LIVE! Real Lawyer Reacts: Sarah Boone's 911 Call - What Does She Give Up Without Realizing It? 

The fact she said she did CPR and then had such a shocked reaction when being asked to do it and hearing gurgles. It makes me think she never attempted CPR prior to being told to do it.

What I learned from this. Never give up your power to another person. You never know what they are capable of.

She’s annoyed he died and now she has to deal with this.

As an addiction counselor, the one thing that stood out for me in this case is Sarah's unwillingness to admit she has a problem with alcohol. At first, I thought it may be related to custody issues but now I see it as deep denial of her pattern with using substances. The simplest way to reconcile this case is to attribute her behavior to being drunk or in a blackout. She cannot bring herself to do this to her own detriment. I wonder if we'll learn this was the point of contention between her and her parade of attorneys.

I'm a respiratory therapist and we go to every single code in the hospital where compressions need to be done and I'm telling you 150% positive that she would not be able to do that without running out of breath also it didn't sound like she had even put down the phone you would definitely hear more of a commotion and she would absolutely be out of breath. We usually have to have people account for us because CPR is the best workout you will ever get

Her x said he wasn't inside. When she told him he was dead, he turned around and walked out. He wanted nothing to do with it.

As someone who has been trained in CPR and has actually performed it, she couldn't have been talking that fluidly and been giving compressions at the same time.

On rewatch crew, that suitcase moving gives me the chills. Her asking what happened is astounding, she’s already answered her own question. If she was doing the cpr she’d be out of breath it’s exhausting even for professionals.

Sounded like she did the first compression, he gurgled and it freaked her out (the scream sounded real to me) and then she stopped. She definitely wasn’t doing compressions when she was counting… she would be out of breath

If she killed him, last thing she really wants to do is try to help him or touch his dead body. She's annoyed. She wants his body gone. She doesn't want to deal with it.

So for Peter and the others saying why is she doing CPR if he’s dead? That’s who you do CPR on, not on someone who’s still breathing. Also if he’s stiff how did she get him out of the suitcase and straighten him out to do CPR? She’s pumping on his chest but yet her breathing doesn’t change, she should be getting exhausted!!

The maddening thing about her is that she will not listen. I don’t know if it’s a mental thing, it just seems like she has to be right and talking over everyone will make her right.

Doing CPR on a adult male is physically exhausting and she’s talking during CPR. A 30 year nurse and this would never be possible in a person her size let alone carry a conversation.

There is no way she is doing cpr the entire time she’s on the call with the operator. Anyone that has done cpr knows how exhausting it is, which is why emts or nurses switch places. She isn’t out of breath or skipping a bit during conversation at all.

Wow, she actually sounded annoyed with the 911 operator more than anything

I found my mother in the LR having had a massive heartattack. I did CPR for 20 min while waiting for ems and omgoodness is so tiring, hard and it takes it out of you. It did sound like get ribs were breaking. The 911 operator said that means I'm doing it right.

I hope this trial will be televised. It’s unbelievable! Thank you for your live streams.

It's kind of unreal sometimes how emergency phone operators don't pay attention at all.

I’m a nurse, I have done CPR, it is exhausting and strenuous for the rescuer and quickly causes the rescuer to have to breath more heavily from the exertion. There was no audible exertion in her voice when she was counting.

If I heard it correctly In her 911 call she said she PUT him in a suitcase and they were playing hide & seek, hide & seek doesn’t involve knowing where the person hiding is…

The ex stayed outside. Smart man. He just got the vibe she wanted him to be in the house to set him up. Would not have put it past her.

About the CPR: I watched CPR done on my dad when he went into cardiac arrest, just before they did a de-fib. It’s nothing like they show in movies and stuff, it is TRAUMATIC. It’s violent. It’s painful. And that’s just for someone watching. If she was doing chest compressions, she was doing the Hollywood version; I can’t imagine she was really trying hard if she believed it was too late and it was performative.

I just watched the video of Jorge begging her because he could NOT breath and she laughs, curses at him and knows darn well he is suffering and does nothing to help him. I can’t believe this. I really did not expect that video at all. I am beyond shocked and devastated. Hurts my heart.

If this was said previously, ignore…zippers in the dozen/flat position “lock”, as in won’t slide down. I knew this worked in jeans, etc, I checked my suitcase and it works the same way. Even if she left a “hole”, if his finger could not “raise” the zipper out of the “lock” position, he would not be able to open it.

She was absolutely not doing CPR, there is no exertion in her voice, and she’s clearly holding the phone and just counting. I also do not believe they were playing hide and seek. She’s just lying and lying and lying. Her reactions are unbelievable-selfish, annoyed with everyone, demanding, no grief or shock.

I'm a Tampa native and served, in my 20s, on a 1st degree murder trial. I thoroughly enjoyed the process and wanted to make it. When I made it and realized this person's life was in my hands, it became very real and very serious. I would still do it again, but there is stress and pressure in making the decision.

As a 30vetran hospice RN, I masking, 'what is she ABLE to compress if rigor mortice has set in? AND the likelihood of a gurgle when STIFF? I've never heard it. But then again, I don't do CPR

She's not giving him CPR you can tell in her voice she would be exhausted she would sound like she's been running and she's not

NO WAY she tried CPR. She told the 911 operator he had blood coming out of his mouth. When they arrived, she was clean.

If she was actually doing this much CPR for this long she would be completely exhausted and out of breath. The fact that her voice has a similar clarity and tone throughout the whole call is disconcerting considering she’s supposedly trying to restart his heart during this…

Yes it would be amazing if you could report from the trial for us. If we lived anywhere near Florida we would come too! I don’t think this was an accident. She meant to keep him zipped in the suitcase as some sort of punishment but maybe didn’t realise he could die. She sounds impatient and annoyed

Her ex-husband was very smart making HER make the 911 call. I believe he told the police that she had wanted him to do it

Peter That’s exactly how I feel! Can’t wait to get my notice to appear in the mail! I used to dread that letter!! You, & others like you, have changed that!❤🎉

whoaaaa this case is crazy AF!!! Even as a professional Icannot imagine what this case was like to hear on the phone!!! Let alone represent her in court! Playing hide n seek???? WTF!!

I wonder how much or how little time the jury in this trial needs for deliberation

I love your content! I have spent an embarrassing amount of time watching your Sarah Boone playlist today. 😂

Just an FYI. I am a doctorately prepared nurse practitioner with may years working in the ICU many code blues under my belt. CPR when done properly absolutely breaks ribs.

It's so shocking to me that she never says anything like, Omgosh baby please be okay. Pleae don't leave. I mean anything! But it's just a big annoyance for her. And she's definitely not doing chest compressions!

I’m a EMS first responder there is no way to tell if CPR has been done on a dead person unless there was some sort of post Morton bleeding. On a person who survived CPR which I’ve done on my brother he was in a lot of pain the next few days. I told him he should be thankful he’s not in a coffin. I bet she takes the stand and gets convicted.

Could you cover all her previous lawyers motions so we can understand why she went through so many lawyers?

I am an RN and for him being so young his ribs probably would not be broken. If someone is elderly and their bones are brittle it is completely possible. I also have jury duty next week and am hoping to be picked!

I'm a nurse practitioner and actually just renewed my CPR certification last week... whether CPR is done right OR wrong, ribs can break. Generally, being alive is preferable to broken ribs. And usually, when it's done wrong, it's because people aren't pushing down enough, because they haven't locked their elbows, which is less likely to break ribs. I remember one of the first times I did real CPR in the ER while an intern, we worked on a guy for a whole hour and when it was my turn to perform compressions (pretty early on) we all heard the crack of a rib breaking. It's kind of creepy lol, even more creepy feeling it!!!. Unfortunately, the guy arrived DOA and was never revived.

Wow. It’s like it’s a inconvenience to her to try and save her boyfriend who she just let die! Omgoodness.

I can't wait for Sarah's trial. I'm only assuming it will be televised. A lot of us are going to be disappointed if it's not.

Hello Peter ! So happy your covering all these cases . I’ve been working so much lately haven’t caught lives.. but 100% catching up after the lives .

New subscriber! Love you and your dad’s expertise and the take on these cases!!!😊

Thank you, Peter! You're the best!

Thank you for your commentary. Difficult to catch you live but watching the replay. 1:43

Love this channel, thank you for your hard work.

Have just recently subscribed, really like listening to you breaking it all down for people like me that doesn't have a lot of knowledge to how it all works,I've like button as well.

New sub!! I've been following the Sarah Boone case since day one. Thank you for all you do to keep us informed Peter. 🤗

And the neighbors said they heard loud thud’s coming from the stairs inside Sarah’s apartment! And Jorge had bruises and marks from the slams on the ground, so he could also have had internal injuries that she never spoke about… 😢

I have only been called for jury duty once. I couldn't participate due to spine surgery. I was so bummed. Thank you for sharing you expertise!

🥳🎉 CONGRATULATIONS on 175K 🥳🎊

Thanks!

Sara keeps telling them to hurry- YET she waited , called her ex and even waited on him to put his puppy away and drive over , now all of a sudden she’s in a panic and wants them to hurry. When she says “ believe me I’m doing it (CPR) we know she decided to go outside and smoke. Fist thing she says when paramedics get there is “ can I quit giving him CPR now”.

Listening to the BEST!

I am watching the replay of this. Great cover. Interesting in this case

Yes!! I would love that in Orlando. Thank you!! ☺️🙌🏼

Just subscribed recently. l enjoy your takes from both sides.

I found your channel during the Murdaugh trial and I am getting caught up so I can follow you for the Sarag Boon trial. This one is crazy! I was on a civil jury in 2021 and it was a very sad case. We awarded damages above her victim's layers requested.

I got redirected, I wonder if it's a setting we all make on our accounts - like autoplay?

I had to leave the video and came back a day later. Love the content and how you explain!

My experience on jury duty several years ago, it was a horrible domestic violence case. The guy nearly killed his girlfriend. We found him guilty on all counts. After the verdict was handed to the judge and jury poled, the defendant jumped out of his chair and lunged at our jury. Deputies tackled him and sat him back down and the judge quickly dismissed us with escorts out of the courthouse. It was frightening because I was on the front row.

New sub here. I love your videos... You break everything down so clearly. Thank you!!!

Thanks Peter 🙂

Would love to see and hear it live. 😊

Thank you for the insight. Also, I didn’t get the redirect and went to your channel and found it. Wasn’t sure if there was a paywall. Peace!

Omg yes Peter!!! I would love to hear your perspective from sitting in at the Sarah Boone trial.

If you were able to become our eyes during some of that suitcase trial, it would be awesome..I vote yes! I have loved your channel from your early days of the Ronnie O'Neal trial. Remember that crazy one? 🤪 Thank you for always giving your honest, fair, and intelligent opinion.. I am truly excited with all your efforts and your personal teaching style, you make it easier for the lay person to understand and/or any (future Jurors)..Justice always matters, and understanding the rules of the court system and how it works definitely helps figuring out the rest of confusion... You do a great job!! Congrats for all your efforts!! Blessings and prayers to you and your entire family, from a lil old Nana of 3 in NC🥰

Love hearing your opinion lots of love from Scotland UK ❤

Oh.. I didn't know it was LIVE! I thought you were reposting the video from yesterday. This is cool 😎

If she says we were playing hide and seek and I feel asleep again I'm gonna scratch my eyes out.

Ii was in the Army. Thanks for all you do.

Andersonville, Tennessee here!

This will be an interesting trial for sure!! It is so sad and shocking at the same tim. I am Looking forward to your breakdown' of this trial.

"I put him in the suitcase, we were playing," & "we were playing hide n seek." I must have been playing hide n seek wrong all those years. Would have been much wasier if we put the person where we wanted them to be and then seeked to find them. 911 call is not good for her in that respects but I would like to know more about the injuries from ME. If he was unconscious and she put him in the suitcase after the fact and when he came 2, that is what we are hearing him pleading. Idk. Will have to wait for other reports of injuries.

Just another prespective Not a nurse or a medical professional, my experience from doing CPR come from being First Aid certified as a police officer. Most people do CPR with dispatcher guidance tend to use hand free if she is calling from a mobile phone (which is most likely) or would have to put down the phone if you are on land line because you need both hands for it. And if you use hand free, you are using omni directional mic, which will pick up background noise like crazy. And if you put down the phone or hand it to someone else, you wouldn't be talking on the phone. I neither hear noise (the phone conversation is crystal clear) and I didn't hear break or info relay from someone else, I don't think she is doing CPR.

I thought it was interesting to hear you talk about whether or not you would take a case or choose to work with a potential client. I would love to watch an entire video about what that is like and some examples. How does that go? Are there interviews? When do you decide and how do you know? Do you have cases you regret taking (no judgement, my attorney friends definitely have their less than favorite clients and cases)

If she “put him in” then who was he hiding from??

You know what peaked my interest...her voice volume never changed from talking to dispatcher to talking to guy giving advice on cpr. So either she was on speaker the whole time (but didnt seem far away) or she somehow was doing CPR either phone pinned to here ear and the phone wasnt moving enough to cause any sort of scuffling noise. I wonder if she was actually doing CPR or only started right before the emts walked in to make it seem like she was doing it the entire time. She seemed so annoyed having to count, like ugh 18 19 20.

New subscriber ..Madeira Beach FL love your channel

I also did not get redirected, but I am now in the rewatch.

OMG I didn’t realize you were here in Pinellas county!!

True, I'm a nurse who has done compressions fast enough, not buying it.

Replay crew !! Here to comment I"m interested in your on-site coverage of the SB trial....my sister will be also!

Watching you earlier and my youtube shut down totally. Had to restart phone to get back on.

Great video

Been Member for 8 months today! This case is unreal. Jeez when she said SHE put him in I gasped! Wrong thing to say. Love this channel!!!❤

I always miss your lives. How do I know when u go live? I’m not getting notifications

Replay crew for both today. Fascinating case, she’s something else this Sarah Boone

I think they fought. She either pushed him or he fell down the stairs and was unconscious at the bottom. I think she then panicked and put him in the suitcase. At some stage he came to, she decided to keep him in the suitcase as a form of punishment. Then went to bed.

Weirdest funeral I ever went to was for a lifelong alcoholic. The family was sad but also there was a sense of relief that the abuse was over. I don’t know if she did it on purpose but I could see how a part of her was relieved that he was gone. This would be a hard one to be on the jury. Definitely a toxic relationship that will be hard to untangle.

YES! Would definitely enjoy LYK in the courtroom--it would be interesting and informative. Hope it happens!!

Did not get redirected. Catching on the replay.

i'm loving this case, wow i wathced the first one you did today, i didn't realise she's been i prison for 3 years already, .i remember feeling very claustrophobic for her in her interrogation in that small room where she didn't quite realise her freedom was gone. then there's the video clip from your first video that shows Jorge in the suitcase asking for help. wow that's real claustrophobia. i can't believe i'm even able to watch this, i hate enclosed spaces. but i'm enjoying it. i feel sorry for her, she got the wrong boyfriend for her personality. she did a bloody stupid and morbid act but she won't do it again. my mind weighs up these things when it comes to sentencing. what's the point her being in jail? it would be great if she could get out but be punished forever by being micro managed every hour and limited to access to entertainment, contact and treats while still having the basic semblance of a normal life. then she maybe would have a more realistic idea of remorse.

I didn't get redirected on RU-vid either, but got my notification. Liked both. 👍

I have a fascination with Sarah because she is just a roller coaster of a human. Your many videos on her made me subscribe and hit the bell. I wanna see a discussion of every letter! I do not fear people I cannot understand, but hold a morbid curiosity about them... from a very safe distance. As my sister, who survived my abusive biological family as much as I did, which is why we "adopted" one another as sisters, said, "Not understanding people like that is a good thing. It says you are sane and upstanding."

Some "hide n' seek" game that was! Boone knew where he was hiding--she put him in the suitcase, and with a faulty zipper to boot. She was annoyed with the man on the phone because she knew that her boyfriend was already dead! She told the operator that. All the pumping of his heart from that point on was futile! She knew it! If you watched the interrogation, she was rather abrupt and cocky with the interrogators. I think at first, she felt they were her buddies and that she was going home. She was the one who put Jorge in the suitcase and left him and went to bed intoxicated. Plus, she videotaped him in the suitcase. She's one shrewed operator, that one! Good Lord!

I think her defense’s biggest obstacle is going to be mitigating her personality. I realize it isn’t fair but something about her is just so off putting to me. I can’t help but think it will affect her likability to the jury.