Most Forgettable Whiskeys 

I agree, except for ER and New Riff

Loved the show guys!

Dam yum - not eagle rare - i buy it all day for $40ish and love it!!!

Haven’t had two new riff single barrels that tasted the same, and all good in their own right

Baisel Hayden, Smoke Wagon Sb, Balcones Pot Still Bourbon, Woodinville Straight Bourbon and Penelope 4 grain

I love the Michter’s Sour Mash. I’ll take that bottle of your hand.

interesting. I now will have to look at my shelves and see what I have forgotten about. I rather enjoy New Riff, but was not in my area until recently. So I hoping to try more of them. maybe it will become forgettable, hopefully not. cheers

For my collection same boat with Eagle rare and michters sour mash. My friend drinks most of my Eagle rare though. My third is Jack Daniel’s SBBP. I like it but I just prefer other high proofs I have

Mine are Makers Mark 46, Russell Reserve 10yr, and Michters Rye. All good/ok but collect dust

Yellowstone, Very Old Barton

I'll take that bottle of Eagle Rare I still can't find it by me.😁

Damn you guys. Now I want a peanut butter milkshake 🤤

I have to say that at this moment regular old Buffalo Trace is in the forgettable category for me. It's good, but there are so many other bottles that I can actually find that I like more.

Hey, I'm with friends, I'm laughing, we're consuming brown alcohol, whatever they bring is fine LOL.

I think price point definitely influences how forgettable a bottle is. Eagle rare used to be my daily driver. It could be had for 25 bucks a bottle on base tax free. These days its definitely on my forgettable list although i always have a bottle and backup on hand.

peerless small batch to much money for the juice nice video Boys !!

I agree Old Tub is 'meh', I agree the Sour Mash is 'meh', but the Eagle Rare (at MSRP) will always be a favorite of mine. Worth $30 all day long. $80 is ludicrous. For me, 'meh' is Elijah Craig NAS, 1783, regular Makers Mark. They aren't bad, just boring.

Amen on the Rebel. But I have to go with Elijah Craig Toasted, it's good but the proof pisses me off.

New Riff SB are all over the place. Had some I loved and others I considered dumping. For that reason, I probably won’t buy more. Buffalo Trace, Maker’s Mark, Basil anything, Woodford Reserve (except the Master’s Collection), Russel’s 10 year, Rebel… I’ll stop because I’m boring myself and pissing people off.

"We all gottem" - boy this turned out to be something different than what I first expected.... 😺

I've got a Rebel SP that's just meh as well.... OK you guys have a couple things right BUT YOU STARTED OFF WRONG!

Jefferson’s anything

Michters is meh. All of em. Not bad but not great

Stopped watching after the Eagle Rare slander.

HOT TAKE INCOMING : NEW RIFF SUUUUUUCKS

Watches video and I'm already triggered in the first 40 seconds. EAGLE RARE IS GREAT, YOU SHUT YOUR FACE AJ!

Old Elk, Heavens Door, Whistle Pig 6 year, Wilderness Trail BIB, Noah’s Mill. Just to name a few. ALL MEH 🫤