Madden NFL 24 is TRASH! Gamer's Enquirer Review 

This is the worst madden I’ve ever played. Never buying again

Game flat out blows. Madden needs to give up sell the game and let somebody else try.

I am a casual gamer who recently bought Madden 24. I love franchise mode in sports so that's where I started playing. It was OK until about week 12, and my starting receivers would play one play and then they would be replaced for the rest of the game. I couldn't figure out what happened and then I poked around on RU-vid and figured out it was due to the fatigue system and they were too fatigued. It's a cool idea to have cumulative fatigue over the course of the season, but seems like this goes too far. But what made less sense is that because of fatigue, my wideouts essentially sat out the last 4 games and I kept them out of reps in practice. Based on that then, they should have been well rested for the playoffs. But nope, they stayed fatigued. By the time I got to the Super Bowl I had back up fullbacks playing receiver.

Madden still got the same commentary since 17

The overalls don’t mean anything for the teams. The browns are and 87 overall and every year they get 5 wins. With the 9ers they’ll either get 3 wins or 14 wins. With no injuries too

This is why i just keep playing madden on ps2 and 360.

This is what happens when only one company can make a football game

That's y they got it from 69.99 to 13.99 right now. If it was really that good it wouldn't be that low, God of war and spiderman ain't never dropping that low

Worst madden in my opinion as well. Momentum and passing mechanics are trash. Stop trying to reinvent the wheel. It’s football.

The players in the game are so bad. Your fastest WR's move like slugs and don't beat anyone on any route. CPU Defense players teleport 8 yards just in time to break up a game saving pass. O Lines collapse after 3-4 seconds (RIP if your QB can't run) I don't even know why I asked for it for Christmas. Now I feel bad that I made someone feel compelled to spend money on this garbage to gift it to me.

Madden 23 gameplay was better even it was trash. 24 is the most glitchiest Madden ever.

My opinion might be a bit unpopular. The graphics are horrible compared to other games on the same console. The body sliders really don’t even make a difference at different weights so why put it in there The bodies of the player models are horrible, the skeletons they use make the bodies look worse QB flak jackets are just absolutely atrocious, it’s like the visual designers took a width slider and maxed it out it looks so bulky it’s ridiculous The combine workouts don’t even effect your ratings, because they already have set ratings for height and weight, so the combine only effects your drafts stock, while in past maddens with the combine, it effects your ratings so honestly the combine was complete filler, there’s no need for it if it doesn’t effect your ratings. The presentation is extremely bland and repetitive. Just seeing the madden 24 logo it looks so bland and generic, not to mention the scoreboard and ticker display is horrible The game looks like a 4 remaster of an Xbox One ps4 era madden, it looks horrible It’s still animation based and has frequent animation glitches cause the game can’t decide which animation it wants to use during certain situations in the game Mini games don’t feel like they used to, it’s like they just threw something together and put it out And overall, the game just looks and feels lifeless and uninspired I bought the game played it for a few days to try to get into it, deleted the game and went back to 23

We MUST come together and make them change now. I will be making a petition to sign later . Also filing a small claims lawsuit . EA , time for the robber to get robbed .

They should bring classic historic teams like the 2012 ravens 2016 cowboys and Michael Vick on the falcons

3:18 The touch pass was in Madden 23 too, and possibly earlier installments as well. It's not even new to Madden 24. Pass blocking and outside run blocking is still broken because the game is using the same trash engine that Madden has been built on since like 2013. This series fell off hard and it's been totally absorbed into the black hole that is MUT. Until competition is restored amongst multiple football video games I doubt it will ever change.

good review but you missed a point on the positions because the positions are the same as madden 23 with you picking between QB,HB,WR,LB(MLB),CB basically you can't play as a FS,SS,FB,LT,RT,LG,C,RG,RE,LE,DT,K, or P like the oldeb days last time we even reached up to SS was madden 16 and that's sad. This game is awful there's glitches in all levels i was close to breaking my controller due to this shit. In madden 07 and 08 ps2 you can play up to special teams as a player especially if you're someone new to football and try to get up to speed and even kicking is skillful back then especially with the right stick.

I only enjoy franchise mode and its ruined. It's bad enough nothing has really changed in 10 yrs but the glitches in Franchise mode ruin everything. Players with wrong numbers changing skins, its sad. I havent bought in four years and I may never buy again. THIS GAME IS DOO DOO!

I bought it on sale. It still wasn't worth it. Nope. Cold turkey never buying another. This did it. I skipped 7 maddens up until this one. If 2k does one ill buy but never EA again.

I have had enough until the NFL allows someone else to make a football 🏈 game I am done they will not get another $ out of me. It’s so horrible the oline is still stupid there is pass interference on like every play. Going against the cpu is beyond pathetic. They know every play. They need to trash this game

Ea basically just been copy and pasting stuff since Madden 18. Same game engine same gameplay same glitches and bugs. Little additions here and there, but it's basically Madden 18 with updated rosters.

If they were smart they'd start remastering the 2000s madden games with that loose arcadey feeling movement when the series was actually Madden. Also remaster NFL Street 1-3 and then reboot that series without fking it up.

I wouldn't play this game for free it's currently on sale on xbox x/s for 30 usd. I would rather spend 100 dollars for a new improved better football simulator , a 💩 game is gonna stink regardless the price tag

It's a football game not a RPG . Any one born after 2000 need to understand its not about you.

Madden could be amazing but they just keep repeating year after year

I think the worst part is superstar mode especially when you get drafted to same team over and over after restarting so many times

Me and friends got this game first Madden bought in years only to find out we can't have a crossplay franchise which is the only reason we got it

I'll never buy another Madden or 2k video game

Ain’t no way this guy said the graphics and character models were good. This game has made billions of dollars over a decade. The fact that this game doesn’t have graphics like god of war or the last of us is an absolute disgrace. It should look like I’m watching the game on NBC.

The game has been 34.99 or 27.99 for months already 😂 they are desperate to sell it

I bought the game a few days ago for $27 and it’s still not worth the amount. I quit playing before the first quarter ended. Player models look weird and they jacked up simple things like the spats on the cleats. Just looks weird. I really don’t have faith in the college games that’s coming. Madden 22 is a better game to me.

Please bring back NFL 2K

Can't play as a ss. That's my favorite position to play besides qb. Why remove it?

This makes me sad. Huge Eagles fan and I want to play with the current roster.

I agree with you it is the worse madden I ever played and the fact that it’s is on ps5 and this bad speak volumes it no longer a realistic football game it very glitchy and unrealistic

Madden is a gambling app.

*Trashes the game for 9 minutes* Still recommends buying it. We buy it because there's no competition. Which is exactly why they don't make it "ground breaking". Why would they when we still give them our money? This is technically our fault. EA has been the same for decades.

Dude its upsetting the HOURS i spend gettin a good team then i play H2H and get killed by idiots playing bs. Its trash

Is Madden 24 really that bad? I have a pc and thought about getting it just because I haven’t played a madden game since probably 2014 when the PS4 came out! But grew up play Madden in the early 2000s

So far, I have deleted it from PS5 and then PC. Only paid for it on PC to play it with mods. Mods never would work, so the game had to be deleted. I refuse to play it without mods. Unbearable to play this game.

Give the rights back to 2k mane

They have it on sale now for $13.99. Is $14 bux worth it? Never played any madden game before.

I like the simple days of madden like the SNES versions

On franchise. I won a game. They marked it as a lost with a totally different score. And one game I won. It didn't save. Had to Sim it all over

Madden is fickle . It plays decent , then it plays trash . This is the laggiest Madden ever .

The last madden I ever bought was M19.

I just paid $13 for this game. I still feel ripped off. Still trash water!

Both fifa 24 and madden play terribly you see a lot of stuttering you didn’t use to see and the game pace is so alow

Ah you’re a Washington fan. A man of culture

I still got 3 hrs left on my 10hr trial.

Is it worth it for $35? I see it target I debate cause college is coming in 6-7 months. I just don’t think it’s worth it now. Am I wrong?

Yall probably cant wait till madden 25..smh

Still playing madden 21 updated my own rosters been done with it

Pretty good review

Same old pig of a game with fresh 24 lipstick. EA should be giving the game away for free by now. Just make a game that works is it that hard.

It’s even worse post patch 😂😂😂

Go back to the old Madden

Trash cheating game, And it’s not the same as madden 23 at all

Yeah i dont like

I think this is the best madden in yrs.