Тёмный
No video :(

MP Lloyd Russell-Moyle explodes at fellow MP calling her comments 'transphobic' during gender debate 

The Scottish Sun
Подписаться 336 тыс.
Просмотров 17 тыс.
50% 1

Conservative MP Miriam Cates was accused of making “transphobic” comments after she said Holyrood’s proposed changes to the gender recognition process would make it easier for “predators” to access to children.
Labour MP Lloyd Russell-Moyle (Brighton, Kemptown) was told to calm down in the Commons after he responded angrily to Ms Cates.
He said linking trans people with predators is “disgusting and you should be ashamed”.
The row erupted as MPs debated the Government’s decision to block the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill.
Ms Cates, the Tory MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge, said: “The Government is very right to be concerned about fraudulent and malign applications with the implications for child safeguarding.”
“Predators will exploit any loophole they can find to get access to children. And that is, I’m afraid, what will happen with this Bill.
“We shouldn’t be asking how easy is it for someone whose uncomfortable with their sex to obtain an GRC (gender recognition certificate), we should be asking how easy is it for a predator to get access to children.”
Mr Russell-Moyle was chosen to speak next, and said: “Goodness me, that speech was probably one of the worst transphobic, dog-whistle speeches that I have heard in an awful long time.
“The idea of linking trans people with predators frankly is disgusting and you should be ashamed.”
Deputy Speaker Dame Rosie Winterton told him to “calm down” and “moderate his language”
Become a Scottish Sun Subscriber and hit the bell to be the first to know
Read The Sun: www.theScottishsun.co.uk
Like The Sun on Facebook: / thescottishsun
Follow The Sun on Twitter: / scottishsun
#scotland #genderBill #section35

Опубликовано:

 

17 янв 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 252   
@bobbyuk5866
@bobbyuk5866 Год назад
Man tells woman how she feels.
@aranhoulihan7618
@aranhoulihan7618 8 месяцев назад
He’s just an old drama queen
@123rfd1
@123rfd1 Год назад
How can such an angry intemperate “man” become an elected representative. His reaction speaks volumes
@atlarge2621
@atlarge2621 Год назад
Exactly!
@paulsspangle
@paulsspangle Год назад
I just asked the same on here, then scrolled down to see that I'm not alone in wondering how the hell he got into public office.
@wotdoesthisbuttondo
@wotdoesthisbuttondo Год назад
Yeah, he was very intimidating and justified her point making sure to demonstrate it.
@stephencollins9062
@stephencollins9062 Год назад
He is one that's why They get so angry because it reminds them of themselves.
@stephencollins9062
@stephencollins9062 Год назад
Check out Dr John Money the creator of trans and gender ideology.
@MarciaMatthews
@MarciaMatthews Год назад
Women are not bigots or phobes for asking for our own word, our own spaces, our own sports.
@benfisher1376
@benfisher1376 Год назад
Or...for knowing that they are biological women. Honestly I have always considered myself to the left, but I'm so concerned about the rabbit hole we are going down into wonderland. It's scary. Nobody is going to tell me I'm a "cis" man, I'm just a biological man end of .
@BrassToff
@BrassToff Год назад
This is exactly why people feel unable to discuss the issue. They get shut down by people who shout and throw their toys out of the pram. This is the guy from Brighton whose assistant was shouting at a baby at a rally - you can see the video online.
@stephencollins9062
@stephencollins9062 Год назад
The party want's you to deny the evidence of your own eyes.
@hazelisaacs2201
@hazelisaacs2201 Год назад
Carly May Kavanagh was his staffer shouting "fascist" in a baby's face in Brighton. The whole team are unfit to represent the public. Nasty, nasty inadequate little misogynist man.
@ooblebip
@ooblebip Год назад
@L G screaming at it, calling it a fascist that would grow up to be evil, all because its parents had walked into a park while a women's rights event (and counter protestors, who the assistant was with) was being held. they weren't even there to support the apparently fascist women, they were previously unaware of the event or the issues. just lunacy
@bennym5244
@bennym5244 Год назад
He also tried to physically stop the brexit vote by grabbing the royal mace. Guy is unhinged.
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
The guy is unstable. I hope his female constituents see this and vote him out.
@enriquepuerto7146
@enriquepuerto7146 Год назад
Haha. This is the sort of reaction you’d expect from an outraged troll on Twitter, not an MP.
@benfisher1376
@benfisher1376 Год назад
Welcome to 21st century political discourse. Every political discussion now is like that of a student union meeting 🙄
@henrycollins3121
@henrycollins3121 Год назад
You should hear this guy’s 2019 acceptance speech. He’s clearly mad.
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
@@henrycollins3121 He’s clearly misogynistic (as is the Labour Party).
@stephenholmes1036
@stephenholmes1036 3 месяца назад
​@@moraymac2922very much so
@chriscurtain1816
@chriscurtain1816 Год назад
Looks like yet another case of 'You can have any opinion you like and express yourself in any way you want. Unless I disagree with you'.
@kathyb1011
@kathyb1011 Год назад
This man is disgusting. He is a misogynist. Thinking any man should be able to say he is a woman and enter women's spaces is just total disrespect for women.
@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559
Exactly. He has no regard whatsoever for women, and how this law could expose THEM to sexual predators. His only concern is for men who think they're women, and protecting them at the cost of women's safety, health, privacy and freedom.
@j7ech402
@j7ech402 Год назад
He's absolutely utterly disgusting and vile. He needs to be taught a very harsh lesson
@chriscurtain1816
@chriscurtain1816 Год назад
kb1056 Agreed. And it's potentially downright dangerous, which, I believe, was the point made by the previous speaker.
@mrwhite9775
@mrwhite9775 Год назад
Be careful there angry wee man , not a lot of trans votes to keep you in a job , hope his constituents remember this
@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559
It should be played on repeat on a digital billboard, for them all to watch over and over again, lest they forget what a blatant misogynist he is.
@kay1625
@kay1625 Год назад
We can't oust him because of the student votes in Brighton 🥺
@doodlebrighton124
@doodlebrighton124 Год назад
Makes me ashamed to live in Brighton.
@darkmusky9851
@darkmusky9851 Год назад
Oh his constituents will keep voting him in, it's Brighton the wokest city in Britian
@laurarichards7007
@laurarichards7007 Год назад
is anyone else sick of hearing the word "bigot" said so loudly by bigots?
@cartoonhead9222
@cartoonhead9222 Год назад
Means absolutely nothing these days.
@benfisher1376
@benfisher1376 Год назад
The dictionary definition of bigot is someone who is intolerant of others views. That would include this bloke.
@robjavier8064
@robjavier8064 Год назад
sick of hearing the word woke ,cancel culture , snowflake- usually said so loudly by easily offended bigots
@Logies_right_hand
@Logies_right_hand Год назад
I’m gingephobic after watching footage of this angry man
@ArseneJenga
@ArseneJenga Год назад
What. A. Child.
@georgemitchell2778
@georgemitchell2778 Год назад
Loud Plonker
@Razormiller
@Razormiller Год назад
Pro womans safe spaces and rights isnt transphobic.
@mizobvious3753
@mizobvious3753 Год назад
this little gay man will decide for women, passionate is an odd word.
@radioactivebeverage
@radioactivebeverage Год назад
Oh yeah men are definitely the more logical and emotionally controlled ones
@fraserct533
@fraserct533 Год назад
an obvious exception - embarassing
@imnotconvinced4833
@imnotconvinced4833 Год назад
This isn’t a man, just look and listen to it. 😂
@louiseparker1915
@louiseparker1915 Год назад
What a horrible rude man!
@greengardener517
@greengardener517 Год назад
Saying that self-id makes it easier for predators pretending to be trans is not transphobic, it's phobic of predators pretending to be trans.
@robbishop1287
@robbishop1287 Год назад
But there aren’t predators pretending to be trans
@littlecatfeet9064
@littlecatfeet9064 Год назад
@@robbishop1287 can you actually prove that? What was Darren Merager, Karen White, Demi Minor? All claimed trans status, all committed an act of SA against women or girls, none transitioned.
@DudeTotally1000
@DudeTotally1000 Год назад
@@robbishop1287 A convicted rapist said he was trans to try and get into a women's prison.
@TheGeneralDisarray
@TheGeneralDisarray Год назад
@@robbishop1287 how do you know? Have there not been cases of women being raped by predators who have been placed in women's prisons? Karen White (birthname: Stephen Terence Wood) admitted raping two women in prison. Are you saying he's not a predator pretending to be trans? Because the only other conclusion is that he is genuinely transgender.
@henrycollins3121
@henrycollins3121 Год назад
A phobia is an extreme and irrational fear. This is a perfectly rational aversion.
@anista1390
@anista1390 Год назад
What an unprofessional performance and blatant straw-manning! He knows full well this is about making sure safeguards aren’t removed that allow predatory men to pretend to be trans, as predators will exploit any loophole and already have done!
@bennym5244
@bennym5244 Год назад
But he just wants everyone just to see how this bill works out. He just wants to see if any women are actually attacked in large numbers or not. Dangerous unhinged loon.
@alisondytor4683
@alisondytor4683 Год назад
Women want to feel safe , but that doesn't seem to matter though
@elainecartwright4496
@elainecartwright4496 Год назад
The chair is despicable not standing up for women
@LadyLyndhurst01
@LadyLyndhurst01 Год назад
Why didn't you show where he crossed the floor and sat next to the female MP and GLARED at her? Showing EXACTLY the threatening male angry behaviour women are expected to put up with!
@BenDover-ln6ns
@BenDover-ln6ns Год назад
That’s what i came on here for, is it available to watch?
@LadyLyndhurst01
@LadyLyndhurst01 Год назад
@@BenDover-ln6ns Only seen still pictures not the actual act of him moving across the floor.
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
Disgraceful man. Hope he gets voted out.
@stephenholmes1036
@stephenholmes1036 3 месяца назад
That needs showing as it shows him in hix true colours a women hating misogynist.
@alanstjohns
@alanstjohns Год назад
Seek out Kellie Jay Keen, people
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
I have!!!! She’s great!
@MsBonzodog
@MsBonzodog Год назад
This man’s behaviour here is disgusting. Amazing the Speaker has to caution him.
@kimmac231
@kimmac231 Год назад
I am so sick of this debate,there are only 2 genders,trans can do as they want,and why is it always men shouting about this issue?
@jeniferhalkola8837
@jeniferhalkola8837 Год назад
Because misogyny.
@eustaceh.plimsoll6625
@eustaceh.plimsoll6625 3 месяца назад
“Always men”? Which planet have you just landed from?
@kimmac231
@kimmac231 3 месяца назад
@@eustaceh.plimsoll6625 I ment trans woman,wanting our spaces
@michaeldeakin4287
@michaeldeakin4287 Год назад
He also crossed the floor to sit very close to tory Miriam Cates, after crossing swords with her over the same debate, If he'd been a Tory, almost every labour mp, news station and womens rights group would be calling for his head..
@bennym5244
@bennym5244 Год назад
Is there footage of that?
@HelloKittykat21
@HelloKittykat21 Год назад
In the meantime he thinks it's acceptable to put women at risk as an experiment. Remove the GRA
@johnperrow8089
@johnperrow8089 Год назад
Those who shout loudest are worth watching. Trans rights should not Trump woman's rights, why is so much time spent on this issue when the country is facing more important issues, like education energy prices health,etc some people including elected members need to get a grip or stand aside
@paulallen1745
@paulallen1745 Год назад
because we are a collapsing civilisation,
@alm5966
@alm5966 Год назад
Why such a mysoginistic outburst towards a woman for simply telling her story? Why sit on an opposition bench near to your victim of your own ire? The constituents who voted Moyle as their MP should be ashamed and if you're a woman, afraid of his views. He's a deeply troubled individual.
@alm5966
@alm5966 Год назад
@@gaelicreaction1049 Because his rage was directed at a woman who was simply stating she felt disturbed by a man dressed as a woman staring at her. His outburst displayed a lack of empathy with her stated situation at that moment and dismissed her concerns in an exaggerated manner. He then purposefully crossed the House from the Labour bench to sit in the Conservative benches so he could intimidate her further. That good enough for ya, pal?
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
It will be quite shameful if he gets re-elected.
@bennym5244
@bennym5244 Год назад
Yes Russell lets just see how the bill works out. Let's just see if women are attacked in prisons and wards. Dangerous man.
@HelloKittykat21
@HelloKittykat21 Год назад
Emotional matters - he's a man and has no skin in this game. I bet he was screaming that women should have the right to abortion which Incidentally is a womans issue as is the erosion of our rights.
@oblux
@oblux Год назад
Lloyd Russell-Moyle - fizzing with the fury that only an absolute ideological fundamentalist could. What a contemptible little man.
@sallywright8065
@sallywright8065 Год назад
The speaker here was disappointing. Nothing transphobic was said.
@jla98765
@jla98765 Год назад
He should be disgusted with himself, talking down women
@staticcentrehalf7166
@staticcentrehalf7166 Год назад
It is beyond ridiculous that a vanishingly minor issue, affecting such a tiny proportion of the population, gets so much coverage and parliamentary time.
@paulbyrne6532
@paulbyrne6532 Год назад
Aw bless poor little lamb had a hissy fit 🤣🤣🤣
@robertblair2035
@robertblair2035 Год назад
He then crossed the House and sat beside her to intimidate her adding to what she had been through. Sooooo brave Try that tandrum against a male MP. But that would take courage !!!!! He is possibly not employable anywhere else anyway. No employer would tolerate his history of futile behaviour Definately not on a building site !!! 😂 This debacle is verbal assault and physical intimidation. A charge should be layed.
@libertasdemocratiam887
@libertasdemocratiam887 Год назад
This man shouldn't be in parliament, this is the same guy that tried to take the commons mace a few years back.
@vtechead1
@vtechead1 Год назад
Did he say he was gay ? I would never have guessed. Apart from him having a hissy fit, and maybe the tie, it wasn’t really obvious. Well well.
@galvatron3214
@galvatron3214 Год назад
that would explain his outburst wouldent it?
@sadoldgit313
@sadoldgit313 Год назад
Scrap devolution! It’s been a disaster!
@kelsohunt460
@kelsohunt460 Год назад
Delusional
@galvatron3214
@galvatron3214 Год назад
No wonder he got so heated at what Miriam Kate said, if he is lgbtq himself. Why do we live in a world now of forced narratives?. Where certain people with certain feelings/sentiments have to be gagged?. Why cant a cis woman come out and say that they dont feel safe sharing a public WC with people that were not born of the same gender as her?. Why must she just tough it out and put up with an allowance that makes her feel uncomfortable and unsafe?. Why must people who bring pure feelings to a debate thats based on facts be allowed to triumphant just because they shout and act offended?.
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
There are no cis women. Just WOMEN.
@RhodieRowley
@RhodieRowley Год назад
This is the same man (?) who lifted the house of commons mace 4 years ago. Nice piece of work.
@davedavids2231
@davedavids2231 Год назад
Who the hell voted for him
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
Frightening isn’t it?
@pamelajessup7931
@pamelajessup7931 Год назад
I know you have facts but I'm taking offence so...
@carlt9265
@carlt9265 Год назад
Awful trans bummer its men and woman the end
@Noddy656
@Noddy656 Год назад
He is the one who should be ashamed.
@elder753
@elder753 Год назад
What a disgraceful example on how to conduct yourself. A bully that wants to force people into thinking a certain way. SHAME!
@jeremynash5708
@jeremynash5708 Год назад
He talked a lot and said nothing of substance.
@idorus
@idorus Год назад
so brave and stunning a man yelling at a woman because she doesn't want men in womens spaces!!
@susansalt1965
@susansalt1965 Год назад
Just shows he does not listen.
@antsly
@antsly Год назад
He should have had the Labour whip removed from him for this. He can disagree but this was not just a disagreement. Women have a voice and they must feel empowered to use it. He is disgusting.
@jeremylawrence5855
@jeremylawrence5855 Год назад
LRM is a total and utter embarrassment to the people of his constituency, the House of Commons and the whole country. He is by far, the most vocal bigot present in that debate!
@mikecmoore
@mikecmoore Год назад
Im not sure why the speech he so vehemently commented against was not included in this clip, it would give the audience an opportunity to see that it was not transphobic in any way! Sadly Moyle like many others can only shout and decry those he disagrees with in such a violent and oppressive manner that he looks like a fool and a bully. Personally, the present government has made me want to vote for the opposition, but Moyle's outburst and Starmers inability, when questioned, what is a women, to answer factually has turned me back to the Tories, disgusting behavior by Moyle.
@stevenpower811
@stevenpower811 8 месяцев назад
You can't be transphobic it's one of the great myths of our time it's autogynophilia in other words,fetishism,fashion,narcissism,a grotesque lifestyle choice.
@tonycairns6728
@tonycairns6728 Год назад
I'm anti-Tory, and support equal rights for transpeople, but liberals are batshit crazy on this issue! Exclusive rights aren't equal rights, and I've yet to hear any proponent of 'gender identity' give a coherent account of what it is.
@stonedtemplepilot5
@stonedtemplepilot5 Год назад
Bed wetter
@Belle-rk2hk
@Belle-rk2hk Год назад
Dude is so annoying...he already lost the battle the moment he chose violence and insults in his speech.
@baba0563
@baba0563 Месяц назад
What a 🔔 end LRM is.
@SantiModina
@SantiModina Год назад
He’s a emotional misogynist
@christinabatey927
@christinabatey927 Год назад
Flimsy theories from an aggressive bloke. Yawn.
@evesapple
@evesapple Год назад
He then sat near her to try to intimidate. Vile, odious little man.
@Alan-gx8gf
@Alan-gx8gf Год назад
4'20 And there you have it , his sole reason for complaining !
@Amathusukx
@Amathusukx Год назад
Another good ad for Labour, their supporters and voters should research these people before voting, not just vote for them because Grandad always did. Well sad to say Labour is not the Labour of bygone era's
@eleanorcrawford9978
@eleanorcrawford9978 Год назад
This woman was not paying attention.
@user-hs7po1cs9j
@user-hs7po1cs9j 6 месяцев назад
He is a revolting individual who sees the world through his tiny narrow mind. He has no right to represent his constituency which, presumably, consists of 50 per cent women. What a shock that he is a Brighton MP!!!
@lawrieflowers8314
@lawrieflowers8314 Месяц назад
‘The idea of linking trans people with predators is disgusting.’ HIV positive Moyle off on another of his rants. Clearly to him they can do no wrong. But other, more sensible & objective types, will see it differently. It clearly touched a nerve with him…
@fredahulmston8783
@fredahulmston8783 Год назад
Lloyd Russell-Moyle FOXTROT OSCAR, you bully!
@Kath-C
@Kath-C Год назад
Wonder when old mate is going to transition
@thefella131
@thefella131 Год назад
Zzzzzzz
@curtismackland5257
@curtismackland5257 Год назад
He should be ashamed of that shirt & tie combo.
@jlclark7373
@jlclark7373 3 месяца назад
omg
@thomasley4006
@thomasley4006 Год назад
He’s right.
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
He’s an intimidating misogynist who cares nothing for the well founded fears of biological women and girls. And if he is so right why did he say that he was mortified by his behaviour?
@thomasley4006
@thomasley4006 Год назад
@@moraymac2922 Because he got emotional and angry and, being a decent person, doesn’t like to get angry and loud towards someone else - however justified because that someone else spews hatred and bigotry while smiling politely. It’s really simple.
@Khaos969
@Khaos969 Год назад
Africa let there people vote on what they wanted , they declined to legalise homosexuality and in doing so they have NONE of these problems.
@posh0610
@posh0610 Год назад
Lets all go and iive in Africa. Though there is no such country!
@alexboston343
@alexboston343 Год назад
I agree with him
@moraymac2922
@moraymac2922 Год назад
But he’s said that he is mortified by his intimidating aggressive behaviour. And Miriam Cates felt vulnerable and unsafe during the experience that she relayed to her fellow MPs. Who are YOU or Russell-Moyle to tell her how to feel?
@rebeccaaustin9613
@rebeccaaustin9613 Год назад
He's absolutely right and I'm grateful he spoke up for trans people. This is absolutely just a new queerphobic attack, with exactly the same old language from the Tories.
@ciaranclark5314
@ciaranclark5314 Год назад
Wow a lot of transphobes in this comment section. He's completely right. He has a right to label people in the house transphobic if they are. Pretending that this is misogyny is a low, bad faith, distortion of reality, cynically designed to undercut his very valid objection to the government's outrageous blocking of Scotland sovereign right to rule their own country.
@stephencollins9062
@stephencollins9062 Год назад
Groomer spotted.
@edlewkowicz
@edlewkowicz Год назад
Transphobe where did that come from you a bloke posting from a womens prison by any chance ?
@niek82
@niek82 Год назад
rEAliTy
@jeniferhalkola8837
@jeniferhalkola8837 Год назад
It is, in fact, misogyny.
@Jenny-nz8fb
@Jenny-nz8fb Год назад
@Ciaran - women and little girls don’t want to share toilets with men. You are a groomer and enjoy predatory thinking. F off and stay out our spaces and stop arguing for men to do that.
@gordonfleming458
@gordonfleming458 Год назад
Typically from a ginger
Далее
Ne jamais regarder une fille à la plage 😂
00:10
Просмотров 526 тыс.
Watch chaos in Parliament after Brexit votes fail
11:10
Rosie Duffield MP Speech on Domestic Abuse
9:29
Просмотров 20 тыс.