Lets talk about youtubers having an "awakening" I Can we criticize youtubers?

Подписаться 301

50% 1

Hi!
Two topics for today:
1) the shift that some youtubers are making in their content of (over)consumption to minimalism. Some people call it a trend, some people hate it, some people really love it. I will be giving my thoughts on this type of content ;)
2) Can we criticize youtubers? Who or what are we criticizing? Is it always mean to do so?
As always, this video is just for fun! Leave your thoughts down below :)

Хобби

Опубликовано:

6 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 5

@marianapereirae 2 месяца назад

Hey Amanda, your perspective in the video really got me thinking. I've always had a passion for fashion, and recently, especially since I don't have many friends who share my enthusiasm for the subject, I decided to start my own RU-vid channel. And like you, there's no financial incentive behind my channel - it's purely driven by my love for fashion and the desire to connect with people.v Lately, I've noticed this sudden shift in content from certain RU-vidrs, making me wonder if my content is unintentionally promoting overconsumption on a smaller scale. I think some RU-vidrs are shifting to become more niche, as it's still their job as content creators and brand owners to pivot when necessary. Of course, for some, it might be for personal reasons. But what troubles me is when a content creator advocates for "buying less" while flaunting luxury items that are out of reach for most viewers. It can foster judgmental feelings among those who can't afford such items, perpetuating a sense of inadequacy. Similarly, there's a dilemma when creators endorse certain brands as "less problematic" while criticizing larger chains for perpetuating the fashion fallacy. I think it's okay to do the latter as long as you don't put yourself on that pedestal of superiority. Overall, videos like yours are very much needed!

@madeinnorden 2 месяца назад

@marianapereirae Hi, just to say it first- thank you so much for your very thought through comment! I've had the same thought, if I too am promoting over consumption. But if we had an arts and crafts channel, would we be accused of promoting overconsumption of art supplies? Or any other subject? Let's just share our enjoyment :) I think it's easy to not shop or buy less when you have a room packed with clothes after years of collecting, that should be considered when making "I stopped shopping" videos definitely. Maybe I miss your point but I don't think there is anything wrong with buying luxury (even when doing so during a "buying less" period). The fact that they are buying less may be the reason they can afford buying luxury (together with all things that come with income, financial status, debt load etc). And if they like to shop luxury, who am I to judge? If I wanted watch, there are plenty of channels with affordable fashion (but I am drawn to brands like Sézane, Toteme, Loewe...which is not very good for the wallet hehe). The key word may be "flaunting", of course some are showing off but I tend to see it as someone just sharing for most part, but I might miss videos ;) I personally really dislike the whole "this was sooooo exclusive, and it is soooo elegant" kind of vibe xD! I am guessing that it might be a try to be more sustainable, and as someone who has tried to shop sustainably, it is INCREDIBLY difficult. All clothing brands are to some extent unsustainable, the whole industry is. So back again with the "overconsumption" dilemma. Personally I have made the decision to shop clothing that I LOVE, because it is so important for me to express myself, and that means that sometime I will buy from less sustainable brands. We all have our vices, and this is mine. I make other life choices that are more sustainable, in particular political choices (which is the biggest contribution a single person can make unless they are the CEO of an oil company). Does that even it out? I don't know... but it is not easy being good in this day and age, so let's just be at peace with our own faults and give others some reasonable doubt. Have you seen "The good place"? They make a great commentary on the difficulties of being alive and "good" today :) Sorry for such a long response, this subject has been plaguing my mind for so long haha!! You seem like a very intelligent, thoughtful and honest person and I am delightful that you decided to start a channel, I wish you the best of luck xx

@FS-rb2bh Месяц назад

Finally some sense please. I very much agree with you: I love beautiful things and yes, I buy things because they seem pretty to me (and with good quality, good manufacturing and European, but that is my vibe and my personal OCD). For example, I am a big lover of dresses from the rouje brand, probably if you put together the number of summer dresses that I have from that brand over the years someone would be scandalized. Does that mean I have a mortgage to pay them? The truth is no, but I do buy little by little as I can afford. I also buy some expensive cosmetics because I have sensitive skin and age and it can be considered a whimsical expense as well. On the other hand, I cut back on other things that are not so important to me (mobile phone model, makeup, I always look for the best offers and discounts (also in those purchases of clothing and cosmetics), I exercise at home and do not pay gym fees, I make homemade food ...What I decide to do. Everyone has the right to organize themselves as they want and of course: they can buy what is nice and what they can afford (and fits into their home of course). The only thing I would say is to raise awareness about not buying something. to use once and throw away due to contamination issues, but come on, if any of you are tempted to throw away a luxury bag, don't do it, I'll take care of giving it a home

@madeinnorden Месяц назад

As always, great to hear your perspective! As you say, most people are not in a trans or need of an awakening to feel happy in their life! For most of us, it's just pretty things that we buy because we like to and in the amount we can afford (both financially and in space). Nobody else's business to be honest 😆 of course, not buying crap that you know is low quality and will fall apart after a wash, that just seems like a waste. But most adults don't do that?? We all have too many bills to pay and too little time to take out the trash haha! Love that you splurge on dresses and cosmetics, those are fab items! ❤️

@FS-rb2bh Месяц назад

@@thebigscreentheoryIt is a common expression, I imagine that it is used in many countries as an ironic expression. I think the context also makes it quite clear.