Тёмный

Michael Sandel at Human After All conference 2014 

New Economic Thinking
Подписаться 261 тыс.
Просмотров 39 тыс.
50% 1

In recent decades, market values have crowded out non- market norms in almost every aspect of life-medicine, education, government, law, art, sports, even family life and personal relations. Without quite realizing it, we have drifted from having a market economy to being a market society. Is this where we want to be?
Should we pay children to read books or to get good grades? Should we allow corporations to pay for the right to pollute the atmosphere? Is it ethical to pay people to test risky new drugs or to donate their organs? What about hiring mercenaries to fight our wars? Auctioning admission to elite universities? Selling citizenship to immi- grants willing to pay? This discussion takes on one of the biggest ethical questions of our time: Is there something wrong with a world in which everything is for sale? And if so, how can we prevent market values from reaching into spheres of life where they don't belong? What are the moral limits of markets?
Introduction: Robert Johnson
President, Institute of New Economic Thinking
Presenter: Michael Sandel
Professor of Government, Harvard University
Discussant: Chrystia Freeland
Member of the Parliament of Canada, Toronto Centre

Опубликовано:

 

11 апр 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 45   
@bnmahdistore7062
@bnmahdistore7062 7 месяцев назад
Thank you michael sandel , I wish more vidoes like this, about meaning,s of life Wissam from sudan 🇸🇩🙏
@hamrazahmad850
@hamrazahmad850 3 года назад
Being a muslim i am all the day searching your videos in the RU-vid in this holiest month of ramadan....upload as more as your videos are available....(my respect and love for you all the way from Pakistan) ( Peshawar)
@sergkapitan2578
@sergkapitan2578 2 года назад
You see, what means nobel Christian man:) as oposed to many who often do not care:(
@petercheung9809
@petercheung9809 5 лет назад
Thank you Michael Sandel, wish more video like this to educate the mass. Once again Thank You Very Much !!!!!
@hndrwn
@hndrwn 6 лет назад
there are annoying background sound that enter the recording. it sounds like people using or sorting utensils. It is unfortunate because it can distract people from otherwise superb lecture by Dr. Sandel
@matthewmcclain9852
@matthewmcclain9852 3 года назад
Was it a luncheon he was speaking at? Sounds like knives and forks on plates to me.
@ergker2243
@ergker2243 3 года назад
Thank you Michael Sandels. 👍🙏🙏🙏💖
@tokotokotoko3
@tokotokotoko3 6 лет назад
Talk starts at 3:48
@azzamohamed9757
@azzamohamed9757 4 года назад
Thx
@sheilabright2091
@sheilabright2091 3 года назад
TY
@elvisehang5296
@elvisehang5296 7 лет назад
great lecture
@vivianoosthuizen8990
@vivianoosthuizen8990 3 года назад
It’s simple if greed hurts humans then laws should be created to protect humans from it
@interests1094
@interests1094 10 лет назад
does this guy teach in harvard?
@Patrick77487
@Patrick77487 5 лет назад
As we just discovered university admissions ARE up for sale, at least under the table.
@markhubey5729
@markhubey5729 10 лет назад
Is there a transcript?
@pathoplastic2
@pathoplastic2 7 лет назад
Different time/place: tannerlectures.utah.edu/_documents/a-to-z/s/sandel00.pdf
@markhubey5729
@markhubey5729 7 лет назад
Thanks
@sergkapitan2578
@sergkapitan2578 2 года назад
Why not to pay money to mams who do want to be home and bring up their Kids???????
@user-sf6bj4ug8z
@user-sf6bj4ug8z 11 месяцев назад
Buon coraggio 👍 👏👏👏
@bnmahdistore7062
@bnmahdistore7062 7 месяцев назад
❤❤❤
@rajgiri7533
@rajgiri7533 Год назад
I want to make my further carrier from Hardbard.
@sergkapitan2578
@sergkapitan2578 2 года назад
Who really want to go deeper, read Nicolas Berdyaev "The destiny of Man"
@mehdibaghbadran3182
@mehdibaghbadran3182 3 года назад
We’re creating market, but not market creat us
@lahfais5488
@lahfais5488 2 года назад
01:02:00
@user-mf4xf5ps6t
@user-mf4xf5ps6t 2 года назад
😘
@mehdibaghbadran3182
@mehdibaghbadran3182 3 года назад
See the production, the rest is side orders
@mehdibaghbadran3182
@mehdibaghbadran3182 3 года назад
I like money, but not by any price !
@sergkapitan2578
@sergkapitan2578 2 года назад
You like not actually money , but what you can by for it:)
@vonkruel
@vonkruel 10 лет назад
We do have to stop worshiping markets. In "free markets" many people are enslaved (and most of them think of themselves as free). If you are capable of realizing that someone who earns 10000x as much as someone else is actually _not_ 10000x more deserving of rewards, then you're ready to question the sanity of the current order. Capital should serve us, but we allow it to rule us.
@vonkruel
@vonkruel 10 лет назад
***** By "according to the facts" you meant "according to the almighty markets". Markets do have an appealing logic to them. I hope one day you can see beyond that logic, to more important truths. I probably won't be able to change your thinking. It's off-topic to moralize to someone who wants systemic change about how they need to "get out there and earn!". You might be surprised to find out that not everyone who wants systemic change is poor themselves. Low income people don't need our moralizing - they've had quite enough of that and where has it gotten anyone? Well, it does have a benefit for those who like to moralize... A root problem here IMO is a false idea of self. You may think you are your body, and that you can really take credit for everything "you" can do. If so, your idea of self is too small. You're a piece of this existence. So is Warren Buffett. So is Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. So is a flower. If you stop identifying with your physical self, there's real liberty in that. You can be grateful to have the skills you have & to be able to put your energies into something worthwhile, and not be worrying (or even gloating) about how your skills stack up against someone else's. In the larger perspective, you just want to be part of making this world a real success, so you can enjoy that along with everyone else. There's no good reason why we need to allow people to be stuck in "poverty traps" any more. We can do better than that. When people are well, and not living under a constant threat of homelessness, then you can see what they're capable of.
@vonkruel
@vonkruel 10 лет назад
***** that was roughly as expected.
@colinc1878
@colinc1878 9 лет назад
If millions of people voluntarily watch a TV show with a single star, who are we to say that the star shouldn't benefit from this and receive orders of magnitude more income than someone who only entertains a handful of people - say a local stand up comedian?
@Orf
@Orf 6 лет назад
1:29:00 feminist question
@DerekWong967
@DerekWong967 4 года назад
so stupid, she just antagonizes everyone in the room for no reason
@kaveia
@kaveia 7 лет назад
you CAN buy a Nobel price: the economics "Nobel" price
@mehdibaghbadran3182
@mehdibaghbadran3182 3 года назад
I prefer to be natural
@an34uchannel36
@an34uchannel36 5 лет назад
Marxism helps in some way
@user-or1ke5yh4m
@user-or1ke5yh4m 4 года назад
pluralisme de manger et faire petits, selon Aristote, jamais de moralité, mais pratiquent en économique, par Jean Tirole, capitalisme en Chine communistes
@sergkapitan2578
@sergkapitan2578 2 года назад
Why so "modest" On gambling:) IT is immoral, exactly as playing with money in the Wall street...!!!
@user-qt7uo3sk3l
@user-qt7uo3sk3l 2 года назад
The thirsty editor marginally depend because discovery greely raise absent a unequal teacher. broken, temporary driving
@martingraziosi45
@martingraziosi45 4 года назад
36:25 Mr Sandel is very inteligent and interesting, but not neutral either. He is using the example of the day care in a very...how can I say it. Deshonest is to strong, and unfair to lite. You decide. The problem with his example is that he does not tell all the story. In his example there is a demand for more day care centers that the public is willing to pay. The market is not the "bad inflence". The market is simply showing that there is an unmet demand. Secondly, the people, that ran this particular day care in Israel, don't want to extend the sift? Then the problem is not the market, the problem is that they priced the fine to low. Let me use the logic of mr Sandel. If I go to New York city with my car, and want to park in Manhatan. I see a sign that says if you park here the fine is u$s 100 and a block away there is a parking lot that charges u$s 200. If I park on the street and save u$s100. Mr Sandel will say that the markets are destroying my civic virtues etc etc. I think that is a falacie. Because markets work when you allow them to work as a hole, not in one area a not in the others. The price of fines can't be arbitrarie and the prices of the parking spaces can't either. In Israel, if they let the markets work, very soon some one will see that that particular day care is not meeting all the demands of the parents and so will open anorher day care when the first one closes. I think that mr Sandel is a good man, getting old and romanticising the past. We old people do this all the time. I am from argentina and very often tell my kids how good it was to play soccer on the street with a bunch of kids from the neighborhood. It was there where we share the public space and made friends that money can't buy etc. One tends to believe that the markets have destroyed that posibilities, because today people have bought millions of cars and kids can't play on the streets etc etc. What mr Sandel and I need to understand is that no one person can force the good life into others. Markets, justice, freedom can take us to a good place or a bad place. But gives us the choice. Planing, forcing others to live well, in the long run, takes us to a very dark place, and there is no choce with those very well intended "Harvard sugestions". The Church , great intentions, the USSR, great intentions, the liberal universities of the usa, great intentions. Lets learn from facts, not intentions. I know that it is very popular, today, to believe that there is no such things as facts. Everything is an opinion etc . If this is the case. What are we arguing about?
@sergkapitan2578
@sergkapitan2578 2 года назад
You are too oversimplifing things... He is not naive and does not push anyone to do something, mostly He provoke to think where people usually do not think much! His ideas against meritocracy is very good and timely!!! He speaks very well against Neoliberalism! Not all things in history come about immidiately, so slavory was not abolished when Wilberforce was speaking in the Parlament... Only later people come to critical mass to get rid of it!
@user-yp7nc7dn4m
@user-yp7nc7dn4m Год назад
سندوتشات.سندل.لي.مشاكل.في.لاسم.الذي.سجل.في.مديا.سوسيال.غير.لاسم.السليم.المسجل.بالبطاقه.هو.اسم.مستار.. هذا.والبنك.اف.امركا..وبرتش.بنك.كل.منهم.لاسم.المسجل.عندهم.هو.اسم.مستعا.ولام.الحقيقي.الحبيب.بنعسانه.التصحيح.لاسم.وتامين.علي.المال.عندهم.لكي.لا.يدون.ايديهم.وكشف.حساب.من.البنوك.برتش.واف.امركا.والسوسيال.مديا.هل.ممكن.التخل.منكم.او.تدلونا.علي.من.عنده.امانه.وشكرا.لكم
Далее
HLS in the World | Markets and Morals with Michael Sandel
1:22:30
Michael Sandel: On the Good Life
23:58
Просмотров 44 тыс.
СПАЛИЛА МАМЕ СТАРШУЮ СЕСТРУ
00:23
The Failure of Liberal Politics
27:30
Просмотров 181 тыс.
Three Chinas | The Economics of China Episode 1
17:56
Michael Sandel on the Justice of Education
53:00
Просмотров 48 тыс.
Think Fast, Talk Smart: Communication Techniques
58:20