Karachi, Al-Qaida & Terrorism FT. Ali K. Chishti | Podcast #25 

99.99% of Pakistani has always own version history.but this guy looks knowledgeable , acknowledging truth make u perfect as a nation,

hey brother , as an indian i can say most of the talks ur guest has said is true about india , it is hard to find these speakers in pakistan , 2008 -26/11 was watershed moment , if it happened today , modi would have retaliate without thinking , modi is good for us , he is honest , and country believes in him that he can take country where it was before british came , u may say he is little right wing but he is not extremist , he got majority in UP largest muslim state in india with more than 60 percent vote share , talking about pakistan , modi took a risk of his carrier by visiting pakistan in 2015 but know he feels that their is power vaccum in pakistan and most of indians feels that pakistan govt is controlled by army so their is no one credble to start dialogue with , and as ur govt stopped trade with us on kashmir isssue i dont know was helped by that ban , so pakistan is just completely isolated in higher powers because people feels that whenever we have normal relations some attack occur in INDIA ,

Best podcast, didn't know about Ali Chishti before. He seems like a nice and informative guy, we need more podcasts with him.

Seeing Ali Chishti after a long time. He's as crisp and candid and very bold. Obviously, you would need 3-4 podcasts with him as he's one of the best resource and go-to with international exposure to talk on the subject but very well done, Daniyal.

I am from India and I am impressed with the way @Daniyal Sheikh handles his podcast. Ali Chishti is a very knowledgeable and learned person.

Amazing how Danial wanted to argue and disagree but was completely left speechless because he was presented with facts and logic. Ali Chisti is an extremely well read and well informed guy. Neeed more podcasts with him

Great podcast. Saw Ali Shb after a long time. He's very knowledgable!

Very informative podcast by Ali Chishti. He's a gem of a person in person too. He stated the fact and full marks to Daniyal to bring him as we know he had not being coming or giving interviews. Thanks a lot for this podcast

Brilliant and to the core by Ali Chishti. Few has the grasp on such topics and the bravely to say it is. Well done, Daniyal.

Excellent podcast. Really liked Ali Chisti's take and in a way admiration towards Modi and the hard line foreign policy. No hypocrisy there. Not blinded by patriotism and jingoism - very objective and straight forward. Not easy to acknowledge. God bless!

Excellent podcast. Engrossing and Educative. Few quick points. No mention of Hindus of Karachi. Their contribution to Karach and post partition their migration to India and today, Sindhis are very successful businessmen in India. Unlike Mohajir, Sindhis never faced any linguistic or erhnic discrimination in India. Parsi contribution to India is enormous, Field Marshal Manekshaw, Cricketiar Farooq Engineer, Industralist Godrej and many more. Its great tribute to Hindu culture that nobody Jews, Parsis or Ahmedias ever persecuted in India. Even Bohri community never ever faced any negative fallout because of Qaide Azam M A Jinnah role in creation of Pakistan. Problem is deep rooted Hindu hatred that Mr.Ali Chishti has not a word of praise for them.

Excellent podcast. Ali Chishti Shb has a treasure of knowledge and I understand reading some comments about the heat Ali Chishti has faced, its obvious. Daniyal keep doing the good work and looking forward for part 2 of Ali Shb.

Wow Daniyal, great job, for the first time me and my whole family are watching a podcast together.

There are lakhs of Hindu Sindhis who have settled in and around Mumbai..they all are part of our city, state and country...they never felt discriminated ..they are very good at business..they flourished after migration.. unfortunately that didn't happen to Muslims who migrated to Pakistan...they are still called as Mohajirs..and face discrimination

ab tak tak best podcast.. very informative and to the point.. hatsoff

One of the best podacast ever, is se pehle yeh batien kbhi zindagi me na suni na pata krne ki koshish ki, srf suni sunaen baatien sun kr bethe rahe itni knowledge is se pehle kahi se ese interesting tareeqey se nhi milinThankyou Daniyal bhai for this❤❤

I am from India,and I watched many videos,you are very good human being because you say all truth without any discrimination IND and Pak,love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️

Bhai sahab 92 blast, kandhar hijack, 99 kargil, 2001 parliament attack, 26/11. Kitane chot mile hai hamane. Hamare leaders ne hamesha hath badhaya hai tumane pith pe chhura gopa hai.

Don’t know why Ali blames Modi for offensive strategy of India. Indians wanted to give a tough time to Pakistan as response to any attack from their end. He is doing what Indians asked for. We will not take any attack lightly. Since Modi is in power, no serious terror attack has taken place as it used to be under Congress rule. Indian Economy is reaching a point of almost double of what it use to be since he took charge. For Kaushik’s life story as RAW Operative in Pakistan, I recommend John Abraham’s movie ‘Romeo Akbar Walter’.

One of the best Podcast I have ever seen in my life. You nailed it broski 🥊💯

No need of daniyal presence in this conversation, this man is enough by himself totally... Wisdom speaks loudly!

Yaar what a powerful and informative podcast Daniyal. I didnt know Ali bhai before this podcast but now i have become a fan of his knowledge. Thank you for having him. Keep it up 👍

Great Podcast by Daniyal and Ali Chishti whom I had followed for 14 years. He's an excellent human and an extra ordinary author and analyst.

One of your best podcast...❤❤

Hey, good to see Ali K. Chisti. He is someone among some of the best intellectuals of Pakistan. We Indians were very concerned when we heard that he was picked by Establishment and tortured. He is absolutely a thorough gentleman. He is a great guy. God bless him.

Excellent podcast covering the much taboo topics. Full marks to Ali Chishti to reminding people about Jamaat-e-Islami as the mother of evil in Pakistan. They can-not wipe off the blood just by Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman. Kudos to the host Daniyal too

Dear Dani, Very informative podcast, this kind of information is for everyone. Especially about the history of immigrants in Pakistan/Karachi and various communities and the difficulties they face.

Wow, I'm seeing AK Chishti after 7-8 years. He was very active in Karachi news back then on social media. He had a huge MqM related controversy after which he completely went off all social media. Good to see him back.

Always wanted someone to do podcasts like these you have inspired me and many thank u for your time passion and dedication.

This is your best podcast!! Daniyal bhai❤

A great podcast Daniyal sir, Ali did some great informative talks and would surely love too see him once again in your podcast.

Where I stay in India , there are more than 50,000+ Sindhi settlers. They talk about Karachi and the businesses they had there. In fact, there's a chowk that has two names , one is the local name and the other name is Karachi chowk. There's a Karachi sweets and a Karachi hotel there. Some shops still have names written in Sindhi. They are today , one of the richest communities in my city. They started from scratch and I have hardly heard anybody calling them mujahirs or refugees. There's jhulelaal sweets and general stores. Apparently there have been muslim sindhis also who migrated to India.

He's a dictionary for knowledge hats off the best podcast

Great & Honest Podcast !!! Bravo both of you !!! 👍👍👍

Born and raised in Karachi and still in 2023 face the same prejudice.. started from school to college to university and in office too. I remember when I was child and my friends used to say that our parents say xyz (ethnic) people are bad. Means that's how we nurture our generation and result is that we hate each other.. I'm not only one here many would relate this. mr ali said we should give amnesty to the mqm workers who were involved in many murder cases becz they belong to mqm.. being that intellectual and supports to culprits where he should condemn for everyone who is involved in any criminal activity in karachi or Pakistan irrespective of any ethnic group.. may Allah protect us and Pakistan

I saw young Ali Chisti when he destroyed lal topi where he was emphasizing on solving internal problems. His words were so true. Today Pakistan is going through the same he along with Hasan Nisar mentioned.

Absolute crystal clear source 👏👏👏

Best podcast ❤, We want Part 2

Best podcast ever in my life so far ❤

its good that we are talking about all these stuff, we must learn our mistakes and make sure never to repeat such. every great society had made mistakes in past and learn from there mistakes and move forward.

As a Mumbaikar 26/11 is one of the most painful experiences we have witnessed, but I am glad to see such a matured discussion on such a sensitive topic, especially how Ali Chisti ji has explained the finer points on the relations between the two countries have deteriorated. Hope his kinds and tribe increases.

I never commented on any you tube video but you deserve appreciation we need more people like in both the countries. Respect from India

44:15 military training se copy nhi kiya aapki military ne hi unko training di thi

Daniyal, thanks for highlighting the baseline:)

Great informative podcast. Keep it up brother. Love from India

In Pakistan, the quota system was actually introduced in 1948 when Liaquat Ali Khan was the prime minister who was the real architect of the quota system. A notification issued on September 1, 1948 laid down recruitment policy for the central services. Under the policy 15 per cent quota was reserved for the candidates who had not yet acquired the domicile of Pakistan.

Yes Daniyal, you rightly said that our roots are the same. I too sincerely wish that the relationships between India and Pakistan are improved. This will definitely benefit the common ppl of both the countries. Hats off to you for talking about India differently from the mainstream media. At the same time, we do understand that it's their "rozi roti." Of course, this applies to our Indian media as well. Lastly, hope to see many more interesting contents in the future.

Stumbled upon this podcast and loved it. Great to see Ali Chisti after a long time, remember seeing him on Kamran Shahid's show. Sir, with all due respect to both, your understanding of India is way too simplistic. There was Congress govt from 2009-14 and the peace of talks didn't go anywhere even then. This is a foreign policy, doesn't change with govt. By the same token, it was Mr Vajpayee, who belongs to the same BJP/RSS from where Mr Modi comes, who started the peace process which you on your show were gloating on. Second, Mr Modi too tried the peace initiative, first in 2014 with his swearing in and second in 2015, when Mr Modi landed in Pakistan. Within a month we had Pathankot which has created a mood that after kab tak. I'm a great advocate of India-Pakistan friendship. Also, regarding extremism, we had instances in Kerela in 2016 where a professor's hand was chopped by a Muslim mob for saying something on Islam. Again there is no BJP MP or MLA in Kerela. So this frenzy is everywhere. These things are more amplified due to exposure and social media. Also, whenever Sara Ali khan gets trolled for visiting a temple or SRK gets trolled for ganesh chaturthi, check out the names of the people trolling him. Also, regarding media, sir you guys had PPL like Zaid Hamid, whom I know Ali doesn't like, were gloating about the attack and balkanization of India. I know that's not truly representative of Pakistan but this also is true. My msg is apna Zehen istemal karein, behkawe mein mat jaayein. Love from across the border in Delhi.

Maturity in your podcasts is supreme

Where we can find the document which you are talking about

Best one so far

Waiting for next episode with his. He is very intellectual and honest

Best podcast ever in your PC list...

One of the best podcasts ever.

Hello Daniyal bhai , Consider this as an appreciation comment. Nice podcast.

Boy zabrdast ali Bhai ka podcast part 2 b ana chaiye..... Ye topic continue hona chaiye...

Agar Danish bar bar Interrupt karta I was leave Podcast ... Im Glad to listen Ali Chisti Great Person.....

Very very good podcast Daniyal.. appreciated

Amazing daniyal and as always visionary Ali chishti…

One of the best pod cast . But few things you have to correct 😊

I've moved from Karachi in 2014 I was born and was brought up in Karachi from 1998 to 2014 now when I talk about Karachi I'm being called ghair mukaaami and bashed by people ..... I've immense love for Karachi and it's so heart wrenching to hear all this

It's good to listen to history of Karachi..

Seeing ali chisti after a long time....

Why nobody is talking about India's direct involvement in many suicide attacks in Pakistan. Killing someone innocent can not be justified in any way, but somehow Pakistan failed in showing the world about India's involvement in many blasts in Pakistan.

Great points by Ali Chishti Shb. I think that a, he's spot on JI relationship with terrorism in Pakistan b, on Mohajir traregdy and institutional relationships etc. He's a great resource . .

It was a nice discussion

Excellent broadcast

As Indian I appreciate your podcast bcoz you providing good information.

My grandfather had shop in Karachi. He used to travel from Kutch to Karachi via boat and it used to take 9 days i think. He don't use word partition till date. He says "Karachi fetai". It is Kutchi word for Downfall of Karachi. He says we had shop in Saddar Bazar. He lost his eyesight so i will never able to bring him there to see it but I wish I can visit Saddar bazar once.

Good show...plz share the guests books

Wonderful podcast

Excellent pod cast.

Guest have so much information so impressed

Some corrections related to Parsis: Yes , the Parsis came to India to avoid persecution. Their fortunes were primarily made trading opium and textile from China . Slowly they started helping the British with the contracts also. They were early adopters of the British things and gelled with them. They did not marry Englishmen because if a Parsi marries outside of their community they're forever kicked out , only exception being the men sometimes. Today most Parsis are in Gujrat, Mumbai and Pune.

As an Indian I am impressed by Mr.Chisti, he spoke truth(26/11). It’s not easy to talk about faults of one’s own country. Wish there were people like him on this side to talk some sense to the rabid bhakts.

I am very impressed with Chisti sahab.

Some Pakistanis were definitely happy about the 26/11 attacks. On one hand we were celebrating the attacks and at the same time were saying "yeh to India ne khud hi karwaya hai..."

Best podcast everrrr. since making of Youtuvbe

Waiting for part 2

Great podcast I would say❤

Amazing Ali Chishti !!!!

Appreciate your content

Best video I every seen in RU-vid

Best podcast, but i just wanted to correct one thing that Biharis in Bangladesh are more comfortable and happy thier first cricket captain Akram Khan was Bihari, his nephew Tamim iqbal is still main stream player in Bangladesh Cricket tear.. also Biharis families are doing great businesses there

Can anyone explain what does Mahazir mean?

Excellent 👍

Ali, what you are saying is directly coming from heart and resonating with the hearts of many Karachiites! It is refershing to see that people who speaks truth are still there. Thank you Daniyal for bringing Ali to your show. It has definitely increased the quality even further and I am loving it!

In 90's, On Indian govt TV channel (Doordarshan) news, MQM (Altaf Khan) protests were covered majorly. He was famous in India as a Muhajir leader.

JIYE ALTAF HUSSAIN BHAI ✌️❤️

Loved your podcast ❤ as an Indian hope for betterment in Pakistan

Ye jo banda hai ali chishti isne india pe jo jankari diyi he ye 90% correct hai.pakistan me india ke bare me sahi jankari hone vale bahot kam lok hai isme ye banda hai.very knowledgeble person about india.

Best podcast ever

Behtareen Podcast

Living and watching from nazimabad no.1 KHI.

Mission majnu is a periodic film based on the late 70s and early 80s.

great Ali Bhai ....

Excellent and logical. The issues which Ali Sb raised are not 'sexy' and needs a lot of courage to speak up since people had forgotten due to serious propaganda by PTI, JI crowd.

Amazing podcast and very nice initiative. But it is very difficult to have good relation with pakistan because they will again backstab so its better to have distance and continue the things the way it is.

Just one thing i will neglect of ali chishti is that the reunion of the MQM according to him is good but adapting to me it has no benefit 🤷🏻‍♂️

Another best podcast from daniyal sheikh and ali Chishti is indeed a ray of hope in pakistan I still remember one his old talk show with kamran shahid where he badly thrashed zaid hamid with his logic and facts.