Тёмный

Influences vs. Rip-Offs (Greta Van Fleet Review Addendum) 

fantano
Подписаться 1,8 млн
Просмотров 247 тыс.
50% 1

My Greta Van Fleet review: • Greta Van Fleet's Anth...
Follow your melon:
Twitter: / theneedledrop
Instagram: @afantano
FB: / theneedledrop

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

 

1 ноя 2018

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,2 тыс.   
@noelc8927
@noelc8927 5 лет назад
You know it's serious when Anthony's lighting gets better
@steviewonder1663
@steviewonder1663 5 лет назад
Normal video: nightlight Serious video: nightlight and a ceiling fan
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo 5 лет назад
Or when the Flannel turns into a Plaid.
@zacroper3577
@zacroper3577 5 лет назад
Some of his older videos (2014 - 2016) are genuinely aesthetically pleasing, don't know what happened to that.
@cheesecakelasagna
@cheesecakelasagna 5 лет назад
Now I know why Ant keep getting beautiful in my eyes
@drmarkchang
@drmarkchang 5 лет назад
Noel C E
@coffeemon3607
@coffeemon3607 5 лет назад
Red = Bad Orange = Meh Yellow = Good Blue = Plagiarism
@ShalerMelee
@ShalerMelee 5 лет назад
Coffeemon 360 nice
@february690
@february690 5 лет назад
I read meth lmao
@rckstr1123
@rckstr1123 5 лет назад
Coffeemon 360 nice
@MichaelGrey11
@MichaelGrey11 5 лет назад
Wife beater = Meme
@fallentrash1673
@fallentrash1673 5 лет назад
Good Plagiarism = Blue and Yellow.
@Dethmaster64
@Dethmaster64 5 лет назад
theneedledrop is a rip-off of thatistheplan
@SJ-ff6zh
@SJ-ff6zh 5 лет назад
#neverforget that Fantano copystriked all thatistheplan videos and got their channel terminated to conceal his blatant thievery #staywoke
@ThatOneGuy7550
@ThatOneGuy7550 5 лет назад
thatistheplan is a rip off of Anthony Fantano
@iamgreatness542
@iamgreatness542 5 лет назад
@@SJ-ff6zh true
@kozhikkaalan
@kozhikkaalan 5 лет назад
You sweet marmalade man
@gdawgs101
@gdawgs101 5 лет назад
@@ThatOneGuy7550 r/woooosh
@forgivenessstops423
@forgivenessstops423 5 лет назад
Lol Anthony I think you’ve got it all wrong. Led Zeppelin is the one who ripped off Greta Van Fleet. Not the other way around. It’s ok, we all slip up sometimes
@pascualsandoval6592
@pascualsandoval6592 5 лет назад
Ikr, fuck led Zeppelin bunch of posers, more like dead Zeppelin
@MicTheGuitarMan
@MicTheGuitarMan 5 лет назад
thats funny, i told a buddy of mine that Led Zeppelin only existed to get us ready for Greta Van Fleet
@xenigron6237
@xenigron6237 5 лет назад
@@pascualsandoval6592 zeppelin conquered the world ,they were beautiful , REAL Musicians with one of the best vocalist of all times,you are just an envy loser like the ones that can't bear the GVF enormous success,you are dead sandoval,now return to listen to your crap,idiot
@forgivenessstops423
@forgivenessstops423 5 лет назад
@pascual sandoval aw geez man he told you
@bonesaw2716
@bonesaw2716 5 лет назад
Greta Van Time Machine
@mikecasino5427
@mikecasino5427 5 лет назад
Just happy king gizzard was used to explain how a real modern rock band works lmao
@AIXONA
@AIXONA 5 лет назад
Mike Casino yeah same I was sitting down thinking of them and he said their name and I jumped out of my chair like woah wtf
@keisi1574
@keisi1574 5 лет назад
Coke and Hentai Wow! I was just thinking of all the words in your comment- then boom! there it was!
@gastrodong3893
@gastrodong3893 4 года назад
Julian incorrect
@rytovanatoly1409
@rytovanatoly1409 4 года назад
@@julian2955 no
@zackzallie8735
@zackzallie8735 3 года назад
Fuck GVF. King Gizzard needs more recognition. Theyre pretty retro yet very original.
@breadmold6647
@breadmold6647 5 лет назад
Greta Van Fleet is like that friend who rips all their jokes from a RU-vidr but won't admit it and trys to deny it.
@mayfalltribe4747
@mayfalltribe4747 5 лет назад
YouWontDivideUS
@Rekko82
@Rekko82 5 лет назад
You just described Led Zeppelin.
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo 5 лет назад
I used to do that but with rap battles instead of jokes at lunch and I got caught once. I could have walked right up to embarrasment and give it a hug the feeling was that real that day
@coltoncurlee2423
@coltoncurlee2423 5 лет назад
Bread Mold or all their musical opinions *oh shit you got me*
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
the worst cover band is better than the shitty alternative garbage
@OMGYasuke
@OMGYasuke 5 лет назад
Melon, why are you hating on Led Zeppelin so much lately?
@florida_mane6267
@florida_mane6267 5 лет назад
Cause they tha DEVIL'S music
@benjamingiddens6758
@benjamingiddens6758 5 лет назад
It's interesting because my little brother's favorite band right now is GVF. He had literally never heard of LED Zeppelin until after falling in love with the first GVF album. Now he listens to both bands
@squatchjosh1131
@squatchjosh1131 5 лет назад
​@@benjamingiddens6758 Weird that it turned out that way since Zep is pretty much always one of the first bands people try when they try getting into rock, like AC/DC, Queen and Nirvana. I'm not quite sure how that happened with your bro
@Rekko82
@Rekko82 5 лет назад
Because Led Zeppelin are blac people's music.
@lilwaterpump3289
@lilwaterpump3289 5 лет назад
Squatch Josh I personally started with newer bands when I started getting into rock but I guess everyone’s different
@TheDude4077
@TheDude4077 5 лет назад
GVF literally wears Led Zeppelin costumes on stage and tries to mimic Zep's body language. Literally just watch one live performance of GVF and pay attention to how the guitarist does the exact same poses as Jimmy Page, and how the singer does the exact same hand thing (y'all know what I mean) Robert Plant does when he sings, and then say they're not ripoffs.
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
so what??? rather than (c)rap slternative deathspeedemonumetal I would prefer to listen (and spend LOTS of money)on hundreds of clones of the band from the 60 70 and 80's!!!! That was REAL music
@banana-boatdreamsicle8859
@banana-boatdreamsicle8859 5 лет назад
@margix cringe
@frogwad
@frogwad 5 лет назад
margix poes law?
@xenigron6237
@xenigron6237 5 лет назад
@@banana-boatdreamsicle8859 poor loser envy of who is able to play real rock,you're a pathetic piece of shit
@FremboFiveDown
@FremboFiveDown 5 лет назад
This man logged into three different accounts just to sound like an idiot on all three.
@Zhoniin
@Zhoniin 5 лет назад
I swear when I heard Greta's radio song (the one with the hook like "YOOO HOOO" or whatever) I legitimately thought it was some Zep song I'd never heard before. Maybe the DJ was playing a deep cut or something. But then I heard him say it was Greta afterwards and it blew my mind. I immediately thought "how were they signed?". I think Fantwan was justified in his review. But hey that's me, I don't know shit about anything.
@IsaacPurpleguy
@IsaacPurpleguy 5 лет назад
"I don't know shit about anything." Same here lol
@benjamingiddens6758
@benjamingiddens6758 5 лет назад
Whatsbinteresting from my perspective is that GVF is currently my little brother's favorite band. He had never even heard about Led Zeppelin until after he fell in love with the first GVF album. Now he listens to both
@OmniTron1000
@OmniTron1000 5 лет назад
same.
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
I would like them to be even more zeppelin sounding since on the last album they are not,I also would like hundreds of new bands sounding like the bands of the 60 70 and 80 since THAT was the BEST period for modern music,fuck alternative the clash "modern" (read FAKE) rock etc...
@OkByeNw
@OkByeNw 5 лет назад
They probably got signed because they sound similar to Zeppelin and other forms of classic rock, so their label probably thought they could successfully sell records by addressing a currently underserved genre. You don't have to lose your shit about it.
@CLaw-tb5gg
@CLaw-tb5gg 5 лет назад
I think John Lennon said "originality is trying to be like someone else and failing"
@lynnpehrson8826
@lynnpehrson8826 5 лет назад
Influenced by zeppelin = White stripes Ripping off zeppelin = GVF
@pallbearer1175
@pallbearer1175 5 лет назад
Big Facts
@rckstr1123
@rckstr1123 5 лет назад
THIS
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
hahaha white stripes are zeppelin for the dumb alternative kid that cannot play ....gVF are the REAL THING since they can play for REAL ,
@forgivenessstops423
@forgivenessstops423 5 лет назад
@margix haha, nice joke. You should write that one down
@colangelog09
@colangelog09 5 лет назад
I always thought "Aint no rest for the wicked" was by the white stripes. However that fits into the conversation...
@JesseMaurais
@JesseMaurais 5 лет назад
If Greta had put actual Zeppelin covers on their album and owned the cover band label, they'd probably get a lot less shit from critics. But they're young and naive, and I suspect they'll find their own sound eventually.
@Calvin_Coolage
@Calvin_Coolage 5 лет назад
Mixing their own songs with one or two Zep covers actually seems like a good idea, honestly.
@jodiallardice1500
@jodiallardice1500 5 лет назад
They actually covered a lot of zeppelin songs in the early days, there’s a video compilation of all their zep covers
@sinane.y
@sinane.y 5 лет назад
I highly doubt they're naive lol. I think they're cynical assholes who got their whiff of money and said "hey suckers buy it, keep doin it"
@UnitedFeodor
@UnitedFeodor 5 лет назад
@CoolerKing37 The Beatles, The White Stripes, The Rolling Stones
@UnitedFeodor
@UnitedFeodor 5 лет назад
@CoolerKing37 Led Zeppelin themselves as well.
@quintinpace2627
@quintinpace2627 5 лет назад
Critics hated Zepp too oh my god Greta wont stop with the imitation
@Andf-kc4xx
@Andf-kc4xx 5 лет назад
history repeats itself and everyone complaining about GVF simply dont understand that notion.
@gaagleboss6449
@gaagleboss6449 5 лет назад
difference is lz was hated because they sound different from the music critics were used to back then, they weren't open minded as today. while gvf gets shitted on for basically being lz .2. only good lz ripoff band is probably triumph
@WeTalk440
@WeTalk440 5 лет назад
I genuinely laughed my ass off at this
@kipwilliamson5737
@kipwilliamson5737 3 года назад
@@gaagleboss6449 true!
@raphaellages3454
@raphaellages3454 2 года назад
this aged well
@ghostlightinthegreenroom
@ghostlightinthegreenroom 5 лет назад
GVF's lyrics really sound like they were written by a Rush/Zeppelin algorithm
@thenoodledrop
@thenoodledrop 5 лет назад
Kyle Orzech I’m sorry people keep comparing them to Rush but like how ???? Maybe the debut album Rush but even then ????
@skyfox490
@skyfox490 5 лет назад
@spando dongdee the vocals
@jessegro4
@jessegro4 5 лет назад
Uncle Remus yeah but Kyle said LYRICS are a mix of Rush and Zep and that’s super insulting to Rush lol. Neil is an amazing lyricist
@TheTechAndScience
@TheTechAndScience 5 лет назад
They sound nothing like Rush, not the riffs, vocals, lyrics or anything.
@ghostlightinthegreenroom
@ghostlightinthegreenroom 5 лет назад
Guys and gals, I said the lyrics are like Rush, not sound. And mostly I meant the more fantasy elements. Like mentioning the sun, and the moon, rivers, frolicking through meadows. In terms of the Zeppelin stuff, I can't stand the "mama" stuff. I have a hard time imagining these kids actually calling a girl mama in 2018
@OurFoundingLiars
@OurFoundingLiars 5 лет назад
I think the Gretta guys might be from the same cloning facility the “rapper” Kid Buu is from. Look for any strange markings on them. Keep asking questions
@florida_mane6267
@florida_mane6267 5 лет назад
Greta Van Fleet is the Logic of rock bands imo.
@WordoftheElderGods
@WordoftheElderGods 5 лет назад
Look for a π on the heel of their foot.
@steviewonder1663
@steviewonder1663 5 лет назад
My boy Trippie Blue coming in clutch with two correct statements
@mitchellgass4141
@mitchellgass4141 5 лет назад
@@florida_mane6267 "[BLANK] is the [BLANK] of [BLANK]" Behold the internet music hot take formula
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo 5 лет назад
This comment should have been said by a black person and on twitter.
@analogies
@analogies 5 лет назад
This applies to visual art so much too. Artists of all kinds whether they be illustrators, fine artists, graphic designers, etc. have to deal with this very same issue and I think your words resonate in those fields as well. I wish more people would talk about these things in the visual arts, but I’m glad at least there’s a logical video such as this to dispel the difference of influence vs rip off.
@TheMFYeti
@TheMFYeti 5 лет назад
I think a strong difference is that in fine arts, you learn very quickly to be good or be good at it - meaning that if you're going to appropriate a style, you need to make a twist on it very fast to not get labeled a hack or just know your influences and subvert them to make your own kinda style. I know that's exactly what Melon's saying, but I think it's a bit more prominent in the art world where people have 0 qualms about calling out rip-offs. Then again... Jeff Koonz is a millionaire ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@analogies
@analogies 5 лет назад
Right, each genre of art has their own subset of rules about what’s appropriate and what’s not when it comes to being influenced and straight up ripping off. In anime you could say that the vast majority of these artists rip each other off, but it’s not an issue, in fact it’s indubitably supported by its community. But then there’s like a weird nuance to it all where each anime artist has a _slight_ variation on the anime style and you need to be well versed in the aesthetics to even notice it. Even then I think it’s rare that any anime fan would care that much if someone was ripping another artist off because the design philosophy behind it completely supports that sort of thing. If anything it’s more seen as being influenced and they separate styles, usually by era since each artist in that genre tends to follow the design trend of the time. In fine art it’s a hard thing to tackle because it covers so much ground, but for the most part you really do have to have a solid reason to be copping another artist’s style especially because people with be adamant about throwing you off your pedestal. In fine art and illustration artists are more seen as brands, entrepreneurs, or even “inventors” (I think they’d like to see themselves as that anyway). So if you fuck with their marketability then there’s a price to pay for it. But they act that it’s more about having integrity to be your own person and do your own thing. There’s truth to that, but in both those fields often times artists can get away with ripping off certain artists especially if they’re from the distant past. Kind of hypocritical in my opinion tho..so it’s only ok if the artist are dead? But really it just supports my other point..it’s more about marketability. The dead artist have nothing to support so it’s “ok” to steal from them because they’re not gonna go after you, they’re dead after all. People will see it more as an “homage”, but it’s sort of like intellectual grave robbing seeing as how the former is perceived as so much worse. They act like it’s about having genuinely interesting ideas they really care more about how long their careers are gonna last. Having truly unique ideas is just a perk I think.. it’s not really the sole basis of why they do things even tho the profess that it is. But I digress, that’s more of a rant on my part. I’m definitely of the camp that really appreciates when artists find their own path, but I totally don’t mind seeing influences in their work either. Just think artists need to be honest with themselves as well as try to push their ideas into interesting places, because it benefits everyone at the end of the day.
@mariosuena
@mariosuena 5 лет назад
“Tell me brother... what were you the god of again!?” *Thor summons Thunder* *Greta Van Fleet starts playing in the background*
@Speeff
@Speeff 5 лет назад
Pepito Greta Van Fleet exist for movies to not have to pay a bunch of money to use a Zeppelin song
@dinoflame9696
@dinoflame9696 5 лет назад
wow thats probably true. just like how most modern abstract art is just a money laundry scheme.
@NICKWAPPERER117
@NICKWAPPERER117 5 лет назад
@@Speeff they exist because zeppelin doesn't let people even USE their music in movies for the most part lol. Toatall agree
@leftovernoise
@leftovernoise 5 лет назад
Grethony Fleetano
@vaildog1
@vaildog1 5 лет назад
Vampire weekend and Paul Simon are a prime example of heavy influence done well. They took what Simon was doing and ran with it to a point where it feels more like an inventive sequel than a remake
@itsbeyondme5560
@itsbeyondme5560 4 года назад
@@jeremyc9593 They do idoit
@afternoonwalk6384
@afternoonwalk6384 5 лет назад
People tend to mistake you for a melon. Are melons ripping you off? Or is it the other way around? You have some explaining to do, Jon from ARTV!
@thelighthousekeeper9520
@thelighthousekeeper9520 5 лет назад
Greta Van Fleet should be called Greta Van Feet cause they took a major L
@jacobsarvathayaparan2337
@jacobsarvathayaparan2337 5 лет назад
Shouldn 't that make it Greta Van Flleet?
@thelighthousekeeper9520
@thelighthousekeeper9520 5 лет назад
Ah shit
@maxintrnt7013
@maxintrnt7013 5 лет назад
well this is awkward
@bouteillemauve
@bouteillemauve 5 лет назад
@@jacobsarvathayaparan2337 or Greta Van FLeet
@thescoobymike
@thescoobymike 5 лет назад
🤔
@bill6364
@bill6364 4 года назад
Perfect example of influence without imitation: Electric Light Orchestra and The Beatles.
@honeycomblord9384
@honeycomblord9384 2 года назад
Porcupine Tree and Pink Floyd is another good example.
@calebdonaldson8770
@calebdonaldson8770 2 года назад
Justice & Daft Punk
@nurgle333
@nurgle333 2 года назад
STP and Zep
@axeties3087
@axeties3087 Год назад
Death grips and nav
@Christian-97
@Christian-97 Год назад
Talk Talk and Radiohead.
@guitarmaniac004
@guitarmaniac004 5 лет назад
Anthony I burned my flannel. Notice me
@redcalxz6846
@redcalxz6846 5 лет назад
Remember Led Zeppelin!!? I clapped when I heard Greta Van Fleet because they sound like a band I recognize!
@marcomeme4875
@marcomeme4875 5 лет назад
RedCalx Z what about the new memorable sounds?!
@venusinblurs9430
@venusinblurs9430 5 лет назад
AT-AT'S! AT-AT'S!
@florida_mane6267
@florida_mane6267 5 лет назад
When is Melon gonna have Maukaly Caulcan (I know I fucked that up hard) in one of his reviews
@dustycomputer1806
@dustycomputer1806 5 лет назад
Simon Torres AC/DC! AC/DC!
@gretasstolendreams2154
@gretasstolendreams2154 5 лет назад
Jay bauman is that you?.
@Msflamingo-wl4qo
@Msflamingo-wl4qo 4 года назад
The great Robert Plant called GVF "Led Zeppelin 1", in a good way. But when Robert mentioned that GVF says "(our) biggest influence is Aerosmith", he rolled his eyes, coughed then smiled. 😂😎
@nartebear
@nartebear Год назад
Ironic because only 2 songs on Led Zeppelin one weren’t stolen
@marcomeme4875
@marcomeme4875 5 лет назад
Fantano is a melon rip off
@twinblade6
@twinblade6 5 лет назад
I'm a simple guy. I see *NOT GOOD* on one of Fantano's videos, I click.
@Rodrigombia1990
@Rodrigombia1990 5 лет назад
You're pure evil
@ThatOneGuy7550
@ThatOneGuy7550 5 лет назад
You're a hero
@andrearieta8291
@andrearieta8291 5 лет назад
I can't believe he pulled down the video, tho.
@poopstain5216
@poopstain5216 4 года назад
twinblade6 sheep
@ladyyupiel2821
@ladyyupiel2821 5 лет назад
*SHOW FEET*
@jackbanker4244
@jackbanker4244 5 лет назад
We have to donate more tokens
@BlakeBolton98
@BlakeBolton98 5 лет назад
Greta Van FEET
@ledzeppelinfan1001
@ledzeppelinfan1001 5 лет назад
So we hit this cancer now huh?
@matthillfromcollege4109
@matthillfromcollege4109 5 лет назад
Really uh, just really through and through from the comment to the name to the icon one of the worst RU-vid comments ever
@sebbama5376
@sebbama5376 5 лет назад
holy shit dude can you link me your profile picture thats amazing
@lucaschamberlain253
@lucaschamberlain253 5 лет назад
I hadn't listened to GVF until just now. It's like Gus Van Sant's remake of "Psycho": just because you _can_ mimic someone else's art, doesn't mean consumers should care. It's marketable because the original already established the hype and expectations. GVF is clearly talented, why not put your _own_ spin on something instead?
@cherrrymaraschino
@cherrrymaraschino 5 лет назад
The members of greta van fleet seem like the kind of people who were locked in an attic as kids by torturous parents, only had old rock records to play with, and were only given plates of hamburger helper through a crack in the wall as to avoid contamination from outside music sources.
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
THEY HAVE BEEN PREVENTED TO BE POLLUTED FROM (C)RAP (S)HIT HOP ALTERNATIVE AND OTHER FAKE MUIC NONSENSE ,YOU HAVE THE DUMB TORTUROUS MINDS PIECE OF SHIT
@virmico1
@virmico1 5 лет назад
LOL! Ever been to Frankenmuth? It is the least Rock n' Roll place on earth. No wonder the little dwarf Josh looks like a hobbit: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8isgfHclHHA.html
@EvanSaltare
@EvanSaltare 5 лет назад
@@margix1172 you're in middle school aren't you? The last time I heard the whole (c)rap joke was 15 years ago from the emo kids who sat by the handball court, yet never played handball.
@dinoflame9696
@dinoflame9696 5 лет назад
not american so had to google hamburger helper. all their food looks like savory vomit. which is sort of what led zeppelin is to me.
@bigogarland7325
@bigogarland7325 5 лет назад
Yeah. What a charmed upbringing. Hamburger helper rules. Music sucked after the 80s. I am jealous.
@Gnurklesquimp
@Gnurklesquimp 4 года назад
Agree with this, I think there's valuable stuff to be said about having an identity, but at the end of the day, your reason for making a certain kind of music doesn't have to be any more complicated than ''Yeah I like it''
@jameslabuschagne1915
@jameslabuschagne1915 5 лет назад
Actually getting kind of annoyed with the fanboys of GVF reacting so incredulously. Do they really not hear how identical they sound to LZ? The instrumentation is blatant enough, the singing though... come on man. COME ON.
@jons5756
@jons5756 5 лет назад
THANK YOU!!! God, they were getting annoying.
@jeltje50
@jeltje50 5 лет назад
There is literally no one defending GVF...
@jons5756
@jons5756 5 лет назад
@@jeltje50 go to his review. And change comment settings from top, to newest.
@jeltje50
@jeltje50 5 лет назад
@@jons5756 I did... And found nothing. Maybe there are like five people who said it. But they are an EXTREME small minority.
@jons5756
@jons5756 5 лет назад
@@jeltje50 The majority of them were from when the video came out. The only likes any of them have are their own.
@Bambi_9000
@Bambi_9000 5 лет назад
I'd really like to hear what you have to say about the new Slipknot track
@Falxifer95
@Falxifer95 5 лет назад
He shared it on Twitter so it'll probably appear on the Weekly Track Review. Hopefully, that track was SO BANGER!
@Bambi_9000
@Bambi_9000 5 лет назад
@@Falxifer95 I'm hoping so, cuz yea that track got me pretty hype
@peaceofmind7313
@peaceofmind7313 5 лет назад
I love Knitslop
@Bambi_9000
@Bambi_9000 5 лет назад
@@peaceofmind7313 same
@squatchjosh1131
@squatchjosh1131 5 лет назад
Sounded like self titled with modern production imo, not a bad thing I just hope if they're planning a return to their roots they do something interesting with it
@littleferrhis
@littleferrhis 5 лет назад
Greta Van Fleet is the Ready Player One of music when it comes to nostalgia. “I know that thing from the past and I am a walking encyclopedia on it, look at how cool I am for knowing that”.
@mrplut0
@mrplut0 4 года назад
All of their videos’ comment section is stupid. Save music industry? More like “Hi, I am either a very attention-seeking 16 year old/below or an old man who thinks every other music genre fucking sucks and only rock and roll can be in the industry.” This is why Pop vs Metal war begun in the first place back in early 2000s till now; close minded elitists. This band? They didn’t save anything. They’re just recycling the old work, and tweaking a bit on their own. They’re just a cover band without covers. There are other rock bands who are unique and have fresh and new sound, if anything those bands are the one that deserves to be called as the “savior of rock”.
@TotalRunningProductions
@TotalRunningProductions 5 лет назад
Fresh melon
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo
@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo 5 лет назад
Taste like shit
@blarghblargh
@blarghblargh 5 лет назад
​@@Y0utubeIsFuckingHomo Flowers grow from shit 🌺
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
anthony,david lee roth was right when used to say that the critics that did not like them were all nerds that listened and looked like elvis costello,you are as ugly as costello,but more dumb and less talented than him
@gaythiestMTG
@gaythiestMTG 5 лет назад
Fresher than the Prince of Bel-Air
@jayjasperjp
@jayjasperjp 5 лет назад
Pale Waves sounds identical to The 1975. It’s almost a parody
@SalvSceptile
@SalvSceptile 5 лет назад
Their album was produced by Matt Healy
@MrDussek
@MrDussek 5 лет назад
they’re literally on tour with each other
@tcaw8813
@tcaw8813 5 лет назад
Neither of them write their own stuff tho
@oddfutureplaylist
@oddfutureplaylist 5 лет назад
The lead singers hair bothers me
@westerling8436
@westerling8436 5 лет назад
his voice bothers me, it's like I'm the only one who notices it's stupid and like a parody, am I neo in this matrix?
@ellijahminogue344
@ellijahminogue344 5 лет назад
He looks like Frodo
@cdreyes81
@cdreyes81 5 лет назад
When he sings , he makes these faces and remind me of Jack black singing
@ellijahminogue344
@ellijahminogue344 5 лет назад
@cdreyes81 Saddest part is that Tenacious D is more of an original band than GVF.
@kbkman7742
@kbkman7742 4 года назад
@@westerling8436 I always thought it was an ugly chick
@EFarley81
@EFarley81 5 лет назад
"Two much-overdone Willie Dixon blues standards fail to be revivified by being turned into showcases for Page and Plant." -Rolling Stone 1969
@landey5191
@landey5191 5 лет назад
I think melon is a rip-off of grapefruit.
@lennyrose5852
@lennyrose5852 5 лет назад
How much for the red flannel, Antonin? $$$😩😩😩💀💀💀
@Hhuiza0
@Hhuiza0 5 лет назад
Saint Laurent dont even use the Y no more, his taste for the vintage is deeper than i thought
@antoinea.9791
@antoinea.9791 5 лет назад
two and a half melons
@Hhuiza0
@Hhuiza0 5 лет назад
@@Noah-wv4td the website its still ysl, and mostly bags and heels use the old ysl logo since its iconic to those, but its still just slp
@EYTPS
@EYTPS 5 лет назад
Melon good vid but did you really need to agree with Pitchfork here?
@benjaminpugh4775
@benjaminpugh4775 5 лет назад
Though I do agree with the whole similarity between Zep and GVF, being a fan of both bands I can distinguish which one is which. They are starting to distinguish their own sound and as Fantano stated; most bands wear their influences on their sleeve before they develop. Give this band a chance!
@CoadyShay
@CoadyShay 5 лет назад
Melle Melon, review Ben Shapiro on Meme Review.
@toiletbrush69
@toiletbrush69 5 лет назад
Pewdiepie set a new low for himself.
@danielcain7535
@danielcain7535 5 лет назад
0:07 I guess you could say he's going to... 'ramble on'
@mind0killer
@mind0killer 5 лет назад
I love hearing the influence in an artist when they bring their own fresh vibe to the table as well. It helps me feel connected, since I feel like, "Hey, this band I like also likes this other band that I like!"
@ilovemiffy888
@ilovemiffy888 5 лет назад
I can’t lie, I actually do like Greta Van Fleet. I don’t feel so good about their last album, but their debut album is pretty solid in my opinion and I can listen to it in its entirety and enjoy it. However, I think all the criticism they receive is pretty warranted. From the interviews I’ve seen, they seem like guys who love music, but they’re so wrapped up in an era they couldn’t experience that probably died out for a reason. I mean they have to be doing something right though, 70’s and 80’s hard rock was never appealing to me (punk and emo are more my speed) and they sure did catch my attention.
@fuzzydunlop4513
@fuzzydunlop4513 5 лет назад
Im pretty sure I've lost 1 friend so far because of my negative opinions on Greta Van Fleet lol.
@skyfox490
@skyfox490 5 лет назад
That’s how it be
@SpiralDream
@SpiralDream 5 лет назад
Sorry to hear that your friend is deaf
@pepperings
@pepperings 5 лет назад
and I've gained one!
@pcaviator687
@pcaviator687 5 лет назад
I don't fucking care who they sound like...if you enjoy their music then that's all that really matters. It will be up the them to decide what direction they will go and how successful they will be.
@robsylvia6546
@robsylvia6546 5 лет назад
If GVF had a different vocalist they would sound nothing like Led Zeppelin. They’d sound like a 70s era bar band playing their own compositions. The singer has the voice he has, and I like it. Sometimes he sounds like Plant, Sometimes a little like Geddy, Sometimes like Jones, and I guess sometimes like himself. Yes, they capitalize on these influences, but they generally drive me to the influences. I listen to Greta on line, I spend the day listening to LZ. People complain about the lack of musicianship, and how they suck compared to LZ, but LZ were seasoned musicians already. Page already famous, and at one time a sought after sessions player/studio musician, so they were on a whole ‘another level , even by today’s standards. I don’t know that GVF can change, or should, because the kids listening to them don’t necessarily make the LZ connection...and older listeners like the LZ connection. Win win for them. I hope they make millions. They’re neither a clone band, or a tribute band, nor are they original. They are however a bunch of kids chasing a dream, and I can’t knock them for that.
@EFarley81
@EFarley81 5 лет назад
"The album’s most representative cut is “How Many More Times.” Here a jazzy introduction gives way to a driving (albeit monotonous) guitar-dominated background for Plant’s strained and unconvincing shouting (he may be as foppish as Rod Stewart, but he’s nowhere near so exciting, especially in the higher registers)" -Rolling Stone 1969
@explodyz
@explodyz 5 лет назад
Compare an band inspired by led zeppelin to greta van fleet and you really see the difference. Inspiration still requires creativity to stand out while greta van fleet does nothing to be creative. It's like comparing kevin hart to Amy schumer
@ilovecody7514
@ilovecody7514 5 лет назад
The NOT GOOD epilogue.
@dxyzstudios2144
@dxyzstudios2144 5 лет назад
So how do you draw that standard with pop music? If the vocals were more similar you could easily mistake any artist today for another.
@cowboycatss
@cowboycatss 5 лет назад
I’m a huge fan of GVF, your review was very good. You acknowledged they were talented but you also talked about how they need to evolve their sound.
@IgnorancEnArrogance
@IgnorancEnArrogance 5 лет назад
It's ok to steal. You just gotta morph it into your own unique way of doing it, and not steal too much. Noel Gallagher stole a lot for Oasis, including straight up stealing the riff for "Bang a Gong." The difference is that he used that riff to make an entire new song unique to him, and played it in a different way in a different key. GVF doesn't change up the stuff they steal whatsoever.
@jakexdilla
@jakexdilla 5 лет назад
What you said about some of the greatest rappers ever starting out wearing influences on their sleeve and coming into their own is so true. Kendrick Lamar’s first mixtapes had such a Lil Wayne influence it’s crazy. Kendrick also made To Pimp a Butterfly and GKMC within three years of each other.
@wadekemmsies7180
@wadekemmsies7180 5 лет назад
Yeah Great Van Fleet will fade into oblivion just like Wolfmother.
@not_ian5543
@not_ian5543 5 лет назад
Wade k 21 Oof
@PowerTheGamer
@PowerTheGamer 5 лет назад
What happened with wolfmother?
@user-hw3wb3ic8j
@user-hw3wb3ic8j 5 лет назад
they did kinda fall off huh
@hibuddywazsup3739
@hibuddywazsup3739 5 лет назад
@@PowerTheGamer Exactly
@tommywalzer9051
@tommywalzer9051 5 лет назад
Wolfmother is never going to fade completely. In my personal opinion their last album was pretty good. But regardless of that, their debut album was so strong with hits like "Joker and the Thief" and "Woman." Those tracks are basically embedded within the generation (mine) that grew up with that music. They'll probably just be remembered as one hit wonders tbh but those songs will be karaoke favorites a few decades from now. They're not going anywhere.
@coolmanjack1995
@coolmanjack1995 5 лет назад
What did you think of Temples first album? I dont know of a specific band they sounded like but they did just adopt the 60s sound. I liked it but felt weird about it
@TresWash
@TresWash 5 лет назад
Hey Anthony, nice shirt bro! 👍🏾
@moony4566
@moony4566 5 лет назад
Anthony I don’t think you get credit for how handsome you are bro
@williehopscotch
@williehopscotch 5 лет назад
GvF fans are like Drake stans: totally delusional and just *can't* accept the L that was served to them on a silver platter.
@billwren5033
@billwren5033 5 лет назад
call them what you want the band is getting bigger every day.I accept the fact that they sound like Zep and I am ok with that.No delusion here.
@williestackson5720
@williestackson5720 5 лет назад
While the Jamband scene may not be for everyone that is where some of the most innovative music comes from in my my opinion. Some of my favorite Jambands include Umphrey's McGee, Phish and Electric Octopus.
@SuperMiley1994
@SuperMiley1994 5 лет назад
Can u do a review on the Struts? They're influenced by Queen but i wanna know whether or not if they sound too similar to Queen that it became a rip-off.
@jeremyc9593
@jeremyc9593 4 года назад
The answer was.....................no.
@SenatorJaiz
@SenatorJaiz 5 лет назад
As a musician most everything I do is a product of my influences. When making music just make sure you are not influenced by Marvin Gaye. His family does not mess around. They make you PAY. That being said, I mostly agree with you on GVF, but in the end it is just rock-n-roll. Rock was not made to be heavily analyzed. Sometimes all a song has to do is make me tap my foot and get into a groove, so there is that.
@HeyImBrim
@HeyImBrim 5 лет назад
I mean yeah, GvF sounds like Led Zep but if you can't tell the difference between the two bands that's on you. I find it laughable that people say these bands sound exactly alike...
@evgordon9095
@evgordon9095 5 лет назад
Not much difference same chord progressions same sounding voice similar grooves similar writing style
@TheTctoocold
@TheTctoocold 5 лет назад
Muh gvf
@SidewalkTrip
@SidewalkTrip 4 года назад
Wow really got em mr. bitches
@GraphTechGuitarLabs
@GraphTechGuitarLabs 5 лет назад
Would you say the same thing applies to Airborne Vs. AC/DC?
@AdmiraHax
@AdmiraHax 5 лет назад
Well, Anthony, after so many logical arguments you said, it's difficult to argue with you. However, I always believe in people. I will keep my eye on the boys from GVF. They will certainly change for the good. You can see it by comparing their EP "From The Fires" (I own that one and I don't regret anything) and their latest LP. I am really curious what will they become. We just have to keep the criticism constructive and do not get emotional like their music insults our mothers. I cheer on the boys, because they have a dream. And like W. Disney said, if you can dream it, you can do it (Yeah, cringe, I know).
@harperlee8516
@harperlee8516 5 лет назад
Ripthony offtano
@dariocaporuscio8701
@dariocaporuscio8701 5 лет назад
Melon, please review the track "With the love in my heart" by Jacob Collier!
@GormlyKeep
@GormlyKeep 4 года назад
Big difference between wearing your influences on your sleeve and just changing the lyrics of classic songs
@djjazzyjeff1232
@djjazzyjeff1232 5 лет назад
I like Greta Van Fleet. You don't have to, but if your main reason for disliking a band is because they sound like another band, I personally think you may need to leave the house more often.
@pazuzu6589
@pazuzu6589 5 лет назад
It’s his job to critique music.
@TheTctoocold
@TheTctoocold 5 лет назад
But what off the other band sounds better and therefore melon has no reason to listen to gvf
@djjazzyjeff1232
@djjazzyjeff1232 5 лет назад
@@pazuzu6589 No I get that, and that's why I didn't attack him or his criticism directly, but that's honestly how I feel. If your main criticism is that a band sounds like another band then you may as well never listen to music ever again because music is inherently derivative.
@saheliumd7182
@saheliumd7182 5 лет назад
The fact that I haven’t ever seen them acknowledge Led Zeppelin in interviews is annoying.
@TeaLeafThief
@TeaLeafThief 3 года назад
This. Intact they claim they are influenced by Aerosmith. I am beyond angry about this cheap dog shit Zeppelin rip off and how they have managed the comparisons in the media. If they owned it it would be ok, but they would tell you they have never heard of led Zeppelin. Makes me sick. What a shit band.
@rockobama4022
@rockobama4022 3 года назад
They have but the thing is that they’ve always been told they’re exactly like Led Zeppelin. They shy away from it because they don’t wanna be Led Zeppelin no matter how much they sound like them. There’s videos where they talk about their influences and someone will say “Led Zeppelin” and they honestly say they were a Heavy Influence
@not_ian5543
@not_ian5543 5 лет назад
Is it weird that I like GVF’s From the Fires EP more than this one?
@kaorii10
@kaorii10 5 лет назад
ShutInBoy no dude it is better imo too
@monsterinthepants
@monsterinthepants 5 лет назад
I honestly feel like they've begun departing from the Zep sound. If you look into it, the songs that sound the most heavily influenced were written years ago, and the newer songs are the ones that have really resonated with the fans. They're still really young, and I think that by the time their next album comes out they'll have really found their sound while out there touring
@omars.4159
@omars.4159 5 лет назад
Melon acknowledging Ninja Sex Party makes me feel good for some reason, being a fan of GG and all
@genericwhitekidthesecond4330
@genericwhitekidthesecond4330 5 лет назад
I thought Melon God was friends with them though, right?
@jaygreen1359
@jaygreen1359 5 лет назад
Mastadon is a perfect example of of being influenced by certain styles of music while having their own sound
@vgynylrecords
@vgynylrecords 3 года назад
Sha Na Na were great. For a band in the late 60s to already be making tongue in cheek parodies of 50s "at the hop" culture is kind of amazing, they were pretty ahead of their time. Granted I probably only ever heard about them because of being a Hendrix fan, but they deserve their place in history.
@aidenferry23
@aidenferry23 5 лет назад
Also you NEED to do Zeppelin in classic week. Thank you for coming to my TED talk
@ONFIREYO
@ONFIREYO 5 лет назад
Hey guys what do you think about my music?
@ian8736
@ian8736 5 лет назад
Do track review of the new slipknot song
@ian8736
@ian8736 5 лет назад
Anthony...I’ll be pissed if you talk shit about it
@evanmoses8669
@evanmoses8669 5 лет назад
Track review request: Slipknot - All Out Life
@margix1172
@margix1172 5 лет назад
rather than liste to a single second of the garbage fake music called shitnot I would listen for the eternity ALL the cover bands of this world,fuck you and your shitty tastes of "music"
@meinlpurealloychina227
@meinlpurealloychina227 5 лет назад
margix jeez. Someone is upset.
@quentinbringthenumetalchil5125
@@margix1172 Slipknot > Greta Van Fleet. Change my mind.
@CarloBruh
@CarloBruh 5 лет назад
@@meinlpurealloychina227 lmao I wonder why tho
@xenigron6237
@xenigron6237 5 лет назад
quentin childs shitnot and gvf shouldn't even be in the same sentence...shitnot is pure diarrhea...gvf is pure chocolate..fuck deathspeedemonumetal REAL ROCK RULES
@ikamts2
@ikamts2 5 лет назад
They have a lot of time to change. They fell into a trap of everyone telling them they sound like Zeppelin so they just went with it. I guess that’s fine because after all we are talking about them... so they have their name out there, they could now easily change their sound
@pee8607
@pee8607 5 лет назад
It’s not just the vocals, its the riffs too, the main riff on highway tune is literally just the rover
@papajohn8115
@papajohn8115 5 лет назад
Greta Van Fleet just reminds me of Fleet Farm
@mightymcloven3321
@mightymcloven3321 5 лет назад
"Whatever, whatever, whatever, I digress." -Melonhead
@Not_Whelan
@Not_Whelan 5 лет назад
Yoooo, dropping that Psychostick reference!
@xXXJimboSliceXXx
@xXXJimboSliceXXx 5 лет назад
Would you consider the death metal band Gruesome a cover band without the covers? Since inception it's been a nod to Death (formed after a Death To All tour, the first album is dedicated to Chuck Shuldiner, and music draws heavily from early death metal bands from the late 80s / early 90s), but some metal dudes I know think Gruesome sounds more like early Bolt Thrower or Massacre.
@Mothlover69
@Mothlover69 5 лет назад
James Crowell ooh I love me some bolt thrower. If you're interested in old school death metal listen to the band obliteration
@jzga1
@jzga1 5 лет назад
Think my issue with GVF is not that they "rip-off" Zeppelin, is that the songs are just flat out bad. Take for example The Young Veins formed by ex members of Panic At The Disco, that album has HEAVILY influenced/ripping off The Kinks but those songs were actually quite catchy and enjoyable. If you're gonna make a song that influences/rip-offs a sound from yesteryear, at least make it good.
@judehastings2643
@judehastings2643 5 лет назад
jzga1 Panic at the disco, dude you’re literally asking for a beating
@JakobeOG
@JakobeOG 5 лет назад
Lol PATD get out
@pepperings
@pepperings 5 лет назад
all their flat outs won them best rock album, they made it better than good.
@sean3279
@sean3279 4 года назад
As someone who is starting to make music right now this video really helped. Thank you Melon boi
@someirishguy1662
@someirishguy1662 5 лет назад
Interpol are an interesting case for influences, the band set out listening to def leppard, and Paul Banks is more into hip hop than rock music yet his music is reminiscent of a noughties post punk
@Aandi_pants
@Aandi_pants 5 лет назад
So are you gonna review Psychostick new album or what?
@Sockedin
@Sockedin 5 лет назад
In their track Lover, Leaver they took a direct riff from led zep and placed it at 1:49 from Nobodys Fault but Mine. Not impressed.
@kilroyfrills3084
@kilroyfrills3084 5 лет назад
If GVF want to succeed they need to learn from this and evolve
@EErriic1
@EErriic1 4 года назад
Jawnboi shut up
@Jmankarate
@Jmankarate 5 лет назад
You need to review FM! Holy shit it’s amazing!!
@swishasnkush1573
@swishasnkush1573 5 лет назад
FREDDIE GIBBS x CURREN$Y x THE ALCHEMIST - Fetti EP. REVIEW IT PLEASE? It's only 23 mins long @ 9 tracks and dropped on Halloween. I'm curious to see how you like or hate it.
@miguelhuaman8280
@miguelhuaman8280 3 года назад
He really nailed whats the deal with this album when he said this sounds like an interlude before you go listen to an actual ledd Zeppelin song.
@churricardo1457
@churricardo1457 5 лет назад
GRETA VAN FLEET 2: A D D E N T U M
@twr412
@twr412 5 лет назад
A classic rock cover band from Frankenmuth, where you can get Christmas decorations year-round.
@SamB-ss2mh
@SamB-ss2mh 5 лет назад
Why haven't you reviewed the new metro album?
Далее
LET'S ARGUE: Meg White Is a Good Drummer!
13:41
Просмотров 878 тыс.
LET'S ARGUE: Yoko DIDN'T Break Up The Beatles
12:29
Просмотров 749 тыс.
The Worlds Most Powerfull Batteries !
00:48
Просмотров 7 млн
Мама ударила дочь #shorts #iribaby
00:17
Jordan Peterson's New Song is Whack
20:21
Просмотров 158 тыс.
theneedledrop hating eminem for 20 minutes straight
20:07
Rig Rundown - Greta Van Fleet
34:43
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Pitchfork's 90s List Isn't Bad
15:27
Просмотров 331 тыс.
Are They Just A Sh*tty Tribute Band?!
11:16
Просмотров 181 тыс.
Machine Gun Kelly - Mainstream Sellout ALBUM REVIEW
13:03
LET'S ARGUE: Best Album Covers of All Time
12:42
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Селфхарм
3:09
Просмотров 917 тыс.
Это было в России
3:14
Просмотров 503 тыс.