I am impressed with some of my old Too Faced eyeshadows, I feel bad to own 10+ years old shadows but they perform amazing still. I feel validated with your video today 😅
I haven’t watched the video yet but I just saw your comment and oh my gosh YES?! I’m currently using one of my OLDEST palettes - the too faced natural eyes in the tin packaging - and I’m super impressed with the eye looks I’m getting out of it still!
I'm really impressed by my old Too Faced and Tarte. They all hold up great. I also really enjoy the formulas for satins and metallics in them, I enjoy the more updated sparkly and high shine formulas too but especially the old Too Faced metallics are better than anything today IMO, they beat ND and PMG easily. Super creamy, highly pigmented and smooth, great shine, easy to apply w brush, don't crease. Companies just stopped doing these. Also the satins in older palettes are lovely to use and look great on the eye