(Skip installation 8:24) Thanks everyone! I know this could have been a bit more "real life" scenario like. But it was fun and still gave us a good idea of the different protectors capabilities.
I’m giving a thumbs up for the beginning. The fact that you put in your title where installation stops. Do actual drop test. So direct and honest. Not click bait like the rest on RU-vid. Ty. Jesus.
Read the directions on at least the cellhelmet if you give it a go again, it says it needs like 24 hours to fully cure, so I don't feel like it was a fair test for the cellhelmet one at the very least.
Voting Moxy at 8:34 will edit after done Edit: Moxy did win but it makes more sense to get multiple tempered glass protectors than to buy something that once broken you have to replace the phone screen. This was a fun video to watch, gonna subscribe
Really liked the video. Very informative and helpful. Have you ever tried this test with a totally unprotected screen? Would be interesting to see the difference in strength between unprotected and protected.
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-WCpL2pU6P6Y.html they only doing cellhelement but alt least you can get an idea of the differnce with and without protection.
You need a control! Next vid could do the test on an unprotected screen to compare. Also the lock is maybe a bad choice, something spherical would be ideal, but if the control breaks with the batteries we at least know the protectors work.
Thanks for the video! Cellhelmet denied my $297+ warranty on a screen replacement claim after my screen was damaged, 7 months after the product was applied. I registered the product within 24hrs of purchase with a copy of the purchase receipt and a picture of the phone screen. Cellhelmet is difficult to reach by phone, email, or live chat to follow up on a claim. Check their BBB and Google Play reviews.
if u used ball instead of those, it would me more precise as ball is round shaped. u would get same pressure all the time. it doesn't have any corner like things u used and pressure are different in different points.
I dont think so.. Thanks for the comment. Im working on a new video with liquid, film, tempered glass, and nothing! And using a steel ball this time! Stay tuned!
Very helpfull video. But, i have a new ask. What will happen if liquid screen protector and tempered glass be combined? And can it be combined? *Applying the liquid for first one, n using tempered glass after the liquid be ready to use
Does the liquid works well or not which I recently used on my screen I peeled off screen protector and while applying the liquid the screen looks shiny clean it's hard to tell where the liquid stays on screen I don't see anything after buffing on the screen it looks like no screen protector the liquid goes invisible.
Thanks!!! Im guessing because in reality the test could be a little more "real life" scenario like. But it was fun and still gave us a good idea of the different protectors capabilities.
I totally "didn't" buy a moxie liquid screen protector after watching this video! Great test guys! Have you guys encountered any other liquid protectors? Is moxie still the way to go? or do you all like another brand?
Oliver Well, we have a pending video with actual metal balls 🏀 so it can be more fair. For now we alternate between Moxie and Cellhelmet and also tempered glass.
You have to weigh the phone a drop the same weight as the phone because that would be the same as The Phone Falling otherwise it wouldn't be a fair test or accurate
You have to wait 48 hours for the liquid glass to fully solidify. Watch the cell helmet drop test. They will show you a heavier item that they dropped on a phone.
Surely you can slide the batteries/ objects down a plastic pipe or similar, to ensure the application/ energy/ angle of incidence is the same in all tests?
Cool and helpfull video man... Need info ...do you have the supplier info for the second phone nano application brand . Im from East Malaysia . Sabah. Tqs.
Why on your website you are only selling the helmet screen protector which is the one that lost first, where can I find the Moxie screen protector? I've looked and can't find it on Amazon.
My sisters S10 screen cracked with the liquid glass applied now she has to get the screened replaced. I’ll stick to my tempered glass at least if the cracks it’s a cheap replacement
Mannn!!!! Thats unfortunate! Yeah who knows, which liquid screen protector did she use? Let me know if you'd like to ship her phone to fix it. Roughly around $275.
Consider too, that the initial tests may be weakening the protective layer so that the heavier tests are undertaken on already compromised protection. If it doesn't break due to heavier weight, it could break due to persistence (very well have been the lighter weight that breaks it).
Yeah thats something we thought about. The glass starts getting weaker and weaker. Most, like myself, never realized that until it all made sense in the microscopic level. Thanks for your comment! **We MUST do another drop test. This time, 3 or more phones, one metal ball equivalent to the weight of the lock seen in this video, ONE DROP EACH from the max height seen in this video!!!*** What do you all say??
I would do either one of the liquid protectors, plus the regular tempered glass. Then go to settings and activate the touch sensitivity for screen protectors. I have an s10 myself
I have a film screen protector on my S9+ and a Spigen case. Its been dropped MANY times, including once from a motorcycle at about 50mph. There's a mysterious cut in the middle of the sceen protector and some scrapes and scuffs on the case and screen protector, but the phone is in perfect shape.
Great job boys, but your test was flawed. You need to use ball bearing as the impacts would be consistent no mater how the item falls as the point loading. The items you used would cause different point load depending on how it falls
On cell phone test try weighing the phone then finding something to drop on the phone to represent dropping the phone maybe? So yp6 think tempered is better because you can replace it?
Yeah i think tempered is better in skme cases but a film is better for curved screens. A recent test video we did shows the difference between tempered, film, liquid, and nothing on! Stay tuned just editing it now.
You should've done from and back, and put the rest on other devices like a watch or anything glass just to use the left overs and. Not wasted, but great video.
Proper test is with a ball bearing...that way it lands on device same way every time.....and if you ever registered the cellhelmet for the warranty $ you would know it starts a 24 hour timer ....even though the liquid glass dries enough to finish application process, it is not completely cured and protected until after 24 hours
Thanks for sharing your tests. However, you have at least 2 methodological flaws that make the results of your tests unreliable: 1. You didn't do a control experiment with a non-protected phone. How can you be sure that the 1st liquid protector is better than just no protection ? I suppose it is but without a control you cannot be sure that that liquid indeed does something. 2. You only did one repetition of each experiment, but as with any experiment you're subject to random effects and so each time that you drop the lock on the same type of protector you can have different results. That's why the first tempered glass broke from a much lower height than the second one. You will need to have much more iphones available to repeat the test on each protector and compute the mean and variance of the height to have comparable results. Mmm, a little bit expensive though ..., Nevertheless, thanks for sharing, it was nevertheless interesting and entertaining, and thanks to you I discovered the existence of those liquid protectors.
The kid was educated after a while it its liquid and its not gonna magically turn into glass but wjat it does is compresses the glass by filling the micro holes that is in yhe touch screen
Hey guys, thanks for the demo. BUT, aren't the "screen protectors that you place on the screen-made of glass also"?? So, what if you put the Moxy onto the screen protector and then put it onto the phone screen(if the protector isn't made of glass, then don't use it-if ya know what I mean!)!!! Let me know either way, as others might as well. Thanks, take care, "God Bless", sincerely Randy.
Can you re do the tests all with aftermarket screens bought from same place at same time ... just my input I dont think test was done correctly not your fault but their is ways to tell if screen is aftermarket but not all time is accurate like rebuilt screens have different glass same lcd and then their is the Foxconn built aftermarket screens that have oem look and barcode and lettering but is not same lcd or glass then their is the aftermarket replication oem screens just cause it has apple logo on ribbon doesn't make it oem iv seen on many aftermarket screens so I think test should be re done all with aftermarket screens bought from same place is only way to make sure test is accurate...as you can tell if worked as a cellphone tech for 14 years iv seen it all ... infact can you make sure all of the cellphones have the correct barcodes in right places make sure oem cause the cellphone battery door back housings are made of different materials aka different flex in back housing can throw off test also ...if you re due test I'll subscribe and watch more
Thanks guys! Very informative and looked like fun! I just bought cellhelmet before reviewing it and w as s really nervous, I still may get an extra protector but seemed to holdup pretty well and that extra rebate back if it does break really is nice.
Has ANYONE ever tried putting a liquid glass screen protector on, and then adding a plastic/tempered glass screen protector on top of the liquid glass protector?? I feel like that would improve the durability a bit... you should definitely do an in depth durability test with both!! ... or do a layer of liquid screen protector, then a tempered glass protector, then liquid glass on top of that! That sounds like ultimate durability to me!!
Well, looks like liquid glass won. But to make the test better, I suggest using a steel ball for the past one because of how the lock can hit it at certain angles that will not have as much impact as the ring on top of the lock.
Test is not totally accurate, especially with the glass protector. How the padlock lands on the screen can affect whether or not it cracks it. If the lock made contact with the screen from on angle and from the locks 4 bottom edges its more likely the crack it than if it lands on it flat on its bottom. That is why the tempered screen broke at 2 feet but than didn't at 3 and 4 feet and above since those two landed more flat thus spreading the impact over a larger area preventing it from cracking. As far as the liquid ones are concerned they are more or less useless other than maybe improving scratch resistance a bit. Doubt they will really improve impact resistence.
@@911Gadgets Steel balls are a great idea. The BB and pellets guns are probably not necessary if you are just trying show near real world impact scenarios phones get into. People are usually not shooting their phones. Although you may as well do those just for the fun of inflicting damage. :-)
