@@WhamBang First time I saw "touch grace" it immediately occured to me it's similar to "touch grass" which was incredibly funny to me, I hope that was the joke
Not much was lost. She barely appears even when resting before the graces. I quite literally spent enough time playing game for me to *completely forget* she was in it, that's how miniscule her role in the overall adventure is.
The only way to save Melina is to inherit the Frenzied Flame, burn the Erdtree yourself, and heal yourself from the Frenzied Flame with Miquella's Needle. But she will still leave you
well yeah, the needle doesnt kill the flame, it only seals it. you aren't healed, the flame is still in you, its only being held at bay by the needle. If anything were to happen to you, or the needle, the world is fucked so of course she'd leave you after you had done something that stupid (stupid from a lore perspective, not a player or gameplay one).
@@jasoncarnelian3325 whata the source of that tho?the item description of the needle says its 'Capable of subduing the flame of frenzy'. nothing about only sealing it.
@@jasoncarnelian3325 not it means 'bring under control'. It only works for millicent temporary but for us it works permanently as we use it outside of time in Plasidusax boss arena
@@JakeDavidRoberts that doesn’t change anything, it’s beside the point. yes it is sealed permanently because of the needle. But if the needle gets damaged, or destroyed? If you, the host, gets killed, or even fatally wounded? Given the flame is tied to the outer gods is a safe assumption that if the integrity of the host or needle is jeopardized at all at any point that flame is busting out and consequences would be catastrophic. The flame never should have been touched. That’s beside that fact that taking it in the first place is a severe lapse in judgement at best that Melina rightfully scorns you for. There is no justifying that decision.
If you don't betray her, she dies. Lore wise it's extremely heartbreaker. You become a lord at the price of your maiden, or you would burn it all just so she lives.
Everyone in the game tells you it's the worst ending because none of them can truly understand how irrevocably broken the world is. Each of them believes it can be fixed---MUST be fixed---in the way that THEY believe is correct. All the other endings do is replace one set of terrible circumstances for another. Every character in the game is tied to their own specific despotic ideology that places their own interests first. They are all demagogues. Burning it all down is the only way to truly set everything straight once again, allowing it to restart. This is a pure reflection of the true reset of the Souls universe that allows the Fire to fade and the cycle to begin again.
@@currentlyspeakingbmwmusic1793 in a way, melina embodies the driving force of living creatures after you become the embodiment of entropy by inheriting the frenzied flame. It's poetic, in a way, that melina is essentially granted life's infinite desire to push on and survive, in the same way that in everyday life, will and order trump chaos and entropy
“No matter how ruined this world may become. No matter how mired in torment and despair, life prevails. Births continue.” “There is beauty in that, is there not?” That one and and the next really stick with me as her first trying to convince you and then realizing it’s not goings to work and just start desperately begging you to stop. “Please inherit not the frenzied flame. Those who would are not fit to be called lord when the land they preside upon is lifeless.” This game really gets to me.
A sick kind of beauty indeed. Life itself being idiotic enough to keep birthing poor new souls onto the world filled with torment and despair. And admitting it to be beautiful in of itself. Fucked up beyond belief. Sickening.
Yes, births continue. Births of the Omen and the Misbegotten, people who have been punished for generations for crimes their forebears committed that they have no hope of atoning for. Theirs is an existence of misery through no fault of their own. Not even an Elden Lord can reverse their misfortune. But the Frenzied Flame can.
@@theusher2893 except there are no more births, the ff ending kills all life, if you want to save the omen and the misbegotten then chose the dungeater ending
@theusher2893 no it can't, imagine how much of a psychopath you have to be thinking that killing them all is how you save them. As long as there is life there is opportunity. The slaves from the past irl had it worse than the misbegotten people and even they desired to fight and for their future generations to live. Frenzied flame is just for cowards who think death solves the problem.
it's their job to say that they WILL kill you no matter what, but they still die. But at last, they can not win since only we have the power of the Main Character
Maybe in the next game she will bring someone that will kill you, you the player are now tasked with taking down your former self, the frenzied flame lord.
@@justalockheedf-117nighthaw7 To answer you,I know for sure I won't be able to buy it,plus it's a multi-ending game which is fun to check the options Plus as an artist and fan I like to see as much as I can to stay lore accurate
She misunderstood the whole plan😅. I wanted to save her so I used frenzied flames to burn myself then used the needle from milsent quest at azula to stop the frenzied Flames then I did ranni's ending because it's the best ending for everyone.
@@Chara_Murdererr They thought of that, but characters in fiction don't have to be aware of everything and know everything that's going to happen. Melina maybe doesn't know about that arrangement and the ideas the Tarnished have for themselves. It's natural that she thinks you're going to fully embrace the Frenzied Flame ending. People should start thinking how human logic and natural writing works before judging scripts and narratives.
You didn't save her. You just give her an eternal suffering for whole life. She doesn't need a hero to save her life, and you disrespect her need as she said.
Probably how you should be feeling given that your ending the world when you could be fixing it. And you also kill torrent by doing the flame of frenzy ending betraying your one constant companion and the one who chose you as his rider.
how the hell did I unlock this ending by accident... seriously I was just wandering around the world and after opening a door that I thought was path to a new area, melina appears and tells me this...
Imagine she’s actually terribly weak and doesn’t give enough runes to level up for the point you are at Because the point is that the real challenge was actually killing the one person who actively aided you all this way
@MothmanOfficialWva i dont think devs mKe fun choices like this, its probably going to be the same old dark souls experience with out anything experimental I mean, adding a jump button was a game breaking change for them lmao
@@clover9725 I don't think they will do it in the DLC (it wouldn't make much sense), but to say they wouldn't do this sort of thing is completely wrong, when they literally did exactly this in Sekiro, their previous game. In Sekiro's bad ending, there's an exclusive boss fight against Emma, who has a very similar role to Melina as basically your 'maiden'.
I didn't know how to feel. I was so invested in the chaos flame i thought it is the right choice for me. But the way she threatens you makes you overthink your decisions.
Okay so i didn't rest at that grace so i totally missed that warning and i remember someone comented that you need to undress by the gate so i tried it not knowing it would instantly make my decision. I then rest after i get it and she threatens me like that i was just sitting there like woah that escalated quickly... lol@libraflame8263
“Didn’t mean to” > gets curious about leyndell > finds sewers > explores sewers > finds secret area > finds mohg the second > kills mohg the second > completes jumping puzzle > takes off clothes voluntarily > voluntarily meets 3 fingers and inherits frenzied flame > loses maidens > kills funny big fire man > burns giant tree > kills a good boi > kills first elden chad > kills god > becomes -elden lord- lord of chaos
It's not too late! You can forsake the frenzied flame. You have to save Millicent in Caelid, then defeat Placidusax in Farum Azula, and use the Needle while in that arena.
In the realm where I play the villain, your hatred may be my burden to bear, but your life, my love, will remain untouched. For if I take the path of the hero, the sacrifice demanded would be your very existence, and that, my dear, is a cost I'm unwilling to pay.
@@garfball3010 but if that os the case then you burn the erdtree and just die by doing it?then if you die what,you dont het to fight morgot godfrey and the final fight or what.
@@tonystarrk4859 Didn't she say that "I shall leave Torrent with you", when we got her to the Capital? She phrased that as if she very much had a choice in the matter.
I’m prepping for the DLC and I see a lot of people seem to have discourse about the endings in this comment section, the only thing I’ll say is there really is no best/good ending or bad/worst ending. You either follow a demigod bound to repeat the past mistakes, Become the elden lord ensuring that nothing changes, or become the frenzied lord while unleashing chaos upon the land. All have their cons, so choice is yours.
Chad tarnished take the frenzied flame, use it to burn the erdtree and save Melina, then use Michelle's needle to go for a different normal ending. If only we had the opportunity to *tell* her that's the plan, dammit
Well the needles don’t remove the influence entirely, just halts it. You’re still a carrier for the flame, essentially, and I doubt Melina would be chill with that.
They should have added a dialogue when you use the frenzied flame to burn the erdtree, and purified yourself after from the frenzied flame with the needle so she didn't have to sacrifice herself. I think it should even unlock another ending where Melina thanks you and becomes Elden Lord.
I don’t regret about choosing becoming of the lord of frenzied flame, but what i mad about is how devilish they make my character looks. I chose my character to have beautiful blue eyes, but now as soon as i chose to become the frenzied flame lord, he has a pair of golden snake eyes! I am feeling very mad about it. I couldn’t get it changed. I spent almost an hour to make my character look fabulous, but now everything is ruined.
Go to the Mirror in Fai's room in Roundtable Hold. Go to the eyes option, and turn off eye alteration. That will remove the Frenzied Flame visual from your character's eyes.
pfft, you can't kill me, lightweight Thanks for letting me keep the magic horse, though. That would have been a pain if the game took the horse away that late
just inherit the frenzid flame and then use the pin Millicent gives you (it cures madness) and you will be able to get the age of stars ending without killing melina
This was one of the only bad parts about the frenzied flame ending, hearing Melina’s disappointment in you after finding out you inherited the frenzied flame.
Hahaha wouldn't it be really funny if I spent my first playthrough going for the Ranni ending, messing this side quest up by completing the Frenzied Flame questline and then realizing you have to complete Milicent's questline and defeat Malenia to undo it hahah? I totally wasn't so salty I completed that blood soaking for Varre by using Hyetta in NG+.
I was so irritated because I allowed the maiden to Trick me . she was so polite. Wanting me to give her grapes. That I got trapped into that ending.And I could not beat millennia. So😢 I erased the entire game and started over again. So now I left her down in the pit for eternity, On my second play though I beat Molina. but The maiden she will still stay in the pit for ever...
People be saying that getting the Frenzied Flame ending is the best for Melina as she is alive and give her a purpose. I truly believe that letting her burn the erdtree and scarifies herself is the best option for her. That is her purpose, she even thank the player wholeheartedly for letting her doing it while also making them as Elden Lord.
How do you get this dialogue? Is it from inheriting frenzied flame before the fire giant? I'm at the ashen capital, then inherited but never got this dialogue.
So how is she going to try to kill us when we have essentially killed everything and we are basically the strongest most powerful entity in the verse now? I’m genuinely curious