Inside China's 'thought transformation' camps - BBC News 

Chinese gov replied, before they donthe crime, let us do crime on them first

These people are clearly in no danger. This is just the west picking at China again because the whole Hong Kong thing didn't go exactly as planned. If you people care about human rights go help these kids in cages at your border these kids need food clean clothes and medicine. Stop buying into propaganda. What China is running is more like a rehabilitation centre than a prison.

@@marshalljulie3676 they are in danger since they are held against their will. can you accept being held in a muslim countrey against your will and dicteted how to live and what to do ?

@GDOI Soldat ᚦᚬᚩᛅᛄᚢᚠᚻᛈᛉᛋᛏᛒᛖᛗᛠᛢᛣᛥᚸ no one should be obliged to learn anything if he don't want to. its called freedom. have you ever heard of freedom?

@GDOI Soldat ᚦᚬᚩᛅᛄᚢᚠᚻᛈᛉᛋᛏᛒᛖᛗᛠᛢᛣᛥᚸ hhhhhhhhhh i dont want to learn.

I agree Meg. The US should intervene now and send some democracy to China like they did in Iraq and Afghanistan. After all US has been very kind to Muslims throughout history.

@@hitchhiker8798 hitchhiker good sir what on Earth are you talking about

@@megmaynot he is saying that unlike China, uncle Sam brought destruction to muslims

@@SgtNoPants sergeant, my friend, I’m seriously starting to doubt that you even watched the video, or are even aware of the situation in general

@@megmaynot meg, darling, you better start watching videos from both sides to come to a conclusion...

And is that a bruise on his eye?

zainab rahimi that’s what I was thinking lmao

zainab rahimi I didn’t notice until you mentioned it as I thought it was a drag kinda make up but looking closer it could possibly be a skin pigmentation issue

I think he was looking at the translator, could be wrong though. 1:42

@@TheMainLuke it looks like a bruise

7:52 the guy to the left accidentally drops the thing too early then quickly fixes his mistake

💔

I see happy people receiving free education, nothing wrong with that.

@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth So then people in Work Camps are getting employment lmao

@@just_dmitri3192 After the education, they have the option to travel aboard to get a job where the area needs. China CPC spoke with many business leaders to look for talents trained in these camps. Those businesses do get some sort of tax relief.

@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth Yeah they are all happy so why not join them ?

@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth lol did the chinese goverment threathen you to say this?

Humanity or extrimist.

@Grey Wild Wolf really? you tell me which scene shows abusing? just tell me ？ it just a skill training school ,BBC got nothing，at the last BBC did make a second unannounced “surprise” visit late at night, what they got ?only to see Uyghurs leaving the center, as usually as the other weekend，BBC got nothing evidence ，them they edited this movie with dark colors, weird background music,and Induced narration。is it a documentary should be？ why not look at this ,the same re-education skill training school visiting by japanese,ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-SnUNpnVll_A.html BBC

@Grey Wild Wolf Don't you see that this footage is edited by a kind of campus suspense movie technique?

@Grey Wild Wolf There are always people who have never been to China and feel that they know China better than people who have been to China or Chinese people,even actualy they know nothing bout China.Let me ask you some questions repeatly ,and you can ask youself too:,have you ever been to China？ Have you ever been to Xingjiang ? have you ever seen any footage showing massacre on Tiananmen Square? Have you ever talked with any native chinese ? Over so many years, have you ever seen what is the “concentration camps”look like? have any medias and the CIA got any pictures,video,recordings of the so called “concentration camps” just like the U.S. army abusing prisoners at Guantanamo prison? Why you believe the things you have never seen ? why you believe all what the the media tells you?Even some of them said the mask is useless for virus.why not go to China to see who is telling the truth and who is lying? Why not look at this youtuber ,this guy is living in Qindao in China.he often make live streams ,you can see the real China without any Intermediate media,all you need to do is open your eyes .ru-vid.comvideos

@Sir Sinjin Smythe What did they do?

yes indeed. fake news is very very evil.

@@zexiali6483 the Chinese spy who defected to Australia has a lot of documents to prove its true.

search“July 5th riots”then you will know who is truly evil

@@jackzhang3939 that's actually fascinating. none of this was shown on western news.

@@jackzhang3939 Chinese officials and a spy who defected to Australia government leaked many documents containing orders about Uighurs, Tibet, Hong Kong and many more. You can't just lie to yourself and say it's all western propaganda because those proves comes from Chinese citizens who don't want to be part of those horrors and brutalities anymore.

And watching this believing we're not next.

​@@labogne1928 omg 😢

😢🫣😡 Uyghur Lives Matter 🆘

They look happy as they have been reformed from their evil thoughts !

​​@@HandleorHandleyou deserve to be treated worst than they're treated if you're this stupid!!

I thought it was a black eye too

It's not a black eye, it's an angioma

😂😂😂

🤣🤣😭😭😭😭💔💔

Everyone report the Chinese bot that keeps replying on every comment

There's High speed internet in China, Businesses, Lots of fast food, TV shows, Holywood Cinema, Cars, Motorcycle, electric car/busses/motorcycle... In North Korea you only have your bike and your morning get up and go to work Morning Announcement.

China could have build Guantanamo style camp but they chose these.

@@kakabitan Is that the price of freedom....

@@tonyatgoogle6076 Another shill arent you... you need to work at it.

@@1Live2Love3Thrive China has more freedom than United states. In the US you can't share your opinion if you're not a liberal democrat, can't drink milk because milk is racist, soon you cannot study math because math is sexist and racist, your companies are against right to fix law, changing tires of a tesla must be in service centers, your mac and iphone are unfixable, you can't do the ok sign because it's racist. In China they do not care if you copy this or that, you can drive without license as long as your car is electric, you can eat dogs and cats, no Liberal SJW and feminazi on the street. You can basically do anything just not against the president or the Government and practice religion of terrorism.

It was a primer. It never mentioned the using of death row prisoners for organ harvesting and sale. Criminals don't need kidneys and livers, eyes and hearts that can go to lawful wealthy citizens.

Have you met religious extremists?

@@zitronentee even religious extremists aren't as monstrous as atheists and communists

1984 was supose to be in Chinese obviously

USA, country of 320mln people: prison population larger than all other world countries combined, prisoners treated like dirt and forced to work weeks just to pay for 1 phone call to family. Also asylum seeker kids dying at the border with no flu medicine. China: Opens reeducation camps after uighur riots to eliminate religious brainwash and antisocial behaviour while at the same time building trade network through the region to eliminate economic stressors that lead to violence. World: omg china is the new nazis, this is 1984

👏👏👏👏👏🔥

Don't call people 'stupid muslims'. Have some respect, you're disgusting.

Kiki Kannibal free speech

And this stupid channel is deleting all the Chinese comments wow , freedom of speech hahaha wow

I had to censor words coz this channel has banned some words so my comments gets automatically deleted

They can’t or else they will get beaten 😭😭😭

Just imagine the bruises on the prisoners not allowed before the cameras

SuperSMT that’s sad 😔

bro, that's birthmark just like Gorbachev

They are supposed to be free to leave if it's their will joining

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-2Shla50pRxA.html

wander knight it’s just a phrase dickhead. I’m atheist and use the term all the time

Brian Is Me yeah it’s an expression, implying one who is Omnibenevolent, omniscient, or omnipotent would know of the secrecy of evil. This Is what I am implying, since China and the CCP are a secretive government. For example, “the great fire wall of China”. Wander knight is likely a troll.

@@wanderknight69 hmm are you using vpn?

@@wanderknight69 And Talibans are what, tribal people from Afghanistan. What did the Uygurs do to anyone.

Lol, what you can read their faces, Go to China and look for your self and get the facts right, Don’t trust any shit this channel publishes, just false news and propaganda.

yea sort of like the islamic brainwashing that had been forced on them previously turning them into jihadis.

you can say that to anyone that wants to control your speech. "no swearing in public" The thought police

@lionpro +12 social credit points to your account, comrade.

@@koka1571 you dont get sent to prison for swearing in no swear zones

@@koka1571 you have a point but this isn't just mild censorship this is full up cultural genocide

@lionpro i know, all these evil bots saying that genocide is bad, and that people should have freedom to practice whatever religion they want And all those evil bots talking about how this is exactly like nazi Germany

@Juke Chinese, you have to do whatever you want in your own land China, Eastern Turkistan aka Xinjiang is Uighur land invaded by Chinese in 1949. Tibet invaded too. Chinese must go home to China. We are tired of endless Chinese immigration, just like Eu tired of arabs, go home Chinese.

That was A Lie, I am very sure the Policeman did only recommended to join.

Didi Smith the translation is not very correct here, in China, ”a policeman in my village” is more like a social worker in western country.

@@didismith5805 Guess you didn't watch the video.... they said they put people in the camp that haven't committed crimes.

@@thenutbrothers8726 before 1949, Xinjiang is controlled by China's former goverment --the Nationalist Party Government. and before the Nationalist party government is China's Qing government . So you should get used to the Chinese. Xinjiang is China, the Chinese must go to Xinjiang

Ikr

Yeah, fvck china

@@khani54 They know Islam is not a religion of peace.

China kills 0 people in Xinjiang, mainstream media calls it "genocide." America kills millions in the Middle East, mainstream media calls it "spreading freedom."

@@Generalshouchew You are fully right

What is there to hide? They are just being forced to take these lessons, that's the issue that the BBC is trying to expose. The moral argument from the West is that forcing people to sing, dance and paint while depriving them of their freedom is wrong. China's position is that by helping poor undereducated people learn valuable skills they can prevent the despair that leads to religious extremism and terrorism.

@@grimcommander4172 No, what they are doing is torturing them in secret. It is just Nazi Germany in China.

Grim Commander if they were just forcing them to do lessons, as you said. Why would they keep them in such highly protected building in the middle of nowhere, and why would there be people protesting against these "lessons"? The survivors claim they got beaten and tortured. Why would they hide certain areas from journalists? the nazis sent photos of people playing and having fun at the camps, and look at what they found out.

@@grimcommander4172 congrats my man you are brainwashed

@@RereAndRerun - No, at first I was being sarcastic, but then I contrasted that with the UK where British women are told to "shut up about grooming gang rapes for the sake of diversity." and I saw that China has a point to their argument. If people are educated with skills they will avoid despair that Islamist terrorist recruiters often use to their advantage against the government. So China puts education on the front burner, a temporary injustice though a long term helping hand. As Jesus said, "Give a man a fish, he eats for a day. TEACH a man to fish and he eats his whole life." China is teaching them to fish so they will have good jobs their whole lives!

did u finish the video? they actually leave at last

@@lugangwang1227 I did finish the video. Did you finish the video? Only some of the men get to leave in the middle of the night, and leave in shifts. It's literally a prison.

@@giangstr yeah， u always see some prisoner leave prison at each 8 o'clock.

@@lugangwang1227 When they 'finish' the transformation process, while most of them even don't know when it will be over (~few years). I just repeated the scripts in this video.

@@pomni8696 do u know what exaggerate mean? and that's what media do for living

It's probably the over 200 terror attacks carried out by Uyghar extremists that did it.

@@ZincFold 50 cents isn‘t enough to defend this goverment. Stop it

@@umerirfan1188 nope it was the same form of extremism that also sparked Washington's War On Terror post 9/11. The major difference is the U.S and allies have slaughtered and displaced millions more in the Middle East. China is dealing with it on the home front. There are Uyghurs detained in Guantanamo Bay for the same reason but you don't hear anyone crying about it. Western MSM has you blindly accepting a double standard here.

@@ZincFold lol i could repeat the same sentence to you ''blindly accepting a double standard here.'' that one thing goes on doesn't make the other one less worse. don't kid yourself.

@@giocommentary no one is saying that here or aren't you paying attention? The U.S and allies have actually done a lot worse in the Middle East.

Thank you for your concern. A few things, though: First, you gotta know that calling this genocide is an insult to the actual genocide victims. Second, using google and reading news is not considered a "research" (you gotta know where those reports come from). Third, this video is a propaganda and full of mistranslations (you can checkout medium article titled "breaking down BBC visit on Xinjiang"). Also, let's not forget how all of this started. The Uyghurs are influenced by wahabbis, became extremists, and did what extremists do, striking terror on the Han Chinese. The CPC (or CCP) then responded by reeducating the suspected Uyghurs who became extremists to clean their Wahhabi influence. The west saw opportunity to bash China even more by accusing China of genocide towards Uyghurs. If you think that what the CPC do is immoral, then you should consider how the west would react if they get the same event in their countries. The west will not do such hassle building reeducation camps to eliminate the extremism, instead they would choose the hard way: by bombing them to the stone age. The alternative is so bad that the reeducation camp sounds really good for me. You got free food, free shelter, free education, and free time on weekends.

It’s all fake news don’t believe British!

i am a youth from Hong Kong, and i have travelled many different provinces in China. What's I could say for this video is that's video may have a great misleading to audiences. Before you watch this video, some facts you should know first, 1. China is a developing country, even thought it is the greatest economic country in the world, but its GDP / Person is still very low. Don't expect always having very good facilities, especially in those very small town. 2. China have great infrastructures in different city, but still have a lot of old building still not be renew. ( i think most of the village government still did had that budget for that as one of latest KPIs on village government is building public toilets ) So when the reporter described that it looks like a prison, then the man will feel angry as it is just as good as the living level compared with the average of local living environment to him. (There is another topic about economic development, i will not extend here, but you could try to treat it as a normal phenomena in village that still not well developed. i believe you wouldn't expect a place have high living level where's average salary level is lower then 300 USD per month) 3. There are a still lot of people who born 60 - 70s don't received education, but most of the job offered to those with at least primary education and that basic threshold made those people cannot easily fit in the society. in 10 yrs ago, when i travelled in China with my family, we are always need to keep our eyes on our properties as it was a lot of theft especial in tourist attraction. And sometime you could hear some news about brutally killing / kidnapping by ethnic minorities (Xinjiang minority is most of the case). You could search about Xinjiang cut cake may know more. A lot of bad news about some Xinjiang people selling cut cake, but not telling you the price. After they cut the cake, if you didn't pay for it, they will show the knife and i meat once in Yunnan in 2018 (Xinjiang minority as well) , an unbelievable experience hahaha, then i told my friends i almost die. 4. Those social issue that i mentioned is getting much progress now, it is much more safety and indeed i appreciate for what the government did. They provide a basic education opportunity for those adult by reeducation training. That could increase the credit / at least good in CV for them when they look for a job. As old generation Xinjiang minority did have good impression to public, it may have difficulty for those 40-60 seeking a decent job. I know I couldn't change your mindset for China, but if you just look on the surface on one event , i believe you probably be misled to the wrong direction / led to a preset perception that the reporter want you to see. As a person who understand a bit more about the situation , I couldn't do nothing but to tell you something more. Yes, China have a lot of social problems but they all happen around the world. like poverty, public health issue, security issue, social inequity. US, Euro, Asia have the same problems as well or even worst. What we need to see is how the government take responsibility for handling those crisis under their capability ( financial / technical / operational / else ) . I don't think that Xinjiang is a human right issue, but a measurement that government trying to eliminate the inequity for those minority in a disadvantage in the society. We all got free education, why others couldn't even a basic version. I couldn't say local government in China always did perfectly, there was always could have improvements but we know that it spare no effort in handling / responding the social problems. And all of my friends from Xinjiang give positive appraisal for the government performance. I am not criticizing BBC just showing one face of the problem, but I really hope that people who watching this video could had an opportunity to use different angle to understand China, but not just the face that the report what to show. I could understand most of the comments are come from nice persons with sympathy. you know, it is always have scandal if you want. But what we could do if we really want to understand a country / person is to travel there and have a talk with the local people with a humble attitude ( a basic respect that is very important ) , then you will know more about them but not just receive the message from a media. I believe you will see the different world if you really take this step forward.

This is purely information distortion, if you really ask a person who can speak mandrain. The translation and information is so distorted. PLUS china has one child policy for HAN people (most chinese), but Uyghur has priority that they can give birth to how many they want. So that the Uyghur population is increasing significantly faster in China without restriction like anyone else. And you call it 'genocide'? Give priority in policy, and it is now called genocide? Great distortion. These so called camp education is a way for dealing with terrorist activity. Do you know the background of the camp? If you know nothing about the terrorist activity before the camp education, CONGRATULATION! You know how much that you don't know about the REAL story. The whole story is so much distorted, without background, without proper translation, with selected information to present. I have so many Muslim friends and I wish you can see more of the background to see the real picture.

How are people here actually defending the imprisonment of 40 million Muslims for NO reason other than they believe in Allah. Shame on you all, may Allah guide your blackened hearts.

Freggel Meggel even more ironic because there’s definitely prisons where you can paint lol

@@sandratran8335 ikr,, in some prisons, programmes are pitched to let the prisoners sew/knit or paint etc.

yeah as if painting is an escape

Camp is fake news, wake up

Lol tf in Germany you have to have your own room bc it’s a basic human right to have enough space to live. You even can go outside over the day. When I say outside I mean like idk go to the supermarket etc.

True it’s disgusting

@Nerdecon Thought that same thing

@Nerdecon the word is *Sinicization* .

Yesss that’s what I was thinking!!!

● What China's area education camp in Xinjiang really about? ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-U3YBomwuB10.html ● A glimpse into the lives of Uygur youths in Kashgar m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-hS93tMWzRjQ.html ● How mosques are protected for China's Xinjiang Muslims to pray m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-oS9M5ifFd9M.html ● Xinjiang officials hit back at allegations over the region ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ZYI1dJ4O4k0.html ● I went to XINJIANG or | Train to Stay city, walk through Uyghur neighborhood ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Opc_FL605PI.html ● Stable lives of trainees from Xinjiang vocational centers counter Western liars: www.globaltimes.cn/content/1201973.shtml ● The Real Reason Western Media Lies about China ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ve4cwf458k4.html

That’s the same thing I thought. You can determine that someone COULD use violence against other people, but you are not able to determine if someone is one edge of committing a crime, that’s (nearly) psychological impossible.

this means exactly what they said. they use AI cameras EVERYWHERE in china. they are identifying "at risk people" by features they exhibit. and arresting them. but only of the islamic culture. china is now the leading worldpower in AI after deepminds alphazero crushed lee sedol and china realized the potential of AI, then after running a huge AI campaign generated BILLIONS of dollars to build these compounds and put cameras everywhere to fight a small opressed culture residing in their territory

All it means is: here's a wonderful excuse to imprison and brainwash people we don't like

Thought crime

CHINA #1 TIME TRAVELLING JUSTICE

Allahumme Amin........

@@culture5679 If the BBC showed what really happened, China would never let is be broadcasted in the first place. And if it was the whole truth about these camps, knowing China , let's be real the journalists won't come out alive. Thanks, I'll check out the link.

Sadly this is not unique to China, whatsoever. All around the world there's concentration camps/"detention centers". The US has them for immigrants. Many other countries do. 😭 Kashmir in India, Palestinians have basically an "open-air" prison in Gaza, where Israel will not allow them to leave & they're being bombed repeatedly. 😭 It's really, really sad this still continues. 😭

@@JaseekaRawr exactly this isn’t a surprising thing.

@Sam They don't have to be called "camps" to be detainment centers or be oppressed on basis of nationality, religion, etc. Kashmir, like Palestine, can be classified as an "open air prison". Where the majority or ruling state can control their actions & human rights. I'm not sure if Kashmir even has internet access restored. It was cut off a while back, during crackdowns. Palestinians aren't allowed to leave. They cannot travel freely & are segregated as second class citizens - on their *own native homeland.* Neither are in "camps". They're oppressed in an open air prison situation. 😕

china is clearly not a developed country

Because a lot of people care more about money than freedom. And China is a massive market.

Much worse, I am from China . I can tell westerners : compared to China , former socialist countries such as Yugoslavia Romanian Poland. East Germany and Soviet Union were heaven for US in terms of human mental brutality. China are completely away from civilization for 3000 years . They have never been in modern society in mentality. Stalin . Tito , hoca , ceocescu , milosevic putin or lukashenko , are just saints comparing to Chinese leaders

none none that’s bold to say and I respect it. Stay safe

Dan Richardson It’s very different, because Germans and Germany were quite free and prosperous.

American businesses were doing business with Nazi Germany before and even after the war. The companies even sued for assets lost in Germany due to Allied bombing raids...and won.... I wish I was making this up. :(

I really don't wanna dig deeper into that statement.

Because they force them to or they escape.

Guard: "IT NEVER HAPPENS...but if it did we would encourage them proactively..."

Yeah, I wish the reporter would have pushed him on that one. Why would literally no one have a problem leaving their family, jobs, homes, and communities behind? Wouldn't you? Literally everyone would.

@@MsJeanneMarie I think most people there don't have a job... The school is teaching they living skills too.

I think it's because they know that these journalists are technically "untouchable". Behind the camera there would probably a group of lighting crew, sound crew, interpreters etc. China is not North Korea, they still benefit from the "oh we're just being misinterpreted" facade, so doing any harm to the journalists and his crew would endanger their interest to keep the facade.

I like it though, because it shows what's really going on.

Gregapple His already opinionated questions did not bring more information though.... If you say “his sounds like brainwashing”, they obviously will say “no”. I wish his questions were formed to bring out more information instead of making the interviewed defensive...

The BBC pot calling to Chinese kettle black.

lelununu should they ask them whether the prisoners enjoy dancing or making their beds more? Why do the reporters ask at all right? They should just let the chinese prison guards tell their agenda and broadcast it to the world for them for free

Ken Ko exactly I always wondered how the fuck did he get that

That's how he was convinced to go to that school

I'm sure he just "tripped".

I think it was a birth Mark

When someone make a funny comments and it become hilarious

All of them... and read whatever you want, learn whatever you want, and have a fixed term for when you leave

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8N3hnCKtrjE.html Try to hear the voice from both sides

@@clairee4939 inhumane is the word. I'm actually surprised they don't just put a bullet in their heads like the KGB. I guess in China, letting them live at all is probably seen as humane.

@@clairee4939 breaks my heart

Colin Wang Tut tut tut, no more trying to fool us with propaganda!

I m Uighur and all Uighurs who live abroad was asked by Chinese government to scan all documents and send to China- documents are : passport, CPR number, work address,home address ,phone number FROM ALL FAMILY MEMBERS, We have been told, if we are on social media or in any news papers make a remark or complain about Uighur genocide, the Chinese government will kill or cut fingers, RIP teeth or nail of our siblings and nex if kin back home.

​造谣是要负责任的，你竟然不在乎家人的死活，你个鳖孙儿

Although I don't fully agree that the education camp is right, it's effective.Because the terrorists caused the massacre at the Chinese railway station before.

@@Shenzhou. Lmao Chinese people continue to convince me their population is full of complete psychopaths.

@@ericcartmann Look at Chinese culture, and we value hard work, being studious in school and industrious at work, so why can't Chinese government impart some of these positive virtues to Uighurs? The Uighurs weren't even Muslims in the first place, and Xinjiang was part of China long before the Islamic invaders conquered the region and converted the natives to Islam. Why can't Chinese government undo the damage that radicalism done to Uighurs?

But how much religious terrorism do they have ?

I'm pretty sure there is art therapy in almost all prisons in the western world.

"Hmmm, how can we hide the fact we have a prison? ...." "ah, fingerpainting!"

Actually prisons where prisoners perform some craft or learn stuff aren't rare.

@@shanehull6235 0

Wdym “instead of planting bombs”

Well we arrest them? If they still resist we can always harvest valuable organ. /s

They deport you. China deports Muslims because Islam is illegal there. I can't say I disagree with the policy.

@@KFrost-fx7dt Ah yes, who cares about religious freedom. The literal basis in which many freedom ridden countries were made from.

@@kimjunguny When the founders of free societies decided we should have freedom of religion they didn't envision death cults like Islam. Islam imposes its own set of laws which are completely contradictory to those of a free society, such as institutionalized rape, murder, torture and child marriages. Islam indoctrinates with force. That is NOT freedom of religion. It's religious tyranny.

Apparently you don't realize the alternative is far worse

SniperRose ikr they’ve clearly been brainwashed

Shhh they are studying

Because they're being forced to

Its called BRAINWASHING !!!!

When the feeling part of brain that is governed by emotions is made superior over a person's Thinking brain (the logical side), they start to blindly believe in ideologies. The dancing and singing arouse the feeling brain.

Yumydude West against extremists? Anti-terrorism. China against extremists? Oppression. Double standard BS, watch what’s actually going on in Xinjiang. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-u4cYE6E27_g.html

Marcus Ng You don’t have to be a phsycic do determine that the guards aren’t treating them well. Also relax yourself 😂.

Hikari yeah glory to the people’s republic that’s literally censoring information as much as possible to any negative aspect about their country.

Hikari extremism? Having religious beliefs is now extremism? You’re ignorant, and it stinks.

It’s a birthmark

Here in norway the prisoners can paint and im sure they can in denmark and sweden as well..

Doesn't seem to have addressed his extremist tendencies very effectively, though. Let's hope the Chinese and their painting classes do better

I’m pretty sure in America inmates can paint if they request the materials for it

Yeah my thoughts exactly, painting is actually quite common in prisons world wide You can even buy their paintings in some areas, I know that because there was a scandal here in the US with people trying to buy this serial killers paintings out of idolization a while back (decades back)

Just want to say this, hitlers prison was basically a house arrest, he wasn’t a common prisoner

I that’s exactly what I thought

It's the same in most OECD countries.

In America you actually have to commit a crime to be in prison ! Not being detained for having a wasup app lmao .

I So have I! Art to inmates.

These people are innocent civilians ! If they are really terrorist China would of have cases everywhere ! It's a joke ! Just look at all other parts of the world ! There is a difference between a extremist vs a normal Muslim ! China is no different than north Korea !

@@stevenl5006 A Hong Konger. So he has EVERY right.

@@stevenl5006 and even if he was Chinese, since when can’t we criticise our own countries?

i'm from Ohio lmfao

@@stevenl5006 lmao your comment XD so someone who’s ethnically Chinese cannot have a say in China’s policies. Interesting, pretty much destroyed human logics in one go.

@@stevenl5006 😂😂😂😂😂 dude you got made a fool of

Yup similar though not as extreme as the actual genocide

Funny that the 1080p screen and the bed that you are on is most probably from China and the money you used to buy them could have been used for this.....

@@ahmedullahkirmaniclassof2083 aren't we all supporting them? Don't forget money we paid to the US for their wars everywhere too.

No one has been killed, snow white whiteboi

Yea like the freedom genocide of Afghanistan, Iraq libya and Syria

On the other hand, prisons in the Western world are more like Hotels. The criminals are not afraid to go there, many even want it! So they will neve stop stealing, robbing, etc...

@@Mar-bh7uj so we're going to treat someone's child even worse than zoo animals because they stole a couple wallets? And if criminals want to go to prison because that's better than what they have, that just shows how bad normal living quality's are in that country

Ma r Bruh what? You are speaking out of your ass. Only in Norway is this true, in no other western country is this the case. I come from Kashmir, I have seen our prisons and western prisons as well, the only difference is that the guards are not allowed to beat the prisoners, which I think is a good thing. But western prisoners still live without privacy or freedom.

@@mobeenkhan824 No. You know nothing, and obviously you have never been in prison in Germany or Sweden for istance.

@@mobeenkhan824 He is correct, prisons in the UK for example are far too lax, which is why we have something like an 85% reoffending rate.

Omg my exact thought. Look at their expressions. They all look so robotic and forced

4:08

@Pavor Yea sure. Except in every NATO nation (maybe except for Turkey which is still ten times better than this), you have freedom of thought, to choose your religion, have whatever opinion you want, etc. How is it that there are communist parties allowed in NATO nations and in some cases, they even participate in government, because we have absolute freedom to have whatever opinion you want. In communist countries, there is not any space for political pluralism they do not allow any other opinions than the official one.

BadAt Everything ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-NubnqlSNF64.html Watch it before they try to take it down again.

It is very very disturbing

You send ordinary people to these camps, not just terrorists. You said it: Chinese and Uyghur culture are different. Yet you still want to rule them and don't respect their culture. You try to assimilate them. Then some extremist among them uses weapons. You create these terrorists by your intolerant suppressive assimilative distopian regime.

You wumao are a sad story. You're paid to spread this propaganda by your overlords who don't even allow you to be on youtube. You will say this but behind your back, your relatives are next in line for organ harvesting. The fact you think you can simply go to Xinjiang and ''see for yourself'' is hilarious. When reporters went to ''see for themselves'', they were blocked by roadworks and random collapsed trees on the road, and they were chased by government officials. I think you should grow some dignity and call out your government for their latest genocide. It's not a unique thing to the CCP though is it? There has always been a genocide at the hands of your government.

you are well manipulated by china, communism, it doesn't surprise me at all that it is chinese who wrote this, i would write you proofs of such things but it's not worth it

Yeah, either with paint and canvas or their own shit.

These are the clean camps, in the dirty camps uighurs get beaten up for saying the word Allah

Was thinking the exact same thing

If I remember correctly, prisoners could paint in Alcatraz

Yes, there are art reform programs in US prison.

Maybe it’s because BBC chooses a person from thousands of people whose expression is especially easy to interpret the meaning of this movie.

It's normal in China, my aunt dances similarly every day at the square near her apartment. What are U thinking? A dance class must be ballet? They are just making fun

Did you forget your meds?

China just can't no right can they? How happiness can be twisted into horror with the magic of editing. Love how they used the hairdressing thingy for the brainwashing segments. Yeah the chinese are a proud people, deservingly so. Come on everyone knows what islamic extremism does to people. Better this than death, poverty and violence.

So are you just going to insult their culture then? Hahahaha wtf

Haha, it's not true. Do you know that these Uyghurs who are wrapped in extremism and terrorism, it is genocide to change their thoughts into normal people? As a Chinese, why don't I know? The BBC never reported how many Chinese and Uighurs these people killed for their so-called jihad

it took me five, not too bad, jk, all jokes aside we all need to unite under one common ground to remove all this discrimination crap

shane Wilson otherwise you will become a student too.

"You need to think carefully before you answer..." What the "thought-police" usually says.

The Muslims around the world must stop buying Chinese stuff and smart phones , let's see what Huawei and oppo etc will do

@@captaindebabeche4892 They are too busy boycotting Israel which whatever you think of it ensures the religious freedom of Muslims and complaining about Europe and the USA over marginal issues. Yet somehow they do not care about the actual genocide of Muslims in Myanmar and China.

shane Wilson The next day the principal is missing never to be seen again.

Crystal Watson yes it’s true just because they are Muslim

it's not because they are Muslim. it's because this region has 40% of coal industry.

The question is simple: should we risk majority people's life or minority people's right? innocent muslim people will also feel hurt because you guys are not treat their life as life, but only care about humanright.

do you want china to become another londonistan or parisnistan?

@@camilosittegassevol2944 there are two billion people living in China now. more over-generalization, MORE!!!1

Lies, look at them they look very sad and they don’t speak

And this BBC report is what you want to see? Check this video before making up your mind m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE--9zJF1sR2iU.html

@@user-mv6nt2nx9j so you trust a sky news video from 5 years and not this?

​@@Shiba9870 I mean see things from other sources and sides, especially efforts to fight terrorism. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BjgSOYRZqIo.html

No he was waiting for the translation

Marhxzii that what I was thinking.

Its disney, they're the best friends of any country wanting to clean their image. Disney just lost all of its morale, they deserve to get shut down ngl.

@@gamesnig ye

@@gamesnig Walt Disney is turning in his grave.

Remember boys and girls, restaurants in China used to have a sign that said, "forbidden from entering, dogs and Chinese people".

Disney loves the Chinese gov

@Viacheslav Vasiliev true, there r also prisons where prisoners can watch tv and play PlayStation & xbox. Shows us how much they know about the outside world.

Prisons you can paint? Where do you live Norway or sth?

heck you can even write books in prison.

@@adrianatgaming8640 This is where you end up in the Netherlands if you cut a woman in pieces, rape and kill a child or just be a serial raper. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1Tk0Ixu6FuE.html As you can see you have your own cell what you better can call a room with your own TV , playstation, magazines and books. You can do a study if you like, even on university level, you can cookand eat what you like if you want. Sports, hobbyclub, just name it.

@@Rana-cz2dl how abt tattoo?

Communism is the future of the Mankind, comrade!

@@ericweiwei9116 Islam is the future for Chinese.

@@yz9308 no,it is communism !!!

Y Z don't bother. He is joking around.

Now I see why communists designed communism as that. Everyone is equal=no social issues, but also will kill diversity of culture. If everyone is equal, then there's no minority, no people to rally or uprisings. It's basically a means to shut people up.

AbdallaMahmoudz I believe you can do the same thing in the US. But I would like to go to prison in Dubai

Gibran Saliba Or not to go to prison at all lmao

AbdallaMahmoudz this isn’t even about Islam (which is a backwards religion and does need to evolve with modern times) it’s about the treatment of people, regardless of beliefs. Islam is not a tolerant belief system and Dubai is not a tolerant place, though they pretend to be. In fact, the treatment of foreign workers across the Middle East is a mirror of this institute in China, though they don’t bother with the premise that they’re helping. The point here is that people shouldn’t be treated like this regardless of beliefs.

Matsab exactly.

@@matsab7930 dubai being not tolerant has got nothing to do with Islam, it's a capitalist country which looks down upon people coming from south east Asia

@dfrew werwe I think you havent read or understanded it properly.

Who's grandparents?

@@mac1bc My grandparents

@@crimsonspector1967 wow that's crazy. Did your relatives ever think about leaving?

@@mac1bc They did but their passaports are taken away. Wish they could come here before..

THIS IS SO ACCURATE

BROOOOO YESSS

it's also like the concentration camp videos the Nazi's showed to the majors.

Dude you hit the spot

@@phatmilkers2074 I guess history does repeat itself. smh

China is worse than nazi Germany

It sure is a dystopia and scary. North Korea is very similar.

@@InvalidUser_ so true lmao

the truly scary thing is that they dont even dare to try because the goverment is too strong and persistent. Ccp is really different level

lol then you haven't seen Madarsas.

One day the whole world will know what xi jinping's fan did!

@Marcus Ng you should live there then.

Marcus Ng as from someone that’s part uyghur and goes to china every year. THEY ARE FORCED TO GO THERE. they get taken from their families and sent to those camps where they treat them like COMPLETE ANIMALS.

I believe that's birth mark though.

True...

if somebody wanna destroy your country what do you want to do. your hypocrite people

@@暗夜骑士-w6l communist should leave xinjiang.

@@jsdev4454 white people should leave America .give back America to Indian if your did we did .your hypocrite.

@@jsdev4454 Communist Party didn't force them to stay Chinese.They are Chinese before Communist Party came to power.

@Alex Mercer so you mean is the whole religion of islam is extremist? 🤔

You are sick

your country has not suffered from terrorists attacks?? Innocent killed?? Just wait until Islamic extremists slowly infratrate every country on this planet, it's Islam extremists agenda, weaken every country and conquer the world, there are tons of Christians killed by Muslims, why nobody is talking about it. Starting with massive Muslims migration, look at Europe look at British, Germany, Denmark, Sweden, you are dumb.

Btw they force Uighurs woman’s to marry with a Chinese man it’s really sad

death eater your sick

Ok, probably they’ve been forced to do that but wtf being tortured for hours in a room with a floor fulled with blood? Wtf that was done decades ago and humans sentenced that was inhumane and illegal

@Jarlaxle Banre Google, DNA samples were taken from all Uighurs age 12-60, And if tissue match with a potential customer, that day Uighur must die. Chinese aim to kill all Uighurs. The war against Uighurs is about Uighur land and has nothing to do with Islam.

That 'scar' looked like a port-wine stain birthmark to me. But yes to everything else. Creepy as heck...

@Bob A wtf are you talking about? you 're obviously a hater who doesn't know anything about islam get your fact straight before spreading hateful stereotypical lies and the fact that you justifying murders and tortures says all about you.

It's not a scar, it's a birthmark. But I agree with you.

EXACTLY, and even completely fake and glorified version is horrific.

Don't forget that north korea is a satellite state of Chinese Communist Party and you will know that this is their idea of propaganda. This is the "good" that they want to show the world. They don't show most!

Yes, maybe it's the same as the Nanjing Massacre and the 731 biochemical unit that Japan concealed. Now criminals should begin to wonder if other people would be as crazy as themselves👍

@@meray6811 wumao detected

@@MortenErCrazy Yes, I’ll share 2mao with you.

Prayer Knots Gotta stay in denial or else you might realize that you’re the baddies.

He had a good teacher 🤔🤔

It's because prisons in China are places to punish people not for them to have a good time. The high school I went to had worse hardwares than these places, similar kind of disciplines and activities. The only difference is the alleged beating. Yes, we had only one's leave per fortnight. If you know this you wouldn't be so surprised why so many people are defending these "camps". I never heard the media fighting for my rights when I was in a similar situation. (Not saying these centres are a good thing. just that you need more background knowledge to understand what these are in the context of china.)

Oh maybe it is a prison, like he said in all honesty.

@@EddyCNAU Nice coverup. How much did they pay you?

John McClane who’s George Orwell?

@@shaz3651 Grandson of Fabian Society founders, who founded their British branch in 1884. "1984" was a novel explaining to the public what they wanted for us all.

That’s not priveleged, that’s normal. What’s happening in China is perverse and evil. Humans shouldn’t feel grateful when they’re not treated like sheep.

Literally sheeps.

Those were birthmarks

www.google.com/search?q=red+birthmarks&sxsrf=ALeKk00cIjHAxKpmiDrXNRAmRHkLysXbqQ:1595515386071&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjZ38f-zePqAhXPjKQKHY5jAlEQ_AUoAXoECAwQAw&biw=1920&bih=941

@SharkyDuck Dude that's just how his face is formed :D Look at the other side (look closely) then you see the same bone structure and no swelling. Also when someone has e fresh bruise then his eyewhite would be flooded with blood and the eye would completely swell till it would be closed.(fresh because only red no blue and nothing - cant be more than 15 minuites old looking like this - the older the bruise the darker it would get and it would be a mix of colours, but this is only pure red). This is clearly a birthmark. How I know that? because I am a paramedic. Also think about beating someone to bruises and put him as frontman in propaganda video? doesnt make any sense right?

@SharkyDuck Also blood ALWAYS wanders under the eye, because gravity. www.google.com/search?q=bruised+eye&sxsrf=ALeKk01qyc67W_3ug6W1sY9dkMtp6DeI_g:1595519081790&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiq0ujg2-PqAhWLi1wKHXhNAbUQ_AUoAXoECAwQAw&biw=1920&bih=941 look closely

@SharkyDuck all their smiles are fake

You really never met religious extremists, don't you? They're as bad as KKK and often play victim.

Mustache Merlin whitest comment I’ve never read in my life lol. Religious are illegal in China? That’s such bullshit. There is catholic, Christian churches everywhere in Chinese cities. You got brain washed by your precious western media already my poor friend.

Chenyang xu That’s correct, religion isn’t banned in China, rather the country is officially atheist. The real issue is that religion only exists to the extent that the CCP allows it. Those who step outside of their circle of “acceptable religious beliefs” will find themselves in a position similar to those in the video.

ARIE5_ Not anymore

If you only to know China on BBC (bullshit broadcast corporation). You will because fool.

BBC FAKE NEWS ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BjgSOYRZqIo.html see this,you will know more Allah-uAkbar，jihad Is this what you want?

@@wangwilliam2692 ok bot... you probably used VPN to access youtube

@@wangwilliam2692 Chinese go to the space and don't come back

王牛逼 STUPID CHINA,YOU ARE COMUNIST LIKE NORTH KOREA HAHAHAHA EVEN CHINESE TAIPEI HATE CHINA REPUBLIC HAHA

So you think everyone should be fat like American?

Next China will invade the internet and hunt down people voicing their opinion about china

Liar

@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth shut up you puppet

G Gameplay they already do

How did King Edward I of England treat William Wallace? HANGED, DRAWN & QUARTERED for high treason and crimes against the English civilians~And' these charges ' really means ' the Scottish independence'. A perfect double standard, well done

It's a birth mark.

BigZed stupid

@@bigzed3495 stfu gtfo

@@bigzed3495 birth Mark ???

@@muhammadrifadz11 your videos are stupid and you can't sing for shit

It has fooled everybody enough though

Would you like to know more?

It kind of reminds of that Vice North Korea visit where they were taken on tour to show them how good North Korea was but everything was just super creepy and weird.

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xqHYF0pLEs0.html CHİNESE PERSECUTION

Look up the Kunming train station attack. XinJiang used to be an unstable region with hundreds of terrorist attacks which mostly targeted innocent civilians. In the last few years, 3 million people have been lifted out of poverty in XinJiang because of China's efforts. The region is growing now and prosperous. What about US prisons ? Guantanamo ? Children ripped apart from their family and put in cages on the Mexican border ? The US only knows how to punish and destroy people. China uses education and employment as a tool to reform people.

JamesTavRule what Are you trying to say?

The Art Institute of China lol

George Orwell turning in his grave going "I told you so"

“I MEAN LOOK AT THEM FFS. THEYRE PAINTING HAPPILY WHILST NOT BEING FORCED”

JamesTavRule china hasn't been socialist since the 1970s

😩😩😂

You joke, but in that famous 1999 documentary "The Cold War", there is literally an interview with a former Russian Soviet politician where he states that all the Communist members of parliament had a copy of the book 1984 they were using for ideas.

@@AdmiralBonetoPick *what the fuck*

@@chees8067 The Party is real, and _we are not invited._

1984 is a terrible book. Book 1 was alright but it just continuously goes downhill in a narrative perspective.

I feel like every politically motivated interview in china is literally 95% consisting of lies, it's just insane

dude gave psychotic enforcer vibe

Chinese officer wield the sharingan.

MaxDamageTV Blank stare = Godlessness. It's one who has lost touch with reality.

@@rickshaw6198 Not sure god is a necessary requirement. Their "godless" Chinese handlers look far less blank than they do.

@@MaxDamageTV Well on the bright side, no one is dressing up as a ninja or wearing those mobile tent things.

Probot2000X they never wore that in the first place, you imbecile swine!

after ww2 ended, germans were detained in interment camps for "denazification". isn't that punishing people who have "wrong thoughts"?

@@majesticflyingbrick not really no, it was more than just thoughts, it was their actions

Andrew McDonald they punished all germans for the actions of a few. how is that different from what china is doing?

@@majesticflyingbrick the German war machine was much more than just a few misguided men. I can't even believe we're having this debate

people are punished routinely in the west for their thoughts too

You haven't heard what the extremist have done?

@@alchemistlogic9421 Wow you are the one to remind me. If I havent added that word doesn't mean I can't write what I feel.

@@fahadopel8658 These are what your brothers are doing ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-u4cYE6E27_g.html

@@alchemistlogic9421 i don't trust a news station that is "funded by the Chinese government", since they are notoriously known for their media manipulation and censorship

@A K Ok so you are racist. Now I am not going to listen to you but thats your opinion, but I would advise that you first research ok!!

Corona virus has arrived and the country will go through severe pain. I have been waiting for this product 😈

One that teaches true patriotism?

@@domore1287 big man shut the f up not all of China is.like that

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xqHYF0pLEs0.html CHİNESE PERSECUTIOn

cos many protester are stupid enough to manipulate. they doesn't even know what details inside the bill

@@dwimj so you're telling me that all the professionals from the legal sectors that took part at the legal sector protest do not know the details? including the 12 former chairmen of the hong kong bar association?

water heart only people working for CCP like yourself think what you got in China is “Freedom” or pretend you got 1. WTFU!!

@@Lyricsxeverythin yes thats true. those professional also doesn't understand that bill. or" maybe" they understand the bill ,but they already made crime ,so now they afraid

@@Cuongt0505 iam not CCP. i just ordinary people that already examine that bill, and who afraid with that bill,are just big criminals, and their supporters, its the same like protest in America ,the protesters doesn't even understand what they protest,they just following the provocator

Watching the massacre by the Chinese government seeing is believing ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-WU3cpoodpIg.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-67pU0Ybovnc.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5gbD-vfO_OU.html Persecution of Uyghurs? ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-u4cYE6E27_g.html people's channel ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-OewWrCt3sgA.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9H088qCNCVE.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-K5sFALR3OMg.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-TJrGKlJ_Sio.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-l8qew8w4AFk.html Please come and experience it yourself

To be honest, this might just be some guy in there who asked a girl out and got rejected...

@北洋提督 believe me, they didn't have to make it anything up to make China look bad here.

@@karankenZ yes it's a very common sentence may appear on any wall of school in China,just a teenager have trouble in love

all this probably sterm from muslim extremist who cause trouble. the woman made it sound like just installing whatsapp caused her arrest, but its false, alot of chinese use some american social media's. she probably sent extremist informations.

i like the chinese, they're upfront they dont want any extremist towards the government, not like america that would have extremist in congress and the country is one big mess. insults, defamation, no respect towards your presidents etc.

@Suraj Hawale I swear you are Indian and you are supporting China? Ha, move along and stop talking about the false stuff you think happens in Islam. How about the caste system?

@Suraj Hawale yep speak for yourself regarding raping you know what happened in (UP) and your own government turned a blind eye. Why because Hindus can do anything Because of bjp and rss.

@Suraj Hawale true, Islam is anti freedom

@@dionysus8967 Shut up dude,women cover up so pervs like you dont stare and harass them.And it is the women's choice,and our countries are at war,because of the US or are run by US puppets like the saudis

@@saifjuntu1003 sure bro. Just believe blindly what your local imam tells you, he is totally not brainwashing you.