Thomas was Werner. I cannot envision anyone else filling the role so perfectly. Every nuance, every upturned smile, every loving gaze was perfection. What a handsome man. They both said so much with saying nothing. A true tragedy of war.
This movie shows that there are love and victims on both sides. So sad. War is cruel. Lost loves and mothers crying on both sides as they lose loved ones.
Propaganda on both side to stir up hate on the Resistance side, blind lying on their true intentions towards France on the German side. Young people are easy to manipulate! Think of what has been happening here in the US, and what they did to young people (Red Guards) in China during the Cultural Revolution....They use young people to do their bidding. With what we all know today, especially the commentators here, I would advice Jeanne and Werner:"Whatever you are outside the house, do NOT have to be what you are inside the house. The war won't last forever, peace will return. So take good care of your hearts, treasure your love. Stay alive. Always choose love, not death."
Τι αγνή αγάπη...67 χρονών είμαι και δεν σταματάω να την βλέπω. Μακάρι στ' αλήθεια να ήταν έτσι ο έρωτας αληθινός ..αγνός. Ούτε ένα άγγιγμα ούτε ένα φιλί αλλά μόνον το βλέμμα τους σε μαγνητίζει και νοιώθεις ότι ο έρωτας υπάρχει και με αυτό τον τρόπο!!
Жанна и капитан сыграли великолепно какие они оба красивые как трудно скрывать любовь она его спасла от гибели. Удачи им двоим этот фильм шедевр спасибо режиссерам за такой фильм.
Yes, Julie Delarmet was very good playing a part that was quiet difficult, but I don't think that this film would have been anywhere near as successful as it was, without the delectable, Capitaine Von Ebrennac. ❤❤❤
Посмотрела этого актера в других фильмах. Вернее эпизоды с его участием. Очень талантливый актер. НО! Его роль в " Молчание море" лучшая и он в этой роли просто прекрасный. Видела фото его с женой. Симпатичная. НО! Я в свои 70 лет наивная..... Не хочу его видеть рядом с другой.... Лучше бы и не видела. Пусть бы в моём воображении жила сказка. Вернулся он после войны живым и нашел эту маленькую хрупкую хорошенькую девушку. Её заплаканное личико так и стоит перед глазами....
А мені дуже подобається, що над кожним епізодом можна довго міркувати, пояснювати, чому так зробив Вернер, чому так зробила Жанна. Інтрига якраз і спонукає до думок про мотиви їхньої поведінки. Шкода, що в кохання, яке спалахнуло з такою потужною силою, не було майбутнього. А винна в усьому проклята війна.
Perfect song. Massive Josh Groban fan & Run is actually on the playlist for a Le Silence de la Mer/Temeraire the Dragon crossover fan fiction that I unfortunately haven't had the time or motivation to really work on. Run is a song that I associate with my characters, the Frenchman Landry Durand, a writer, and his lady, Adelind von Ebrennac, Werner's cousin & officer in the SS Dragon Corps at the beginning of their relationship. Unlike Werner & Jeanne, Landry & Adelind are openly together & engaged after going public to the whole village.. Lots of funny dragons in the story, too.
Yes! Adelind & Landry & their companions in the United Resistance are my own creations. So are their dragons. Adelind absolutely hates Jeanne when she meets her. The premise of the story is that Adelind & Landry along with their companions hatch a plot to steal valuable dragon eggs from the Third Reich. Adelind meets Jeanne & hates her with a passion because in my story Werner is being held in a Russian POW camp & Adelind blames Jeanne for breaking his heart. At the end of the story, Adelind goes to Russia to free Werner. A lot happens in the story. I titled it Souls Invictus & I really ought to write it. 😛 It's dramatic, romantic, and hilariously funny in parts. Hildreth, Adelind's fire-breathing dragon, is especially crazy. In this AU, dragons talk.
@@morganmills13 Sounds fantastic. Hope Werner makes his way out of the POW camp. Jeanne made a terrible mistake by not telling Werner about the bomb, he not only lost his friends and his orderly, he may have to carry out the order to kill 99 hostages, I believe he left abruptly to not have to be part of that, and because of survivor's guilt. Would love to read Souls Invictus if you will make it coming true :). The Third Reich had bases in Antarctica, they might be in alliance with the Dracos?
I actually found this scene that I wrote ages ago. Thought I'd share it since there seems to be interest in my story, lol! Here we see Jeanne & Adelind having one of their many not-nice moments! The two women eyed each other warily across the large kitchen table. Jeanne swallowed back every ounce of her fear and trepidation as she met Adelind's icy gaze. The dragon officer was a strikingly beautiful woman and her blue eyes were the same soft shade as Werner's, but all similarity between the von Ebrennac cousins ended there. Where Werner was a gentle soul, his cousin put Jeanne in mind of a goddess of war, death incarnate as she held her pistol aimed at Jeanne's heart. She exuded power and grace, a jungle cat stalking her prey, a woman seeking the ultimate revenge. No wonder the locals called her The Lioness of Tusson. Landry cautiously approached his girlfriend as their friends stood a fair few feet away. "Come now, she isn't worth it. Give me the gun. Werner wouldn't want you to kill her." He glanced over at their companions. Ernst, Dylan, Rivka, and his father, Benoit, all looked tense. Rivka nodded imperceptibly and made her way slowly around the table until the Polish girl was standing next to Jeanne, her hand on the young woman's shoulder. "Lower your weapon, Adelind. Like it or not, she's Resistance, too. And we need all the help we can get." Benoit nodded his agreement. "Let it go, girl," he said to his future daughter-in-law. "Jeanne deserves to pay for her sins against Werner, but if he was willing to overlook them and he sent her to us, then... Let's honor his wishes." Adelind seemed to consider, her features still taut with anger. To everyone's relief, she lowered her gun. "Understand this, Jeanne," she said, "I will never, ever forgive you for the way you and your grandfather treated Werner, and if he survives captivity and comes home, I will make damn fucking sure that you never marry him. You aren't worthy of our name. If you survive this war, if I don't finish you, Hildreth will! Though," she laughed bitterly. "You're just a little piano teacher. Look at us!" She gestured around the room. "I'm a major in the SS. Ernst is a lieutenant and son of the Kommandant. Rivka is a fighter who survived the ghetto. She leads feral dragons. Dylan flies for the King of England. And Landry is the son of dragon captains. How can you possibly compare to us? No. You're nothing. Landry's right. You're not worth it."
@@morganmills13 Oh no, you are letting them ganging up on poor Jeanne lol. Very good writing though. Vivid and full of kinetic energy even though no one is moving, the energetic potential I suppose. Thanks for sharing. I wonder how Adelind can convince Werner to not marry Jeanne if he comes home unscathed.
Bellicima parte del puente cuando el la esperaba isele puso enfrente pensé que dejarían aunlado los perjuicios i obstáculos para decirse lo que sus corazones cayaban
¿Viste? Pero no. Ella no podía romper sus propios principios debido a lo que él representaba para la entera Francia de la Segunda Guerra Mundial. Y él es un hombre extremadamente respetuoso, y no quiere forzarla. En el libro él es más frío pero hace frente a sus propios principios, y por eso, como castigo, lo mandan al frente ruso, cuyo único destino solo puede ser el de la muerte. :(
@@alexbay3885 You are right. In France then, women who loved German soldiers were called terrible names and beaten. Her Grandfather couldn't have stood that. And she, too was a patriot, joining the French Resistance at the end.
@@mt.shasta6097 Angry men who lost the military battle have to take their hate out on the women who had relationships with the occupier. This year is 2024, 80th anniversary of D Day, can we please shift our perspective somewhat to 1. not see all German soldiers as caricatures; 2. start to recognize the relentless propaganda to whip up desired sentiments on both sides by using lies, half truth, emotional manipulation to achieve their desired end result. These propaganda programs young people take up the interests of certain political group's agenda first, and forsaken their individual lives (love interests), often in the name of nationalism (a concept that can be twisted in every which way depending on who is using it). Are Jeanne and Werner individual human beings? How does their love for each other hurt anybody? On the contrary, their love for each other has to hide because it brings life threatening consequences. What a twisted world War brings. So please think again when we talk about "principles"-----what principles, whose principles? Who decides how to phrase these principles? What individual liberty do these principles destroy?
Very good point, the investigators would ask: How come the other two officers and your orderly died in the bombing, but you did not? Germans are notoriously punctual. Werner must have some explaining to do. Also, if I were him, I would be crushed that Jeanne saved him and let his buddies and orderly die. I would not be able to not feel resentful towards her, and be crushed by survivor's guilt.
Every time I watch Le Silence de la Mer, I'm always inspired to a new fanfic idea! 😂 First my still-unwritten story about Werner's cousin & her dragon who meet up with Jeanne & now my imagination's come up with a story in which Jeanne & Werner live long & happy lives together & after they pass, their granddaughter who I named Veronique brings them back to the sea by the farmhouse Jeanne lives in this film. Veronique is an international classical music superstar known as the Gothic Soprano. Think a Gothic symphonic version of Sarah Brightman. She & her husband meet a young man who's a major fan of her & also his grandfather. Grandpa is Pascal & he gets the shock of his life. Yeah. Gotta write this.
No this must remain a a tragic love story. He will die on the Russian front and she will be shot because she has now joined the resistance. Any sequel would turn a beautiful story into a mundane boring mess. I think you are going Barbara Cartland with the schmaltzy sequel. Don’t mean to offend but in my opinion a beautiful tragedy far outweighs the mundane.
Well, honey, it's my experience that any time someone uses the phrase "I don't mean to offend," they actually intend to do just that & are merely being passive-aggressive. If I want to write a fun fanfic exploring what could have been, I will damn well do it.
@@morganmills13 First, I am not your honey. No one is stopping you from writing whatever pleases you. I prefer the logical ending and you may write your own sequel. Nothing changes the fact that this was a very emotional and well portrayed movie by a sterling cast, well adapted from the book and beautifully directed. So write away. If you choose to be offended by another’s opinion, that is your prerogative. Luckily freedom of speech still exists. Adieu!!!!!
_she: de Red EU Plague.._ *him: ..cannot separate us* _she: ..we will İNTENSİFY!!_ *him: with Nationalism++!!* _she: de bruxelles komissariate.._ *him: ..is a pLeb.* _she: Jean-Claude Junkers.._ *him: İZ A DRUNKARD!!* _she: (..staRes aT hiM)_ *him: (StAreS bAcK.)* *BREXİT OF LOVE: **_İNTENSİFİES!!_* ✓✓
