Is political unity in Somalia achievable? | Inside Story 

As long as the Halenle Camp is functioning, Somalia will never see or sense stability because it is the center of holding somalia back to the side of anarchy

I applaud and thank Al-Jazeera for not bringing Matt Bryden in this topic of discussion!

Somalia went through a lot in the past 30 years, including war, famine and other problems. We must move forwards as a nation though it is apparent that some regions are less willing to work together than others, or else we will take many steps back. We cant look away from our problems and we need to discuss things to deal with it.

Allah make easy for them the most smart people to see them like this it hurt .

Ordinary Somalis from all Somali lands not not just Somalia are united ☝🏾❤️🇸🇴

Many Somalis in the West would be willing to relocate but skeptical about Somalia. 1 person 1 vote is needed Get rid of corrupt leaders representing foreign interest Join BRICS. The Arab nations need to focus on isreal and Iran condlict. The USA, Arab nations, Ethiopia have less ability to interfere right now - this is the best time for Legislative change. We need to start encouraging return of Somalis to rebuild.

Although Puntland was not included for this important discussion about current political situation in Somalia but overall it's good dialogue and all participants contributed greatly.

Senator Samatar's statement saying "Omar Gelle of Djibouti is the only leader of Somalia's neighboring countries who want Somali unity" isn't far from the truth!?

Professor Elmi afyare it's good point

It's high time to see that Somalia take care of their own country. Work together to be united for goodness for all.

Af Yare and samantar well done . Somali people all of across the world believes (one single Somalia policy. )

Somaliland is NOT part of federal Somalia. Somaliland was independent before Somalia in 26 June 1960. After failed union it took back its independence in 18 May 1991 after Somalia Carried out Genocide in Somaliland in1988.

Djibouti is the worst neighbor we have!

I cannot wait for peace

This is one of the best debate about somali political impass. The three guest speakers are well grounded in the subject and are honest.

Somalia's problems in depth are Hassan Sheikh, him self 100%, no doubt that.

Like stated in the discussion. Somalian unity can be achieved by focusing on a handful of common interests amongst ALL SOMALIS. Food security, infrastructure development, health security, education, anti-corruption, security in general. Intelligent leadership would rally around these topics. Somalia has the potential to become on of east africa's power houses in the upcoming decades. Why? Here are some reasons... 1) Coastal key geographical access to growing markets alongside the BRICS+ main routes. (Asia-Africa). 2) Demographics 3) Highly educated diaspora in various sectors like IT, economics, health (Knowledge and Skills Transfer). 4) Numerous natural resources such as iron ore, uranium, copper, tin, bauxite, gypsum, salt, and natural gas and oil. 5) Untapped potential for tourism. Let me just stop here. The list goes on btw. Unstability and internal conflicts perhibit the manifestation of a new golden somali era. Archaic clan rivalry amongst self centered "leaders" is something to be left in the past if Somalia really wants a prosperous future for ALL SOMALIS. Africas problem with weak and corrupt leadership doesn't exclude Somalia but we have seen that multiethnical nations can grow and change course effectively. Several african nations have shown that in the past. A good recent example would be the west african coastal country of Senegal. The predominantly muslim nation is multiethnic (Wolof, Pulaar, Sereer, Mandinka, Jola, Soninke and more). Around the same population like Somalia they now democratically elected a 44 year old former tax inspector who openly published his assets (His bank accounts hold roughly $6,600) beforehand. The election itself went peaceful and the results have been accepted by all participating parties. Current economic growth rate around 8,5 %. Guess what they don't have? Clan rivalry and tribal partisanship. Somalia is blocked by self induced hardheadedness and backward sectarianism. The moment these problems dissolve the horn of africa will see another golden era. Insha'Allah. Salaan my beloved brothers and sisters. ❤

The prof in all fairness shud have been the president and we will be rallying behind him given the chance. Our country needs your wisdom now more than ever.

As a Somali 🇸🇴 I want Somalia to abandon the west and join BRICS.

𝐒𝐨𝐦𝐚𝐋𝐢𝐋𝐚𝐧𝐝✨🙌

Inshallah we get to se a united and prosperous sonalia🇸🇴 from 🇬🇳 guinea

Somalia will never stand on its feet as long as foreigners are running its affairs!!

I just do not think such a complex position can ever see a conclusion. The people are the only ones suffering

the biggest somalia problem is foreign interference and foreign forces bases in somalia and somali politicians who are serving foreign countries like UK USA E.T.C

I wonder why do most world media use worst pictures and videos from somalia when they reporting somali essue, that picuters and videos was 15 years ago, My dear reporters use the approperiate pictures and videos that represents how somalia is giong now

The one from nairobis is just putting words together the glasses one seems very articulate

In Somalia, our earnest desire is to have peace and justice. It's crucial for politicians to empathize with the growing number of people in need of assistance and humanitarian aid. The panel said true, all we ask is to live with dignity within our own country.

Yes, we want our country Back.

Funny some of those pictures aren’t even Somalia

The president and his team felt that the unity of the country is moving in a dangerous moments. That is why the president is enthusiastic to complete the constitution, even if the process is not complete as they are claiming amendment can be done latter. The problem here is that some people want the continuation of 4.5 selection and scare of that the powers of the states will be limited.

Politicians like these two Somali gentlemen on the show should’ve been in power and leading Somalia instead of the corrupt politicians who cares about filling their pockets with money.

All are on point and I partially agree with what they have pointed out but, Aljeesara should have invited the government side to tell us their view.

The two involved guests are GORGEOUS and well deserved to be OUR PRESIDENT AND PRIME MINISTER POSITIONS KKKK

Hassan Sh Maxamuud is the biggest liar he put the power to his family daughter , wife, son in law his clan

It is impossible for Somali political union after the powerful Central government of Siyad Barre fallen. But, one thing is for sure and no one could change or undermind. The Somali peoples unity is very much there and will always be there!

That long coastline full of natural resources of all sorts, beautiful beaches and a country big enough to accomodate us all and yet we chose to suffer? What about the potential tourism and maritime trade? do improved agricultural techniques alone enough to sustain the lifes of many?. Somalia can do better but the question is WHEN?

Oil-rich Puntland will not stop for puppets ❤

2024 aya la Maraya inaguna waxan is lenahay Ana landhere ah iyo Ana laandhere ah

Very intelligent and well educated guests. Ismail and afyare are amazing 😊

There's something weired and unusual here. Why didn't Al-Jazeera invite all concerned sides of the matter rather than inviting unilaterally those who are well-known for their blindly opposing views on anything/ everthing that the current regime does?

I’m born and raised in America my parents met here in America but are from Somalia and came here as refugees fleeing from a civil war. I don’t know much about the Somali politics but what I do know is Somalia will never move forward until they stop with the racist tribalism mentality and the government specifically Villa Somalia actually put in the effort to rid Somalia of Al Shabaab, there’s absolutely no reason that these terrorists should still have areas they control within the country

Together, we stand and shine, divided we fall@ let us hold heads and move forward. We are the most blessed people on earth. The future is bright ❤

Viva somaliland

Yes it is Achievebal in one condition

There is no other problem in Somalia except political leaders who are running to protect their group or personal interests. Another thing is that the people of Somalia have never been the cause of all the obstacles that are happening in Somalia, and they cannot do it.

We’ll see where “Loo joojin maayo” takes HSM government. I am sure soon he’ll loose other FMS and international community support.

Ethiopia is the problem of Somalia, the only country dividing it, they want to recognize all the states of Somalia as hostile independent states.

We all were one Somali until the British broke us up. My father is from the Isaaq tribe in Somaliland. Our great poet and warrior Hassan fought the British and prevented them from making Somalis slaves as they did in West Africa. We fought the Portuguese to, and all other invaders. We are Somalis it is the blood line even though we came from different Tribes that has broken up into clans. We have been fighting for centuries petty of us over land that is already ours. The land belongs to all Somalis and Somalis only. My people are 200 years behind they think they are still fighting with swords. Now we have three armies with guns and bombs, pirates and planes. We are capable of wiping each other out for good. The British were wrong, Barre was wrong, and the killing of civilians were wrong. The splitting us up is wrong. All Somalis should be independent and help our country grow strong, rich and peaceful. We may have a love and ancient hatred for each other, from centuries past.That can only change for the better in time. The question is when? It is now 2024, I feel this year or 2025 this epic saga, this generational conflict will climax, this old story will end for the better or worst. However, we do have to live on the same land, and share it because, it is not yours, mine it' is ours. Separating and telling Somalis they are not Punt Lander's or Somalilander's or Somali, and they can't go here or there is wrong. Selling our land to non Somalis is wrong, and it is stealing from the Somali people. The Ethiopian MOU deal with Somaliland hasn't gone through as of yet, and if Ethiopia insist on stealing or invading our land it will be war. Honor Hassan and Huru/Horus and come together and live and let live in peace. You can't run or hide from your blood line. We can't deny that we are all Somalis. Although we embrace Allah, but we come from the god of the underworld Pluto, who has never left us. We have been living on his dark side lets change for the better, and live on his bright side moving forward. I burn a candle to honor Hassan and Huru/Horus my and our ancestors every night. Peace!

I don’t think our country will ever be the same around this era of time…probably in 15-25 years yeah

﴿وَيُحِقُّ اللَّهُ الحَقَّ بِكَلِماتِهِ وَلَو كَرِهَ المُجرِمونَ﴾ [Yūnus: 82] (82) And Allāh will establish the truth by His words, even if the criminals dislike it." - English Translation

Why did you only invite the opponents of the direction of the government. To be impartial, you should have also invited politicians who support the current direction of the government to defend their position.

Ethiopia is not a problem to Somalia, but we are problem to ourselves.

The question is can Hassan mud and his tribal politician achieve thier day dream ..... Hassan isn't a president of Somalia he is one of the tribal leader in moqdisho....

As a Somali, I have been asking myself this question for the past few decades. Is political unity in Somalia achievable? Unfortunately, the answer is no.

Only solution in somalia is three states Somaliland puntland and southern community

At this time , constitutional issues don't appropriate to discuss it due to decentralized powers that exists in the country and the points that were changed the constitution may escalate conflicts between Federal Government and states.

They should recognize Somaliland as its the only one achieving its own success with little outside influence

Somaliland is not Somalia. The professor is lying Somaliland ask people from Bay and Bakool whose security depends on Ethiopian Forces.

Indeed, Somalia's problems are not small. a head of state that does not allow to be ordered, 8 differnt presidents, a constitution based on clans and Ethiopia that has never leave our affaira alone is the problem.

You showing incorrect map. Check it again.

Somalia problem is Hawiye clan .they don't want government because they know what they have done

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Ethiopia is not Somali problem. Somali is Somali problem. Ethiopia is not claiming territory, Ethiopia is leasing a port. Mr. Samatar, this is a different Ethiopia, upgrade your knowledge.

I believe Somalia is heading in the right direction now, and I'm fully behind the current leadership. We'll achieve stability despite certain individuals spreading negativity. Let's stay positive and keep supporting progress together. Take care!

Most speakers are correct, but it would be better to invite people with different opinions who view the constitution positively. Somalia is a country of small tribes, where each tribe lives in its own territory. The first problem is that Somalia's federal system has never worked, since there are no collective tribes that can form a regional government.

As long as the gulf states won’t stop interfering in Somalia politics, security, peace won’t exist.

All this images are only from southern somalia but puntland and somaliland covering 70 of the country are stable region no famine war or so on...

All these problems are coming from Halane our Somalia Leader has to shut off all Halane and let leave all those who are in that place they are destroying our Nation the master mind is coming from there period.

254 Praliment members has voted the constitution changes and the somali people are happy about it

I was just talking to someone in Somalia and they had no issues with food😂. Matter of fact they were eating more than me. Is this about rural areas in the desert?

@aljazeera you have to know guys. These 4years daarood clan will comment only negative things, while hawiye (current in the power) will only talk about prosperity. These people are just a joke.

me as Somali live in Mogadishu, the absolute answer is no!, Somalia needs its own way of government, 4.5 clan based federal will never work it will only increase extremism, who will allow 2024 you are less citizen or half citizen 1/2, the answer is no, they will never be loyal to the government and will prefer resistant like al-Shabaab or any other form. I'm civilian and there is something we cant say because of our security.

The main problem of our country is the foreign interference and corruption and also the leaders who are willing to make their own benefits .

Ethiopia was supporting Alshabab, why did Somalia invite Ethiopian troops to protect civilians in Somalia? Doesn't make any sense

No, Somalis do not want their country back! Anyone who knows a little about Somalia knows this fact.

Al Jazeera Is my favorite channel! But when it comes to Somalia experts you always bring someone who is corrupt, biased or criminal. Please do find someone who is trustworthy. Thank you

When life gives you an enemy like Somalia 🇸🇴. Fight like Somaliland.

Pro Samatar went to Somalia 🇸🇴, looking for a political position, and lucky got it . But no sooner, he started dividing the somali community 😂

Why always the media take the worst pictures Somalia 🇸🇴 🤷🏽‍♂️

It's shameless to fight tribalism in this century

Somalia needed to be dismantled as a four different small countries like Khalij and they can evolve from there, because of selfishness by the positions. Somaliland is already gone for good, but the rest are not ready to be govern by demococarcy and free election. Imagine up til now they do not want to accept one vote one man. They buy their vote by money. This is not the way that you can govern a country. The positions are very corrupt and need to be addressed. I'm Somalian who like to help Somalians

world should recognize somaliland as foreign country

I don't agree with Abdi Samater that Djibouti honest broker in intra-Somali conflict.Djibouti has been against Khatumo state.

Hey world we are rich people we are smart people we don’t need any help today Stop using the bad side pics ans clips in our country 🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴

I lose interest in Samaters, ever since I was a teen. they're smart, articulate can elaborate a complicated ideas and present a digestible chunks for they've teaching in the West and South African universities.

Aj missed the opportunity to balance the program. They are all on one side. To make a good program, there must be contrasting pioneers where here they are all on one side

We don't need as somali citizens to listen negative analysis regarding where we are going we need to go forward because the majority of somali pupils they have representatives in the Parliament then who missing as citizens we need to vote regarding our future and we need 1 man 1 vote period

Somalia will never unite again

When it comes to Puntland its first state in this country and it has enought resource oil rich and two busy Ports Bossaso and Garacad, in the North Somalia and throughout Gult Aden.

Hassan Sheikh isn’t the president of Somalia. He is one of the tribal leaders in the Mugdisho. He has No right to change the constitution without consulting with the rest of the leaders and the people.

The video features a valuable discussion with knowledgeable experts, but there are a couple of aspects that could be enhanced. First, the use of older and unnecessary clips by Al Jazeera doesn't fully capture the current state of Somalia. While challenges persist, there are positive developments that could have been showcased for a more balanced perspective. Additionally, the absence of a pro-federal government participant in the discussion creates a bias, limiting diverse viewpoints on governmental strategies and decisions. Including a broader range of perspectives would have enriched the conversation and promoted fairness.

The destruction of somalia startedfrom siyad Barre regime was orchestrated out side especially from neighbouring countries who act to facilities foreign interest.

President hassan shiek is working on to up lift Somalia from the thrush and Puntland attempts to thwart the efforts of every president in pursuit of their objectives but hassan knows how to deal with them

I was born in this country and trust me i lost the hope. I dont think that Somalis will unite. They cannot rule themselfs. For more than 30 years! Still same problem. No unity , no stable and functioning government. Tribalism, corruption. They cannot even bring their currency back to live! We use dollars and other foreign currency. What kind a government is this????

Mr Omar of International crisis utterly asserted that the Puntland regional government is the mother of the Somalia Constitution Apparently,Somaliland was the Father of the constitution and had five kids from that mother of five kids called Federal state members. Unfortunately,Somaliland divorced to that Mom for good any one that claims Somaliland to give up its Independence for somali unity would be look like divorced mother trying to make the previous man out which would be traditionally and Islamically more Draconian than being legal. All guests have vested interests including the AlJazeera TV host None of them genuinely believe in what they are saying Senator Abdi Ismail Samater is a Somaliland political dissident mainly,his Intention is to prevent Somaliland from being recognized and he’s disobedient child of Somaliland. Prof Afyare Elmi is unknown child of Somalia and Impulsively what he has argued became Insulting to two years old child Intelligence. When I came to the TV political Commentator (Mohamed) he represents the vested interests of his own tiny country called QaTar. Qatar always plays a big role in somali political affairs in order to benefit from somali oil exploration.

The inclusivity address here doesn't exist in Xasan Sheekh Maxamuud dictionary. This politics of Xasan Sheekh Maxamuud will again delay the long ongoing reconciliation

Yeah why not with a bit being nationalist 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

This panel avoided talking about Somaliland as an independent state. Somaliland has a functioning government unlike Mogadishu and will implement the MOU with Ethiopia when it is finalized.

No isn’t close

Great news from Aljazeera for recognising Somaliland by limiting the to Somalila and it is in fact a Somalia problem and not Somaliland.