Тёмный

Men’s Mental Health And The Hard Truth 

Chris Williamson
Подписаться 2,8 млн
Просмотров 3,3 млн
50% 1

Watch the full episode here - • Gymshark CEO Explains ...
-
Get access to every episode 10 hours before RU-vid by subscribing for free on Spotify - spoti.fi/2LSimPn or Apple Podcasts - apple.co/2MNqIgw
Get my free Reading List of 100 life-changing books here - chriswillx.com...
-
Get in touch in the comments below or head to...
Instagram: / chriswillx
Twitter: / chriswillx
Email: chriswillx.com...

Опубликовано:

 

30 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,2 тыс.   
@ChrisWillx
@ChrisWillx Год назад
Full episode here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QfKwidYQW6M.html
@BushBanditGuy
@BushBanditGuy 8 месяцев назад
The link isn’t available?
@_cloudface
@_cloudface 8 месяцев назад
​@@BushBanditGuy Links haven't worked for RU-vid Shorts for a long time but apparently most "big creators" or their employees don't actually bother watching RU-vid Shorts to know this. They also don't read comments so they just keep posting links despite people saying they don't work.
@antonysloan6110
@antonysloan6110 8 месяцев назад
Lazy bastards mate lazy bastards what are you going to do about it we’ll looks like this preacher is er nothing 🤣
@alaakela
@alaakela Год назад
This isn't only for men. That "what are you going to do about it" line is a life changer for every young person.
@greyaliien
@greyaliien Год назад
Right but they are talking about men here. It's important to distinguish between the lived experience between genders as they're different and as he highlighted in the beginning sometimes applying a universal solution doesn't help
@sideburnsandwich1119
@sideburnsandwich1119 Год назад
It’s not advice only for men but there aren’t numerous organisations or programmes that exist solely to support or encourage men. If a boy doesn’t learn that his problems and shortcomings are his responsibility to solve and overcome, no knight in shining armour is ever going to ride up and save him just because he has a pretty smile.
@debbiewilder4738
@debbiewilder4738 Год назад
​@@sideburnsandwich1119 It made it very clear that these are the main things that men deal with women want to be loved and men want to be honored so hes not saying that women don't want this. He's saying that it's a lot more important for men to meet their needs.
@diamondgarcia9409
@diamondgarcia9409 Год назад
Yes
@debbiewilder4738
@debbiewilder4738 Год назад
@@greyaliien i like to know those organizations?
@cryco472
@cryco472 Год назад
As a woman, the best cure for my depression has always been to be able to implement actions that can better my situation. Aka I need to feel capable & empowered, like he described for males. I don’t know how legitimate that gender distinction actually is in this scenario…
@Chrismontt
@Chrismontt Год назад
I say the most problems women have is accountability and respect... Modesty is something I don't see anymore!!!
@callanc3925
@callanc3925 Год назад
Thats the best cure for most depression because depression is a symptom of not doing the basics correctly in 95% of cases. For most people with "depression" all they need to do is fix their diet, fix their sleep, fix their exercise, fix their routine and they'll feel better. Mental health is much more than depression, in fact depression is often a symptom of physical health not mental health. Most women find talking through their problems to be the most effective way of making them feel better, hence why its so common for women to get mad when their partner tries to fix her problems instead of just listening. Most men find talking through their problems to be pointless if the focus isnt on solving the problems, which is why its so common for men to not open up to their partners very much. The man wants to fix the problem but the woman thinks she just needs to listen to him talk about it.
@Chrismontt
@Chrismontt Год назад
@@callanc3925 I like the way you see things but Depression for me is not just be able to sleep or going to the gym, I'm bipolar so for me its very different and I have a childtrauma wish is a really hard to understand I wont go into detail but for some if you do the basic is not enough for me I learn to cope and learn to adapt to things and still I felt like I didn't belong but it take time and it's a fight I will have to deal my entire life happiness for me is the little thing in life even if for you sound banal for me I get happy if a get 8hr of sleep hehe
@anaximanderofapollonia9842
@anaximanderofapollonia9842 Год назад
To feel capable and empowered? I have no desire to feel capable and empowered. I want to be capable and to be capable is to have power.
@petercameron2137
@petercameron2137 Год назад
I think as a generalization what he is saying is pretty accurate. It's not that men and women can't both use the same stratagems to solve personal problems. It's that in the male experience men are being fed lines of resoning and solutions for life that don't actually focus on accountability and personal improvement. Not saying that's not what you do- but i've been to talk therapy for a long time and there's only so much you can be made aware of before having to take things into your own hands. Men are told to accept their emotions and it's valid to cry and just sit with pain, but personally speaking- and i think some people will agree with me on this- men really only benifit incrementally from that kind of advice. Men need more kicks in the ass than pats on the back.
@lexaneli
@lexaneli Год назад
Kudos to his dad.💪🏾✊🏾. Great dad instilling life long lessons to his son. This is why good parenting is important.
@doomincarnate
@doomincarnate Год назад
I keep saying we need both perspectives to be a well rounded person
@nadinekore6308
@nadinekore6308 Год назад
You're so pretty Chris Williamson xx
@Yaara1115
@Yaara1115 Год назад
I heard about a woman whose husband was depressed and had PTSD after serving in a war (Yom Kippur war, Israel). So she took in as a foster family sick, unwanted babies whose parents abandonedatbthe hospital . Over the years, they took in over 70 babies. She said she initiated it so that her husband would see that some people have it worse than he does, and so that he would feel the need to help her take care of them. Maybe it made him feel capable again.
@barbaraweber3084
@barbaraweber3084 Год назад
I have never thought about this before....good stuff.
@greg9069
@greg9069 7 месяцев назад
Strong as an ox.. even an ox needs a rest sometimes.
@purple_king6131
@purple_king6131 5 месяцев назад
Thing like that tells me instantly he is not ok
@manoo2056
@manoo2056 Год назад
Everything is bs. Your path is your path and you always do the best you can.
@fabianpatrizio2865
@fabianpatrizio2865 Год назад
follow Stoicism....common sense, temperance, wisdom, courage....take on what you can control, not what you cant control....
@isobelnicolson4866
@isobelnicolson4866 Год назад
"What are you going to do about it?" Is literally the gold standard of parenting. Especially when closely followed by "ok. And why is that the best option?"
@ferinzz
@ferinzz Год назад
Wish he would have said that second part, because the part where the parent helps guide the child through the solution is the most important part.
@andrewogilvie9051
@andrewogilvie9051 Год назад
Everyone has sinned and we all fall short of God’s moral standard. And so the payment for our sins is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. So declare with your mouth, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, and you will be saved.
@cosmicvixxonalice6795
@cosmicvixxonalice6795 Год назад
Yep. Parenting and therapy. One of the best therapists I had let me vent and cry for 20 minutes and then asked, "What's your plan?" And he helped me make a solid plan. Did he treat me like a man or a person who needed a reminder to take control of what I can control, namely my actions? A person.
@cosmicvixxonalice6795
@cosmicvixxonalice6795 Год назад
​@@andrewogilvie9051 lol, do you mean the biblical god's moral standards of endorsing slavery, rape, and genocide? I'm more moral than your god. You probably are too, unless, of course, you also endorse those atrocities.
@artesque
@artesque Год назад
It's so good even moms can use it. It works on daughters too. And it empowers the person to make their own decisions, but it also shows that you are listening and that you care. Everyone deserves to feel acknowledged, capable, and loved.
@matt_cartwright5782
@matt_cartwright5782 Год назад
💯 spot on. Children need strong male role models. Otherwise they go off the rails
@jakesmith-bs4jd
@jakesmith-bs4jd Год назад
I agree. I’m an only child raised by a single mum. I’ve never had a dad, grandad, uncle, brother or even close male friends. I haven’t gone off the rails as such but I’m definitely not developing at the pace I should be. Got a lot of internal work to do.
@GaryAJMartin
@GaryAJMartin Год назад
Yes and no. Many men would give the boy a beating which doesn’t particularly help matters. There has to be a fine line, not too ‘strong’, not too soft.
@JerryGarciaPOBox
@JerryGarciaPOBox Год назад
My father taught me by example. Worked his butt off, switched to nights for 5 years to look after my brother and myself, never fought or yelled at my mother, always told me to pick my battles, to accept constructive criticism & so much more. We had a few difficult years(my fault) but never gave up on me. I'm middle aged and he's my best friend and greatest role model. Still I made some terrible mistakes in my life. A good father is just part of the equation. You have to use all those lessons to mold who you are & become.
@pcgameboy8407
@pcgameboy8407 Год назад
​@John Martin There is nothing wrong with a spanking. Discipline is good, and as long as it's done right, and the father still shows he loves and cares for his son that's fine. I got spankings from my dad, but he sat me down, gave me a hug, told me he loved me, and explained what I did wrong, and how to improve. Spankings showed the world will have consequences, and some may be physical. Also that there will always be people stronger, and bigger than me.
@GaryAJMartin
@GaryAJMartin Год назад
@@pcgameboy8407 I’m sure your son will/does love it.😉
@helgaioannidis9365
@helgaioannidis9365 Год назад
As a clinical psychologist I'd like to inform you that also female clients with depression don't profit from someone just "stroking their ego". I've treated men and women and all of them first need to accept their limits to be able to then set realistic goals.
@LeetTron5000
@LeetTron5000 Год назад
Yeah this is just stupid. Nothing here is Fair to the actual needs of depression between either gender. Depression isn't black and white.
@alivingamazonbox9370
@alivingamazonbox9370 Год назад
This is true however the issues surrounding men are far more underrepresented, so again this is true, but everyone knows this I understand what you are trying to do though 👍
@trueblissconsciousness2821
@trueblissconsciousness2821 Год назад
Yep, and these 2 guys are talking about a way of thinking that doesn't accept personal limitations.
@20quid
@20quid Год назад
These two men are also talking in a way that isn't applicable to all men or even the majority of men. It's only really applicable to men in their own subculture. The criticism they're levying against mental health treatment, that there is a one-size-fits-all approach to a highly individualised problem, is the exact mistake they then go on to make themselves when they generalise for all men.
@ifluxion
@ifluxion Год назад
My observation is that when women says they have a problem, it is less about the actual problem, but more about what the feel about the problem. When men says they have a problem, it is about the actual problem and their ability/inability to fix it. This is why women tend to benefit from just "talking about it", because it helps those feelings to settle down. However, men tend not to benefit from this because they don't have this feeling problem in the first place.
@elikravitz5344
@elikravitz5344 Год назад
Like many 1-minute social media hits, I think this raises a legitimate and important point while way oversimplifying a complex and nuanced conversation
@fletchercalderbank8498
@fletchercalderbank8498 Год назад
Agreed because I definitely feel a lot more capable, but I want to feel cared about and loved so I agree 😂
@justasomeone7860
@justasomeone7860 Год назад
I completely agree and love how articulately you said it.
@3CODKing
@3CODKing Год назад
K.I.S.S. "Keep It Stupid Simple" (or keep it simple stupid.) Most of the time simplicity is the answer
@justasomeone7860
@justasomeone7860 Год назад
@@3CODKing There's a big difference between simple and simplistic. It can often mean the difference between genuine understanding that is useful to a large extent, and seriously misunderstanding something in a way that has far-reaching, avoidable negative consequences.
@quinnholloway5400
@quinnholloway5400 Год назад
Feeling loved and cared about is important to me as a Guy, i want to feel that people honestly do want me to do good in life and be happy I dont need to be super strong or always in power I just want to keep a good sense that reminds me "i'm not alone, i have people who care about me, and i care about them as well"
@mjh277
@mjh277 Год назад
With a young boy, start with ‘how/what are you feeling?’ And end with ‘and what are you going to do about it?’ Develops emotional understanding and the recognition of responsibility at the same time
@zondernaam2040
@zondernaam2040 Год назад
I would say that counts for children in general
@mjh277
@mjh277 Год назад
@@zondernaam2040 absolutely true
@PlayshotKalo
@PlayshotKalo Год назад
We should do this for everyone tbh. We all need a healthy balance between our right brain and left brain. Nobody should be neglecting one side of their brain
@TheNebulon
@TheNebulon Год назад
​@@PlayshotKalo >me, sides of my brain looking like David and Goliath
@ilhamsharif000
@ilhamsharif000 Год назад
​@@PlayshotKalo that's not how brain works 😂
@yareyaredaz3522
@yareyaredaz3522 Год назад
One does not negate the other. When you go to therapy your therapist finds the root of your depression. For others its feeling unloved. For others its feeling powerless and useless. Most of the time you feel both. But one is the root of all the rest. No one treats male patients like they are female. Each patient is individual and theirs is a unique case.
@hboy8625
@hboy8625 Год назад
Wake up and join the real world
@o0alias0o
@o0alias0o Год назад
@@hboy8625 Ummmm their comment was a realistic and factual assessment of therapy. “Join the real world” That is so dramatic 😂
@clarkdavison40
@clarkdavison40 Год назад
@@o0alias0o Just wondering how you can state categorically that the comment is "realistic and factual" when the very next comment is from an actual female psychiatrist saying how useful the short is for her to hear from a man's perspective - because Men respond differently.
@fazelok
@fazelok Год назад
true. I feel like they in the video, and alot of republicans think that everything needs to be a certain way, that every tradition is a one-sized-fits-all thing, when it isnt. I mean, I get that democrats are garbage, but that doesnt mean every republican value is correct either
@devinhoyt2935
@devinhoyt2935 Год назад
Sadly nuance might make for good therapy but it doesn't make for good clicks.
@OGDeepStroke
@OGDeepStroke Год назад
“Be firm, but fair, be kind and courteous, but have a plan to correct”.
@therealmr.incredible3179
@therealmr.incredible3179 11 месяцев назад
Or -Be 6’4 -Be Scary Large -Be Rich -Be a Asshole
@stoyanpetkov3853
@stoyanpetkov3853 Год назад
As a psychology major and therapist intern, I can tell you that any (good) therapist would NEVER tell you that you are "okay the way that you are", whether you are a man or a woman. That defeats the point. If we want male depression to be treated with better understanding and approaches, we need more male psychologists.
@starinthesky8134
@starinthesky8134 Год назад
This statement makes it incredibly hard for me to believe you’re a psychology major. Have you by chance been sleeping though most of your classes?
@maearcher4721
@maearcher4721 Год назад
@@starinthesky8134 I had depressions for years, even to point i often thought of suicide. And you're wrong! So wrong! I've heard it million times...'Things are not so bad, it's ok to feel low, but remember tomorrow it's going to be better. You're fine..." That's not helpful-that's gasslighting! All sympathy, all words...0 real support. Most of time...telling me how i am actually ok for like 5 minutes...and not even letting me finish what I wanted to tell them! Not listening what I had to say...but telling me how I am ok...when I felt like throwing myself out window less than five minutes prior. ...It's not ok. And telling depressed person...that the way they feel is ok or normal...when they desperately want that feeling to stop...is pure insanity.
@stoyanpetkov3853
@stoyanpetkov3853 Год назад
@@starinthesky8134 No, I just actually listened to them. And to many multiple therapists have taught me. Have you? By telling a client "you are okay the way that you are", you only serve to reinforce their unhealthy / ineffective coping mechanisms.
@starinthesky8134
@starinthesky8134 Год назад
@@stoyanpetkov3853 so you’re saying it’s better to make patients feel bad about feeling bad? Like „hey you’re depressed, and you know what that’s not okay you piece of sh*t“ or „hey I know you’re feeling confused and scared about the future right now but that’s totally not acceptable“…. Pretty sure that’s the actually unhealthy thing
@CymruGoch_
@CymruGoch_ Год назад
@@starinthesky8134 you know there's a middle ground between those things right? Many therapists I've seen that have helped me have directly said what I was feeling wasn't normal or ok to feel, but that doesn't make me wrong or bad.
@gryranfelt5473
@gryranfelt5473 Год назад
Honestly, women need this, too.
@cryco472
@cryco472 Год назад
Agreed.
@knowahnosenothing4862
@knowahnosenothing4862 Год назад
The western cultural indoctrination is to infantilize instead of truly empower.
@Luke_wait_for_it_marengo
@Luke_wait_for_it_marengo Год назад
Agreed, but unfortunately we have different rules.
@xLegendaryPictures
@xLegendaryPictures Год назад
Father can't be really like that anymore or their wife will take half their shit. Not saying it doesn't work but once you have chosen the wrong partner because you weren't a man already, it's difficult if not downright impossible to bring that kind of energy to raising your kids.
@nottheone582
@nottheone582 Год назад
​@@xLegendaryPicturesyour response displays a fundamental misunderstanding of how real relationships happen. Women don't "take half men's shit" they earned 50% by helping their spouse to become successful. They were an equal partner in accumulating that wealth. No man becomes successful in a vacuum, thas just egotism speaking.
@mmmeaks2245
@mmmeaks2245 Год назад
As a female psychiatrist this is super useful to hear. Men respond so differently to things and hearing men’s’ views like this helps me massively. Thank you.
@High_Lord_Of_Terra
@High_Lord_Of_Terra Год назад
It wasn't accurate for me.
@user-ht3sc3sz7h
@user-ht3sc3sz7h Год назад
PLEASE don't listen random dudes on the internet trying desperately to perpetuate gender normativity and an insanely atomizing and isolating individualistic ideology. As a man, MEN DON'T NEED TO BE TOLD THEY NEED TO 'MAN UP' MORE. PLEASE DON'T LISTEN TO THESE PEOPLE
@MustbeTheBassest
@MustbeTheBassest Год назад
As a man who was neglected and bullied as a child. All i ever wanted was to feel loved. These men are one bad day away from suicide. Because all their welf worth comes from providing.
@timjauhonen5624
@timjauhonen5624 Год назад
@@MustbeTheBassest If that’s your take you need to whatch this clip again he said men want to feel capable and powerful. Providing was not mentioned. For a man to feel good to love end respect himself he need to feel capabel and powerful.
@borgCube100
@borgCube100 Год назад
But... the first words in this short was "Don't treat depression in others like how I suffer from it"..... and now you're going to say "THIS IS WHAT MEN THINK?"
@LyndlEndique
@LyndlEndique Год назад
Once, I threw away my lollipop on the sidewalk. My dad immediatelt scolded me with a stern voice, "Pick that up and throw it in the garbage." I was 5. I'm 27 now and have never littered on the street EVER.
@laestrella9727
@laestrella9727 Год назад
Mums do that too.
@benjamink.1970
@benjamink.1970 Год назад
@@laestrella9727 not as often or effectively as men.
@chalk4156
@chalk4156 Год назад
@@benjamink.1970 What a load of BS, of course moms do this too. The same way dads can just let their kids do what they want and encourage bad behaviour/ moms can also do this. It depends on what kind of person you are and how you have been raised.
@benjamink.1970
@benjamink.1970 Год назад
@@chalk4156 I never said that they wouldn't or couldn't. Focus buddy.
@russman738
@russman738 Год назад
@@chalk4156 The way Moms do it and the way Dads do it are different, and equally important. The lesson is in the tone of voice the parent uses and the delivery of the lesson. Each different delivery and tone support the importance of the lesson within a slightly different context. The difference is the emotional context of the child receiving the correction. Both different, both invaluable.
@somewhereisgone
@somewhereisgone Год назад
As a girl, when I was depressed my mom told me, "what are you going to do about it?" and it absolutely crushed me every time. I felt so unseen, uncared for, and alone. Goes to show you different people need different things.
@estoyaqui257
@estoyaqui257 Год назад
Same I completely went thru the same thing. When I just wanted to be understood and acknowledged of my frustration and someone says "what are you going to do?" It made me frustrated even more and felt like no one cared about how I felt.
@BanjoPixelSnack
@BanjoPixelSnack Год назад
I agree but I don’t think it’s a gender thing, I think it’s a contextual thing. “What are you going to do about it?” doesn’t help a child who is subject to terrifying things outside of their control it just makes the child feel shame and shame is corrosive.
@Ateka9
@Ateka9 Год назад
Every psychiatrist (probably) knows this. These guys are just using a strawman to prove a point.
@Asura2k
@Asura2k Год назад
​@@estoyaqui257no. U just was too afraid to tell truth. U were a coward to explain your problem and admit u lack knowledge and need some guidance. Question itself is perfect. It puts u in a place where u are in charge of the outcome. Your parent literally asked u what's going on. But u run away from it and even today can't admit u are coward.
@Twhistle
@Twhistle 9 месяцев назад
What’s said in the clip doesn’t speak for all men. A lot of men would feel exactly like you did.
@asia-rg6wf
@asia-rg6wf 10 месяцев назад
I personally think ppl who treat men like they have to be tough and say they basically can’t be emotional. If I have a son then I will make sure that he knows that he can come to me about anything and if he needs to cry I’ll help him no matter what
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 7 месяцев назад
Yeah man, I’ve had a very cold relationship with my father because of this sentiment. It’s so harmful, I can’t believe this kind of shit is being pushed to the gullible masses again.
@hengineer
@hengineer 5 месяцев назад
It's a far cry from saying men can't have emotions, to saying "wallowing in your emotions with no end game is unhealthy"
@mewe1023
@mewe1023 5 месяцев назад
​@@GarrotWireThere is a difference that you can't understand because in your life these lessons were done differently so you only think thats how everyone gonna do. But its not brotherm
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 5 месяцев назад
@@mewe1023 True, one size doesn’t fit all but we could at least admit that in certain cases this isn’t always true. Ignoring your emotions while hiding behind a “tough” fascade is not only pathetic but unhealthy as well. I’ve spoke with guys before who have said they’ve had no issues with this growing up but their way of living habit, and characteristics say otherwise. It’s just having self-awareness, something men are slowly starting to develop due to the information highway.
@christravisedgar
@christravisedgar 2 месяца назад
Well hopefully he has a father to help him develop a backbone whilst you mollycoddle him!
@GreggyAck
@GreggyAck Год назад
I want to feel loved and accepted more than I want to feel capable and powerful. It’s nice to feel capable and powerful but the absence of those wouldn’t get me down.
@KGG2
@KGG2 2 месяца назад
He is assuming really outdated and traditionalist gender roles.
@hollywoodbb
@hollywoodbb Год назад
I’ve found this difference between me and the women in my life, for the most part. When they vent, my first instinct is to fix it, but they 90% of the time just want to vent without a solution. It’s foreign to me, but it’s something I’ve had to learn. I think as men our first instinct is, “alright, what are we going to do now?”
@anaximanderofapollonia9842
@anaximanderofapollonia9842 Год назад
My response to these kind of situation is: "If you do not want me to help you fix your problem, then make your complaints funny. And if not, then don't expect me to listen."
@lukefitt56
@lukefitt56 Год назад
This is the typical situation for most all male/female relationships and it’s usually because they want to just get it out in the open and then are able to think about it better. The way me and my wife try to do it is at the beginning I ask if this is a “fix it” situation or a “just listen” situation. It’s usually the second 😅. But there have been plenty of times as we’ve used that technique that she’s asked for my opinion afterward. I think it’s helped our marriage a bunch
@jimlucas0
@jimlucas0 Год назад
Research has shown that venting alone can help lower stress significantly, so can't blame them. I'll still try to find a solution though lol
@GrgAProduction
@GrgAProduction Год назад
Yes. Women just want to validated and told they are correct, listened to in whatever they are venting about. They do not want a solution.
@lingtwist974
@lingtwist974 Год назад
My girlfriend became oregnant unexpectedly, and I sent her some information about abortions because neither one of us wanted a baby. However, she didn't take it well because she needs time to sort out her emotions about it and I was coldly trying to solve it logically too soon.
@turkleton4783
@turkleton4783 Год назад
What’s the empirical data do back this up? Or is it just more of the same “it feels good” style of “truth” that’s so popular today.
@TheWhiteGoblin
@TheWhiteGoblin Год назад
Beyond that i actually think some of this is harmful. The truth is some things cannot be controlled, sometimes it is the environment around you... and you cannot change it. Even more so part of, especially chronic, depression and anxiety is realising that, at least part of you, isn't capable and you need help. Now of course that doesn't mean that improving ones feelings of control and power cannot help but if you don't also come to grips with your feelings of self worth being directly connected to those things and how you need to change that it is exactly the same as hollow ego boosting.
@nahreallytho6583
@nahreallytho6583 Год назад
No this is complete nonsense again
@turkleton4783
@turkleton4783 Год назад
@@TheWhiteGoblin You’re absolutely right, it’s incredibly harmful. Thinking like this is how abusers are created. It comes from a pretty spoiled place too.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
It's like there is some truth to it but the explanation is so scrambled it doesn't make any sense. He makes it sound like the way to treat male depression is to not respond to their feelings and that is harmful and not grounded in science at all. But it's a fact that there are decisive gender differences in mental illness that often get overlooked by professionals. For example autism and adhd are underdiagnosed in women, depression and borderline are underdiagnosed in men, due to the fact that symptoms and their pattern differ due to 1) men tend to externalise symptoms while women tend to internalise. There's lots of data on that. 2) while all humans have the three basic needs or motivations of control/power/influence, achievement/self-efficacy, and attachment/affiliation/belonging, there are gender differences in how strong those needs are that are mediated by sex hormones and social environment/culture. Higher need for power is associated with testosterone while higher need for affiliation/attachment is associated with estrogen and oxytocin. Now this is a tendency and everyone needs to have their needs met, but the higher the need the more suffering and dysfunction a frustration of that need (or motivation) will be. In therapy there should always be a focus on helping the person cope with frustrations and find ways to satisfy their needs, taking into account the individual and their experiences. That being said, a "typical male" with mental illness that is externalising and has a high need for control would benefit from being taught how to establish boundaries and respect other peoples boundaries and how to feel in control of themselves and their emotions first and foremost, while a "typically female" mental illness expression benefits the most from bonding experiences and emotional validation. That doesn't mean that men don't need that, it just means that they might bond in a different way and that focusing on a domain that is less of an issue for them will neglect the domain that they need more support in, which is a sense of control. Hence, when the therapist focused on emotional validation instead of his sense of control his needs got frustrated and he didn't feel it helped him deal with his depression.
@Kishqui
@Kishqui Год назад
Anecdotal - it's true for me.
@benjifricker-muller6104
@benjifricker-muller6104 Год назад
As a psychiatrist I want to say that this is nonsense without a whiff of understanding of what he’s talking about. Firstly, if you tell a child or adult that “everything is going to be okay” when it isn’t they will know that you are lying, and three things will happen: 1) they won’t trust you and/or 2) (usually a child) they will repress their own feeling that “this isn’t okay” and learn to ignore their feelings to make important people happy, and 3) learn that bad feelings are the end of the world and spend much of their energy trying to avoid them. Both ain’t great. It’s better to observe and validate the feeling, sit with it, accept or at least reconcile with the shittiness of the situation and then move towards a solution if a solution is possible. It’s great to teach responsibility and self-reliance but this only comes (for men or women) through a firm foundation of internal security from the love of early care givers - or learned later in life. Without the former what looks like autonomy superficially is usually a narcissistic defence (i am amazing I never need anyone) and/or aggression/rage masking sadness and fear. When his father says “what are you going to do about it” it might work if this secure foundation is in place, or most probably it just teaches him to internalise “I am on my own, my father’s love depends on me pretending to be strong”. How many lives have been ruined by boys forming their life around this? Perhaps advice for how we should understand masculinity and mental health shouldn’t come from personal experience but from someone who understands the science and has the experience.
@monopolybillionaire5027
@monopolybillionaire5027 9 месяцев назад
Male depression is a symptom of this tough guy macho crap everyone is doing. Everyone is playing the same lads lads character and its so draining. And if you don't act like a hooligan they treat you like crap. Most the problem actually is toxic masculinity, yeah buzz word I know. But every man is playing thus cookie cutter macho type and its gotten boring after 17. Most these types don't grow up they stay teens way into there 50s
@seanbeebe8095
@seanbeebe8095 Год назад
Much of the time, depression is made up of unresolved issues. Don’t be afraid of it because your inner mechanic needs to get in there and start repairing. Only you can do this. Don’t let someone who is unfamiliar with your condition to tell you what’s wrong and how to fix it. You need to be brave and face it yourself, man or woman.
@luckerowl8990
@luckerowl8990 Год назад
if you're suggesting that people don't need to see a therapist to help with depression i think you need to relearn what depression is. what causes many people to fail to get over their depression is that they are unable to recognise why they're depressed and what delusions they're having to cause those symptoms, as this is extremely difficult to achieve alone if not impossible. when the very way you think is disordered you can't just "be brave and face it".
@seanbeebe8095
@seanbeebe8095 Год назад
@@luckerowl8990 True enough. I wasn’t suggesting that, but rereading my comment, it kind of sounds that way. Upon familiarizing your therapist with the condition, they can help you. I was referring more too RU-vid pod casters giving blanket advice for a complex condition.
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 7 месяцев назад
It’s always best to fight depression with a community that loves you, gives motivation, and validates your feelings.
@soulie2001
@soulie2001 Год назад
Its true. This broke me out of my huge depression and entitlement complex.
@andrewogilvie9051
@andrewogilvie9051 Год назад
Everyone has sinned and we all fall short of God’s moral standard. And so the payment for our sins is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. So declare with your mouth, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, and you will be saved.
@milansvancara
@milansvancara 3 месяца назад
@@andrewogilvie9051 What are you even talking about, have you read the bible carefully at least once? Most people are more moral than God
@daveboy2000
@daveboy2000 Год назад
jesus christ the ignorance both in this video and this comment section about what mental health is
@henrysjolin
@henrysjolin Год назад
Interesting how you'd call it ignorance when so many people agree with what Chris and his guest are talking about here.
@dickurkel6910
@dickurkel6910 Год назад
Yeah fuck that I'm not gonna keep scrolling, people are so fucking stupid on here
@thorstmixx
@thorstmixx Год назад
​@@henrysjolinMany people also think the earth is flat. It has literally zero relevance to whether or not it's true.
@henrysjolin
@henrysjolin Год назад
@@thorstmixx Sure, but neither does dismissing a claim as "ignorant" without elaborating on why it is. All I'm saying Chris has a strong following for a reason
@daveboy2000
@daveboy2000 Год назад
@@henrysjolin Just because everyone agrees doesn't mean it isn't ignorance. A lot of people think the earth is flat but that doesn't make it any less round.
@123iln7
@123iln7 Год назад
But then men also want to feel valued, like someone cares. I think ppl feel they have no value when they dont know people love them... I dont think its a male thing to respect people and to take action when faced with a problem?
@J939N
@J939N Год назад
Be polite Be respectful Have a plan to kill everyone you meet "Tf2 meet the Sniper"
@RicardoSantos-oz3uj
@RicardoSantos-oz3uj Год назад
Respect is something that is earned. Not given. Courtesy on the other hand is something you give even to someone you are about to execute.
@J939N
@J939N Год назад
@@RicardoSantos-oz3uj be sure to pay respect to the dead
@sr.mental5876
@sr.mental5876 9 месяцев назад
Based.
@pranav.bhasin
@pranav.bhasin Год назад
Agreed. That said, let’s not stop at “male” depression. Everyone can learn more about self-reliance and integrity.
@ulfson279
@ulfson279 Год назад
We need to stop at male because the way mental health works is generic in its field and it helps women with how women think and operate... It stops at male because men don't get the treatment they need and deserve when it comes to mental health... And the way men work is different than the way women work...
@martijnoerlemans765
@martijnoerlemans765 Год назад
You're not wrong but the point that male depression differs from female is still in there.
@NewesSkiller
@NewesSkiller Год назад
@@martijnoerlemans765 I agree, really tired of all the male outlets for talk always turns into well women.... instead of just focusing on men for 1 fucking second.
@sleepypanda8724
@sleepypanda8724 Год назад
I think everyone should be given both treatments of “male” and “female” depression. Being listened to and validated is important and so is doing something tangible to help move in a positive direction.
@itsjarcia9151
@itsjarcia9151 Год назад
true
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 7 месяцев назад
Those feelings must genuinely be validated in order for that person to move forward. Bitterness isn’t the healthiest approach to solve your problems.
@julietmike1018
@julietmike1018 Год назад
Dude this is so freaking true. I grew up with parents who always told me things would be ok, but what I really needed was to be charged with the responsibility of getting myself out of the holes I dug.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
All children need to be provided with structure, and taught responsibility. That is a basic developmental need, it's not a gender thing
@kevsmith562
@kevsmith562 Год назад
You can do both!
@mathius_dragoon532
@mathius_dragoon532 Год назад
It's because women are satisfied with being made to feel better, while men want to see actual tangible impacts in their lives.
@jc98103
@jc98103 Год назад
I'm 24 years old and not having a dad still messes me up everyday
@user-zp4de5lq9i
@user-zp4de5lq9i Год назад
“What are you going to do about it?”. I’d recommend you to build your own moral compass and make it your life goal. As long as your moral code of conduct intact after how many time you fall, you’ll just have to do what’s right and move on with it. At least that’s how I live my life, I help the needy during my free time and absolutely uphold my code in any moment and I probably will until I take my last breath on this earth. Lately I’ve been studying different religions then comparing them with each other and I’m not trying to follow any religion but I’ll take what seems to be common between these scriptures and live my life by the code. Hope it’ll help you to figure some things out in your life. Have a nice day mate.
@starwarsfamilyguy0
@starwarsfamilyguy0 Год назад
I don't think so
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 7 месяцев назад
@@user-zp4de5lq9i Bro, let’s just get to the point, this guy needs to be loved. Having a loving support system is crucial to solving big problems.
@StudMacher96
@StudMacher96 7 месяцев назад
Damn this world is so messed up. Why can’t we all just be treated the same?
@FITMK01
@FITMK01 7 месяцев назад
Fax
@willm678
@willm678 6 месяцев назад
I’m a 19 year old male. I’m in my second semester of my first year of college and have been visiting with a counselor once a week to help with the struggles I’ve been having adjusting to college life. Last semester I sought no help from anyone and nearly got suspended because of how poor my academic performance was. Getting over the roadblock of admitting I can’t do it alone has paid major dividends for me. Going to counseling has provided me with pragmatism that I think can benefit all men and women, and to learn about why these struggles come up and how I can deal with them is a skill that is useful beyond just school. Growing up with 2 older brothers and spending most of my time with them and my dad I’ve had no shortage of life lessons being taught to me through experience and learning from the other men in my life, but some problems aren’t so simple that they can be fixed simply by being grabbed by the scruff of my neck and being told I need to be strong.
@ДаниялДандамаев-и7ц
@ДаниялДандамаев-и7ц 4 месяца назад
THIS! Hopes it getts better, buddy.
@baNkzFortnite
@baNkzFortnite Год назад
Isn't it necessary for a broken man to feel loved and accepted before he can start feeling capable and strong?. Like this:" it's okay that you're struggling and hurting, it's very understandable and there's great compassion, however you are capable of so much, you can heal and actualize your true potential, becoming a strong and loving man." I don't think that love and acceptance say "it's okay to be weak and broken, stay weak and broken". But I think love says:" it's okay to be where you are right now, let me take you by the hand and help you walk towards what you can become
@ante5544
@ante5544 Год назад
It's not okay to be where you are right now if right now you're in a genuinely bad mental place making genuinely crappy decisions. But beyond that I agree with everything you said
@johnbrooke6867
@johnbrooke6867 Год назад
Not to make light of male depression but depression is depression unless it's hormonal related, I guess. Children need role models, period. Depression sometimes is just an honest reaction to the harsh shitty realities of life. Taking initiative, being proactive, getting perspective have very little do with gender. If you can dead lift your way out of depression...by all means...do it. But usually there is an psychological component that requires analysis and maybe just a little bit of time to enable a return to previous contentment. That being said men are entitled to be just as depressed as anyone else given the card dealt.
@mgtowvalues
@mgtowvalues Год назад
There is no such thing as depression except as inviting sadness and then deciding not to let it leave. Just another form of cognitive dissonance.
@rejectwokeness1314
@rejectwokeness1314 Год назад
For someone who's been going through really bad stuff and currently jobless for 6 months and being rejected countless times despite having really good feedback from interviewers, and wondering whether I'll even have a job ever again, I really think men just needs a hand over our shoulder to assure us we are loved. We don't like to talk through our problems to a counsellor cos it only adds to our pain. We only want a listening ear and assuring touch. Because no one will give a man that, not even my parents who I imagine cares for me but never ever show it even when I look like I wanna end it all. I think I'll cry like a river if someone actually sincerely gives me that.
@childofchief2290
@childofchief2290 Год назад
I think a balance is good. Tough love means the love has to be there for it to work to be tough. Showing young boys or girls how to overcome challenges and how to build their self esteem through facing difficult moments is a valuable discipline to learn. We cannot wrap ourselves in cotton wool for every difficult scenario
@narlenenortler2638
@narlenenortler2638 Год назад
Not exclusive to men, and not universal for men. It needs to be understood that human physiology and psychology are so wildly diverse that you HAVE to cater treatment to the individual. Blanket statements or treatments do not work when a series of complex circumstances unique to each individual are responsible for everything that we know, say, and do in our lives.
@christravisedgar
@christravisedgar 2 месяца назад
Amazing how women can’t hear a clip like this without personalising it and being offended. THEY ARENT TALKING ABOUT YOU!
@lotusstar347
@lotusstar347 Год назад
I wish your dad were a dad to all young men. I taught male adolescence all over the US and just watching the boys walk into the classroom, you can read the strength or the lack of it. Finally! A man who is willing to be a man and you cannot treat the two sexs alike. They're not alike. And, yes, it's okay for women to be tough, strong be respectful as well.
@QuantumTap
@QuantumTap Год назад
Yes you have to be in control, there's no point in only sitting and crying, BUT MEN ARE ALLOWED TO FEEL THEIR FEELINGS. feel, process those emotions, then take action.
@EsStagefright
@EsStagefright Год назад
I'm glad I had a dad in my life, he taught me how to respect people and to control my emotions while still realizing that they are valid and important
@elyse443
@elyse443 11 месяцев назад
Your dad sounds wonderful. But he cannot keep you from having depression. If something caused your serotonin levels to dip you would 100% experience depression like everybody else. Depression is not sadness. It is a physical disease.
@hypno5690
@hypno5690 6 месяцев назад
You just described being sad.@@elyse443
@therealmr.incredible3179
@therealmr.incredible3179 11 месяцев назад
‘I turned out fine’ -His Eyes look Demented as duck -His Voice sounds Dead and Void of Life -He gives off Painful energy Listen, You need Love AND Toughness. One of the many reasons why I try not to emotionally attach to people is because all they have to do to hurt me emotionally is say something mean(confrontational or otherwise)/get angry/Ignore me. I try not to form Bonds but make sure to have my Fun. You need a little bit of Fat for the Cushion.
@DonnieToys
@DonnieToys Месяц назад
For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved. (Romans 10:13) I tell you, Nay: but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish. (Luke 13:5) The LORD is righteous in all his ways, and holy in all his works. The LORD is nigh unto all them that call upon him, to all that call upon him in truth. He will fulfil the desire of them that fear him: he also will hear their cry, and will save them. The LORD preserveth all them that love him: but all the wicked will he destroy. (Psalms 145:17-20)
@jake.b6886
@jake.b6886 Год назад
As a father of two young boys, when one of them come to me with a problem I’ll say what are you going to do to fix it? And I will only help if they have at least given it a go on their own, but I’ll also always be there for them when they need a hug or a heartfelt chat. As fathers our job is to teach our sons and other young boys in our life how to be capable and at the same time loving to others.
@gunsmokegaloreyt6840
@gunsmokegaloreyt6840 Год назад
Jake sounds like you’re doing a fine job and have reached the perfect balance of lovingness and strength/harshness. Keep doing what you’re doing, I never had that
@whosMaagii
@whosMaagii Год назад
W DAD
@maskofsan1ty
@maskofsan1ty Год назад
Nothing you said there can't be done by a mother.
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 7 месяцев назад
Nice! A father that’s finally aware of the balance.
@SMCwasTaken
@SMCwasTaken 7 месяцев назад
Will do the same if it was a different gender?
@sunshinelizard1
@sunshinelizard1 Год назад
Men and women do tend to experience and need different approaches to therapy. Not all, but in general. Nothing wrong with that. Hiring managers need to be aware that women tend towards being self-deprecating, and so get less promotions and wages, to managers need to be aware of this so women get their fair share of raises and promotions because they bring good leadership and so do men, it's just somewhat different.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
Yeah, different but equal. Differences are what make our species so strong and resilient and that's why we should appreciate each other for what we have to offer instead of putting each other down
@tylerhatch3161
@tylerhatch3161 Год назад
I remember when I was a kid, something happened that upset me and I went off to my room to cry. A couple minutes later, my dad came in and sat me down. He told me that I couldn't run away from things and that I needed to learn to face and confront problems or things that were upsetting me. Easily one of the most valuable lessons I've ever learned.
@nhundahl8483
@nhundahl8483 Год назад
What happened next ? Did you confront your troubles
@GarrotWire
@GarrotWire 7 месяцев назад
Was there any love presented? There needs to be a balance. Sure, he taught a lesson but it doesn’t completely patch up those wounds from inside..
@rooramblingon895
@rooramblingon895 Год назад
Not my experience. My deep depression was treated like I do not exist and I should pull myself together. Not all men act like this stereotype, yet they still know they are MEN! The plethora of neurological wiring is big enough to encompass may things. I am big, strong, able to defend myself and my family, not gay, not in the "wrong body". But I am also incredibly sensitive, empathetic, child centred and gentle....I cry. Stop treating the average as representative of everyone fellas. It is what has brought us to the madness of trans-idiocy: that how the average act is what makes a gender!!
@PrincessMicrowave
@PrincessMicrowave Год назад
Both men and women want to feel loved and to feel powerful. This is silly.
@roastedpotato2159
@roastedpotato2159 6 месяцев назад
Yeah but men dont get nearly the amount of emotional attention as women do
@bobholyoake8577
@bobholyoake8577 Год назад
Depression is symptom..
@callanc3925
@callanc3925 Год назад
facts, depression is a symptom of poor physical health most of the time. for 90% of people, fixing your diet, sleep, exercise, and routine will make depression go away.
@sr.mental5876
@sr.mental5876 9 месяцев назад
@@callanc3925 Agreed. The few times that you’re depressed by some genetic fault is extremely rare. Pharmaceutical companies love to treat the symptoms they themselves may have caused.
@mr.shadow1850
@mr.shadow1850 4 месяца назад
​@@callanc3925pure bullshit if it's severe it's not gonna help anyway
@TheRexTera
@TheRexTera Год назад
The problem is simply that the model for how we treat emotions is wrong for both boys and girls. An emotion need need to be felt to be processed and regulated. Neither the “sucking up” or the “cuddle” it away is healthy options. It’s much healthier to teach your child to pay attention to their bodies and describe to themselves how an emotion physically feels trough meditation. I love the way Sam Harris explained how and emotion separated from its root in thoughts had little to no half-life before it’s gone.
@JoseRRodriguez
@JoseRRodriguez Год назад
This! All that gender wars is only useless poralization. New psychology is needed
@ktdubs-vf5jj
@ktdubs-vf5jj Год назад
Men want to be respected more than their desire to be loved. BUT both go hand in hand, you can't have one without the other. Even if you respect your husband, God made you, his wife, to be a companion. You nurture him, encourage him, notice, and recognize the sacrifices he's made for you. Then in respecting him, you listen to his guidance, when he makes a decision for the household. Even if you think it's the wrong one, he'll make it right because he's looking out for what's best for you. It's hard to do. To put all your trust and hope in your husband, a human that makes mistakes. But it'll all work out in the end. If you have married a real man. That's how you respect and love your husband.
@timdecker6063
@timdecker6063 Год назад
For me the ego stroking didn't lead to feeling entitled, it just made me believe my mom or anyone else was not being sincere almost anytime I am complimented.
@PrinceAzura
@PrinceAzura Год назад
Male depression this, female depression that, guys it's just depression. Everyone should feel capable, strong, loved, and cared about
@nocturnal03
@nocturnal03 Год назад
Nooo. Men must feel superior to women yet underdogs all the tiiime.
@sanyo8440
@sanyo8440 9 месяцев назад
Non binary depression this, non-sense gender classifications that? Why do you bother chiming in as a failed man?
@kittenhrdr
@kittenhrdr Год назад
Venting is just the first part of processing feelings. Sometimes, it is the solution. When men come home from a long, hard day's work, sometimes they will vent about whatever difficulties the day brought. Letting off steam to your partner is part of why we get together, a safe place to release the frustrations of the world. Man or woman, we all have bosses or coworkers who vex us, unreasonable customers, flat tires, etc. In public, we have to behave and be professional. At home we are allowed to be ourselves, and let it all out. Listening IS the fix.
@miriades
@miriades Год назад
You said:"At home we are allowed to be be ourselves." That’s the problem… Who allows who? Who needs to feel allowed to be oneself?? Society makes us frustrated on so many levels then we think all of this is normal feeling.
@kittenhrdr
@kittenhrdr Год назад
@miriades we allow our partner to have a safe place to process the frustrations of society and the demands of surviving. Love with understanding can create a safe place two share, where they have each other's back.
@miriades
@miriades Год назад
@@kittenhrdr You're actually right.
@kittenhrdr
@kittenhrdr Год назад
@@miriades thanks for the support 🙏
@Defactodissident
@Defactodissident 6 месяцев назад
That is true even in men groups to whine lol, not only to their partners. But they do not exhibit the topic of depression
@JT-91
@JT-91 Год назад
my brother has CP when going through physical therapy I asked my mom to stop coming. She refused to let him go through pain and would often stop the progress. Women's greatest strength is compassion but its also a great weakness too. As much as we need comfort from parents we also need them to continue to push us towards success even if it means discomfort
@kaifritzsche8377
@kaifritzsche8377 Год назад
I really dislike this video. 1. it suggests that depression only hits male who are not in control and „weak“ Look at the science, this is not true. Even successful, strong, respectful, „should be happy“ men can suffer from the disorder depression 2. the video suggests that if you have depression, you only need to „man up“, stop whining and do something about it. This also is terrible advice. By definition of the depression disorder in later stages it becomes almost impossible to motivate oneself to do the simplest tasks. Even worse, trying to overcome everything alone, being tough, strong and a lone wolf much more often than not leads to the depression becoming worse. Far better advice would be, to have the bravery (in my opinion mich more bravery needed here) to open up about oneself and get professional help. Which brings me to my third point 3. The statement in the beginning of the video, that one is always treated to feel loved and accepted, is just not true. Professionals merely help immensely in the process of one helping himself The advice from the video is maybe helpful for someone struggling with taking responsibility over himself in live. In terms of depression disorder, it’s one of the worsed advices you can potentially get.
@drvren030
@drvren030 Год назад
I'm a woman who's worked with both primary school children and high school children. I'm more empathetic, intellectual, intuitive, introverted and my little brother is more athletic, outdoors-y, reeeallllyyyy hyper, and empathetic too. from my view, honestly, men are generally supposed to be handled differently than women. because biology for both is different. especially after puberty, where there's clear changes. I kinda disagree with this guy in some ways. some people say men are "doers", that is absolute bollocks and that's like saying women can be happy without doing anything, and saying men are doers is exactly the sort of thing to say so that women can easily run away from basic responsibility and duties. men are physically stronger, absolutely no doubt about that. so that makes them more aggressive physically. this means they can do manual labor of lifting things naturally better than women. but there's a lot of things humans "do", that's only a fraction of it. there's things besides giving birth that women can handle much better than men. what we NEED is to give men space where they can project their physical aggression and strength from a very young age, and not make them feel bad about it. with age, they'll tame it and learn where to use it, where not to use it. if two boys fight, don't label them as "crazy and violent", talk to them there and then. give the teen boys a chance to truly open up. don't let that anger build up into narcissism and psychopathic behavior later on in life. this mentality of "be a man", and in saying that not allowing little boys and teen boys to be emotional impacts both men and women in the long run.
@Minaa298
@Minaa298 Год назад
I feel like men want to feel capable and powerful so that they could ultimately feel loved and accepted, so it all comes from the same place as humans.
@alexforce9
@alexforce9 Год назад
Men mostly want to feel capable for themselves. Like - we dont learn how to fix a car so we be adored for our ability to fix a car - we just want t have that skill. Coz its in our nature to want to get things done. And look at male power fantasy - Thor, Hulk, Blade, Superman, Batman - we just enjoy power and capability. (Also why Tyler from Fight club is so popular)
@tmy3411
@tmy3411 Год назад
No, its not same. I will have people who love me but I feel useless and like a load on them. I know that's not how they feel about me but I am built to feel that way it's not a conscious decision I made.
@isabellehoux8014
@isabellehoux8014 Год назад
There’s a sweet spot there. There’s a male in my family that was way too tough on his sons, calling them stupid and idiots whenever they did something “wrong”. He didn’t treat his daughter like that. So he was very tough on the boys, and nothing they did was good enough. It took them all about 40 years to get their lives right. A lot of suffering and depression before that. And they all competed for their father’s love, which they never fully got. So making generalized assumptions is dangerous. Hopefully, children grow up with parents who know themselves well enough, and are aware enthusiasm that their children are not mere extensions of them.
@youngknowledgeseeker
@youngknowledgeseeker Год назад
Men and women need both male and female role model and support. Both need love and acceptance, and both need tough responsibility. Too bad that's so hard now a days...
@bellavega8048
@bellavega8048 Год назад
@Kevo Walkerso what are you going to do about this?
@bellavega8048
@bellavega8048 Год назад
@@AnonymousIRL hell for you maybe
@roarblast7332
@roarblast7332 8 месяцев назад
Psychotherapy is genderless. It isnt about love and acceptance. Its about taking responsibility for your emotions. This whole gender fixation that people have now is a complete waste of everyones time.
@yajy4501
@yajy4501 10 месяцев назад
I think this is overly simplistic. Just about everyone wants to feel loved and accepted as well as capable and powerful. Still, clinical depression is more than just a lack of those things. Those are certainly part of it but they aren’t the whole picture.
@themissydeyo
@themissydeyo Год назад
I am a woman who has struggled with depression. No one ever asked me what I was going to do about my problems, I was coddled. It was only when I was broke, living in a women’s shelter after struggling with addiction for a decade and nearly dying so many times that I finally asked myself, ‘What are you going to do about it?’ And now I’m over a year and a half sober with two jobs after being chronically unemployed, losing weight, quit smoking, and totally excelling.
@landontucker2866
@landontucker2866 Год назад
Not every person with depression has an ego wtf
@brookalakin
@brookalakin Год назад
It is a big part of it. Depression has been described as anger at the self. It can have roots in interiority and perfectionism, and the root of both is pride. Pride = ego. This is an oversimplification but I want to make a point the the perfectionism, anger, and entitlement that results in a few cases of depression can orginate in deeply imbued internal schemas that translate pride/ego or in other terms self-esteem. Low self-esteem and "high self-esteem" (the narcissistic type) are both egoic and find their resolution in humility. This being because anger at the self for your life circumstances or self image slowly dissipates as entitlement goes down and and personal responsibility goes up. The eastern Orthodox church teaches this in a way kind of. I heard it in a somewhere. My explanation has probably muddled it but I hope it illustrates a point.
@XRyanK
@XRyanK Год назад
Damn right. My fathers therapist is currently doing that and it emboldens him to argue with everyone cuz now his ego is rampant.
@mattknibbable
@mattknibbable Месяц назад
This is an incredibly naïve view of make mental health. Telling men to man up leads to suicides. And since when were CEOs known for their positive mental health? When was the last time you saw these guys really laugh? have all the money and influence you want, without laughter you're going to be unhappy and unfulfilled.
@peterjames3238
@peterjames3238 Год назад
It is sad how something clearly focusing on men’s mental health and all the comments are “women needs this too”. Great, if that’s what you think you need, but it’s not the topic at hand 🤦‍♂️ and yes I said think you need because countless studies would dictate this is in fact inherently not what you need regardless of how you “feel”.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
It's like there is some truth to it but the explanation is so scrambled it doesn't make any sense. He makes it sound like the way to treat male depression is to not respond to their feelings and that is harmful and not grounded in science at all. But it's a fact that there are decisive gender differences in mental illness that often get overlooked by professionals. For example autism and adhd are underdiagnosed in women, depression and borderline are underdiagnosed in men, due to the fact that symptoms and their pattern differ due to 1) men tend to externalise symptoms while women tend to internalise. There's lots of data on that. 2) while all humans have the three basic needs or motivations of control/power/influence, achievement/self-efficacy, and attachment/affiliation/belonging, there are gender differences in how strong those needs are that are mediated by sex hormones and social environment/culture. Higher need for power is associated with testosterone while higher need for affiliation/attachment is associated with estrogen and oxytocin. Now this is a tendency and everyone needs to have their needs met, but the higher the need the more suffering and dysfunction a frustration of that need (or motivation) will be. In therapy there should always be a focus on helping the person cope with frustrations and find ways to satisfy their needs, taking into account the individual and their experiences. That being said, a "typical male" with mental illness that is externalising and has a high need for control would benefit from being taught how to establish boundaries and respect other peoples boundaries and how to feel in control of themselves and their emotions first and foremost, while a "typically female" mental illness expression benefits the most from bonding experiences and emotional validation. That doesn't mean that men don't need that, it just means that they might bond in a different way and that focusing on a domain that is less of an issue for them will neglect the domain that they need more support in, which is a sense of control. Hence, when the therapist focused on emotional validation instead of his sense of control his needs got frustrated and he didn't feel it helped him deal with his depression.
@2ELI7E
@2ELI7E Год назад
The issue is most men are depressed because they feel lonely, unloved and unwanted.... So the key to treating that is to not make them feel those things? Man these blokes have lost the plot entirely
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
@@2ELI7E depression is always a sign of unmet needs, it can be caused by a myriad of things from nutritional deficiencies to lack of affectionate bonds, it's the task of a therapist to find the reasons and solutions in each individual person. But the best prevention is a social environment that is attuned to a child's needs and helps them learn coping skills and to meet their needs. For the longest time it was normal to neglect and traumatise children of any gender. Today, while the situation has improved for girls overall compared to lets say 100 years ago, it is still normalised to neglect boys in traditional ways in many places and families. It is true that needs differ in strength and expression but we are still all humans with the same basic built.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
@@2ELI7E even if they WOULD base these assumptions on existing data, it would be like saying "oh men need a little less emotional bonding than women? Let's give them none of it then". It's actually so insane and misguided.
@jamesharvey1720
@jamesharvey1720 Год назад
​@@pandapanda246 those unmet needs are the biological need to create. Men need to feel powerful not loved.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
@@jamesharvey1720 incorrect and lacking scientific foundation. This is simply bioessentialist misinformation. Even men, believe it or not, are human beings and have the needs that are universal for humans. Attachment and affection are part of that. Rejecting this is actually indicative of attachment wounds that a lot of men have due to cultural beliefs like this one that men don't need affection and attachment.
@-haclong2366
@-haclong2366 Год назад
I don't even think that we should be treating women like that, ¿Should we tell an overconfident woman with misplaced arrogance that she's perfect? We don't like it when men believe this and society rightfully punishes those jerks, but this doesn't happen with women. This is why Karens are so common but the male version is nearly non-existent.
@cryco472
@cryco472 Год назад
As a woman I agree. I’d rather be told “what can you do about that” after validating the actual feeling being felt, which is an important first step regardless of gender.
@TK_Danes
@TK_Danes Год назад
I think the problem is this Because when they claim "emotional distress" it's deemed a woman's issue But to "feel capable and power" wasn't in the docket for women in medical history, it was to deem them incapable and "hysteria" Learn the medical history on what the studies are based on first.. before listening and taking face value of what they are saying
@ryerye9019
@ryerye9019 9 месяцев назад
Everybody idiolizes a tough strong male model, except when they're teaching young men to genocide minorities. There is balance between toughness and compassion. Older generations may have been tough and resilient, but they were also unquestioning of the babarisms that prevailed at that time. That is not to say that we haven't become uncivilized in the digital age.
@omok2
@omok2 Год назад
Honestly he was pretty spot on about the "what are you gonna do about it" It stirred a vague memory of hearing the same thing from my father and now that I think about it it's one of those tiny life lessons. That has lots and lots of mileage.
@transgenderbasketballplayer
This is why men kill themselves so much. Because people like this tell them that opening up about feeling unaccepted, or weak, or sad that they're not being manly enough. Father's teach their sons that crying is wrong and girly and that being hurt, being incapable, making mistakes, is unmanly and wrong. If you really want to talk about mens' mental health, talk about THAT!
@chagarro5459
@chagarro5459 Год назад
Incorrect, men have been content forever because the role of protecting, stoicism and respectfulness not only drives us but fulfils us as well. The illusion that we will be happier if we relinquish control of our emotions and succumb to the lack of a role a man is given in todays modern society, is unfathomably destructive and detrimental to men’s mental health and well-being.
@TheGrumbliestPuppy
@TheGrumbliestPuppy Год назад
@@chagarro5459 No, you misunderstand. Men literally have higher rates of suicide when raised in the traditional values of men because they don't know how to handle their emotions. The solution to this isn't to spoil them rotten and teach them to be complacent, which is what we've done. The true answer is balance between the two. Teach them its okay for men to feel sadness, and how to express it, and how to ask for help, but ALSO how to work hard, be responsible and be strong.
@starinthesky8134
@starinthesky8134 Год назад
@@TheGrumbliestPuppyyou’re close, except that everything talked about goes for women too.
@Skaldzerker
@Skaldzerker Год назад
​@Grumbles No, men have higher suicide rates because they use more violent and damaging methods in their attempts. It's a solution for them. It has nothing to do with the value systems under which they're raised. Women attempt suicide more because it's one of their ways of calling for help. I am NOT saying this in a bad manner, but it's one way women and girls seek attention for their problems.
@kevsmith562
@kevsmith562 Год назад
@@chagarro5459 It's so weird that folks have this warped, rose tinted view of historical masculinity when really just about any historical male figure you care to think of was an alcoholic, abuser or worse. Men in the past were not ok, much less content.
@itsthemetho
@itsthemetho Год назад
Everytime a hear a male complain about being a victim; I know the problem. It is sometimes manipulation, but more often it is being powerless. In life as a male, you really need to work towards a goal and be fairly stoic. You'll feel better about yourself if your making positive changes, rather than dwelling on feelings that frankly no one cares about.
@PlayshotKalo
@PlayshotKalo Год назад
Imagine being in a marriage that’s void of feelings. There’s no way for humans to bond intimately without feelings and vulnerability. Repressing your feelings only leads people to isolation because we never bond with anyone. What we actually need is a balance of both
@anaximanderofapollonia9842
@anaximanderofapollonia9842 Год назад
Stoicism is a side effect, not the goal. If being stoic is your goal, then you already failed at your first step.
@anaximanderofapollonia9842
@anaximanderofapollonia9842 Год назад
@@PlayshotKalo Your feelings are a product of your desires. Therefore, what are your desires a product of?
@bokchoiman
@bokchoiman Год назад
@@anaximanderofapollonia9842 id wager to say that desires are uncontrollable because we have no true free will.
@anaximanderofapollonia9842
@anaximanderofapollonia9842 Год назад
@@bokchoiman How so? As in, if "I do want X" is beyond my control, is "I do NOT want X" also beyond my control? Also, can you force yourself into wanting something? And what would be your reference point for "true freedom/free will?
@bb9331
@bb9331 Год назад
I don’t care about a man feeling like he’s not okay with the way he is because a female can’t say those words without a man tryna “humble” her . BYE EHH U TRIED TO MAKE THEM A SOMEBODY NEXT
@terranaxiomuk
@terranaxiomuk 11 дней назад
Worst advice ever for adult men. Things happen in situations you can't do anything about and well wishing you'll just magically fix it isn't a thing. You can't snap your fingers like a child and it's fixed.
@NerdManiaLegends
@NerdManiaLegends 4 месяца назад
Personally I can agree as a male being told that everything is alright and I am loved doesn’t help. It just becomes redundant overtime. At the same time no one needs some toxic masculinity I’m top honcho. That doesn’t fix anything either I’m depressed because i think i have no control so how do you expect me to say to myself I’m the man of the house let me take control of my life like my dad did? Everyday I hate myself more and more and the only thing stopping from ending it all is my parents and the clean up so in a way that love and support bullshit that you say is for girls is the shit that keeps me from killing myself.
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
I'm so proud of this comment section for having so many people bring up balanced and insightful points about how and why this short is way oversimplifying the issue and why we need intersectional and mindful solutions. Amazing. Hope in humanity restored. Still I am saddened to read the responses that feel validated by this in promoting toxic cultural standards. I hope we can all grow and heal together and engage in productive discussion
@theezenriarinze9203
@theezenriarinze9203 Год назад
What exactly was toxic about men not finding solace in being told everything is going to be ok vs tangible measures to take back control of their lives?
@pandapanda246
@pandapanda246 Год назад
@@theezenriarinze9203 you misunderstood me. I did not say that the video promotes toxic standards, in fact it just kind of misrepresents something that is actually true, which is that men differ in how they prioritise, experience and express needs from women on average, and that mental health professionals are often not schooled in how mental illnesses differ in symptom expression between the genders. What I said is that I am saddened that some people in the comment section take this video as "proof" or agreeing that men don't have any emotional needs to be met, which is false and a toxic cultural belief. Just because men's need for control has a higher priority doesn't mean that needs for bonding and emotional validation are irrelevant or nonexistent. Clearly, if what you lack is a sense of control that needs to be addressed, especially if it has been neglected so far. That does not conclude to being the only need men have.
@waleedabbas4996
@waleedabbas4996 Год назад
​@@theezenriarinze9203Because barely any therapist tells men "everything is going to be okay". It's make believe to rile people up.
@sr.mental5876
@sr.mental5876 9 месяцев назад
@@pandapanda246 The only people who seem to misunderstand this video are unilateral thinkers, aka socially manufactured sophists. If any of you think following his advice, literally word for word, is the first action to be taken, and a good choice of action at that, then honestly I feel sorry for you and I hope you all get to work on that aspect of thinking. Most people (men in this thematic aspect) today are pampered and matured in false educations as to fall into this trap. Into a false sense of understanding, which funnily creates problems such as these.
@edmanning274
@edmanning274 Год назад
Ahh yes, let’s put all men in a basket. Role models are important but characters are different.
@James-iz9qb
@James-iz9qb 29 дней назад
I believe what he may be trying to say is valuable- 1. you should have the capacity for self-criticism, 2. its often best to accept things beyond your control and focus on acting in the best way within your control. However, without further context what he says here can be a one way road to total psychological dysfunction. 'what are you going to do about it?' in many contexts will create deep shame in a child that could linger for decades to come, especially if that message is repeated many times in such contexts
@cyberneticbutterfly8506
@cyberneticbutterfly8506 Год назад
People in the comment section please! You are too focused on mums and dads and forget about personality type. I remember a great show from Korea that split everyone in the more emotional personality types in one room and the more rationalist types in the other. They were going to discuss something or do something together I don't recall what. Quickly the feeler room devolved into crying and emotional conversations while the thinkers where helping each other process stuff rationally. Or something like that. Point I'm trying to make is that although women were slightly overrepresented among the feeler personalities it wasn't that large a margin so we need to have this conversation about parenting and personality type almost just as much as whether the parents are male and female.
@BartoniusAustinius
@BartoniusAustinius Год назад
All the people in the comments bitching like this isn't just a 30 second clip spliced together from a much longer, more complex conversation
@lilianreal5272
@lilianreal5272 10 месяцев назад
Psychedelics are just an exceptional mental health breakthrough. It's quite fascinating how effective they are against depression and anxiety. Saved my life.
@JamesTaylor-ff4dp
@JamesTaylor-ff4dp 10 месяцев назад
Does anyone know any good source to get them? I put so much on my plate and it definitely affects my stress and anxiety levels, would love to give shrooms a try.
@zarkos2313
@zarkos2313 10 месяцев назад
A lot of people have testified about this and I really want to give it a shot. I put so much on my plate and it definitely affects my stress and anxiety levels
@carsonelias4594
@carsonelias4594 10 месяцев назад
Shrooms was definitely the best trip I ever had. It was amazing!
@jorgparker2463
@jorgparker2463 10 месяцев назад
Is he on instagram?
@divineojiako8462
@divineojiako8462 10 месяцев назад
YES very sure of bergwilly11__. I have the same experience with anxiety, depression, PTSD and addiction and Mushrooms definitely made a huge huge difference to why am clean today.
@kcj1993
@kcj1993 Год назад
Also consider that we can get stuck trying to do something about an issue that, realistically, we can't remedy or control and need to let go of.
@MrSoulinet
@MrSoulinet Год назад
A good father teaches his kids about duty first, rights later. Boys and girls.
@lisaadams8004
@lisaadams8004 8 месяцев назад
I'm a female with depression, but it's not that I don't feel loved, I'm an empath and I can tell how much I am loved but that doesn't stop me from not feeling capable and independent. Depression isn't one size fits all with men and women.
@JottoHearthStone
@JottoHearthStone Год назад
"What are you going to do about it?" is the best mantra you can live by. I know so many people who are adults and never learned to act to make their lives better. Even if you are dealt a horrendous hand in life, there is always something you can do to make it better, not perfect, but better. It's very difficult to help people who are unable to help themselves.
@nottheone582
@nottheone582 Год назад
Okay but don't all humans need to be strong and take accountability? This isn't just men thing. Everybody should be this way
@callanc3925
@callanc3925 Год назад
Right now is that the case? Yes technically For 99% of human history has that been the case? Not so much. Strong and accountable has traditionally been the mans responsibility.
@bgos4727
@bgos4727 Год назад
​@@callanc3925 human history is so full of shit that is hard to look at something without being afraid is stained of that same shit. Tradition luckily is dying. and we should let it die in peace
@mikekeltner4291
@mikekeltner4291 Год назад
Working out and boxing cured my depression
@de8852
@de8852 8 месяцев назад
Its not about stroking your ego, you should be moving from healthy emotional response into problem solving. Time and space need to be given to both stages for both of the sexes.
Далее
S T R U G G L E | Ultimate corecore mix
26:50
Просмотров 479 тыс.
Редакция. News: 136-я неделя
45:09
Просмотров 1,4 млн
5 Things To Know About Passive Suicidal Ideation
24:18
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41
James May finally drives the Tesla Cybertruck
14:15
The Gentlemen - Best scenes
9:51
Просмотров 115 тыс.
The Voices of Men // Men's Mental Health Documentary
10:48
L O N E L I N E S S | ultimate corecore mix
17:53
Просмотров 538 тыс.