I just cannot get enough of Nadia May’s version. I’ve listened to it twice now. I’ll have to give Newton’s a try but May’s has a special place in my heart of being the first to tell me the story of Jane Eyre ❤️
My favorite literature professor used to say "There are two kinds of people in the world: the Wuthering Heights people and the Jane Eyre people." I am afraid, after reading Wuthering Heights multiple times, that I enjoy it better than Jane Eyre. Jane Eyre, however, is what made me study literature in college. That story was riveting and sorrowful.
@@carokat1111Sorry you didn’t much like WH. What gets to me about WH is that women say they don’t like, say, men like Heathcliff, but actually many fall for such brutally cunning and manipulative men … time and time again. It’s one of the few books I’ve read more than twice.
@@csbenzo I read it in high school and was fascinated by it but didn't enjoy the experience at all. Decided to try again age 40 and I think I liked it even less! I don't think I will try for third time lucky.
@@carokat1111 You have a point in unlikeable characters in WH. My interest is in Heathcliff, is in that many years ago I had my “Heathcliff moment”. Overnight I went from quiet law-abiding nerdy chess player with minimal social life to major suspect in a kidnap murder, purely by bizarre circumstantial associations. I featured in the news, too. I was mortified and thought this is the end of what little social life I have. Couldn’t have been more wrong. I was to discover that women of all ages, married or single, love celebrity, even alleged criminal celebrity. They like the thrill of danger. The edgy. Being able to tell their friends they survived the night with a major suspect. Not all women, of course, but an inordinate number. My social life improved quite dramatically. It was then that I realised Emily Brontë was on to something. Secretly and not so secretly, woman want Heathcliff. And this is why the book is so popular.
Jane Eyre is one of my favourite comfort novels and has helped me through high school, college, illnesses and loneliness. It's also distracted me from my disability as do other things. I first read Jane Eyre aged 11 and fell in love with both Jane and everything about the novel. I remember not liking Mr Rochester very much as he deceives Jane but after many readings of the novel, I began to sympathise with him as he's not had an easy life with Bertha. It's a beautiful and romantic book and I've loved it for 23 years. Thanks for the video and giving me an opportunity to talk about novels Ben. X
Thank you so much for sharing such a beautiful appreciation of this masterpiece, Kate. I love how special Jane Eyre is to you. Great literature truly has a life-saving power and our favourite writers end up becoming our close friends. I don't know where I would personally be without writers like Charlotte Brontë :) x
@BenjaminMcEvoy Thank you for your lovely message, Ben. I learnt about The Brontes on a school trip to Haworth in October 1999, aged 10. I visited The Bronte Museum and fell in love with the family. I read Jane Eyre in the autumn of 2000 just as I started high school which wasn't the easiest time for me so Jane Eyre helped me. The novel still continues to comfort me through dark times. I own two editions of the book. My aunt bought me a 1930s copy in 2011 and my parents gave me the Folio Society edition for my birthday a few years ago. It's beautifully illustrated. I've read Wuthering Heights but I find the book dark and disturbing. I really like The Tenant of Wildfell Hall too. I wish Anne got more credit for her novel. I love Juliet Stephenson's narration of Jane Eyre which I own on Audible. I want to listen to it again. I think books do help us and comfort us through life. Ben, thank you very much again for allowing the opportunity to discuss my beloved Jane Eyre. 😊 x
I read Jane Eyre in Spanish when I was around 15 years old and I loved it so much that I had to read it again a couple years later, now that I’m 26 and a lot more fluent in English I must read it in it’s original language so that I can enjoy it in all of its glory :)
Jane’s personal strength is what makes this my all time favorite book. I first read it in 2018 and read it a second February/March of this year. I too actively thought about the story when I had put the book down even after finishing it as well. Prior to reading Jane Eyre, I had read Villette, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, Agnes Grey, Wuthering Heights, and all of Jane Austen’s books. As for my choice of male leads, definitely Mr. Rochester. He drew Jane out of the corner so she was able to participate in the evening’s discussions and challenged her intellectually, while Heathcliff’s highly emotional nature of jealousy, anger, and violence were not appealing to me. I very much enjoyed watching this video and it is making me want to pick up my copy of Jane Eyre again!
jane eyre was one of the first novels that made me fall in love with reading. prior, i didn’t read much, but i always enjoyed the classics i had to read for school. i remember picking up a three dollar copy of jane eyre and it collected dust for two years before i finally decided to read it; and wow- i’m lucky i did. not only did it introduce my own volition and soul into the world of literature, but it truly changed my perspective on the world. to the brontë sisters!
Dear @Ben I know its not in this year’s syllabus, but reading Wide Sargasso Sea just after reading Jane Eyre would be such a mind blowing experience… I love Jane Eyre, but after reading WSS, it radically changes your whole perspective on the novel and the characters… once you read it you’ll never see Jane Eyre with the same eyes again… it’s Such a great example of conversations happening through literature… ❤
This book was a great distraction to me during India’s particularly brutal second wave of Covid. Hearing the name “Jane Eyre” is enough to take me back to that time.
i can relate. i hated how scared all of us were of the 2nd wave. constantly feeling terrified, so many people dying everyday. im happy that you could find comfort in this book. for me, i could not get myself to read any book during that time.
jane eyre, one of the first classics that i read and fell in love with. fascinating book and easily accessible , highly recommended classic for beginners
Would you describe it as an easy read in terms of style and vocabulary? I am a non-native speaker and I am hesitant to start reading it. I get so annoyed when I start reading a book and get bored when the vocabulary is too complicated then end up throwing it away.
@@KawtarElAzouki yes i would describe it as a relatively easy book for beginners the plot and style is straightforward especially for a classic, you might encounter a few words or phrases that you dont understand but that is a positive and good learning opportunity. and i am also a non native English speaker and i enjoyed it thouroughly
Hello Benjamin. I do enjoy your videos. Amazing!!! Charlotte Bronte and her protagonist Jane Eyre have each touched me in so many ways. Sheltered, with hardly any experience in the ways of relationships and yet understanding so well the depths of passion and romantic love, being solid in her feminine strength even at a time of repression and being so deeply in touch with her inner truth, makes this amazing author so ahead of her times. I love the other Bronte’s as well for these qualities. Thank you for your introspective insights. ❤️🙏🏾
I read Jane Eyre after reading Agnes Grey and loved both books in different ways for the different reading experiences with them. Jane Eyre truly a deeply moving book that captivates the reader with the passion conveyed between the lines.
Hi Benjamin. Congratulations on 100k subscribers! Your channel is what got me into reading classic literature. I have always enjoyed reading but I never really even considered reading the classics until I saw how interesting you made them all sound. I’ve now read and enjoyed Crime and Punishment, The Illiad, and I have about 150 pages left of War and Peace lol.
Hi Benjamin, I just found you on You Tube. I am a prolific Victorian reader, but your You Tube on Marcel Proust really intrigued me. I bought all 7 volumes of In Search of Lost Time and soon will begin a deep reading of In Search of Lost Time. I will soon be turning 70 years of age. I have lost much time in my life, some of the time quite frivolous but now that I am reaching 7 decades I think the best gift I can give myself is read "In Search of Lost Time." I have prepare myself by purchasing a lovely journal to have beside me while I read and then write my inner thoughts and experience of what I read and perhaps connect what I write from my past experience, or even what I would love to experience henceforth. I believe this is the perfect time to read Marcel Proust and will adhere to all your suggestions in the video. Thank you for finding a treasure in your channel.
Yay! Thank you for the great content Benjamin. You make these works available to so many people with your knowledge, enthusiasm and love for these books. Your work is love made visible as you always say. Keep it up
Jane Eyre is my favourite out of the Brontës. It's very complex and personal, and as a woman I can relate to her. This discussion is very insightful and I agree with you, it is a somewhat rebellious book in their time. It is such a treat rereading it! Hope you can discuss more of the Brontë Sisters. Wuthering Height is so poetic and dark but I think Anne Brontë is least talked about. Tenant of Wildfell Hall is my favourite in her works.
I just wanna say I absolutely love your Channel Benjamin! I only discovered it very recently but I can't get enough of your videos. You are amazing at talking about the books you focus on. I started getting into reading more in the last few years after ignoring that passion for a long time but I think that passion has always been hiding inside me. I just needed my first attempts at reading some great novels that have that alluring aura around them in order to truly ignite that burning flame of passion. Greetings from Germany
Team Rochester here. 😍Great discussion of my favorite novel. You've inspired me to read deeper and wider all of the Bronte sisters' works (I've only read Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights) and the biographies. Thank you!
Dude, you are simply awesome. I enjoy literature but find myself studying the writers and the back stories more and more as time goes by. You do such a great job at explaining the back stories, keep up the great work.
Thank you so much, my friend. That is so kind of you to say. You have completely made my day. I appreciate you being here and enjoying these great books with me! :)
I'm so excited for this one too, Jenny! I love how much affection there is for Jane Eyre. It's definitely going to be a very special reading experience :)
@@BenjaminMcEvoy Also, let me give you another big THANK YOU for recommending the book, "The Secret History of Jane Eyre." I'm reading that now and you are correct, it is definitely a fascinating read (and anyone who loves Jane Eyre will learn something new by reading it.).
I just found a few classics at the thrift store, including Jane Eyre, Barnes & Noble classics edition. I have always wanted to read it, and I am a bit late to the party (I'm54). I definitely want this to be "life changing," and I want to love it so much that I want to keep going and read all of the Brontë sisters' works. I think you would make an excellent narrator as well. 📖
I finished Jane Eyre, for the first time, two days ago. I was so moved by this novel! At times I read too quickly because I wanted the story to go in a different direction and I was so upset with Miss Bronte! I miss it already, and now that I can relax into the plot, I want to start it again and savor what I blew past. I feel so connected to Jane. I don't think I've ever rooted harder for a main character.
Never clicked this fast! Another banger by sir Ben! Jane Eyre is actually on my list and I can't wait to read it after my current novel which is Wuthering Heights. Thank you for this amazing content sir!
Thank you so much, my friend! I really appreciate that :) I love that you're going to read Jane Eyre right after Wuthering Heights! I would be very keen to know which one resonates with you the most!
I hope you read it if you have not yet it is the first classic I read and still my favorite glad there are no spoilers as this is one you should experience as it happens
I am currently studying this book for my British Literature class, this video comes out at the perfect time ! This book is new to me and I like it so far !
I don't think Brontë disliked Austen out of jealously but different approaches. I studied art history and Katy Layton Jones describes the difference of the two rival schools of the Italian Renaissance. Florentines worked frescos on plaster and the emphasis was on draftsmanship as you needed to have a design in your head to work your painting quickly before it dried - that's Austen neat precise work in intricate directly onto the wall - detailed work on small canvases. In Venice it was too wet from frescos so they painted in oils and used layers to build up dramatic landscapes of light and darkness. The Florentines derided the Venetians as not able to draw properly and the Venetians as being passionless and unable to evoke emotional landscapes. Austen poked fun at gothic literature whilst appreciating it - Florentine. Brontë called Austen passionless whilst appreciating her craft somewhat - Venetian. I love both but you appreciate how Brontë couldn't appreciate Austen. Interesting they are both clergymen daughters. Mark Twain didnt like Austen when he was talking about her as one of the few times i think he was talking out of his arse so to speak. Weirdly enough Juliet Stephensen played Mrs Elton in the film of Emma.
This book is my favorite,im currently reading it and enjoying the plot. The other book i was reading was Wuthering by her sister Emily. I'm planning to read Anne Bronte's The Tenant of Wildfell Hall and Agnes Grey as well Charlotte's three books The Professor, Villete and Shirley
20:49 I just found a copy of this used on World Of Books. I'm so curious to see her personal letters, I wonder how much of her is actually in Jane Eyre.
Ben you might not need a dictionary by your side when you read Jane Eyre. I very definitely do. I bought them at the same time and the dictionary has fallen apart first.
Yes! English is my second language and I kept referring to the dictionary every paragraph 😂 definitely not an easy read for me, but loved every bit of it.
I’ve re read Jane Eyre more than any other book. I loved taking time out every summer to read it but that was a few years ago. I’ve been thinking about joining the Hardcore Literature Book Club. This video has persuaded me absolutely. I’ve leant so much from it. Thank you Ben.😊
Thank you so much, Sarah :) I'm so happy you enjoyed the video so much! I'm thrilled that you're joining the discussion at the book club. I can't wait to hear your insights as we read through this masterpiece. I can definitely understand why you have reread this book so much. Truly such an astonishing novel! 😊
Hello Benjamin. I like your podcast and You Tube channel. I have always liked the idea of 'living' the books I read. The characters becoming real people. I do not know of many who feel this way, so it was truly refreshing to hear you say that. May there be many more discussions to come. Take care. From the divided states.
This book had a profoundly therapeutic effect on me when I read it at 13. I so related to feeling misunderstood and dismissed like young Jane. Her strength strengthened me through the years.
In the early 90s I read Jane Eyre for the first time as part of A level English. It was by far the best thing to come out of that course and it’s been my favourite novel ever since. I still cry at all the same parts every time I read it!
I have a strong desire to join the Hardcore Literature Club and hope to do so sooner rather than later. I have read Jane Eyre about 3 or 4 times but right now I just started re-reading Villette for the second time. While Jane Eyre is undoubtedly the more popular and is considered her masterpiece, my personal favorite is Villette. Other than all the French in it, which being an American I'm woefully ignorant of, I just love it. Your suggestions on how to read Jane Eyre I think will help me read Villette in a way I didn't the first time. Thank you for all you do and for your generosity. It is much appreciated.
Benjamin, when listening to you, I’m always trying to understand your intelligence that allows you to speak without interruption, showing a complete immersion into the literature. Also, Wuthering Heights has always been my favorite novel. Heathcliff had to overcome so much from an early age.
I’m excited that you made an in depth video on this one. I’m reading this right now. I’m 4 chapters in and loving every page. I did a month of the Proust tier last month and I listen to the podcast as well. Been following for a while Ben. I love your perspectives on everything. Your passion is infectious. - Tony
Thank you so much, Tony. That means the absolute world to me :) I am so grateful to have you watching and reading along with me. I'm thrilled that you're loving Jane Eyre so much. It really is such a masterpiece. I would love to hear what you make of the rest of it because it keeps getting better and better throughout!
@@BenjaminMcEvoy when she cries out “Deceit is not my fault!” I nearly cried the scene is so powerful. I felt elation for Jane in that moment, and was blown away how Brontë was able to connect me to her character so deeply in only a few chapters, but I knew I was in love when I read her description of sitting by the window pane and looking out at the damp November day, before the first incident with John Reed. That’s when I knew I was all in.
Excellent essay. I'd like to see more top hundreds but of all types short stories, with maybe one divided into genres, too. It's a great way to encourage readers into the reading habit.
In Charlotte's passionate letter, I see more of Mr. Rochester than Jane Eyre. I still feared for him on a recent re-reading of the original - even having read the russian translation a decade ago. Jane has Faith and Reason to ground her, and years of experience compartmentalizing her past to keep functioning. Mr. Rochester's emotional immaturity is captured well in Wide Sargasso Sea, the prequel by Jean Rhys.
Incredible video. Incredible passion. I will start Jane Eyre for the first time soon. I'm sure now it will be very inspiring - you're doing fantastic work!
This is so well researched and informative! When I had first read Jane Eyre, I read it as an interesting story which I had enjoyed. But now whenever I will re read it, I will see Charlotte Brontë in it.
I just finished Jane Eyre and it’s a book I find to be very good in some parts and boring in other parts. But it hooked me and kept me thinking about it after reading, so that’s something. I love this video, gives me more insight about things surrounding the book.
Congratulations on finishing Jane Eyre! It sounds like you gave it a very deep reading. It's definitely a sign of a profound work when you continue to think about it after you've finished! :)
Bravo to you man, for explaining the joy of reading this (and other) book! The way you go about it reminds me very much of my English teacher back in the day. I am very glad I found your channel here! I love the 19th century classics, A specially the English and Russian classics in this century!
Thank you, from Stockholm Sweden, believe it or not I was just about to start reading Jane Eyre, and how lucky was I not, so now when I have a better understanding of the milieu and the author it will be a happening instead of merely reading a book. How fun.
Benjamin McEvoy, you are a wealth of knowledge! You have a special gift to get one's interested on "Hardcore Literature", pun intended. English is my second language, and I have been trying to immerse myself onto the classics of English literature. I read Jane Eyre last year and found it fantastic. Back in 2001, I started my journey into the USA life, at the same time, I read Wuthering Heights. As for your question regarding Mr. Rochester versus Heathcliff characters' traits, I find Mr. Rochester less evil, less cunning, more likeable, yet, as a rebel woman, I feel more "attracted" to Heathcliff, always going for the dangerous type (insert laugh!). I am currently reading The Picture of Dorian Gray, and your video on the book that turned Dorian evil it's masterful too. Thank you for your talks and videos. You are a fountain of literature inspiration!
Thanks for the video. Last year you encouraged me to read Tolstoy's Anna Karenenina. Now I am going to go for Bronte's Jane Eyre. Soon I will be joining your book club. Thanks a lot ❤❤😊
You're so welcome. Thank you so much for watching, Cecilia. I am so happy to hear that you read Tolstoy's great novel. I can't wait to hear what you make of Charlotte Brontë's masterpiece! ❤️🙏
Top drawer, as usual. Your videos are an oasis, an escape from the mundane. I'm obsessed with the Brontes at the moment, and surprise surprise, along came your video. Thanks, guv'nor. 🙏🏽
Thank you so much Benjamin for this video full of great information on Charlotte's life and the Gothic form. Your passion for the great books is absolutely contagious. I love it! You made me pick up and appreciate Moby Dick!! I read Jane Eyre in French many years ago and I absolutely fell in love with it. She shows us the way to resilience, inner strength and love. What a model of fortitude! My goal is to read it in English. I'm sure it will be a different reading experience.
There's a companion novel to "Jane Eyre." It's called "Wide Sargasso Sea." Wiki says: The novel serves as a postcolonial and feminist prequel to Charlotte Brontë's novel Jane Eyre (1847), describing the background to Mr. Rochester's marriage from the point-of-view of his wife Antoinette Cosway, a Creole heiress.
I read this way before J.E. and if I remember correctly, it shows Bertha as innocent victim, thus totally ignoring Charlotte Brontë's characterization of Rochester.
Thank you, Benjamin, for another brilliant video. Definitely team Rochester. Heathcliff is too brutish, violent, and cruel, though he did have a difficult childhood. My first reading of Jane Eyre when I was in my teens in university. That was after reading Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. You can imagine the shock. It was like experiencing day and subsequently night. Jane Eyre and Charlotte Bronte are just so modern and the message of equality is still relevant today. For me, in my teens, I was not able to appreciate the wit of Jane Austen and quite tired of reading about having teas and ball dance again and again. Jane is plain so unlike the conventional heroine in those days and more relatable and you can see her growth as a person in the novel. Wuthering Heights is indeed a standalone, and I love it too. The gothic atmosphere evoked is so enveloping and seeps into your veins. Also read Anna Karenina and love it. Jane Eyre and Tess of the D'urbervilles were my favorites in my teens and still have a special place in my heart some 40 years later. I have read them many, many times. Thinking of joining the book club. Want to read Jane Eyre again.
Yay, one of my favorites! 👏🏻Looking forward to a fourth read with Hardcore Literature Bookclub and hearing your in depth, thought provoking lectures along the way! Thank~you, Benjamin.
Thank you so much, Suzanne :) I can't wait to hear your thoughts from your fourth reading of this masterpiece! I can feel that this is going to be a very special reading experience!
I’ve read Jane Eyre several times, but after watching this, I feel compelled to read it again. Is too late to join the book club? The first time I read Jane Eyre was when I was 14. I was sick at home and my English class was watching the film adaptation. Since I missed it, I decided to read the book, which was actually not assigned reading. I fell in love with the book and was almost glad I got sick. I’ve since read it a couple more times. It just keeps getting better. I am also a fan of Wuthering Heights. Heathcliff and Rochester are such different characters, it would be interesting to do a close reading comparison of the two. Also, you mentioned gothic novels, and I just recently finished reading The Mysteries of Udolpho. Hard to get through the overly effusive descriptions of scenery, but I am so glad I read it.
Enjoyed the presentation on Jane Eyre! I came very late to JE after a number of failed attempts as a younger man. It was a different experience from WH, which was like trying to read a hurricane. Jane is a Protestant saint who will not bow to her oppressors and is rewarded for it. JE reminded me of Robinson Crusoe, except the island she's marooned on is England and the people who make her miserable are the cannibals. As Harold Bloom said, the Brontes are more like themselves than they resemble any contemporary writer.
Read it at age 14 and never once thought it was deep. Didn't know there was such a thing. Just a page turner. What an interesting tidbit, " an autobiography ."
I just read it for the first time recently and it blew me away! Not since Dickens have I come across an author who utilizes first-person narration in such a memorable and engaging way. When I read Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte a couple of years ago, it became one of my favorite novels ever. Jane Eyre is also now one of my favorites. So much so, that I have already put other novels aside and started reading Villette. At this rate, when I develop my own top 10 list in the future, it's likely going to be primarily made up of books by Dickens and the Bronte sisters. It's too soon to make any definitive statements because I have not yet read even a tenth of the literature of the great 19th-century novelists. That being said, in my (limited) reading experience so far, Victorian literature is the GOAT!
I read it first when I was a lonely preteen. There were many aspects of Jane that I could identify with. Plus I was so happy to be someone's confidant even if it was a character in a book by a long dead author.
I've just joined your Book Club today and I'm super excited to start the journey! It's going to be a tough choice between Anna Karenina (which I read in high school but want to re-read with a more slow and thoughtful approach) and Jane Eyre which I haven't read. I'm one of those people who often read several books in parallel so maybe that's what I'll have to do this time! 😅
We're so happy that you're reading with us, Natalia!! I'm so excited to hear your insights as we read through these great books together. It's definitely a tough choice between Anna Karenina and Jane Eyre. They're both such beautiful masterpieces and contain so much wisdom. And it sounds like you have the same reading style as me! I love running multiple books in parallel. I find that the authors start to speak to each other when I do that 😊
@@BenjaminMcEvoy Thank you for a warm welcome! I have been catching up on a lot of your videos and one of them was about your reading style. It was the first time I finally felt at peace with mine because of you sharing that! I used to think it’s kind of silly/not productive to surround myself with 8-10 books in one evening and look through some sections from each for 10-15 min. To be fair I do it mostly with non-fiction books on the same or similar topic. With fiction it would be “only” 3-4 at a time. 😂 But yes, your sharing your experience made me feel seen! Thank you!
Brilliant...what about the first person narrative? I have found this book such a profound reflection of my own life...,hard to imagine such strong identification with a fictional character.
Jane Eyre is one of the most honest and fearless books I've ever read. Charlotte Bronte says what she thinks and feels so frankly that it's scary. My favorite novel next to Moby Dick.
I only read Jane Eyre this year after putting it off, well, most of my life. Once I read it though, I was utterly drawn in. Why hadn’t I ever read this brilliant novel?! (I asked myself). It made me realise how I had some wrong assumptions about books. In the end, I bought copies of this book and gave them as gifts to my female friends urging them to read it and have their lives changed as well. (Yeah I became THAT person!) 🤣 Thank you for your videos. They are all brilliant!
Really enjoyed this -- *thank* *you* (& very much thinking about joining the book club just to hear your further lectures :) An aside but to Charlotte's dislike of Austen, it always struck me as possibly because Austen is so (comparatively) spare in her prose -- she says what is necessary, and often with a proverbial razor -- Brontë's language is utterly and completely different and I wonder if Austen seemed like something of a cold fish to her given the kind of intensity in/with which they wrote their novels and lived their lives.
Thank you Benjamin. Reminded me of the Antiques Roadshow where a woman turned out to own a mourning ring with a lock of Charlotte’s hair in it. Staggering - worth a Google if you haven’t seen it.
Thank you so much for recommending this, Annette! I've just watched the clip and that is seriously so cool!! I love the collective gasp from the crowd at the evaluation! What an incredible treasure to have! ❤️
Ben, Just finished my second read through of JE and finally made time to watch your video. I know it was spoiler free but wanted to have it fresh on my mind before watching. Now we definitely need a spoiler-filled video! I was so disturbed by Jane Eyre on my second read through…she is young enough to be Rochester’s daughter! I think she has daddy issues :/ she is so obsessed with serving and pleasing others and I feel Mr. R really took advantage of that. I will say at least we know neither had interest in the other based just on looks. But (spoiler) when she insists on leaving and he whispers in her ear that he may get violent…that is just unforgivable to me! Maybe it’s my knee-jerk reaction as a DV survivor? Maybe he didnt mean he would hit her but that he would become violent and break things around him? Either way, so childish of him. To throw a tantrum when he doesnt get what he wants. And for St. John to do the same, the way he WHINED like a toddler, “But it’s not what I want…it’s not what I want!” Seriously! Then he accused her of not doing what GOD wants her to do. I can only look past Jane going back to Mr. R since he tried to save poor Bertha in the fire and stopped begging Jane to come back even though at that point, their marriage would have been legal. Speaking of Bertha, I’ve seen criticism that this novel is racist and I didn’t quite catch that until my recent reread. My first “read” of Jane Eyre was listening to the audiobook and I have terrible ADHD and missed a few details! Caught the second time around that Bertha was Creole I think? I cant remember off the top of my head. But it was insinuated that she was darker complected, when we find out how she and Mr. R met. This was after the scene where she ripped Jane’s veil in the night where she was described as having long dark hair and swollen purple lips. Wondering what your thoughts are. Thank you for such an in-depth video! This is the first I heard of Wuthering Heights and Agnes Grey being published together. Coincidentally picked those two up on my birthday last month. Diving into WH now! Thanks again and take care Ben!
I’ve just found your channel and I’m loving it. I read Jane Eyre in my teens and I can still feel its effect 50 odd years later. Some of your recommendations seem a bit highbrow for me - I didn’t have a university education 😢. But I’m tempted to give one or two of them a try. Also many of today’s paperbacks have quite small impacted pages, which I find off putting. Suggestions welcome. I have read - or tried to - James Joyce’s Ulysses - and I didn’t understand it at all. I just assumed I’m not clever enough. I’ve read most of Steinbeck and I love Ishiguro. Where to begin on the deep dive into literature appreciation - or should I stick to gardening 😅
Happy you mentioned King's Danse Macabre, Thackeray, Bronte and Dickens were "popular" writers, that is why they ended up in "The Canon." If Radcliffe the Mother then Walpole the Father,😅. I seldom reread, but I have read Jane Eyre at least three times, possibly more, Charlotte is my favorite Bronte and yes, the companionate marriage was odd before the 20th century. Real life was all the horror you needed, when a marriage proposal was an invitation to an early death from complications of child birth. I am old, so two of my Great-Grandmothers died young from complications of child birth, each leaving one daughter to grow up being raised by women, who regretted their very existence and said so to their own children, now that is scary.😮
