Тёмный

Joe Rogan and Neil deGrasse Tyson Tackle Gravity 

JRE Clips
Подписаться 7 млн
Просмотров 1,5 млн
50% 1

Taken from JRE #1347: Neil deGrasse Tyson: • Joe Rogan Experience #...

Опубликовано:

 

9 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 8 тыс.   
@davidchico9574
@davidchico9574 4 года назад
Joe: Why does gravity exist? Neil: Well, why are you bald?
@TheSuperCoolMan122
@TheSuperCoolMan122 4 года назад
lmao
@tefbloc9100
@tefbloc9100 4 года назад
He didn’t have an answer so he became petty 😂😂😂😂
@theoriginalrocketman3430
@theoriginalrocketman3430 4 года назад
😂😂😂
@ajcook7777
@ajcook7777 4 года назад
I believe that the temperature of the universe has a huge part to play in gravity and how electromagnetic waves conduct themselves. Watch the video in the link below, that metals superconducting temp is 92 Kelvin and the universe is 2.73 Kelvin imagine the superconducting properties of the ozone being cooled to 2.73 Kelvin that's probs why we don't get alot of radiation from the sun and why certain WIMP particles will never be found passing through our planet! Id like to ask Neil about this ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JIjzJKnpahA.html
@gstylez0107
@gstylez0107 4 года назад
Joe's hair follicles are more sensitive to the effects of gravity, it pulls the hair towards earth, thus preventing it from growing upwards out of his head...
@Prometheus7272
@Prometheus7272 4 года назад
Neil: Science is always asking why Joe: Why Neil: Shut up
@onyxtytanium964
@onyxtytanium964 4 года назад
Dr: R u still gon ask me why there is gravity????? Hahahahahahhahahhahahaha
@goncalobaia1574
@goncalobaia1574 4 года назад
Yes but not in a phylosophical way, science asks why to the unexplained facts presented by physics, why can we usually see a spectrum of seven colors? Why can we see colors? Why did this apple fall on my head? And to those common sense facts we get explanations, because the material has properties that absorb part of the white light it gets, but not all, because the reflection of the light in the objects can reach our eyes and so we see it (I haven't studied science in a while, so sorry if this explanation is a little blurry), because there was a force called gravity that was acting on the apple, those why's are scientific why's, but if you ask, why are there colors, why is there gravity, that is more of a job for phylosophy, and you will end up asking why is there life, and will know nothing It's just the way things are, that's what I usually go with
@BluntBrazenCurt_Evolved
@BluntBrazenCurt_Evolved 4 года назад
gonçalo Baia shut up its funny
@goncalobaia1574
@goncalobaia1574 4 года назад
@@BluntBrazenCurt_Evolved yes it is, but I figured a minimumly intelligent comment was better than a presence-marking "Hahaha"
@tsduali7516
@tsduali7516 3 года назад
he answered question 3 times , from the first one it was obvious what he was talking about , yet you expected him to say what? that he doesn't know answer on question no one can , at least now .
@tobblesmash6193
@tobblesmash6193 2 года назад
Joe:"isn't it crazy how strong gravity is as a force" Neil: "isn't it crazy how shiny your bald head is"
@vaishnavplays203
@vaishnavplays203 2 года назад
🤣
@JR._1985
@JR._1985 10 месяцев назад
🤣 damn 🤣
@NicoDelCap
@NicoDelCap 10 месяцев назад
No way 😂
@johndiekmann
@johndiekmann Год назад
“Neil Degrasse Tyson is the most intelligent & articulate man this world has ever seen” -Neil Degrasse Tyson
@BabylonGateLA
@BabylonGateLA Год назад
LMFAO 🤣🤣
@generalsaufenberg4931
@generalsaufenberg4931 4 года назад
“The more I learn, the more I realize how much I don't know.” Einstein
@MatthewsArcade
@MatthewsArcade 4 года назад
what a revolutionary thought, the more i explore the more i realize how much i haven't explored
@deussivenatura5805
@deussivenatura5805 4 года назад
Wasn't that Socrates?
@JeffWithAnF
@JeffWithAnF 4 года назад
shit hits me in my soul
@david17500
@david17500 4 года назад
Me too
@generalsaufenberg4931
@generalsaufenberg4931 4 года назад
@@raymondz595 look it up. the quote from socrates is different.
@GG-ou2tz
@GG-ou2tz 4 года назад
Joe Rogans head is the curvature of space and time
@fakechloe207
@fakechloe207 4 года назад
LoL
@EcHoquickscopez
@EcHoquickscopez 4 года назад
G G Phahahhaha😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@seeyouchump
@seeyouchump 4 года назад
@@fakechloe207 some say it's causing gravitational waves as well
@aragone8650
@aragone8650 4 года назад
Gold
@GG-ou2tz
@GG-ou2tz 4 года назад
@@aragone8650 lol
@TK-qh4gr
@TK-qh4gr 3 года назад
The best part of this video is when Joe presses him about being defensive about the question.
@Howhighsquad001
@Howhighsquad001 3 года назад
😂😹
@loucard1752
@loucard1752 3 года назад
Yup we really don’t understand it !
@theeendo3677
@theeendo3677 3 года назад
Very sus
@ZiplineShazam
@ZiplineShazam 3 года назад
Yep. . . .Narcissism is one hell of a drug
@tpjmadrigal12
@tpjmadrigal12 2 года назад
Its hard to watch somebody i held in such high regard act like a that. Its like he took something before hand that ended up effectinf his mood hes normally arrogant, but not rude like that
@natebrown2111
@natebrown2111 3 года назад
It took Neil a good 10 minutes to just say “I don’t know”
@TrevorAndSky
@TrevorAndSky 3 года назад
He answered the question though, by saying that Gravity is the curvature of space and time. He said "I don't know" when he got asked "why is gravity the curvature of space and time?" Which is basically the same as being asked "why is gravity gravity?". The first question was "what really is gravity?". And Neil answered. And then he basically got asked "why is reality this way and not another way?". I think the confusion derived from the fact that the concept of gravity is hard to understand: it is a curvature sure, the same as a ramp at a skateboard park, but you cannot perceive it. You can't see it. Cuz it's in 4D, per say. But just because you can't picture it in your head, doesn't mean you don't know what it is. Neil knows cause it's his field, many people didn't really understand it I think.
@bulcius
@bulcius 3 года назад
​@@TrevorAndSky Neil did not give a sufficient answer for Joe and for many people. It was very frustrating to view this clip as Neil continuously talked about the fact that we know 'enough' about gravity to get us to land on Mars for example. Neil did not explain what is the accepted theory in physics at the moment about how particles get their mass to create the curvature of space time. He just rambled about how what we know is enough and that is not an acceptable answer for a physicist. Neil showed his bad side with this podcast.
@PrinceIsot
@PrinceIsot 3 года назад
Actually he said it at the top of when he started talking he said "we don't know why gravity works we know we are limited to it's properties." It's better to keep asking how questions than why questions
@PrinceIsot
@PrinceIsot 3 года назад
@@bulcius he literally we said we don't know why gravity works 🤦🏻‍♂️ you guys aren't particularly.....equipped to understand what he was saying
@TB12Pats
@TB12Pats 3 года назад
Dude is a complete freak. He makes me super uncomfortable
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
Wow. Neil got so pissed off of Joe from asking why, he started calling him bald.
@ThumbWiggler
@ThumbWiggler 4 года назад
Underrated 😂😂😂😂
@Wizznilliam
@Wizznilliam 4 года назад
I think Neil was getting somewhat agitated because he kept trying to explain that at some point the "why" question is irrelevant. But I'm not sure why Neil feels that way. Who knows what could come out of an even deeper understanding of why/how gravity bends spacetime. Especially if we somehow figure out how to reverse it counteract it. This could be huge for future space travel, no? Wasn't that the whole plot to Interstellar?
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
@@Wizznilliam yes, some scientists still question the validity of gravity, it doesnt make sense completely in some pieces. What Neil did here is he is closing the conversation on the theory of gravity, if I recall correctly, this is not how the scientific method works. Infact this is very detrimental to it. This is similar to the God argument religious people use. Its a real shame. I also think Joe made a brilliant counter argument agains neils analogy between hair follicles and gravity, which simply was "we know a lot more about hair follicles than we know gravity" (thus its ok to dig deeper and ask more questions).
@jobuswayne9354
@jobuswayne9354 4 года назад
Based on tone of voice Joe seemed way more agitated than DeGrasse and I don't particularly care for him normally, but in this convo Joe irked me. DeGrasse was right in that we understand gravity to a fine enough degree to land interplanetary shit. People still by and large go bald if their genes say so ..which thing is manipulated to a greater degree by humanity then?
@warpath8453
@warpath8453 4 года назад
@@missionpupa your getting tired of these people too, huh? Lol
@henriwilson2155
@henriwilson2155 4 года назад
"But you seem oddly defensive about something that's scientific" LOL
@stressfreepaperchase3215
@stressfreepaperchase3215 4 года назад
🤦🤦 YES
@warpath8453
@warpath8453 4 года назад
@Al Garnier Neil was condescending in many parts. Neil might have been genuinely trying to help, but that just means he's a genuine asshole. Just because "Why" isnt obtainable through science, dosen't mean its not something you can't ask a scientist... he didnt have to answer as a scientist... and then he went on to make the worst point he could, which is "good enough" science. We understand it good enough and the things we don't know aren't important... i hope i dont need to explain why its bad for a scientist to say that
@brooksbrooks6805
@brooksbrooks6805 4 года назад
@@warpath8453 you don't understand what neil was saying... neil is saying there is an Infinite philisplophical never ending ever receding asking of "Why" like a child you can keep asking why til the end of the universe. It matter what "Why" you are satified with... Purpose is spiritual or theological which has NOTHING to do with science. You find meaning on your own, but in the mean time we will keep discovering HOW things happen in our universe. He is NOT saying to stop dicovery... he is saying we can eventually discover the true reason WHY life exists... and you will still have people... asking why.... there has to be a point of satisfaction with why so you can move on and KEEP DISCOVERING
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
@Al Garnier Joe clearly wasnt asking for a purpose, Neil knows fully well Joe wasnt. Joe was simply curious. Neil knew he lost his point.
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
@@warpath8453 who said you cant obtain why from science? The fuck? Science answers why all the time. But science cant stop people from asking why again.
@mortezasalarkia2842
@mortezasalarkia2842 3 года назад
6:23 nailed it, Joe is a genius at interviewing
@Douken
@Douken 2 года назад
I liked this one more. 5:44 . It was hilarious to see Neil's face. Genuinely not knowing the answer and then deferring to Einstein's definition which is not even a definition but a description of a framework.
@jonathansoko5368
@jonathansoko5368 2 года назад
He hasn't been on point like this in a long time... Other than that ep with the cnn robot guy
@kfm908
@kfm908 Год назад
Joe let him off the hook .The question was what is gravity,not why is gravity
@TDashem
@TDashem Год назад
@@kfm908Neil told him what gravity is.
@WhiskeyTango1911
@WhiskeyTango1911 3 года назад
Joe: "WHAT is gravity?" Neil: *rants about asking "WHY"*
@MichaelBrussow44
@MichaelBrussow44 2 года назад
WHY is the force that causes intelligent people to question things! Why do the planets do this instead of that is what caused Copernicus and Kepler to question the motion of the planets.
@calisongbird
@calisongbird 2 года назад
I thought I was the only person who noticed that
@thedonn4719
@thedonn4719 Год назад
So he knows why but not what. So he doesn't know.
@stellarwind1946
@stellarwind1946 Год назад
Neil: rants about Joe’s baldness
@TDashem
@TDashem Год назад
@@thedonn4719I think you need to listen again. And that’s not a insult, it just takes a minute to digest.
@poctordepper4469
@poctordepper4469 4 года назад
Roe Jogan: Y Geil neDrasse Tyson: fuck you. *You bald*
@angelhernandub1029
@angelhernandub1029 4 года назад
👌👌👌👌🤮🤮🤮😹😹😹
@astutecultivator2418
@astutecultivator2418 4 года назад
👎
@dattmamon112
@dattmamon112 4 года назад
he sounds real educated dont he...
@bonganimkhwanazi2081
@bonganimkhwanazi2081 4 года назад
Me: Why? *Neil DeGrasse Tyson has left the chat*
@mykls8712
@mykls8712 4 года назад
Haha yup
@danielsimental2803
@danielsimental2803 4 года назад
Ight, ima head out.
@thisisbaxter1354
@thisisbaxter1354 4 года назад
@@nonenone5326 i think this joke went over your head...
@elliottuberbacher1354
@elliottuberbacher1354 4 года назад
The earth is round
@Ari-lu5ve
@Ari-lu5ve 4 года назад
Makaveli chuckling more like he has entered the chat 😂😂😂
@oigitsuckit
@oigitsuckit 3 года назад
I feel like Tyson is a very angry man behind closed doors.
@SoulDelSol
@SoulDelSol 3 года назад
I know why insult Joe for being bald, joe was just trying to learn
@shanongwynne6439
@shanongwynne6439 3 года назад
This is a scary question to the physicist community as it exposes their lack of basic understanding and shows they rely massively on Einsteins laws but have no idea why hehe.. oh well that's mainstream for ya
@yz4043
@yz4043 2 года назад
I've heard that when someone's under stress it shows who they really are
@inertiaforce7846
@inertiaforce7846 Год назад
Tyson is just frustrated by religious dogma. He's had enough of it. Religious people are claiming to have made the greatest scientific discovery of all time, that there is a God and what the properties and characteristics of this God are. Such a discovery would be the greatest scientific discovery of all time. The problem with the religious people is that they are making this claim without sufficient evidence to support it.
@arlenegrundy7671
@arlenegrundy7671 3 года назад
Actually, "spooky action at a distance" was coined by Albert Einstein. He was refering to the quantum mechanics phenomena of Entanglement.
@urosmarjanovic663
@urosmarjanovic663 3 года назад
When will people comprehend that entire science is just a human's honest response to their own incompetence to fully comprehend the true nature of Nature?
@CharlieWeller
@CharlieWeller 3 года назад
Thanks, was looking for this reply.
@abegohr2576
@abegohr2576 3 года назад
Thank you, it left me puzzled since he was quoting Newton, who obviously wrote in English, but "spooky" was not an English word back then.
@mustafa-cx2fg
@mustafa-cx2fg 3 года назад
Entanglement ? I knew that word meant something else besides Jada Smith fucking August Alsina
@m.c.4674
@m.c.4674 2 года назад
that is true , that quote is Einstein's , but it was the critics of newton that first identified the problem of action at a distance .
@osirisgolad
@osirisgolad 4 года назад
I would have greatly preferred a video of Joe Rogan and Gravity tackling Neil deGrasse Tyson.
@skankhunt6066
@skankhunt6066 4 года назад
🤣🤣🤣
@karthiksravan9498
@karthiksravan9498 4 года назад
That's really clever because of characters involved.
@pre-packaged_9692
@pre-packaged_9692 4 года назад
Classic Gravity move
@bobbyesteban6741
@bobbyesteban6741 4 года назад
Lol boo this man
@dirtybombasticds
@dirtybombasticds 4 года назад
"I don't know", would have been an acceptable answer Neil.
@mykls8712
@mykls8712 4 года назад
He couldn't do that. "I'm good with this... I GOT THIS!!!"
@akaakaakaak5779
@akaakaakaak5779 4 года назад
but he does know.. to an extent.. how far back do you want to go? All the way back to "why is there anything?"?
@normanatdi
@normanatdi 4 года назад
exactly
@godzzila
@godzzila 4 года назад
He seemed irritated this podcast.
@edwardanstett2297
@edwardanstett2297 4 года назад
In other interviews he was asked the same question.., and laughingly said he didn't know. The only "why" that troubles me is "why" was NDT so triggered
@aloncr1796
@aloncr1796 3 года назад
-Joe: you are being defensive. -Neil: why? Owned.
@RockHudrock
@RockHudrock Год назад
😂
@valenmolina
@valenmolina 3 года назад
- Why did you bang the table? - Because you won't stop asking me why
@dyslexicteletubby4048
@dyslexicteletubby4048 4 года назад
I didn’t know where this was going, he got kinda angry while basically talking to himself. 😂😂😂
@007VitaminD
@007VitaminD 4 года назад
He doesnt like being questioned. He wants us to believe like blind faith.
@stressfreepaperchase3215
@stressfreepaperchase3215 4 года назад
@@007VitaminD 👍👍
@warpath8453
@warpath8453 4 года назад
@@007VitaminD No... he's been on before, and he was never like this. He was always open to answering questions
@supernintendochalmers6628
@supernintendochalmers6628 4 года назад
Lmao! Dude, Joe was over it. He kept interrupting Joe, so I image Joe just bowed out. Like, "dude, why are you preaching right now? I'm TRYING to have a conversation."
@natureboy7766
@natureboy7766 4 года назад
A renowned astrophysicist does not want to ever admit "Well, we really don't know".
@mrokesene
@mrokesene 4 года назад
A convo of two men really saying “farrrk you” behind fake smiles
@LeeBo318
@LeeBo318 4 года назад
Yeah, pretty much 🤷🏽‍♂️😂😂
@Jackboy019
@Jackboy019 4 года назад
Got the vibe when Neil thought it was a religion rabbit hole lol. After that they seemed cool again tho.
@afrog2666
@afrog2666 4 года назад
Neil gets a bit edgy any time someone pursues a line of questioning he feels he adequately answered, and Joe doesn`t let shit go if he`s not satisfied with the answers, but I don`t think they`re all like "fuuuuuuuuuckyoooooooo BUDDY!" lol
@orestispalampougioukis6043
@orestispalampougioukis6043 4 года назад
@@afrog2666 The thing is NDT does not get edgy when someone pursues yadda yadda. He gets edgy here specifically, because while he adequately explained multiple times, Joe tries to present it as if he is avoiding to answer. NDT again explains that he has answered, that we do know what gravity is, we just don't know the philosophical "why". Joe basically keeps asking rabbit hole questions, which don't lead to a what, but basically to a "why", and he does not even understand that he is doing that. This is what is frustrating about it to NDT, and I fully sympathize with him.
@MrDOB1000
@MrDOB1000 4 года назад
@@orestispalampougioukis6043 he is edgy, because he's a scientist first and foremost. If he feels questions are superfluous, he will probably be quick to say so. Nevertheless, we are limited in understandings of many things, and this can frustrate us, and NDT is no different. Also, theological questions are not often welcomed by scientists, which "why" could hint at, and in that case is fundamentally different to "how".
@cryptanium500
@cryptanium500 Год назад
Joe: "why is there gravity?" Neil: "Do you ever wonder why is your head bold"
@yeyeballesteroschannel8302
@yeyeballesteroschannel8302 2 года назад
5:10 Neil "when did you go bald" Degrasse Tyson.
@panno1103
@panno1103 4 года назад
The interview in few words. Joe: What is gravity? Niel: A curve in space and time. Joe: Why? Niel: You are bald. Joe: I remind you that I go to the gym regularly. Well, that escalated quickly
@paradoxxgaming
@paradoxxgaming 3 года назад
Hahah
@donkeydan5996
@donkeydan5996 3 года назад
Somehow it turned into hair follicles
@matthewroreilly
@matthewroreilly 3 года назад
Joe got pretty tight lmao.
@AlexSanLyra
@AlexSanLyra 4 года назад
My dad's a physicist. He always says: "how" is for scientists, "why" is for philosophers. Maybe I'm just used to it, but... it sounds about right to me.
@lotusflower8
@lotusflower8 4 года назад
Alex San Lyra ~Nice~ I’m not sure “how” happens without the “why?”.
@joshuaalbert9092
@joshuaalbert9092 4 года назад
Alex San Lyra nope science answers both once both can be answered and philosophers do nothing except push the scientist to answer both of these questions furthers
@AlexSanLyra
@AlexSanLyra 4 года назад
@@joshuaalbert9092 And you're basing that comment based on what? Are you a scientist? Or a philosopher?
@joshuaalbert9092
@joshuaalbert9092 4 года назад
Alex San Lyra a biologist with a disdain for people who have to answer everything with a story about how it had to be created. Also I was just being tongue in cheek.
@Eagle45678910
@Eagle45678910 4 года назад
@@joshuaalbert9092 has nothing to do with that. "why" can be answered with science
@thatoneunicornguy9366
@thatoneunicornguy9366 3 года назад
Neil was way more interested in letting Joe know that he's intelligent than anything Joe was trying to have a conversation about lol then when Neil got called out, it was a slippery slope of him being defensive as hell the rest of the way lol
@RecK1312
@RecK1312 Год назад
Holy fuck you are dumb
@RossFennell
@RossFennell 3 года назад
“I’m always hooked on gravity” - Joe “As you should be.” - Neil *joe ignores dad joke*
@Aterhallsam
@Aterhallsam 4 года назад
Why does gravity exist? Neil: mind your own business, boy.
@XeLProductions
@XeLProductions 4 года назад
Aterhallsam why does gravity exist is the wrong question.
@jamstonjulian6947
@jamstonjulian6947 4 года назад
@@XeLProductions Why is it the wrong question?
@XeLProductions
@XeLProductions 4 года назад
Jamston Julian Because theism
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
he didnt ask why gravity exists, he asked what is gravity. why gravity exists is a dumb questions to ask.
@XeLProductions
@XeLProductions 4 года назад
Feralz exactly!
@blindspotspotter.2352
@blindspotspotter.2352 4 года назад
Pretty sure "spooky action at a distance " was Einstein's quote decrying quantum entanglement. Not Newton explaining why gravity works.
@Mike-nf6nf
@Mike-nf6nf 4 года назад
Yup. That's exactly what Einstein meant.
@launchsquid
@launchsquid 4 года назад
Yes, Spooky Action at a Distance was an Einsteinian quote but the concept of action at a distance was a very big and defining limit to Newtons descriptions of Gravity. Newton didn't have the concept of "space-time" being a fabric, he thought of space as a vacuum only, so he wrestled with and failed to answer a mechanism for gravity, he could only make predictions of how it would manifest. He couldn't think of a way for two objects that aren't sharing a medium of something else to affect one another, to him it was action at a distance. What NDT was clumsily trying to say was that when Einstein described the concept of "space/time' and that Mass and energy can curve it, we no longer needed a concept of action at a distance for gravity, we had a medium, it was space/time itself.
@blindspotspotter.2352
@blindspotspotter.2352 4 года назад
@@launchsquid wow. Well said. So when Einstein used the " spooky action at a distance" line, was he actually incorporating Newton's "action at a distance " line in order to throw shade at Niels Bohr's quantum physics thesis?
@launchsquid
@launchsquid 4 года назад
@@blindspotspotter.2352 Einstein famously thought Quantum entanglement was impossible. He believed the universe to followed the principle of locality and that quantum entanglement broke that principal. Einstein rejected the older alternative of action at a distance, such as Newton had invoked when he tried to explain how he saw gravity influencing objects that were unconnected and in a vacuum with no interconnecting medium. Einstein later showed the warping of spacetime was the mechanism for gravity and the connecting medium between celestial objects was spacetime itself. Because Einstein believed any particle or energy state could only be influenced by another particle or energy that is causally linked to it he rejected the notion that action at a distance was a thing. Quantum entanglement allows for two particles to influence one another over infinite distances instantaneously, despite no obvious causal link, so Einstein dubbed it spooky action at a distance as a way to deride it.
@Marcoose81
@Marcoose81 4 года назад
NDT is so full of shit. "Why do you want to know what gravity is, isn't it enough that current theories work!?" He sounds like a science denier.
@christopherwn100
@christopherwn100 Год назад
Joe: Why is there gravity. Neil: Why are you asking me that? Lecturer: Write a research paper on why gravity exists. Neil: Why am I in this class?
@stephencech3696
@stephencech3696 3 года назад
The thumbnail looks like Joe is thinking 'Interruption number 5000!, WOW!'
@musicrocks80s90s
@musicrocks80s90s 4 года назад
lol Joe did get Neil on the edge of an anger attack
@DT-kc7fd
@DT-kc7fd 4 года назад
seemed like it
@OurBlackFriend
@OurBlackFriend 4 года назад
Well imagine being as intelligent as NDT and trying to explain that concept to Joe "I know, but I dont know..." Rogan. I mean even if you've ever tried to teach someone whose new on a job it can be infuriating. Somehow at 60 years old Joe is still new on life and needs a lot of this stuff explained to him lol.
@phantomimaging
@phantomimaging 4 года назад
@@OurBlackFriend Joe isn't any different than all humans asking for answers. Neil is in a "greater" position to provide a little more insight however on the grand scale even tyson doesn't have the ability to propel our knowledge of anything more vast than 11% of our unlocked brain. For example how to worm holes work in the universe? why haven't we found a way to live too 170 years old? Why has climate change been on the four front lately when for billions of years volcanos erupting gives off far more carbon damage than anything humans have done in our small real 400 years of industrial earth damage
@willforbes6495
@willforbes6495 4 года назад
Alex Stoll I enjoy teaching new people on the job and I also enjoy learning and asking why. Maybe you’re just an asshole. Get off that pedestal you’ve put yourself on.
@JonnyVerace
@JonnyVerace 4 года назад
Alex Stoll joe is like 49 he’s no where near 60
@ivanraimi5524
@ivanraimi5524 4 года назад
Joe Rogan starting to look like Professor X
@Tizon_Eclipse
@Tizon_Eclipse 4 года назад
LOLOL, whos X? idk but that sounds funny
@redcastlefan
@redcastlefan 4 года назад
Now all he needs is to somehow get his legs crippled.
@kaayjaay2
@kaayjaay2 4 года назад
😂😂😂
@Googleaccount-wu4cj
@Googleaccount-wu4cj 4 года назад
@@Tizon_Eclipse From the X-men franchise.
@FantasticFox21
@FantasticFox21 4 года назад
Get Joe Rogan for the MCU!
@craigh1240
@craigh1240 3 года назад
I wish Neil would have explained his perspective about how we might begin to manipulate gravity in the future
@A-Chap
@A-Chap 3 года назад
"How" is just "why" that hasn't happened yet
@newish6596
@newish6596 4 года назад
Never let him babysit a 4 year old
@PAULEYBOY84
@PAULEYBOY84 4 года назад
😁 right
@Guppusmaximus
@Guppusmaximus 4 года назад
Why?
@Itsopvious
@Itsopvious 4 года назад
@@Guppusmaximus he wont let him ask WHY
@majedsolaimani9040
@majedsolaimani9040 4 года назад
@@Itsopvious why?
@philorgneopolotin8762
@philorgneopolotin8762 4 года назад
Guppusmaximus because all young children do is ask “Why?”. They’ll ask why? about the same topic 50 times and just never stop. It’d drive Neil crazy
@Raygun34
@Raygun34 4 года назад
I have a feeling this will be the last time Neil is on the show.
@qalbi-s_Ahnfy2095
@qalbi-s_Ahnfy2095 4 года назад
F
@honeybadger2171
@honeybadger2171 4 года назад
After that I hope so but I also see is stupid view he went about it the wrong way
@OzanSoylu
@OzanSoylu 4 года назад
Need more of Brian Cox and less of NDT
@skiz8848
@skiz8848 4 года назад
@Jerf Hankell I found you Neil
@voyageeats1409
@voyageeats1409 4 года назад
Jerf Hankell you eat shit
@fnaltf4201
@fnaltf4201 2 года назад
Funnily enough Nobel Prize winner Richard Feynman once had almost the exact same conversation in an interview, except he was asked about magnetism. (You can easily find that on youtube by searching "Richard Feynman. Why.") He also struggeled a bit to explain how a physicist views this sort of question. But in my opinion the most helpful quote from that interview was: "When you are explaining a Why, you have to be in some framework that you allow something to be true. Otherwhise you are perpetually asking why."
@baseydotwav1462
@baseydotwav1462 3 года назад
I didn't know count chocula knew so much about gravity. Man I loved that cereal.
@vanlyman2317
@vanlyman2317 4 года назад
Can be summed up as follows: Joe: Why does gravity exist? Tyson: I don't know and I'm gonna get weird and defensive about it.
@NessieAndrew
@NessieAndrew 4 года назад
No one knows the explanation to the rules of the universe.
@jdmnomore1420
@jdmnomore1420 4 года назад
I dont think Neil was defensive. He just thinks like a scientist and doesn't go much further than that with gravity. Gravity to me, is related more closely to the miracle of life itself than the math that gets you into a crater in Mars. We are a long ways from understanding the why of why there is life and things like gravity that seem to be present and factors that allow for life.
@tefosemanate9514
@tefosemanate9514 4 года назад
Shane O Mac theres no reason to ask why to an established objective truth; just as court cases where you don't prove or disprove agreed facts among parties. The "whys" that are asked for the sole puropose of generating controversy have to be shut down; because that's how you get to flat earth, holocaust denial, space is fake, etc. there isn't any need to have more imbeciles than those that already exist.
@bane5343
@bane5343 4 года назад
@@tefosemanate9514 Yea well, Neils flowery poetry shit & insisting on not asking why just reinforced all of those imbeciles! I've had elementary school teachers that could have given a more satisfactory conclusion.
@jewulo
@jewulo 4 года назад
t@XY ZW Is it really true that Relativity is unproven garbage? Apparently the GPS wouldn't work properly without accounting for the Mathematics of Relativity. I know that you can do Space Travel without Relativity but simply with Newton but GPS I have heard relies heavily on General Relativity. Or have I heard wrong?
@gokufujison
@gokufujison 4 года назад
*Joe:* "But isn't it still interesting to..." *Neil:* "You are bald and your hair is never coming back."
@eliazarperez3585
@eliazarperez3585 4 года назад
@@TV-cn3tf no it makes sense cuz he is bold for having a bald head🤯
@TrueWarlordMafia
@TrueWarlordMafia 4 года назад
Eliazar Perez good troll baby😎
@eliazarperez3585
@eliazarperez3585 4 года назад
@@TrueWarlordMafia Thank you glad to see my craft being respected for once. ✌✊
@TrueWarlordMafia
@TrueWarlordMafia 4 года назад
Eliazar Perez uwu Have a good one g
@TV-cn3tf
@TV-cn3tf 4 года назад
Ha he changed it 😘
@ayushdutta8050
@ayushdutta8050 3 года назад
I miss this set so much 😭
@deadsevenmick5697
@deadsevenmick5697 Год назад
Knowing how something works gives us the ability to exploit it for our benefit. Knowing why something works teaches us how not just to simulate something, but to truly recreate it and to manipulate it in ways we have yet to even imagine.
@conk6570
@conk6570 4 года назад
This doesn't sit right with me. When was the last time you heard a scientist say "Stop asking why, just believe."
@phantomimaging
@phantomimaging 4 года назад
I don't believe Neil was implying stop asking questions rather lets continue our purpose to see gravity work on a scale we have yet to figure out. It's like having a math question and we all know 1+1=2 and someone standing up with why is 1+1=2. The answer is given so shouldn't we move onto other math equations just as gravity needs to be explored more then just asking the same why question in different context. :)
@atomicsmith
@atomicsmith 4 года назад
Science has painted itself into several corners. This is why the number of breakthroughs and discoveries has slowed to a trickle. Gravity is very important to one of them: Dark Matter. 25 years of searching for the stuff and not even a whiff to show for it. Cosmologists are getting very defensive that their knowledge of gravity is complete and perfect. If they admitted that their knowledge is incomplete, the funding might dry up...
@lightwork68
@lightwork68 4 года назад
Because at the end of the day faith triumphs doubt
@TrainerCTZ
@TrainerCTZ 4 года назад
Very odd. Plus how he responded re Tesla.
@meowster101
@meowster101 4 года назад
I think what he was trying to say is that even though there's no scientific explanation for why the laws of physics seem to be so arbitrary, you don't necessarily have to know the why in order to understand the other things that depend on them. Kind of like back before people could go around the world to prove that it's round, the ancient Greeks could still calculate the circumference of the earth using just the sun and trigonometry. It's just the way he said it made him seem like a dick for no reason
@mikebruce4332
@mikebruce4332 4 года назад
Joe: but isn’t it still curious? Tyson: Well you’ve got a bald head. 4:59
@bornfourthis635
@bornfourthis635 4 года назад
Hahaha you got a bald head
@NoWorldOrd3r
@NoWorldOrd3r 4 года назад
he says 'yaaaa'
@scootaymildo1070
@scootaymildo1070 4 года назад
Was a weird analogy! Seemed like a cheap dig 😂😂
@Xxd_unit_007xX
@Xxd_unit_007xX 4 года назад
@@scootaymildo1070 i thought the randomness was the point. you can ask why forever about gravity, or balding.
@princehabeeboo1728
@princehabeeboo1728 4 года назад
This why we needed Eddie on so he could of quickly said... oh I get it so gravity is like fatness the more you eat your belly starts to curve like the Earth... allegedly 😉 Ndt-😠😵
@sullymusic4186
@sullymusic4186 Год назад
I feel like finding out what property of matter causes it to bend space is a good direction to head in order to find the unifying theory between relativity and quantum mechanics. And may lead to discoveries we didn’t know we were looking for. And Joe Rogan, despite my recent disagreements with him, is a genius at intern.
@joshuatree6189
@joshuatree6189 9 месяцев назад
JR is a good comedian.
@Tao-hb5wc
@Tao-hb5wc 4 года назад
Don’t ever stop asking why.
@janus3555
@janus3555 4 года назад
NDT is basically describing religion and in essence, it makes science -- at least in this example -- a religion upon itself.
@jamesthen1nja
@jamesthen1nja 4 года назад
Why?
@JonnyUnderrated
@JonnyUnderrated 4 года назад
@@jamesthen1nja cause he said.
@jamesthen1nja
@jamesthen1nja 4 года назад
@@JonnyUnderrated why?
@sahirdiesh6386
@sahirdiesh6386 4 года назад
@hahagotcha!!!! Thats true .if you keep asking why then eventually you will reach a point where no one is going to be able to answer your questions
@LegacyProduction2013
@LegacyProduction2013 4 года назад
My boy Eddie going to have a field day with this..
@EddyA1337
@EddyA1337 4 года назад
My name is Eddy I'm ready
@joshn1678
@joshn1678 4 года назад
@VFT - WHAT?? That's because Eddie is a moron who doesn't care if he can prove his own beliefs.
@AdrianVanOyan
@AdrianVanOyan 3 года назад
I think neil really changed how a lot of people view him lately with just a few podcast you could really see a bad side of him that I personally didn't see before.
@ALEXANDERATTACK
@ALEXANDERATTACK 3 года назад
Maybe all the positive attention he got made him arrogant, I’m glad we got some more perspective. Same thing happened to me with the Kanye podcast.
@S4murai2077
@S4murai2077 3 года назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-FEzPfN9B_QM.html Just check this out and maybe that's why Neil acted like that
@PrinceIsot
@PrinceIsot 3 года назад
@@ALEXANDERATTACK he wasn't getting defensive though. You people don't understand the answer "we don't know why" if it isn't framed that way. 🤦🏻‍♂️ Which he also said we don't know why. Everyone is so defensive when they aren't as smart as they thought
@lucasgibbs5459
@lucasgibbs5459 2 года назад
You got to see his real side. You can't escape from Rogan. That's why it's so good.
@lwwarren9485
@lwwarren9485 3 года назад
This is a guy who has been asked “why?” Waaaaayyyyy to many times!😂😂😂
@infoharvester
@infoharvester 3 года назад
"too"
@ringsofbravo
@ringsofbravo 4 года назад
Spooky action at a distance was what Einstein said about quantum entanglement. Not what newton said about gravity
@phenomstef
@phenomstef 4 года назад
exactly
@REGAC83ONE
@REGAC83ONE 4 года назад
I posted same shit! Wtf
@ios7hacker704
@ios7hacker704 4 года назад
Johnathon Washburn he actually explains this in one of his books that wasn’t his point
@all_angles8528
@all_angles8528 4 года назад
Johnathan Washburn.. Thank You .... exactly what I thought
@deandalton8482
@deandalton8482 4 года назад
was just about to post the same comment
@aj5878
@aj5878 4 года назад
Props for joe for keeping his cool throughout this whole thing 😂😂
@mosescampos4102
@mosescampos4102 4 года назад
His stomach is rumbling must be hangry you should have fed him first joe so his not so defensive. Choke him out joe.
@recipoldinasty
@recipoldinasty 4 года назад
Mike B yeah and get sued badly... it aint relevant
@eanayac
@eanayac 4 года назад
Yeah, props for Joe! Tyson is annoying af!
@drealboy_
@drealboy_ 4 года назад
@Cinozzz NDT brings much more to life than stoned joe Rogan Rogan is a peasant in the presence of NDT Joe knows his place.
@BluntBrazenCurt_Evolved
@BluntBrazenCurt_Evolved 4 года назад
. Na just a dummy asking questions and the teacher getting the same question over and over. Props to Neil if anybody foh
@MylesKillis
@MylesKillis 3 года назад
I'm actually glad I came across this. Cause i am always asking why why why.
@syashadeed7552
@syashadeed7552 3 года назад
So basically Gravity is still a theory and can't be proven. Thanks Neil.
@connorsmith6517
@connorsmith6517 Год назад
Gravity is real, we can measure it. We experience it, we can see it happen. Why it happens is unknown, but gravity is a very real tangible thing. The way you phrased this makes it seem like you don’t believe in gravity, is that what you are implying?
@stephenshowell
@stephenshowell Год назад
“Theory” does not mean “guess” bub
@thehurricane6767
@thehurricane6767 Год назад
You sound ignorant
@I_AmBoom
@I_AmBoom 4 года назад
Neil's energy this entire podcast was weirdly uncomfortable to watch. Noticeably different from what we've seen of him over the years. Joe felt it, handled it well
@1steyevision
@1steyevision 4 года назад
I think he was nervous because he was wondering the whole time if Joe was going to bring up anything about the sexual harassment incident that happened.
@Charmer4856
@Charmer4856 4 года назад
He's edgy is this one for sure. Maybe he was on coke or needed to be laid
@ytglobersanglobersan5842
@ytglobersanglobersan5842 4 года назад
Neil: Why did you go bald? This is the last time we will see him in JRE
@Corntron5000
@Corntron5000 4 года назад
YTglobersan Globersan hope not, idk why joe has to choose to oppose guests sometimes. Once he’s decided nothing can change his mind. Why argue with a specialist ya know? Generally joe asks questions and enjoys learning but he isn’t that open minded when it comes to science.
@NomadicEmcee
@NomadicEmcee 4 года назад
@@Corntron5000 Because that's what you're SUPPOSED to do. Ask questions in order to understand better.
@hellotheir1427
@hellotheir1427 4 года назад
NomadicEmcee explaining gravity to a non physicians isn't easy. Its like a doctor telling a patient how cells work snd disease. It will take to long,
@ninpeg4441
@ninpeg4441 4 года назад
@@hellotheir1427 If you cant explain the basics of gravity to someone then you dont understand it. Thats why questions get asked. You explain the basics and if they want to know more they will prompt you to go more in depth by asking questions. Gravity is a force that pulls all bodies with mass together. Boom, gravity explained. It is explained at a basic level but if they want to know more they prompt with questions
@hellotheir1427
@hellotheir1427 4 года назад
Ninpeg This podcast isn't an education video. Neil didn't get invited by Joe so he can get explained in detail about the laws of physics. He got invited to advertise his book and have a high-level conversation about physics.
@smallbluemachine
@smallbluemachine 3 года назад
I always thought if Degrasse tackled gravity, it would be his downfall.
@thekingofsmooth
@thekingofsmooth 3 года назад
this man didn't let Joe finish one sentence
@jimallen1303
@jimallen1303 4 года назад
Newton didn't say "spooky action at a distance" , Einstein said it refering to Quantum entanglement.
@marccas10
@marccas10 4 года назад
Maybe drunk?
@wingsuiter2392
@wingsuiter2392 4 года назад
NdT has said a few scientific things that were actually terrifically inaccurate during his career, and you are correct about what Einstein said about Quantum Entanglement. Newton did refer to gravity as an "action (a force) at a distance" and it is quite a curious force because we don't know how it works fundamentally despite being able to predict how it will affect bodies in our Universe. I think we can give him a pass on this one because he might have been drinking or smoking with Joe prior to the broadcast...
@PaulMiil
@PaulMiil 4 года назад
Totally.
@chhimi4025
@chhimi4025 4 года назад
Newtob said " action at a distance" and that's what neil said when he was referring to gravity listen closely ppl he didn't say "spooky action at a distance"
@PaulMiil
@PaulMiil 4 года назад
@@chhimi4025 2:06 NDT does say Newton said "spooky action at a distance, fast forward 300 years to Einstein..."
@Psyche-ud2mn
@Psyche-ud2mn 4 года назад
"How dare this bald MMA nut outsmart me? im Neal Degrasse Tyson"
@_Nosferatu_
@_Nosferatu_ 4 года назад
I think when Joe kept asking why, that's a very common question religitards ask when they are trying to say that behind it all stands God. It's an argument they always use, and from videos I've seen of Neil they've asked him that countless times, and I'm sure in his personal life people have asked him a lot too. All I'm trying to say is that that question gets annoying after a while, I'm annoyed of it of just seeing Neil deal with it countless times in videos. I'm guessing he's probably heard it most of his life so I totally understand why he lost his cool a little bit, I knew the reason right away. Also he didn't know Joe's agenda, he thought he was religious, but when Joe told Neil that he isn't, and the purpose of Joe's question wasn't coming from there at all, Neil backed off as you can see in the video.
@1Peasant
@1Peasant 4 года назад
You thinking that the amount of times someone comments something is proof of anything is proof that you're a fucking brain-dead.
@bakarenibsheut12
@bakarenibsheut12 4 года назад
@@1Peasant Honestly, it is a little pathetic to keep copy-pasting the same comment everywhere. However, the point the comment makes is quite good. The reason most religious people ask "Why" is to smuggle God into the scientific explanatory regress. It's taking advantage of the fact that all science is based on assumptions, and there is always a deeper "why" behind those assumptions, so no matter how much science progresses and explains why stuff happens, God will be the why behind that why. It's a disgusting trick.
@bakarenibsheut12
@bakarenibsheut12 4 года назад
@@johnnyk5385 If that's true, then the fact that the KKK exists is proof all Protestants are murderers and rapists. Congratulations.
@johnnyk5385
@johnnyk5385 4 года назад
@@bakarenibsheut12 Shut up yoy utter and complete moron.
@ChristelVinot
@ChristelVinot 3 года назад
omg neil at the end lol dang
@lurefishingexperience5064
@lurefishingexperience5064 Год назад
" ok we can say you have a bald head why did you go bald ?" 😆 🤣 😂
@ItsTMY
@ItsTMY 4 года назад
Why is NDT acting like he's never been on this Joe Rogan podcast before
@skama2010
@skama2010 4 года назад
Hes a smug prick. He prejudges joe as a mediocre mind and treats him accordingly.
@jessegonzalez7035
@jessegonzalez7035 4 года назад
hit jtowers he’s a clone
@TheThunderSound
@TheThunderSound 4 года назад
Too much coke
@gsciglia1
@gsciglia1 4 года назад
Thank u.... I was thinking the same exact thing.. at least from this clip.
@Jonalexher
@Jonalexher 4 года назад
seriously man, that was very odd, like dude you've been on JRE like 3 times already, why are you asking what the format of the podcast is like? very very odd, made me lose the respect I thought I had for him.
@bereckdavid4810
@bereckdavid4810 4 года назад
My god Niel seems offended. He's attacking Joe's baldness. That was hysterical.
@BrianPaul1984
@BrianPaul1984 3 года назад
It's just that Niel's attitude about "why" questions has been jaded over time by religious nut jobs that usually end up invoking the a "god of the gaps" argument every time a science discussion moves to the frontiers of current understanding. He explained this. Quite frankly, if I was him and that is what was really happening, I would have been getting frustrated as well with that kind of William Lane Craig bullshit.
@yarnosh
@yarnosh 3 года назад
​@@BrianPaul1984 Yup, this is why scientists just have to disengage from religious nut jobs, flat earthers, and the like. Ignore them. Engaging them as a credible scientist just lends them an air of credibility. It's just not healthy for people who really understand the science. It's a waste of their intellect. Leave the Flat Earthers and creationists to us semi-educated grunts on RU-vid comments and Reddit where we can just have fun with them and walk away when we get bored. I actually learn things engaging these people. It forces me to look up and refresh on topics I would otherwise just forget from school.
@TwinTurboZach
@TwinTurboZach 3 года назад
Thats not what offended is.
@bereckdavid4810
@bereckdavid4810 3 года назад
I hate to reply to this stuff. But this will be fun. Science is a whore.
@nellatl
@nellatl 3 года назад
@@yarnosh you idiots separate science from religion as if there isn't religious scientists.
@alexojideagu
@alexojideagu Год назад
This is even a bigger issue in Quantum Mechanics. We literally have no real clue why it is the way it is, and most scientists don't bother and just claim it's a philosophical question. "Shut up and calculate". Although some like Sean Caroll aren't happy just accepting it.
@nate456
@nate456 Год назад
gravity doesnt even have little tiny losses
@tashitenzin5718
@tashitenzin5718 3 года назад
Give him some DMT Joe... Let's get his perspective after the trip
@robwright1286
@robwright1286 3 года назад
The fuck is the JRE following just a DMT cult now lol. *it's time, he's ready for the vision* 😂
@mattasticmattattack8546
@mattasticmattattack8546 3 года назад
Tyson might just tell us everything about everything ever. Whooaaaaaa
@ozzynomicon2817
@ozzynomicon2817 3 года назад
Neil would then be woke. He would evolve past humanity
@g_gaming2893
@g_gaming2893 3 года назад
Bruh Neil would be so humble and confused I’d love it. He’s probably just get done and looks at Joe and be like “That’s pretty cool” and just move on😂
@CanuckMonkey
@CanuckMonkey 3 года назад
@@IllyrianStrength Nice one!
@OMWTFYB
@OMWTFYB 4 года назад
Neil trying to explain gravity to Joe is like Joe trying to explain to Eddie why the earth is round
@gial8862
@gial8862 4 года назад
Down The Rabbit Hole , Yea, after this podcast I am starting to think this whole gravity theory is wrong. Maybe its just density....
@everfragoso6313
@everfragoso6313 4 года назад
One hell of a comment sir 10 out of 10
@doc-holliday-
@doc-holliday- 4 года назад
@@gial8862 Or maybe you don't know wtf you're talking about and you never finished high school. That seems far more likely.
@FrankValchiria
@FrankValchiria 4 года назад
i actually really enjoyed the banter and super insightful
@thomastobin8529
@thomastobin8529 4 года назад
But he didnt explain what gravity is i think joe braught this up because in a way gravity enforces life
@Take_Them_Sticks
@Take_Them_Sticks Год назад
“Good good “ 😭😭😭
@infiniteskies22
@infiniteskies22 3 года назад
“why did you bang the table?” well because it was lookin mighty fine that’s why
@jawadkhanniazi2802
@jawadkhanniazi2802 4 года назад
Props to Joe for maneuvering through this extremely patronizing attitude. Joe is a very smart guy.
@steph1804
@steph1804 4 года назад
He did a magnificent job.
@ztwntyn8
@ztwntyn8 4 года назад
I concur
@luissantiago874
@luissantiago874 4 года назад
Joe is like a child.No respect for neil.And when neil respond he mocks him with ta ta ta and raises eyebrows.But i guess since joe spoke to other astropysicist he is smarter then neil.smh
@philliph8991
@philliph8991 4 года назад
@@luissantiago874 no, joe is a guy thats not intimidated. He was a fighter for a living. Titles, acclimations, dont matter. In the end, he knows he could probably beat ur ass. Working in tandem with that, hes a fairly intelligent person. I love NGT, but Joe had the right of it. And hes not afraid to express it.
@KingsCountyLightHaus
@KingsCountyLightHaus 4 года назад
Joe's great, but he's a borderline sped.
@CurtPryme93
@CurtPryme93 4 года назад
Joe didn’t even ask why . He said “We don’t really know what gravity is.”
@owl4446
@owl4446 4 года назад
Nobody is picking up on this. Neil started with "why" Just to build a foundation for his ranty behavior and ended it with blaming Joe for wanting a purpose to life? cmon now
@_Nosferatu_
@_Nosferatu_ 4 года назад
@@owl4446 When Joe kept asking why, that's a very common question religitards ask when they are trying to say that behind it all stands God. It's an argument they always use, and from videos I've seen of Neil they've asked him that countless times, and I'm sure in his personal life people have asked him a lot too. All I'm trying to say is that that question gets annoying after a while, I'm annoyed of it of just seeing Neil deal with it countless times in videos. I'm guessing he's probably heard it most of his life so I totally understand why he lost his cool a little bit, I knew the reason right away. Also he didn't know Joe's agenda, he thought he was religious, but when Joe told Neil that he isn't, and the purpose of Joe's question wasn't coming from there at all, Neil backed off as you can see in the video.
@hasoonnine
@hasoonnine 4 года назад
@@_Nosferatu_ nice copy and paste dude
@goodheavens5440
@goodheavens5440 3 года назад
This is like a child questioning his parents about how Santa Claus can fit down their chimney.
@soroush9142
@soroush9142 3 года назад
When teacher asks you a question which you don't know the answer but you start talking about all the other parts of the lesson.
@mocktubelol3355
@mocktubelol3355 4 года назад
I'm glad Joe kept pushing. As Penn Jillet podcast recently pointed out, if you are intelligent enough, you can argue any point. But it doesn't mean you are right. I definitely know Neil is intelligent. But he doesn't want to go deep into certain questions and is very good at changing topics whilst not looking like he is. Neil kept going to philopsical purpose whereas Joe just wanted the science but he couldn't go that deep into it because science is based on results and not necessarily understanding to the point degree of Joe's essential point of question.
@silver933
@silver933 4 года назад
MockTubeLOL Because Neil doesn’t have an answer so he just twisted some words. He’s too proud to say he just doesn’t know
@methdxman
@methdxman 4 года назад
I'm with Neil on this one. Joe's questioning was going down the path of meaning and purpose. Joe was lazy with his words. And Neil had an excellent point that your WHY questions can get reduced down to very fundamental components where the WHY questions are meaningless. Joe could not follow this line of thinking/logic at all.
@FenixDown147
@FenixDown147 4 года назад
@@methdxman Joe's question was "What gives Matter Mass?" Tyson heard "Why does mass bend space?" Same diff, Tyson got flustered
@FenixDown147
@FenixDown147 4 года назад
If you cant explain something in less 1 or 2 sentences, then you don't understand it well enough to teach it.
@jaymiddleton1782
@jaymiddleton1782 4 года назад
FenixDown147 the saying is “if you can’t explain it, you can’t teach it.” There’s no sentence limit on that saying. Also, that’s all it is - a saying. It’s not a truism.
@newton4098
@newton4098 4 года назад
NDT got so mad he started attacking Joe about his hair.
@Vic2point0
@Vic2point0 4 года назад
Lol, I couldn't get past that interpretation either.
@TheAstraeuss
@TheAstraeuss 4 года назад
He was mad? I heard a lot of laughing....Maybe you want him to be angry?
@Vic2point0
@Vic2point0 4 года назад
@@TheAstraeuss He was noticeably irritated. Even Joe said he was being defensive.
@TheAstraeuss
@TheAstraeuss 4 года назад
@@Vic2point0 I didn't see it that way. Neil is a passionate guy and his enthusiasm can sometimes come across as anger if you're not familiar with Neil's style of communication. Lol Joe is a moron.
@Vic2point0
@Vic2point0 4 года назад
@@TheAstraeuss Except that Neil has been on his show before and it looked very different. Joe even specified exactly what seemed to be the catalyst for Neil's defensiveness this time around.
@husamwadi2635
@husamwadi2635 2 года назад
Looks like Firas's Gravity Gremlins coming in handy here.
@msabccbscnnoanfoxnews
@msabccbscnnoanfoxnews 3 года назад
Gravity is tied to time. The higher up you go from the center of the Earth the faster time moves. So when you have an object on earth or an object like Earth, the time moves quicker towards the top of the object and slower towards the bottom thus pushing the object down
@nameme5280
@nameme5280 4 года назад
He got pissed for some reason...he called Joe bald, middle aged and fat...all that was missing was a yo Momma joke
@CobDaGOAT
@CobDaGOAT 4 года назад
Doesn’t like that he doesn’t know the answer
@dylanlol3501
@dylanlol3501 4 года назад
This whole conversation was strange. Neil is losing credibility in my book. I saw a clip of him comparing rock climbing on a mountain abroad to scaling important man made buildings. Explaining how some regions people don’t like westerners rock climbing on their sacred mountains. He went on to say something like that.. “how would a westerner feel about someone repelling down (whatever building of importance he suggested)” I can’t remember exactly which buildings he listed but the argument is absolute horse shit. Comparing an actual mountain that is formed in nature to a man made building in a heavily populated area is just ridiculous
@electrojay2540
@electrojay2540 4 года назад
@@dylanlol3501 lol ppl can be wrong why does that tiny arguement affect his credibility
@brucanthwood
@brucanthwood 4 года назад
@zwiebelblumen whoa easy on the fascism there... dudes just a little excited.
@yurandeveloper6958
@yurandeveloper6958 4 года назад
😂😂😂
@nemdenemam9753
@nemdenemam9753 4 года назад
Joe: What is gravity? Tyson: Why are you pestering me with purpose?
@billmoyer3254
@billmoyer3254 4 года назад
Tyson has no clue
@madlarkin8
@madlarkin8 4 года назад
@@billmoyer3254 uhhh what? I think he pretty clearly explained a firm understanding of it.
@madlarkin8
@madlarkin8 4 года назад
@@nonenone5326 what is conservative about it? I genuinely wonder if we watched the same video. He says he has no clue, but Neil Degrasse Tyson has studied gravity in every conceivable way our technology allows and admits that any new knowledge is "the frontier" how can you say he doesnt know anything? I think tyson got defensive because every day on twitter he has to defend basic scientific knowledge to retards who say "but what is the purpose of gravity" or "but why is it doing that" as if that invalidates hundreds of years of compiled research. As if the scientists dont ask those exact questions to themselves all the time, but instead of wasting time looking for a moral purpose to the universe they devote their lives to quantifying the underlying mechanisms.
@twoOfThemThangs
@twoOfThemThangs 4 года назад
No, he asked why is gravity Tyson could not answer that, he just kept talking in circles
@madlarkin8
@madlarkin8 4 года назад
@@twoOfThemThangs he didnt talk in circles, he explained why it is a logical dead end to ask "why" a fundamental force of the universe exists. The questions of "why" any fundamental force exists or "why" life exists is not a question that science is even attempting to explain. He VERY clearly explained that science is only to and CAN ONLY explain the HOW as our technology and understanding deepens. Asking "why" something exists is a philosophical question that cannot be proven or disproven with logic or the scientific method. He isnt saying "i dont know" because again.... he is clearly saying "i dont care"
@nicksewell6642
@nicksewell6642 3 года назад
This is me arguing with fractions.
@Day_Chap
@Day_Chap Год назад
TLDR: We don't know why Gravity exists, but we know how to work with it
@hercules911
@hercules911 4 года назад
Joe: “Why does gravity exist?” Neil: *WHY ARE YOU BALD*
@Sondaze
@Sondaze 4 года назад
Sounds like he just doesn’t want to say the simple phrase “I don’t know.”
@SurfMastery-kz6je
@SurfMastery-kz6je 4 года назад
Well he does say theres a point where he stops being able to answer "why".
@browndoc
@browndoc 4 года назад
I think there’s a difference between being passionate about the subject matter and anger. “Why” questions do propose a purpose usually , and for all physicists they are annoying because it does have a diminishing demeanor towards the hundreds of years of hard work by these guys to understand it. It’s like asking”why is there light ?”. It’s a stupid question and is more suited to a religious mentality that panders to the perceived thoughts and actions of imaginary deities . I like Joe but if he actually went and did a PHD in astrophysics he would most definitely not ask the why question unless he was a bible basher .
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
Neil is always willing to say he doesnt know. But he just didnt want to be embarassed that Joe was right.
@ramoncruz1007
@ramoncruz1007 4 года назад
Peter Browne lol peter, the majority of science is driven by why questions broken down into what or how questions. The only reason anyone would have a disdain for why questions is because they assume that why questions require purpose alone. Yet they don’t see that all what and how questions require looking at the physical world with purpose. So to ask questions like “why is their light” might seem like a question about philosophy, but one could also see it as trying to ask bigger questions about the fundamental nature of the world. Maybe the why within the system can help us understand more about the nature of particles. Also, religious individuals can still answer what or how questions with God, so I think the whole split between what how and why questions in order to avoid philosophically religious thought is nonsense.
@amoonra8385
@amoonra8385 4 года назад
Neil full of bullshit
@UFOUAPMagnet
@UFOUAPMagnet 3 года назад
"Spooky action at a distance," actually refers to the phenomenon known as Quantum entanglement, observed by Einstein. Newton never said that.
@angelalgarin1918
@angelalgarin1918 Год назад
Honestly seeing this video multiple times now, I can understand the frustration of Neil as well of Joe. Neil is saying that there’s pretty much a point where there’s literally no point in trying to keep figuring out the why is works because it could be way far from our knowledge but still making sense that for right now there’s no point in keep trying to understand more of it if we have understood it enough to know how to use it and how it works. I side 50% with Neil there. Now my other 50% is with Joe in the sense that I really believe that for us to ever even reach such fantasies(right now) of traveling at the speed of light and travel planets and galaxies at an extreme velocity(safely) we MUST keep asking how and why gravity is what it is. Maybe also the path into understanding dark matter more as well. I’m no physicist so obviously no expert in the matter but both make sense to me. If science has reached a certain place where we can’t understand more about gravity then I guess it’s just a waiting game on the spawn of a brain in which can further understand and reach new knowledge of the universe.
@AnwarAliyambath
@AnwarAliyambath 9 месяцев назад
No such thing as gravity
@dominicsinableng349
@dominicsinableng349 4 года назад
he got him. he got him good. “you’re being oddly defensive.”
@mgilbert9004
@mgilbert9004 4 года назад
Neil: well its been a long day............... Baldie.
@charlesverg2184
@charlesverg2184 4 года назад
hE gOT hiM. hE gOt hIm gOoD. Stfu idiot 😂
@jazzjames
@jazzjames 4 года назад
I don’t see defensive...I see frustration of trying to explain physics without a chalkboard to someone who wouldn’t understand the math in the first place. Why? Because Jesus. Move on? 😂
@johnnyk5385
@johnnyk5385 4 года назад
@@charlesverg2184 Distorted Caps= No credibility.
@_Nosferatu_
@_Nosferatu_ 4 года назад
When Joe kept asking why, that's a very common question religitards ask when they are trying to say that behind it all stands God. It's an argument they always use, and from videos I've seen of Neil they've asked him that countless times, and I'm sure in his personal life people have asked him a lot too. All I'm trying to say is that that question gets annoying after a while, I'm annoyed of it of just seeing Neil deal with it countless times in videos. I'm guessing he's probably heard it most of his life so I totally understand why he lost his cool a little bit, I knew the reason right away. Also he didn't know Joe's agenda, he thought he was religious, but when Joe told Neil that he isn't, and the purpose of Joe's question wasn't coming from there at all, Neil backed off as you can see in the video.
@EzziiG
@EzziiG 4 года назад
Neil deGrasse Tyson says allot without saying much at all
@jamkerblam4348
@jamkerblam4348 4 года назад
Sneintzville yep
@jackpen5341
@jackpen5341 4 года назад
Maybe he should be a politician, that's 99% of the job.
@tinomts
@tinomts 4 года назад
Pseudo-scientist
@jackpen5341
@jackpen5341 4 года назад
@@tinomts Ehhh, quite the stretch.
@tinomts
@tinomts 4 года назад
@@jackpen5341 The guy literally attacked Joe verbally for asking a question he couldn't answer. Hardly a beacon of intellect
@kumbi6896
@kumbi6896 3 года назад
“Matter tells space how to curve , space tells matter how to move.”
@1391Pancho
@1391Pancho 3 года назад
This is why I love Brian Cox. He's awesome at explaining stuff and conveying stuff.
@jonnyhawt8973
@jonnyhawt8973 2 года назад
He's a better Sci Fi Religious High Priest than NDT. I enjoy his pseudoscience wizardry much better.
@brettpace3883
@brettpace3883 Год назад
Brian Cox is a useful idiot. Nothing more.
@AnwarAliyambath
@AnwarAliyambath Год назад
Hahahah
@BabylonGateLA
@BabylonGateLA Год назад
@@jonnyhawt8973 Okay little John
@jonnyhawt8973
@jonnyhawt8973 Год назад
@@BabylonGateLA 🤣🐑
@jimbojones091
@jimbojones091 4 года назад
At least joe has the spine to call out NDT. Most people would’ve just caved because “big brain man says no more questions”.
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
Joe wouldnt dare call someone out whose an expert of their field, unless Joe wad absolutely sure he knew what he was talking about. Luckily he did.
@PATTHECATMCD
@PATTHECATMCD 4 года назад
"Why? Because it IS..." Which just goes to show how teachers are scared to admit "We don't know". But they'll give students hell over using that exact same response, "Because it IS".
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
@@PATTHECATMCD I thought it was funny at the end when Joe, asked him for the last time "Do we know what gravity is?", and instead, Neil says, "No, were working on it." If he just said that earlier, it wouldve been over right there.
@revorebelwealth2588
@revorebelwealth2588 4 года назад
Haha LMFAO poeple stoopid FR FR!!!
@soldatheero
@soldatheero 4 года назад
true that
@Troyster94806
@Troyster94806 4 года назад
I believe it was Albert Einstein who said spooky action at a distance, and when he said it he wasn't talking about gravity. He was talking about quantum entanglement.
@jefferee2002
@jefferee2002 4 года назад
I concur. And the fact that Neil, an astro physicist, botched that fact goes to show how irrational he was in attempting to answer the question at hand, or defend his non-answer.
@Troyster94806
@Troyster94806 4 года назад
@@jefferee2002 His reaction did seem rather peculiar. He gave his reason for the defensive behavior, but I'm not sure I bought it.
@EM-ez1td
@EM-ez1td 4 года назад
jefferee2002 Neil being a fraud is my belief
@TalkingToLeedskalnin
@TalkingToLeedskalnin 4 года назад
You are exactly correct. Btw, watching Joe kind of manipulate NDT into a temper tantrum certainly seemed to qualify as spooky action at a distance to me
@Theelectroarcheologist
@Theelectroarcheologist 4 года назад
That's what was thinking
@Chishi420
@Chishi420 Год назад
Joe should have his own late night show
@yz4043
@yz4043 2 года назад
I so thought he was gonna say "why does matter, matter?" Lmfao
@sniffableandirresistble
@sniffableandirresistble 4 года назад
5:42 "we know more about why people go bald than we do about what gravity really is" the most intriguing and interesting assertion I've ever heard Rogan make on behalf of us all
@glennbarrera8353
@glennbarrera8353 4 года назад
But he is wrong. It is the opposite of what he said
@trinitygodsaint
@trinitygodsaint 4 года назад
@@glennbarrera8353 Wrong
@paulohyp
@paulohyp 4 года назад
Man! I thought the same thing! Best reply rogan made to an extrem intelligent guest ever.
@faded9043
@faded9043 4 года назад
That's because gravity doesn't exist
@spergmamale6737
@spergmamale6737 4 года назад
Tom H Baited
@jjohnson218
@jjohnson218 4 года назад
Joe had Neil up against the ropes. The gravity mystery was about tko Neil into retirement
@jedimojojojo1603
@jedimojojojo1603 4 года назад
Lol haha
@justinzaff
@justinzaff 4 года назад
That has to be a joke , you couldn't possibly be serious .
@ANGRYGREEKMANYO
@ANGRYGREEKMANYO 4 года назад
Not really you just hate Neil cuz ure a racist dumb nobody lolll
@JACpotatos
@JACpotatos 4 года назад
@Mike SKARONIS are you NDT in disguise? You literally used a four word response to call someone stupid. Dude made a good point seeing as I could've given a better explanation for gravity, in a tenth of the time.
@missionpupa
@missionpupa 4 года назад
Joe was being reasonable. Neil got angry. Angry people lose the arguments, because its a fight or flight thing. Neil was on autopilot.
@mortenpaskins6073
@mortenpaskins6073 3 года назад
This guy is smart. He should become a world famous astrophysicist
@RockHudrock
@RockHudrock Год назад
Not quite as smart as he thinks he is, however.
@alekseyzadorkin9600
@alekseyzadorkin9600 3 года назад
Brian Greene: i dont know. Brian Cox: we dont know. Neil deGrasse: hair
Далее
Isaac Newton Was Insane | Joe Rogan
6:13
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Yes or No Fruit Shake for My Son #cooking #shorts
00:41
СТРИМ-МАФИЯ С ДРУЗЬЯМИ
4:09:21
Просмотров 988 тыс.
Neil deGrasse Tyson Explains Time Dilation
10:41
Просмотров 2,5 млн
Joe Rogan - Neil deGrasse Tyson on Space Force
18:38
Просмотров 3,3 млн
Physicist Brian Greene Explains Black Holes
12:05
Просмотров 2,8 млн
The Universe and Beyond, with Stephen Hawking
47:00
Просмотров 2,7 млн