Okay fine but there's a big difference between being critical and/or giving a negative critique of someone's food and just going out of your way to be an asshole to someone.
It’s a character. He won’t say that outside Masterchef ON CAMERA because of nda’s and the potential of him returning. All the chefs on that were judged critically and heavily like that by him all said he’s a nice guy, so.
im ok if the pride based on something real like what Gordon did, absolutely respect Gordon, but this fking Joe guy is just Stupidly Arrogance based on his ego and bully pride.
Worst part is compared to Graham, Gordon, Aaron etc Hes not even a chef, half the time he has no idea what hes even talking about when it comes to all the important cooking stuff.
Theres a difference between attacking and giving criticism. gosh why people these days using words misleadingly, im scared of future era communications
@@basedneutral1173lmao it's not that deep and he's right. Joe is just attacking people. Not even the food. One time he "critize" the plating not by mentioning it looks mismatched, or lack of contrast, or y'know any other technical term. He said "are you proud of this plating? I'm not impressed, it looks cartoony" like, how do you improve from that comment. What even is cartoony?
This man, rarely, RARELY offers good criticism towards ANY cook whatsoever. I understand that there is always a script. Yet becoming a mood killer over 15 episodes is way too much
@@jade7631ill be open minded, he does critique but he is out of pocket throwing food away without tasting it and judging food based on looks usually always and not on taste
@@jade7631you do understand they taste it before it was even served to them right.? They even explain this before final tasting and picking top 3.. plus Joe does help and gives really good cooking tips that actually help the contestants.. it's just overshadowed with how people like you only pick up on what he does during the final judgement.. if he's a bad judge then Ramsay won't invite him to judge over and over again.. I'm a massive MasterChef fan and Joe's tips and helpfulness rarely gets shown on the show but those rare instances you can see how he wants the amateur cooks to learn.. of course he's gonna be pissed if someone's not listening to advices and thinks what they're doing is correct and will wow the judges just to prove them right and the cooking is terrible.. I mean let me ask you this.. have you ever taught someone in the field of your expertise and they shrugged you off to the sides saying they know what they're doing just for them to prove you are right and they are stupid.? Irritating isn't it..? Well that's Joe for you.. Ramsay is also like that but he is much more constrained.. yet we see Ramsay can also be overboard like in Hells Kitchen where he teaches professional chefs what to do only for them to think they know better and fuck up..
@@A.jmmmm04I think on masterchef, other than taste, they also have to judge the food based on looks because they're trying to find the best homecooks from all of the US. So SOMETIMES simple isn't the answer. When you become the winner of masterchef you will open your own restaurant and so you have to be professional.
@@VIDEOHOMESYSTEM and he has no right to open his counterfeit mouth on the topic of food if it wasn’t for his mom and being able to coast by on her accolades. Joe embodies the essence of not earning your station and his criticisms strongly reflect how little he knows.
What your saying is people who can’t sing or dance can’t be judges on America’s for talents. Or only athletes can judge on Olympics or only criminal can be judges. You don’t need to be a chef to judge food. You just need to know food. Joe is a winemaker and restauranteur.
Yeah, after he said that, I kind of just lost respect for him because Christine was an amazing chef, and the fact that Joe called her a liability, even though she had so much talent just pissed me off so much.
He is totally correct. a blind person being a chef. how the hell does she know what the ingredients are. how does she not burn herself on the stove? How does she know the correct measurements for the ingredients. How does she know The correct temperature for the oven. It is totally ludicrous. 🤪. Off camera I am almost totally positive that there is someone helping her. she only won because they felt sorry for her and it was good for the show and it was politically correct
Right. Because only the most knowledgable should ever be allowed an opinion. Also Joe is extremely knowledgable. He owns a bunch of restaurants, his mom made millions off of cookbooks. Deal with it.
@@AlexDuWaldtin the nicest way possible: knowledge of cooking should absolutely not be measured by how many restaurants you own and that is a crazy criterion to suggest. Any Michelin-starred chef on Earth knows more about food than Salt Bae.
Except Cutter was indeed the most obnoxious and baffling contestant during that season. He reached the Top 5 yet he was consistently bad, only having a few good dishes. Not defending Joe, he's just as pretentious. Just saying that some of the cringe-inducing contestants at least get deserving nasty reviews.
@@frenchfriedbagel7035 Gordon Ramsay is on the same line as Marco Pierre White. Severe, strict, but willing to give advice in order for people to improve (if they have the right behavior and don't act all cocky and shit)
@@astrovisionbroadcastingunion Gordon does like to talk shit, but he usually and almost always does it in a jokey poking fun kind of way and doesn't really 100% meant what he said.
Remember the time when he said "do you miss your husband, well.. you might see him tonight" to a contestant who was not safe in the competition. Why tf would you attack someone's personal information in a competition.
He never gives feedback though, he just says disappointing, whenever contestants try to get creative he shuts them down, he thinks of food way too conservatively
@@basedneutral1173 Nothing I said is to the contrary, my point is that Joe doesn’t care about any of those factors. He’ll demean the contestant simply for the sake of it.
@@billqiu4692 Not really. He doesn't care more into creativity sh1t most of the times. If someone put so much detail over my food too, i wouldn't even enjoy eating it. Food is meant to be consumed and tasted, not for creativity or art. A normal steak is already beautiful naturally, don't need to ruin the fk of it.
@@basedneutral1173agreed. These judges clearly und that presentation is merely the surface level, though it does show what kind of chef they're dealing with.
@@YonkoBlackbeard lol no. The 1st restaurant he opened was not inherited from his parents. You probably just heard his parents were famous so you assume he just inherited everything 🤣🤣
So he does not feel bad. Should of asked him about the time he was mean to Christine ha. Cause she is blind she is a liability in the kitchen. He is not a judge he is a jerk how he was not fired is still crazy to me
OK that was a bad example of Cutter. He was actually asking an appropriate question and none of the judges actually gave him a non passive aggressive answer😂
People defend joe and say hes just "doing his job" no he isnt. he the amount of times he targets the food that he is supposed to "judge" is extremely lacking, and his ability to provide advice and give feedback, which is what judging entails, is similarly lacking, especially when comparing him to other judges on the show. Instead, he attacks the chefs themselves, being downright rude to many of them. You can be harsh as a judge, sure, but to be rude, discrimatory, and outright a bad person is simply unacceptable and, in his words, is "digusting".
When he congratulated the lady on having the worst dish he ever had and she smiled and said thank you and gordon covered his face trying not to laugh is still one of the funniest things ive ever seen on that show 😂😂😂😂
I refuse to believe that’s actually how he’s like and that he’s not just playing his character right here. Until I meet a person in real life, I won’t make any real judgements on them as a person. I’ll judge his made up character, just not him.
There’s a difference between criticising someone’s dish to help them improve vs criticising someone who’s tried their best and acting like their failure is some kind of moral wrong. He acts like he’s entitled to good food and anyone who doesn’t provide is disrespectful.
Extremely unlikeable chef even Gordon And Marco Aren’t as harsh as is him and they give compliments to the cooks food when its good and let them know when its bad even when a dish is good joe still has to find something wrong about it joe is just a bitter person and it shows
Criticizing and belittling someone are 2 different things. On that point, why is he even a judge? He gives the chefs ZERO constructive criticism on how to better their food. He probably can’t even articulate why a dish is bad nor what they could do to make it better.
So far Gordon Ramsay & Alvin Leung is my fav judges yes Alvin Leung throwing the food, but i really appreciate that he still taste the contestants dishes❤
A judge I respect is someone like chef Michael from Masterchef Canada. He gives you the good points and other things that can improve the dish. His decisions are final, but he still wants the best out of those home cooks. If it's blatantly bad, he'll also tell you why instead of slamming it into the trash right away.
Tearing down Tali was more than necessary and only Joe had the balls to call him out. Dude's delusional, proclaims himself a genius, takes no notes, no feedback and cooks subpar stuff.
Maybe that's why people inside the masterchef US competitions were and are so brute and frontal as shown on camera, recorded. *Because the society Has Normalized Insults as Constructive Critizism* And that's why i stopped watching the US version a long time ago and switched to Australia's version.
i like Joe a lot, to me he is honest, some of them need to be put in their places, so many have big egos and he's good at taking them down a notch, well done!
theres so many ways to go about criticizing something or trying to give some constructive criticism/feedback and this dude just ignores all of them and just belittles and bullies the contestants. he acts like he’s the only judge in the room and that each and every dish made is going to directly impact him for life. i’d much rather be told it stinks but given tips on how to improve rather than be told it’s a complete and utter disgrace and basically drain all the hope out of people
I remember one of the dishes he just slammed down the trash can. It was a bunch of cut fruits with a sticked poked on top of every piece. I mean, when you are faced with a "dish" like that, how do you even say anything to improve it. It's utter trash.
