Mario, but UH something is VERY wrong with Toad... 

-"uhhhh, Toad...WHAT THE HECK bro?" 🤏...-"Mama-mia!"

BTG: This isn't scary. Random hand: Oh really.

Right when you said this isn't that scary you got jumpscared

This game has the Meta horror vibe for sure. This was amazing. The full release would be amazing if they can keep this vibe to it.

When the game looked all glitched it looks like when you put an NES cartridge in wrong and it's all dirty

Maybe Toad is hungry, he's not himself when he's hungry. Someone get Toad a Snickers, stat!

The crazy toad chase with the SMB2 boss fight song was so awesome! I hope they make a full version soon

BTG: This channel is family friendly. Also BTG:

Toad had enough being in the wrong castle

0:25 That's a funny name for a horror game

i wish lair could play this himself too

This toad is a little strange 0:09 ...

BTG: Family friendly channel! The game: Toad is dead. BTG: Blood doesn't exist! What you're seeing is ketchup! Look! The game: Toad is condimenting. (joke don't kill me) (See replies.)

Back away slowly then run! 😂 Definitely not for younger audience or it's nightmare city; thanks for sharing!

I always knew blue toad was the best, at both platforming and murder

Oh no what is Todd doing?!

I’ve seen this creepypasta game before so when I saw the title and thumbnail I was like “JUST Toad?” It’s a fun take on the mario creepypasta genre for sure.

I feel so sorry for Luigi, he is seriously having a bad day, i wonder if Peach has been turned into a demon as well.

Yellow is the best color. Everyone does love that color.

Now, THIS is a game that Sonic XL should play!

3:56 WHOA

"This isn't scary" Giant Hand:"Allow me to introduce myself "

its cool to see people make his own stories of mario. creative stories and the most famous kind of mario stories is the exe ones where the guy who tell the story is the guy who chases you[exe] and more

Man… this is so crazy! What a weird game!

This is the nightmare Mario was having at the end of Super Mario Bros. 2.......Probably 👀

Haven't watched it yet, but I'm sure my kid will love it. The Nightmare before Christmas is too scary but she loves creepy peach and cursed goomba.

YES! A HORROR GAME! AND A RETRO-ISH HORROR GAME! WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Time to Play SMB2! All the Characters look . . . interesting . . . except Luigi. Also note that the ROM in the PAL version of the game, maybe this will be important. This looks perfectly normal . . . nothing seems wrong with this. HAND! Hello Mario! That's no ketchup, it'sa PASTA SAUCE! MARIO! YOUR FACE! Long walk in the woods, oh hey random disembodied voice and OH MARIO! NO! You Squooshed Weegee! Dang, the Emulator crashed! Luigi is being hung on a chain and he . . . broke it? I thought Toad was the strong one in SMB2 . . . oh well. VERY UPSET TURNIPS! I would so pick it up! Oh ToAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH WHAT IS THAT! RUUUUUUN! We locked Toad in! . . . watch him break out . . . and . . . turn Luigi into Pasta Sauce. Wait, is peach the voice? We haven't seen her. Weegee got punched! Welp, weegee probably is fine . . . actually. Fun video! Loved the horror game! I hope we see more of these types of games!

That demo was creepy especially.... Toad

Remember: theres still peach, birdo, wart, and everyone else. Plus the entire toad species that exists.

Hi Darby, Good gameplay!

That was very well drawn, congrats to the developers.

"I'm gonna map everything on my controller" I love you so much. Nerd. Lol

9:45 That shocked me!

This would be SO scary is Darby hadn’t been so nice and light harded

Poor toad 😢 He just wanted to go to bed

Are you gonna make another episode on the full game? I’d love to see it!

FINALLY, MY BOY TOAD GETTING SOME RESPECT! GOTTA LOVE THE MUSHROOM MAN!

Solid piece of advice. Don't watch this video at night. EVER!

BTG: heh, this isn't scary Mario.exe: *you will regret saying that*

There's also a non-Mario-but-Starfox-type-of-creepypasta fangame. It's called: Starfox.exe Widescreen edition. It also has loud noises in it. It's in Luigikid Gaming's .EXE direct. [And I saw Luigikid played it. I really hope you'll play it.

Mario feels like he can control everything

Oh no Toad is getting weirder but I think the comments are safe I hope

I like the exe games that actually have gameplay and not just cutscenes.

You’re my favorite channel on RU-vid!

why is every single exe game torture the second player

That first Toad Jumpscare caught me off guard!

That was spooky! Also, “ketchup.”

Awesome :) I jump scared with the hand bit lol

I'll stay tuned when you make another episode of this fun horror mod!

The full version would be a great game to play on Halloween. 👻🎃

"Mario, where did your face go?" Junji Itoh wrote this script.

You made the dialogs so funny

The mario with no face is actually called mutkifer, he could be infected by a virus, which is spreaded by sonic.exe, maybe mario was infected and now is called mutkifer (or mario.exe)

Not lying, that Toad scare was unnerving!

Right when Toad started to chase him at the start I had the willys

“This isn’t scary!” *enter big hand* “you sure about that?”

"This isn't scary!" *famous words before being clutched by the hand of god*

7:44 the fruit look like crying children

I also love how he can turn a horror game into slightly a comedy

9:03 be like: RED PAINT FOUNTIANS FOR 50¢! 10 LITER MAX.

I never thought I would say that I just got jump scared by toad

This is actually the first time you playing a horror game

I think it’s spaghetti sauce Mario and toad is trying to turn us into

Darby: "This isn't scary!" Hand:

I love how convincing it is at first, if you took a screenshot of that and told me it's just mario 2 corruptions i'd believe it

The game should be Super Toad Glitchy 2 (STG2)

This is amazing! Haha love the content keep up the awesome work Darby!

I love your vids they also helped me get to sky chase zone in sonic 2

Wow hopefully we'll see the rest of the cast,and what ever that no body voice is. ❤ please keep playing if possible 😊.

lol good job

Man I think Mario is just cranky, someone get him a snickers!

Welp i ain't having nightmares cause you made this funny and im glad

Dang! Toad has gone rage mode

I wonder what would happen if you managed to jump into a spot that Toad doesn't touch when he chases you that allows you to get behind him.

I love how you can only play as Luigi with it being terrifying. It makes since because of the Luigi’s mansion series

Toad gone mad!

Mario 2 from eBay be like:

Creepy indeed. However, not as creepy when you watched this in the morning.

Diagonal toad and diagonal mario

PLEASE STAND BY for a...... JUMP SCARE!!!!

Toad…was here…

The EMUNES at the beginning is an EMUlator of the NES

13:30 This image just makes me think that Luigi is just scared and that Mario and Toad are trying to Cheer him up(This does Mean its luigis bad dream)

I wonder if they're still working on this? It'd be cool to see a full game!

Good, a horror game about the Toad

As a mushroom myself, I can confirm that something is, infact, very wrong with that toad

Toad jumpscare is very great!

I'm ready for a spooky time! 🍄👻

bro stays calm during everything like wth

Uhhhh,Toad...what the heck bro👉...-mama-mia

Luigi is the best character to play as anyway so be need to play as the blobs

i saw this game before and why did u played this morning

I would like to recommend playing the Sonic hack "Sonic: Hellfire Saga". This is a very beautiful and cool hack and I think it deserves your attention.

I think it's interesting that the boss music for smb2 is better chase music than boss music

When Luigi gets squished he becomes too late .exe

Darby, you could probably any horror game not scary

Darby plays creepy mario games but m80 plays creepy sonic games and they are both awesome

POV: You bought Super Mario Bros. 2 USA Edition on the Dark Web

“Toad? Oh thank goodne- oh. Oh no.”

I love your videos and how talented they are!