Nehru ने Patel, Jinnah और Mukherjee से बहस में क्या बोला था? | Kitabwala | Saurabh Dwivedi | China 

भाई साहेब ही हिंदी से मंत्रमुग्ध हूं। लंदन में लंबे समय तक रहने के बावजूद इतनी अच्छी और शुद्ध हिंदी।सलाम है आपको!!!

रामचंद्र गुहा को बुलाओ सौरभ जी

Invite J Sai Deepak in kitabwala or guest in the newsroom

बेमिसाल बेहतरीन बातचीत इतिहास के आदर्श पुरूष को नयी दृष्टि से अवगत कराने के लिये बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद आलोचना का नया पक्ष और नयी दुनिया स्वस्थ राजनीतिक आलोचना का बेहतर अनुभव है ये कार्यक्रम ।

सौरभ भैया विक्रम संपत जी का इंटरव्यू करिए उन्होंने वीर सावरकर के जीवनी लिखी है

सौरभ जी इतिहास से सबक लिया जाता है। गलतियों को सुधारा जाता है। दोहराया नहीं जाता। अगर हम वर्तमान में उन गलतियों से बचें तो ज्यादा बेहतर होगा।

Saurabh, I watch this show regularly and love it. I too am a book lover. I would request you to air a special Annual Edition/Summary of the shows of 2022, by year end, or in Jan. This should sum up all the books reviewed, and also read & recommended by you. Looking forward to Annual Editions of all your Main shows like- LTS, Netanagari, Duniyadari , Aarvam & Kharchapani summarising events of 2022, and experts opinion about what 2023 portends.

why no interviews of j sai deepak and his bestseller books??

बहुत सुंदर बौद्धिक परिचर्चा व विमर्श।आप दोनों को बहुत बहुत साधुवाद।

Brotherhood of islam is only for muslim, it's not universal

Yeah Interview mujhe critically sochne par mazbur kr rha hai ki kuch logo Nehru par Deep researche kr k criticism krne sey bhi career bana sakte hai.....

Thanks

Eye opening facts about Modern India history.

Bring J Sai Deepak for his books

why don't you invite Mr. J. Sai Deepak And Mr. Vikram Sampath on their latest best seller books !

very good episode. well conducted interview and above all sounds like a very interesting book.

excellent conversation by two gentleman's

Waah....dhanyavaad....!!

Jaise Nehru ki puraani baaton mein itna interest aaj dekh vaise hi Sourabh ke puraane tweet itihas ka hissa banegi

Patel to 1 number tha, Lekin Gandhi ka chella hokar Nehru ka Diya tha offer is wajah se hum sab Hindustaani bhogat rahe Hain!

Oh PM who lost more than half of Kashmir and ladakh to enemy.......also Alama Iqbal the person who gave idea for pakistan

Sir please call Dr Ranganathan

पुरानी और अच्छी जानकारीओ के लिए धन्यवाद.

This program is quite interesting. The way you discuss these books and give independent observations are really fantastic. Now a days it is difficult for a senior like me to read these well written books . Thanks for very interesting discussion . Books you have chosen are also extremely well researched and nicely written.

Nahru ke liye apni image desh hit se adhik important thasamkalin netrutva sabhi nahru se adhik yogya aur doordarshi the

What a narration, that's how a well read person speks .@saurabh

This segment of Lallantop is simply awesome...thanks to the team for educating us..

Saurabh bhaiya ap J Sai Deepak ko bulaiye. India Bharat aur Pakistan par unse bat kijiye.

सौरभ सर आपसे एक बार अनुरोध है कि कृपया इस सेशन में मराठी लेखकों को भी बुलाइए. और नरहर कुरुंदकर जी के अनेकों पुस्तकों के बारे में पढ़िए....! 🙏

Good work lalantop....always working as your name.........

Ek जरूरी किताब और बातचीत

इतिहास के बारे में बात करते वक़्त उसी समय को ध्यान में रखना पड़ता है न कि उसके सौ साल बाद किताब लिखते वक़्त वर्तमान समय के हालातों के आधार पर। ये बिल्कुल वैसा ही है जैसे एक व्यक्ति का अपनी जायदाद को दो बेटों में बांटते समय ये कहा जाना कि जो गाँव का मकान लेगा उसे शहर वाला मकान और दुकान नहीं मिलेगी और शहर में लेने वाले को गाँव की ज़मीन और मकान नहीं मिलेगी और इस तरह से जायदाद बाँट दी जाती है और छोटा बेटा शहर का मकान और दुकान ले लेता है। उसके 70 साल बाद गाँव की जमीन हाई वे पर आ गयी उसके रेट बढ़ जाते हैं। तो छोटे बेटे का बेटा अपने दादे पर इल्ज़ाम लगाने लगता है कि दादा जी ने जायदाद सही तरीके से नहीं बांटी, धोख़ा किया😂😂, अब आप बताइए इसमें दादा जी कहाँ ग़लत हुए। इसी तरह वर्तमान समय के हालात के लिए नेहरू जी को ज़िम्मेदार कैसे बनाया जा सकता है?

@35;18 ARE SAURABH JI aapne to kitni he baar kaha hai ki ye to WTSUP gyaan hai ki Bharat ko USA ne kabhi UN ki Permanent seat offer he nahi kari . . . . .. . Ab kya hoo gaya Babu

I never thought Tripurdaman Singh is such a young guy. Sixteen stormy days is great work.

Kaunsa wireless mic use kiya hai aap ne good sound quality.

I wish you had the other author also there . I had loved their interview with Amit Varma.

Looks like its an interesting book. Ordered it just now on Amazon

another wonderful episode of kitabwala love this series and newsroom series...

Ashok Pande sir ko kitabwala me please bulaye sir unki nai kitab k liye

आज लगता हे ग़ुलामी अच्छी थी आज इन पागलों को जिसने आज़ादी दिलाई ग़ुलामी होती तो आज मज़ाक़ बनाने की ओकात नही होती ये किसी अंग्रेज़ के पेर दबा रहे होते क्योंकि इनको ग़ुलामी पसंद हे किसीकी भी करे

Agar Patel aate to Aaj wo gali sun rhe hote aur log keh rhe hote nehru hote to desh jyada majboot hota. Sach kuch bhi ho log itihas ki analysis apne faide ke hisab se kate hai jisse unki roti sik sake

Nahru ki China policy bhi utni hi vifalta thi jitni Pakistan policy

Invite j sai Deepak

पंडित नेहरू और सरदार पटेल ❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳

Your anchorship is marvellous

❤❤this is awesome content

hindi edition ka link bhi de diya keriye plzz...mujhe lagta hai ki agar kitabwala me rkhi gayi sab kitaabon ka link users ko diya jaaye to unko easy hoga :) just a suggestion

kya new samvindhan pr koi book ya koi chrcha hai ya ki gayi hai or apko ek sesion is pr lana chiye

Bahot Dino baad ek achha kitab wala tha. Aur Lekhak achhe narrator v hai. Warna bahot se logo ko bolne hi nai ata.

इस विचारवंत के विचार अभी तक प्रगल्भ नहीं हुवे हैं,,,, ऐसा मुझे लगता है,,,,, विचारों का कद बहुत ही छोटा लगता है

Outstanding and beautiful program Saurabh ji only you can do the justice to Kitabwala with all the knowledge of complex issues and thanks for the detailed information!

Superlike !!

माता-पिता भले ही अनपढ़ क्यों न हो लेकिन शिक्षा और संस्कार देने की जो क्षमता उनमें है वो दुनिया के किसी स्कूल में नहीं। 🌹💐🌷💐🌷💐🌷💐💐🌷💐🌷

Saurabh bhai u interpret this book many times better than books own author

Invite j sai deepak for his latest book

Good show!

Thanks for your post for disclosing the truth. ,,the thought tree,,IAS RAS coaching centre jaipur rajasthan India Director Shrawan Yadav Especially for upsc Rpsc aspirants.

Kamal-Jatin-Nikhil love you guys

Pranam

Nice😊

Nice

Nice analysis

❣️

👍

Being objective does not necessarily mean being neutral. वस्तुनिष्ठ होना ततस्थ होना नही होता है सौरभ जी

👍👏

सौरभ जी जेठमलानी जी रोज पांच सवाल इंद्रा जी से नहीं राजीव गांधी से पूछते थे।

Kindly discuss on 1964 of Mrinal Talukdar from Assam.... with the author

Sarraubh.thank.forgoodknldg

To Saurabh Dwivedi ji - In the backdrop of Maharashtra Govt.'s regressive step to form a committee to inquire about "Inter Caste - Inter Religion" marriages in the state, please review the book "Caste Matters" & interview book's writer scholar Dr. Suraj Yengade.

સૌરભ ત્રિવેદી સાહેબ 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Comes from BJP. Cannot believe a word he says. For this people Patel was a superman born with Sudarshan Chakra in his hands. Distortions on Kashmir colors the 1962 China story, and falsification abounds. These people take a letter or two of Patel which were part of on going exchanges and then selectively present them. Nehru took a pragmatic stand, he asked Gen Cariappa if India could take on China vis a vis Tibet, the General said no. These letters are in the Indian Archives, do not be surprised if this government has destroyed them. Tibet was an autonomous part of China brought into India by the British arbitrarily when there was chaos in China. Britain also acknowledged suzerainity of China over Tibet. UK and US too acknowledged the same, there are documents to prove this. UK and US refused to give any military aid to India if India did something in Tibet. Nehru had to make agreement with China on Tibet, Nehru introduced Panchsheel - a code of conduct to rope in China in good conduct, Mao also acknowledged this, there is documentary evidence. India was dirt poor, fighting communist insurgency at home, people had to be lifted out of poverty to thwart communism. No money, for foreign exchange. In 1959 Nehru asked for Rs 100 crores to buy arms, JP Kriplani blocked with unrealistic thinking that it would violate the soul of the Father of the Nation. Nehru tried to do give and take with Chou En Lai, who kept doing somersaults, Nehru's cabinet did not co-operate, press which was free then, went jingoistic. In 1954 and in 1957, after the Tibet agreement, Chou is on record saying the border issue was settled and then in 1959 suddenly said the entire border was up for negotiations. Read, read and read instead of listening to master story or rather half truth story tellers of BJP

❤

10 May 1951 ko Nehru ne Ist Constitutional Amendment Bill Laye the sirji. 16 may Nahin . Aur 18.06.1951 Gazette Notification nikala tha

लल्लनटॉप का सबसे बेहतरीन कार्यक्रम है यह मेरा

આભાર 🙏🙏🙏🙏

The concept of Gangajamjuni Tahzeeb being analyzed , and its good to know about the Society of UP at that time , lets understand and feel good.. Any way, its UP which is base of all concept and civilization for Muslims also , and cultural centers after 1857 indeed. Jai Hind !!!

सर आप का चैनल देखते रहते है अच्छा लगता है

Proud of Bikaner raja who was first to dissolve in india , and his minister panicker was chosen as PMO secretary.

Bapu ne chacha ke pyar liye pakistan aur bangladesh ke lakho hinduo ko marwa diya.

sabse pahle patel sir ko naman hira tha wo india ka thankku sardar thankku

Why his name is not added in the title?

35:55 41:58

Current Affairs for BPSC Prelims Exam

👌❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️👍

Mr. Saurabh, please approach Mr. Harshal Pushkarna, a renowned writer, columnist, speaker & trekker. He is first reporter who goes to Siachen (not only at base camp, but various army posts located there) & wrote a marvellous book named "THIS IS SIACHEN" (Originally written in Gujarati named આ છે સિઆચેન). I am 100% sure, you won't get disappointment. He is also running Siachen awareness drive.

Swabhbhik jhukav tha china ke taraf... that's speak the mindset of author.

Saurabh bhaiya बीकानेर महाराजा गंगासिंहजी के जीवन पर कोई किताब सुझायें🙏

Ek bar wastwik video banaiye mahatma Gandhi ke brahmacharya ke preog pe

Time stamp daal do pls🥺🥺

Saurabh you should invite Vijay mankar an enlightened leader of our country.

नेहरु को क्या तिब्बत में रूचि नही थी?

त्रिभुवन जी नेहरू और गांधी के सबसे बड़े पाप पर अपने कुछ नहीं लिखा। भारत का विभाजन हुआ Two Nations Theory यानी मुसलमान हिन्दुओं के साथ नहीं रह सकते, पर हुआ। उसके आधार पर मुसलमानों को पाकिस्तान दे दिया गया। तो किस आधार पर नेहरू और गांधी ने आधे से ज्यादा मुसलमानों को भारत में रहने दिया। जो हमेशा के लिए हिंदुओं के लिए समस्या बन गए और बने रहेंगे।

Bhai interview kiska he???

ये कहाँ से कहाँ आ गए सौरभ जी 🫣

Sir BJP was a decent opposition and also a decent administrator. There is participation but the blame for not allowing discussions goes on Congress which is glaring.

Read this book as a critic on Nehru. Might be a good book to know few odd specific aspects of Nehru and a few decisions he took as PM. Definitely India is not defined and cannot be defined and no one should claim that few debates can define. Quite interested show. Although theme is outdated. Good luck author

Hi sir aapka tv channel kabhi aana wala hai

One Mistake you made Sourab Sir that Qadian is Near Ludhiana. Its not Near to Ludhiana but its Near to Amritsar and Gurdaspur.

Bhakti or chamchagiri se pare aaj ki rajniti se koi ummid nhi ki ja sakti ki vo niswarth bhav se sach likh sake iss episod ko yahi varam deta uchit samjhta hu dhanyavad🙏