Тёмный

How Voldemort Got His ORIGINAL Wand Back | Harry Potter Film Theory 

SuperCarlinBrothers
Подписаться 2,2 млн
Просмотров 84 тыс.
50% 1

Go to meundies.com/super for 20% off your first order and free shipping.
Today J dives deep into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to uncover how Voldemort got his original wand back after the perilous night of the Potter’s plight!
Tickets for Through the Griffin TOUR are ON SALE NOW!
supercarlinbrothers.com/events/
Tour dates:
Boston - 6/2
New York City - 6/3
Philadelphia - 6/5
Washington, D.C. - 6/13 (SOLD OUT!)
SEE YOU IN REAL LIFE BROTHER!
Through The Griffin Door
RU-vid :: / @throughthegriffindoor
Apple :: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify :: open.spotify.com/show/062Ypac...
#supercarlinbrothers #HarryPotter #JvsBen
Edited by : Isybelle Christley
Carlin Brothers Coffee & Merch ►► carlinbrothersmercantile.com
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

25 апр 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 764   
@SuperCarlinBrothers
@SuperCarlinBrothers 21 день назад
What a wonderfully weird and whacky Woldemort theory, amiright?
@dragoscristea7827
@dragoscristea7827 21 день назад
Peter Pettigrew rat form search rubble find wand. Right?
@greatlakes2047
@greatlakes2047 21 день назад
Yes. And what wonderful alliteration!
@luttara644
@luttara644 21 день назад
I actually contend the wand breaking only actually happens and matters for students who get expelled, so that they cannot illegally perform magic(as part of the statute of secrecy). This wouldn't matter for graduates who don't necessarily need the appropriate wand since they have the appropriate knowledge, so they don't really bother.
@OdinSmilesRavensLaugh72051
@OdinSmilesRavensLaugh72051 21 день назад
It's an interesting one, also think about the wizards who understand wandlore you'd think voldemorts yew and pheonix wand would be heavily desired as an insanely powerful wand particularly with the dark arts that goes without saying 🤷‍♂️ like obv those who know desire the elder wand but voldemorts wand.. hmm lol fun fact my wand in hogwarts legacy is actually yew and pheonix feather 😂 and yes it has the pale bone design as well... I'm a dark wizard what can I say dark arts fancy me and i fancy them 😅😅
@Cyandog102
@Cyandog102 21 день назад
Why so much alliteration
@iRule37
@iRule37 21 день назад
What if: SCB wrote the rest of Fantastic Beasts?
@m4xamillion966
@m4xamillion966 21 день назад
what if SCB rebooted the franchise completely
@SuperCarlinBrothers
@SuperCarlinBrothers 21 день назад
I'm game
@amberbanuelos7053
@amberbanuelos7053 21 день назад
Yes!! Only I’d want them to rewrite the last two movies; the first was good, the sequels… not so much.
@kayleighlehrman9566
@kayleighlehrman9566 21 день назад
Let SCB be the James Gunn of Wizarding World; full creative control over all projects, and final arbiters of what is and isn't canon (cough Cursed Child cough)
@richardchisenhall387
@richardchisenhall387 21 день назад
I'd like them to redo the whole series, with Harry as a Slytherin, Hermione as a ravenclaw and Ron as a Hufflepuff. Make Neville more integral as the main Gryffindor character, give Draco the redemption arc he deserves, give Hermione and Luna a deeper friendship and make the pairings Ron+Luna Harry+Hermione and Neville+Ginny as they all balance each other better. Ron is grounded while Luna is whimsical, Harry is lax while Hermione is active though they're both geniuses, and Neville is soft spoken and gentle while Ginny is brash and fiery it just feels like a better match up than what we got
@coolbrotherf127
@coolbrotherf127 21 день назад
The amount of alliteration in the script isn't lost on me lol It's pretty funny.
@SuperCarlinBrothers
@SuperCarlinBrothers 21 день назад
Glad you enjoy!
@ContesHistoireEtLegendes
@ContesHistoireEtLegendes 21 день назад
Omg I was only concentrating on the alliterations and rhymes and at one point I forgot to listen to the whole story and started pointing out the alliterations in my head 😂
@madethistocomment727
@madethistocomment727 21 день назад
​@SuperCarlinBrothers how many takes did you need? I feel like there would be a lot of tounge-tyed moments.
@apocalypsepack9769
@apocalypsepack9769 21 день назад
The entire thing reminds me of the V speech, V for Voldemort
@tjrs1618
@tjrs1618 21 день назад
@@SuperCarlinBrothers No quick cut away to V introducing himself to Evie. LOL Great job!! Was it in alphabetical alliteration?
@GTrevise
@GTrevise 21 день назад
I always assumed Peter got the wand the night the potters died, and stashed it somewhere. Then he picked it on the way to find voldy.
@MythStarFire
@MythStarFire 21 день назад
My thinking as well. He knew where the house was and when Voldy went. He might have even been there hiding and watching, since he knew to hide from Sirius within hours.
@jawstrock2215
@jawstrock2215 21 день назад
Actually, I think he might have gone there right after faking his death facing Sirius. That might have been the better timing. If only to see if it was true.
@ultrauniqueRRRfan216
@ultrauniqueRRRfan216 21 день назад
This is what I always thought happened too.
@lxena8033
@lxena8033 21 день назад
Bingo.... that's what I thought.... still do. He didn't need Lupin's wand to transform back to a rat. That's just a movie thing. In the books he uses it to stun Ron to get out of the shackles, ans stun Crookshanks. Also.... just gonna say, Hagrid would have given the wand to Dumbledore....so..... sorry, one of the few theories I can't get behind.
@joshuacarroll6668
@joshuacarroll6668 20 дней назад
@@lxena8033in the movie he wasnt using the wand to transform he was going to use lupins wand to attack or kill the gang. Harry uses Expelliarmus and he transforms after he’s been disarmed
@dawnmcauley6411
@dawnmcauley6411 21 день назад
My own theory for why Hagrid's and only Hagrid's want (but not the Death Eater's) was snapped was it was an aspect of expulsion specifically. In my mind, every *fully trained* witch and wizard has an irrevocable right to a wand. So where does the leave Hagrid? He wasn't fully trained. Magical schools not only exist to integrate young witches and wizard into the wizarding world but ensure that their magic is not a danger to themselves or others. Hagrid never received this full training and the snapping of his wand is a precaution against the potential danger of that, not an outright punishment of crime (it effectively is but it's not the purpose of such.)
@tikoimer
@tikoimer 20 дней назад
I thought the same and since Fantastic Beast even more. If there is one wand you want to snap in half, it would have been Grindlewald's. I know it was in America, but when the representative of the English Ministry got the wand, he also didn't destroy it. Maybe only the Minister of Magic may do it, but I still think MACUSA would have also done it then
@kairemeriniit
@kairemeriniit 5 дней назад
Still, what would define a fully trained one - with some of them raised in home and some quitting themselves as Fred and George?
@dawnmcauley6411
@dawnmcauley6411 5 дней назад
@@kairemeriniit Probably the OWLs. They seem to be standardized and are used to determine career path.
@colinayers3498
@colinayers3498 21 день назад
The alliteration is strong with this one
@TolliverHiker
@TolliverHiker 21 день назад
I was like…in my head…this is on purpose, right!? 😂
@SLX__13
@SLX__13 20 дней назад
There are ample alliterations appearing in this appealing announcement!
@CrazyxAngel93
@CrazyxAngel93 20 дней назад
I was thinking the same thing!😂
@kf10147
@kf10147 20 дней назад
Yeah the script sounds almost like AI it just does not sound natural or human
@Rizzob17
@Rizzob17 20 дней назад
I literally just commented the same thing, verbatim, haha.
@hatchera
@hatchera 21 день назад
The amount of awesome alliteration left me positively perplexed.
@SuperCarlinBrothers
@SuperCarlinBrothers 21 день назад
😉
@Miss_Myth
@Miss_Myth 21 день назад
Absolutely astonished alright! 😂
@fredkaanapu8693
@fredkaanapu8693 19 дней назад
Same 😅
@elfishmoss1457
@elfishmoss1457 19 дней назад
to be fair, I had the opposite experience, I couldn't watch the entire thing because of the alliteration
@crehenge2386
@crehenge2386 18 дней назад
Extremely annoying
@deviantmonday2427
@deviantmonday2427 21 день назад
There is such a thing as too much alliteration LOL
@Dreadjaws
@Dreadjaws 21 день назад
This is all plausible but also _extraordinarily_ complicated. I think a much likelier chain of events would be: - Voldemort kills the Potters - Sirius arrives, but in his rage he fails to notice the wand (or doesn't care) and goes straight for Peter - Peter fakes his death, escapes and arrives at the Potter house, either to see if it's true that Voldemort failed or with the express purpose of getting the wand - He gets the wand and goes into hiding - At some point he moves in with the Weasleys, leaving the wand stashed somewhere - All the events until and including Prisoner of Azkaban occur - Peter retrieves the wand from its hiding place and goes looking for Voldemort I find this much simpler and less dependant on a bunch of weird decisions and odd coincidences.
@UnfazedPhoenix
@UnfazedPhoenix 2 дня назад
If you're boring af and don't understand how this universe works sure. Also Peter wouldn't go to the scene of the crime after faking his death like that it makes no sense. Jay's theory is better as usual.
@Dreadjaws
@Dreadjaws 2 дня назад
@@UnfazedPhoenix Imagine being this ridiculous and not actually offering any counterpoint.
@wolfboy7778
@wolfboy7778 21 день назад
I actually think the whole diving for Lupin's Wand thing wasn't to transform, it was to get the magical cuffs off...which is ironic because getting out of handcuffs is literally muggle magic.
@nightleopard13
@nightleopard13 21 день назад
Carpe means seize...wandeum diem means Wand Day.
@SuperCarlinBrothers
@SuperCarlinBrothers 21 день назад
Yes i know
@listinglazily
@listinglazily 21 день назад
Isn't that why he said "wand the day"?
@SgtSupaman
@SgtSupaman 21 день назад
@@listinglazily , he said "seize the wand".
@laurynwalton
@laurynwalton 15 дней назад
My thought exactly! 😄
@TheGreatBambi13
@TheGreatBambi13 14 дней назад
Love that Out Cold reference
@robertgronewold3326
@robertgronewold3326 20 дней назад
My personal head Cannon is that the ministry of magic collected the wand as evidence after the Potter murder, but Augustus Rookwood of the Department of mysteries swapped out Voldemort's wand for a fake one and then put the real one in whatever meeting place the Death Eaters had. Fast forward 12 years and none of the other Death Eaters are going to the meeting place anymore, so Peter Pettigrew can just Waltz right in.
@emma_704
@emma_704 17 дней назад
That is certainly a good one!
@KristinSLuce
@KristinSLuce 20 дней назад
Given Occam's Razor (the simplest theory is usually correct), consider this instead: Pettigrew was skulking outside the Potter residence when Voldy went in. Why? Because he was about to be either honored beyond belief by Voldy, or something would go awry and he would be in terrible danger (from the Order, and Sirius in particular). He was the Secret Keeper and could therefore witness, in this case from outside, what would happen (like a rat). He sees the whole event go down and is thus the first one on the scene. He finds Voldy's cloak and wand, encounters his two dead "friends," and Harry, crying in his crib after this horrific ordeal. What does he do, rat that he is? He abandons baby Harry and his friends' corpses and flees with the only thing of value: the wand. He does not yet know what happened to Voldy, he has his own wand, and further he has not *won* this wand. So, he hides V's wand, buries it perhaps. Then he taunts Sirius into a duel (using his own wand) for two reasons: fake his own death (they find nothing but his finger, and his wand! which helps prove his death), and it gets Sirius into Azkaban so that Wormtail is now a bit safer in the world. He won't need his own wand as he is living as a rat. How did he turn himself into a rat without a wand? Under extreme circumstances, one can produce magic without a wand. Or, perhaps he kept his wand and it was lost in another way during the past 13 years of being in hiding. From there, the rest is history, and everything falls into place. Once Sirius and Remus discover him, he transforms, scurries away, retrieves Voldy's wand from hiding and goes searching for him-knowing that Voldy will take him back because he can prove that he is a "trusted servant" by having kept his wand as well as coming to find him.
@Jan_Koopman
@Jan_Koopman 20 дней назад
I loved the alliterations. And I don't know if it was intentional, but there seemed to be some rhymes and a rhythm, too. The entire video sounded like a poem. Chef's kiss
@adamfoust7663
@adamfoust7663 20 дней назад
The amount of alliteration is amazingly astonishing. Absolutely approve.
@blakdeth
@blakdeth 21 день назад
I think peter needed a wand to turn back into a rat was because they forced him out of his rat form using magic. He probably had some sort of spell on him that disabled transformations that he had to remove before transformating.
@LordTKII
@LordTKII 21 день назад
Or maybe he needed it because he was never as good as Sirius or James with the transformation, Peter wouldn't have managed the initial transformation without the help of James and Sirius. And additionally he hasn't used any magic let alone the transformation for thirtween years. Maybe he was just a bit rusty and he used the wand to make sure it worked.
@genio2509
@genio2509 21 день назад
6:17 I think Peter grabbed Lupin's wand because they had casted him the anti animagus spell, which blocked him from transforming, so he needed to cast the counter to scape.
@jawstrock2215
@jawstrock2215 21 день назад
plausible.
@windhelmguard5295
@windhelmguard5295 20 дней назад
Peter also claimed lupins wand against lupins will at that moment and was thus its master, whereas he was not the master of voldemorts wand and thus couldn't have used it effectively anyway.
@reinkdesigns
@reinkdesigns 21 день назад
I never viewed it as Peter needing a wand to transform, I assumed lupin put a jinx on him preventing him from turning back into a rat and he needed a wand to undo that
@LunaBeth97
@LunaBeth97 21 день назад
Idk if I prefer the mental image of a rat using its own tiny wand or a rat attempting to use a normal sized wand
@gqsmooth1969
@gqsmooth1969 21 день назад
My vote is for tiny wand. I want to see that now lol.
@paraschauhan1603
@paraschauhan1603 21 день назад
Scintillating speculation aside, the stream of syntactically specialized shooting-off was stupendously stimulating.
@tamarmolerick3814
@tamarmolerick3814 21 день назад
The "how did Voldemort/ Sirius/ Death Eaters get their wands back" question really is a gaping plot hole
@Mary_Studios
@Mary_Studios 21 день назад
Possibly Sirius got a new wand for order of phoenix by Dumbledoor's request to Olivander, it's quite possible that since he gave some of Fox's feathers they're on good terms, or even just used a family members old wand if it was still in the house.
@fhbirsidha
@fhbirsidha 20 дней назад
Just bought/forcefully took one from any wand shop... Multiple wands can choose a wizard
@musicjunkiie2393
@musicjunkiie2393 20 дней назад
It could be that dumbledore summond his wand for him once his innocence was proven (despite him knowing all along that he was innocent of getting the potters directly murdered)
@cmarie1357
@cmarie1357 20 дней назад
The whole thing with Sirius’s wand has bothered me for YEARS.
@rachelmanning5709
@rachelmanning5709 19 дней назад
Two words. Government incompetence.
@CharpyTheHedgehog
@CharpyTheHedgehog 21 день назад
Love your theory videos! Have you ever thought about making a video on how the series has a chiastic structure, meaning the books are mirrored to each other, hinged around book 4. So 1 and 7 are mirrored, 2 and 6 are mirrored, 3 and 5 are mirrored. Those pairs all have similar themes and patterns, to an uncanny degree. Book 4 is the centrepiece and has parallels to 1 and 7 (for example those three books are the only books where Ollivander and Wandlore feature and the only books where dragons feature (baby dragon Norbert in book 1, mother dragon Hungarian Horntail with her egg in book 4 and elderly dragon Ukrainian Ironbelly in book 7 in Gringotts). It's really fascinating!
@kex5835
@kex5835 20 дней назад
Assuming that Petigrew could use Voldemort's wand at all seems like a guess. And the fear of Voldemort finding out that he used his wand could also prevent him form even trying to do so.
@lidular
@lidular 21 день назад
If you were wondereing the line "pocketed it" appears in all 7 books as a bit of an inside joke/ prank on Stephen Fry. He had a lot of trouble saying it as he narrated the philosophers stone audiobook. He therefore called the auther and asked if it was alright if they changed it to "put it in his pocket" she responded no, and then made sure to put it in every single book from then on, just to annoy him
@imaginepageant
@imaginepageant 21 день назад
Thanks for explaining, I had no idea about that! Reminds me of how the Scottish David Tennant had trouble saying the “oo” sound in a British accent as the Doctor, so the writers named an alien race the Ood just to make him say it a hundred times in one episode. 😆
@SmerkyRandomised
@SmerkyRandomised 20 дней назад
​@@imaginepageant true lol, i think they messed with him even more in the episode with the Judoon platoon upon the moon!
@imaginepageant
@imaginepageant 20 дней назад
@@SmerkyRandomised Omg yes! I forgot about that!
@53prime
@53prime 19 дней назад
Additionally the reason she refused to change it for him was because when he arrived to record Philosophers Stone and he met her he was just told "it's a children's story and it's getting a sequel" and he was pretty smug about it, so she was petty about his request.
@Cheesehead_Caleb
@Cheesehead_Caleb 20 дней назад
The amount of alliteration in this video is awesome.
@williamjeska3711
@williamjeska3711 21 день назад
As for how people get there wands back - my headcanon has always been that the wand becomes the property of the owners family (we do see similar things on the other end with long bottoms and even Ron used his older brother’s) - so these prominent families probably appeal to the ministry to retrieve the wand. The assumption is the death eaters are never getting out of Azkaban, therefore it really isn’t too big of a problem, almost becomes a memento. Hargrids wand was snapped due to being expelled while underage (before his OWLs).
@DreadKyller
@DreadKyller 21 день назад
The first people to the Potters residence was Hagrid and Sirius, who was there to collect Harry and could have easily not seen a wand buried under rubble. His mission was to get Harry out before anyone else came snooping, he wasn't going to hang around looking. As for Sirius, it's never really explained whether he goes into the house, from understanding he goes to see the house to check on the Potters after not finding Pettigrew where he should have been. Upon seeing the house he almost immediately goes to seek out Pettigrew. While it might be easy to assume the wand would have been immediately recovered there were more pressing matters at hand and no evidence that anyone spent significant time at the potters residence for at least the first day or two. It is entirely possible that Pettigrew grabbed the wand either before or after he was confronted by Sirius and hid the wand away somewhere. This theory you present honestly requires more assumptions and chance than the simpler alternative of "They didn't really look because everything was in a rush right after it happened."
@mousermind
@mousermind 21 день назад
Someone apparently struggled to meet the word count for the assignment.
@Nero-ub6pv
@Nero-ub6pv 21 день назад
What was with the abundant alliteration?
@TolliverHiker
@TolliverHiker 21 день назад
It was funny for a few mins then it made my brain 🤪
@jefftheevilpotato
@jefftheevilpotato 18 дней назад
The alliteration was authentically awesome, another word whatsoever would warm my heart
@MikeSiegert
@MikeSiegert 20 дней назад
I’ve always wondered why Voldemort‘s wand looks like a bone, since it is never explicitly described in the book, I always figured that was a liberty the movie makers took without really thinking.
@jakegordz101
@jakegordz101 15 дней назад
The alliteration throughout this video is amazing
@tjhall1000
@tjhall1000 20 дней назад
i assumed since harry backfired his spell with it as a baby, that harry was the true master of voldys original wand which is why it refuses to kill him lol
@pecassoo
@pecassoo 21 день назад
WHY IS J TALKING LIKE V FROM "V for Vendetta"???
@iowa89357
@iowa89357 21 день назад
*vendetta5
@emilydwelch3962
@emilydwelch3962 20 дней назад
The amount of alliterations used in this video is amazing. Well done, J
@tia7520
@tia7520 20 дней назад
What I think is that this much alliteration makes it hard to focus. It also made me think of pippy from Mr poppers penguins. She only alliterates in P's
@jmc9419
@jmc9419 20 дней назад
Yeah, agreed; so hard to focus!
@nanadroid
@nanadroid 20 дней назад
My head cannon is Peter went the the Potter’s and found the wand and hide it near the Potter’s home and during the time Peter went to find Voldy, he thought “I can’t just go empty handed” and then he went back o grab the wand and then find Voldy.
@heylolp9
@heylolp9 20 дней назад
What If suggestion: What if Barty Crouch Jr. escaped with Harry's Wand after casting the Dark Mark at the Quidditch World Cup >Harry needs to buy a new wand >No Twin cores at the Graveyard >Crouch Sr. when not finding his Son might sound the alarm
@Alex-cw3rz
@Alex-cw3rz 21 день назад
Surely when Ollivander was making that wand he must have had an inkling that this wand is not going to go to someone who is good. A giant chicken bone with a white stick jammed in it does not inspire confidence. Maybe that's why with the second one he went back to a nice simple wood, he realised that at least your not garentueeing the owner will be a we irdo.
@alastorclark3492
@alastorclark3492 21 день назад
I don't believe Ollivander adds those bits. Seems like an addition made by rich families such as Malfoys wand.
@riluna3695
@riluna3695 21 день назад
One has to wonder if he suspects the personalities that the wands might look for. I've done some deep research on this stuff for a story of mine, and for at least one of my characters, it seems like Ollivander should be able to predict that that person is NOT okay from the precise wand they get. Then there's the idea of wands shorter than I think 8 inches, that seem to gravitate towards "a witch or wizard in whose personality something is lacking", which basically screams messed-up in some way. Umbridge for example. That or they're smol. I guess that's the out. They could just be tiny and so need a smaller wand, so he can't assume they'll all go to bad people. That'd be...size....ist, or something.
@jagnestormskull3178
@jagnestormskull3178 21 день назад
Maybe he believed that one would choose a great villain and the other the great hero that stopped him. Maybe he was just playing dumb when Harry was trying out the other wands and knew all along that the other Fawkes wand was destined for Harry.
@leventebardossy5962
@leventebardossy5962 21 день назад
The wands are never mentioned to have such unique designs in the book.
@ultrauniqueRRRfan216
@ultrauniqueRRRfan216 21 день назад
@@leventebardossy5962yeah, that seems to be a movie trait.
@rebbjewar
@rebbjewar 19 дней назад
The alliterations in this episode had me cracking up 😂 Jonathan, you're fantastic ❤
@DizzyedUpGirl
@DizzyedUpGirl 21 день назад
The alliterations are killing me.
@thareelhelloagain
@thareelhelloagain 21 день назад
HEY BROTHERS!!! Theory; do the Dursleys desires represent the Hallows? Dudley for power (the Elder Wand), Petunia for getting her sister back (the resurrection stone), and Vernon for conformity and normality, AKA to be invisible (the invisibility cloak).
@simasimm8497
@simasimm8497 21 день назад
I think Dudley will chose the cloak, he has major character change by book 7. Vernon is the power hungry one and would go for the wand.
@simonvanberlo983
@simonvanberlo983 21 день назад
I am not really on board with the idea of Petunia wanting her sister back. They had a strained relationship from the moment Lilly found out she was a witch. She had been yealous at her from this moment and resented her for being special while she was not.
@emily79519
@emily79519 21 день назад
I don't think Petunia wants Lily back. she pretends that she doesn't even have a sister, even before Lily dies
@thareelhelloagain
@thareelhelloagain 21 день назад
@@simasimm8497 I was going mainly off their characterizations in book 1.
@thareelhelloagain
@thareelhelloagain 21 день назад
@@emily79519 I'd counter by saying that I think Petunia's biggest regret is not being close with her sister and missing the time she could have had with her when she was alive. I think that's another part of the reason that she truly hates magic is that without magic she and Lily would still be friends and Lily would still be alive. She hates magic because it took her sister from her, both initially, and then again when she was killed. I actually think that Petunia wishes more than anything in the world that Lily had survived, maybe even instead of Harry. I think she absolutely does wish she could have her little sister back. It's the entire reason she even so much as does take care of Harry. Just like Snape, she wouldn't if it weren't for her love of Lily.
@toeray5864
@toeray5864 21 день назад
Headcanon alert - the death eaters, being from long magical lineages, have generations of wands stashed at their homes. Most probably did have their wands repo'd but they were able to source another one with a good "feel" after they broke out of jail.
@imaginepageant
@imaginepageant 21 день назад
Oooh, A+ theory!
@imaginepageant
@imaginepageant 21 день назад
Oh but wait… doesn’t Ollivander identify Bellatrix’s wand in Deathly Hallows?
@mindovermatterbecomingyour1561
@mindovermatterbecomingyour1561 21 день назад
​@@imaginepageantyes he does & Hermione uses it when disguised as Bellatrix it's why Harry has to cast imperio on the goblin & Travers because the goblins & death eaters know who stole it also Hermione talks about how repulsed she is to use it & mentions the major crimes it's been used to commit
@emma_704
@emma_704 17 дней назад
@@imaginepageant Yes, but that was after Voltemort took over the Ministry. It would be possible her wand was seized and she got it back. The Azkaban takeover starts in OotP already.
@17jbeltran
@17jbeltran 21 день назад
so much alliteration this episode. reminds of Hugo Weaving's monologue in V from Vendetta
@kitjune9333
@kitjune9333 17 дней назад
My head canon is that Pettigrew followed Voldemort the night he killed the Potters and was the first to enter the house after Voldy got dematerialized. He hid the wand in the ruins of the Potters' house, what better place than where its master lost the battle, (the place became a shrine after all) collected it after he escaped Sirius and Lupin in Prisoner and then set out to find Voldemort.
@janicelewis3744
@janicelewis3744 20 дней назад
The alliteration is awwwwesome! Great vid as always.
@h.t.8812
@h.t.8812 20 дней назад
Gosh, I assumed this one wasn't gonna be very interesting, but they always surprise me, the poetic way the theory ends is awesome
@Narmatonia
@Narmatonia 21 день назад
It feels like something like Voldemort's wand would be quickly snapped up by the Ministry for safekeeping, or a museum as a grisly piece of history.
@mitchellwaits
@mitchellwaits 20 дней назад
I freaking love all the alliteration in this one!
@ODISeth
@ODISeth 20 дней назад
Take a shot every time J says a word that starts with “P” good lord this might be the most alliterative episode I’ve ever seen and it always revolves around P
@TemitayoOsinubi
@TemitayoOsinubi 4 дня назад
The alliteration this video was s-tier. Well done sir. You were spittin
@samurexatlas7373
@samurexatlas7373 21 день назад
What's with the alliteration
@50shadesofinsanity
@50shadesofinsanity 17 дней назад
For y'all's 400th Harry Potter video, you need to do something special! How about a theory of what if Lily was able to get away with Harry? How different would everything be?
@quartz9646
@quartz9646 18 дней назад
Whats funny is that the day this came out, it was the day before my local theater had a harry potter film festival where we spent the weekend watching all 8 movies in theaters, it was a lot of fun, i got a quiditch collectors set and a hufflepuff keychain:)
@user-or5ke5yn4w
@user-or5ke5yn4w 16 дней назад
Two favourite scenes of J and Ben: Voldemort laughing and Hermione hitting Harry with a newspaper.
@TIAMATRIA
@TIAMATRIA 21 день назад
My personal head canon as to why voldemorts wand looks so sinister is because I think like when Voldemort creates his horcruxs it altered his appearance it seems reasonable then that creating a horcrux would also alter the appearance of that wizards wand
@Drecon84
@Drecon84 17 дней назад
Pretty sure Ollivander is one of those "Wands don't kill people, people kill people" types.
@codyharvey4257
@codyharvey4257 20 дней назад
Wild that this video’s sponsor wasn’t a thesaurus
@jordannewton3112
@jordannewton3112 20 дней назад
Had me in stitches over the alliteration. Such a joy
@kylejohnson4615
@kylejohnson4615 20 дней назад
The alliteration goes absolutely crazy in this one
@khrystynaoselska8390
@khrystynaoselska8390 19 дней назад
Liked the theory! The effort in for this one is crazy. The best brothers)
@chikowashere
@chikowashere 18 дней назад
The amount of alliteration in this video is remarkable.
@tyrannosauruswrex123
@tyrannosauruswrex123 16 дней назад
You covered this already (You said it was wormtail who collected the wand from the ruins potter residence after fleeing in prisoner of Azkaban, to present it to Voldemort as a peace offering)
@rubygracemoseley8144
@rubygracemoseley8144 18 дней назад
I’ve never even thought about Voldemort having his wand back in The Goblet of Fire and how he would’ve gotten it back but this really does make sense
@DdKk-uc4ek
@DdKk-uc4ek 19 дней назад
My theory was that Dumbledore knew the wand would be valuable and asked Hagrid to retrieve it. I agree it was likely in the hut because anywhere within the Hogwarts Castle would have been too risky.
@remnis1120
@remnis1120 15 дней назад
someone paid the alliteration bill this month
@samwiseplaysyt485
@samwiseplaysyt485 19 дней назад
This whole video feels like a giant tongue twister 😂
@Jasonlovesmusic559
@Jasonlovesmusic559 3 дня назад
As always, this video is arguably amazing and also aptly alliterated. Awesome!
@marsik30
@marsik30 20 дней назад
VIdeo idea: What if at the end of the third book, Sirius or Lupin literally just stunned/petrified Peter before leaving the shrieking shack, preventing him from ever escaping? Never understood why they DIDN'T do that, especially since Hermione had no problem freezing Neville at the end of the first book...
@ankhgirl3
@ankhgirl3 20 дней назад
The alliteration in this video is so entertaining!! 😂
@diamondz104
@diamondz104 19 дней назад
Day 5 of asking can you do a video where the Potters survived? The scenario I'll make up is when Voldemort breaks in, Instead of killing James, he tortures and used the paralyzing spell on him and makes him pass out and plans to finish him off later when Harry and Lily are dead because as Dumbledore said, he likes waiting for his enemies to beg for death before killing them. Upstairs with Lily, the same thing basically happens except Lily misses the curse and falls on the ground. Harry still gets the love protection and Voldemort still loses his body because Lily was prepared to sacrifice herself for Harry. We saw this in Deathly Hallows when Harry's protection from sacrificing himself stopped Voldemort from torturing Neville when he stood up, Even though Harry didn't die.
@mackenziemc
@mackenziemc 19 дней назад
Oh how my literate heart loves the alliteration used in this lovely video❤
@Zeke_O3773
@Zeke_O3773 21 день назад
I like the theory! It would also explain how Dumbledore knew Voldemort was gone-Hagrid told him he found the wand. Dumbledore wouldn’t want one of Fawkes’ wands to be destroyed in case the twin cores came into play.
@amandah2935
@amandah2935 20 дней назад
The alliterations in this video are delightful
@aaronstone8147
@aaronstone8147 17 дней назад
Love the wordage used in there!
@deathab0ve
@deathab0ve 20 дней назад
Loving all this Alliteration, thanks so much for it.
@quan7umjack
@quan7umjack 18 дней назад
Theory aside that masterful alliteration throughout was mesmerizing.
@luciusbrimstone9036
@luciusbrimstone9036 10 дней назад
That alliteration was awesome. Well written essay
@RDeathmark
@RDeathmark 20 дней назад
Your obsessive and overwhelming overuse of alliteration was absolutely awe-inspiring
@IansChonkyCat
@IansChonkyCat 21 день назад
Olivander should've given an interview to the Daily Prophet about Lord Moldyshorts' real name
@tomcat124us
@tomcat124us 21 день назад
That's how you get Un-Alived after being turned into a Vegetable then used as Inferi.... it won't be quick... nor painless....
@derekstein6193
@derekstein6193 20 дней назад
​@@tomcat124us I think OP meant after he was presumed dead by the wizarding world at large. If he is dead, why worry? Now, it wouldn't help him later when Tom showed up again, but that would be after the fact.
@WhakaNiaMai
@WhakaNiaMai День назад
My head cannon is that Snape grabbed it when he was being a creep over Dead Lilly, gave it to Dumbledore, and then after the graveyard they decided that he would give it back to prove his loyalty
@laceymcelroy2802
@laceymcelroy2802 21 день назад
i was so distracted the whole time
@tommyxboy101
@tommyxboy101 20 дней назад
Absolutely amazing attempt at excellently executed elocution, exceptional!
@UnfazedPhoenix
@UnfazedPhoenix 9 дней назад
Jay has been reading Dr. Seuss and watching true crime or something 😂😂 the alliteration was wild
@Remnant-Star76
@Remnant-Star76 21 день назад
Just noticed how many different "P" Alliterations were used. You guys have done "What If's" on a couple things now. What if Harry was sorted into Slytherin " and "What if James Kept The Invisibility Cloak ". I have a suggestion for a potential good one. "What If Regulus Black Lived?" That could have some big changes to characters. Like Regulus and Sirius being better and closer. Regulus potentially being a secret spy for Sirius.
@alexandraertz1238
@alexandraertz1238 18 дней назад
The alliteration had me thinking I was going insane for a minute!
@albusgrindelwald1991
@albusgrindelwald1991 21 день назад
I love these videos, y’all are truly some of the best Harry Potter videos. I always wondered what happens to a wizard or witches wand after they died, so this video was a idea I wondered too.
@user-in9km3lb3i
@user-in9km3lb3i 21 день назад
Omg I love this vid thank you both so much for posting incredible videos that make me smile ❤😊
@HeddaToast
@HeddaToast 21 день назад
Love from Michigan! Currently on a mini vacation and this upload is helping me out a ton, thank you :) Y’all should definitely finish writing fantastic beasts, that’d be…. Fantastic
@lizbaena2012
@lizbaena2012 4 дня назад
I always thought that because Voldy wanted to make 7 Horcruxes that Magic made all moves to bring him down i.e. Harry living, Harry’s wand…
@arianasharma4024
@arianasharma4024 19 дней назад
The numerous number of terrific takes must have been greatly gigantic due to the awesome alliteration!
@tannerwallace7231
@tannerwallace7231 11 дней назад
Y'all should do a quiz episode based on your what ifs.
@richardtabor8686
@richardtabor8686 18 дней назад
love the alliteration in this one. lol. ty for the content.
@AaronJamesMediaProductions
@AaronJamesMediaProductions 20 дней назад
Spectacular supercarlins video features fundamentally fantastic level of amazing alliteration 😂
@jacobswenson8607
@jacobswenson8607 18 дней назад
I’d only tweak one thing with the theory; I think Dumbledore, in this scenario you’ve presented, would have asked/told Hagrid to hold on to the wand if he happened to come across it while picking up Harry, rather than Hagrid haven simply discovered it while he was at the Potters’.
@hallamchitty3481
@hallamchitty3481 11 дней назад
Hagrid could have gotten so miserably drunk from the Potters death immediately after delivering Harry to Privet drive that he completely forgot he picked up Voldemorts wand and it had gotten lost amongst the junk in his cabin. So maybe no one knew about it being in the cabin,even Hagrid
@kellyknowles236
@kellyknowles236 19 дней назад
This doesn’t change the theory at hand, but I always thought the snapping of hagrids wand had to do with him still being a student and it being a “you can no longer learn/finish your learning” punishment, rather than something that would happen to any criminal wizard
@sunilpermaul7876
@sunilpermaul7876 20 дней назад
Jay!! Where can we buy that shirt?! I want it so much but it's not on your website. *I NEED TO KNOW!!*
@closeempress8213
@closeempress8213 20 дней назад
I absolutely adore all the amazing alliteration! 👏 😊
@crashking4207
@crashking4207 20 дней назад
Alliteration gone wild in this one. Love the theory as always.
Далее
Part 2 ??
00:30
Просмотров 3,7 млн
Китайка раскрыла Зайку😂😆
00:19
Subway Surfers вернулась к классике
00:34
Why Does Voldemort GOOGLE AUTOFILL
21:35
Просмотров 92 тыс.
Voldemort’s HUGE Mistake | Harry Potter Film Theory
15:11
Bluey Just Did Something Incredible...
19:45
Просмотров 465 тыс.
J vs Ben: INSANE Harry Potter Trivia Quiz
31:24
Просмотров 797 тыс.