@@johnopen9667 you obviously made a wild assumption (a wrong one) and a logical falicy. Whether Annette's voice suits this music is NOTHING to do with how well Floor Jansen sings. Whether Floors version is "way better" or not is subjective. Of course I have seen Jansen's version from her solo shows, multiple times in fact. It's great, because Floor is great. And yet strangely, no matter how many times I hear Floor sing it, Annette's version weirdly doesn't magically change in its quality.
imaginaerum, dark passion play, are one of my fav albums, not saying tarja is bad, indeed she is a goddess, but these 2 albums are simply a masterpiece
So... the various notes out of key are just part of "Anette's song"? Floor does this and every Nightwish song better than Anette and that's just because Floor happens to be a good singer.
Erised Widia She wasnt off key, she was doing it in the style of New Orleans Jazz which is shifted one and a half notes above normal singing style. New Orleans Jazz is in the key of E flat while most sung music is in the key of C
All three vocalists are great, Tarja, Anette and Floor. They each have certain songs that they do best. This one's Annette's, along with Eva, Meadows of Heaven and many more. Floor does Ghost Love Score the best.
La gente critica anette porqie se encapricho con tarja. Anette canta muy bien vivo. Mejoro bastante incluso desde que se fue de nightwish canto un tema de opera. Por ptro lado hacia buenos covers de tarja poniendole su estilo. La verdad las tres cantan bien. Cada una con su estilo.
@@xVTSWx Thanks for your recommendation. Now, from a Nightwish song, I am entering a rabbit hole of dark Jazz. I fall in love with The KDE at first listen :))
I think Scarytale and Slow Love Slow are two songs that really fit Anette's style. Storytime is also obviously good but I think Floor's version from Wacken 2013 is the best for that song.
I love Jukka period. He is so enthusiastic about his drumming. He obviously has such a passion for it. Kai is a great drummer. No doubt about his technical ability as a drummer. But he lacks Jukka's passionate flair.
This (type of music) is what Anette should have been doing as a carreer. She sound natural, comfortable and pleasant to listen to in this song. She should never have been the lead singer of Nightwish (this is the greatest enigma for me: why mr Holopainen selected her...???)
Neither you, me or anyone else but the band themselves decides who fits in there. Comments like this makes you look like an asshole. Also, Imaginaerum and DPP is some of their best work. Also also.. the band grew about 800% in fans during Anette's years with them... Make of that what you will...
Sorry people Floor's voice is far superior to the former singers. They are not even in the same ballpark. Not saying they are not good singers just don't compare.You would be hard pressed to find anyone with same quality's as Floor. She is called the QUEEN or GODDESS for that reason. FLOORGASM
