HUMAN or ROBOT? (Guess The Vocals)

Подписаться 4,3 тыс.

Просмотров 391 тыс.

50% 1

[READ DESC. BEFORE YOU PLAY/COMMENT]
EDIT: Wow, 200K views!! Thank you so much ;-;
(If any of the content that I use belong to you and you're uncomfortable with it, please let me know! I will gladly take the video down)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXPLANATION:
This is a little game I made to test your capability of differentiating the human voice and the artificial voice that is made with a vocal software or synthesizer. (which is technically a singing 'robot', as mentioned in the title- for simplification. 'Robot' is not a 100% accurate term to refer to voice synthesizers, but I just figured people would understand the phrase "singing robots" better than "voice synthesizers", so don't take it too seriously.)
VOCALOID, UTAU and CeVIO all fall to the same category: voice singing synthesizers/voice synthesizers/vocal softwares.
(Pardon my mistake in the video, "voice programs" isn't a correct term. "Voice synthesizer" or "vocal software" are more fitting terms)
RULES/HOW TO PLAY:
The rules are simple, a snippet of a vocal will be shown for not more than 15 seconds, and the next two seconds are left for you to decide your final answer whether it is a robot/voice program or a human, before the actual answer will be shown on the screen.
This game has an overall number of 20 questions, so your final score will be calculated as ?/20.
Art Thumbnail credit: kawanocy
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SONGS:
1. Moe Shop - Magic (VOCALOID Nekomura Iroha cover by Nekoshey)
[ / moe-shop-magic-nekomur... ]
2. Lady Gaga - Telephone ft. Beyoncé (UTAUs Sakasa Shiki & Yami Ryone cover by wasureru.)
[ • [UTAU COLLAB] Telephon... ]
3. *Luna - Manic ft. Otomachi Una & Rana (이청하 cover)
[ • 【HYUi】マニック(Manic)　歌ってみた ]
4. Yuduki - Dear You (Higurashi No Naku Koro Ni OST) (VOCALOID Lumi cover by cillia)
[ / lumi-test ]
5. sasakure.UK - Campanella ft. GUMI (acane_madder cover)
[ • 【カムパネルラ】を本気でささやいてみた【ac... ]
6. Mikito-P - Akaito/Red Thread ft. Hatsune Miku (cillia cover)
[ • 【歌ってみた】Akaito【cillia】 ]
7. toa - Dry Dry Flower ft. Hatsune Miku (UTAU Matsudappoiyo cover by れんじ / ウル
[ • 【UTAUカバー】ドライドライフラワー / ... ]
8. Capsule - Dreamin Dreamin
[ • dreamin dreamin - capsule ]
9. fun. - We Are Young (VOCALOIDs Dex & Daina cover by GiantOrigami)
[ • [DEX & DAINA] Fun. - W... ]
10. SNSD - One Last Time (VOCALOID SeeU cover by Kyouken)
[ / one-last-time-seeu-wip2 ]
11. kz - Last Night, Good Night ft. Hatsune Miku (UTAU Ms. Atia cover by Ms. Valentine)
[ • Video ]
12. Furukawa Honpo - envy. ft. Megurine Luka (UTAU Rinne Tsubasa cover by ragey)
[ / envy ]
13. Zig - Lent Lily ft. Hatsune Miku (dongdang chan cover)
[ • レントリリー / cover 【dongdang】 ]
14. DATEKEN - Honey Moon Un Deux Trois ft. Kagamine Rin (cheesum cover)
[ / cheesum ]
15. niki - ARROW ft. Lily (CeVIO Satou Sasara cover by kimchi-minome CeVio trash) [ / deep-sasara-sounds-lik... ]
16. Perfume - Communication (CircusP cover)
[ • I sing "Communication" ]
17. ZEDD - Spectrum ft. Matthew Koma (VOCALOID Fukase ENG cover by cillia)
[ • Copia de 【FUKASE】SPECT... ]
18. Taylor Swift - Shake It Off (VOCALOID Cyber Diva cover by cillia)
[ / shake-it-off-cyber-div... ]
19. Kyary Pamyu Pamyu - Kimi Ga Iine Kuretara
[ • Kyary Pamyu Pamyu - KI... ]
20. Akagami - Leave ft. GUMI (UTAU Samura Tomi cover by KOLA)
[ / tomi-test ]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This video was difficult to make because I wanted to make sure this game would not be too easy. I tried my best in picking the most realistic sounding vocals from the voice synthesizers, and also the most "artificial" sounding vocals from real life human singers.
Those who have been in the Vocaloid/Utau fandom long enough or have enough knowledge/experience with the virtual singer world would probably find this not as difficult. So, to extend the fun, make your friends who don't know anything about vocal softwares play this game!
I hope you had fun in playing this. If you wish to leave any critiques/thoughts/opinion, please feel free to do so. And if you want to see a part 2, let me know in the comments down below!

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

10 июн 2019

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 2,2 тыс.

@egg-o679 4 года назад

The song at the beginning is nihonbashi koukashita r keikaku :)

@kanamoney210 4 года назад

Thank you SO MUCH

@vacannot 4 года назад

What genre is this?

@egg-o679 4 года назад

@@vacannot i'd say pop

@vacannot 4 года назад

@@egg-o679 Sadly i don't think ill find similar sounding songs by searching for pop :] I especially like the ending of the song / what was used in the intro here. Any idea where i can find more of that kind of sound?

@egg-o679 4 года назад

@@vacannot well i found some songs that are kinda similar clutery and flos sung by miku caffeine by kiro is kinda similar but more intense(?) Ye i recommend those if u liked the first song

@fcantil 4 года назад

ngl autotuned humans can almost sound like vocaloids.

@StarlitLilies 4 года назад

More like they can almost sound like utau, vocaloids have a peculiar sound that's hard to mimic imo

@Ajia_No_Envy 4 года назад

@@StarlitLilies what's the difference between a vocaloid and Utau?

@StarlitLilies 4 года назад

@@Ajia_No_Envy The way that their phonemes are recorded I presume. I'm not qualified to answer since I don't work with those programs, but my impression is that utaus always sound closer to their voice providers than vocaloids.

@joannamysluk8623 4 года назад

@@StarlitLilies Depends on the UTAU, and the tuning. Like, the UTAU who sang the last song on this list, Samura Tomi, sounds very similar to Cillia when tuned correctly, and sounds very robotic and metallic when tuned wrong. She is still of very high quality though, what a shame that she's so unpopular...

@Maydarx 4 года назад

the ones that are made with a voice program always have some kind of distortion to the voice. thats how you can tell easily

@xanzusx 4 года назад

Robots trying to sing like humans Humans trying to sound like robots What a world we live in

@KangJangkrik 4 года назад

No, it's actually human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot sounds like human sounds like robot... [Error: Stack Overflow]

@Airixsas 4 года назад

you spoiled it

@elizabethharris1851 4 года назад

yep, confusing

@landy3901 4 года назад

,,Skynet'' захватит мир! И будет петь людям каждый день.

@ADeeSHUPA 4 года назад

@@randomgen7257 hM

@g.ullible6067 4 года назад

After you listen to enough vocal synth music, it’s not hard to identify the engine noise in the music in other languages. Some of the humans do sound robotic because they’re autotuned, but they lack the distinct processed sound.

@vanadium723 3 года назад

One song in english almost got me before i heard how they pronounced what should have been the same sound differently in different words. Even with accents some human pronunciation patterns are hard to fake.

@chumbawomba3298 3 года назад

Exactly what I was thinking! You can tell when something was recorded by a human because it sounds like it was said out into air. Vocaloid has this sort of sharpness on it that comes from being constructed within a computer

@kdandsheela 3 года назад

It's like...this specific type of virbrado that doesn't... exactly match human vocals

@thegoods7011 3 года назад

the way I identify it is kinda with that,,, "kssh" noise that some vocaloids have. Or the light growl some also have.

@Tookatto 3 года назад

Exactly

@Jojo2 4 года назад

WTF...As a huge vocaloid fan, it's very strange to see UTAU sound way more realistic than I thought. Teto kasane is how I seen most UTAU

@emurysorrow6632 3 года назад

There's definitely some great UTAUs, and people that have great tuning skills, that's why I love UTAUs so much! They have something really special. My favourite is Yokune Ruko (male kire).

@wjsnactivist6141 3 года назад

Kyaami's use of Utau can be extremely realistic!

@kyrakyra_art 3 года назад

maybe important to note that seeU is a vocaloid, not an UTAU, which can help make her sound more realistic easier i think?

@wjsnactivist6141 3 года назад

@@kyrakyra_art nah not necessarily. Plenty of Utau sound as realistic as, of even more so than, Vocaloids

@orxidpink 3 года назад

Hey, Teto may sound realistic! It depends on tuning, really

@tom4to241 4 года назад

its easy to know those are not human but it's hard to know those are human,

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

interesting!

@izayahemerald2070 4 года назад

AGREEEEEED

@bajszosjozsef4850 4 года назад

Probably due to the tremendous amount of autotune used in their voices...

@disgusting2208 4 года назад

TOM4TO so it’s hard. That’s the point lmao.

@Hi-ii8vz 4 года назад

Haha mine's the opposite XD

@Cynziax 4 года назад

The hardest of all is HUMAN THAT SOUNDS LIKE ROBOT

@gregory7555 4 года назад

Fi-AR《フィア》 IRONIC XD

@Hyacinthus623 3 года назад

AuTotUneS

@user-ts6qd7zh2m 3 года назад

I actually can sound like that

@Biajuuu 4 года назад

Question : Human or Robot? Answer : Voice Program Me : dammit i got all wrong

@kaomei17 4 года назад

🤣🤣 sad

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

HAHAHAHAH LMAO😂 im a bit inconsistent with my choices in terms/words.. sorry bout that!

@Biajuuu 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie haha no problem, i'm just joking, good video tho

@selkoshichiffon243 3 года назад

Awkwkwk 😂😂

@toast3163 3 года назад

Dw, the trick is to hear if they take a quick breath, Ofc since humans breathe lmao

@jugger6228 4 года назад

Vocaloids don`t have this gasps like humans, but if humans remove their gasps, well then we all are lost xD

@mirkohoble 4 года назад

Big Al.

@hecklife6636 3 года назад

miku inhales at the start of world is mine. we were boned from the getgo

@taigatanfan_ 3 года назад

Oh they actually do. If you have listened to songs made by Ryoo(supercell) then you know, he was pretty famous for how realistic he made the vocaloids sound with the gasps, and breathy notes. So yes, depending on who mixes them, they do have gasps like humans.

@Arya-we7vf 3 года назад

They do, actually, just depends on who makes the song.

@fridalighjemdallen7283 3 года назад

Breathing was added I think either late into V2 or early in V3. I remember losing my mind when everyone was showcasing it lol. Been a nerd for way too long ;u;

@megurineziam5900 4 года назад

Sksks it's so hard to differentiate some of the UTAU from the humans. The vocaloids were a breeze though.

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

Megurine Ziam the utaus sound a bit more realistic here compared to the vocaloids huh? ironic because they’re known for sounding more robotic than vocaloids 😆 but times have changed now

@megurineziam5900 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie I mean I guess it depends on the UTAU and how it is used. Vocaloids will always be better in quality in general but tgen there's these gems you would suddenly find featuring uber realistic UTAU usage

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

Megurine Ziam that’s true, but there are a few UTAUs that in my personal opinion are capable of sounding good & realistic even without doing much tuning work. a few that i can think of are Ham, Denatsu Sora and Yamine Renri. utaus have a stronger sound in general, much more than that of a vocaloid, which i think adds up to the realistic-ness factor ^^ again, it’s just my opinion ;)

@CatsBootleg 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie There is also Gahata Meiji :)

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

Jadi 044 right! meiji too

@totaleclipse3528 4 года назад

There’s a specific effect that the robotic voices have. It was actually pretty easy for me to tell which was which

@louise4152 4 года назад

Same!

@anna-it5pq 4 года назад

same, it’s especially obvious when they’re switching notes

@liiocxy3406 4 года назад

Same

@felisss2869 4 года назад

Same

@bobblyblinkers 4 года назад

Same

@XxjedzxX 4 года назад

Voice programs have this certain "O" sound in them, which gives me a nostalgia. It's been so long since the last time I listen to Vocaloids. I'm glad I came across this.

@keepyourshoesathedoor 4 года назад

XxjedzxX I agree

@halcyonbuzz 4 года назад

Wow, this is actually pretty hard... it's harder with the UTAUs, because with a lot of Vocaloids I have the sound of their voices memorized by now.

@FreshStartSquid 4 года назад

I thought Lumi was a human singing for a second-

@lemonn6073 4 года назад

same ..

@quimiu4400 4 года назад

Same

@RandomPerson-ks3ql 4 года назад

Same

@sakuraxox4839 4 года назад

yeetus cleetus aa same

@hanabeilschmidt8443 4 года назад

Sameeeee wtf

@andikim1498 4 года назад

If you’re not a vocaloid fan, it will be hard 😂

@official-deepseacreature863 3 года назад

Yeah this was easy ngl

@criesandthrowsuponthefloor608 3 года назад

Also Utaloids

@melaniegamer2 3 года назад

I don't listen to Vocaloids often but I DO listen humans so I guess I can guide with that?..

@CrystalicAria 3 года назад

I am a Vocaloid fan and it still is hard xD

@nex8154 3 года назад

Nah, i don’t listen to vocaloid’s And i got all of them right tought.

@playerguy2 4 года назад

Man, UTAU is really convincing.. Vocaloid is quite obvious (but the style is perfectly fine). Overall I'm surprised.

@AlainaWithanA 4 года назад

Well this is very interesting, it's making me realize how much auto-tune humans use 😅 I think part of the reason why it's so hard to distinguish some of them is because they are heavily filtered with Auto-Tune

@disgusting2208 4 года назад

AlainaWithanA exactly the only way you can distinguish them is to listen closely and pay attention to syllables.

@MrMike-kk1bc 4 года назад

True

@econekokun 4 года назад

Ohmygod it's the "this is my voice" tiktok girl--

@AlainaWithanA 4 года назад

@@econekokun lmaoooo yeah that's me 😅

@kittenmimi5326 4 года назад

When the "human" one is something a human could never ever do without heavy editing and such

@aa-zb1jf 4 года назад

Its hard to spot because people put so many effects on their voice, so its hard to say if theyre human or not

@idk-un3ty 4 года назад

No, it's not. Vocaloid's/utau's have some problems with sylabes, if you pay attention you will notice what i mean

@greennikexful 4 года назад

Also cuz if u listen carefully, you can hear a human’s breath in a human’s song(idek know what I’m talking about anymore lol 😂)

@zeldahyrule3525 4 года назад

Generally it’s rather easy to tell an auto tuned human voice from a voice program. You just need to know what to listen to. Voice programs generally go syllable by syllable, which sound pretty disjointed even when strung together. Think, what your voice would sound like if you said each syllable with a slightly different inflection. An auto tuned human’s voice originally had an organic flow so even if it’s adjusted after the fact, even to sound robotic, it comes off as smoother.

@selueen3028 4 года назад

@@idk-un3ty most of vocaloid songs have that, yeah, but there are some incredible well tuned tracks that make it much less obvious.

@aa-zb1jf 3 года назад

@@idk-un3ty i do,i pay attention to it because ive been listening to vocaloud for a while

@jjju3 3 года назад

4:15 that is an IMPRESSIVE voice program, fuck me! Ive never heard a vocaloid _belt_ before. A robotic vibrato is impressive

@filedeletefelix 3 года назад

utau* but yeah

@najmaht.a.1314 3 года назад

That’s an UTAU, if you want a VOCALOID then I suggest ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Lp8mbxD-1mo.html

@mamatila123 Год назад

THATS UTAU FOR YA!! superiorrr stuff

@turquoiseninju7 7 месяцев назад

All of the impressive ones were utau.. and fun fact utau is free and has comparatively less features :0

@NEverglade 4 года назад

It’s easy to tell vocaloids from the humans, mostly from their pronunciation for me. Certain sounds will be chopped up from the over all flow, while human speech blends them all together smoothly. A great challenge either way! Would work best on someone who’s never listened to them before.

@unknownperson3929 3 года назад

The pronounciation and flow actually depends on the tuning. If a VOCALOID is tuned perfectly, they can sound almost just like a human.

@Helena_idk 4 года назад

This was easy for me, because humans don't have that robotic sounds that all Vocaloids have, but for someone that haven't heard a Vocaloid in his life, this probably was a what the f-

@Someone-zn4dh 4 года назад

As vocaloid fans, I find this kinda hard Like not easy, and also not hard

@sinixe9073 4 года назад

Yeah this was still kinda hard lol

@LaevLivy 4 года назад

Almost getting all of them right.. I guessing two Voice Program as Humans.. they sound so real T^T

@selueen3028 4 года назад

Honestly, really well tuned vocaloid is pretty much imporrisble to tell apart from tuned human vocals. (Even if we ignore the fact that vocaloids are just sounds banks essentially). It's just really hard to tune them to be so convincing. It's not that hard to make normal vocals sound robotic if you want to.

@fukunaga-kane 4 года назад

HelenaVRP :v tbh it’s kinda easy. Vocaloid can’t do long pulls in ballad lol. They are noticeably “shorter” vocabs in between the lines that they sing

@waterunderthebridge7950 4 года назад

I feel like the biggest difference between generated and human voices is the fact that humans can make more smooth transitions between different sounds, vocal breaks and pitches, that difference goes out the window tho if the singers use too much autotune or go for a very electronic vibe

@Slammatoro 4 года назад

Water Under The Bridge and god do the Japanese love auto tune and their electronic vibes

@luckylucy4078 4 года назад

Also, humans can have a lot of sound artifects (artifacts+effects), that came from "How recording works" (like at 2:00 where you can hear that P sound from blowing right in front of microphone)

@zoobazee6299 4 года назад

And breathing. Humans need to breathe, you can tell if there is breathing.

@smokeandmirrors2356 4 года назад

@@zoobazee6299 Vocaloid has breathing effects tho

@zoobazee6299 4 года назад

Not many. I only heard one with breathing.

@blackopslink1655 4 года назад

every comment: this was easy Also every comment: this was hard

@ink2476 3 года назад

okay are we not gonna talk about how 12 was literally amazingly tuned?? out of several words, you can only just barely make out any slight vocal warping. fooled me 100000%

@adrienthompson4771 3 года назад

YEAH i was convinced it was human at first and then i was like ah no thats a program but HOLY SHIT that sounded so human

@tehterminator3605 3 года назад

Fooled me too!!

@0Clewi0 3 года назад

12 was the robot I got wrong and also got wrong a human later

@luciandelle 2 года назад

I just got it wrong when I saw this, it sounded breathy so I thought it was human

@gothmenincombatboots 4 года назад

A few dead giveaways that a vocal is a robot is that they lack breathiness and the pitch shifts sounds awkward. People need air when they sing. You'll here people take breaths between notes when singing. I'd be impressed if someone made a vocaloid or utauloid programmed to take breaths between beats.

@janickajavier4526 4 года назад

Mitchie M, a vocaloid producer takes the time to make vocaloids breathe between singing!! You should go check them out! The realism they make vocaloid sounds like is unreal!

@doodlemoo 4 года назад

Nikukurin OMG TRUEEE

@sugarycoated 4 года назад

there was a bloody stream cover i found where the vocaloid they used breathed! it was cool

@gothmenincombatboots 4 года назад

@@sugarycoated o.o sauce?

@sugarycoated 4 года назад

@@gothmenincombatboots ok so the breathing is a LOT more annoying than i remember but it was a len cover by zefurry

@lilyabon7803 4 года назад

got all correct but I have to admit this is the best video out of category "guess human or non human singer"!! the choice of songs for this is very accurate so it's easy to get puzzled, nice 😙👌

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

kaligari scouts thank you for the feedback! i really appreciate it ❤️

@burnedcalculat0r566 4 года назад

kaligari scouts I’m getting like all of them wrong

@egzona5149 4 года назад

@@burnedcalculat0r566 same

@mikuhatsunegoshujin 4 года назад

a couple

@acecrust6877 4 года назад

kaligari scouts same, I think it’s just the way they sing if you listen closely you can tell the difference

@cainiwakura 4 года назад

Wtf just when utau become this good ? Some of utaus here even really sound like a hooman.

@limimelo 3 года назад

Utau has always been good, it's all about the tuning.

@Cherryblossoms110 4 года назад

And TIL Utauloids sound more human than Vocaloids. Damn.

@duality7404 4 года назад

The trick is that voice programs don’t need to breathe.

@aa-zb1jf 3 года назад

Some people make them breathe though-

@otakotako2601 3 года назад

the trick is the engine noise, even the clearest VB have a distinct engine noise that won't go away no matter how amazing the tuning is, you only need to identify that

@rie9327 4 года назад

this just makes me realize how realistic utaus sound now,,

@sazukick 4 года назад

Right!!??

@rikosama7648 4 года назад

Thats true sometimes more realistic than the one u pay for aka vocaloid ...smh But also its about how u tune it ..mine ends up so choppy and robotic ...fml

@SFuruda 3 года назад

Right? Some are better than the most of vocaloids Xd

@luminacake588 4 года назад

4:10 I see what you did there. You expect me to think It's a Vocaloid because It's a Vocaloid song. Well,that ain't gonna fool me,I know that isn't a robot-- Wait,that's an UTAU!? How did they make her sound so natural,like,she legit sounds like a human and the voice is so beautiful and emotional! And to think UTAU is supposed to be lower quality than Vocaloid like how did they do that!? It's incredible!

@snowdrop5048 4 года назад

Lumina Cake it’s not „supposed” to be worse than vocaloid, it just used to be, remember it was made by one person and needed a community and their work (resamplers, plugins, vbs) to get better.

@luminacake588 4 года назад

@@snowdrop5048 Oh ok thank you for telling me lol

@najmaht.a.1314 3 года назад

UTAU isn’t supposed to be “lower quality” than vocaloid, it’s there to be more accessible for people who want to make their own voicebanks and such.

@luminacake588 3 года назад

@@najmaht.a.1314 Yeah, I know, I sort of misunderstood. I figured it would be lower quality in most cases because Vocaloid is the real thing and UTAU is the free alternative, and It's harder to use, but I guess that dosen't apply in all cases (we saw some great examples of that in the video)

@FunnyParadox 3 года назад

UTAU's engine edit less the sound, and there's a tool (mod) to remove most sound correction, to make it the most realistic as possible, so technically UTAU have a way bigger field for realism then Vocaloid, we can also record extra phonemes for more realism, and UTAUs are ofter VCV, while Vocaloid are CVVC, so less record, less variety, less realism, and popular vp are usually way better at making voicebank then big companies, also UTAU's engine is allowing waaay more voice diversity and voice tone then Vocaloid, so more realism, so technically UTAU is way more realist then Vocaloid Tho if you record a mono-pitch/append CV with a potato like in 2008, in this case Vocaloid is better x)

@parapparappin2727 3 года назад

No matter how well tuned a voice program is tuned it still has a certain rasp to it

@tinyangryace31 5 лет назад

That was hard I'll admit

@monsteralfie 5 лет назад

tiny angry ace i somewhat feel proud hearing that😜😂

@paparrunop6785 4 года назад

Dhmis :D

@孫子 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie You're like that one teacher who likes to make tricky quizzes and feels proud of themselves when students fall for it lmao

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

lmao is that a good thing!?😂😂

@孫子 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie true LOL

@MnstrMthd 4 года назад

how the hell were the UTAUs the ones that got me when did UTAUs get more realistic than vocaloids?? hello???

@tami7992 4 года назад

Same thought XD

@halinaqi2194 4 года назад

since they are fan made and a community available, people can improve on it.

@kamukoma1181 4 года назад

They were always more realistic?

@karayura10 4 года назад

@@kamukoma1181 check out Tree UTAU. It sings like realistic tree

@kamukoma1181 4 года назад

Kara十Ra10 It really does doe 😳

@charles8032 4 года назад

Four mistakes and they were mostly humans using autotune like wtf

@sprootoveralls1450 4 года назад

4 wrong. 1 human with a lot of filters. the other 3 were utaus that sounded way too realistic lol

@lemonknife 4 года назад

only got one wrong and it was cheesum but i swear to god he sings exactly like how some voice programs sound?? but yeah as a general rule to spot songs with vocaloid, utau & co what i listen for is the cadence/choppiness of the voice between words/syllables and that kind of... wheezey sound that most programs have even with the best tuning? idk how to describe it exactly but human voices overall tend to flow smoother and be more pure i suppose. in the end i always get really hype about how cool it is that some of those sound almost human and i really applaude the programmers for the tuning and pitching because it isnt easy to get such good results, even with already really good voicebanks.

@BB-eq7hb 4 года назад

oli lemonknife i usually listen in for that fuzzy/static-ey sound that utaus and vocaloids commonly have but producers are getting too good at tuning to the point where a lot of the times it’s nonexistent 😭

@lemonknife 4 года назад

@@BB-eq7hb RIGHT!! some of them do an amazing job and its stunning, while i still love the older songs its also amazing to see producers create such smooth vocals with the programs. one example that comes to mind is kiras use of english gumi, especially in his most recent songs

@BB-eq7hb 4 года назад

oli lemonknife dude kira is like.,,, god tier, especially in the english vocaloid producer community. i always think about mitchie m with the super good crazy tuning and even their old stuff never has that fuzzy sound

@sourandsweet1048 4 года назад

Same

@corasundae 4 года назад

I was listening for end breaths, since tuning people find realistic has them very often.

@dr.ducttape2161 4 года назад

I didn't miss a single voice program, however humans prove to be quite tough. Fukase and Fukase Vocaloid are so similar I almost lost that one lol

@Strawbiwi Год назад

Lol I'd recognize Fukase anywhere XD

@kittiechen2005 4 года назад

Tbh the utaus sound more realistic than some of the other voice programs even thought they’re supposed to be “cheaper”

@tvulipxv 3 года назад

Vocaloid and UTAUs have a really hard pronunciation of "Ho" and "Sa" they almost sound like they are choking. I don't know how to describe it... it' "sahHH" instead of "sa". It's "HHHHo" instead of "ho"

@zyxeldominus7527 4 года назад

If you listen closely, vocaloids/utauloids have their tones move in a stepping kind of manner. You’ll also hear subtle voice breaks. They sound very autotuned, but some add breathes and smooth ends so that they’d sound more human. For humans with autotune, you’d still hear tones not altered while they sing because of the autotune set to only some notes most likely. You could also hear very realistic breathing in between lines. It’s kind of easy when you know this, I got around 14

@Mintysaur 4 года назад

6:20 hol up i knew circusp was a vocaloid song producer but daM i didnt know he could siNG????

@jiafei4511 4 года назад

SAME

@sofiaperez7918 3 года назад

Same I was suprised

@thegaang2829 3 года назад

Yeah their singing was similar to their tuning style so I thought it was one of their tunes, but I was wrong

@fridalighjemdallen7283 3 года назад

Bruh it's like every vocaloid producer can sing It'd be so unfair if it wasn't such a damn double blessing to us fans ;u;

@sakura9959 3 года назад

Same, I really thought it was a vocaloid specifically because of the tone of the music

@yokothefox. 4 года назад

When you have 13 years of vocaloid experiences it’s so easy to tell who is who- maybe I should stop listening to it lol. Also the way to find out easier is to hear for a vibration in the u and o, a is a little harder since it can sound soft sometimes, o and u are still a struggle for the programs unless you bend your back 1000 directions to fix the tuning.

@BlackTearDrop 4 года назад

Though Vocaloid have a audible distortion to their voices a lot of the time I honestly think it gives them character, I like it.

@Astrelixia 4 года назад

of course the only one i got wrong was mixing up Cillia, an absolute legend, with a loid smh

@Supernova10000 4 года назад

Same

@Deathstarwhite 4 года назад

I got it wrong because she sounds EXACTLY like her damn utauloid so I guessed Samura, then realized it was too crisp. fml

@gyatttdaym 4 года назад

question sir, is this the same cillia as kyaami?

@bycowgotoschool5089 4 года назад

S. A. Yes

@gyatttdaym 4 года назад

@@bycowgotoschool5089 Aaaaaaa even the artist sounds like the arts they created❤️ thanks btw!

@whiteegretorchids8234 5 лет назад

I got 4 wrong (I listen to vocaloid and UTAU all the time)

@aa-zb1jf 4 года назад

Same uwu

@cassandraa 4 года назад

Yep same

@RoseGirl3 4 года назад

Yeah, me too. I feel uncultured.

@plantasia878 4 года назад

Yeah same

@MidoriMatcha 4 года назад

The thing that tells the difference apart from the two is their “EhHhHhhH”

@GE-0530RN 3 года назад

*inhale* eHHHHHHHHHHHH

@starspeakerarts 3 года назад

The Utaus are seriously tripping me up more than the actual Vocaloids

@mishiraK 4 года назад

I got 13 out of 20. Pretty good songs/cover choices! A lot of Utau and Vocaloid sound human. Usually, for me, it's kinda hard to find a good Utau/Vocaloid covers that sound human but Kyaami proves me wrong with her cover of Charles using Mikoto MEIKA.

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

Mishira I’m glad you think so about the song choices! I really took my time with picking each one. And yes, Kyaami was the first person that came to mind when deciding the tracklist for this video.😆

@akki384 4 года назад

4:53 I was pretty sure that is human...

@ermayonnaise 3 года назад

same!

@thefrostyslime 3 года назад

Honestly, I'm so impressed by how far Utauloids have progressed in the past ten years. Shout out to all the creators who put so much hard work into their production!

@Entropy67 4 года назад

humans can always sound like robots but robots cant always sound like humans. Some of the robots tried pretty hard to sound human tho. Some of the tell-tale signs of a human is audible breathing that don't sound fake, pauses that are clearly for breathing rather then a part of the song, trailing of at the end of a long chord, and other minor things that make them slightly imperfect. Obviously humans can be basically perfect and identical to some of the robots as well, which is what makes this hard... I got 16/20 still

@lizbett570 4 года назад

The only one that I got wrong was CircusP’s singing holy smokes he’s good

@flowersnferrets 3 года назад

same :]

@CJdoesntlikehandles 4 года назад

Its not that hard if you just listen for the squeakiness that voice programs have

@Slammatoro 4 года назад

You will remember me, or don't, I don't care. When talking about the Japanese I think squeakiness is evetything

@tonedeath4536 3 года назад

You got me on Rinne Tsubasa and cheesum, but otherwise I could tell the difference because of the sudden cuts in the vocal even if there were super high pitch songs or the person used auto well. It still introduced me to some songs that I've not heard so this was pretty entertaining. Very nice vid. Much enjoyment.

@nekoprankster2184 3 года назад

I fucking thought cillia was a UTAU and also cheesum/CircusP, but in my defense, I’ve heard his UTAU in action before.

@otakotako2601 3 года назад

technically she is ? she voiced samura tomi

@nekoprankster2184 3 года назад

@@otakotako2601 Did not know that.

@gervaciomarykleineg.660 4 года назад

The voice banks are more human voice, on the other hand most of human voice was sounded like robot because of voice filter/synthesizer or whatever it s to change their voice

@nunyabusiness6450 4 года назад

Woah rinne UTAU was so realistic

@anxelavalverde6563 4 года назад

I actually said "bro, try making this harder" just when 12 arrived I said it was human, big oof

@angel7443 3 года назад

I just did the same mistake-

@angel7443 3 года назад

@copy and paste damn, you're a monarch now, sorry I don't make the rules

@emurysorrow6632 3 года назад

FR. I GOT FOOLED, THAT'S SOME GREAT TUNING. Number 11 got me too, wow, just WOW

@sakura9959 3 года назад

Same

@Msanimefanatic25 3 года назад

me too haha

@criesinvariable2493 3 года назад

vocaloids had like a ringing noise at the end of each sentence

@hizumizaigo4219 4 года назад

Only 5 wrong, some parts were more obivious than others, I was hearing for Breaths, no insane jump of tone of voice, lip smacking as well and for a echo.. but ONE ROBOT Breathed like a Human in this.

@fsskye6389 4 года назад

Not gonna lie, the third song got me confused, it made me go back and forth I was like "Human! Wait no- ROBOT! WAIT NO IM SURE IT'S A HUMAN."

@saftsack 4 года назад

why tf do voice programms sound more realistic than humans,,,

@Ruzovy_ 3 года назад

Because we tune the voices of voice programs to make them more realistic, adding little breaths, slightly off pitching and tuning them.. While actual singers add auto tune to perfect every single note leaving it with that robot sound

@hutao6874 3 года назад

Tbh its kinda easy? Robots have this sound to them that separates them from human that you to listen for (i cant really explain it but some of yall might understand 😅)

@wilting-k742 4 года назад

I feel like it's a bit easier for me to tell when you normally listen to vocaloid, utau, etc. Music normally

@engel_l_l 4 года назад

everytime i guessed was exactly the opposite

@Nulley0 4 года назад

Same

@SEmmS_OrigamiStudio 4 года назад

Same!!!!!!!!!!!!

@aquasama588 4 года назад

I like how humans have Imperfect sounds that are distinguishable from the Vocaloids, Like Breathing and that popping sound that they make with their lips, while vocaloids Just have sharp entry and ending.

@runatiz_ 4 года назад

This is still a fun game to me Because I like human-tuned vocaloid/utau I lost to UTAU Rinne, Dongdang, Cheesum and Kyary Pamyu Pamyu (damnit cheesum, I misheard you with Ham)

@sakurabiskuit 4 года назад

Man, Lumi got me good. I hadn't listened to her voice yet, it's beautiful.

@user-xl5kx2so1h 4 года назад

I only got number 14 wrong, thought it was UTAU lol I probably recognised the voice from Ham

@evjmn 4 года назад

it really sounded like one tho

@symneoart 4 года назад

Same

@bittsystar276 4 года назад

yeah me too

@bobbieproductions4491 4 года назад

OMG me tooo

@plipplop1769 4 года назад

Same, I only listen to one song with that utau but it sounds exactly like him.

@kerohotcake 3 года назад

0:48 shiiiit,,, thats a really good utau.

@unitymask 3 года назад

FINALLY SOME DAMN LUMI RECOGNITION THANK U

@inessacafarella.2564 4 года назад

The only ones I got wrong we’re humans using HEAVY autotune especially capsule.

@ghost_evermore 4 года назад

Got everything right except for circus p. SO MUCH AUTOTUNE lol

@liquorice8449 3 года назад

1 - vocaloid (iroha?) 2 - robot (yes I knew she was an utau, overall they sound much more realistic in english than vocaloid) 3 - human 4 - vocaloid (lumi has a beautiful voice) 5 - utau. LMAO well she really sounds like that smooth utau with pink hair 6 - human 7 - utau 8 - human 9 - vocaloid 10 - vocaloid (seeu omg girls generation my sone heart

@rainbowmacaroni1063 3 года назад

the "for now" scares me

@McImoi 3 года назад

Nice! I was able to guess all of these correctly. A lot of vocaloid and utau have a slightly metalic sound to their voice but humans with autotune and no breath is VERY tricky LOL.

@reidar541 4 года назад

10/20 - no different from random chance even though I could identify telltale signs that some were sung by a voice program (pronunciation of certain sounds in English for example). However, human voices that were modified sounded robotic and led me to guess incorrectly.

@cheesura485 4 года назад

17/20 Though I will admit I have listened to most of these covers already (if not i recognized the voices) was still fun to do nonetheless :DD

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

{}mítαmα{} you must go on soundcloud a lot! (considering a lot of these are from soundcloud)

@cheesura485 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie I used to actually, I mosyly stick to yt now though.

@violetiolite 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie I see so many UTUs on SoundCloud, it definitely isn't difficult to imagine that you took it all from there!

@UCAJq2oN0BQLFi3aAhhsX8-A 4 года назад

Actually UTAU can better than Vocaloid

@myassisonfire9143 3 года назад

thanks for this video bro, now I have a whole bunch of new songs to listen to

@inzurego 4 года назад

Darn. I got 2 mistakes. I thought cillia's and cheesum's voices were a voice program. I guessed that they were probably an UTAU. . q_q

@user-ns2mz4bw2y 4 года назад

Indira Gayle Gonzalgo Same! I got 2 wrong. I think. The one that got me stumped was the UTAU who was singing Last Night Good Night. It sounded sooo human😫😫😫😫

@inzurego 4 года назад

@@user-ns2mz4bw2y Darn! That one was actually a bit difficult since the UTAU sounded so well tuned. I literally had to think twice, listen carefully, and just stuck with her being a voice program.

@plipplop1769 4 года назад

@@user-ns2mz4bw2y I only guessed fake because it was last night good night.

@deswina1069 4 года назад

6:46 OMG AAAAA I didn't think that the one singing was fukase I thought "HUMAN", apparently vocaloid fukase, the sound of fukase is very real like a human, ahhh I just know this song !!!🔥🔥🔥❤ Its very COOL😭

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

うぃなMAD/AMV i personally thought fukase sounded very human too, its all thanks to kyaami for using him excellently

@deswina1069 4 года назад

@@monsteralfie I don't know that kyaami make a song again for Fukase why Kyaami doesn't post on her youtube channel?!!😔

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

@@deswina1069 she didn't post it on youtube but she did upload it on NicoNicoDouga! you can find a reprint of it on youtube though. check the description box and you'll find the link to it! :)

@hikarii8758 4 года назад

I got this at first try I think the clue it gives is rather clear, the "slides" of the notes (if you know what I mean) don't really sound human also, the only human I can think of is Matthew Koma; his voice has some sort of spikes and he usually changes the notes without "sliding" at some points

@icantchangemyprofilepic7874 4 года назад

*_Fukase best boi_*

@burnblast2774 4 года назад

Male voices were really easy to tell, but female/neutral ones (especially at higher pitches) were significantly harder.

@KazukiP 4 года назад

There’s a really distinct sound that all UTAU have that you can tell the difference between vocaloid and UTAU

@Pluvillion 4 года назад

okay but can we talk about how cheesum managed to sing exactly how his UTAU sings???

@Bystandaur 4 года назад

If you listen hard enough and hear a wave or something octave(?) Then they're not human

@TheLibermania 4 года назад

Me at the beginning: "Nice idea" Me after Dear you played: "I'm off and listen to a bit Dear you" Me after coming back: "i'm going to watch Higurashi later"

@anonymousme3571 4 года назад

7, 12, 13, 14, 16 Gotta hunt em down I'll be honest, I thought 7 was human-tuned. Sounds awesomee

@emilijabez.3254 4 года назад

16/20 Some like Fukase and Cyber Diva were pretty easy, but I was surprised at how circus P sounds.

@RandoPassingBy 4 года назад

The time you know all the songs and therefore you know whether they're human or not since since you know this shit so well

@cyrene03 4 года назад

Cillia has insane tuning skills, while also having a beautiful voice holy-

@shenhui9408 2 года назад

The most realistic for me was hands down UTAU Rinne Tsubasa. I was really surprised.

@kola9061 4 года назад

Omg my leave cover!! I’m so happy u used it in this video

@monsteralfie 4 года назад

it's such a beautiful cover, thank you so much for blessing the community with your amazing works!

@doodletrash01 4 года назад

everything right baby 20/20!!!!!!!!!!! this was hard tho cuz utaus can sound so real sometimes

@ricestrange 4 года назад

I ♡ your profile picture

@doodletrash01 4 года назад

thanks lol mikus cute

@violenthoe571 4 года назад

ME TOO AAGGG

@feythii 3 года назад

Love how majority of the voice program songs are tuned by Cillia/Kyaami, her tuning’s truly incredible.

@tutterbear98 4 года назад

It's nearly 3am I can't sleep I'm going delirious and got all of these right in a very stressful stretch of 20 minutes of thinking through my progress. Honestly, it's mostly just listening to the points at the end of syllables. If you've heard enough vocaloid you can connect how that's supposed to sound. Some of the humans were replicating that effect, but were much more dramatic about it than how it actually sounds when a vocaloid goes from, say, one half of a word to the other half. Vibrato can also be a tip off, it's really distinct.

@kiyuu685 4 года назад

....I got everything right .. But its actually easy to hear out if it's a utau or a human

@blackstar044 4 года назад

1:30 Who else thought a human was singing? 😱

@godouttathemachine 4 года назад

it's amazing how far vocal synthesis has come. some of these synthesized voices i legit could not tell apart from a human's voice.

@clomyst 3 года назад

The humans are easy to recognize due to the real emotions, breathyness. Vocaloids sound more robotic, blunt, too perfect, nasally. But some humans still fooled me, i got 7 wrong.