Iran and Israel need each other - here's why | Defence in Depth

Подписаться 6 млн

Просмотров 74 тыс.

50% 1

Israel bombed an Iranian consulate. Iran retaliated with hundreds of missiles and drones against Israel, but didn’t kill anyone; then Israel struck back with a bombing raid just small enough for the Iranians to pretend it had not happened.
The world held its breath as the middle east’s military superpowers headed towards a conflagration that would have ignited the entire region, and quite possibly triggered world war three. Then, just as suddenly, it was all over.
What on earth was Tehran thinking?
In this episode of Defence in Depth, Roland Oliphant, senior foreign correspondent, asks the question: would a war with Israel rally Iranians to the flag - or would it be the last straw that would see them finally overthrow the regime?
Read more here: www.telegraph.co.uk/world-new...
#iran #israel #explained
Find our Defence in Depth playlist here: • Defence in Depth | The...
For our podcast Ukraine: The Latest, visit: • Ukraine: The Latest | ...
Subscribe to The Telegraph with our special offer: just £1 for 3 months. Start your free trial now:
www.telegraph.co.uk/customer/...
Get the latest headlines: www.telegraph.co.uk/
Telegraph.co.uk and / telegraphtv are websites of The Telegraph, the UK's best-selling quality daily newspaper providing news and analysis on UK and world events, business, sport, lifestyle and culture.

Опубликовано:

24 апр 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 224

@telegraph Месяц назад

Have a topic you would like us to cover on Defence in Depth? Let us know in a comment down below. The team does read and value your comments, suggestions and feedback.

@BrandonClark-mz9dp Месяц назад

I think The Telegraph should do a video on the history and prominence of the Sudanese Rapid Support Forces (RSF), in light of the current humanitarian catastrophe following the beginning of last year's civil war.

@musative Месяц назад

It would be really interesting to learn more about propaganda/ disinformation circulating on both sides about Israel/Hamas via social media, and how this is being used to influence electoral/ trade union politics in the West, and to what end. And more broadly where do pro-Palestinian/ anti-Zionist views on the left come from (e.g. how did Chomsky, Pappé, Zizek etc come to form their viewpoints)? It can't all just be from Iranian propaganda... Right?

@AchaimenidEmpire Месяц назад

💩🇺🇸💩🇲🇫💩🇬🇧💩🇺🇦💩🇮🇱💩🇩🇪💩

@user-zy7zq5qx6f Месяц назад

🇮🇷🇵🇸✨🇮🇷🇵🇸✨🇮🇷🇵🇸✨🇵🇸🇮🇷 Or jab Hitler ne Israel walo ko nikal diya the Germany se to koi country ne unhai nahi liya. Lekin Palastine walo ne unhai apni zamin per rhane diya or fir kuch salo bad Palastine walo ki zamin ade se ziyada Israel walo ne unhai mar ker chin Liye uska kya? Unka ka hak nahi hai kya apni zamin wapas lene ka? ✡👎✡👎✡👎✡👎✡👎✡👎✡👎✡👎✡

@zulkarnainkhankhosa Месяц назад

Pakistan & India

@mry1393 Месяц назад

this was the most informative video I've watched in a while

@charbelh.boutros4971 Месяц назад

Most importantly, the military industrial complex needs both of them to remain forever at odds.

@LOKSTED 27 дней назад

Blaming centuries of conflicts on arms company is insanely stupid

@bradayers9637 27 дней назад

"But the military industrial complex" -anyone too lazy to learn the first thing about geopolitics

@user-vp2lz4qu5v 27 дней назад

@@LOKSTEDno conflict

@areaxisthegurkha 23 дня назад

@@bradayers9637 true tbh, the military complex does benefit from it but they are not the fricking Sith Lord.

@juancsmix 23 дня назад

how to detect a brain dead person: this type of comment

@carms500 Месяц назад

I think its important to explain how physically far apart the two countries are. Any direct confrontation would involve rockets and airplanes. Large scale tank battles or infantry clashes are simply impossoblr for both countries.

@tzar9ja 28 дней назад

Quite impossible for the smaller but not the larger one with proxies.

@richardsimms251 Месяц назад

Terrific discussion and speaker. RS. Canada

@nofham7311 Месяц назад

🫡 Sharp and levelheaded report, now that’s journalism!

@ariankarimi952 Месяц назад

Trash and totally biased. Good luck with your superpower Israel.

@Bozzy-zq8vw Месяц назад

wow... god help us, if this is journalism..

@thedavid00100 Месяц назад

The fact that we live in a world where an American president can warn a Near East country not to strike an ally and it still struck is truly a remarkable turn of events

@costcontrolteam2618 Месяц назад

Senile old man gets a message, forgets it while he is shuffling across the stage in the wrong direction. Obama is running the White House, not Biden.

@eranhaim9913 23 дня назад

Biden's word is worthless and everyone knows it

@shahrozyousefi48 Месяц назад

Good analyse!

@ET_LWO Месяц назад

4:28 Strategic patience

@animulovers3881 27 дней назад

Thanks for the wonderful explaination..i wish peace will rule

@asadbinmushtaq Месяц назад

Very well done Roland

@ilrozen 13 дней назад

very interesting and balanced. good job!

@kayswag2nv Месяц назад

Nice in Dept Dom

@MichelMrz Месяц назад

As an Iranian who opposes the regime, let me answer that question: 9:10 The borders of Iran hold immense significance for the majority of people. Personally, I feel a surge of intense emotion whenever I hear of possible conflicts erupting on our soil or discover attempts to incite tensions among minorities by Israel. Instead of engaging Iran directly or supporting the division of Iran, the West should focus on diplomacy and addressing issues outside of borders. It's crucial to understand that the people of Iran have a deep love for their homeland and are willing to defend every inch of it with their lives.

@Arte-Vi Месяц назад

I understand that nobody is talking about invading Iran, but about stoping Iran's regime from having nukes. Nobody cares about France having Nukes, or India or even Israel, but Iran's regime is a very active promotor of terror, and terror with nukes will produce horrifying things that probably have no name yet to describe them. It has to be avoided by all means. Therefore, I don't think a diplomatic solution is possible with terrorists. Not with this regime.

@6balance9 Месяц назад

@@Arte-Vione mans terrorist, is another mans freedom fighter.

@6balance9 Месяц назад

RU-vid is censoring my comments lol 7times

@6balance9 Месяц назад

Is another mans freedom fighter

@AchaimenidEmpire Месяц назад

🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷 > > > > 🇮🇱🇵🇸🇹🇷🇸🇦🇬🇧🇺🇸🇩🇪🇲🇫

@fettywap1738 Месяц назад

Good article

@davidfognini8526 Месяц назад

Right, Iran needs Israel but in HELL 😂

@juggernautxx_ 18 дней назад

Saying its not just wetern propaganda then stating western propaganda😂😂

@AbhinavSingh-nl7ov 26 дней назад

Nicely written.

@MyTubeOne 28 дней назад

8 to 9 billion no one mean No one can afford final count down

@shahradebrahimzadeh7693 17 дней назад

very accurate analysis

@betweenlamppost Месяц назад

Dude, Iran spent $30 million baby drones and 72 hour warning while it took Israel $1.5 billion of US tax payer money! Do the simple math and say who lost!🤷‍♀️

@User9681e Месяц назад

Wdym now they get billions by selling the interception systems easily with 99% real world proven anti blastic missile capability Btw Iran did it because they know Israel could intercept it

@nwankwosampson-xk3jc Месяц назад

Israel isn't poor as Iran

@User9681e Месяц назад

@@nwankwosampson-xk3jc Israel is much much smaller and has oil , diamond trade industry , gas , hightech etc It's not poor

@nwankwosampson-xk3jc Месяц назад

@@User9681e it's a mistake bro. I forget to put "not"

@gonzalesfrederic6213 Месяц назад

@@User9681eGas, lsrael has. Oil, barely. But indeed if a country has highly capable scientists, it is lsrael. Not that the US, India, France, Russia, and others do not, but lsrael impresses

@bratzoc1785 Месяц назад

West really did not understand that whoever Sit in Iran Regime... They will still oppose Israel in the Region 😆

@nwankwosampson-xk3jc Месяц назад

And who cares

@eranhaim9913 23 дня назад

no they wouldn't Iran and Israel used to be friends. I'm Israeli and my grandpa came with an Israeli company to build a hotel in Iran in the 70's. he was greeted good. it's merely the Islamic republic that made an enemy out of America and Israel.

@amirrezatm2872 17 дней назад

It was an awesome video, a correction is needed here: The nationalists who said "why isn't the leader responding the the bombing of the consulate" weren't actually demanding a response, but making fun of the weakness of IRGC's power against foreign armies (and that they only have enough strenght to beat us the people for hijab)

@robertsteele474 Месяц назад

Why not just call this "Israel: the Latest"?

@stompie51 Месяц назад

Huh? It’s about Iran.

@robertsteele474 Месяц назад

@@stompie51 Sure it is. "#israel #iran #explained"

@MyTubeOne 28 дней назад

But it should not ignore Because Human being is very strange often

@TreasaVeigas-qq5jm Месяц назад

Can't imagine that such old human beings can be so evil before meeting the good God.

@user-sm3xq5ob5d Месяц назад

Fact is that those who most fervently claim religious beliefs are those who are the least fervent actual believers. It is only a tool to stay in power. Religion is for the masses.

@PauloAdriano-zo2ng Месяц назад

Who? Biden? Or Bibi? Age doesn't improve everything. Biden will age like milk toast.

@muhammadafg1126 29 дней назад

@@user-sm3xq5ob5d facts netanyahoo killing palestinians on a daily bases

@user-nx8hj9xt4b 19 дней назад

Whats disappointing historical records are there as to how u deal with criminal states .Dresden and Berlin faced the wrath of the allied forces to take out hitler

@xWeAreCoolx Месяц назад

Hi Dom

@eltonbritt1502 27 дней назад

Iran itself may not be attacking Israel, but its proxies are.

@thenewniccage2283 Месяц назад

Hello Dominic

@G.RobertMoore-dk4sz Месяц назад

IDK, within the first 30 seconds the reporter refers to Israel and Iran as (albeit 'regional') superpowers. I think it's appropriate to call them great powers, but not superpowers (nor, of course, hyperpowers). Those words do mean something.

@JM-bo7ko Месяц назад

Why can’t we all just get along. In the end what’s the point

@Birthhammer 27 дней назад

That ‘hard revenge’ poster was clearly fake

@danw2502 7 дней назад

the title of the video has nothing to do with its content...

@danilomillendez4343 13 дней назад

Sir, pls clarify - need each other to be foe or to be friend?

@Fa2x_Cy Месяц назад

Propaganda as well…

@idankamhine3333 27 дней назад

Nice video just the title is very misleading - why Israel need Iran? It wasn't talked about in the video (possibly because Israel doesn't need it at all)

@user-tb7nj8di7i Месяц назад

When Iran and Israel come together no nation can stand with them but the west divided them. There are more Jews in Iran than other countries apart from US and maybe Israel

@jolness1 Месяц назад

1) no… 2) hostilities between Iran and Israel aren’t western plots

@MustafaAli-lb8dq 27 дней назад

Bullshit. Majority of the Jews left Iran and moved to Israel.

@MrZZooh 26 дней назад

@MustafaAli-lb8dq there are still some 10 thousand Jews left in Iran.

@MustafaAli-lb8dq 26 дней назад

@@MrZZooh That is nothing compared to the Jews living in Irma before Israeli state

@mrbaywatch21 Месяц назад

This was actually pretty informative

@TheMagicLemur Месяц назад

Good analysis, although misses the fact that Iranians themselves mocked Iran's retaliatory strike.

@MustardSkaven Месяц назад

Iran is full of groups that hate the regime.

@gusawad8121 16 дней назад

They actually didn't and a lot of them were praising the attack. Go back to your hole.

@darshansingh4375 Месяц назад

Sounds like a fair assessment. Let’s pray wisdom will prevail , and that wider war will be avoided..So far Netanyahu is committing a genocide in Gaza and in the West Bank. He is a ruthless corrupt leader using war to stay in power.

@John-bravooo Месяц назад

Iran committed a genocide in syria

@thembastoep733 26 дней назад

so theres no reason as to why they need each other, what a waste

@eldarbaris6766 25 дней назад

"Breaking a rule that never been broken before": 5:58 Nahhh, iran did it against an Israeli embassy in Argentina in 1992

@ALKalashnikov 23 дня назад

It wasn't officially claimed

@alionline999 Месяц назад

The telegraph is a mossad outlet.😂😂🎉

@Bell_plejdo568p 23 дня назад

All westren media is

@workoutwarriorzone 21 день назад

Indeed

@thekneidlachengineer6038 27 дней назад

Comparing Mullah's Iran with an elected prime minister of a liberal democracy says volumes about the western moral decay. Dangerous times ahead...

@user-vp2lz4qu5v 27 дней назад

West have democracy lol

@pubguc6771 Месяц назад

Iran including

@adriennefried5368 Месяц назад

Fahad killed yesterday in Iran 😢

@AchaimenidEmpire Месяц назад

Fake news 😂

@youtubeuser1946 24 дня назад

@@AchaimenidEmpire Salam. Who is farhad?

@PonelyPonely Месяц назад

Irans military base wasnt bombed in isfahan lol. Israel launched a bunch of dji size drones and it was all taken down hence why none of the media talks about it since it was sooo bad lol.

@orientalcaesar Месяц назад

6:00 The building that was bombed was NOT part of the embassy. A lot of it is misinformation or disinformation.

@satiricgames2129 Месяц назад

Reckless when its Israel cool storry

@Awon5 21 день назад

This senior foreign correspondent lives in gaga-land. initially i thought he was an israeli spokesman. Needs to learn more about war strategies

@h.n1977 Месяц назад

@PeaceTrain1 Месяц назад

Dude, World is getting the truth! Shut up!

@jacobsaunders1092 Месяц назад

What? 😂

@rana123asif Месяц назад

Preset match or drama

@Eyewitness4545 Месяц назад

Free Palestine from Israel. 🇵🇭❤️🇵🇸

@Eyewitness4545 Месяц назад

@@tomnik9592 🌏❤️🇵🇸

@LAmusic2023 25 дней назад

@@Eyewitness4545🇺🇸🇮🇱

@Holdthelube 11 дней назад

Not no more he just died like 3 days ago

@DavidDing-op5jm Месяц назад

What a shameless and laughable promotion of the british monarchy

@DavidDing-op5jm Месяц назад

@@FunnyBunny-pd5xx is that your best comeback😏

@yesyes-om1po Месяц назад

the greatest promotion of the british monarchy is in the history books with how much more peaceful and put together the entire middle east and africas were under british rule

@netsiteing Месяц назад

Iranian people can and should bring down the Ayatollah's regime and save the People/Nation with great Persian history and future possibilities to be a flowering nation of the Middle East

@user-vp2lz4qu5v 27 дней назад

Like bibi in israel

@mimjimsaghafi5051 23 дня назад

Lots of misinformations. Let alone unprofessional judgment. Forexample strategic patient was never mentioned by Mr.khamenei.

@singhvlog4962 Месяц назад

Why this Israel is always on the show! What Netanyahu fighting for ? are we dealing for another ww3?

@user-xl6mg1tm7s Месяц назад

Ok let

@user-fi7hr3gx4h 19 дней назад

Iran thousands of years of history and family tree. Israel was created 1948. Do the match

@MosiacSecretpatio Месяц назад

@stephanieb8267 Месяц назад

For the algorithm

@thenguyen4873 Месяц назад

Iran isnt as bad as what america make them out to be. Just cause a country doesnt like war as jt know their people will suffer due to the war. What happiness cone fro war?

@sTraYa249 24 дня назад

It's an agitator full of mad mullahs. The people of Iran are mostly lovely....its just the dysfunctional islamists

@eranhaim9913 23 дня назад

Iran doesn't like war? or that's why they founded, armed, and funded Hezballa, the Houthis, armed and funded Hamas and send their forces everywhere to surround Israel?

@netsiteing Месяц назад

Ayatollah terror regime tried to save face (and it may have for some its domestic supporters) but in fact it was embarrassed (before those who actually saw what happened) while Israel showed the regime how easily it can strike within.

@MrShoeReviews 29 дней назад

Why are we so hypocritical on what Isreal is doing? Feels like we are supporting a devil.

@oggierock 28 дней назад

What, no Russian bots on here? 😂

@alcibiadestome9619 26 дней назад

What ?

@NimaKhoie Месяц назад

Middle-East's military super powers!?? Is this "expert" for real!??

@adriennefried5368 Месяц назад

Oxymoron civilized war 😢

@PauloAdriano-zo2ng Месяц назад

Just like an *illegal invasion,* as opposed to a legal invasion. 😮😅

@kashinathpawar6341 Месяц назад

🇮🇳 ❤🇵🇸 😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰😘

@LAmusic2023 25 дней назад

Hindus support Israel

@gonzalesfrederic6213 Месяц назад

Well, to make some of my desserts, l may need both Israel and Iran. Iran has the best pistachioes and Zagros figs, and Israel has great dates and melons. Now, this stated, Iran may need Israel to restore Zoroastrianism and Christianity. Israel also has Bahai, who may too contribute to giving Iran help iit get rid of lslam. The thing is, as it stands, the end of lslam in lran is jeoardized by the lranians who are willingly Muslim. I am French, l regularly encounter in France lranians who, upon being safe, revert to Zorolastrianism or Christianism (usually they opt for being Catholic or Lutherians instead of reverting to being Nestorians). If the Islamic Republic falls, l deem that within days a fitfh to a quarter of the Iranians would cease to follow lslam.

@juniorluma9129 Месяц назад

Liarrrrr Stop it your lying since Persian time Iran has been Muslims so the Islamic regime will never fall

@sarahjames927 Месяц назад

Why does Iran not show this level of fervour against Myanmar. Hypocrites

@josefshah7878 27 дней назад

Why doesn’t Saudi aribia doing anything then are hypocrite and doesn’t even help Palestine and they want to be friends with Israel instead

@danisraelmalta 27 дней назад

Thats the most idiotic take i ever saw.

@UncriticalRaceTheory Месяц назад

unprovoked invasion? Iran was targeting top Iraqi gov officials

@Salehalanazi-7 Месяц назад

Both of them 0 kills lmao. They told each other before each attack lmao. What a movie

@noonwraith401 Месяц назад

Yep.Peasants dont understand this.

@gersonlevilazzaris4785 28 дней назад

Am Israel Chai ❤

@MrZZooh 26 дней назад

😘🇮🇱💩🧻🚽

@YouTubeAlex666 Месяц назад

That Iran bloke is a right beardy git.

@SteveIsabelle-yu3cb Месяц назад

MYXLAVACEALLAHISGREATGRANTISALLAH.INCHALLAH FRONTILIMESALAME.

@eddyr1041 Месяц назад

Wxpensive war😅

@farhathasnain1508 Месяц назад

BRITISH PROPAGANDA AS USUAL

@ulanulan2344 27 дней назад

The author is just jealous with Iran cause Brits politics are just boring...

@user-sl9vx9gh9i Месяц назад

😂😂😂😂

@johnsperthsangma3622 Месяц назад

How Ibrahim Risi exalted himself before Israel, but now he should humiliated.

@fghezelbash8731 Месяц назад

pertty inaccurate

@norkhach1715 29 дней назад

U guys total BS

@mazdakbamdadan9733 25 дней назад

Disgusting and misleading

@eugenearokiasamy5662 24 дня назад

Hilarious nonsense.

@liv2510 Месяц назад

We all know Iran hammered Israel. If the us an Israel could off retaliated harder they would have. They just don’t have the weapons to strike Iran without being in Iraq which the Iraqi pm doesn’t want usa an Israel soldiers there. Hence why Iran has won the strategic war.

@satiricgames2129 Месяц назад

😂😂😂 delusional terrorist

@jacobsaunders1092 Месяц назад

Nah we don't know that 😅 sounds like a bunch of BS to me

@noonwraith401 Месяц назад

What?

@liv2510 Месяц назад

@@jacobsaunders1092 yeah nah we do know, biden was begging iraqi pm to host us an israli miltary hardware, but told to go get f,:cked 🤣😂