Тёмный

Indian atheist debates Evangelical Christian 

Vimoh
Подписаться 48 тыс.
Просмотров 6 тыс.
50% 1

Otangelo asked why I am an atheist. I said it had to do with there being no evidence for the existence of god. The conversation took us towards logical models and methods of knowing what is true.
I am Vimoh, an Indian atheist and my videos have to do with religion, atheism, Indian culture, and sometimes contemporary political happenings.
Support this channel at / vimoh
Or make a one-time donation at vimoh.stck.me
Below are some videos from this channel that every Indian atheist must watch.
✔️ Videos for the Indian atheist - • Delving Deeper
✔️ How I became an atheist - • My journey between rel...
✔️ Why I am not a "Hindu atheist" - • Why I am not a Hindu A...
✔️ Why I am not a "Hindu atheist" (part 2) - • Belief in karma = beli...
✔️ The Indian atheist problem - • The Indian atheist pro...
✔️ Why atheism is important - • You can't fight irrati...

Опубликовано:

 

23 май 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 71   
@jstube36
@jstube36 2 года назад
At least the Atheist is honest when he says "I don't know". Something that seems very hard for some people to admit. And to his defense. There is yet to be any proof of any supernatural existence.
@preetgamer1495
@preetgamer1495 6 месяцев назад
Its about the sense of insecurity ! People fear to live with the statement "I don't know" and hence look for something to cling on irrespective of the fact that its untrue. In short, delulu is the new solulu
@ddspace
@ddspace 2 года назад
This was a good debate and I hope Otangelo revisits his core beliefs.
@roywallace5899
@roywallace5899 2 года назад
Why should he once again we accept you to believe what you want but you just can't leave us to believe what we do there is no God
@ddspace
@ddspace 2 года назад
1. Because there are no facts to support your belief in God 2. Because historically this belief in an unverifiable God has always be used to create rules (i.e.) what people should or should not do to receive God's blessings or curses Atheism is not a "belief". Its a mechanism to say "Here's what we know based on facts and here's what we don't know". It is a way to appreciate the world for all its grandeur and complexity without automatically assigning it an all knowing creator.
@roywallace5899
@roywallace5899 2 года назад
@@ddspace I am an agnostic you might as well say atheist because it would take God floating down from heaven right before my eyes and touching me and healing me of my pain so I'm with all of you it is time to drop this God s*** mankind knows what's good and bad or evil we know right from wrong it does not take some higher being to teach us this I agree with you 100% about religion and this silly believe in God I live in the Bible belt in Arkansas United States don't know where you're from but these people here are screwed up
@ddspace
@ddspace 2 года назад
​@@roywallace5899 A lot of folks have been subject to mental conditioning at a young age and that is something that is very hard to overcome. Logic and facts rarely win against deeply held beliefs. Religion is very very old and for all the terrible things it has unleashed, it has still provided people with a sense of structure and belonging. It will take a long time before religion is replaced.
@roywallace5899
@roywallace5899 2 года назад
@@ddspace I have the same morals talk to me by my mother in my house when I was a child that anybody who goes to church and listens to to this day if you want to go sit there and think there's some God watching over 7 billion people on this Earth and his name is Jesus effing Christ then believe it but it doesn't belong in our schools it belongs in your churches and in your communities and homes you don't have the right to subjected up on my kids it must be awful to think that the only way you can have morals is to believe in some hokey God but that's just my belief
@-logic6654
@-logic6654 2 года назад
Your mental endurance is great 😅 i am easily irritated by these dodgy arguments, good job pinning it right before things got loopy.
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
Thanks! The trick is to not over reach and deal with things on the table. One thing after the other.
@michaelmccarthy2369
@michaelmccarthy2369 2 года назад
@@vimoh you don't let people speak you constantly speak over people and you believe in a big bang an idea by a mortal man for some reason you believe where people have been with God for 2000+ years. Just like Indian scammers. You are well dodgy mate
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
The gentleman I was speaking with also seems to agree the big bang happened. Do you think he is dodgy too?
@swagatochatterjee7104
@swagatochatterjee7104 Год назад
@@vimoh how do you train to calm yourself down. I always start raging at times, which defeats the purpose. It would be great if we can learn the same.
@vimoh
@vimoh Год назад
I don't know why. 😊
@imme805
@imme805 2 года назад
Atheist :- i don't know, i will explore and will find an answer. Theist - Well it must be God, God did that, God did this 😂 so God is the answer for theist's "don't knows".
@yuishigami780
@yuishigami780 11 месяцев назад
Dont forget it also is always god of my religion
@gurnoorsingh2214
@gurnoorsingh2214 Год назад
'I dont know' is better than ' my good god made us in his image, he did this did that and he loves you'
@StiveGuy
@StiveGuy 2 года назад
I don't know is better than asserting something without evidence.
@freethinker812
@freethinker812 Год назад
Good explanation vimoh sir.. Thanks please do more debate with Indian thiests also in hindi.
@RustyWalker
@RustyWalker 2 года назад
Not having a reason to believe in God is not a good reason to not believe in God? I can't help myself. I think we're going to need to list a few things we don't have good reason to believe. Starting with the obvious: -Santa -the tooth fairy -easter bunny -the flying spaghetti monster -mermaids -Bigfoot Does it follow that not having a reason to believe in mermaids is not a good reason to not believe in mermaids? I don't think it's necessarily the case that the universe is expand "into something" since space-time is within the universe. Think of it like all the galaxies are dots drawn on the skin of a balloon as it's blowing up, but the skin of the balloon itself is space-time. The analogy is weak because the balloon is in atmosphere, so you need to focus just on the skin and ignore the atmosphere. The atmosphere is in space-time but it wouldn't be true for the balloon as the universe. The *inflation* of the universe had a beginning. That's not the same thing as the universe having a beginning. Wasn't the demonstration of the existence of the Higgs-Boson particle ontological? They had calculated it should exist and set about an experiment to show it existed. I'm still not that confident with ontology.
@RustyWalker
@RustyWalker 2 года назад
@Rib_Guy_101 People have claimed to have God or claimed revelation in other ways, but it does not follow that they did, and thus it does not follow that God has given us anything.
@RustyWalker
@RustyWalker 2 года назад
*to have heard
@AmitKumarAlphaX
@AmitKumarAlphaX 2 года назад
The Werewolf analogy got me ROFL! 😂😂😂✌️✌️✌️✌️
@sindhubs23
@sindhubs23 2 года назад
Wow!
@kk-ot9kn
@kk-ot9kn 2 года назад
You should do a collab with thecosmicsceptic!!
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
Kahaan wo, kahaan main
@glkglkglkglk9193
@glkglkglkglk9193 2 года назад
@@vimoh the onlything you're lacking is the audience man ,,,,,you're straight up there
@kk-ot9kn
@kk-ot9kn 2 года назад
@@glkglkglkglk9193 Bilkul sahi. Aap lage rahe bhai Vimoh audience bhi aa jaayegi hopefully.
@peacefullife8587
@peacefullife8587 2 года назад
💙🙏💯👌
@DhruvSingh-ev8md
@DhruvSingh-ev8md 2 года назад
👍👍👍
@amangadpale9284
@amangadpale9284 8 месяцев назад
They ask questions in round and won't on point as they want to make the word i believe come from your mouth , they keep creating logically fallacies
@dhanaazm7897
@dhanaazm7897 Год назад
Hi this was a very interesting conversation. I don't want to debate but just explore it further. We all know that the physical world is ruled by very strict laws. They are almost mathematical in nature and no one calls mathematics, God. However we don't know the spiritual rules, we don't even know that spiritual rules exist. So we know, that we don't know much about anything or many things. So far God per se is defined differently by different people and has remained elusive to all. But if we understand spiritual rules (if they exist) maybe we can then kind of pinpoint multiversal God. Just a thought.
@vimoh
@vimoh Год назад
Sure. If they exist. And their existence has to be demonstrated. If it can't be, then why would we assume they exist.
@dhanaazm7897
@dhanaazm7897 Год назад
@@vimoh so in order to prove spiritual laws we will need to invent some machines to measure them, show them, or for that matter price it's existence. Having said that I am sceptical of scientific rules and laws because in spite of empirical evidence they refuse to accept certain ideas as truth.
@vimoh
@vimoh Год назад
@@dhanaazm7897 If you want to come on my live stream and discuss this further, you're most welcome.
@dhanaazm7897
@dhanaazm7897 Год назад
@@vimoh Yes I would love to Vimoh. Let me gather something to talk about what to talk about. Thank you so much for the offer.
@raymondcarter1137
@raymondcarter1137 2 года назад
What’s the difference between your imagination and god and how can you tell the difference? There’s no difference.
@nitishpavithran3191
@nitishpavithran3191 Год назад
Tell me one thing what is diff btw creator and god
@nitishpavithran3191
@nitishpavithran3191 Год назад
Creator is only one quality that god possess. God by religious definitions has more qualities like love, compassion, mercy , judging, anger etc. Can u explain me why an entity with these much qualities won't work as much as with chance of luck for everyone through communication tool called prayer
@MrlovaLova16
@MrlovaLova16 21 день назад
The old man what thinks is logical. And other thinking is illogical. He can say without any evidence that God created this universe. But when vimoh says there a thing which is half human and half werewolf. Will u believe it. He is saying an illogical question. What is the logic behind the old man's thinking.
@nicolebartlein1854
@nicolebartlein1854 2 года назад
I don't have enough faith to be an atheist.
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
That's not an argument for anything. Let alone an argument against atheism. Atheism is not faith. It is rejection of faith that god exists.
@bharatpenumutchu6487
@bharatpenumutchu6487 2 года назад
Being an atheist is to be rational, because the whole concept of faith (in god) is irrational . Religion is just mental gymnastics conveniently linking random events to an entity no one has seen.
@trenton1190
@trenton1190 2 года назад
You seem to be willing to admit both that there is no absolute proof that God exists and that there is no absolute proof of any other explaination as to how creation was formed. The question then becomes what makes you choose one belief over the other?
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
My point was that what kind of evidence convinces the theist that there is a god. I have not rejected any evidence because no good evidence has been presented. My position is neither of what you proposed. It is simply 'I don't know'.
@trenton1190
@trenton1190 2 года назад
@@vimoh "Good evidence" is subjective. You reject the evidence you reject because you deem it to be not good, not because there is proof that it is not good. If there were proof that it were not good then it would not be evidence. Me and you are in the same boat, we both admit that we don't know, the difference is that I believe and you do not. Why do you think that is?
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
@@trenton1190 Because, as you said, I do not find what you consider evidence, to be convincing. So I reject the claims you make on the basis of it.
@trenton1190
@trenton1190 2 года назад
@@vimoh Then that means either you find evidence that there is no God more convincing, or that you just don't want to believe in God. Mind if I ask you if there is any one evidence in particular that convinces you that there is no God?
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
I repeat. I never say there is no god. I say nothing about whether god is possible or not possible. I say 'I don't know'.
@VishwaneetSingh
@VishwaneetSingh 2 года назад
To those who believe, no proof is necessary. To those who don't, no proof is possible Vimoh, stop wasting your time.
@vimoh
@vimoh 2 года назад
What a pointless comment.
@VishwaneetSingh
@VishwaneetSingh 2 года назад
@@vimoh 😁
Далее
Indian atheist debates Evangelical Christian - Part 2
27:29
Indian atheist debates theist about knowledge of god
14:33
Мой инстаграм: v1.ann
00:13
Просмотров 117 тыс.
Идея под заказ😂
00:20
Просмотров 212 тыс.
Belief in karma = belief in god
9:38
Просмотров 10 тыс.
How Hindus appropriate Atheism: A Dance of Definitions
23:45
Evolution random chance nahi hai
18:48
Просмотров 20 тыс.
Believe it or not: An unbelievably hilarious debate
8:36
Appoota doesn't understand agnostic atheism
14:39
Просмотров 3,5 тыс.
Atheist vs Christian: The argument from complexity
22:20
My journey between religion, spirituality, and atheism
1:13:16
Мой инстаграм: v1.ann
00:13
Просмотров 117 тыс.