Тёмный
No video :(

My Little Pony G5 Issue #1 - Review & Analysis 

Addy Lovestar
Подписаться 6 тыс.
Просмотров 3,9 тыс.
50% 1

My Patreon: / addylovestar
Discord Server: / discord
The new MLP comics aren't exactly starting with a bang, and it looks like they may fall prey to the same flash over substance as the G4 run, but only time will tell for sure, and as always I have optimism.
#mylittlepony

Опубликовано:

 

27 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 42   
@ibdora05
@ibdora05 2 года назад
i loved this comic! i can't wait for issue 2. 😁
@javierfebronio8907
@javierfebronio8907 2 года назад
This comic feels less like a contained story and more as build up for the next issue. 1. The flashback raises the question of how Argyle knew about Canterlot when it was an era long before him. It's also strange that both in the movie and here, Argyle has so much faith in Sunny. Dr Wolf had this theory that Argyle somehow knew/prophesized Sunny's Future ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8IDNpYENigc.html 2. It's also odd how Sunny and Pipp casually mention Twilight. In the movie, it was implied that the Mane 6's existence was forgotten/doubted 3. Another thing is the lighthouse. While we hardly see the outside, it turns out it still the same lighthouse from the movie, the inside is simplistic instead of colorful and extravagant and the Unity Crystals are on an altar instead of a floating glass shaft. Since months passed between the movie and Make your Mark, maybe the comics take place in between and they will explain how the lighthouse changed. But that raises even more questions/plot holes, especially since Tell Your Tale is implied to be canon
@AddyLovestar
@AddyLovestar 2 года назад
As to Number 1: I think it's pretty normal for parents to have that level of faith in their children? Especially the kind shown in the film
@Visleaf
@Visleaf 2 года назад
I don't get it, I thought the point of the timeskip was to move on from old things? Would the ponies really not just inhabit Canterlot or patch it up or something if it's not like, lost to time? Is it like an uninhabitable radioactive danger zone? Strikes me as a weird cynical choice, like they're only doing this because we know what a Canterlot is.
@AddyLovestar
@AddyLovestar 2 года назад
This first issue raised at least two dozen questions, and I'm hoping for half as many answers
@God-T
@God-T 2 года назад
I hate sunny rainbow 🌈 😒 Hair t looks werid & she looks better without it.
@RLDragonStrider
@RLDragonStrider 2 года назад
Thats probably the classic writers trope of "flushing the established canon down the toilet to do whatever we want", you see it happen with stuff like Disney Star Wars and Star Trek etc. Probably any answers are gonna be trivial and not really explaning anything. To be fair, the ponies splitting up was contrived and trivializes G4 and it's accomplishments. It would be insteresting to see why but I doubt it will be a good explanation. Nothing epic, nothing dark, absolutely no risk. Just a simple missunderstanding that you can talk through. Garbage really.
@haylie9049
@haylie9049 2 года назад
I think it'd be neat if Hasbro decided not to place G5 directly in G4's shadow.
@dustyyhazzy
@dustyyhazzy 2 года назад
Yeah, well, they have to do a little bit, since its a sequel. But, ITS not the same characters, its a "reboot"
@AddyLovestar
@AddyLovestar 2 года назад
I wish G5 was its own unrelated media, like all previous Generations
@launacyko4523
@launacyko4523 2 года назад
@@dustyyhazzy A soft reboot to be precise :)
@haylie9049
@haylie9049 2 года назад
@@dustyyhazzy Someone made the decision to MAKE G5 a sequel, so that doesn't really change my criticism. It in no way had to be one.
@TeamFriendship8600
@TeamFriendship8600 2 года назад
I think they're only connected because G4 was the most popular installment. Besides, why start over when a previous show already had worldbuilding as strong as Tara?
@RLDragonStrider
@RLDragonStrider 2 года назад
Consdering the head writer lady for this has some....weird credits to her name and some really boring detective comics I can't say I am suprised. Lets call it for what it is, this will suck and over 10 years of lore and 100 issues of the G4 comics went down the shitter. It honestly boggles my mind how Hasbro just axed G4 regardless how dull the show was for me, there were probably alot more fans and Bronies out there that would've consumed 2-3 more season. Unlike Disney Star Wars they really didnt screw up the original vission for the show too badly so the money would've just printed itself, but NOPE they axed it and a decade of lore and character development dosent matter. So Twilight was groomed by Celestia from the beginning to take the throne so she and Luna can retire and despite all Twilight and her friends accomplished Equestria falls apart after no more than a decade or a century. That is just...wow...it basically means it didnt matter in the long run. Thanks for the review, now I know how right I was about the new comics.
@pippo17173
@pippo17173 2 года назад
G4 needed end man. I love everything about g4 even with the issues that I debated with other people about. But we all agreed it needed to end now. However I wish g5 was on its own as I think it would be a bit better for it. I like g5 characters so far but I won't deny its held back by being a semi sequel to the previous gen.
@RLDragonStrider
@RLDragonStrider 2 года назад
@@pippo17173 Agree and Disagree. G4 was still going fairly well and one to two more seasons wouldn't have mattered. If anything the show started to suffer from the same kind "slife of lifey" garbage that previous MLP generations were notorious for. The comics really were a breath of fresh air (although with their own problems) and did alot more to expand the lore and the world and get us out of Ponyville. Cannot say I am a fan of G5, the character are kind of one dimensional, I liked Izzy in the movie a bit, but it seems her personality got castrated in the new short and comics. Comics who it seems like for the first issue are continuing to piss the sheets and pull out more weird lore we have never seen before like some odd "Gate of Friendship" garbage.This is only going to go further down from here. I have no confidence in this team of writers and all that remains is to just watch G5 burn.
@pippo17173
@pippo17173 2 года назад
@@RLDragonStrider The thing is that g4 is suffereing too many cooks in the kitchen at its final seasons. Ya I enjoy more the episodes which is mostly opinion but I cant really deny people's accusations of seasonal rot and honestly people I talk to wanted more slice of life then lore related episodes but were not really happen with where it went with that. I disagree thinking that episodes we got in season 8 and 9 are mostly good but I can see their point there.
@RLDragonStrider
@RLDragonStrider 2 года назад
@@pippo17173 I believe the problem with G5 will be the exact opposite One cook that dosent know what the fuck they are doing. As I said previously I decide to look up the lady that is head writer and well he credits are not really amazing or good. I can honestly see some signs that this will just bring up more questions than answers and the answers we do get will be unsatisfactory. Not to mention cranking the character's quirks are ramped up. Dont know about the slice of life however, you can get that with any sitcom. Agree to dissagree I guess.
@vanoskuro-ponyform1714
@vanoskuro-ponyform1714 2 года назад
Does it really matter? Going by the last mlp comic series, it's not going to be canon.
@AddyLovestar
@AddyLovestar 2 года назад
I don't only care about things that're canon. And the comics wouldn't be made if people just bought things that're canon
@willowallen4688
@willowallen4688 2 года назад
Canon or not, it still builds on the world and typically should help you understand the world and the characters better in the main series
@ronaldpagar6513
@ronaldpagar6513 2 года назад
Since the canterlot is here that means twilight sparkle spike flurry heart and cadence might be alive somewhere in G5 except for discord which is apparently
@ronaldpagar6513
@ronaldpagar6513 2 года назад
@Eram hasan really? Tell that to the ending of g4 it seems that twilight sparkle spike flurry heart and cadence might be outlive her love ones
@ronaldpagar6513
@ronaldpagar6513 2 года назад
@Eram hasan what about twilight sparkle?
@ronaldpagar6513
@ronaldpagar6513 2 года назад
@Eram hasan I assume that spike might be alive somewhere in G5 because of the dragon egg
@ronaldpagar6513
@ronaldpagar6513 2 года назад
@Eram hasan let's hope so because we haven't seen the every creatures in Equestria that are united each other
@ronaldpagar6513
@ronaldpagar6513 2 года назад
@Eram hasan you look at Equestria daily because they show discord in the comics
@viriyananda
@viriyananda 2 года назад
Izzy and pinkie pie is same just half they over fun and joy and side they have serious issues about abandoned just like pinkie pie her friend doesn't come to party
@dancingwithpalmtrees
@dancingwithpalmtrees 2 года назад
i love the art style though
@AddyLovestar
@AddyLovestar 2 года назад
I also enjoy the art quite a bit
@xfacade_productions
@xfacade_productions 2 года назад
where can you buy these comics 😔
@AddyLovestar
@AddyLovestar 2 года назад
From the IDW storepage, here: www.idwpublishing.com/series/my-little-pony-2022
@andlar05
@andlar05 2 года назад
😃👍🏿