Moist Meter | Red Dead Redemption 2 

Blar_ “The city of Sawn Dani is grateful for your service.”

sandy knee

English is stupid

😭😭😭😭😭😭

@@kgo4026 well it's French but whatever you say uncle

Rybreadsandwich or the folk

Makes me feel like a good boah

7/10 has a little something for everyone

2/10 too many cowboys

1/10 too much grass

fr

@@cycyshawty2866 ummm we can start with Elden Ring… lol. And ya know… the game that beat Rdr2 for Game of the year… GoW2018. And also this new Tears of the Kingdom 30 hours in, is probably the best video game I’ve ever played. It hasn’t released yet but got early copy. So if I was comparing games with scores Tears of the kingdom: 10/10 Elden Ring: 10/10 GoW2018: 9/10 Halo 2: 9/10 Halo 3: 9/10 Skyrim: 9/10 Rdr2: 8/10 Breath of the Wild: 8/10 Sekiro: 8/10 Gta5: 8/10 The Witcher 3: 8/10 The last of us (PART ONE LOL): 8/10 Hogwarts Legacy: 7/10 Smash bros Ultimate: 7/10 GoW Ragnarok: 6/10 Cyberpunk: 5/10 The last of us part 2: 4/10

@@cycyshawty2866 ok honestly Rdr2 is a special game, but I’m pretty harsh when it comes to review scores. To me an amazing game could still be a 8/10 But average games are like 4/10 or 5/10 like your typical assassins creed I grade this way so its easier to separate the average from good and good from great. So if I give Assassins creed a 7/10 but the witcher 3 or Red Dead a 9/10 that makes pretty much no sense because both games are far and away better than Assassins Creed

@@cycyshawty2866 I mean I’m sure you’ll disagree with everything I have to say but I just think there are a few games the past 20 years that were better than Rdr2

@@cycyshawty2866 I love Rdr2 but wish there was more to do. Its just not quite up there with the best games of all time.

Yeah you are obliged to just stand and watch the sunset or go hunt the legendary animals, go into random houses on the map etx

​@@DailyShit. that's not what the comment said. There is a lot of content besides the story which is immersive and funy but when you only rush though the story you won't see how incredible the game is. Noone said anyone was obliged to do it, but for a review it's necessary

He's a entrepreneur. He got no time

Charlie tends to dislike my favorite games for the exact reasons they are my favorite games. There are plenty of other fast paced ADHD games out there that are a blast. We don't need more. The game industry desperately needs more slow burn games.

@@bravingbrivatebrian He is a speedrunner at the end of the day. I don't take his opinion on what makes a game good seriously whatsoever. This is a totally braindead take from Charlie.

That’s because he rushed between mission objectives trying to fucking speedrun because he can’t sit down for 5 minutes and enjoy a fucking game Edit: I’ve come back to this comment realizing that I sound really mad but I wanna make sure everyone knows I wasn’t mad and idk why I phrased it like that

@@downwindfish1 chill out bro😭

@@downwindfish1 it really annoys me 😂

@@downwindfish1 thats true i had 100 hours playtime on this game and i still havent seen everything there is to see

@@Bando710_ nah he spitting, the same fucking shit markiplier did. Probably memeing the entire time and not giving the game the time and care it deserves. hours upon hours of work, a brilliant story, ruined because he wanted to run through it as fast as possible. Charlie missed.

HelterSkelterOG dumb ass feature

@@damion1332 dumb ass person

@@schippai3308 oh shit someone has opinions must be an idiot amirite.

@@schippai3308 Dumb ass windows 7

@@damion1332 Yea dumb ass feature that mimics real life by having things expand by heat and shrink from the cold, damn I hate physics

Yes

literally 💀💀💀

Underrated comment

That was just an example of the overall misstep in regard to the over immersion aspects of the game which I definitely agree it’s way to much and certain personalities definitely find this game boring Edit: and tedious

I think I have a counter argument for the looting complaint. For this we need to consider what do we get from looting NPCs. What we usually get for looting random NPCs is money, consumables (like cigarettes and stuff) and sometimes jewellery that we can sell for more money. All of these items are neither rare nor do they require a ton of effort to obtain in the game. Sure you can loot the bodies if you want, but enemies are not the main source of these items. Bcoz you're gonna get a ton of those items simply playing the game. And most of the time you can play for hours if you have a few of those items on hand without needing to refill your inventory every few minutes. Money is also never an issue and you have plenty of money all the time, and even if you don't, looting NPCs is not the way to earn money bcoz they have cents on them at a time, so you don't need to loot if you don't want and you also won't miss out on anything. On the other hand, something that you will consume and run out of a lot is ammunition. This is where the game has made it much easier to loot ammunition. Just like the other items mentioned before, ammunition is also something that you find on enemies. Except this time enemies are the main source of ammunition. Sure you can buy ammo at a store, but when you're in the middle of the desert or the swamp and run low on ammo (which will happen a lot), you probably won't go all the way back to town to buy some cartridges. So what do you do? You kill NPCs and loot their ammo. But unlike the other items you don't need to manually loot each NPC for ammo, you can simply walk past them and Arthur will pick it up. That's how the game has made it be realistic for those who would want to get immersed and loot each body, while not making it frustrating for people who don't want to do that.

what are you talking about, riding through saint denis at night time makes me cream everywhere. the yellow lighting with the blue sky on a quiet street as you hear the horse gallop is something soo amazing. and i love the other places just as much, but saint denis is bealutiful

@@ishmamyousuf2595 I find both the wilderness and Saint Denis beautiful. Rockstar did a great job designing the world.

@@ishmamyousuf2595 agreed st. Denis and from hidden valley to tall trees is my fav woodlands area.

When you're looking at Saint Denis from a distance that's true, but when you're in the city it feels so alive and bustling, and as clearly evident by how fast Charlie was trying to bulldoze through the game he did not take the moment to sight see the city from outside because it is beautiful once you're in.

Plus he called it Saint Dennis. Its Den-knee, CHARLIE. GOSH

Agreed. It was chock filled. I used fast travel like three time in my 80hr playthrough.

Really though? I rode with John (after Arthur dies) for like an hour just South West into the desert and barely did anything the entire time. Edit: I have since revisited Rdr2 and played it slowly, really enjoying the experience as thoroughly as possible and while I think it’s far from perfect, it is a very good game.

@@samuelabbottchannel wrong game

It's the least empty open world on the planet

@@samuelabbottchannel New austin is more of an easter egg for completing the game than part of the actual map.

True the one true downfall lol

Dont worry, there wont be any camp to walk in soon.

@@riotriguez5854 is that a spoiler!? >:(

@@Lezzylree mhm, I love sticky lizards...

o_o . . . I'm an art channel btw

How the fuck do you complete a game in 4 months

I had trouble in the beginning of playing, because of how slow it was. After a week I came back and decided I would immerse myself, I've played the game twice now and I agree, these peoples problems with rdr2 is just because they wish they could speed run stories in less than a day.

And for him to say they didn't change the gameplay from rdr, just shows he barely played almost. He may have played through the story, but he clearly didn't actually PLAY.

I don’t want a game to take 4 months to beat that’s ridiculous. The games cool but it is wayyyy to slow placed a slow burning story is fine but the game straight up isn’t fun at certain points.

@@mernky3562 yeah, it does take too long to set up sometimes. It's a VERY slow burn. I personally enjoyed it because I bought it during quarantine, but if you have a life you can't really make up the time to truly enjoy the game

I agree with charlie

@@clashroyalepro9845You didn’t play the game right then

@@dukegrady9 I beat chapter 6 so I have some value in this opinion but talk your talk

@@clashroyalepro9845 So have i 😂 Rdr2 is amazing if you think otherwise you didnt play it right or youre just a delusional hating fool

@@clashroyalepro9845 Plus you play roblox and fnaf on you channel 🤣 Your opinion on gaming is irrelevant

not a con thou

@@yareugae638 then why did Charlie make it sound like a con?

@@yareugae638 It is a con, it's very much a con. The story and scenes in this game are great, but it's seriously held down by its extremely shitty and unrefined gameplay. RDR2, any R* game for that matter, would make a waaaay better movie or TV series

@@dylanj950 dumbest opinion I think I've heard on this game lol

@@STANDARD_POTATO doesn't mean it's a con lol

Then fall guys dies in 2 months

@Radioactive Gentleman yep I played it thank god it was free for ps plus and I got bored of it after 8 games it's absolutely shit

@Radioactive Gentleman True

@Radioactive Gentleman I can tell your like 6 because you use Gay as an insult for a video game. Everyone is subjected to there own opinion and using gay to describe an insult just makes you look sad and childish.

@@donke9120 are you gay?

A game should be realistic to assuage your immersion into the word you are engrossed in....but at the same time it shouldn't be that realistic to the point where it blends itself in with the real word you are trying to escape from. In some cases, developers should just capitalize on the fact that this is a video game, and you can cut corners here and there. Image in Dark Souls you had to watch your character refill every individual flask when you rest at a bonfire with a laborious animation just for the sake of immersion and realism.

@@Mrhappyface52so u want to walk over the body’s and prefer the object just show up in your inventory? I swear people are too lazy to press a couple buttons nowdays

​​@@Mrhappyface52 I love the animation but you're kinda right they should have put an option to turn off the animation

@@xdmrzzz8740”pEOplE ArE Too LaZY” yeah cause i def wanna spend the next 30 mins bending over dozens of corpses in some random ass swamp

​@@xdmrzzz8740Yes, brother. It is a video game. Its purpose is to be fun. Looting and watching the same fucking animation for 3 minutes after every encounter is not fun.

he clearly has undiagnosed ADHD

Call guys got 90% and this didn’t

Yeah, I don't see how he could give it 80%. It's 65 at most. One of the most boring and useless gaming experiences I have ever had. Guarma was okay but that's such a small part that it could never make up for the rest of the sleep trip.

@@Sandlund93 did you play through it high

@@djblackcat1999 Nah, I think that was the problem. I might have enjoyed it, at least somewhat, if I was high the whole time. But I actually had high hopes for this game, that's why I was so disappointed.

I got some jellybeans. you like jellybeans?

Can i turn myself in?

Just wondering what the plan is Dutch ??

There he is, the man with the plan, The Mysterious plan that we must all trust

I too have a plan.

Lol

Slow very very slow

GOTEEEEE

1k likes but only 4 replies Ok....

@@CRAZY-M6641 exactly

@@bottlife2407 wym? How am i a mearyder if i don't like gta but like red dead redemption

@@bottlife2407 exactly

pretty sure he just doesnt have time, last time i checked your not a youtuber, or a streamer.. and he probably has a life outside of video games.

@@GuyHoleMan My guy i am an engineer and I still had time to finish the game💀🫵🤡

He is terminally online ofc he can't sit down for a minute without the dopamine

Literally, everyone complains about slow gameplay, looting takes forever, I love the immersion, it made me feel like I was Arthur, I agree looting bodies takes forever but, literally after you rob the bank in Valentine, I barely looted bodies anymore because anything the NPC's carried was so insignificant it really didn't matter cuz I just bought ammo, and healing items from the store.

@@KreamyBeef I personally really love the skinning and looting animations.

it's probably a great game if you have lots of time or have no life, but if you play it for 1 hour sessions with 10 minutes of loading screen it's unplayable

@@Jeffff13524 saying it’s a great game if you have a lot of time or no life is just an incredibly flawed argument in my opinion. sure it’s your opinion, but we’re free to disagree also

​@@Jeffff1352410 minute loading screens? Sheesh, I forgot how bad old gen and HDDs are lol. Get a new gen console or even better, an SSD. You'll literally forget loading screens exist, for the most part.

I agree when I watched his streams he just rushes through every mission

Hades Because some people realise we don’t have eternity to live and are trying to have fun.

nayypalm Reviews are opinion, that’s why each review is different. The only thing that isn’t opinion is the graphics, and he said they’re amazing. And I own the game and play it sometimes, but it’s far from the best game I’ve ever played. And I’m allowed to criticise the game by the way.

I was actually completely fine with all of it, which is surprising because of my ADHD. I completely disagreed with Charlie on the alleged “emptiness” of the game between towns. IMO, the space is filled to the brim with wildlife, strange encounters, and overall just beautiful views and angles every which way you turn. So far, I’ve probably put a good 60 hours into the game and not once have I ever taken the train.

@@JK-ei7wr it's about immersion, if you're trying to stream for the lulz you're probably not gonna get sucked into being a cowboy. It's about spending an evening hunting for pelts in the woods. Incredible game.

JoeBobThe3rd goddamn that actually convinced me to buy the game, that’s pretty cool

@@prakharmishra5187 your missing out dude

@@iloveseeingtheworldburn4035 whelp, as a medical student there's only so many games I can play lol

Prakhar Mishra I would definitely play the game when you have a lot of free time so probably not right now but good luck on your study’s bro

@@prakharmishra5187 aye dw, play it at your own pace. I play it for like an hour a day. I shot a guy's fingers off. And then i ran around in the wild for the rest of the time. And i enjoyed every bit of it

Agreed. He became IGN when he made this lol

agreed, just finished it.. shouldve been like 60%

@@martincapek96 You have a terrible opinion. Go back to playing your MWIII with your anime skins cnt

You rdr2 fans get triggered so easily😭😂

​@@UnderliningsquareYou should watch the live streams Critikal made when RDR2 came out. He started criticizing the game since THE FIRST LOADING SCREENS

you clearly haven't played breath of the wild or tears of the kingdom

@@BingBong422 can the horses balls shrink in winter? i dont think so

@@Wv-mt5vc exactly, can you kill someones husband and the wife will remeber you did it. i dont think so

@@BingBong422mid af

​@@BingBong422i have and red dead ABSOLUTELY CLEARS

Exactly and if you pay attention in the single player theres always people to meet or small missions to do in the wilderness

@Levelovixor yeah he completed the game in a couple streams probably and hasn't touched it again

Unlike gta 5 were you feel like you are in a museum and you cant touch anything

@@tudor7501 yeah there is a real lack of interactivity with alot of the environment is gta v

@@bird1ee._..__._._.__._.613 That's something I hope will change in GTA VI, that would actually be fking huge

He would have gave it a 90% if it wasn't for Alfred, that bastard

just got the game, i just finished tahiti, where is alfred, I’ll blast him for Charlie

@@r3trobananas33 Too late, he's already contracted lumbago and died

Some say he moved in to a small city in the west coast. Little did we know Alfred was Lamar all along

@@r3trobananas33 haha found you lenny

nah the game is overrated trash, charlie says only facts here

@@user-hhf234fse found the fortnite kid

@@myhad cope

@@user-hhf234fse Wow such a cool and smart guy!!

​@@sleuff WOW SUCH A SARCASTIC GENIUS HERE!!!!

Wait are you serious?

@@DaffierPig6843 why did nobody tell me :(

Me too my dude put it on cinema cam thinking I'll use it as an improp to fast travel and I watch RU-vid and next thing I know dead is on the screen this game is crazy with how lively the world really is he really hasnt sat down an really soaked it in

Yup you get a random encounter like every few minutes.

Totally agree. Red dead 2 and the Witcher 3. Most alive open worlds I’ve ever experienced

Sro check out metro exodus if you haven’t yet, super realistic game and fantastic story definitely on par with red dead 2 in a lot of regards. And especially more so if you have played the first 2 metro games

it keeps repeating itself at a point

@Tumour Consumer yeah, people seem to forget that he plays online games a lot (which are largely fast paced) and 2 of his favorite games are Doom and Doom Eternal which are fast-paced shooters.

Exactly thank you

Well said

Yeah but the thing is that reviews are supposed to be used as if a game is good or not. Not if a game is good for the reviewer to enjoy or not, if that’s confusing I’m sorry it’s not easy to explain

Nope. It's not the "slowness" that puts people off, it's the clunkiness. RDR2 is an insanely sluggish game with awful mechanics. It's so bad that it's almost unplayable on free aim(no auto aim). Its a very convenient excuse to say it's slow and realistic but the truth is it's just very badly design from a gameplay standpoint. If people don't stop nuthugging rockstar and praising them all the time, the bad controls will be a standard for their games.

@@BruceMakesGames That’s what I’m saying, he’s wrong.

dude just chillax, let the guy think what he wants, its his opinion, he said it was a great game.. but it is very flawed.. in my opinion.@@poopbuutt i respect that you like the game though, you should do the same.

@@GuyHoleMan Yeah its just some feedback. Rockstar definitely needs to update its gameplay style and even minor inconveniences are solid criticisations

As opposed to the rdr2 meatriders 😮‍💨

Exactlyyyyyyy

What's the point of that though? How does it serve the gameplay in any way? It's just icing that means absolutely nothing if the cake tastes like shit. If you like the gameplay as it is, I bet stuff like that adds a ton. But if you are nothing but bored by the gameplay it does nothing. Well, it might serve as escapism from the game for 2 seconds lol. Personally, I play games because they themselves serve as the escapism. In their entirety.

@@Sandlund93This game is anything but empty. It’s the little things like a hawk swooping down and catching its prey or a bear hunting fish by a river or animals playing dead when their scared that really immerse you into the world of red dead redemption. I think you are to blinded by having to have fun every 10 minutes you can’t appreciate such a beautiful game. It even has that fun factor every once in awhile you’ll encounter an npc who needs your help or attackers ambushing you on lonely roads in certain areas.

@@22mph You're absolutely right. I play games to have fun. And I never did with this one. And while I agree with some of Charlie's points, the boring factor is my main criticism. I guess it's a bit like Once Upon a Time in the West, it's too f-ing slow. And if I'm already disconnected when it finally picks up its pace... well, there you go. It constantly took me out of the immersion but I get that it was the opposite for most people.

@@Sandlund93 Ah yes, cause a game should have content action with fast paced everything! We get it, you have a slow attention span and can't play slow paced games. It's not our fault youve been taught that way

@@ZachZone Unless you were on the dev team, I have no idea why you take it so personally.

Yeah same

same i found all the little animations enjoyable lol

The game is supposed to be played like that! For fast gameplay go to Rdr online

Honestly, why he trynna be so fast?

You didnt even have to loot you could jus go buy shit, you make a lot of money on purpose

No

Botw did that for me but instead of slowly galloping I was always distracted and discovering new shit before I get to the objective.

Dave Bobier EXACTLY! “Hmm. I’m going to rob a store at saint denis.” *RANDOM ENCOUNTER* “Oop, I wanna check this out.” “Alright nowww I am going to go.” *Sees a perfect animal* “Hmm, I wanna kill and sell this.” “Alright, done will sell this thennnn go to saint denis” *Bounty Hunters going for my huge bounty* “Agh, will kill them and take there loot” “Alright done. No distractions.” *ARRIVES AT SAINT DENIS AND STORES ARE CLOSED* “Gah, I got too distracted.”

some people dont have fucking eternety

@Sam Beckett its not as easy sam beckett, i want to play the game, but i dont want to go through the slowness of picking up each item

that sounds miserable

@@ilovecapybaraanimals9411 Its not a game for everyone.

@@bizar7130 its not a game for anyone this man made now rd2 sound like a game for actual losers. Was gonna buy it now im not

@@ilovecapybaraanimals9411you play it how you want lol

@@Hellllllo852 Wdym? Theres no variation.. its all forced on you in a linear path.

Let alone the treasures, hidden hats, weapons, Dino bones, wall carvings, legendary animals, fish, rare horses and even a fucking murder mystery

He is so Brain dead its not even funny

@@mr.mysteriousyt6118 it's just taste doesn't make him braindead

Yea he just prefers fast paced games over slow burns. I've never seen him give a slow paced game any higher than an 85%.

Exactly bro

linear I agree the slower paced gameplay was nice compared to other games

linear same

Yah I think he missed the point there

That's fine for the first playthrough of the mission but trying to get gold in that same mission having the ability to get past that would've been nice.

Right! On my current playthru I try and ride slow just cuz I don’t wanna miss any chit chat!

Have you even listened all of his complaints. I agree that the world isn't as empty as charlie says, but listen to his complain. He isn;t totally wrong, is he?

@@aridbreeze8613the comments say otherwise lol

@@HungrySlothDEFCON1yeah fanboys are crying in the comments cause he has a different opinon lol

⁠@@DeadX2fanboys? All I see is Charlie meat riders defending their precious saint against the horrible rockstar fans for having a shit take which apparently almost never happens.

One of THE worst reviews ever*

Jesus Christ hell yeah jesus

@Absol The darkness Stop

@Absol The darkness you aren't funny, please stop

If Jesus is buying it, I have to as well. Now I need to get a PS4 Pro....

I like how jesus is verified so you *really* know he's the one and only

Yeah the bounty system is the worst part if this game and the only thing I really dislike

Joe Sheridan I hmmm h

I don't like how easy it is to lose honor sometimes, one time I was looking for the second Jack Hall map and I lost honor because someone got attacked by a cougar and I couldn't even get to it because I was on a narrow cliffside not anywhere near where this could have happened. And then when you accidentally knock someone over in Saint Denis and you become wanted, even though they survived.

Anakin Skywalker There’s a lot of sand in it too

@Anakin Skywalker thats the problem. You don't shoot your way out of it, you defuse with the lawman, and he tells you to get out of the area, no bounty, no memory, no shit like that. Hope you see this.

Charlie has a small kids brain . If a game doesn't have a million explosions in his face it sucks

@@TheDonkey666 he probably just doesn’t enjoy rockstar’s outdated clunky gameplay and shitty level design 🤦‍♂️

​@@lewiemhmad7394 Charlie doesn't care about story, he just wants to speedrun everything. He is the reason there is Subway surfers gameplay during a video.

@@lewiemhmad7394shitty level design? Gameplay isn’t even that bad, ppl like you just want to find a way to criticize the game.

@@TheDonkey666the worst part of it all is that Kai cenat, known for being a child just finished the entirety of rdr2 on stream recently.

real

Yeah same, the flaws weren't noticable enough to even be considered flaws. The only real major flaw for me was the shitty mechanics when you are going up a hill on foot or on a horse, your character just fucking ragdolls and dies or your horse will just slide all the way down the mountain. I think Charlie didn't like the game that much because he's much more into action packed games and generally doesn't like slow paced, methodical gameplay, which I can respect but I also think he should recognize why people play this game and like it so much when rating it.

@@goldmantis5850 my only gripe with this game is how tedious the animations were and how clunky the combat was, other than that this is my favorite game because of the writing itself

@@carlo2038 the controls feel clunky because the settings start off slow but sensitive. Which you can change

The flaws make some things a live hate situation like I hate and love the horse riding system as well as the aim system

@@coolgamer3646 there's an autopilot mechanic for riding horses

I agree. It feels like Charlie didnt or couldnt climatise to a more immersive, slower, but amazing game. You can even see in the streams that he was rushing the game.

That's like every rpg

@@milk-el8vq not really

rockstar missed with this trash game

@@itsfirecrakr9419 I play the exact same way and it makes it difficult for me to enjoy the game. I'm worried it's always going to be that game that I recognise as great but never quite have a good time with it myself.

same but id still give it like a 70 because i know its flawed, its way harder to make a perfect game when its this big and detailed

This is one of my top 3 worst game that I've ever played, almost everything about this game is complete trash.

@@Sandlund93 goddamn

He’s literally complaining about an option that is GIVEN within the game, an option that won’t have an effect on his gameplay experience if he just chooses the option to not fucking do it; Which rockstar has given. Pretty fucking minuscule, borderline irrelevant dumb complaint to say the least. And to spend three minutes ragging on it in a 10 minute video. C’mon now son. Most of what he said is subjective though, so it just is what it is.

@@himersampsbutstronger5946 i consider Charlie as God of objective opinions, although his initial 2 complains about the looting mechanics and world feeling empty were extremely idiotic, he plays to must fast paced games and judged this by those standards, not a good opinion

@@himersampsbutstronger5946 someone's mad...

"Not a good opinion" I don't think you have a good opinion lol. In all seriousness though, this game isn't God tier, far from it infact. It's okay to criticize the things you love, I do it all the time. The issue is when people just ignore the flaws in a game, it's much harder to make a better one when you don't know where to improve.

@Leigh Ramsay since you spent your time replying I'd say some folks do give a shit smh.

his answer was in-depth of the pros and cons and where he mention the pros he gives credit where due -- this is a honest and good review

@@AlluringPegasu13 he doesn't have to agree with Charlies cons🙄

@@AlluringPegasu13 charlie has the concentration span of a 13 year old

@@kn478 i disagree with the cons entirely

@@AlluringPegasu13 why do people like you always say things like “rockstar fanboy” ??? like it means anything offensive….. plus i am aloud to disagree

antagonists with a plural Dutch Van Der Linde Micah Bell Agent Milton and the Pinkertons Leviticus Cornwall Colm O'Driscoll and his gang Lee Grey Catherine Braithwaite and the Lemoyne Raiders Angelo Bronte Alberto Fussar the Del Lobo gang the Nightfolk and so many more

John is better Arthur is alright very overated

@@DeadX2 That's your opinion and you're in the minority. John is cool but I felt more for Arthur. Also he's funnier, more intimidating, he has regrets. He's way more relatable and his dynamic with Dutch and the gang more interesting

@@Mochaphilatte arthur isnt funnier arthurs lines are copy and pasted johns lol and yet john is still funnier and johns def more intimidating

@@Mochaphilatte also the reason im in the minority is cause its mostly 12 year old arthur fanboys who never played rdr1

Yeah this is the type of game that once it clicks, you are fully immersed. Taking everything slowly and just soaking it all in. This is one of my favorite games of all time

It gets boring sometimes which drops the score, gameplay is outdated as well

@@poopooman6725 i agree, the mission design for this game is several decades outdated, the missions play similar to GTA SA and thats a game from nearly 19 years ago at this point. rockstar needs to step their game up in terms of quest/mission design, to make them more fun and not just walk from point A to B kill a bunch of AI and then go back to point A.

@@epepepe7178 San andreas was the best gta game.

The hunting was so shit what

Ikr what a fucking dumb ass

@@MonsieurEldritch jeez man chill out

@@hijutakai4726 Nah moist is a dumbass. He's complaining about nothing.

@Koli so you're surprised someone doesn't like a shitty opinion?

@Koli understandable

LENNY

HAHAA Found you lenneyh

damn :)))))))))))))

Yup everyone who doesn’t like the thing you like has a small attention span. I read a lot of books every day. I watch dry ass cinema. When I play games, I judge them on the merits of the video game medium, which is gameplay. As a video game, rdr2 is clunky and outdated and limiting. As a cinematic escapist experience, it’s unprecedented. But it’s a video game at the end of the day

@@juggles5474nah you just dumb

​@@juggles5474You might be the dumbest lad I've ever heard of boii over here saying it is outdated, lmao you like reading "parently" doesn't make ya attention span good nor watching boring ass cinema it's you that is wrong your mindset to a certain game made for certain people which will take place in ya future. I am certain to not say dumb shi, you got offended and typed on whatever ya use to a point that is dumb saying " I read and watch boring shi studying daily picking words out head ah" that there lad is ego.

Honestly I think Charlie is unable to enjoy story based and immersive games he is more of the type of guy who wants gameplay more than anything.

@@Originalsapling405 Or maybe he just wants a decent gameplay in story based games, because that adds to the immersion? Why choose one or two, if you can have all three?

you are not qrong

I will plant the flag with you good sir. This game is perfection. The only people who disagree are adhd kids or speed runners who can't handle mini cuts like when you're skinning an animal ect. The more you take your time the more you get sucked in then all of a sudden 7hrs goes by and you sit there like damn lol

@@W47689 thank you

Die on that hill, and face to the west so you can remember all the good times we had that way.

It will be until a few years later

I agree, I just wish more people who dislike the immersive elements would stop claiming their view as law.

Its not immersion its realism. Games that have fantastical elemts can still be immersive

Jupp

I love it

Yeah I like takin my time with shit and just enjoying the game I'm playing. Some of these guys in the comments talk as if they have a stopwatch to time every small action in the game to test the maximum efficiency.

Can’t agree more man

Eh it’s just a movie the only gameplay you have is holding x

I really hate this way of comparing rating from games from 2 completely different genres. If he put both together he would probably chose rdr2 because it’s the better overall game but he’s not because they are no where near the same game so stop comparing irrelevant scores.

@UCHWOkqyXrXd7sKx_9G7WVkQ your a moron. You clearly just rushed the missions. You didn’t fish,hunt,

Same idiot that gave tlou 2 a low score as well. Give him any anime or anime game he rates it a 90%

Moist Meter: Warframe when?

Legatus this undoubtedly would score a 120/100

Lego star wars complete saga is okay i dont know y ur so hyped about it

Early my man. I can respect that.

It’s all ogre. He ain’t gonna do it

This game made me feel depression when arther died and I didn’t even want to play it after

Dude I still haven’t 100% I just need all the challenges

@@mattyice535 i saved the most boring ones for last, but i did complete them xD

@@eduardozamudio8812 thanks for spoiling

@@mritachirulz lmfao the games been out for 2 years and youre in a comment section of a review, of course youre going to see spoilers dude

Physical Manifestation of Cancer Does anyone take his reviews seriously at this point? He gave Halloween the same score as this. I miss the crit that didn’t think his opinion was worth anything.

They always say yee haw, but never ask haw yee :(

i do understand its the same shit from 8 year ago but i think it was mostly aimed at people who just met the franchise and they wanted to play it but not the old version

+@@MercurialStatic I just ignore the actual number rating. The rest of the review is far more meaningful and accurate in my opinion.

1 Yeehaw = 8 or 80%

Bro what

when strimmer doesn’t like game i like (im retarded)

You've probably played 3 games in total

@@ant8041 pobanly

@@HaPham-jn7jk lol fixed it

@@ant8041 I have played a LOT of games including elden ring, bloodborne and tlou2. i can confidently say that this game is the best game i’ve ever played.

@@DrakeRing No god of war? Because to me it is the only game that tops red dead rdemtion.

You probably just got the game

@@mayonnaise3959 nope, i said 3 years

What are you discovering? I didn't discover shit. The epilogue sucked balls and the desert area sucked even more. The only part I enjoyed somewhat was Guarma, the rest was utter boring trash. I had to force myself to finish it, which is something that rarely happens with neither games nor series.

@@Sandlund93 the game is just clearly not for your type of personality. You can go through these comments and see people say the exact opposite. You admit yourself that you speed ran the game which you’re supposed to do the opposite of

@@hooper157 Yup, I think you are spot on. Because I really wanted to like this too. But at the same time I'm not gonna lie to myself, I didn't think GTA 5 was anything special either. It was average to me, so I just don't see where all the Rockstar hype is coming from. But I obviously wish I did.

A linear storyline isnt supposed to be replayed imo. Its not like Minecraft if you get what I mean

@@paulcartman6795 honestly I agree....but I've already replayed it over 15 times lol

The only game in which I’ve geared up. (When Arthur died)

*teared

@@LittleJP34 yeah man, after you finish the game and replay it you always try to avoid getting tuberculosis lmao

The Necro sawn denee

The Necro no it’s Saint Dennis.the characters just pronounce it as “san denee” because of their accents

schneid that’s completely wrong. It’s pronounced san denee. It’s a French name.

"Sandy knee" lol

For French people it’s just Saint Denis lmao

Do you ever regret speedrunning your first ever experience with it? I feel like you wouldn't feel as sad at the ending when the time you have spend with the gang and Arthur himself falls as short as just doing the main story.

@@ryxga6392 It feels kinda boring to do side quests when theres a main questline with a really nice story (on a first playthrough) though that's only my opinion

@@aimbotxd7992 I would agree with you if it was any other game than red dead redemption 2. the side quests just fit into the game so beautifully and it makes the experience so much better because you learn about the world, the characters and you get to know the gang and arthur more

Ive played this game for a good year now, Ive finished it twice and have ( at a guess) well over 200 hours in it, and yesterday I did a string of side missions I never knew existed. I also come across random encounters ive never seen before very often

You ever heard of opinions? And you actually don’t get to do much in this game except shoot, shoot shoot

@@xeibei4804 must not have played it then

@@xeibei4804 There are side missions that don't need you to shoot shoot shoot. If you are only doing the story missions you are missing out on a lot of the games side missions

Agreed, and plus just the scenery is beautiful, there is nature, beautiful graphics, missions, encounters and just overall things you very specifically can't find in a city or town so I agree, and the whole looting thing where he said it takes too long I mean...It's not like u even have to loot the bodies, the only case where looting can be useful is with special characters and people from encounteres because they may have things no one else has like letters that lead to a hidden side story, past game references, Easter eggs and more.

@Ghost actually soundtrack is something to consider during a games rating

@Ghost well games like the elder scrolls skyrim invest alot of money into the soundtrack, and bethesda for instance has worked with this guy Jeremy seol I belive his name is, and he has made a lot of the soundtracks for the elder scrolls games, and he usually gets his recognition in reviews.

@Ghost most certainly even in many publications like gamespot and ign will have a section for soundtrack which will add or deduct points, but usually they do that for games that intentionally put work into the soundtrack or "scores" as they call them.

@@jims4592 **Blurryness Intensefies**

Music may not count in some empty IGN rating, and may not in your own rating, but to some it does. Like me. The whole games atmosphere, which the music contributes to, is really the most important part for me.

Dam Son No U

theyre not cowboys theyre outlaws

@@philthethotdestroyer4194 yeeahaw

And that's something everyone should feel once in their life. Fosters a sense of humility. Without humility, you've no humanity.

You really FEEL like Spiderman

In my opinion ign is the reason why rating games doesn’t work anymore

@@will1222 i agree

yea like i thought 5 was supposed to be average because its in the middle making it the average and i would rate a game i really liked a 7 and people would be astonished that i rated it so low, humanity has gone from 10 options to rank a game to 4 and its really annoying

@@mrtumblewumble8457 man he rated the new xbox a 80%

@@bogdanbucurean2087 i wasn't talking about that?

99.5 percent cuz the game randomly unequips guns

@@dm8in in your opinion

@@dm8in Is a duck an opinion?

@@dm8in I went my whole life thinking a duck is a duck i cant believe that it was an opinion this whole time

@@dm8in not everything is an opinion and that is a fact because facts exist meaning it’s also a fact that you’re stupid

Fishing is SO boring in this

Without looting all that there is left in the game is killing random animals and pedestrians and completing the pre-scripted missions

Frank Merker There’s also the strangers, the challenges, the customizations, the treasure hunts, the secrets, etc.

@@frankmerker630 I like how you ignore the main money making thing in the campaign, treasure hunts

Ah yes, don’t loot. In fact, skinning animals takes time, don’t hunt. And side missions take time, don’t do them. In fact the story takes time, don’t play the game. Not using mechanics isn’t a solution to the problem, that criticism is still valid.

@@Deedo_67 I think the big difference here is that those other things you listed are far more essential than looting. Would the game be a bit better if it were quicker? Sure. But you already earn far too much money far too quickly in this game, so in the end I don't think the criticism is too strong

It would've been nice if you could scalp ppl

@@mynamajegg2463 It doesn't fit Arthur or John Maybe for an online dlc

Yessss I attacked people with my sword only!

@@Ebrahim_17 Im more of a hatchet person

My Nama Jegg you can blow their heads off with a shotgun. That's always fun.

same

This is Watch Mojo and we present Top 10 times felt Moist after Moist meter.

It was better in the manga

Dude!.. shut the fuck up. Please

Same,uh, what's your favorite arc? 🤔

@Dewy they already did

Dewy 18 naked cowboys in the showers at ram ranch

@Dewy Cowboys Even Getting Fucked In Their Sleep

Its just a coffee shop mini game expansion, if ya catch my drift.

Smiley the Smile i just can't quit you, smiley.

I agree I even felt overwhelmed by how much there was to do

but what about suck a dick?

@@hishamjalal9078 you can do that to your father

Yup i feel a lot of people skip the part about animals and skinning them, and hunting them. Especially if you go for the legendary satchel which i do recommend to get early on. For the panther i put bait down covered myself with scent lotion and waited 5 minutes behind a rock and it was so satisfying killing that panther. And it being the last animal was amazing

Me: "Welp, I finally got the semi-automatic pistol, can't wait to try this out! lemme just get on my horse real quick so I can test it out on some o'driscolls" *Presses triangle* Arthur: *GIVE ME ALL YOUR FUCKING MONEY RIGHT FUCKING NOW OR I SWEAR TO GOD I WILL FUCKING BURY YOU* Random citizen: *starts crying* "PLEASE NO I HAVE A FAMILY AND A DOG AND MY WIFE JUST HAD A BABY" Arthur: *DO YOU THINK I FUCKING GIVE A SHIT? GIVE ME ALL YOUR FUCKING VALUABLES RIGHT FUCKING NOW YOU PIECE OF SHIT OR I SWEAR TO GOD I WILL HUNT YOUR FAMILY DOWN AND COOK YOUR FUCKING BABY AND EAT IT* Citizen: *gives bronze wedding ring out of fear* "THERE YOU GO, THATS ALL I HAVE MY FAMILY IS POOR PLEASE TAKE IT, JUST DONT HURT ME!" Arthur: *Murders him and loots him* *finds nothing else* Arthur: "Nothing else? Really? If he told me that was all he had maybe I would have spared him." Police nearby: "Hold it right there!" Arthur: "NEVER!" *WW3 starts begin arthur and police* Me: 0_0

That's happened to me a lot, one time I saved this girl from the Murfree Broods gang and when I was about to untie her Arthur just kicked her in the back out of nowhere and killed her, which made me lose honor. That's actually the only thing that I despise in RDR2, they could have really improved on the game mechanics, but aside from that it's an astounding game.

@@Lallint I read this thing in Arthur's voice, makes it so much better lmfao

never happened to me.

Neander I experienced the exact same thing on multiple occasions lol. I'd come out of the gunsmith or something and suddenly l have a bounty. Love the game to bits though

That's also what made me despise it. All I felt when it was over was relief that I never would have to play it again.

Fr!!

I did that with Skyrim and still finding new things and it's still a perfect game plus elder scrolls 6 is coming out and I bet it's gonna be even better than rd2

@@ajourdanswanson6475 that’s a hard line to cross

@@BrickPirate what does that mean?

@@azure9233 Simple, it’s hard to make games as rich and in this level of detail.

Same

@@WhatAreYouDoingHereA7a u play ps4?

@@alexmarroni971 NEINNN

I'm confused btwn this or witcher 3

@@abhishhhsunil7731 Rdr2 but maybe that's just personal prefrence the witcher was just a bit boring