaine
@Burt_Cokaine 5 лет назад
Lana, it's because this verse is a simulation of another verse. Even if math is perfect, our observation won't match due to us trying to use a perfect concept like math, to describe a imperfect simulation. The programming of our verse allows for things like stars at the end of a galactic spiral arm, to travel at same speed as things closer to the center. For the math to fit our observation they have to add extra energy (dark energy). I think it's more likely to be that those that built this simulation, use it to understand their verse, same as us when we create cosmic motion simulating programs. We observe events that don't make rational sense, but if we think about it in a context that's real easy to see, it's becomes simple. Think of a video game like call of duty. In COD, u can be shot by assault rifles 7 times and if u just duck and hide for 10 seconds.....you'll be healed. Couldn't happen in "the real world", but in THAT combat simulation, it's possible because that's what's written into the program. This Verse was written to simulate events observed by entities outside of it. But it can't be 100% accurate, it's just a simulation, it's just similar to their verse. All the different sciences start to unify when you base it on a simulation rather than it being real or having absolute substance. What we observe, no matter what means is used to observe, is 100% cerebral and made not of the actual things we see or touch or taste or smell, but made from chemicals released in our brain due to electrical signal stimulus. I know I'm probably wrong about it all but since it's all in my head anyway.......I may be right
@CorwynGC
@CorwynGC 5 лет назад
"The more that light has to move by and through the more it is shifted towards the red spectrum. This can be seen locally with our Sun." That isn't what happens to sunlight when it goes through water. It gets bluer and bluer, not redder. Redshift isn't a filter of light so that red is more prevalent than blue (as happens at sunset), but rather a change in the frequency of each light wave. This can be checked by looking at the absorption spectrum lines in the light. In a sunset, the lines will not be shifted to the red, while in cosmic light from extreme distances it will be. JWST will be useless if the 'overused' theory of redshift is wrong. It is designed to see in the infrared, precisely because the light from distant galaxies is redshifted.
@collapsingquantumwav
@collapsingquantumwav 2 года назад
Let's make it simple : We're the dream of a sleeping pussy cat.😁
@fhuber7507
@fhuber7507 5 лет назад
Relative to Earth, everything else is moving and our planet is stationary. First we have to agree as to what point is stationary, before we can attempt to calculate absolute velocity.
@santiagoarbelaez1966
@santiagoarbelaez1966 5 лет назад
Nothing is in a stationary state in the universe. Everything is orbiting around something in continuous motion
@nia6849
@nia6849 5 лет назад
Why are other distant galaxies moving away from each other while our Milky Way and Andromas are moving toward each other? Is it because the MilkyWay and Androm are too close to each other due to gravitationally bound to each other?
@airfun5001
@airfun5001 5 лет назад
Rian yup
@Iamalizard
@Iamalizard 5 лет назад
So it took a hydrogencloud about 23 times circling the centre of the galaxy to form the sun as it is today ....that's pritty fast I'd say :P
@fernandozenomiranda9470
@fernandozenomiranda9470 5 лет назад
Love your explanation. I wish I could be as a passionate as you are with science and astronomy, or at least with something. The thing is there is nothing that drives me enough to work for it and spend time on it. I hope that by studying engineering something big sparks inside me and gives me the passion needed to live for it, be it science, physics or just something.
@ruthfannin9990
@ruthfannin9990 5 лет назад
Fernando Zeno Miranda Many of us experience a lack of an inner zeal and it can happen anytime in our lives. Myself, I had so much drive and creativity when I was younger but lost it in my mid-thirties. I don't know if it will return and I haven't been able to kick start it back. If you are drawn to the sciences especially the Big Questions maybe you might find that inner passion in Physics instead of Engineering. If I had it all to do over again I would.
@flossietube2065
@flossietube2065 2 года назад
Let's see how many speeding ticket jokes there are in the comments section...
@Slick_Nick11
@Slick_Nick11 5 лет назад
What if there are intergalactic civilizations in the Laniakea super cluster and the reason we haven't encountered any aliens or or why we're not apart of their governmental systems is because we're not close enough to the super cluster for them to care about us.
@airfun5001
@airfun5001 5 лет назад
Nick Davis why would you think there are orher civilizations?
@larrysherk
@larrysherk 5 лет назад
The question doesn't mean anything because speed is always measured relative to something else. The speed of the Earth around the Sun is one number, the speed of the earth with respect to the center of the galaxy is another number, and you can choose any reference point you want without prejudice.
@420snoogins
@420snoogins 5 лет назад
A question that doesn't mean anything? Like the sitcom Seinfeld?
@johnhughes7491
@johnhughes7491 2 года назад
The question should have been how fast are we traveling around the sun
@invox9490
@invox9490 5 лет назад
We are trapped in a cosmic traffic jam... Story if my life.
@mistercrab
@mistercrab 5 лет назад
I'm traveling faster than light when I need to buy beer and the shop is closing in 10 minutes.
@Apollyon-sz9sn
@Apollyon-sz9sn 5 лет назад
Space doesnt exist, and earth is stationary. Until there's a paradigm shift, we ain't learning Jack shit.
@tgstudio85
@tgstudio85 5 лет назад
And you are an idiot;)
Далее
Interview with NASA's Michelle Thaller - C2 Montreal
28:22
Was The Universe Born From Nothing?
41:50
Просмотров 4,8 млн
Why Does Light Exist? What is Its Purpose?
15:10
Просмотров 624 тыс.
How Earth Moves
21:37
Просмотров 30 млн
The REAL Movement of Earth Through the Galaxy
18:08
Просмотров 1,9 млн
Hacking Reality [Official Film]
28:07
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Why Does The Universe Look Like This?
46:50
Просмотров 4,3 млн