Kylian Mbappe or Erling Haaland? 🔥| Thierry Henry & Jamie Carragher share their thoughts 

Thierry never actually answers a question. Would be a brilliant politician

Henry is actually eloquent . Didn’t answer a single question but kept you listening to him. If football doesn’t interest him anymore, politics is definitely there for him

"Haaland or Mbappe?" Theirry: "Yes thank you"

Haaland is a tank. Destroying everything in his way to get to the target. Mbappe is a Ninja. Wants to do it in the most beautiful way

I'm telling you. The addition of Thierry Henry as a pundit was a masterstroke.

Translation for what Thierry is saying: I prefer haaland but mbappe is a fellow Frenchman so I have to back him

The media are trying to create the new rivalry of Haaland vs Mbappe.

Sky sports: Question, question, question, please tell us, yes or no... Henry: Yes and No

It’s Haaland for me! He’a a killer infront of goal! Has everything you need in a player! 😎

Thierry Henry’s stats are still remarkable so many years later since he retired. Nobody realises how many assists he used to get for a goal scorer.

Haaland is a force of nature. His mentality is scary, his instinct to positioning himself at the right place at the right time perfect and his first touch and scoring ability incredible. 20 years old, crazy.

Its a crime that Thierry Henry never actually won a Ballon d´Or.

He wants to say Haaland but Mbappe's French so he can't say it outright.

0:53 Andre Silva is having a mad season

This aged well.

Mbappe offers versatility in the sense that he can play on the wings or as a striker. He is a superb dribbler which basically draws players out of position which his teammates can run into or for him to run into. Haaland is purely a striker that gets in behind very easily. His off the ball movement, composure and finishing is superb and he at least guarantees you a goal a match according to the stats provided to us by carra

7:10 ''You were late that day like aubameyang'' LOOOOOL

It’s clear they both prefer Halaand instead of Mbappe😂

Henry: I like a killer. Mbappe: I kill in the streets. Haaland: why not.

it's crazy to me that Lukaku's only 27. feels like he's been around forever, but it's just because he's been that GOOD, for that long. was already a noteworthy performer 7-8 years ago.

I think Haaland will be the higher goal scorer with a big mentality, but Mbappe will be the more technical classy player who will always score the beautiful goals both will be right up at the top for many years to come

I don't know what it is but I haven't seen a Haaland style player before, he has such a strange body type, with that speed. It's as if he was built in a lab!

"owen needed heskey, heskey needed owen" love heskey getting a mention in debate about young world class strikers

I can listen to Henry speak about football for hours man 😍

Jamie: There's something about Haaland, he looks mad😂😂😂

“Jamie will tell you, there is nothing worse when a guy looks at you and goes in behind again and again and again”

Its crazy that Thierry is still number 1 in goal involvements in the pl history, what a player he was.

Just shows how amazing Thierry was. Even with that selfish killer instinct every world class striker has, he was still intelligent enough to become a team player when needed.

Haaland in the Prem would be a problem. You can't outmuscle or pace him and he's a killer

Look, Haaland is a hybrid of sheer talent and grit. he is absolutely terrifying. he has it all, the height, speed, power, finishing, intelligence.

The fact that Henry is up the list there and pretty much chill & composed, says a lot about the man

city is a team that already creates an insane amount of chances, having haaland at city would make them an absolute killer. converting 40% of their chances into goals would make them unstoppable

he did the face, HE DID THE FACE!

Personally I feel like Haaland has the better mentality/determination and is a better finisher that's why I think he will be the better player.

I'd be terrified if my team is playing against Haaland. But I'm also terrified by Mbappe. His performance against Argentina still gives me nightmares. And I think it comes down to what the team needs. If you need someone to carry the ball and create then it's Mbappe. Need someone who'll be on the scoresheet even before the match starts? Haaland.

8:32 onwards.. "He's so big and strong" "He wanna go behind, he wanna hurt you"

Mbappe has more silk and is elegent. Haaland is like punch in the face of defender and score!

As a united fan I just love Thierry Henry, you can hate how good he was but you can’t hate his personality

You're 20 and the entire world wants you... Imagine the feeling!!!

Henry's response in a nutshell: I like both of them and don't want to compare

Thierry Henry's goal involvement stats are absolutely outrageous

if you have Kevin debrunye haaland will definitely win you every game without a doubt

Thierry Henry what a legend footballer and great pundit . Made me smile with all memories flooding back from you’re great days of football

Henry what a man, class on and off the pitch, love (what i think is) the honesty. Some think he gives boring answers, but its more like he gives the right answer on questions instead of getting on some unnecessery hype. Æliing and Solskjær would make a fantastic team.

It's crazy how Lewandowski has also created such a standard for himself that everyone thinks it's normal to have those stats😳

8:31 “He’s soo big, he’s soo strong, he wants to hurt you, theres nothing like a guy that wants to go in behind you.... again and again and again” 😳

Mbappe will get the ball and either get the players to that goal or he’ll do it himself. Mbappe has versatility. The way he is able to maneuver through defenders is so extraordinary that you‘re amazed by him instead of the person who scores the goal. He makes soccer fun to watch.

Mentality is the final decider almost always. Haaland is a monster mentally. Mbappe is complacent.

legend says that Henry still hasn't decided who's better.

Thierry Henry and Carragher one of the best conversations I heard hope he will come and do some more as a pundit

"He's so Big"... "I'm happy to see those guys coming". Ok Thierry XD

No one is even going to suggest Titus Bramble?

Mbappe is super fast with great dribbling but Haaland has the potential to be the perfect striker he literally has everything.

The one week i have to miss MNF is when Henry comes back ffs

Halaand is what Bendtner was meant to be...Not even joking. Tall, powerful, two footed, fast. Shows how mindset effects football.

Sevilla keeper gave halaand the chest and couldn't take it when halaand have him some chest back. Halaand doesn't mind a banter war. Man wears his heart on his sleeve. Breath of fresh air

Henry has such great knowledge id love to see him more on sky sports

Just looking at those numbers, damn Henry was a monster of a player. Also makes one realize really how much of an impact Kun, Drogba, Kane and RVP had on the league. And KDB there with monster assist numbers. Also how crazy Salah has been in such a short time in the league. And Ole, doing all of that from the bench. Couldn't pick just one of them as my main striker. (Except KDB being the only non striker on the list). What an exceptional bunch.

It sounds like Henry is calling Haaland ‘Alan’ 😅

Thierry Henry is hilarious 😂

Only similarities mbappe has with henry is pace, explosiveness and decision making. Doesnt have the hold up, link up play, freekicks, height, strength, and playmaking ability.

I got to say haaland,mbappe is a bit off and on some games sometimes he doesn’t show up but haaland every game he is scoring He’s just a different breed

You gotta give it to Thierry. He's a master of saying something but not saying anything.

From what I've heard, Mbappe goes missing quite a bit in Ligue 1, while Haaland literally can't stop scoring no matter what. They're obviously different types of players but if I had to take one it would be Haaland.

Henry has got better and better at explaining why people are so good and young footballers should listen to the simplicity but mandatory mentality you need as a forward.

Thierry has such an amazing football brain. Love him as an arsenal and a barca fan.

9:23 is when Jamie found out Henry is the love of his life 😂

Henry is so good at answering questions with very long sentences and actually not answering the question, he should become a poilitican.

I love Henry 😂😂 Funny guy, and what a wonderful player he was.

Mbappe is a player that you would like for your ream but haaland is a player that every team needs Consistency, power, speed Man is a machine

Haaland has done unreal things in such a short period

Does Henry ever actually answer a question?

Haaland is an incredible counter attacker and he can also hold the ball up as a false 9. Mpabbe is also an incredible counter attacker but has more flair to his game and less hold up play. This has the potential to be the new Messi/Ronaldo y’all, let’s appreciate their game

8:31 😂 😂 😂

When you realise that Thierry prefers haaland but he is mbappes idol so he doesn’t want to ruin his confidence

Ever since I saw Harland I started praying pep would get him, this kid will break all records

Henry is such a baller as a pundit

0:32 i see the smirk after being on top of the list 😂

This was a really good conversation. And I can agree, it is hard to choose. Choosing would be from a real tactical perspective, as in, you will have to be sure the team can play around that player.

As a Norwegian it is ofc interesting to read about the international attention Haaland gets. The arguably most interesting was the (former) coaching staff of BvB that was pretty much shocked when they started doing tests systematically on him. Haaland actually made some brass claim someth along the lines of 'there is smth wrong with our German football academies-we will never pick up potential players with physical characteristics like Erling'- the point being that a guy like him would be sent to track&field for javelin throw, sledgehammer, pot shot or smth like that. #1 Erling is immensely strong for his age. When they say he eats like a horse it is probably true. He needs energy like a weightlifter. #2 For such a tall guy with some beef attached, he is lightning fast, especially those first crucial meters. He can gain space on a defender like very few others. #3 He is a pure nr 9, almost in a classical way. He is a Joe Jordan with 3-stage turbos attached. As mentioned, his movement pattern is very much like Vardy. Not much lateral movement on the heat map, a clear direction towards the box and fighting for his right to be there. Look at how he acts when BvB are on set pieces. Most defenders are used to dominate in their own box when speed isnt the most prevalent factor. When Erling is in there and in the zone its like he throws defenders up on the stands merely by looking at them. Not many strikers have that fear factor and ability to dominate the actions of the surroundings like him. Even guys like VvD who are built very much the same way like Erling, admit he is a handful. In ice hockey, we talk about 'power forwards'. That is the easiest way to describe him. You will always feel his physical presence.

Great to have Thierry back in the studio 👏

Haaland at ST with Mbappe on the left and Sancho on the right. Tell me that aint one of the most lethal sounding strike forces in recent history

I like how Henry always shuts down the laughing with a big NUUUUUUUUUUUH

It's Mpabbe for me. He brings a lot more to the team than just goal scoring.

I want Henry to come back into Sky punditry but also be a great coach too...

9:20 Someone make a meme of "I loved it, I like that, I loved it, I like that, you like it?" 😂😂😂😂please

Haaland makes it look easy, he really is special

Jamie: I liked it Henry: I liked that Jamie: you like it ?😍

"What happened to playing with two?" Now that would be dangerous!

Haaland the next greatest scorer of this new generation

If city is looking for a striker then they should go for Haaland. They got plenty of great wingers atm.

Lewandowski has 32 goals and 6 assist already this season that's a joke 😱

Hard question. But I would personally go for Mbappe. Haaland is really good. But I would like to see how consistent he can be in the next 3 years.

Let’s not say anyone is better Let’s just hope Mbappe + Haaland can maintain the same tensity that Ronaldo and Messi had

Here after Erling Signed for us, let's see how it plays out💙

Thierry is right, you can't compare the two and it's clear what their strengths are. However I think there's different teams who needs one of their strengths more than the other. I think more clubs need Haalands strengths more than Mbappe's...

When Haaland is running the pitch on a break - with his size & speed - defenders look like they want no part of him. His desire is palpable.

Nice to see a Leeds lad like Haaland doing well abroad. He needs to come home now and play for his local team. MOT

Thierry Henry is great to listen to. Very likeable and knowledgeable guy

Mbappé is a better player as of now but Haaland is a better goal scorer.