If The Quran Is Enough - Why Do We Need Hadith? 

Ok . Than Quran is telling you that "obay Allah and obay the messanger " Can you explain this to me please . It is not for a believing man or women _ when Allah and his messanger decree a matter ,to have any other choice in that matter , and who ever disobeys Allah and his messanger has gone far astray Ahzab verse 36.

@Unfamiliar Light so obeying the messanger meant listing and obeying the revelation (Quran ) revealed to prophet (pbuh) . Than what does obeying Allah meant .Surah nisa verse 59 Surah ahzab verse 36 states . It is not for a believing men of women when Allah and his messanger decree a matter _to have any choice in that matter .indeed who ever disobeys allah and his messanger has clearly gone far astray . I think this is enough for those who believe .

@@moi2961 Are you dumb? If the prophet's message is the same as the Koran then obey what the prophet is saying. Clearly the majority of the hadith contradicts the Koran and adds things to the Koran which was never put into the Koran.

@Unfamiliar Light for example if Quran tells us that obay your parents . So by obeying the parents we are actually obeying Allah . How can you say that by obeying the parents you are degrading Quran or you are placing your parents equal to Allah . Does that mean so ?

@Unfamiliar Light ok. When Allah created Adam ,Allah ordered angels to bow down to Adam . So angels bowed down to Adam . So who were angels worshipping ,Allah or Adam ?

How else is 4:58 going to apply without 4:59? Why do you guys always distort contexts?

@@TheQuranExplainsItself _"Indeed, Allah commands you to return trusts to their rightful owners; and when you judge between people, judge with fairness. What a noble commandment from Allah to you! Surely Allah is All-Hearing, All-Seeing."_ _Quran (4: 58)_ What context? Both verses are very clear.

@@rafayshakeel4812 4:58-4:59 go together and you can not have one without the other. The messenger can’t …judge between people with justice 4:58 if believers do not refer their disputes to Allah and his messenger 4:59 You can add 4:65 to that as well as the messenger can not judge if your disputes aren’t referred to him as per 4:59

@@TheQuranExplainsItself I'm not an expert on this. I'm not a Mufasir, akhi. But thanks for letting me know.

one of the verses of quran mentions someone named Zayed. who is he according to the original hadith rejectors? For imam Bukhari i believe you should know that he didn't find the hadiths in some cave and starts guessing which ones were authentic, all the hadiths he knows, he learned them from his sheikhs like imam Ahmed. the same goes for imam Ahmed and his sheikhs like imam Skafii ... untill the generation of the prophet companions. every hadith has a chain of narration. and the same goes for the ten readinds of the quran from Warsh and Hafs and Douri .... till the generation of companions Ibn Tabit, Ali, Ibn Masoud ... there is no harm in the idea of rejecting the hadith itself. but the problem is the results of that idea. rejecting an authentic hadith means that those who transmitted it are liars. or at least one of them, but since you can't tell exactly who then the only option you have is to assume that they are all liars. Hadith narrators like abou horeira, imam Nafii, Ibn Abbas, ... that you reject are in the same time in the chain of the ten readings of the quran. you may say it is not true but give me one quran that has not a chain of narration in its first page. or at least, a quran transmitted by hadith rejectors till the prophet PRUH. Warsh and Nafii and Hafs .... all considers hadith as a second revelation, you can't take quran from such idiots.

The hadith is the message of God. Not verbatim, but it is what Allah ordered.

just curious, how do you pray then? the Qur'ān does not specify how to pray. sometimes i don't understand Qur'ānists lol. also according to your knowledge you shouldn't trust any historical accounts or books too. you shouldn't trust anything said about the past because who knows?

​@@eepyruthe mere fact of wanting to pray and worship even if its 1 2 or 10 times a day is whats right? Not that your ordered and expected to pray 5 times at an exact time of the day like a worker going to work and doing it because they have to and not because they want to? Id rather do it cos i want to and not be forced by social traditions that are not in the quran. The quran is perfect you think it needs something else. You are wrong. We are not prophets its okay to try be like one and aim to be like one but dont insult and judge people who only want to follow the quran and do the best they can do. You are no God so sit back and let people practise their faith there way.

​@@eepyrui ma doing research between the two. I have questions if anyone can amswer... how did the prophets followers learn to pray? How did most Muslims today and thru out time learn to pray? Was it our fathers and forefathers or was it the hadiths..? . I am sure at first the sahaba firends and followers learned by learning directly from the prophet. I am pretty sure, I am pretty sure that's how it was handed down, hadith wasn't written down before quran? I am trying to decide between the sides, but it seems that logic, and a clear book outweigh what ever claims maybe out there.

Yes, Bro exactly. There are a lot of wannabe Muslims dressing like a woman and wearing beards. I ask myself why they use technology when they want to live like Arabians 1400 years ago, they should go to work on camels.

Allah has chosen different prophets for different age, for salvation and guidance of mankind whom have followed Allah's scared texts, specially in Asia, from Avesta, to the rightful Torah's text among Hebrew, and the Eastern Aramaic Gospel of Jesus, or prophet Isa historically proven Jesus prophetic mission against the rebellion against Allah's former great prophets, from the Hellenic under imposter Alexander of Macedonia, and Athenian Titian revenge after Persian king rejected their false gods, and destroyed their temples, next to Roman republic whom were defeated by the Parthia's great kings, from 50 BC era, due to their aggression plot against the Asian whom believed in one God, from Zoroastrian and Hebrews related to Abraham's and Mose's teaching, until the wicked Roman generals whom invaded Asia minor, Turkey now, as their base to invade Judaea and burn and loot the Temple of Solomon, despite the Roman defeat, by the Parthia's king Phraates the 4th defeating Marc Anthony roman legions, and having the Roman sign a treaty, to leave for good, the Herod's imposter family welcomed the Roman to have them as Herodian line protector under pagan roman, the Herodian betrayed the Abraham's and Mose's teaching, since than west Asia freed under the Parthia's kingdom became a region dominated by the Roman pagan and their rebellious partner wicked Hebrew priests and Herodian, and the nation of Palestine became a victim since, along good Hebrews of Judaea, and as Jesus was born and went to Egypt away baby killer Herod's the 1st tyrannical rule, under Augustus Caesar as a youth, by 14 AD Caesar dies, and Godless Herodotus, and Roman pagans took over, and first they beheaded prophet John the Baptist, and by 34 AD they plotted with high priest and slay prophet Jesus, also Parthia's great protector king Pharrates died in 2 BC, two year after Jesus was born, as friend of Caesar there were no power to protect Jesus and his followers rights they kept Judaea under Herodotus and Tiberius an imposter pagan, like a secure prison camp. Historically century later when the Herodian were doomed, and Roman we're defeated by the Persian great king fro 249 AD on in the early six century AD, Allah blessed and chose Muhammad whom love grand prophets teaching and west Asia lands and expressed admiration about the Persian king whom He was born in his era, as a just king, the noble Muhammad became the Prophet of Allah, and protector of the Muslim converts, by teaching good faith in one God by holy Qur'an and peace to be on earth for all the noble history of early peaceful Islam is very important, the rise of Caliphates form desert pagans masked as Muslims converts after the Roman and Herodian of Judaea must be dismissed, by all faithful always, their sinister example of power as the cursed ones has given rise to doubter ISIS gangs as a demonic order, only to form to defame the peaceful Islam faith after the cursed Caliphates once based in Syria, and Iraq, plus the useless dictatorship in some Muslim countries, for adopting the west street secular, godless Marxist ever again for all the psst lost. Now the projected wars in the Ukraine by NATO against Christian and Muslim Russian, and on going suppression and aggression in Palestine by the demonic Zionist are after the Herodotus the anti Christ and west fooled by the Zionist agents corrupting the weak Christian leaders. Soon to be cursed and doom by the divine intervention. Allah Willing.

Quran also said obay Allah and obay the messanger . Can you explain this to me . I am waiting .

I agree with u brother some only get hidayath from allah

Read front and back verses if u still cant understand i will explain

​@@lokeshraj73Allah*

Quran 16. 64. And We have not sent down the Book (the Qur'an) to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه و سلم), except that you may explain clearly unto them those things in which they differ, and (as) a guidance and a mercy for a folk who believe.

La ilaha ilAllah, Muhammadur RasulUllah ❤

You can't be a Muslim untill and unless you believe in Prophet Muhammad SAW, and make him your role model.

+ Muhammad Rasuli Allah

⁠@@codename-abdullah Say: O People of the Book! Come to a statement common between us and you: That we serve none but God; that we associate none with Him; that we erect not, from among ourselves, lords other than God. And if they turn away, then say: Bear witness that we are submitters (to one God; cf. 3:19).

​@@codename-abdullahDid he say he does not believe in prophet (saw)? He said La ilaha illalah, what's problem with that? We all have believe in prophet (saw) but Allah told us to follow the messenger not prophet (saw)

'Quranists' aka Muslims w/o denominations actually read the Quran, cite the verses and are AWARE of what their Lord has said to them. Hadith worshippers run to 'scholars' for tafsir. Hadith worshippers say Quran is INCOMPLETE w/o hadith. Blasphemy. Disclaimer: we are not Quranists, THEY label us as such. We are Muslims. Muslims w/o denomination. Period.

Either someone is a Muslim or not. There is absolutely no scope for any sects or denominations Islam nor of any Tafsir or explanation. Every needed explanation is given in Furqan(Arabic Quran) just as was given in Hebrew Quran(Torah). But most people incline to twists and falsehoods and are never satisfied with Scriptures. So they begin making their own Scriptures and distorting or hiding the originals. It seems to be a problem that never ceases to end. Perhaps that is why in Surah 2:30 says, "surely I know what you do not know" while replying to the Angels who discouraged creating humans. Afterwards in Verse 5:54 and 43:60 says about a "replacement"...

​@@mgXL7aren't Hadiths the EXPLANATION of the verses of Qur'an? like giving the wide understanding?

@@randomisieren as per Allah as mentioned in the Quran, its stated: Quran is fully detailed and contains explanation of All things. Quran states its upon us to recite it and be mindful of the verses, Guidance is from Allah alone. Hadith is anything but explanation or clarification. Hadith adds distortions and convolutes the clear Message.

@@mgXL7 alright, I got it. Just asking for curiousity, do u pray 3 times a day?

ya Allah give me nice houris

@@muhammadibnwaraqa 💀 hadith literature be like:

@@pointofview5921 k Allah allows "marriage" and sxx with children chapter 65 verse 4 - The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation

@@Sabaahal-Pirani Yes Islam is corrupted Even during the time of the prophet Muslims were fighting over correct verses. How come they did not agree.... Narrated Anas bin Malik: Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman came to `Uthman at the time when the people of Sham and the people of Iraq were Waging war to conquer Arminya and Adharbijan. Hudhaifa was afraid of their (the people of Sham and Iraq) differences in the recitation of the Qur'an, so he said to `Uthman, "O chief of the Believers! Save this nation before they differ about the Book (Qur'an) as Jews and the Christians did before." Sahih al-Bukhari 4987 And who decided which was correct .After all at that time the prophet was already dead. People decided what to put or leave out when UThman wrote his Mushaf. What Muslims today have is what those people decided should be in Quran. Not even 1 version but many different riwayat by different people. Every arabic Quran will tell the name of the reciter on page alif Just 1 expl of different verses in different Quran version by different people. Quran riwayah of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh riwayah 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.

Sunan Abi Dawud 4605 Narrated AbuRafi': The Prophet (ﷺ) said: Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch when he hears something regarding me which I have commanded or forbidden and saying: We do not know. What we found in Allah's Book we have followed.

True! Assalamu alleykum!

"Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4] Do you think the Prophet Peace be Upon Him made the stuff up???? Everything he said in regards to the religion was from Allah so it is a revelation and Allah promised to protect it! He blessed the Ummah with the science of Hadith which you don't understand!

@@Ok44398 no allah only protects his word, the QURAN, he didnt mention any bukhari or muslim or ibn majah to follow

BloggingTheology, what a great channel.

Also quran tells us what to do and hadith tells us how to do For example Namaz Wudhu Birth sunnah and fardh Funeral sunnah and fardh Halal haram Hajj Zakat Fasting To name a few

Really, found it lacking and misleading. They are apparent on what agenda they are working for. Blogging theology. Explain Sura 9:122 then. When the Prophet was clearly with the Believers when that verse came down.

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-GrWTXc6s8rg.html

Quran 16.64

I have a question about that. Is there explanation about how to pray in the Quran? If yes can you give me the number of the verse

​@@MIMI-MOCHIyou can give proof full prayer ( start to end) in single hadith? Prayer already Muslim do from the time of Ibrahim.

​@@MIMI-MOCHI Al-Muzzammil 73:20 An-Nur 24:58 Al-Baqarah 2:238 Al-Isra 17:78 An-Nisa 4:103

well, some hadith are interpretation because those were hard to understand...I could agree with that...but everything else...it doesnt make sense

Whatever the prophet says isn't from his own words. Its what Allah wants him to say. So... when he says something that isn't in the quran, it doesnt mean the quran isn'tcomplete, it just gives details and clarification. Eg. The quran says: Establish the pray and give the zakah. How you do establish prayer? Or give Zakaria? Its found in the hadith. Doesnt mean the quran is incomplete, the hadith just let you understand what quran is saying.

Thank you thank you Bless you الله أكبر علي قول الحق

و نعم بالله Unfortunately many muslims worship our prophet peace be upon Him Yet they criticise Christians for worshipping Jesus Its the same as far we can see

You are right and Muslims should read Ahadith books like bouckari and moslim And shafii and others then they will see for themselves what horrible hadiths are written on behalf of our prophet صلي الله عليه وسلم Ibn Al-Arabi said, “Lineage is an expression referring to the mixture of fluids between a male and a female from a religious legal point of view. However, if this union (between male and female) occurs through disobedience (fornication) then the resulting child is not considered part of a person’s true lineage. That is why a daughter born from zina is not mentioned in Allah’s saying, ‘Prohibited to you (for marriage) are: your mothers and daughters’ (Surah 4:23) because she is not considered a daughter according to the most authentic teaching of our religion.. If there is no legal lineage then there is no legal relationship; for zina does not prohibit (from marriage) the daughter of the mother (you committed zina with) nor the mother of a woman (you committed zina with). […]I (Qurtubi) said: The scholars have differed on the permissibility of a man marrying his daughter who was the result of an adulterous The issue of breastfeeding an adult person is simpler than to raise all such fuss. It is a matter of Ijtihaad (personal reasoning) and ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with her, was inclined to the view of establishing Tahreem (i.e. making a male and female Mahram [permanently unmarriageable] to each other) through breastfeeding an adult person based on the hadeeth about Saalim, the freed-slave of Abu Hudhayfah - who was not his son; rather, he was his freed-slave. Imaam Muslim narrated that Umm Salamah said to ‘Aa’ishah, may Allah be pleased with them both, “Boys at the threshold of puberty whom I do not like to enter upon me enter upon you!” ‘Aa’ishah said, “Do you not see an example to follow in Allah's Messenger? The wife of Abu Hudhayfah said, ‘O Messenger of Allah, Saalim enters upon me and now he is an adult, and Abu Hudhayfah feels uneasy about that.’ The Messenger of Allah said to her, ‘Suckle him (so that he may become your foster-child), and thus he can enter upon you (freely).’” In the name of Allah, the most Beneficent, the most Merciful. The full transcript of the hadith is that it is narrated by Saaidah Aaisha that the Prophet of Allah would kiss her whilst he was fasting, and he would suck her tongue.” (Sunan Abu Dawud p.331 v.1 Narrated Abu Huraira: That once he was in the, company of the Prophet carrying a water pot for his ablution and for cleaning his private parts. While he was following him carrying it(i.e. the pot), the Prophet said, "Who is this?" He said, "I am Abu Huraira." The Prophet said, "Bring me stones in order to clean my private parts, and do not bring any bones or animal dung." Abu Huraira went on narrating: So I brought some stones, carrying them in the corner of my robe till I put them by his side and went away. When he finished, I walked with him and asked, "What about the bone and the animal dung?" He said, "They are of the food of Jinns. The delegate of Jinns of (the city of) Nasibin came to me--and how nice those Jinns were--and asked me for the remains of the human food. I invoked Allah for them that they would never pass by a bone or animal dung but find food on them." There are more and more and more and more Ahadiths that proves we should only follow quoran which the Messenger delivered to humanity Thank you

Interesting

@Truth_prevail. True. Thank you for the knowledgeable insight Brother/ Sister. Quran Verse Furqan 25:30. The Prophet will say on the Day of Judgement that the people have abandoned the Quran. When I found out that there is Wudu instructions in the Quran I questioned why are we not performing it according to Quran, according to the Best Judge A’LLah’s way? Here are the answers I got from Arabic , Islamic Study learned adults. 1: No, don’t follow the Wudu in Quran. Follow the hadiths. Follow what the Prophet did, He was more detailed. But A’Llah says in 6:114 and 6:38, that the Quran is fully detailed and nothing left out 2. This is how our fathers did it 3. Quran is not preserved. It’s been changed. ( from hadith following Muslims who profess to believe in the Quran , mind you and get upset if you inform them that no , Hadiths are not protected) 4: This is new age thinking. Did you befriend someone who’s teaching you this? ( I read a literal verse and point out how it’s different from hadith) 5. Might as well be a Yahood. 6. Won’t even look at the verses that I have as references. They run away or hang up. A’LLah guides whom He wills. Alhamdulillah , He has lifted the veil from my eyes and made me realize that we cannot follow Two Books. I choose A’Llah and His Kitab of Guidance and Hikma. Alhamdulillah lil’Rabb’al Alameen.

@Truth_prevail.I agree with you. I also have noticed they cherry pick and distort the messages. They are steering the Muslims toward falsehood.

These hadith worshipers gonna say: I have to refer to my scholar i am unable to answer this question at this moment. Meaning: i go to scholar not Quran. I don't need my brain, he moulds it for me. I am hanafi shafi jafi hanbali wahibi joffrey toffi

​@@sirchale9272 i have lost family and friends. Same story as you. Its as if they're possessed and worship hadith.

Like father like son and likewise. People are sheep. They follow the majority even if it is wrong. They want the sense of belonging to the group. Thus, the groupthink and hive mindset. The biggest downfall of our civilization.

@@natebrook yess

Allah says in Quran "obay Allah and obay the messanger " Several times . Can you explain this . I am waiting ....

@@moi2961 yeah the messanger that tells you the message he got from Allah and his. In anbiya surah 45 he says he wont inform anyone if there isnt any vahiys

@@moi2961 Obey ALLAH and obey the messenger are both in QURAN 'there are around 329 sayings from the messenger .most of the verses start from the word QUL SAY. How can the HADITHS sayings be from the prophet 'when he was warned with death by ALLAH 'TO NOT MAKE UP ANY SAYINGS OUTSIDE OF QURAM 69-44 TO 69-48..

​​@@moi2961obeying the messenger is obeying Allah (4:80). Bukhari is not the messenger. Quran is words of a messenger from God (69:40-43). Messenger brings the message from God which is the Quran. Messenger's duty is only deliver the Message (2:119) (3:20) Muhammad has several titles. He is a prophet and a messenger. Allah never tells us to obey the prophet. Allah always tells us to obey the messenger. So, Allah tells us to obey the messenger that bring the message.

​@moi2961 dear, if you follow the direct commandment of Allah - the law of Allah, you obey Allah. Similarly, if you follow or act in accordance with those hadith of the Muhammad (PBUH) that are mentioned in the Quran, you follow the Messenger. These hadith are called Ahsan ul-Hadith in Quran. اللَّـهُ نَزَّلَ أَحْسَنَ الْحَدِيثِ... Allah has sent down the Best Hadith... - Quran (39:23)

Cos that's the best you can do since he's dead. Lol And if you heard what he said, he says God could have just revealed the book on its own without any messenger. Or he could have revealed it to a messenger but all at once, but he didn't. Instead he revealed it to his messenger over a period of 20 years and bound it to his life. That's why people want to follow his life too. That's how God revealed it.

you do realize that’s not true at all. The hadith were only compiled years later they were already there being practiced and taught! "Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4]

Please try to disprove the ahadith of Sahih al Bukhari, Sahih al Muslim and the 4 other books of hadith in Kutub as-Sittah, which 1000 years of Muslim scholars have never said are inauthentic. If you think you know better than them, then disprove it.

​@iconic410 Sahih Al-Bukhari book stated aisha ra was 6 and 9 years old in many hadith ( just google) and these hadith are labelled as sahih. Do you really believe that our prophet (pbuh) married a child as bukhari book says ??

@@Zafar_Askarov He (sallahu alayhi wassalam) married (or got engaged to) her at 6, and consummated the marriage when she was 9. At that point, she wasn't a child. She had reached puberty, and marrying women right after they had reached puberty was a common practice of that time, and many years after. The age of consent being 18 or 16 is a new concept, due to kids staying in school longer, meaning they take longer to develop mentally, and aren't ready for marriage. I have had to explain this to multiple non-muslims before but it saddens me to have to tell someone who says they're Muslim.

Also ironically enough, they mock Christians for worshiping a human being. When they themselves mention Mohammed in their prayers.. And they keep saying the Bible is manmade and fabricated. But the hadith does not even claim to be inspired by Allah in the first place, and they take those books more serious then their Holy book the Quran.. hypocrites

good point

good point too@@nadia5717

Very good point. That is what I was starting to think.

Literally there is no such verse in the bible, When you worship a deity who boasts that he is the best deceiver, this is what comes out of your mouth. Spreading false information about other people's religions, while not knowing the teachings of those people

Unfortunately the Muslims have repeated the very mistake of the previous receivers of revelation, they have divided themselves into sects and have taken their scholars words over the words of god. They have turned the prophet nearly into a god , and they lie about god . They make what is Haram halal! I'm so happy I woke up to the nonsense yet I'm very sadened to see how people are living a lie! By blindly following religions instead of worshipping god alone and doing good deeds.

,l,,,l,,,corrupted Qurans with different words ----------- Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh Quran 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.

Muslims are waking up

@@adamnabiyar2706 yes, my thoughts exactly. They've taken an innovation called hadith and elevated it to infallible, unquestionable and corruptible statues. Hadith is revered and worshipped, it is placed next to Quran. In this process theyve associated with Allah, thus committing shirk. In my observation, they resort to the hadith over Quran. Edit: they've also innovated and made a lot more haraam. They have labelled so many things haraam without any understanding. The innovated rules/laws are justified by resorting to hearsay and bizarre interpretations of some 'scholar'. School of thought is school of brainwash. Scholars have poisoned the minds.

@@adamnabiyar2706 that's what u wish but burn in your hate.. it would never be like which you people did.

Hadiths = satanic invention

Hadith sounds like a kid wrote it

not just as a revert brother, I who was lucky enough to be born into a Muslim family, is just as confused by the content of most hadith. So I have decided to only believe a handful of them and rely entirely on the Qur'an

stick to Quran alone is what i suggest, most rituals we do in islam is not even found in the quran, but of course youre free to choose.

You reverted, and I left. Good luck doing researches by your self.

98% hadiths are false. true Muslims only follow Quran

​@@DaGoatObitowhy did you leave? Just one confusion made you leave it?

Hey I’m a revert also and I agree with you. Don’t get too Hung up on it or take the religion too ‘extremely.’ The beauty and learning is in fasting for Ramadan, Deen, prayer, solidarity at Masjid, and reading the Quran. A lot of reverts want to join ‘ the social club,’ grow their beard, wear new clothes, and learn the customs (Hadith). But none of that is important or required.

Welcome my dear brother or sister, and I'm sorry that you even had to worry about the hadith. I too as a born Muslim is confused by this, but just know that the hadith were written 200 years after the death of the prophet based on what bukahri thought the prophet said, not only that but if you search for verse 45:6 you will see that Allah himself spoke against hadith. You see hadith just held us back from flourishing, made Muhammad saw look like a joke and restrict too much, I almost left you know! But my mother told me that if I follow Muslims I won't go far, if I follow Allah and islam then only will I feel content and it's true! Allah found me lost and guided me, my life was about to be doomed all because of something Allah never said in the first place. ❤

Well I on the other hand left Islam because I refuse to accept that a prophet of God would marry a child at the age of 6 then waited for three years to have intercourse. I am a Muslim again, and I believe that my prophet was perfect but alot of Muslims don't know that bukhari came after the prophet passed away and the hadiths came between 200 to 300 years later. In terms of if the hadiths are reliable or not, we will never know because we could not fully trust the words of all Muslims back then because humans for political reasons,if we could have then when karbala happened and the Muslims turned against the family of the prophet and killed and butchered everyone we would have known that it is possible to trust those who have lived in those times.

Wow so the prophet never said do this good thing or don't do that bad thing? Good deeds? Healthy eating?

So we don't need to actually grow our beards?

one of the verses of quran mentions someone named Zayed. who is he according to the original hadith rejectors? For imam Bukhari i believe you should know that he didn't find the hadiths in some cave and starts guessing which ones were authentic, all the hadiths he knows, he learned them from his sheikhs like imam Ahmed. the same goes for imam Ahmed and his sheikhs like imam Skafii ... untill the generation of the prophet companions. every hadith has a chain of narration. and the same goes for the ten readinds of the quran from Warsh and Hafs and Douri .... till the generation of companions Ibn Tabit, Ali, Ibn Masoud ... there is no harm in the idea of rejecting the hadith itself. but the problem is the results of that idea. rejecting an authentic hadith means that those who transmitted it are liars. or at least one of them, but since you can't tell exactly who then the only option you have is to assume that they are all liars. Hadith narrators like abou horeira, imam Nafii, Ibn Abbas, ... that you reject are in the same time in the chain of the ten readings of the quran. you may say it is not true but give me one quran that has not a chain of narration in its first page. or at least, a quran transmitted by hadith rejectors till the prophet PRUH. Warsh and Nafii and Hafs .... all considers hadith as a second revelation, you can't take quran from such idiots.

@@abdellatifaitbihi1774 Chinese PHONE! BOO BOO BOO

Heyy guess who got exiled for questioning hadith, this guy, me. OPs comments are spot on 1000% my opinion as well. Islams golden age ended, philosophical thought ended. So now we have to accept hadith 100% correct? As in its infallible, meanwhile Allah stressed only Quran is protected. When Quran says follow the Messenger, it meant the Message. When Quran said Messenger is Guardian, the meant of the people amongst Him at the time. Why did Quran say to avoid Hadith on so many occasions, why didnt Khalif Rashidun (RA) compile it? Hmmmm come to think of it, didnt all these 'scholars' start schsms in their names? Hmmm Quran said do that! Hadith is the Kaballah equivalent in Islam. Im not saying reject completely, im saying its not 100%. Dont equate it with Quran. Appreciate you OP.

@@abdellatifaitbihi1774 Zayed means so Nd so plural Where as fulana means so Nd so singular

No bc Islam is from shaytan. Muslims never had anything only the conquered nations were advanced Muslims only took over. Islamic countries do not produce anything

Mashallah

It's clear to me that the haddiths are complete nonsense. Ask anyone to tell you about the daily doings of a person who died 200 years ago, from word of mouth only, and tell me they can be even half correct. It is then clear to me that haddiths were forged only to control Muslims, by the caliphate

So never do what the phropet did? Nothing at all?

History of faith in one God, Elohim from the time of the great prophet Noah's, remain as a great scared example of salvation, extending to our age of confusion, lust, and the man's predatory behavior, and wicked mind, prophet Noah legacy must be celebrated in West Asia, where the Ark was set, every years some where in the Islamic nation of Turkey for all people of good will and faith to gather. Allah Willing!

To the person who replied to my comment saying, so never do anything the prophet did? The prophet followed the quran, so as an example if you do ghazal according to the quran, I'm sure the prophet did ghazal the way the quran says to do it. Quran tells us not to defrintiate between the prophets. I don't get why everybody is obsessed by mohammed

The Quran says its clear. So no point in Hadiths to add things which the quran hasn't said.

@@Introvertical873 Couldn't agree more. Hadith introduces laws and rules and many other bizarre things. Somehow these hadith rulings are considered islamic and unquestionable/unchangeable. Somehow they equate hadith equal to Quran and don't see this as an innovation and association. They don't see the Shirk factor.

@@jimmybeam1550 Pretty much. They have put it above the quran. There are things which go against the quran. Like the idea of punishment of the grave. Which finds its roots in hadiths and have no huge evidence in the quran. Its Almost strange the number of people and The scholars who simply took these without no critical thinking at all. Infact you'd see the Hadiths even Contradict themselves.

@@Introvertical873 i have so many examples of contradicting hadiths, critical ones like the (hard to even say these man)...like the Prophet(S) poisoning. How they contradict: Sahih al-Bukhari 4428 Narrated `Aisha: The Prophet (ﷺ) in his ailment in which he died, used to say, "O `Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison." Ok so the Prophet(S) died of ailment from poisoned food? ........ Bukhari 2617 Narrated Anas bin Malik: A Jewess brought a poisoned (cooked) sheep for the Prophet (ﷺ) who ate from it. She was brought to the Prophet and he was asked, "Shall we kill her?" He said, "No." I continued to see the effect of the poison on the palate of the mouth of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) . Prophet(S) ordered NOT to kill her! .................... Sunan Abi Dawud 4512 Narrated Abu Hurairah: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) would accept a present, but would not accept alms (sadaqah). And Wahb bin Baqiyyah narrated to us, elsewhere, from Khalid, from Muhammad ibn Amr said on the authority of AbuSalamah, and he did not mention the name of Abu Hurairah: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) used to accept presents but not alms (sadaqah). This version adds: So a Jewess presented him at Khaybar with a roasted sheep which she had poisoned. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) ate of it and the people also ate. He then said: Take away your hands (from the food), for it has informed me that it is poisoned. Bishr ibn al-Bara' ibn Ma'rur al-Ansari died. So he (the Prophet) sent for the Jewess (and said to her): What motivated you to do the work you have done? She said: If you were a prophet, it would not harm you; but if you were a king, I should rid the people of you. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) then ordered regarding her and she was killed. He then said about the pain of which he died: I continued to feel pain from the morsel which I had eaten at Khaybar. This is the time when it has cut off my aorta. So she WAS KILLED? .................. Quran: Indeed, those who show hostility to Allah and His Rasul are bound to be humiliated. The Almighty has ordained that I and my Rusul shall always triumph. (58:20-21) The Quran mentioned Jesus(AS) was saved bevause Allahs Messengers shall always triumph. Meanwhile hadith state the Prophet(S) died from being poisoned? Ordered the women killed/not killed? ........... Quran 69:46 Then We would have cut from him the aorta. And alll the poison hadith mention aorta. Edit: Lastly, not to mention, the Prophet(S) didn't say any of these for certain. This is how the chain goes for one of em: Hisham bin Ammar said: Sadaqa bin Khalid told us, Abd al-Rahman bin Yazid bin Jaber told us, Atiyah bin Qais al-Kila told us, Bad Rahman bin Ghanem Al-Ash'ari said: Abu Aamer - or Abu Malik - Al-Ash'ari told me..... It could be Aamer or maybe it was Malik....ffs.

@@Introvertical873 i have a tough time with this one but it does seem they have elevated hadith beyond Quran.

the nonMuslims need to stop disrespecting the Prophet SAWW period. That has nothing to do with Hadith. It's not portrayal in a kind light, it is simple mockery of a beloved Prophet SAWW and I can't condone it

@@billybro1403 the disrespect stems from absurd hadith narrations

@@jimmybeam1550 I don't support the hadith at all, you could call me Qur'an centric. But a leader of a religious community is for the followers of that community to deal with. He is not here to protest for the nonsense that goes on in his name, and then these cartoons etc disrespect him. By that logic there have been more violent characters in history that are not made fun of...

​@@billybro1403dear, do you mean Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was a violent character?

​@@billybro1403 brother its the hadith narrations that project the Prophet in negative light hence giving reason to ridicule. As for drawings, cartoons, this doesn't bother me one bit because, unlike widely venerated depiction of holy figures in other religions, the Prophet is the only figure without a depiction which is accepted and venerated. Therefore, their depictions of the Prophet is a testament to his purity, he did not want to be worshiped so there isnt any depictions of him. Their drawings of 'mo' cannot harm me, its a cause of celebration because it has no value whatsoever. Being upset about it is accepting the depictions are indeed of Prophet. They cant protray something they have no way of accurately protraying.

they are! They both come from the same source. The Prophet Peace be Upon him didn't make stuff up. "Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4]

@@Ok44398 the Quran is from Allah. The hadiths are from Bukhari.

​@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 💀

​@@hassanabdur-rahman1559look, I understan being not knowledgeable in some aspects but how can you not know that there were many people gathering the Ahadiths? What about Muslim, Ahmad etc?

@@user-zs6yo3fs3d why are the gatherers of the hadiths not Arab or from Arabia? Also why were the hadiths compiled 200 years after the death of prophet Muhammad (عله سلم)?

god don't need anything beside Quran but thats we who need to understand quran

absolute COPE

I agree and Allah has promised a painful never ending punishment in the blaze for disbelievers like the participants in this video for distorting His message (the Quran), following anything other than the Quran which Allah has declared as the only source to follow (Furqan ie. The criterion) and leading majority of the Muslims to hellfire along with them.

i am a Qoranist Arab and in Qoranist Arabs we consder Sunni especialy salafi are the worst enemeies of Qoran and they are more astray than pagans

❤❤👏❤❤👏

Soon they will be associating Prophet Muhammad (blessings be upon him) with Allah and saying that they are a trinity.

corrupted Qurans with different words ----------- Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh Quran 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.

@Miracleofnight__ which Quran ? There are so many different riwayat from different people . Every arabic Quran is a riwayah Arabic Qurans are not in any dialect all are in classical Arabic and 1 is not the same meaning as 3 or more (many) Verse counts for Hafs are 6236; while Warsh records 6214 Quran riwayah of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh riwayah 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. And why so many different riwayat if all have the same words. ? Like 40 different Harry Potter from different people all with the same words. Silly

True! Exactly! Peace be upon you brother my!

@@0808phoenix peace be upon you too brother 👍

yup thats what i learn by reading alot of years I only Believe in Quran

what are you talking about it 6:114 doesn't say that in the Quran.

@@1cey235 it says the Quran is fully detailed. If you believe it's missing details then enjoy.

True! I couldn't agree more!

@@0808phoenix much love brother. Stand for the truth even if you stand alone. Peace brother.

@@bigdkay3052 May Allah always protect you and your family my brother! Peace!

@@0808phoenix and may Allah protect you and your family.

one of the verses of quran mentions someone named Zayed. who is he according to the original hadith rejectors? For imam Bukhari i believe you should know that he didn't find the hadiths in some cave and starts guessing which ones were authentic, all the hadiths he knows, he learned them from his sheikhs like imam Ahmed. the same goes for imam Ahmed and his sheikhs like imam Skafii ... untill the generation of the prophet companions. every hadith has a chain of narration. and the same goes for the ten readinds of the quran from Warsh and Hafs and Douri .... till the generation of companions Ibn Tabit, Ali, Ibn Masoud ... there is no harm in the idea of rejecting the hadith itself. but the problem is the results of that idea. rejecting an authentic hadith means that those who transmitted it are liars. or at least one of them, but since you can't tell exactly who then the only option you have is to assume that they are all liars. Hadith narrators like abou horeira, imam Nafii, Ibn Abbas, ... that you reject are in the same time in the chain of the ten readings of the quran. you may say it is not true but give me one quran that has not a chain of narration in its first page. or at least, a quran transmitted by hadith rejectors till the prophet PRUH. Warsh and Nafii and Hafs .... all considers hadith as a second revelation, you can't take quran from such idiots.

"The Qur'an" That was clear enough, thanks! {أَوَلَمْ يَكْفِهِمْ أَنَّا أَنزَلْنَا عَلَيْكَ الْكِتَابَ يُتْلَىٰ عَلَيْهِمْ ۚ إِنَّ فِي ذَٰلِكَ لَرَحْمَةً وَذِكْرَىٰ لِقَوْمٍ يُؤْمِنُونَ} Al-Ankaboot: 51

lol I don’t see tafsir of rasoolullah? I just see narrations attributed to him.

its right there in the verse. Whoever doesn't follow Allah AND his messenger have gone astray

@@HalalBoi1404AND his “messenger”. The term messenger So the message of الله

corrupted Qurans with different words ----------- Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh Quran 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.

@@muhammadibnwaraqa they say the same thing?

@@Mesud-rx6ep O I see for a MUslim 1 is the same as 3 or more. Now I know why islamic countries do not produce anything the world needs .Everything Muslims use is made by Kuffar Iphone computers cars planes RU-vid Islam is of no use. Why Muslims lie even when it is obvious different Arabic Quran riwayah say different things. Different words means corrupted Quran Quran riwayah of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh riwayah 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.

@@Mesud-rx6ep one more taquiyya boy crawling around western RU-vid like a snake In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri Quran recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two different fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped.

@@muhammadibnwaraqa ???? i dont get it

I don’t know if I understood your question well, but we should learn from Quran because it’s the scripture that Allah sent for man kind, Torah is now changed by humans so we don’t learn from it.

@@jumysrr Thanks, that was the question.

[6:19] Say, "Whose testimony is the greatest?" Say, "GOD's. He is the witness between me and you that this Quran* has been inspired to me, to preach it to you and whomever it reaches. Indeed, you bear witness that there are other gods* beside GOD." Say, "I do not testify as you do; there is only one god, and I disown your idolatry."

Jesus teaches that you shouldn't kill. Muhammed was a general and ordered many killings and led people into battle. Islam doesn't make sense to me at all. They say the Quran came directly from God but the reasoning behind it is circular and has no proof. I'd say don;t learn from the Quran. Christianity or Buddhism is good enough. The religions that teach peace and forgiveness.

Great question, easy to answer. The Torah and Bible, has throughout time been modified to suit one’s needs and has many contradictions. However the Quran is preserved and cannot be changed or altered. It is easy on the tongue and it is like any other Kitab (book), it is the word of God Allah Subhana Wa Ta’ala. None can replicate like it. Science, philosophy, logic and historically accurate, everything in it. It is truly peace for the soul and will be a testimony for us on the day of Judgement Day. May Allah swt bless and guide you righteously 😊

True! Assalamu alleykum!

"Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4]

Sunan Abi Dawud 4605 Narrated AbuRafi': The Prophet (ﷺ) said: Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch when he hears something regarding me which I have commanded or forbidden and saying: We do not know. What we found in Allah's Book we have followed.

​@@Learn_Quranwithmeand no one can ever guarantee that it's really the words of the phrophet...

You are Muslim?

James you’re a nutter. Everyones consciousness is imperfect and flawed in many ways, and going with society’s accepted values and morals is also imperfect as every decade there are new feelings and actions that people condone. This religion has accommodated millions of people around the world with a solid set of beliefs that had carried us all to this point in earths timeline, and you thinking all it takes it your own consciousness to go about your life, shows how uneducated you are.

Yes, we follow our conscience. Most of muslim doesn't follow their conscience. They only follow their religious leader. I believe following our conscience is the closest path to follow god.

@@subilabi true, any man justifying a man marrying a 6 six year old is not speaking from his conscience.

@@RabinaHud agree

🤲👍

hOw dO yOu pRaY sALat ? Is one of the mushriks favourite question.

The Qur'an claims its both detailed and clear, but does that mean it cannot be futher expounded upon? Does that limit the explanation of it? By rejecting the hadiths, how are you going to pray the daily prayers that are "assigned at their own time"? By not praying, you could be classified as a 'كافر'

@@LionForIslam i pray the way my heart sees in the Quran when I read it. If people actually read it, they would have a UNIQUE relationship with Allah for He knows best. Ready the Quran alone.

@@LionForIslam Did Prophet Muhammad follow Haddiths? Did Ibrahim follow Hadith ?

Exactly! It shows how the prophet(saw) , the mothers of the believers , and the sahaba used to implement the Quran

@@kanizfatima3447 💯💯💯💙💙💙💙

That's y i read only quran n not the hadith

The Quran tells us what to do, and Hadith tells us how the Prophet did it

@@keeznotseerum6254 without hadith wu won't even know how to pray in detail? Tell me months of hajj?

"Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4] Do you think the Prophet Peace be Upon Him made the stuff up???? Everything he said in regards to the religion was from Allah so it is a revelation and Allah promised to protect it! He blessed the Ummah with the science of Hadith which you don't understand!

Muslims do have only one book, Qur'an. The hadith at best are what most narrators felt were interpretations or the Prophet's SAWW lived experience of the Qur'an.

Very well said You will be chocked when You read the type of hadiths you get from boukhari books Beyond imagination

exactly i can relate to that.

@@billybro1403 WE DONT NEED INTERPRETATION. I ALONE WITH THE QURAN IN HAND CAN FIND MY OWN CONNECTION TO ALLAH. He will reveal himself to whomever takes up and reads the Quran.

​@@billybro1403it's not just interpretation because Muslims take divine law from the hadiths and treated as infallible.

Alright where did you get how to pray Salah from? The Quran only tells you to do it, not how to, are you saying we got the method of Salah from out of nowhere? No, the hadith is where it came from, y'all Quranists I swear

​@@servant.of.allah1 so u are saying quran is incomplete?

@@servant.of.allah1 it's the sunnah, what he did and what every Muslim watched and followed then taught their children.

@@billybro1403 And where did the sunnah come from, Hadith

@@servant.of.allah1 salla isn't even prayer, prayer is a man made thing it never even came from the Quran, if salla meant prayer the Quran would have literal language errors.

"Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4] Do you think the Prophet Peace be Upon Him made the stuff up???? Everything he said in regards to the religion was from Allah so it is a revelation and Allah promised to protect it! He blessed the Ummah with the science of Hadith which you don't understand!

notice how Allah constantly mentions 'messenger' and not prophet. messenger refers to the message. which is what? the quran. so do you want to obey the messenger? then obey the quran which is the message.

Eh, I can clearly see who is arrogant here. Quran: the Quran is the best hadith (39:23) the Quran is complete (6:115) the Quran is not missing anything (6:38) the Quran is explained in detail (6:114, 12:111, 41:3, 11:1) the Quran is clarification for all things (16:89) the Quran is the best tafsir (25:33)

​@@BiekoeExactly!

​@Biekoe then why don't you say Allah means Quran...The way you have explained messenger means message.

@@ahmedraz2 bcs the messenger is the one who recited the quran to the people after it was reveald to him. So yeah obey him, in extension you obey what he says, which is the quran. Thats my point.

The Qur'an claims its both detailed and clear, but does that mean it cannot be futher expounded upon? Does that limit the explanation of it? By rejecting the hadiths, how are you going to pray the daily prayers that are "assigned at their own time"? By not praying, you could be classified as a 'قافر'

7:185 أَوَلَمْ يَنظُرُوا۟ فِى مَلَكُوتِ ٱلسَّمَـٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضِ وَمَا خَلَقَ ٱللَّهُ مِن شَىْءٍۢ وَأَنْ عَسَىٰٓ أَن يَكُونَ قَدِ ٱقْتَرَبَ أَجَلُهُمْ ۖ فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَهُۥ يُؤْمِنُونَ ١٨٥ Have they ever reflected on the wonders of the heavens and the earth, and everything Allah has created, and that perhaps their end is near? So what message after this ˹Quran˺ would they believe in? - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran Here, you've translated the word 'message' into 'hadith', and I do understand that in Arabic, the word used for message is حديث, but you've missed the point. The word حديث in this context, means another 'religion', with a new 'message'. The hadiths follow the same message the Qur'an follows. If not, could you present me a difference in both the hadiths and the Qur'an?

Quran verses regarding Hadith: Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail? … (6:114 part) These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe? (45:6) Then in what statement after it (the Qur’an) will they believe? (77:50) What is [the matter] with you? How do you judge? Or do you have a book / scripture in which you learn that indeed for you in it is whatever you choose? (68:36-38)

Bro, Does the Quran say you have to pray 4 rakath for Luhar or 7 times around the Ka'bah for tawaf?? Hadees ans Sunnah show these.

@@muhammadhshifas2179 no, no one learns it thru those books. Its the ummah that shows these. The millions upon millions. Prayer n Hajj didnt need advent of hadith to exist. Stop committing shirk.

Al-A'raf 7:16 قَالَ فَبِمَآ أَغْوَيْتَنِى لَأَقْعُدَنَّ لَهُمْ صِرَٰطَكَ ٱلْمُسْتَقِيمَ [Satan] said, "Because You have put me in error, I will surely sit in wait for them [i.e., mankind] on Your straight path.

​@@muhammadhshifas2179 are you saying Quran is incomplete and Allah SWT forgot details ?

yeah him calling them a part of revelation🤦‍♂️

Lol when he said that, I was like broooo hadiths is not revelation from God. It's the revelation from your Prophet Bukhari. It's so obvious how misguided these people are by the devil, but they don't perceive it. That's the crazy part

@@marioluigi9599 "Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4]

@@marioluigi9599 the BUHARIANS never cease to amaze

@silverboy807 it's like having the prophet speak to you ? ?? There is only one place he speaks and it's through God and that's the quaran. There is only one book we can trust. I have no need for anything else.

"Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4]

@@Ok44398 Alhamdullillah, the Quran is the revelation of Allah. I think you replied to the wrong person

Bro this is what they defend, Read: Saheeh al-Bukhaari was heard by ninety thousand men from Imam al-Bukhaari himself (may Allah have mercy on him), as was stated by one of his most famous students, namely Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari (d. 320 AH). See: Tareekh Baghdaad (2/9); Tareekh al-Islam (7/375). Al-Farbari’s narration of Saheeh al-Bukhaari was famous because he lived for a long time and was precise in copying it out. He heard it from al-Bukhaari (may Allah have mercy on him) over three years, then a number of trustworthy narrators learned it from him, and from them this book became well-known. Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH) - one of those who narrated it from Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari - said: I copied the book of al-Bukhaari from its original text that was with Ibn Yoosuf, and I saw that he had not completed it yet; there were many blank pages there, including some isnaads after which he had not written any hadeeths, and some hadeeths for which he had not written any isnaads. So we tried to complete that. End quote. Narrated by al-Baaji in at-Ta‘deel wa’t-Tajreeh (1/310) The Saheeh was narrated from al-Farbari by a number of trustworthy narrators, among the most famous of whom were the following: Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH), whose name was Ibraaheem ibn Ahmad Al-Hamawi Khateeb Sarkhas (d. 381 AH), whose name was ‘Abdullah ibn Ahmad Abu’l-Haytham al-Kashmeehani (d. 389 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Makki Abu ‘Ali ash-Shabwi, whose name was Muhammad ibn ‘Umar Ibn as-Sakan al-Bazzaaz (d. 353 AH), whose name was Sa‘eed ibn ‘Uthmaan Abu Zayd al-Mirwazi (d. 371 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Ahmad Abu Ahmad al-Jarjaani (d. 373 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Muhammad Among the trustworthy students of al-Bukhaari who heard his Saheeh directly from him and transmitted it to the people with its isnaads in written form was the imam, hafiz, faqeeh and qaadi, Abu Ishaaq Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil ibn al-Hajjaaj an-Nasafi (d. 295). The copy of an- Nasafi was transmitted by Imam al-Khattaabi (may Allah have mercy on him), as he said in his commentary A‘laam al-Hadeeth (1/105): We heard most of this book from the narration of Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil an- Nasafi. Khalaf ibn Muhammad al-Khayyaam told us: Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil told us, from him. This is the most famous way that the scholars of hadith had: they would read their books to their students, or their students would read their books to them. Then those books would become well-known through the students and narrators, not through the original manuscript of the author, which was one copy that he kept for himself. There were no printing presses or publishing houses at that time; instead of printing presses there was the narration of students with strong isnaads. What would any researcher find more authentic than the transmission of trustworthy narrators narrating from the manuscripts that were read to (and checked with) the author himself and approved by him, as they said concerning the copy of as-Saghaanni: He copied it from the manuscript that was read to the author (may Allah have mercy on him)”? See: Fayd al-Baari by al-Kashmiri. If you want to ask about how old the manuscripts that are extant today are, the Orientalist Manjana said in Cambridge in 1936 CE that the oldest manuscript he had come across up to that point was written in 370 AH, according to the narration of al-Mirwazi from al-Farbari. See Tareekh at-Turaath by Fu’aad Sizkeen (1/228).

@@mgXL7 I wasn't talking about what the video was talking about, I was pointing this out that Hadith believers say that taking a picture of a any living creature is haram but at the same time they have videos photos and what not, not only do hadith believers contradict their claim that taking or creating a picture of a living being is haram hadith has contradictions.

@@TruthBeliever5557 it's absolutely ridiculous man. Ive seen them scream n yell "pictures on the wall, namaaz is null and void"..ill chime in and say show me where and there usual follow up is "im a student of scholar NoOneCares, and he said ......" . Then ill ask again, show me where its haraam? They send back TEXTBOOK reply: "are shia, u madlhalis, u salafy, are u ahmdi, you kufr u kufr u kufr".. Me: soooo , you were so confident about prayer void n takfir .... u cant show me where its haraam. They go off like monkeys for about 25min to 48hr on my Twtr account. Fun

Bro they defend this: Pls Read: Saheeh al-Bukhaari was heard by ninety thousand men from Imam al-Bukhaari himself (may Allah have mercy on him), as was stated by one of his most famous students, namely Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari (d. 320 AH). See: Tareekh Baghdaad (2/9); Tareekh al-Islam (7/375). Al-Farbari’s narration of Saheeh al-Bukhaari was famous because he lived for a long time and was precise in copying it out. He heard it from al-Bukhaari (may Allah have mercy on him) over three years, then a number of trustworthy narrators learned it from him, and from them this book became well-known. Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH) - one of those who narrated it from Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari - said: I copied the book of al-Bukhaari from its original text that was with Ibn Yoosuf, and I saw that he had not completed it yet; there were many blank pages there, including some isnaads after which he had not written any hadeeths, and some hadeeths for which he had not written any isnaads. So we tried to complete that. End quote. Narrated by al-Baaji in at-Ta‘deel wa’t-Tajreeh (1/310) The Saheeh was narrated from al-Farbari by a number of trustworthy narrators, among the most famous of whom were the following: Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH), whose name was Ibraaheem ibn Ahmad Al-Hamawi Khateeb Sarkhas (d. 381 AH), whose name was ‘Abdullah ibn Ahmad Abu’l-Haytham al-Kashmeehani (d. 389 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Makki Abu ‘Ali ash-Shabwi, whose name was Muhammad ibn ‘Umar Ibn as-Sakan al-Bazzaaz (d. 353 AH), whose name was Sa‘eed ibn ‘Uthmaan Abu Zayd al-Mirwazi (d. 371 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Ahmad Abu Ahmad al-Jarjaani (d. 373 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Muhammad Among the trustworthy students of al-Bukhaari who heard his Saheeh directly from him and transmitted it to the people with its isnaads in written form was the imam, hafiz, faqeeh and qaadi, Abu Ishaaq Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil ibn al-Hajjaaj an-Nasafi (d. 295). The copy of an- Nasafi was transmitted by Imam al-Khattaabi (may Allah have mercy on him), as he said in his commentary A‘laam al-Hadeeth (1/105): We heard most of this book from the narration of Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil an- Nasafi. Khalaf ibn Muhammad al-Khayyaam told us: Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil told us, from him. This is the most famous way that the scholars of hadith had: they would read their books to their students, or their students would read their books to them. Then those books would become well-known through the students and narrators, not through the original manuscript of the author, which was one copy that he kept for himself. There were no printing presses or publishing houses at that time; instead of printing presses there was the narration of students with strong isnaads. What would any researcher find more authentic than the transmission of trustworthy narrators narrating from the manuscripts that were read to (and checked with) the author himself and approved by him, as they said concerning the copy of as-Saghaanni: He copied it from the manuscript that was read to the author (may Allah have mercy on him)”? See: Fayd al-Baari by al-Kashmiri. If you want to ask about how old the manuscripts that are extant today are, the Orientalist Manjana said in Cambridge in 1936 CE that the oldest manuscript he had come across up to that point was written in 370 AH, according to the narration of al-Mirwazi from al-Farbari. See Tareekh at-Turaath by Fu’aad Sizkeen (1/228).

@@mgXL7 no. Sorry. Too much

How do u pray

​@@hermes112How do you know that the traditional way that you pray by prostrating, reciting some arabic duas, pointing out your index finger in a specific sequence is indeed the correct way which Allah wants?

​@@abiyazalam453 Simple. In the Quran Allah tells us to pray exactly like the prophet prayed. And from hadith we know how the prophet prayed.

تلك في الطاعة لمن شهدوا رسول الله وليس لمن قيل لهم ان نبيكم قال هذا وهو كله كذب، اتقوا الله.

@@GabrieLight و ما الحل من و جهة نظرك؟؟!

@@mohamedali2858 الحل في ماذا؟! القول العاقل المعتدل الوسطي الذي لا علاقة له بالتطرف والتعصب والذي يتبعه الاقليه من الامه هو ان ايات الله قطعية الثبوت في كتاب لم يمسه تحريف محفوظا بأمر الله، ما وافق ايات الكتاب من احاديث نقبل بها وماوافق العلم "المجرب" نقبل به مثل حديث الذبابه، غير ذلك لا يهمنا ولا يجب ان يشغلنا، يجب ان نعود الى كتاب الله، كتب الاحاديث كانت اكبر فتنه شتت اكثر المسلمين عن كتاب الله وتدبر معانيه، اصبح الواحد ممن يسمون انفسهم علماء يؤلف مؤلف كامل عن حديث ويحسب نفسه على الهدى بذلك وأنه يخدم الدين كما كان يفعل "الوضاع الصالحون" سبحان الله! ان وجدت ما اقوله ليس بالحق فهذا يعني انك تعاني من الانحياز والتعصب.

@@GabrieLight كلامك رائع و خطير.. اذا ماذا نفعل بصحيح البخاري و صحيح مسلم و كتب السته المتخصصة فى احاديث الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم ؟

@@mohamedali2858 انا اخبرتك بالفعل مايجب على المسلم إعتقاده في الحديث، عليك بالقراءه المتأنيه.

@Sabaahal-Pirani I'm open to the hadith perspective changed but I have doubts like okay the hadith has chain of transmitters but the shia hadith too and lost between the two because both are claimed to be correct?

@Sabaahal-Pirani thank you thats interesting I'd like to read about it

@@adzmadethis1163shia Hadiths are completely different, they have kitab Al kafi and some usually don’t like Sahih bukhari or Sahih muslim Hadiths. The way they do rituals (wudu) is also different. I’m not a Hadithist, I’m also not a Qur’anist. If there’s Hadiths that corroborate with reason and Qur’an (through intellect) I have no problem. But Hadiths aren’t even revelatory material they’re about two centuries after the fact, they’re not preserved and they’re not memorized or mutwatir.

hadith most of the times need explanations themselves and also get interperted in different ways. so that doesnt make sense. cus with that logic we would need another book that explains the hadith. and agin and again and again

That simply means that Allah has left upon us. He sees our intentions more than actions. He has given us brain to analyze and interpret his message and act accordingly. We don't need a strict code of conduct on how to sit eat walk sleep laugh etc. Allah has made us humans, not robots

Assalamu alleykum! I do know indeed! And many are waking up and asking the same questions!

Quran verses regarding Hadith: Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail? … (6:114 part) These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe? (45:6) Then in what statement after it (the Qur’an) will they believe? (77:50) What is [the matter] with you? How do you judge? Or do you have a book / scripture in which you learn that indeed for you in it is whatever you choose? (68:36-38)

Casting / drawing lots: sunnah hadith: Prophet(PBUH) casted lots to make decisions.....sahi I had a team of fiqs and hanafi scholars run a train on me today for bringing this up lol then i got exiled haha

Imam bukhari did not write a physical copy of sahih bukhari and the first sahih bukhari manuscript was in the 12th century. Allah knows how many things were changed to fit someone's agenda

This is called sherk with the book! Deen Islam is only the words of Allah, becoz its verses preserved by the word of Allah unlike human books, the book of Allah is perfected before prophet Muhammad (pbuh) died, the book of Allah has everything, that's mentioned already in Qur'an. You keep misleading new muslims who doesn't study Islam in Arabic, you keep feeding fanaticism and extremism thoughts, that's why since human hadith books appeared the majority of ummah living in a stray, doesn't follow Islam teachings at all, becoz they left Qur'an and followed parties and words of people! It's mentioned in some "hadiths" that at the end of time, munafiqoon will teach Islam to muslims, also mentioned that iblis will take a picture of a man and tell hadiths in markets and they'll believe him! The verses you mentioned has nothing to do with hadith books, it's talk about the people who witnessed the prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and both the prophet and his rashidun caliphs told muslims to not write his sayings so people doesn't mix it with Qur'an and also to not leave Qur'an for it! You always mixing the "sayings sunnah" with the "acts sunnah" like learning how to pray to convince people with hadith books while both subjects are different, we inherited the acts from generation to another by imitating but not inherited the sayings, that's why muslims was praying rightly and normally for 250 years before hadith books appeared, and i can't explain it more in english, but you should get it. At the end we only follow Qur'an then we accept any hadith that is agree with Qur'an verses, and also any hadith that met the "experimental" science like the fly hadith, that's what every rational Muslim should apply in his beliefs. {وَنَزَّلْنَا عَلَيْكَ الْكِتَابَ تِبْيَانًا لِّكُلِّ شَيْءٍ وَهُدًى وَرَحْمَةً وَبُشْرَىٰ لِلْمُسْلِمِينَ} Al-Nahl: 89 {أَوَلَمْ يَكْفِهِمْ أَنَّا أَنزَلْنَا عَلَيْكَ الْكِتَابَ يُتْلَىٰ عَلَيْهِمْ ۚ إِنَّ فِي ذَٰلِكَ لَرَحْمَةً وَذِكْرَىٰ لِقَوْمٍ يُؤْمِنُونَ} Al-Ankaboot: 51 I prefer any incoming arguing to be in the Arabic language, but if you don't know Arabic then please make yourself a favor and stop it, it means you're not qualified to enter such discussion, Salam alaykum!

You're right, that was my reply to the video.

Some hadiths we dont know if they are true. Thats why we should check with the Quran to make sure they are real

That answer should be easy. Which is God’s word? You go with the Quran. I’m sure there are contradictions. Because the Hadiths aren’t supposed to be followed.

@@melodyarencibia9594well said

Surely He gave you the free will to make your idiocy apparent for the world to see through these comments. Next time, choose not to embarass yourself

@@alhomsiyyahI think he thinks him writing the comment was not freewill 😂

@@kanizfatima3447 Allah willed for him to right the comment obviously and for me to write this. Its all part of his plan. All of it. Freewill is an ilusion. Allah guides who he pleases. Their is no free will. Whether we try to subvert Allahs plan or follow it, does not matter, we are following Allahs plan.

did you not exercise free will before writing something inane, or did predestinstion compel you to be foolish?

@@maessof91 Allah gives hidayah to everyone. Qur'an is accessible to you at your nearest bookstore, free copies are available for download. That's hidayah all around you, now upto you to take it or leave it

you are not Muslim

@@salman6978 what is a Muslim ? Shia Ahmadiyya Alevi Ishmaelite Sufi Sunni Salafi Taliban ?

@@salman6978 You are not Muslim

@@SheikhAlladeen Islam is what quran says....

@@productive-muslim Islam is what Quran says ? No Ahadeeth ? So you do Mut'ah and only pray 3 x a day ? And which Quran are you ref to. There are over 40 different arabic Qurans by different Qari 1, Qaloon Qur'an 2, Al- susi(ibn-katheer) Qur'an 3,Khaled QUR'AN 4,Idrees QUR'AN 5,warsh Qur'an 6, Hafs Ad- Dury (Abu - Amro alBasri) QUR'AN 7,Al- Laith QUR'AN 8,Al- Bazzi Qur'an 9,Al- Azraq QUR'AN 10,As - Susi (Abu Amro alBasri) QUR'AN 11,Ad - Dury(alkisa'i) QUR'AN 12, Ibn shanboodh Qur'an 13,Al- Asbahaani QUR'AN 14,Hisham QUR'AN 15,Ibn Dhakwan QUR'AN 16,Isa BinWardan QUR'AN 17,Sulayman QUR'AN 18, Ibn Jammaz QUR'AN 19,Ahmad bin Farah QUR'AN 20,Qunbul Qur'an 21,Showba QUR'AN 22, Ruwais QUR'AN 23,Shujaa' bin Abi Nasr Al- Balakhi QUR'AN 24, Abu Amro Al -Ala QUR'AN 25,Hafs QUR'AN 26, Ruh QUR'AN 27, Al- Dury(Al Hasan AlBasri) QUR'AN 28, Hafs Al - Dury(ibn kathir) QUR'AN 29,khalf QUR'AN 30,Ishaq QUR'AN 31,Al Hasan bin Said Al- Matuu'l QUR'AN 32, Abu- Farah Al- Shan - budhi QUR'AN

Hadith did not split the ummah. What split the ummah is people innovating in the religion and following their desires. You will not find someone following the Sunnah of the Prophet ﷺ except that they are doing this ummah a great service, and trying to unite us upon the truth!

@@alhomsiyyah they are too many diffrent opinions about hadiths and like i said some hadiths are not authentic and contradictive. Thats why it lead to innoventions. Thats why we are split. Ppl should focus on the Quran and use it as a guidance and use the Hadiths as some side informations which could possible be true.

@@FFeeLiT my brother/sister, hadith science is not the issue. The issue lies within people who mislead others _using_ weak ahadith or fabricated ahadith which the scholars already clarified are weak or fabricated. The same can be done with the Qur'an - the khawaarij misled plenty of people with their ta'weel of the Qur'an. But the Qur'an was never the problem. The authentic sunnah wasn't either.

@@alhomsiyyah But it still devided the ummah. And the devided ummah is the reason why we are living in such a world.

@@FFeeLiT he doesnt care he wants to just say follow hadtih because he to them muslim countries follow hadith and if you say no hadith then you are saying those muslim countries are wrong.

Oh they say and do much worse than that. They are taking the messenger as a law maker and Second authority which he is not. This makes them mushriks.

@@darfvaderr2191 are you guys alright? They both come from the same source. "Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺" [Surah An Najm 3-4]

@@Ok44398 The Quran is enough. Why can you just accept that in your heart.

@@Ok44398 hadith came from the prophet Muhammad? So the messenger couldn't just give us everything that was revealed to him and have it all end up in Qur'an and Qur'an alone? People had to extract information from the messenger through hearsay, by overhearing what he supposedly said or others said about him in everyday speech? That's basically saying the messenger was unable to fulfill his mission of what he was appointed to do. So needed other people to somehow extract information from him to complete it. What a horrible, unreliable, ridiculous way to complete a revelation. I heard prophet say, I heard so and so say the prophet did this or did that. Instead of the messenger just giving it to us straight in the Qur'an, it took hundreds of years after his death for other people to perfect Islam. Aatagfirullah! The Qur'an is enough. If it was enough for the messenger then it is enough for every human-being on this Earth!

@rasco27 why can’t you guys understand that the sunnah is wahy (revelation) he didn’t speak from his own desires when it came anything related to Islam. Allah promised to protect the revelation! The science of Hadith is not some cheap telephone game that emerged 200 years after Prophet Peace be Upon Him like is widely spread. This science is something the ummah was blessed with along with the oral tradition that is also used to preserve the Qur’an.

Ho should we pray or we don't need to pray?

Obey Allah and obey the Messenger (pbuh). Linguistically it would be incorrect for this to mean : "obey Allah and obey the Quran" As this would be unnecessary repetition. The only logical and correct meaning is : Obey Allah and Obey his Messenger (pbuh)

lol your explanation is like say obey Allah2x instead obey Allah and His Messenger

@@mohammedkamalhussain3694obey the messenger these people were unable to read so they sort the project when he was alive and could ask him now we are in the age of higher education and understanding and can read the Quran ourself

@@mohammedkamalhussain3694 ok that’s your interpretation of the first part. I will show that is incorrect; but first, what do you say about the second part (Quran explaining all things), linguistically?

@@suegem Simple questions to you: 1. Is the sunnah mandatory or optional? 2. Did the sahabas disobey the prophet (pbh) by only writing the Quran (as you believe) and living out the hadith?