Mom REACTS to RAMMSTEIN- Mutter “with translation and analysis at the end” 

Please do the live version recorded in Paris

I will look at that one myself so I can take a new song next time

At the beginning he sings about old/senior children already having gray hair and building a chain/necklace made of his hair and tears. So basically him in his late 30s or 40s. Gezeugt in Hast und ohne Samen means, Made in haste and without seed. Not hate. What the Eel thing means i never figured out myself as well, maybe its about the water since he has already thrown her into the water at that point and shes drowning? Ive never looked up analysations of their songs. And yes, This is a third version of hast that can mess with people who do not speak german or dont speak it at a high level. Theres not only Du hasst/you hate and Du hast/you have but also Hast=haste. Theres no difference in pronunciation for these, you need to know more of the sentence or see it in written form to understand the context and figure out that way which one is meant.

Dust to dust 😉

your pronunciation in German is very good!😉

He is !

True!

I would disagree to the frist part only on the basis great poetry can be easy translated no matter the languages and great he is that

Richard wrote it as a wedding song

I will look at it right now … and thank you 🥰

I can sign that one hundred percent. After this song, Rammstein released a lot of other excellent songs that I listen to again and again, depending on my mood. "Mother" was, is and probably will remain the most emotional for me. I still remember that when I first heard it, it ran cold down my spine, as we say in German. No idea how to formulate it in English.

☺️

Also look up Daveinitely , he's a German, explains R+ in English

I will look at that myself now …. Look for ward to it 😉

Interesting, I had kind of a complicated relationship to my mother myself. I was by her side when she died and afterwards I heard this song probably for hours on repeat to get out all my anger, frustration and pain over this lost. So yeah, probably I can somehow feel into this song

Till Lindemann is a poet, in case some of you may not be aware of. Till's father Werner, well-known East German writer of children's.

Very interesting! My thougt or feeling by those lyrics is the message that the human still have their human needs, including the support from a mother, even if a human would be born in an experimental way without a mother and father. You can't simply take the human needs away.

I love my "mutter" and played this for her. Shes 65 years old and love this song. She dont like hard rock, but i think my mother and i will bond till this track, till any of us will leave this world. Mutter, ich liebe dich ❤ Joni, Denmark.

Yet all of this is far from the true reason of till to sing or write this song

It does , indeed

As one of those kinds of people (heavy SA in childhood) I found this song to be an open meaning song with those who's childhoods were not what they were meant to be. Mostly towards maternal points, which is open to other listeners to apply their own meaning and injustice towards. Where the concept is based towards two band members talking about their own parental experiences, the lyrics become open to others from the same or other maternal abandonment from whichever perspective. Its a brilliantly written song covering many different means of childhood trauma.

Danke☺️

Bedankt. Your video reaction was again awesome. In this song he is a modern day Frankenstein Monster . It's not clear if he is really lovable. He's always the "aggressive and demanding male" although one feels pity for him. He's dangerous! But it's a great song! There's only one song even more intense: "Puppe" I recommend the "Midjourney music video" from "Anomaliens". Best wishes from Berlin, uz The lyrics are irritating as well : "Die Tränen greiser Kinderschar..." = the tears of an old group of kids. Like (precious) pearls he pulls them on a string, making them into a necklace. But the German word "Kette" means also chain. He switches to the dark side and calls the necklace a "wet chain", throws it away. And switches to the bright side again: the chain is something he can wish upon.

While I edit, a few recommendations: "ohne dich", "Seemann" (the video from the Nina Hagen cover), "jardin de l'arme", Till sings French with Zaz, "alle Tage ist kein Sonntag" Lindemann and David Garrett. Lindemann as the prostitute Algebra in "Mathematik".... no, I skip this one, too much locker room words

☺️

Thank you ☺️

There is no correct way. You, Tom, are certifiably insane if you think there is. There is NOTHING wrong with pausing. Even every 5 seconds, if there is appropriate, meaningful input on a detail of what you're reacting to. If someone is pausing to go off topic and talk about their dog or some other random thing, it's wrong, but still understandable with how RU-vid copyright bots used to work until someone of the big millions of subs folks recently made a big deal out of it with a repeat of "Where's the Fair Use". Furthermore, the way MommaTaunt and a few others do it actually goes far further into breaking that Fair Use clause of the 1997 copyright law section 107 than the way other reaction channels do it. Others cut parts out and do pauses for comments not because they can't wait to give you their thoughts, but because that's in there in the law. And by it, I mean... No fragments longer than a certain small percentage of the original content(show it in small chunks that prove a point in your analysis), not breaching a certain overall percentage of the original content shown in your own video(don't show all of it), and there being at least as much of your analysis/criticism/commentary as there is of the original content(don't let someone else's work do most of the work in your work). That's how things used to be for years. Don't whine about it like a toddler. That's the format everyone is used to and continues to deliver, bending the rules as much as they can and risking a strike to satisfy snobs like you and stop your frivolous, inane, ignorant nagging.

@@LongandWeirdName no need to be this rude . Me not stopping means the creator of the song is monetized, not me . A lot of people stop every 5 seconds so they can can the money … for me , especially as a singer, that’s a no go . I am not monetized and people who want to support me can buy me a coffee. Furthermore … every reactor can have their own MO… this is mine . At our main channel, my son chooses to stop a few times to ask questions . Also there we are not monetized.. although some artists did white list is because they want to share there percentage . But most importantly…my channel is al about respect and mental health and bullying is not excepted . Be nice 😉

@@MommaTaunT I am not aiming my criticism at you or trying to bully Tom, who it is aimed at. Only trying to show how he is being inconsiderate of the history of reaction channels on the platform and the norms it has set. This is not meant to make him feel worse about himself, but to make him realize why people do these reactions the way they do them. In my eyes, he's the one that's rude and uses this comment section to attack many other creators who are just doing the best they can not to get strikes even when they don't monetize their videos. Pardon me, if I was too harsh. I am simply used to far less civilized discourse filled with ad hominems, foul language, and complete disrespect for the other side's points/lack of willingness to hear out and consider the other point of view. Civilized debate is no longer the norm out there and one often has to be as blunt as a brick rounded down by time to lose any sharp edges to get their point through.

Sorry .. but your last sentence of your first comment is totally uncalled for . And to put something like that under a nice comment ment if someone who just was here to make a compliment is so not necessary. No one was asking for that and it says so much about you … and it makes me sad

Thank you 🙏

True, "no navel" could be interpreted as "no connection" and not thinking of him as her son.

probably you are right but for me it was always also partly relating to the possibility of scientists "making" a designer baby without involvement of a mother or father and what that would do with the child growing up with machines instead of the love of its parents. Another song in that direction would be Ebenbild by Saltatio Mortis

😢

Without sperm? I mean, that's not a human.

That’s the whole point of discussion

It's about Germany. Mother is an allegory for Germany during and after WW2

Test tube babies have mothers. It just means her egg is fertilised “in vitrio”, in a test tube and then implanted back in Mum’s womb.

glad i am not the only one who read Gottfried Benn, I didn't even have to... did not read it in school, just because i liked it.

I think you are actually right with both of these aspects. Eels, although beeing liked by many as an edible fish, are also comsidered by many people I know to be somewhat abhorrent due to their diet of carrion and assumingly due to their physical, snakelike form. In fact, as far as I am informed, eels used to be fished by throwing an animal carcass on a line into the water pullong it out again when enough eels had amassed in it. Talking about a gruesome method here. I am pretty sure Till got these connotations in the background here, thinking about the cruel mother he never had, yet is desperately craving for and wants to kill out of bitterness. Finally it could also be put forward, that "mother" does not only stand for an idealised need of protection, but is actually a symbol for his uncaring creators that he so much despises. That way the whole expression of violent fantasies towards "Mutter" makes even more sense. However, I am also convinced that what you said about an ever-smirking Till, who just thrives in making people wonder and leaves them in a state of ambivalence about individual parts of his lyrics absolutely holds true as well...

@@manuelsiefers8975 Die Blechtrommel fällt mir da wieder ein in diesem Klassiker werden Aale mit einem Kuhkopf gefangen

@@Ati-MarcusS Ah ja, genau! Stimmt! Auch eindrücklich in der Verfilmung festgehalten...

its not Mom its mother.

He was talking to me 😉

Thank you

Thank you ☺️

🫶

Thank you ☺️

Industrial metal or Neue Deutsche Härte

He is!

Thank you 😘

@@MommaTaunT I thank you. ich danke Dir, verzaubernd, hail to You, bin momentan schlecht gelaunt Du hast ein bisschen Freude in mein kaltes Herz gegeben, love, najszczersze podziękowania polish is difficult, the honest thank you, stay strong!

That’s so sweet to say, thank you !

I'm from Austria and some kind of native german speaker, altough the Austrian germen is a little bit softer than the german german. You wäre the first one, Not german Sperling one, that pronounces the Band Name correctly. I even couldn't say that you are Dutch. It was perfect pronouncuation of all the german words! Although I Listen to metal, I never listetened to Rammstein and your analysis was delighting for me. Liebe Grüsse nach Holland von Wien

Thank you so much!! That means a lot to me🥰

Thank you

Foetuses have navels, so it's a clone.

@@robertstallard7836 do you think that clone animals (and humans) do not have navels?

@@modeflicka Now they do, yes, because they're impanted into a surrogate mother. I was assuming this was futuristic, Brave New World type stuff because of the costuming etc.

@@robertstallard7836 when embryo is implanted to surrogate mother, it is doesn't need an umbilical cord yet. But later weeks of pregnancy it is still connected with mother's blood system via umbilical cord. There is no way development of any baby, even cloned, can be without this system, yet.

In the text written by Till Lindemann, the situation of a motherless person is described. Who cries out for an identity and - as a paradox - wants to take revenge on his mother because she was never there for him.

Thats so sweet of you ! I did record a story but didn’t have the right recording settings then . Maybe I should make a new series again . But the story is perfect for bedtime ! Enjoy 😊 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-KVRK9JLALxA.html

​@@MommaTaunT Sorry for the slow response, I went to watch the other video and fell asleep for some reason. ;-) q:"Maybe I should make a new series again" [l.2] I would watch it ;-) Im sure, my kids would sleep better, if someone with a voice like yours read them the bed time stories. Im struggling especially when it comes to classic German fairytales, however those became considered suiting as bed time stories, they are most times actually fitting far better to the genre of Horror. "So, two children behing left to die in the forrest, before being nearly cooked and eaten and then murdering an old woman." "..." "Sleep well!"

Hans und Gretel? 😉

Thank you .. but off course that was already brought to me in the comments . But I can’t correct it 😉

Na, dann sollten wir jetzt aber auch nichts 'überhasten' und uns gemeinsam dem Sperma widmen! ... *räusper* ... Hinsichtlich des metaphorischen Gesamtduktus dieses Liedes dürfen wir den "Samen" nicht so 'hastig' zu gewöhnlich, dahergespritztem Sperma degradieren, sondern ihm die gesamte Breite seiner Bedeutungen einräumen. ...andererseits... vielleicht sollten wir unsere wertvolle Zeit doch nicht mit derlei Petitessen verschwenden.

@@MommaTaunT You are right. We can't correct it :-( That means, there is only one possible solution. You need to delete the Video, then we have to wait untill you forgot everything about this video -even that you've ever watched it- to react to it again.

I hope you find a way to remember to reshoot the reaction as soon as you forgot that this Video even exists. That COULD be troublesome

I do appreciate good humor tho 😉

Thanks

Many people told me … my bad .. but I can’t correct it 😉

i saw that video too ... but i think its a fake. too many cuts ... the children dont sing a single line of the song without a cut in the video ... FAKE !!!! :) Edit: ... and i cant find that video on youtube anymore ...

Thank you

I already did 😉

Nobody said so but it makes sense… I like it ( but it does sound a bit like a nice German beer too 😉)

@@MommaTaunT Rammstein is actually selling a beer called Rammsteiner 😅

🤣

That’s a great tip , thank you 😊

It's "gezeugt in Hast und ohne Samen" which means without sperm...

@@miamiking8385 And in english, the (white) pearls on a wet necklace also means sperm - on a woman's neck, but here it's "thrown into the air", wasted, not where it's "supposed" to be naturally.

Probably next week