I Have A Secret | 1 Million Subscribers 

remember this iconic video. these were the days

The funny thing is that people still thinking that Finn is fake 😂😂

I'm still dying at the fact that people really thought Finn was fake.

i feel like 2% of the subscribers still think finn is fake

Is it just me or did you think that this was a coming out vid

Jack and Finn actually look a lot different to me maybe it's because I'm a twin

Jack: I know what you're thinking Me (thinking): You're drinking coffee while eating an apple? WTF is wrong with you?

At the beginning I thought that he's going to say that he's gay so I was mentally prepared to hear that from him and then he said that Finn isn't real and I was like 'ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME, WE ALL KNOW THIS IS A JOKE, DON'T SCARE US LIKE THAT'

How is it that so many people actually believe this??

dudes finn is real. look at 4:20 didnt you see him and hear him. he was tied up in a chair

who is watching in 2016?

this was the best 1mil vid ive ever seen it's incredible

can't believe people actually believe this XD

To this day I still doubt Finn's existence when ever he is in the videos.... this cannot be undone unless I were to meet them in person. Look what you did, Jack.

Probably my favourite jacksgap video. Very clever and funny

Guys, Finn is REAL! Look in the end of the video, there's a boy on a chair behind the brown wall, this is just a joke

I wonder how many people fell for this?!

who is watching in 2015.

This video is just amazing! love Jacksgap :D

Oh thought he was gonna say that he is gay lol

Meanwhile at 3,149,412 subscribers

These comments make me fear for the future of the human race

It's 2016 and I still love this

Your personality is crazy, I love it!! Going to check out your other videos. Your just awesome.

3,576,365 subs actually

Hahahahah. I didn't see Finn until I read the comments

Oml I thought he was gonna say he was gay

who's watching this in 2086

4:20 You can see Finn at the back

oh god i remember first watching this and totally flipping out

I'M REALLY, REALLY, REALLY, REALLY, CONFUSED. DOES FINN ACTUALLY EXIST? HELP ME!

I thought this was a coming out video omg... Wait Finn does exist right? LOL

the crazy things twins have fun with...

No need to explain: 4:20

On 4:20 is that Finn

I just showed my friend this and she didn't notice Finn in the back😂😂

4:20 finn is right behind

0:20 And that fish. Don't forget the fish.

How did they make this so awesome? Where did they film this?

used to watch this video religiously

For a few moments I thought that this was true lol

I knew this was fake

I remember when this just came out and everyone was debating whether Finn was real or not, :D

(when you see finn tied up) "BAE!?!?! Are you okay????"

i laughed so hard reading the comments of this video when it first came out, people actually thought it was real lol

This is obviously fake because at the end of the video, Finn is tied up behind the bookshelf XD

I'm so inspired by Jack's content. I hope I can create videos like him, it's amazing how fast he grew!

6 years later and I still remeber this video. Awesome dude, just awesome.

I could see Finn tied up to a chair and his mouth tied up (I know I'm stating the obvious)

Guys at 4:20 it shows Finn tied up I think it's fake haha

Who's watching this in 1964?

More than 5 years later and I still love this videos😍 I miss u☹️

I accidently watched the finns revenge first HAHAHAHAH

LOL Finn at 4:20 Fantastic job Jack this was great

I watched these videos so many times back in the day, I come back here six years later and I literally know what he’s going to say next it’s bare weird😅

从阿滴英文来的～

4:19 Isn't that Finn all tied up behind him?

2018 anyone?

Interesting how many years went away... I remember when I watched it was such s huge discussion in comments! It's funny nowdays that some people believed in it! Thank you Jacksgap for these nice memories! :)

I simply loved the idea. Awesome !

Michael from Vsauce is there!!

Poor Finn, tied up in a chair by his own brother making a lie XD

I watched this in 2015 and still the best 1M subs video celebration ever!

Yt recommended me this. Haha I miss the javksgap but what you've become is what everyone should see in yt. Amazing

Fin is at 4:20

OMG FINN AT THE END XD

ur videos are literally the best

I am actually watching some of Jack's videos again, to refresh my mind because it has been a long time since I have seen any of his video, and I remember this video, and I remember laughing so hard...... If you are new please watch Finn's Revenge after this!!

Anyone still here?

I miss watching them in 1 video 😭🥺

I remember watching this video when it first came out, and I still can't believe how far he's come (:

I am new and does Finn really not exist

Its fake. at 4:18 minutes, Finn is tied and gagged, really creative!

I thought he was going to say he was gay

Even after 3 years, I am still loving this video ! 😍😂

Still hands down one of the best RU-vid videos ever made.

that was vsauuse

i'm totally in love

I think it's wrong for people to be angry at them for merely taking a break. People definitely underestimate the time and effort that it takes for even one of these videos to be made. Genuinely... it's currently 6:40am and I'm still awake because I'm trying to edit a video from last night before 8pm tonight, which is when I've promised everyone it will be uploaded. I'm still rooting for you guys, and will stick with you through your crazy ups and perhaps less adventurous downs!!

i miss these videos so much.

4:19 xD

OMG vsauce

So creative and interesting hahahaha you kept me in suspense the whole video

I watched this so many times and I just noticed that it was put up on my birthday a couple years ago!!! :)

i saw Finn in the ending part where Jack said "it's only me!" and i heard Finn screaming for help

i knew it wasnt true becuase i can tell them apart. They have really different facial features and of course Finn yelling at the end while being tied to a chair 😂😂

these videos are so nostalgic i miss them so much :(

I wish they were like this today too....I really love u guys, can u guys plz be stupid like u were at this time..I really love u both...plz start uploading videos u have actually stopped making,I miss u💕💕😢😢

The good old days on RU-vid 😢

oops I watched Finn's revenge before this ._. dang

can we just talk about how impressive this video is? the fact that he got all those people involved and stuff? love these boys :)

So many other you tubers in this! This had me for a while 😂

The first time I watched this I laughed because I had met them BOTH before this was posted...

Not sure if Jack is joking or trying to erase Finn from the internet's existence. Nah, just kidding. Loved the video.

This is still one of the best yt videos I’ve ever seen

i seriously like seriously cry when i see finn, never seen a boy so beautiful

Finn appears at 4:20. Also this vid makes me feel like I've smoked some 420.

Wait, I'm so confused??

omg i dont know why i loved this so much

I remember freaking out when i first watched this😭 too cute