Metallica & San Francisco Symphony: All Within My Hands (Live) 

- lol love it !

@Michael dude, it's a joke

I think he´s used wah for so long that the movement is automatic

Classic Kirk!, jajaja

Michael there was no solo in the song either, yet here there is one. 😉

Well said.

You're absolutely right.

We’ve gone a long way from “KILL KILL KILL KILL KILL KIIIIILLLLLLLLLLLLL!”

Could not agree more. Stripping down and rearranging this song and it's become something I can't stop listening to. The addition of the solo and Kirk on the 12 string with that orchestra gives me goosebumps. Avi is a fantastic component as well. My wife even said as she came by, "Damn, that's Metallica? It's absolutely gorgeous."

This is a much better version than the first, I think

If that entire album was like this I would buy it hands down.

Was genuinely surprised as to how good this sounded, so much better. Who’d have thought that a st Anger song would have made this set? Wonder if there’s any other songs on that album that could get some similar treatment? Although it would have to be done in the studio.....

This is just an adaptation of the acoustic version of the song which dates years back and you can find on RU-vid. And St.Anger saved Metallica so F the haters.

@@Bluesruse I still dont like the album. I dont hate it, its just not for me. I like this version with the orchestra much much more. It grabs my attention much more.

Agreed. I never hated St. Anger. I acknowledge that it was just different. However, that solidifies Metallica's versatility. This rendition of All Within My Hands showcases their musical talent.

I love his voice, but mind you - this is fixed in a studio afterwards. And yes, even the vocals.

@@nickred652 It doesn't sound fixed like in S&M, it sounds pretty natural to me

Seems like it hasn't age at all in 25 years

When I saw them live last year. I was surprised how well James vocals were. Definitely as good maybe even a little better than in studio

@@HerobrineGbriel It is. Pretty clear in parts. 0:59 being one example where the pitch correction is pretty obvious at the end of "suffocating".

+

💕

a thousand years lol

he actually was adding solos to the live performances of the St.Anger songs back in 2004. Both "St.Anger" and "Dirty Window" with solos were really cool. The only time "Sweet Amber" was played he added a solo too. Maybe it's time for a St. Anger remaster with solos :D

@@MiguelGutierrez-vs9zu or more importantly, St. Anger with the snare drum on. That's the biggest problem with that album in my opinion, and I'm a guitar player lol.

Proof the song wasn't bad in the first place.

If they don't record St. Anger, then they're done as a band. It's actually a damn good album.

I liked the song on the album; but in this version I like it 1000 times more

Oh if only they had YOUR guidance 🙄

@@deankissell3196 lol

@@deankissell3196 why so salty lol

Agreed, I do wish they did more songs that they hadn’t already done in the original s&m

they made this "reimagination" all the way back in 2007, it wasnt made this way for s&m2, but it does sound killer

黒Fawx Nah

I was waiting to see a comment like yours

I’m glad it didn’t have that part. That was cringe worthy on St. Anger. This version was WAY BETTER than St. Anger’s.

WAGNER entered the chat

i always wanted to hear it at the bridge school benifit councert that would be funny as hell with acoustics

I would gladly attend that concert and not get tired of it.

Would you spend the whole billion to make that happen 😂😂😂

@@vegeta42578 HA I wish

Start with fixxer bro

While smoking fat cigars and sipping on the finest champaigne too! Nice suggestion bro, i think i would too!

same here, havent they added lyrics to this? have a feeling this was personal to james' addiction

It was cool till you said "neat"...that pissed me off a little.

@@elliotwatson3964 No, same lyrics from the original song.

Same.

Agree💪♥️

I am so very jealous

Really? The world has changed? Well, it hasn't my fellow RU-vid patron. But, in case you insist it has, I assure you the change is temporary. COVID-19 is like a natural course correction. Unless it turns out anything like Captain Trips, then we're thoroughly fucked. If COVID-19 is the change you were talking about... Anyway, my opinion, overt opinion.

@@presidentialcampaignmusic1018 It's Kilby

@@justinkilbythexphile6481 covid is a bio weapon created by china to use on their own people who where protesting. They when let it get out to weaken the world. Now that the United States is weaken they'll take it over, either by dip shit Biden handing it over to them or bu taking advantage of the weakened country

@@fh2058 You conspiracy theorists... There is a bit more to taking over a country than that.

At this point, Kirk is a walking wah wah lol

@@a.t.3192 he's gotta change his name to Kirk Wahmett 😂😂

its to keep tempo

@@Exileduh maybe, it makes sense, we make fun.

@@r.j.motajunior2761 but he doesnt use his foot to use wah , he uses his entire body

No doubt he uses wah too much but I think he's just trying to keep in time.

lol that man sure does lovve that wah-wah pedel...!

Hes keeping time btw. But yeah i get the joke

I'm not saying he isn't keeping time but he's clearly stomping on an invisible wah there. He even turns it off and moves his foot off of it lmao, talk about muscle memory.

@@sam8404 nah, you can tell it's not cause he switched his feet and between what part of his foot was lifted such as at 4:26

Yes, loved it.

iT wAS eDiTEd!!!

He sang it better than the horn played it

@@garrethigdon7678 I mean, it was edited, I was there and that is not how he sounded. Out of 9 performances i've seen, James struggled the most hear. With that being said, I am glad the album was touched up. I want it to go down in the history books like S&M 1 as one of the best albums of all time! Touching up live albums as big as this isn''t a bad thing. Gotta get it right!

Auto tune

amen brother

Such an underrated gem

Best song from St. Anger

I was hoping the same thing when I flew out there. This rendition of handz is amazing though.

Would be crazy and dope if they did st anger and frantic with them idk how they could frantic tho would be nuts lol

Bruh for real.

Finally someone said it

yeah boi

what about blackened 2020?

LageRU-vid that wasn’t anything special

The unnamed feeling was awesome too

They played that one in a few acoustic sessions. Worth checking (School Bridge 2007).

No. Not it certainly Dosent do that.

Nope, St. Anger still sucks major shit and it's their worst album by far. A song or two that are not complete ass doesn't give anyone a reason to like St. Anger as a whole.

@@okagron Is it worse than Lulu? That’s technically a Metallica album.

Yeah, who is he?

@@damienscott6561 His name is Avi Vinocur, he performed with them in 2018 too in their acoustic show in San Francisco. The Unforgiven performance in that show was amazing

@@ValentinTheMad Yeah, I've found about him yesterday. Before that I thought that it's James'es son or a nephew for some reason. I'll give Unforgiven a spin right now.

Still a mystery why Kirk and Rob dont take singing lessons to get better at bg vocals. It's consistently the weakest part of every single one of their shows to the point of cringe

@@cal_chrisdera Kirk's guitar playing also needs a lot of work, but I'm sure he just doesn't have time for such unsignificant things.

St. Anger round my neck, he never gets respect

St. Anger is legit my favorite track. With Death Magnetic coming underneath it by just barely.

GengarBroz Track or album? You have two things going on there, might want to reword.

That snare is like cancer to my ears, there is a fan rerecord of st. Anger on YT that helped me appreciate the album better.

@@gradyshmalady8284 The rerecord it's pretty cool. I dig the og more though, the snare grows on you, you know, it's not bad once you get used to it. It actually adds somenthing to some songs.

Totally agree!

@@adam2aces Jesus, on point

The whole album redone in this style would be killer.

@@Hoi4o Now I'm wondering what Shoot Me Again and Purify would sound like.

@@miguelvalencia4309 and Frantic

Damn true

Good Point! Its True

Thats not a bad idea at all!!

Damn this is true.... Daniel Craig, you Watching?

Better than Billy EIlish an Adele, honestly.

I think it's mostly the guy to the left of James, but it could be that Rob doesn't growl all that well? At least not Jason level. There is almost never an opportunity to hit a higher range background vocals for Metallica.

What are they doing with it? Are they re-recording it with a modern sound or just (remastering only) ?

OH LAWD IS THIS TRUE?

Jesus didn't released the black album will be turning 30 next year

But there is no need to remaster it, it's the best sounding production wise album like ever

@@Randomeris1 I agree but they might work with the mixing as well right?

If you listen to St Anger performed in the band's studio it sounds a lot better. I think the album sounds bad because of bad decisions in the recording/mastering stage, cause it sounds absolutely amazing when they play it live.

They originally did AWMH acoustically back in 2007, then resurrected it in 2018. This is a similar, although I think slightly tweaked version.

It's the name of their foundation, that's why they used it.

This is honestly so much better - I would love to hear the whole St. Anger record re-arranged in this format with an Orchestra. Or at least, as many of the songs as they could find a way to pull off that way.

Unnamed feeling

I don’t get these jokes can someone explain?

@@merimurmeridious0927 The daughter's name is Rose, because her mom love roses. The son's name is the title of the actual video, because the dad loves that video. It's an easy joke and usually easy to understand.

Devotional Films okay I get it now I’ve been wondering for a bit

@@merimurmeridious0927 It's a stupid joke.

Your joke made my day happy

Always. Always. Their Brothers in arms and Loverman songs are differently done covers. Not appreciated much, but i love those songs. Top of the heap for me.

.. 2 examples of different styles, lest the comment looks unconnected.

I absolutely love their rendition of lover man.

Yeah they did a good job. Personally it’s the first time I’ve ever enjoyed the song

@@ronsin9490 awesome! I'm one of those weirdos that likes the St. Anger album. I kind of loved the rawness of it. But I really love to hear songs re-imagined like this because it gives you a fresh perspective on it. Really, I'm just happy that Metallica is still going and making/performing music.

James Eaton I agree. I still can’t really enjoy most of the album to this day but it’s so different that it warrants revisits from time to time. And I like the balls they have to jump out and plug St Anger tracks into things like this. They kind of listened to the masses and pushed the album into obscurity and then every once in a while they toss out a little nugget to remind even the oldest of old school Tallicats that the album did exist and that they still have belief in that period in their lives. So even if not enjoyable to me it still warrants some respect.

Nah I think the acoustic on the heavy part does sound anticlimactic, but distortion would ruin the 'vibe'of thr songs and wouldnt suit it.

They are because you said so bud

No doubt,numbers and facts don’t lie

Yeah everyone know about it i love this band i hope other people be good in the way of life

Lol such a calm song but this band were always amazing i need to see documentary about metallica

1:38-2:10 damn nailed it. That would be the most badass bond theme yet

Yes. Yup. Absolutely. 100%

More like Harry potter

Even has a good Bond title.

@@hairyheartsmith8513 yes absolutely!!!!

You’re in luck, that’s exactly what this video is!!! Take a look!!

@@StephenRahrig He wrote this comment yesterday :D

Mr. J4son N3wkid Lol yeah I kept reading comments just like this and realized they probably did an event teaser post

I had a similar experience 4 years ago... 311 saved me from myself.

Great album.

Same thing happened to me when I first heard Metallica in 1991. I was 14. So bitter, frustrated, angry, ready to destroy everything, including myself...till I realized someone else understood and felt my pain. Here I am, 43, married over 20 years, 6 kids, and in ministry. BUT, I'll never forget Metallica. My wife and I were at the 9/6 Symphony show. We said when we heard the first show we couldn't wait for them to do another and when they did, we were going. We never dreamed it would be 20 years later, but it was absolutely amazing experience - one of the best of our lives. I would imagine your experience and mine could be repeated almost endlessly with this band. They have been the friend of three generations of fans now. Remarkable. And its crazy to me that a lot of us really struggled with St. Anger when it came out. It was by far the MOST un-Metallica for a lot of us. But time has served to show how important this album really is in the history of the band. I now only have the highest regard for it. It's not the album we wanted, but its the album the band - and especially James - needed. And it has had a huge impact on a lot of people. I'm glad to see it getting more love these days, even by me. Glad you're well :)

All of this right here is exactly what the Metallica Family is all about...I love all of my brothers and sisters in the Met Fam.

The original snm seriously was my therapist, and this snm2 becides a couple messed up riffs on the call of katlu and outlaw torn it's an absolute masterpiece! It's something I listened to for 20 years and will still listen to for years to come. To have this new album and mix my playlist with, devil's dance, until it sleeps, of wolf and man, and many other tracks from the original that's like 25 tracks of pure fire!!

Same here, man. Metallica is one of my favourite bands and whenever anyone asked me if I thought Metallica had a bad song I’d reply “All Within My Hands”, no second thoughts. Now, I may not be so sure. I really liked the rewrite they did for the AWMH Acoustic Show and the added symphony just gives it that little extra something and now I love this version (still think the original is rubbish tho)

RIP Cliff and his father. They're finally together now, but they'll live on forever.

I was also there. The Sep 6 concert. Didn't get to meet anyone. You lucky dog!

I ALSO THERE! I SAW YOU TAKING PICUTRE! I FOLLOW YOU BACK HOME! HAHAH

i know where you live...

@@RejhanTrubljanin Google knows the address of your IP. Can't hide it win a VPN either. Keep flagging yourself idiot.

Same here bro :)

Same here :)

Had this song on repeat ✌️

Просто ещё один шедевр F R O M M E T A L L I C A 🤘🤘🤘

Completely agree

yes!!!!

Absolutely!

There's the tendency to forget that this came from St. Anger...even I didn't know.

Funny but I've been listening since '88 and I just heard this on sirius TODAY. Didn't even remember that it was a track on St. Anger because I don't consider that a real Metallica album. This version is great.

That was the best Outlaw Torn performance I have seen

This is such a great interpretation of the song! 😊

They are there, i heard them in the movie

Noor Duif I think he meant for the RU-vid vids

Beautiful beautiful beautiful,❤💋🎶🎸🤗👋👋👋👋👋💋💋💋❤️❤

What?

Director Owl still think this is a greatly improved version imo

Thank you, Man!

🤟

Ay man you forgot the part where James screams “KILL KILL KILL” more than 20 times in a row in the end

I like just because you wrote all lyrics But maybe you just taken it on Google...

KILL KILL KILL KILL KAEEL KAAAAAAEEEEEEEEEEL xd

Always a looser somwhere 🙉

They love Metallica they just REALLY hate announcements

Tomorrow when this starts I'll still be at work and miss the first 45 minutes :( urgh. I've never seen S&M2 so I'm looking forward to it

@@claydo787 perhaps they hate that it's tomorrow and not today. To be fair, they have a point!!

12 idiots now.

Greg Fidelman

According to their website they had the entire show remixed/mastered. I didn't see the show when it was in theatres but they said it sounds even better now.

​@@sam8404 there was no time to mix it properly. Mixing band and orchestra really takes time, there's a lot of stuff to do with so many instruments (equalizing frequencies, separatings and adjusting tuning on some vocals, placing different sounds on different speakers.... I saw it on cinema, it sounded no clear at all to me. Now this mixing is killer, you can hear the bass, the acoustic guitars, string session from the orchestra, clarinets (that's a difficult part because it runs at the same frequencies than voices), all so clear. I hope that they put a Atmos mix no the Blu-Ray, that would be fantastic.

Wena wn

Nicoooo

Weeeena

Buena nicooo

Pues si Nico!!! Menos mal q cambiaron x completo la canción original del insufrible St. Anger...sólo de esa forma se podría fusionar con la orquesta!!! Aprovecho para felicitarte por tu gran trabajo en RU-vid 👏🤟☠️!!!

So true. I was just commenting to someon else what a heartbreaker St. Anger was to me back then. I just didn't get it. And it made me so sad because I connected with literally every other album. Now, I get it. I really get where they were. It wasn't the album I wanted, it was just the album that had to happen. Its what James needed. And though I don't like it, I realize now that had Jason not left and had this album not been made, there would be no Metallica today. Now, I absolutely love the album. It is an important piece of their story, and this version is a beautiful moment of redemption and clarity.

@@Rickkelley365 I never thought of it like that TBH. But if Jason being the sacrificial lamb for Metallica to stay together and make Death Magnetic and Hardwired then I'm actually OK with that. Unforgiven 3 and Spit on the Bone are 2 of my favorite songs.

SoFLsteel777 Unforgiven 3 might just make my top 5. It’s my favorite of the trilogy. We actually flew out to see them in SF last year with the symphony and I just hoped they would put the symphony behind that song. It seemed made for it. That was an awesome moment. Aside, the Metallica story can be told by the bass players. 1) If Ron McGovney hadn’t left, they may have never pursued Cliff. Cliff almost singlehandedly solidified and enhanced Metallica’s musical ability and left his indelible mark on metal history. 2) If Cliff hadn’t died, Lars would have been dumped. It’s well documented now that the band was trying to find a way to dump Lars once they finished the MoP tour. 3) Cliff’s death and Jason’s presence provided the creative and emotional fuel to launch Metallica out of the underground and into the mainstream. Commercially, it was gold. Personally, it was a train wreck for all of them, including Jason, the only one who wasn’t completely awestruck with himself. He saw the band for what it was. Amazing, but utterly toxic. He saw what they couldn’t see. He left. They had to deal with it. 4) Had Jason not left, no St. Anger. Many (including me) would say or did say, it’s the album that should have never been made. But it’s the post-Jason leaving album. It’s the NO BASS PLAYER album. How weird. It’s the no solo album. It’s the stop it with the snare album. But looking back, it’s the stripped down album, and that’s exactly where and who they were. You listen to these songs live and wow. They’re ridiculously good. Had they not made this album Metallica would be no more. Jason made it happen. That album is the remnants of the mess he left. That’s what he was hearing while the rest of us were hearing everything else. 5) Rob Trujillo is the consummate steady guy. Maturity, skill beyond skill, energy, entertainment, no frills, and sincere friendship. He really outclasses them all as a musician. He doesn’t rock the boat. He’s not as musically forceful as Cliff, but incredibly talented. They married up when they got Rob. They paid Rob $1M just to sign. That was the beginning of healing. In my opinion, they should have invited Jason to play with them one song on S&M2. Maybe they did. Who knows. I think that would have been a touching moment of redemption for them all. It was a missed opportunity to mend fences with their darker (bass) side. Lyrically and emotionally, Metallica is the story of James Hetfield. Historically, it is the story of 2 bass players, then a bass player but no bass, then no bass player at all, then a fill in, then finally, a third, bass player. That’s how I see it. Believe it or not, I have other interests hahah but no other band is more interesting or has been personally impactful in my life the last 30 years. It will be a sad day when the ride is over. Looking forward to a drive in concert Saturday and maybe some new music in 2021 if we’re lucky :)

@@Rickkelley365 Damn now that is what I call a break down. Thank you for taking the time to share all of that. So I just cant put together a top 5 or 10 or whatever list because the songs are each great in their own right. The Unforgiven trilogy; each song great but different and awesome in their own regard. How do you compare the sounds of a Four Horsemen with King Nothing. Lightening with I disappear. And so on. Unforgiven 3 is one of if not my favs because it is such a great combination of things. Obviously its a trilogy song which IDK of any other bands that have done that. Piano intro which was different than the first 2. Guitar hits, lyrically powerful and IMHO Hammets best solo. As far as Jason with S&M2 that wouldve been awesome, but from what I understand, he has rejoined the band and played bass with Robert too. Maybe they just wanted it to be their own thing I guess. As far as Lars, he seemed all about the brand and making money. From the hair styles, which i still dont understand how people can hate on a band for a hair do but I digress, to the music videos, going mainstream seemed to be all him and James was probably not the one to wanna fight him on it. Kirk is like the most "IDGAF just give me a guitar" I've ever seen. But it took care of each of them and their families so I dont fault them for it. Rob really impressed me on the making of All Nightmare Long with the flamenco playing. He is so multi talented in how he plays, Im glad they paid that man! Now there is word they want to do their best album in 30 years next. This, I am looking forward to and hopefully James stays healthy to be able to complete it.

@@soflsteel777 appreciate all that! as for favorites I hear you. My favorites are more or less the ones that strike a deep personal chord with me, that I never tire of hearing because they always resonate. At 43, there are songs that still hit me about as hard as they did when I first heard them, you know? Those are the faves for me. Stay well my friend :)

... yeah.

Not the St anger song

just make sure you wash them regularly :)

You should've known this

Nice meme reference =))