DreamXD mentions there was another time traveler before Karl, maybe XD had to reset and make the characters forget their past because of a mistake the previous time traveler?
Just realized something. Adding on to your theory, if this is true, that means that Karl could accidentally run into the time period in which the past time traveler (probably Ranboo ) made that huge mistake. I hope we're both right.
In talking about people bringing memories and experience from other servers, I'm surprised you never mentioned the fact that, when Techno first joined the server, Wilbur asks him to make a potato farm for them, and brings up how he has experience with potato farms, and obvious reference to the potato wars on Hypixel Skyblock, which seems to imply those events, and the rest of Skyblock, happened in Techno's past. This furthers my headcanon that Hypixel is a country made of floating islands, and exists in the dsmp universe, just too high up for most people to reach. Techno arrived to this land in search of the glory of combat, and after becoming the most feared warrior there, he abandoned it, going with Phil to conquer Earth from that other SMP. Then, with nothing left to conquer, he returned to the Skies, attempting to make a peaceful life as a humble potato farmer. Peace, however, was not for him, and he turned even a simple potato farm into a war. After being crowned both Potato King and Mayor of Skyblock, he once again had nothing to do. He reached the top, and no longer had anywhere to go, which is when he received word from Wilbur that they needed help in the dsmp, and he once again headed off to a new land in search of new glory. That's just my interpretation though. It neatly ties together most of Techno's previous series into his backstory, but otherwise has little effect on his character on the smp.
We actually do know something about Tubbo’s history: he was found in a box by Phil and adopted, presumably raised alongside Wilbur and having early exposure to Techno and Tommy, who were prior friends with Phil and Wilbur
I always just took each persons previous Minecraft experiences as their past or rather their "previous lives/home worlds" like Dream being a Runner with George, Sapnap,BBH,Ant and Sam being hunters, Techno being king of Hypixel and also conqueror of the world in Wilburs Earth SMP etc. ..... Anyone else had this as their head cannon? XD Edit: Yeah Philza is the best example of this, coming from his Hardcore world and carrying over his 1 life AND even his wings
The idea that "It is not in minecraft so it shouldn't be possible on the Dream SMP" isn't actually that good of an argument since there are a bunch of things in the DSMP lore that are not in vanilla minecraft. Like resurecting the dread, summoning lightning, scorpions (witch canonically live around Las Nevadas as confirmed by Wilbur) and the idea that some characters don't actually look like their in game skins. But the idea that Tubbo can build these things while others can't because he has experience from a "previous life" is cool and honestly i can imagine it becoming canon. BTW Techno can rip apart mountains canonically (Technoblade YT channel, Past livestreams playlist, "The Favor" 38min 43 sec) So he is still very strong even compared to nukes.
A lot of these characters probably lived pretty average lives until they moved into the Dsmp, which explains why some decide to not give backstory to their characters. I like to think that Tubbo always knew how to work around complex technology since he was known as the builder & redstone guy when he first joined the smp, but that so far he hadn't had any reason as to why he'd make something as extreme as nukes. It's not before L'manberg was absolutely destroyed and after he'd lost whatever leverage people had over him that he decided to strengthen the protection around his soon to be new home, and it was only decided to be used as a last resort (as he didn't really have beef with anyone at that point).
Techno seems to also remember his past. He has said in a live stream that “where I come from we didn’t have 3 lives” or something similar. The livestream was when Eret, Tubbo, and Techno went a locked Sam in the prison.
And even aimsey says that she wasnt born into life knowing she could have three of them, so when tubbo killed her she thought she was done for completely.
3:15 and techno, techno mentioned in the stream where they saved Michel from Sam “Where I come from people don’t have multiple lives” I don’t know the time stamp but it’s after they pick up eret Really cool thearoy, I’ll take it into account looking at more lore streams in the future
I’m really excited to see what the character of Tubbo gets up to in the near future. I’m loving the recognition of the fact that he just might be the most powerful non magical person on the server now, and that means that if he’s pushed to the point of attacking someone there’s close to no stopping him. The only things I can think of that could pull Tubbo back would be, The fact that he only has one cannon life left and may not get revived after that’s gone, His friends getting threatened, Possibly threatening something he loves? Although from what I’ve seen recently he doesn’t seem to get emotionally attached to places or items easily.
Very cool, would like to say that Slime would probably also be a guy who remembers his backstory, though that’s story is just him being in the ground 3:15
Notably techno and ghostbur both have pre SMP memories. Wilbur has revealed the few thing Ghostbur still remembers and several take place Pre SMP including sparring with techno. And techno specifically recognizes Phil as an "old friend" Notably ghostbur is a ghost (which have weird memories anyway) and techno comes from somewhere else where "people don't get multiple lives" So both of these make (some) sense, plus they're both somewhat small or simple things.
This has always bothered me: Phil has 1 life because he played hardcore before dream smp. But Dream has 3 lives even though he played manhunt before dream smp where he had 1 life
I haven't watched the entire video yet so I'm not sure if you have mentioned it, but Niki has an entire backstory. She was born on the Perfect Smp with Bear where she grew up but became frustrated by how 'perfect' it was and so ran away. There she befriended Wilbur who later invited her to join L'Manberg. She hopped between Bear smp and Dream smp until bear smp was shut down.
Well if Philza can hop between dimensions, and Tubbo is his son, then perhaps Tubbo can also do it. He might have seen the destruction of L'Manburg and took a little trip to find himself into what is now the modded servers, and learned/gathered these nuclear abilities.
I've seen people theorizing that Techno isn't actually a player, but a mob like Charlie, a zombie pigman who was cured of the zombie plague and taught to speak and read, so he has one life like every other non-player mob.
2:29 🚨SPOILER ALERT🚨 Nobody stopped him. Tubbo and Jack dropped a nuke on the prison bc they wanted to kill Punz and Dream (Tommy distracted the villans giving Tubbo and Jack time, and wanted to dying like a hero). But Tubbo didn't want to Tommy die so him and Jack webt to the prison and the nuke exploded. It ends with an amnesia plot. (What Tommy and Dream said in the prison is smth about the past and other things, watch the vod for more info.) Well, you kinda predicted
honestly- based off the canon stuff that phil adopts tubbo in a box thing from like when ghostbur started existing or whatever- it would be pretty hilarious if phil had looked at a kid (tubbo) with an extensive past of nuclear warfare, who had gone through a ton, like, what the video talks about, and phil went to wilbur like yep hi wilbur heres your new brother he can nuke your insides but its all good :D
I have a theory that the dsmp and the outsiders amp are in basically the same universe. I think that the dsmp was one of the first versions of the maze where there was only one clearing so more people kept coming, and the clearing would keep expanding so the maze was so far away that over time they simply forgot about the maze in general. This would explain why people don't remember there lives before the dream smp and some get flashbacks and remember some (like puffy). This theory is most likely wrong, but I Just thought of the similarities and formed my theory.
hey, OBVIOUSLY the only LOGICAL reason Ranboo and Karl are SO forgetful is JUST because of the Inbetween, and we KNOW the Inbetween makes you forget things if you’re in it for too long, so of COURSE, NATURALLY, they forget things.
I suggest you research into the Bear SMP lore, because it is implied that canonically Dream SMP Niki was from there. (I think, I haven't caught up with the new lore for a while.)
see, this is why my headcanon is that tubbo is dreams younger brother and hasn't told or mentioned it to anyone, on top of being an admin, he was raised to be as good or even better than dream in PVP and had to act like he couldn't fight when the L'manburg revolution started
I would love to see a video about recent wilbur lore with tommy and dream there was something just missing dream giving in this easily wilbur swithing up on dream and is dream actually losing all his power or this was a small play in a big story @ani
this would explain a lot! tho i do hc that sam taught tubbo all he knows about machinery, bombs, and all that. (idk how sam would know how to build bombs but.. creeper??…idk he built the prison tho) bc didn’t sam and tubbo hang out for a while in the earlier server days????
@@ioan.c8868 yeah, but it is still a fun head cannon. i feel like there is so much we don’t get to see of the characters, we only get to see the parts that is shown on stream..
I’m just gonna go on a whim here we’re not be the same for dream and techno because dream is already discovered he can use God like magic what if he discovers he can use Godlike powers but if he discovers he’s like very powerful than he already is Techno already claimed to be the blood god can copy as a joke but what if he discovers maybe he’s actually the blood God or just someone who used to work for the blood god if dream and techno discover their past because techno somewhat remember someone of his past dream has no memories of his past or does it can you go more depth into that because it could be the same for them
I think that Technoblade's character if things came to it might side with Tubbo and "The death book" could also be used to kill tubbo and Sapnap could steal the nukes and his character would just practically throw them away nuking random things (most likely Tommyinnit)
-tubbo, nuke, could it be Drista?/ dreamXD (drista can actually explain things that are not suppose to exsist in the dsmp e.g. shulker) -people dont want to talk about their past ||possible reason||: too painful to recall happy/sad memories || it was just an average life, too busy to talk about it -people recognize other before they arrive dsmp, some even knew each other beforehand >> they have past memories + they can hear news from other server [phil and techno knew and is friend with each other for a very long time(phil knows about techno's voices), wilbur knew potato war, quackity's been to minecraft Monday etc.]
You forgot about Technoblade. He said in the saving Michael stream that were he came from people only has one life so that means Technoblade knows were he came from.
