I am a Mongols from China. Hazara people are our Mongolian brothers. I have funded several poor Hazara students to complete their university courses. My original intention is to help cultivate excellent talents of Hazara people and build their own homes! The strength of a nation can only be changed by strengthening itself! And don't forget your history, traditions and ancestors!❤️
I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart as a Hazara for doing these kind acts! Thank you so much! I hope those students grow up to make a difference in the world as well.
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM
The great Khan, Feeling proud of our Mongolian Heritage. The great khan would be very sad to see his People in this state in Afghanistan. From Jahgori Hazara
@@lanatmolaje2901 yeh, no one is stopping pustoons from being afghan. Be Afghan all you want. But the reality is we are first Hazara and then Turco-mongol
@@lanatmolaje2901 Who the fk are Afghans, and whats your history? Bring me any document that existed before the 19th century stating that there is an Afghan ethnicity or nation.
@@hovaida1 turk Chi mekona. Ma hazara pesh i ke jangiz khan beyaya da Afghanistan bodem.. ne turk ne mangol. Afghanistan az ma bod wa bakhair pas az ma mesha
@@karteSakhi درست که ما بودیم، در این شکی نیست ولی تمام شواهد و دی آن ای و ۲۲ درصد لغات تورکی در زبان هزارگی و فرهنگ و تمام اینها ما را و نژاد ما را به تورک میرساند، همانطور که تاجیک آریایی میگیره هزاره هم نژادش تورک است و اگر تحقیق کنی به این حقیقت پی میبری
Pakistani Hazaras are very much influenced by the Western writers and do not even think if what those writers say makes any sense. They accept it just because a Western writer has said it. The British historian, Jonathan Lee wrote in 2018: "Under the influence of Western ethnology, many Hazaras today claim descent from the Mongol garrisons of Chinggis Khan or even the Mongol conqueror himself." You are also one of those Hazaras.
@@temujin260 HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM
I appreciate that our brothers around the world looking for our nation to know us We were alone for decades. Now our student and honor people all around the world not only in Iran & pakistan but in many countries are seeking knowledge to find their roots and brothers Thank you for your awarness🌹🖐
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
The taliban are in power once again, right now I am powerless, all I can do is send money to my families and other Hazaras in the Jaghori region, but in a few years I will make sure I have what is needed to make a change. I know there are many like me, and collectively we can save the people of Afghanistan, thank you for this video.
Yes definitely! I'm Muslim Kashmiri but feel bad for my brothers and sisters in Afghanistan. I will pray for all mongolians and also all people in Afghanistan who are under thr rule of the war between the Talibans.
We are originally native from the centralasia that means we are one part of centralasian turkic and we become after cengiz han empire mixed with the mongholian from JAGHORI Ghazni Afghanistan 🇦🇫
Hazara are over 40% Ydna C2 and C3 which is rare in Turks(save for Kazakhs) and common in Mongolian. Turks are mostly Ydna N1c,Q1a and R1a which means Hazaras are mostly from Mongols and Pashtun mix. Also Hazaras used to speak "mogholi" up until the 20th century with only 200 speaking it today with most speaking Dari now. (Hazaras deny mongol origins because Pashtuns make fun of them and no one teach them how amazing their history is also because Mongols used to invade and kill Muslims so jhazaras rather claim "Turkic" instead even though DNA says they are mostly Mongol.....
@@teovu5557Stop spreading lies! No Mogholi-speaking Hazaras have ever been found, although the Europeans looked for them for nearly a century. Many European writers have written about that. The people who spoke Mogholi were the Mongols of Ghorat and had no relationship to the Hazaras. Most Hazaras deny Mongol heritage because now it has come out that Hazaras have been mentioned in literature centuries before Changez Khan. Your data about DNA is also not accurate. There are DNA studies that say that the Hazaras have no Mongol DNA.
Interesting video, however, I must add that, the original name of Hazara, was Azra with Turkic roots. We have lived in Afghanistan for more than 2000 years and adopted persians language, culture and religion. Our ancestors left Mongolia and came to Afghanistan long before the Mongol Empire.
Language cannot 100% identify someones ethnic roots. There are many Pashtuns who cannot speak Pashto but speak Dari or Persian. Hazaras still have Turkish and Mongolian words. In Mongolia Turks and Mongols both have the same thoughts about Wolf and many other things. So mainly Turks and Mongols are cousins.
Hazaras as an ethnicity didnt exist even 900 years ago in AFG. Not even turkics lived in AFG that far back then. You do however have some native ancestry in you(around 30%), which are original locals of Bamyan, who were rather east iranics(alike modern day tajiks)
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
Hazaras are not 2000 years old in afhanistan lmao. They claim there only during Mongol times. And the people who built Bamiyan and the statues of the Buddhas were Kushans/Yuezhis a Indo-European speaking people who lived in western china and got kicked out by t he Turkic Xiongnu and Gokturks and settled in Afghanistan as the Kushans and mixed wth Sakas to form the Hepthali people.....Hepthali is the same as the Pashtun tribe called Abdali(now called Durrani) they were buddhist til the Turkic Ghazanid destroyed them and made them Muslim. At least that is what ALL historicans agree with....
There is a place in Afghanistan called besut I am from besut and from chukana ethnicity and besut was a clan which was one of direct descendant of changiz khan I don’t know if there is still a clan bye this name in Mongolia so yeah I think we share same ancestry and we are targeted bye majority as minority of Afghanistan and we will always fight for our culture,people and religion. There are still changiz khans sons in Afghanistan and one day he will rise again i lived in Afghanistan and know the bad satiation beacuse we are under push from so many parts and fighting against an unfair and a big majority there are so many hazara boys which will never forget what they did with there people and fighting against them as stronger as the past and there hearths are a peace of fire we are still that empire that conquered half of the world and still changiz khans empire and proud of it I hope one day turko_mongol people all around the word have peace and security and I am also really sorry about uyghur people in China they are our blood brothers and have a bad satiation if you can please make a vedio for uyghur people that we remind them we will never forget them as a brother we are with them at first I always thought And said I am not a mongol so many people told me in Afghanistan that you are mongol but I never accepted cause I thought they want to say I am not from Afghanistan thats why they tell me this but when I got a dna test I was shocked I am 52% Mongolian 31%Central Asia and 12% Chinese and Vietnamese and other ethnicities and now i believe that I am a mongol.peace bro ✌️
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
I love mongolians and I'm Muslim. I know we all didnt agree from our ancestors but the thing is that I love your culture and your language. Your country is way better than the west and love to travel and work and live in Mongolia no matter hard difficult it will be in the future. UK is no good here. I cannot wait until covid is over so we can all go to countries. My favorite would be hazara and also hohhot inner mongolia.
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
because Afghanistan hazara mixed race with uzbeki and turkmen long time，i am pakistan hazara，my DNA test in my video i have 19% chinese，19% mongolian，no Center Asia。。。
@@PakistanChinaFriendship in another comment u said u have 36 % central Asian genetic and now u r claiming no Central Asian genetic then u are not Hazara at all , shame on u hater , I bet u aren’t Hazara jerk
Greetings from Buenos Aires, Argentina 🇦🇷 South America. I liked your video. I agree with you. Hazara people is wonderful and don't deserve be mistreated, discriminated and killed by Taliban. I'm muslima and Islam say that is HARAM kill inocents. Racism, discrimination, xenophobic aren't part of Islam. Taliban follow one evil, diabolic invented religion. They do all that Allah say that we never must do. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) say that is HARAM kill no - muslims living in one muslim country. Allah say in Quran 5:32 that kill one inocent is like kill all mankind. Hope that Taliban can be stopped, so we can travel to know the Hazara people, that deserve have a wonderful life, and live in peace, following they beliefs. #StopHazaraGenocide #HazaraLivesMatter 🟦 ⬜ 🟨 ✊ 🌹
As you mentioned we are muslim now but in the past in Kushanid empire we were buddhist . We have sevral empire even before mongols like koshanid,kharazmid,great seljuks,ghorids,ghaznavid and etc as you know central asia was the geography the turkic people lived there for decades till now . Our people language as researchists said before was one of the turkic language branches
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
Dear brother, it's your own problem. I'm Uzbek from Afghanistan. Who shows more sympathy for Hazaras? Definitely Uzbeks and Turkmens. always call them Hazaras Bula (cousins), and we are brothers . Unfortunately, it's not widely accepted among Hazaras. I have huge respect for the Turkic countries, and I am proud of them. But first of all, we (Uzbek_Turkmen +Hazaras) should units. It's clear that Uzbeks-Turkmen and Hazaras are bullied equally, but why we shouldn't units together.
@@Behnam75289 we hazaras are turkic and turko_mongol like (barlas) but not pure mongol our names is even hazar we same like khazars sometimes they used to be called hazars
@@temujin260 خی پس برید مغول ستان چی میکنید در کشوری ما مغول ها 😂تاریخ خود را نخوانده ندانسته تاریخ ۸۰۰۰ساله هزاره را به تاریخ ۸۰۰سال پیش مغول میتی ما پیش از چنگیز و مغول در افغانستان بودیم نکنید دودسته تاریخ ما را به اوغان ها تقدیم
@@TikTokahmad_beg مغول ها قدیمی ترین ملت جهان هستند، 7 هزار سال پیش هیچ قومی در خراسان وجود نداشت. شما توسط تبلیغات ایرانی و پشتون شستشوی مغزی داده اید. کوشانی ها بودند که آمدند و بر خراسان حکومت کردند، کوشانی ها هون ها بودند، هون ها مغول بودند، کوشانی ها پس از سقوط امپراتوری کوشان به رشته کوه های هیمالیا رفتند. آنها را ماگار / منگر می نامند. آنها کوشانی واقعی و مغول هستند. برو تاریخ بخوان هزاره افغان یا تاجیک احمق🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😆😆😆😆. تو هزاره نیستی هزاره ها مغول هستند!
@@temujin260 هزاره اصلی و بومی داریی تاریخ ۸۰۰۰ساله من هستم تو یک مغول هستی پس من آزمایش دی ان ایی دادم در باره هویت و اصلیت خود میدانم و امپراتوری کوشانی از ما هزاره ها هست که تاریخ به ۶۰۰۰سال میرسه
I'm hazara and I'm proud to be hazara yeah I agree that we have mangoilan I had a friend and I ask her waht Hamer called in your language she said algh so algha is too in hazargi language or shighai wich we play in Afghanistan so yeah we have same language
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
The British historian, Jonathan Lee wrote in 2018: "Under the influence of Western ethnology, many Hazaras today claim descent from the Mongol garrisons of Chinggis Khan or even the Mongol conqueror himself." You are also one of those Hazaras. As you see you are not a freethinker, you slavishly accept anything told to you by the Westerners.
Hazaras are turk and mongol mixed, Kazakhstan and mongolian should help them by weapons, the only thing they need are weapons to defend themselves against genocide, central Afghanistan is Hazaras land the population of Hazaras around 12 million in Afghanistan, the bad thing is their land locked by Pashtuns it happened when a king called Abdurahman who declared war against Hazaras and killed almost 63 percent Hazaras from that time till now the genocide and target killing of Hazaras and forcibly displacing from their land continues, Hazaras need a strong army it will happen if Kazakhstan and Mongolian can help them.
Hazara Mongol workers(Rustam and Abdilla ),1903 . Gustav John Ramstedt , a finnish diplomat ,linguist and Mongolist met with them in Kushka, a village in Balkh Province in northern Afghanistan .They were fluent in their native Mongolian language . When they first met the scientist, They asked from him in Mongolian language " Mana Kele mednee? (You know our language ? )? . Hazara Mongols had kept their native language very well until the 20th century, unfortunately later for many reasons, The native language is extinct and most of them speak Persian(has about 30 percent are Mongolian words) . There are very few Mongolian-speaking Hazara Mongols(Moguls) in Afghanistan today. Ramstedt traveled on several occasions from Finland through Russia to Central Asia with the aim of studying the languages, traditions and history of the Mongol and Turkic peoples and for the purpose of collecting dictionary material.in 1903 Ramstedt heads for the border between Russian Turkestan and Afghanistan in search for Mongols in Afghanistan .Although the commandants and governors working at the border tell him that there are no Mongols in Afghanistan, Ramstedt manages to find two workers at the clay pits near the border who speak ancient Mongolian. They are Abdilla and Rustam .
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
Thank you for this interesting video, I'm an ethnic Hazara and I'm really interested in Mongolia and would love to visit ur country one day. Your accent reminds me so much of Hazaragi dialect, it's crazy! The tone is very similiar!
@fjjdhd No, we are mongolians who moved into central asia about 100.bc and after two thousend years of living with Iranians, we adopted their language and culture. In average Hazars have between 40-70% monglian origin.
@fjjdhd Turkic people in central asia have a strong admixure of mongolian genes, sience real turks came from mongolia and northern china. Turks in West asia and turkey have also a small east asian admixture, about 10%.
@@salehkhan6788 Hazara clan structure, vocabulary, food, and genes strongly indicate Hazara people are direct descendants of the Turko-Mongol Army from the 13th century. The Mongols in Central Asia eventually Turkified, but the Mongols stationed in Afghanistan and Iran eventually adopted Persian. (As such, one the most detailed accounts on the Mongol Empire was written in Persian for a Mongol rulers.) Considering the location, I suspect the Hazara tribes were strategically placed along the Hindu Kush mountains to protect the route to Iran and Iraq (as the Turko-Mongol Army advanced westwards.) Militarily, they probably would've been near Herat (which was the logical hub) from Central Asia to Iran. As for genetics, Mongols, Manchus, and Turks have been living in close proximity for thousands of years. They frequently formed alliances and inter-married, and fought for supremacy. (Some of Genghis Khan's wives were from Turkic tribes in Mongolia. And his ancestors come from the mountain region near Inner Mongolia and Manchuria.) All of this resulted in similar genetics, grammar, vocabulary, phonetics, culture, religion, clothing, food, music, etc...among the Mongols, Turks, and Manchus. To date, as you get closer to Turkic homeland in Western Mongolia and Altai region, the more Turkic (Northeast Asian) admixture they have.
Hazaras have Mongolian words in their language. But also Turkish words. Btw both Mongols and Turks share the same geography they are cousins. Kurut in Turkish means dry. In Hazaragi word Kurud is a dried Cheese. Also Turks use Kellepacha, where ease Hazaras in many Afg. locations use the same word but in different dialect and say kallapaycha. Hazaras use Nilgha word which is same in Mongolian lang., meaning baby. Tutta means run in both Hazara and Mongol language. Atay, Ata used for father. Tata means uncle. Language is one (some times simple) identity of an ethnicity. There are many pashtuns in Afghanistan who cannot speak Pashto but only speak Persian. So, language is not the only entity. I will share more later. Thank you Bro.
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
We don’t have much similar worlds with Mongolian. Only a few Nilgha and lang is two different thing. Also in our Hazaragi (Persian dialect) we don’t say Tata for uncle we say Kaka or Kakai. when listening to Mongolian as a Hazara we don’t understand anything however when listening to Turkish and Azerbaijani we have like 40% the same words and phrases. We understand Turkish the most we use Turkic words in conversations.
Hazaras once had enemy from 8 clan and are Uzbek Turkmen Kalmyk Kyrgiz Uyighur Buraiyt and other that I don't remember but it was published somewhere in my fb and it's true list
Please react mor about Hazara people or maybe about ilkhanet , because I remember my grandfather set to we are Hulegu Khan sons ,this very important for me and for anther generation . I did a DNA test it will coming during of the day soon , I wold like to share to you guys my DNA test results Keep doing! Thank you very much
For some reasons we subsituted our turkic mother tongue to persian with Hazaraghi dialect. Even now more than 30% of our daily words and conversations that we use , have turkic roots. The Name of our tribes, clothes style, our physic anatomy is turkic
The first thing is that you are giving a very high percentage for Turkish words. Also, as the Hazara writer Mohammad Ali Shari says, just because a word is used in both Turkish and Persian does not mean that they are Turkish. The second thing is that it is not so simple to change your language from one to another. It is silly to say that "for some reason" we changed our tongue. Were we crazy to take that trouble? Our clothes style is also not Turkish. The names of our tribes are also not Turkish. The Hazaragi language contains old Persian words from three thousand years ago, which have been lost in other Persian dialects centuries ago. Mohammad Ali Shari has written a whole book about such words.
@@historybuff1591Wrong mate just see barlas is turko_mongol and turkmen is turkic but as well they have mongol dna too but not like barlas we are khazars but our name in turkic is hazar it make sense
@@chad7336 The name Hazara was mentioned in Persian poetry two centuries before the Mongol invasion. The famous Khorasani poet Nasir Khosrow Balkhi in his qasida No 214 (ناصر خسرو بلخی قصیده ۲۱۴) has mentioned the name of Hazara. He mentions the Hazara lute or "dambura i hazaragi" as it is called and even today is an important cultural symbol of the Hazaras. If you search "dambura i hazaragi" in RU-vid, you will get dozens of results.
@@PakistanChinaFriendship iam also from Pakistan I was born in there but its not mean that I am not from Afghanistan my mother and father was born in jaghori.
@@PakistanChinaFriendship if it says Central Asia it's mean you are Turkic Central Asia is Kazakhstan Uzbekistan Turkmenistan Kyrgyzstan Tajikistan Azerbajjan Armenia and Georgia
@@xahedi we aren’t mongol, when mongol attacked and conquered in that time , every person has some mongol genetic not only Hazaras, I remind u we have long history among every nation in nowadays Afghanistan and we are turk not mongol
Hazara are very mixed today that only a portion of them contains Mongolian genes. Even some other ethnics people call themselves Hazara which makes everything confusing. Thx for sharing ur thoughts due.
@@lalajan8848 they came before the mongol invasion and that’s why they been mixed so much! But still they roots go back to the central and Eastern Asia!
@@teknul89 there are no evidences for your claim but Hazara presence in Afghanistan before mongol invasion has a lot of evidences specially archaeology!
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
According to Gustav John Ramstedt's book "Seven Journeys" about his travels along Mongolia, Xinjiang and Afghanistan in the early 1900s he met two Hazara men who could speak Moghol. They were surprised at how G. J. Ramstedt could understand words from their language when he tried speaking to them in Khalha Mongol. They said to each other, "Mana Kele Medana" (He understands our tongue).
Those two that Ramstedt met were not Hazaras, they were named Rustam and Abdillah and they were Mongols of Ghorat. No Mogholi-speaking Hazaras have ever been found, although the Europeans looked for them for nearly a century. Many European writers have written about that.
@@normanhayashiIn Mogholica, Ramstedt himself has said that they said that they were Moghols from Göru-söhar. Hazaras at that time did not call themselves Moghol. Some of them now do under the influence of some Western writers. Those two spoke Mongolian. H. F. Schurmann who has written a book about the Mongols of Ghorat says that 1. No Hazara has ever been found speaking Mongolian, although the Europeans searched for more than half a century. 2. The Mongols are a separate entity and have nothing to do with the Hazaras or Aimaqs. But some Western writers did confuse them to be Hazaras or Aimauks. Even Major Leech who first reported about them mistakenly called them Moghol Aimauks. Ramstedt has written that Rustam and Abdillah themselves denied any relation to the Aimauks. The Aimauks are also Persian-speaking.
@@historybuff1591 Thank you for the source. I read the part about Rustam and Abdillah with my limited understanding of the German language, and I recall the photo GJ Ramstedt took of both of them, they do look more like Moghols than Hazaras. This probably means that the Hazaras have assimilated into Persian culture and lost their original culture probably even before the collapse of the Blue Horde rule over the region. But that of course doesn't rule out the Hazaras being related to the Turkic World (which includes Mongolic peoples). I hope one day they can find out how the Hazaras stopped speaking their original native language and when it happened, and it wouldn't surprise me if their language is very similar to Moghol as the modern Moghol vocabulary still share many common words with my tongue Oirat/Kalmyk.
@@normanhayashiYou're welcome. The Hazara language does have some Mongol words, but the German Linguist Michael Weiers conducted a test to compare both the Hazara language and the language of the Ghorat Mongols to Uiguro-Mongolian. He found out that in the Hazara language, only 4% of the basic words were related to Uiguro-Mongolian, while in the language of the Ghorat Mongols, more than 81% of the words were. So he concluded that the Hazaras could in no way be related to the Mongol armies that came with or after Genghis, since if two languages are related, then even after one thousand years, at least 81% of the basic words would be related. The interesting thing is that the Mongols of Ghorat were very much racially mixed with the Persians and most of them did not even look Mongol. They were also very small in numbers, confined to just a few very small villages. Still, they had preserved their language for seven centuries. So how could the Hazaras with such a large population lose their language and culture? It's just impossible that the language of the Hazaras to have been anything but Persian.
We are not Mongolian we are Turk. Pashtuns people have been calling us this names just to call us off of our ancestral lands. Hazaras have been living in Afghanistan before 5th century when Mongolian army attacked our capital city Bamyan a lot of us got massacred by them the Chengiz army however it is just history but Hazaras are Turk. Please read some books about our hairy before claiming yourself just anything.
Hazara people are very intelligent and seeking knowledge, they inherited the knowledge from their religion as Shia because the prophet of Islam ordered to seek knowledge, and Shia Islam are this knowledge from prophet peace bee upon him and his family. Hazara people are poor but they are brave, honest, progressive, the most intelligent people in Afghanistan.These people were massacred several times,In 1885 by king Abd al-Rahman, in 1993 by Massoud and Rabbani, in 1998 and in 2001 by the Taliban. And in the last 15 years more than 200 times massacred by Taleban and isis.
Brother I'm azeri. Hazara people are not mongolian. They are türkmen people from ghaznavid dynasty. Gengiz han was for 13th century but we have hazara word and tribes in our poetry in 11th century. This is hazara word in naser khosro poems just translate it in google translation. So you're wrong. Actually they are aghuz türkmen .their language changed to persian during 1000years هزاران قول خوب و راست باریک. ازو یابند چون تار هزاره
We aren’t Mongol but we are turk , I know the influence of smal percentage mongol genetic amoung Hazaras but about 80/90 percent we are turk and from South Asia
@@Alexander-lm8zj I have nothing against Mongols bro, and I know what u say, well those who claim Hazaras are Mongol is just for ignoring Hazaras are the real residents of nowadays Afghanistan, hope u get the point
@@hovaida1 DNA does not lie.....look up Hazara Ydna........Its Ydna C2 and C3........which is only found in Mongolians and Hazaras IN THE MAJORITY. go ahead and look it up....Its so sad hazaras are so ashamed of mongol blood even though the mongols were famous warriors who conquered half the known world.....have some pride!
As u said the name of Hazara people means Thousand in persian language it's one of the theory about the name of our nation as researchist said our people can't pronouns H in persian they call them selves Azara or Azra they took their name from Khazars that had great dynasty.
Hazaras are not from Khazars.............lol totally different region as Khazars are from the caucasus between EUROPE and Asia in the 8th century. And Khazar means "Nomad" Freeman" and is related to the term Kazakh. Hazara comes from the persian word Hazar or thousand. Which comes from the Mongol military unit of 1000(minggan) In fact NOBODY and NO SOURCE links Hazaras and Khazars and its sad that you link them only because you think it sounds similar.....lol
Ydna D is not found in Hazaras and Ydna D is most common in Tibetans. Also LOOK UP Tibetan Empire map......They NEVER conquered Afghan region........lol
@@realmongolia101 I mean, yes, you have a great history, maybe you are a great nation, but Genghis Khaan annihilated millions of people by commiting genocides... against Russians, Chinese, Iranians, Turkic ppl and others
@@EvilHamster428 That depends on how you define genocide. Chinggis Khan only conquered nations who provoked him and ill-treated his people. He showed mercy to those who didn't oppose him. There were many cases of him showing mercy to enemy. If you define war as genocide then all the nations in the world had done it in their existence. Even Russians did it against Circassians. Yes, his sons and grandsons had reached Europe and conquered many lands. But we have to respect those who lived hundreds and thousands of years before us.
@@EvilHamster428 You know Genghis Khan and the Mongol invasion is not the only event in there history the Mongols existed Before Genghis Khan, as is recorded by Chinese records such as the Donghu culture, Xianbei peroid(Famous for defeating the Xiongnu/huns and ruling multipe dynasties in northern china) and the rouran etc etc And I guess by your logic Europeans cant be proud of there history because of black slavery or the colonialization of most of the world. or Americans cant be proud of America because 80% of Native Americans that died from war and sickness by early europeans settlers. Russians should hate themselves because of Stalin or china cuz of Mao? lol
HELLO, IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THE MONGOLIAN STATE WOULD ACCEPT THE KHAZARS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR TRIBESMEN FROM A HUMANITARIAN POINT OF VIEW, TO THEIR HISTORICAL HOMELAND, THE TERRITORY OF MONGOLIA IS VERY LARGE AND THESE PEOPLE WOULD LIVE AND DEVELOP PEACEFULLY.THEY ARE VERY HARDWORKING AND PEACEFUL, MONGOLIA SHOULD ACCEPT THEM,
Hungarians are not Huns that is a myth that started during the Ottoman period. Hungarians are called Magyars and the word Hungarian is from Ugria or Unogur....the Latin people added the "H" later on. They are Ugric warriors from the Ural steppes. (Fact that is easily looked up) Huns are Turkic people and Bulgarians are from the Hunnic people who mixed with slavic people not Hungarians...
